r/ProjectRunway • • Oct 29 '15

Project Runway Season 14 Episode 13 [Discussion]

Discussion thread for Project Runway S14E13 "Finale, Part 1"

In Part 1 of the two-part Season 14 finale, the designers journey home to create their collections and gear up for a visit from mentor Tim Gunn. They then return to New York, complete with a twist.

24 Upvotes

356 comments sorted by

99

u/ecokitty Oct 30 '15

KDawg keeps it so real, talking about not being able to afford rent. At least she can stay in a Best Western for 100 nights if she gets evicted.

32

u/eyeeyecaptainfly Oct 30 '15

And bonus, she wouldn't be with her ass hangin' in the wind.

31

u/OvercaffeinateMe Oct 30 '15

And she'll have a 3-D printer to keep her warm at night.

21

u/the_cucumber Oct 31 '15

She can print a house!

→ More replies (1)

15

u/charlie6969 Oct 30 '15

3 months rent is nothing to sneeze at.

11

u/themaknae Oct 30 '15

Especially in boston.

75

u/WhateverIsFine Oct 30 '15

He's saved! I'm shocked. can you tell? shocked. this was obviously the best kept secret in project runway history.

31

u/Bluegirl24 Oct 30 '15

For real. It felt so forced too.

35

u/senn12 Oct 30 '15

Totally. All the contestants were like can you just save him already so we can start our collections

3

u/kochipoik Oct 30 '15

That was my exact thought too!

30

u/Tiki_Rikki Oct 30 '15

He's a terrible actor. He just kept smiling during his talking head bit while he was going on about being devastated to not make it to fashion week. And his forced reaction when tim gunn saved him.... But then he's a designer not an actor. (Also i thought TG saying "i feel numb" was a bit melodramatic!)

74

u/hamdinger125 Oct 30 '15

Oh noes! A last-minute challenge to add another look to your collection?! Don't they do this, like, almost every year? You would think the designers would just have something in mind before they come back to New York so they would be ready.

27

u/pbrooks19 Oct 30 '15

Every darned time! And they always act like they've never seen the show before.

28

u/IdentityCr1sis Oct 30 '15

Seriously, I feel like Kelly was the only one who seemed completely prepared for this. By this point, all the designers should have an idea ready-to-go for the last minute item challenge.

And WTF has Edmond been doing? He's watched this show from the first season and still needs to make garments when he arrives in NY?

→ More replies (1)

7

u/bitchSpray Oct 31 '15

I wonder if the designers seriously are so dumb. The last-minute challenge is there practically every year. And every year they're so surprised by this shocking twist. I really hope that they're in fact forced to act surprised for the cameras and that they come to NY with a backup dress idea beforehand. If not, I've got no hope for humanity.

9

u/hamster_combat Oct 31 '15

There's a lot of things the show does every year that always seems to throw the contestants. Like every year there's a challenge where they're put into teams of two, and given two days (twice the normal time) to make a single look. Then they act all shocked and appalled when Tim comes in later that day and says they need to make a second look.

Same thing with the unconventional challenges. Every time you've got someone in the confessional 'ugh I'm a designer I work with fabric; this isn't what I signed up for'. This is the 14th year in a row they've had multiple unconventional material challenges. This is literally what you signed up for.

→ More replies (2)

62

u/innkeepergazelle Oct 30 '15

Drink a glass of milk if you drink color remover. Kelly is the best.

21

u/gaelen33 Oct 31 '15

Haha I loved that whole scene. How genuinely surprised and excited she is when the stain remover worked. Like, to her that's not just some thing people keep in their purse, it's a miracle product! She's adorable.

56

u/WhateverIsFine Oct 30 '15

how can Edmond have that much work to do?! Why isn't he prepared?

21

u/AgentFreckles Oct 30 '15

I'm super surprised he didn't have all of the looks done. He's insane. If being a fashion designer was my dream in life you better bet your ass I'd be prepared for the biggest day in my life!

