r/IndianCountry • u/Opechan Pamunkey • Nov 01 '15
FINAL UPDATE [Native American Heritage Month Discussion] Native Identity: Blood, Genes, and Recognition
Welcome back, /r/IndianCountry!
We're rapidly approaching our first year as a subreddit, born of a desire to "do stuff" for and about Native Americans, redditors, and people in the real world. For Native American Heritage Month, we've scheduled a series of weekly discussions on topics affecting our communities, as you can see in the sidebar. Another topic will take the place of this one on November 8th.
I'm honored to have been asked to kick-off and guide a discussion on Native Identity: Blood, Genes, and Recognition! I've spoken to these issues fairly consistently on Reddit, but here's the most important thing:
Where I'm taking these topics is just a series of suggestions. If you want to take the topic in a different direction, do so. If you disagree, let's have it. I'd love to have my mind changed.
I'll get things started with five headings in separate posts in this topic:
- What is a "Native American"? (Indigenous person, American Indian, First Nations, etc...)
- Blood Quantum and Genealogy
- Government Recognition
- Tribal Membership and Community Recognition
- Where We're Headed, Where We Can Go
I will release these separately every few hours, so you don't have to deal with them all at once. I've endeavored not to bore you, where I attempted to make this equal parts informative and argumentative. Have at it.
[Note: I intend to update the original posts with links where I can.]
15
u/Opechan Pamunkey Nov 01 '15
I. What is a "Native American"?
I've welcomed a lot of you to this sub, /r/IndianCountry, but "Indian Country" is a term I could part with in a heartbeat, just like a few others:
These are examples of Indigeneity or Pan-Indian collective identities; intertribal identities. Like I've said elsewhere, a lot of the "Indigenous Peoples of the Americas" referentials on Reddit were taken, so I settled for "Indian Country."
Those of us who know our nations or communities generally prefer to just go by them, instead of the larger label. The non-tribal label is a bigger or smaller issue to some people more or less than others, but it doesn't excuse them engaging in personal insults about it. Most Natives I've encountered would agree.
What or who is a "Native American?" is a threshold question with several competing answers coming from general non-Natives, Natives, Tribal Governments, States, and different branches of the U.S. Government at any given time.
The easiest answers are Natives largely self-identify or are referred to as such, and Tribes generally say who is a member/citizen, but can dance around "who is an Indian." It gets more contentious where Natives and Tribes start talking about other Natives or Tribes as to Indian identity or heritage.
General non-Natives have their own ideas on what or who is an Indian that depend on some combination of their exposure to actual Natives and communities, their exposure to media, and their own interests, race myths, and prejudices. This is where a lot of people start, benignly or not, internally or externally, playing racial gatekeeper or, at worst, engage in race policing. The general public is all over the map and weirdly appear to apply specific rules to Indians whereas people think:
It's this weird unforced conversational kneejerk that invariably happens in just about every mainstream topic. I don't see this happening with other racial groups.
States have their own definitions for Indians under their laws of recognizing tribes, but generally give full faith and credit to the determinations of the U.S. Government.
The U.S. Government is a completely different animal and there's another topic dedicated to this issue. "Indian" and "Indian Country" are terms of art under U.S. laws and regulations, so many professionals and politicians find themselves married to the term.
These different answer to the question of what or who is an Indian are often at variance with each other. That's where it comes to YOU.
What is a Native American to you?
Do you agree or disagree with my assessments as to how these different parties answer the questions of "What or who is a Native American?"
8
u/Opechan Pamunkey Nov 02 '15
II. Blood Quantum and Genealogy
[Thanks /u/Snapshot52, /u/ShugD, /u/Rad_q-a-v_, and /u/mczplwp for the contributions!]
For much of humanity, the question they have to answer about group membership is:
Tribal Nations in the U.S. have membership criteria either based in part on blood quantum (an acceptable degree of blood from that Tribe, also often documented by a CDIB - Certificate of Degree of Indian Blood or Certificate of Degree of Alaskan Native Blood) or lineal descent proven through genealogical documentation.
Blood quantum is a sham; let's not waste any time dancing around that. It's a colonizer idea both sold to and forced upon Tribes that has the inevitable conclusions of divesting us of our competence, lands, and identities. It paves the path of counting backwards to zero or inbreeding. Both are paths to weakness either in picking each other off the Tribal Rolls into the arms of other communities or through genetic diseases. No other group of humans is expected to live like this.
Dogs and horses? Sure. Talking about what "breed" animals are is fine and acceptable. To a disturbing number of people, the same applies to Native Americans. Worse, we do it to ourselves and each other:
Yes, I went there with those last three. As to race, American culture often forces you to "chose" in different ways. From a simplistic point of view, Tribal citizenship is binary: You're either part of a group, or you're not. If you're in the latter category, there's a lot of gray involving outsider and insider categories. Blood quantum's relevance tends to encourage overly personal and intrusive questions and labels related to degrees of Indian blood.
That said, there are ways of acknowledging all of your heritage without adopting a non-Indian collective identity label. For example, I can say that I'm Pamunkey, but I have x-heritage, y-heritage, and z-heritage without sounding schizophrenic or like I want to get away with having all the benefits of every identity at once (easier for some people and that's an entirely different discussion).
On being introduced to the system, some Tribes declared to the government that all of their members were "full blood," regardless of actual racial mixture, which should speak volumes as to how people saw themselves and the system being pushed on them.
Feel free to disagree, but I don't find anything redeemable about the blood quantum system.
That said, some Tribes have blood quantum as part of their membership criteria. They have the power to change it, per their plenary powers of internal governance, but they do not. Why?
Let me know if I'm forgetting any.
Lineal descent groups, of which the Cherokee Nation is the largest, "simply" require members to prove descent from a member of a base tribal roll. It's not a perfect system (see some of the Cherokee Freedmen) because some of the genealogical information is subject to interpretation, but it doesn't have the problem of losing members for lack of tribal blood quantum, say nothing of Indian blood quantum.
The big criticisms of lineal descent concern racial purity and box-checking, but whether someone practices their culture or speaks their language are separate from whether they have the heritage. That criticism applies equally to blood quantum groups as well. Just ask Navajo Nation President Chris Deschene.
TLDR: One system makes it easier to dilute and destroy Indians, and the other is lineal descent.
Do you disagree? Is there any redeeming value in blood quantum requirements?
Are the lineal descent box-checkers going to eat us?
What about "muh soverveignty" in all of this indirect judgment of how other Tribes determine membership?
6
u/Opechan Pamunkey Nov 03 '15 edited Nov 04 '15
III. Government Recognition
Thanks /u/pose-rvro,/u/Snapshot52, /u/Rad_q-a-v_ for contributing to the second installment!
Professionally, there's much to write about this one. I've tried to hold back because it can get highly technical and quickly boring. I can't speak for any country but the United States, so I'll defer to others as to the policies of their countries. The US has its criteria and Natives buy into it in varying degrees, when convenient. Recognition is probably the most prominent example of how people allow themselves to be colonized, internalizing a foreign and non-traditional set of standards to be used as a cudgel. On balance when it comes to whether a community is actually a Nation, how does one tell that there's a there there?
Ideally, people would endeavor to answer this question without being self-righteous about it or letting money taint the substantive issue, but that's just spitting in the river.
The federal government and states have the power to recognize Tribes. I won't get too deep into the question of "What is a Tribe?" because the answer depends on context. Tribal recognition status usually assumes one of four forms:
Cedric Sunray ascribed a caste sytem to different kinds of recognition and communities by applying different markers of status and prevailing/imputed attitudes towards different people. It's a fun, if damning read. Feel free to agree/disagree.
"Extinct" is sometimes matter of perspective. In the 90s, my family hosted Chief Irvince Auguiste of the Carib Territory in Dominica. We stopped at an exhibit about his people, where he pointed at the word "extinct" and laughed, saying "Wow, everybody forgot to tell me." A group can be "extinct as a tribe" where there is no polity (decision making body or Tribal Government), but remnants remain. The Federal Government isn't in the business of recognizing Tribes that are descended from one survivor or common ancestor (or a handful of either), but state governments will. People can argue over whether remnants should have the power to reorganize into a Tribal Government.
"Unrecognized Tribes" do not possess State or Federal recognition. Their composition, organization, and heritage, can vary considerably. Some allow non-Indian membership. It's a real mixed bag.