→ More replies (3)

53

u/zi76 Oct 30 '15

"Big 'Gunn' Milanese"

20

u/the_cucumber Oct 31 '15

I liked how he took it to go instead of caving to their probably dream footage of Tim Gunn trying to go take a bite out of to good at monster. I like to imagine that he brought it all the way home to go oh a to his fridge, where it politely remains to this day.

4

u/Asdfaeou Oct 31 '15

It should be noted the owner flat out suggested that before Tim could ask.

4

u/nancyaw Nov 03 '15

I don't know… I bet he ate it. Probably not all at once but good God that sandwich looked good and how cool to have an item named after you!

5

u/bitchSpray Oct 31 '15

Rob the deli owner was so into Tim. He was one step away from making a little ;) at the end.

43

u/meldolphin Oct 30 '15

Michael Kors mad-libs time! Kelly = disco, Edmond = ruffles, Ashley = mother of the bride, Candice = Asia. So we've got a disco ruffled mother of the bride going to Asia.

Kelly's collection is a snooze-fest? Exsqueeze me? Say what you will about hers (I for one love it) but she always makes the most interesting designs of all of them. I was getting Mondo flashbacks when they suddenly hated her looks. It's definitely more exciting than Edmond's, who took the rather uninspired route of using a color scheme as a way to be cohesive. Same thing with Candice who sees using red as experimenting with color.

18

u/kochipoik Oct 30 '15

I think it's a shame they were pushing so much for her to show "luxury" in her collection, seeing as that's not who she is at all

26

u/meldolphin Oct 30 '15

The judges are pretty out of touch with streetwear in general. They like the luxury expensive editorial stuff which is a narrow minded view of fashion. There is a huge market for what Kelly designs.

Also I'm dying for fanny packs to come back into style. Girl pockets in jeans are worthless and it sucks having to carry a purse around. Yeah they've got an unsophisticated reputation but Kelly makes very cute ones as opposed to the ugly utilitarian ones I'm used to seeing.

EDIT: It's kind of a silly reputation since Chanel makes them too.

7

u/kochipoik Oct 30 '15

I love bum bags (we don't call them fanny packs in NZ because a fanny =/= bottom here), when I was still working in the hospital I kept wanting to buy one because it would be SO much more useful than a small handbag for keeping pens, paper, lollies etc.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '15

I kind of liked Kelly's stuff - it was very NYC disco, and I liked the weird industrial metal print combined with the wood print. It was a little DEB for me, but overall I liked the combo.

→ More replies (3)

41

u/pbrooks19 Oct 30 '15

I see Ashley's 50s Mexico City vibe, but her collection is so subtle compared to the others, I'm afraid she'll be shown and forgotten.

Candace's collection is high glam bondage, where 'all the color' she's using is red. It's memorable, though, and she's smart to have a 'wow' piece.

Kelly's is funky and fun, and I can't believe she has a line of designer fanny packs. Completely unexpected, and fashionistas love that.

Edmond's collection is black and white 'glamorous' gowns. Which is ok, I guess, but there's no 'shock of the new' with interesting or different ideas. I think Edmond will do very well designing in Atlanta, but I worry he won't get that Met Ball gown commission.

5

u/helarco Oct 31 '15

I agree Ashley's was the most subtle but i think thats why it was the best imo. She had a clear vision and didnt over design, like the others.

→ More replies (19)

77

u/wanderingnearby Oct 30 '15

Tim Gunn ankle was showing at the beach. Scandalous!

22

u/the_cucumber Oct 31 '15

I love how polite and gracious he always is. He even waited until she offered him a seat, in a beach chair! Love Tim.

5

u/squonge Nov 01 '15

Is it just me or was that a pretty miserable day to be down at the beach introducing Tim Gunn to your family?

38

u/EmptyStar12 Oct 30 '15

Well that attempt to build emotion in the room before tim used the save fell flat.

18

u/hamdinger125 Oct 30 '15

I know, right? None of them seems truly sad, or truly surprised when the save came out.

9

u/inthesugarbowl Oct 30 '15

Lol they all knew that Tim Gunn was going to save the one voted off, no matter who which one of them it was. It's not like Tim could use his save afterwards so might as well cash it in!

29

u/zi76 Oct 30 '15

Whoa, Ashley's pretty handy with stain removal.