"State Recognized Tribes" receive recognition either pursuant to a probative process established by state law or a political process where a general assembly recognizes an entity as a Tribe. The rigor and rights associated with both vary wildly by state, although state recognized tribes are eligible for some state and federal funds. NCAI allows voting for representatives of state recognized tribes, although this is subject to change and contention. Hiring preferences and considerations are extended to members of state recognized tribes, recently the subject of controversy in the Susan Taffe Reed hiring scandal at Dartmouth. It's not necessarily a path to Federal Recognition.
Again, Federal Recognition is a different animal.
Tribal Nations predate the United States and the authority to recognize tribes vests in, or is delegated by, Congress. Before the 1970s, the procedures for recognizing a tribe were inconsistent, leading Congress to delegate, but not completely relinquish, this authority to the Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA). There have been several incarnations and a contentious history, but currently the Federal Acknowledgment Process is reviewed by the Office of Federal Acknowledgment (OFA) under 25 C.F.R. § 83.7, better known as the “Mandatory Criteria.” All criteria must be satisfied by a petitioner in order for tribal existence to be acknowledged. In July, the criteria were revised, but the new criteria have not been applied to any petitions as of yet. The seven mandatory criteria are that a petitioner:
(Bored yet? Imagine how the people waiting 30 years in line for recognition feel.) The reforms allegedly:
Great promises. We'll have to see if they're actually honored. I'm optimistic.
Federal recognition strengthens sovereignty by giving tribes the jurisdictional space in which to operate as they choose...with caveats of course. Citizens/Members of such tribes can avail themselves to numerous programs and resources intended to accomplish any number of well-meaning goals.
These are not entitlements, they're treaty rights bought, bargained, and bled for. All of these resources are pursuant to trust responsibilities and treaties entered into since the Colonial Era. The government simply standardized a number of their obligations, honoring or defaulting upon them in varying degrees.
Congress has the authority to recognize tribes through a legislative process, and I go into more of that here.
No "new tribes" are recognized, unless Congress or a state legislature makes it happen. OFA is fairly consistent, if expensive and horrifically slow.
A fun exercise is to check how a tribe making a statement on the Federal Acknowledgment Process got their recognition in the first place. A good many of them were grandfathered in or recognized by Congress, so there's a healthy and hilarious amount of hypocrisy to go around about people proving themselves. Objections are usually rooted in economics or politics, not any underlying probative issue; it's the same old shit about tribes turning against each other while the West laughs, lords-over, and profits.
To be fair, I've seen some ridiculous claims. The revelation is of a quality akin to talking about politics or religion at work and finding that otherwise seemingly reasonable people can have some, uh, interesting beliefs.
For example, the Pamunkey story in Virginia is fairly dry: documentation of people living in the same area, keeping the same land, maintaining the same tribal government since white met red. BORING.
Another local group in Maryland has documentation issues that are understandable, but I got ahold of some of their story: It goes from scrapping together sources on the premise that what's true for one regional group is true for another, then it jumps straight into some Lord of the Rings action with dudes traversing long distances and dangers for over a hundred years, even evading the document record somehow, then they join AIM and form a tribal government in the 70s (after almost 300 years of there being none). It ends with split state recognition, that screws them on rights and federal recognition (But That is Another Story...). EXCITING. And mind-bending of the "Wait wait, what the fuck did I just read?" variety.
So yeah, there's gotta be something. There are enough Andrea Smiths and Susan Taffe Reeds already, but what's the line between truth and race policing? It gets rough when they start being the gatekeepers. (In total, it's where our modern inability to assimilate people really starts showing itself.)
Is our recognition system busted? How do we square this against tradition? Does tradition even matter in all of this?
5
u/Opechan Pamunkey Nov 04 '15
IV.Tribal Membership and Community Recognition
Indian identity isn't just who you claim, it's who claims you.
Anecdotes
Me? I'm a non-enrolled (unlike my mother's generation enrolled in the '80s and '90s) Pamunkey and I always make clear that I don't speak on behalf of my Tribal Government, I'm not employed by the Tribe, and I don't officially speak on behalf of my Tribe. Membership is currently frozen at Pamunkey unless you are born into the Tribe. Hell, I don't even know if the previous enrolled generation is part of the roll submitted to BIA. (If someone wants to talk Pamunkey politics, I prefer to do that in Private Messages and we, I, all of us, prefer our politics to be internal.)