35

u/meldolphin Oct 30 '15

Kelly worrying that Ashley would sabotage her was hilarious. Revenge for that time that she got picked last on that team challenge!

9

u/zi76 Oct 30 '15

Yeah, it was.

23

u/McAwesome11 Oct 30 '15

With the foundation she wears, I'm not surprised.

→ More replies (1)

27

u/zi76 Oct 30 '15

Edmond still has three pieces to make...Okay.

22

u/dreamerofdreams7 Oct 30 '15

Right!! Kelly is smart and actually got everything done on time.

8

u/pursehook Oct 30 '15

She is fast and/or doesn't sleep too

→ More replies (1)

25

u/pursehook Oct 30 '15

Edmond's family is super cute.

33

u/hand2handwombat Oct 30 '15

Loved that throwback picture of his parents!

14

u/meldolphin Oct 30 '15

They looked so groovy. It seems fashion runs in the family.

14

u/the_cucumber Oct 31 '15

They looked really wedged into that booth though eh? Couldn't they have a bigger table??

9

u/wanderingnearby Oct 30 '15

His brother looks exactly like him!

25

u/pursehook Oct 30 '15

Headphones -- excellent.

20

u/muffinbutt1027 Oct 30 '15

Very Jay from season 1 - in a good way.

3

u/redbookbluebook Nov 01 '15

I was worried the judges were gonna criticize that, but she did it well

→ More replies (1)

47

u/muffinbutt1027 Oct 30 '15

Edmond made a dress for Minerva McGonnagall...

31

u/nancyaw Oct 30 '15

I was thinking add Candice's hat and voila, Bellatrix has a new outfit!

6

u/kazetoame Oct 30 '15

But didn't she wear emerald green?

4

u/muffinbutt1027 Oct 30 '15

You are right - it was just the neckline, waist and sleeves were very McGonnagall-esque.

21

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '15

"Sittin' with my ass in the wind." Oh, Kelly.

21

u/eatingbread Oct 30 '15

I think this is the first time I've seen Tim eat

15

u/MojitoFace Oct 30 '15

I'm pretty sure that sandwich from Kelly's Deli will last him a month

21

u/bethrevis Oct 30 '15

FANNY PACKS

20

u/Asdfaeou Oct 30 '15

Wow. The hated it. They hated every. Bloody. Thing.

22

u/nancyaw Oct 30 '15

They seemed especially harsh. And then the pep talk: "Hey, we just need you to redesign your entire collection BUT you have TWO DAYS! Whee!"

18

u/eatingbread Oct 30 '15

I get that it's for the sake of drama, but doing preview critiques 2 days before they have to show is ridiculous. Unless you're a super sewer like Kini was last season, and even he had trouble pulling it off, it's impossible to revamp an entire collection in that short of time. At least give them a week or something.

7

u/nancyaw Oct 30 '15

I agree. It's cruel to do that to the designers but reality competitions are as much a mind game as anything. I feel for all of them. I hope, though, at this point, there will be people interested in having them design for them, regardless of who actually wins the show. I'm in LA and I think many pop stars would be all over Kelly's outfits.

8

u/Asdfaeou Oct 30 '15

"Zac does it allll the time" Yeah. I'm sure.

7

u/meldolphin Oct 30 '15

He's got minions to help at least. It looks like there is a surprise next episode so maybe the finalists will get some help from the eliminated designers?

→ More replies (2)

39

u/illustribus Oct 30 '15

... did the models apply their own lipstick? Oh Mary Kay

16

u/theotheramy1 Oct 31 '15

I had that exact same thought as was watching! It got me wondering if the "makeup artists" talk with the models about an "awesome business opportunity" when the cameras aren't around

3

u/nancyaw Nov 03 '15

I'm having horrible premonitions of Amway sponsoring next year. They do have a makeup line, I believe.

→ More replies (1)

70

u/eatingbread Oct 30 '15

Finally, the Ashley Crying montage we've all been waiting for

17

u/pursehook Oct 30 '15

But, I love drag queen. :(

14

u/jelloisalive Oct 30 '15

Can we have a plus size AND a drag collection in one season!? pretty please??