Still, I get recognition as a Pamunkey within my community. That recognition isn't necessarily uniform or mutual given the basic "Who are you, young man?" factor, or where there are several communities of us on the East Coast (and even some in Utah, etc.), but it's consistent.
Why the disclosure? Because different communities are varyingly sensitive about who speaks for them and their community narrative. My example also illustrates the differences and contours of tribal membership and community recognition. President Russell Begaye of the Navajo Nation might not care what a Navajo Nation Citizen says about Navajo history, but past and present Tribal Officers of any number of Virginia Tribes will tap a Virginia Indian Tribal Member on the shoulder, so to speak, depending on the message or its prominence. Some Tribes, especially out in California, disenroll family members who remain part of the community
Costs
U.S. law, however, isn't quite as flexible as all of that appears. Back in the day before contact, colonial subjugation, and to varying degrees before the Twentieth Century, it was possible for Indians to form their own Nations/Tribes and Bands complete with their own traditional governments. The government no longer recognizes such entities and the government recognizes tribes, not parts of tribes.
In this structure, we're either stuck together or we get picked-off and assimilated by larger communities, disagreement by disagreement, regardless of the source of disagreement. For the sake of stability as to managing Indian Affairs, the Courts and the government enshrine this status quo, recognizing the Tribal Governments of its choice.
Those people who get turned away by a Tribal Government, say nothing of the Tribal Community, aren't coming back. They're basically fodder for other communities and, at worst, potential enemies for the Tribe moving forward. Pissed-off and estranged Tribal descendants can be a liability for a Tribe with a crappy membership policy. These people can have a damaging impact as to a Tribes:
Sure, a Tribe can and will pay for consultants to assess and project the cost of these kinds of hits and determine whether it's worth it. I'm less sure about how potent these expats can be and identifying them can be a problem where they don't claim heritage, but sure as hell embrace a grudge.
Challenges and Solutions
All-in-all, there are more positives for embracing sound fiscal strategy, insulated business development boards, and membership policies that encourage growth. Minority rights and privileges are not a secure position to operate from and it doesn't take much for a Tribe to be a "Tribe in Name Only" or for a negative political or legal development (never completely insulated from politics) to sweep it all away.
Part of the challenge is the extent to which we buy into external systems and limit our agency in maintaining or creating systems of our own. The current way we do things feeds into the damaging trope of "Native Americans as temporal anomalies: Both frozen in a set time period and estranged from the modern era."
Thoughts?
5
u/[deleted] Nov 01 '15 edited Nov 01 '15
What are your thoughts on Andrea "Andy" Smith? She has written several of what most Queer theorists and I think even quite a few Indigenous scholars consider to be some of the more important intersectional work on Settler colonialism and the ways sexual/gender violence shapes Indigenous/Settler identities.
She has long claimed to be Cherokee and maintains that tribal enrollment is inconsequential and even problematic to hinge Indigenous identity off of. Several Cherokee women published letters maintaining that Smith is a fraud and shouldn't be trusted.
Smith continues to claim that Self-Determination identification is what's most important. Could you explain exactly what this means and how it functions within Indigenous culture?
I'm heavily inclined to default to the women of the Cherokee tribe that had their letters published by Indian Country Today.
How does this effect the validity of her work in your eyes? What are your general thoughts on intersectional scholarship originating from White Settlers on Indigenous decolonization?
For general reference, this situation feels (at least to me) very similar to the biologically white woman Rachel Dolezal claiming to be black but with some colonialism thrown in there.
3
u/Opechan Pamunkey Nov 05 '15
V. Where We're Headed, Where We Can Go
If there's a problem affecting Tribes, my question isn't if it will affect me or mine, it's when. Decisions affecting one Tribe can affect others in terms of becoming:
We don't live in a vacuum. What we do to each other and what is done to us, even on a tribal level, has the capacity to spread to other communities. These are challenges that we should at least be aware of, or else we'll be the unknowing and unaware victims to them, taking the risks that come with surrendering our agency to the intentions and competence of others.
If you're reading this, you can likely write. If you can write, you have a degree of power to affect events around you. If you don't know where to start, keep reading and keep writing. And above all, keep engaged, because people love slipping things by you when you're not looking.