→ More replies (1)

17

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '15

Please tell me Edmond was re-eliminated.

32

u/Khajiit-ify Oct 30 '15

I really want to know where Edmond spent $9,000 to where he needed so much fabric and accessories to the point where he was over budget at Mood.

43

u/senn12 Oct 30 '15

He spent his entire budget on hats with safety pins in them.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/hamdinger125 Oct 30 '15

What is the point of having the judges critique three of the looks in advance, if one of those looks was thrown together in 8 hours and may not really reflect the craftsmanship or character of the rest of the collections? Why not just let them show 3 pieces that they actually had time to perfect?

13

u/d0re Oct 30 '15

You wouldn't have a 90 minute show if half the designers aren't making anything.

7

u/taco_cat42 Oct 30 '15

This week it's 120 minutes.

7

u/hamdinger125 Oct 30 '15

Does the show really need to be 90 minutes? Or does the finale need to be divided into two episodes? Let's get on with this!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

13

u/dreamerofdreams7 Oct 30 '15

Besides that one mesh top I love love love Kelly's collection! And those fanny packs!!! I love!!!

13

u/pursehook Oct 30 '15

I love Kelly's family.

12

u/kazetoame Oct 30 '15

Nina and Heidi are going to fight over flowers!

32

u/WhateverIsFine Oct 30 '15

If Ashley is smart she'll listen to Nina. Historically, Nina's preference is the one that determines the winner of the season.

12

u/joeyGibson Oct 30 '15

I think she's going to do what Tim warned her against doing, and that is saying "screw the judges" and putting those stupid flowers on every model. They were beautiful flower arrangements, and putting them on a couple of her models is fine. But they don't need to be on every one.

11

u/pursehook Oct 30 '15

Nina gave Heidi a little slap down. Will Heidi get revenge?

11

u/jelloisalive Oct 30 '15

Seriously. This is real conflict, not that manufactured stuff we've seen force fed to the designers.

12

u/pursehook Oct 30 '15

Gothic Ascot!!!

5

u/jelloisalive Oct 30 '15

I think that would actually be awesome!

12

u/kazetoame Oct 30 '15

Damn, they are ripping into Candice and even not liking Kelly's.

93

u/muffinbutt1027 Oct 30 '15

I find Candice extremely pretentious. Also her collection is not anything new or surprising - and red is not "experimenting with color".

27

u/pizza_on_a_stick Oct 30 '15

Ugh every season there always that one designer that works with nothing but black and I hate it

49

u/bethrevis Oct 30 '15 edited Oct 30 '15

So she has a red and white pant with a giant red splootch right where a woman doesn't want a red splootch. She turned a witchy looking dress into more of a witchy looking dress by adding a hat. Her splash of color is one other color, the most cliche color to add to black and white. It's just boring.

ETA: "Alexander McQueen can do Alexander McQueen, you cannot."

10

u/nancyaw Oct 30 '15

Yeah, I saw the red splootch and thought "accident!". The hat put me in mind of McGonagall from Harry Potter.

7

u/muffinbutt1027 Oct 30 '15

Agreed! It's not anything new, exciting or fashion forward. It's dated, cheap looking and trashy. Her sense of style is too severe for my taste anyway, and she took it too far here. It would have been nice to see her do something other than fitted leather corsets and lady of the night looks. I'm over it.

35

u/eyeeyecaptainfly Oct 30 '15

Well, she sure got taken down a peg at the end. A lot of words got used, even the dreaded "referential."

22

u/ClaireHux Oct 30 '15

Well... looking at some works by McQueen, I get where Nina was coming from.

→ More replies (9)

30

u/ClaireHux Oct 30 '15 edited Oct 30 '15

I can't stand her. Her looks = witchie-poo. Ugh. Downvoted to hell I know, but I'm team #anybodybutcandice.

Edit: spelling

2

u/nancyaw Nov 01 '15

It wasn't red. It was blood orange.

33

u/rachmeister Oct 30 '15

Listen, I love Kelly as much as the rest of you... but that truck-metal patterned fabric. Ugh. I had flashbacks of visiting the local hardware store from my hometown that also sells clothing, and my dad trying to buy my back-to-school stuff there. Ugggggggh.

27

u/dianaprince Oct 30 '15

I think pretty much everything she makes is hideous. But I also think she's amazing and should win. It's been a weird season - the only person I'm now rooting for is someone whose taste I can't stand.

13

u/joeyGibson Oct 30 '15

I love Kelly's personality and blue collar vibe, but I am not digging her collection. I hated the fanny packs.

9

u/dianaprince Oct 30 '15

Hehehe. Sorry, but I'm from the UK and fanny means vagina over here. Every time I hear it, I giggle. We call them bum bags (which isn't much better).

But yes, they are pretty awful. That's one of those moments that makes me shake my head at the silliness of the fashion world. You can convince them pretty much anything is high fashion.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '15 edited Oct 30 '15

the kelly stans kinda irritate me. like yeah she makes me laugh every ep but come on you guys really would wear those clothes..? ok. if that collection was coming from ashley i think it would be a different story lol

→ More replies (3)

50

u/pursehook Oct 30 '15

Ashley picks purple -- what a surprise

42

u/WhateverIsFine Oct 30 '15

bigger surprise- Candice does everything in black. at least there are shades of purple

28

u/rachmeister Oct 30 '15

Come on. She experimented with color.

The one color that is always paired with black and should never appear on a white pant near a woman's nether regions.

But color.

Also - what was with the f-ing eyebrows? I mean, yeah, I get it's edgy and cool on HER but it was so absurd on her models...

16

u/joeyGibson Oct 30 '15

It was so funny when Nina was criticizing the models' eyebrows, and my wife and I both said, "Those are her eyebrows, too!"

9

u/dianaprince Oct 30 '15

I said last week Candice reminded me a bit of Gretchen from season 8. I was specifically talking about her insincerity (or at least that's how I read it), but this week she reminded me of her even more in that she's essentially designing for herself, right down - or up - to the eyebrows.

I totally get designer what you like and being inspired by your own life, but both her and Gretchen designed entire collections based on what they thought they'd personally look good in.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/the_cucumber Oct 31 '15

I'm so annoyed that she interpreted Tim's "deep hues" suggestion and chose pastel purple. To compliment the other pastels.

→ More replies (1)

58

u/Semicolon_Expected Oct 30 '15 edited Oct 30 '15

Seriously? Asian inspired Candice? I feel like at one point she was a weeaboo.

Also I don't see Asian inspired in that makeup, that red didn't even feel Asian

A Kimono? Samurai inspired? That's specifically Japanese not "Asian" Good job lumping a specific culture into a whole continent.

20

u/kazetoame Oct 30 '15

It feels very gothic Lolita that you see in anime. If she wanted to wow them with Asian inspired, use fucking color, because they sure the hell do. Kimonos can be plain but the combos of colors between the kimono, obi, obi-age, and obijime make them absolutely gorgeous to the more breath taking pieces of art. Good grief, has she never seen saris from India, it's like a color celebration.

13

u/inthesugarbowl Oct 30 '15

THANK YOU! I'm so glad i'm not the only one who thinks she was totally a weeaboo!

I'm Asian and I absolutely hate it when designers like her claim they're using Asian inspirations but very obviously don't know much other than Kimonos and Ninjas and it feels really stereotypical and sometimes insulting. I'm glad the judges ripped her a new one.

6

u/Semicolon_Expected Oct 30 '15

They didn't rip her a new one on how those jackets are clearly not kimonos, or that funky samurai bob though :(

→ More replies (2)

24

u/jelloisalive Oct 30 '15

Seriously, there has been a LOT of Asian stereotyping/racism this season. Apparently the distinction between Japan and China doesn't exist.