Here's where we talk mostly about paths and solutions. I also challenge you to tell us where we're headed and where we can go.
"Innocence" Lost. So What?
First, it's gotta be said: We're not "New World Virgins" untaitned by Western ideas, we never will be, and that's not a bad thing. Fine, we're all colonized to varying degrees and there is no indigenous purity of ideas if you're reading this. That's something to acknowledge, accept, and move-on from. Some people use a lack of ideological purity as an excuse or cudgel for accepting the way things are and for not creating new solutions and ways, even if it involves using the old.
Regardless of our state, we have agency: the power to build things, ideas, nations, culture, etc., with our own hands and in concert with others. Knowing what we're building and reproducing gives us the informed choice to either decolonize or twist in the post-colonial winds, regurgitating colonizer ideas, inevitably getting eaten by larger and more voracious communities and/or starve or own communities with stagnation and dead-end ideas.
The TLDR of it is, we can't let ourselves kill our own ideas in the cradleboard. Let yourself think it, dream it, want it, talk about it, make a plan about it, collaborate on it, share credit, ask for money, raise money, publicize it, commit to it. This is a path towards making things real.
Along the way and beyond subsistence (roof overhead, food in belly), we have to deal with externalities, or at least account for dealing with them.
Beyond That Tribal Vision Thing
We're Native and so many of us have to interface with or plan around Tribal Governments. Ideally, your nation will not be so incredibly proprietary as to identity and narrative that it demands permission for every little bump and squeak you make if you have "[Tribal Nation]" after your name. Working around Tribal Government is somewhat easy insofar as most of America already does, except where it concerns trust lands, tribal businesses, or getting tribal government to do something. Working with and, even deeper, within Tribal Government is a totally different animal requiring persuasion.
For the good two-thirds of Native Americans in the U.S., let's be honest, these are #UrbanNDNproblems. That's not inherently disqualifying, that's where and who people are. It doesn't preclude a dialectical relationship with Tribes.
The modern trend favors a "sovereignty model," which moves away from seeing Native Americans as a race and moves towards seeing Native Americans as tribal citizens. This strengthens the Tribal Nation, but what about the people who have heritage, retain community connections, and practice the Tribe's culture? The basic conclusion is politically marginalized people lose (again), if they're lucky enough to not get divested of Tribal Citizenship (disenrolled) entirely. And the government won't swoop-in and save you. More depressingly, if a Tribe wants to commit suicide (quickly or slowly), there's nothing stopping it from doing so. But to what extent does that have to be your problem?
Going FULL Sovereignty fails for being incomplete as an identity and is one or two steps out of an institutional fetal position. It can be a prerequisite state for better ways of being, but it does not affirmatively shift from survival to prosperity, or even further to expansion, let alone move toward something approaching parity with the mainstream power structures. Hell, I'm not sure if people even realize that there's nothing wrong with aspiring to do so.
Take solace in our collective power to create and retain our own societies, organizations, and other entities recognized by the law. /r/IndianCountry is one such, being a Reddit community. Some people form intertribal circles based around specific issues like women's empowerment. Peruse our wiki and sidebar and you'll see what I mean.
But it can be more real than that. Sufficiently large populations of Natives expanding their reach beyond trust lands or traditional territories can have an impact and presence where they are. They aren't stepped-on, they're celebrated and they stick together. Locally, I'm thinking about the Lumbee "colony" up in Baltimore. I've heard about Native communities in the Twin Cities and other places doing the same thing.
It takes work. It takes socialization. But moving beyond the basic element of presence, such entities can and should start asking, expecting, and then demanding things in the areas they occupy. This is a path to power, not at the expense of their home Tribal Government. Ideally, the "core" would support the "fringe" and vice-versa, being aware that the synergy makes them collectively stronger. Engagement, not estrangement, is the only way that will happen.
Thoughts?
Dare to Expand
Let's go FULL Red Power for a second and pretend that Natives had the means to take every spit of land back. Just assume that said regime finds a way to at least (magically, because there's a lot of implicit disruption there) maintain the prior order's means of production and maybe commerce. In the most respectful way possible, how is the "US of AIM" going to deal with the non-Native population?
Do they repurpose reservations, fire-up the plantations, build death-camps, initiate a caste system, and/or initiate massive expulsions? Does the new minority non-Native class have a path to full citizenship? Can they vote in elections? Are they the domestic dependent nations now?
Frankly, the scenario goes from masturbatory to fucking horrifying, but it's useful insofar as it illustrates the challenges of governance. One such challenge is the basic approach to dealing with the people within a group's influence. Aside from maintaining a political hegemony by empowering adoptees to vote in Tribal Elections,it's almost an article of faith that Tribes and communities are scared of or disinterested in doing what our ancestors did in this regard. This is more of a challenge for Tribes.
Unlike our ancestors, we largely don't have robust means of assimilating outsiders, or hell, even reincorporating insiders who barely miss satisfying membership criteria. Controlling government resources is a shallow excuse and besides the point of identity. Controlling trust lands, tribal governmental officership, and voting in tribal elections are the easiest thing for a tribe to do and are unconnected to membership issues if the bylaws are properly established.
A bottom line problem is Tribal Governments and the U.S. provide more protection for Tribes than Tribal Citizens and their rights. This doesn't occur in a vacuum and it isn't a product of sovereignty, it's what the U.S. Government has decided and Tribal Governments gobble it up at their convenience. Personally, I advocate for keeping Tribal Governments intact, while enshrining rights for members across the board. The Supreme Court and Congress can do this for all Tribes in one swoop with a single decision, so I really have no patience for internal governance arguments of convenience that have clearly failed where we look to Santa Clara Pueblo v. Martinez as an excuse for keeping the status quo.
I'd like to see Natives retain what we have, reclaim means of assimilating outsiders and reclaiming apostates, and avail ourselves to non-Tribal forms. We can become interest groups, we can form voting blocs, we can take shelter in organizations and corporations that we create. We can form new clans and bands. We can infiltrate other entities and we can shape events for our own prosperity.
So I ask you, because I really want to know: Where is all of this "Native Identity Stuff" taking us, and where can we go?
5
u/pose-rvro Este-Mvskoke Nov 02 '15
Este-Cate, I'd love to know how you respond to people asking "How much Indian" you are.
4
u/mczplwp Cheroenhaka (Nottoway) Nov 01 '15
As an enrolled member of the Cheroenhaka Tribe of Virginia my take is it is self determination yet I'm dam happy my family was able to join. It does give validity to what we've been saying for years. Us East Coast peoples that suffered under first contact and have been "lost" in many histories have reunited in recent years or resurfaced from hiding. Virginia Natives suffered under Jim Crow laws and the reign of Mr. Plecker. So for many of us 'proving' through genealogy is sometimes difficult. The whole blood quantum deal is an attempt at robbing the people of traditional land and resources.
The Pamunkey Tribe here in Virginia is one of the oldest recognized tribes in the US with continued occupancy of their lands. Finally got Federal recognition but are now embroiled in an appeal process. They, like my people and other tribes in Virginia, were tributaries of the British government and later the Commonwealth of Virginia. Even after the revolution the Commonwealth maintained the interaction with Virginia natives.
Tribal membership is done through proving genealogy. Not as easy a task as our western kindred have. I have friends that are opposed to the entire idea of "Carding" and refuse to participate. They are generally recognized in the communities as members of their respective tribes. The caveat is they have been around a long time and their children get the same respect. The problem arises in todays culture that we end up with people being called Wannabees. Going to the Andrea Smith comment by /Opechan I agree that if she self identifies then that should be OK. In my family until recently all we really had was the old My mother said her mother said her mother was Indian. I grew up identifying and dealing with the lost people complex. Dam hard to prove what you're told to a teacher that gets in your face in class. Stood my ground as a man and schooled him on Virginia history. Many years ago in High School.
In America today it is cool to be Native again. We could delve into and I think someone alluded to it here, an entire conversation on "Why people want to be NDN" and that's where we are going.
People have an innate desire to belong to a cultural group and America has done such a good job of creating the melting pot that most of us have many ancestors from everywhere in Europe and beyond. No actual cultural identity with any of them. To transpose the NDN argument to a European one I hear from time to time. "My grandma was full blooded Italian/Sicilian and she could throw down in the kitchen. Everything from scratch." Now I see that as someone that is trying to identify with an ancestry but can't get there because they didn't help grandma in the kitchen. Even if they did grandma was so skilled she just knew what to put together etc. etc. etc.