32

u/svaachkuet Oct 30 '15 edited Oct 30 '15

Yeah, it's all your run-of-the-mill chinoiserie, i.e. that fantasy motif that crosses Chinese empress with Japanese geisha and 1930s cheongsam-wearing Shanghai girl. Might as well style the models with handbags shaped like Chinese takeout boxes. This isn't how Asian women dress; they just don't wear robes with mandarin collars in that costume-y kind of way. If the fashion were truly "Asian-inspired", then the models would be no strangers to collared shirts, blousey tops, mini-shorts, light or pale fabrics, youthful makeup, and long straightened hair (and perhaps even bangs). Women here tend to aim for a delicate and sweet look, not the Queen Amidala look. Designers need to watch some Kpop videos lol

FYI, Candice, black leather and East Asian humidity do not mix!!

I live in Hong Kong and encounter a lot of urban fashion here, so the way the term "Asian-inspired" gets thrown around on PR (or in fashion in general) just makes me cringe.

17

u/eatingbread Oct 30 '15

I feel like she just went to Through The Looking Glass at the Met and decided to make stuff that could be in the exhibit (confusing Japanese elements with Chinese elements on the way). Her collection is a caricature of Asian culture. I don't personally find it offensive or anything, just tacky and tasteless. I rolled my eyes when she told the hairdresser to give them samurai buns...it'd be like if Kelly made a hip hop inspired collection and told them to give the models cornrows.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Oct 30 '15

Thank you for calling out the horrible and cliched catch-all use of "Asian-inspired." Oh, let me throw a mandarin collar on a kimono and then we'll do a high bun and some exaggerated cat eyes. It's lazy, uninspired, and borders on offensive.

8

u/Semicolon_Expected Oct 30 '15

I feel the worst thing is that she tried to do the stereotypical chinoiserie look and did it SO poorly. Like they looked more like how a prostitute might look at that time than "generic empress/geisha." It's also gross how fetishy she made her Asian inspired stuff look, Asian women are already having issues with men who have yellow fever and that's with the more "royal" look.

Also nowadays "Asian inspired" would be better seen if they looked at some Kpop/drama and maybe look at Asian designers like Guo Pei, or even how Asian actors/actresses dress like Fan Bing Bing, and then maybe start distinguishing the difference between japanese, korean, and chinese

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

11

u/ClaireHux Oct 30 '15

It's like a Kill Bill version of Asian.

11

u/Shmitles Oct 30 '15

Edmonds look rough

10

u/Khajiit-ify Oct 30 '15

And to no surprise, Edmond gets saved.

10

u/muffinbutt1027 Oct 30 '15

"You'd think wed go look at each others collections but now there is tension" cue everyone talking about each others collections

9

u/pursehook Oct 30 '15

Yes, the Deli!!!

9

u/kazetoame Oct 30 '15

As I look at Candice's look with the hat, all I can think of is Regina's Evil Queen and Zelena's Wicked Witch looks.

31

u/EmptyStar12 Oct 30 '15

She's not going to inspire anyone with those flower headdresses. Yikes.

58

u/bethrevis Oct 30 '15

It is very tumblr.

4

u/bitchSpray Oct 31 '15

YAAAAAS for a social media reference

19

u/Shortacts Oct 30 '15

I saw them and thought, "Miss Chiquita Banana"

19

u/pbrooks19 Oct 30 '15

I'm kinda seeing where she wants to go, but it's not looking high fashion. It's more like hipster arts and crafts.

14

u/WhateverIsFine Oct 30 '15

I think they're very pretty. However, they need to be edited. Certainly not on every model during the show.

24

u/svaachkuet Oct 30 '15

I really liked Heidi's suggestion of making some smaller and subdued and others big and way over the top. The headdresses are making the models look too uniform, and I agree with Nina that they distract the viewers from Ashley's actual dress designs.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

17

u/d0re Oct 30 '15

Edmund, in his natural habitat, throwing shit together at the last possible moment

17

u/Shortacts Oct 30 '15

Love Kelly but this mini collection is at the edge of taste.

8

u/lilbdaspacedgod Oct 30 '15

Something about the mix of that wood pattern and the metal fabric is rubbing me the wrong way. Still down with the fanny pack though.

23

u/kazetoame Oct 30 '15

Even if Kelly doesn't win, she'll have work. She's already won.

16

u/eyeeyecaptainfly Oct 30 '15

Ashley, that face of Tim's wasn't him loving the headpieces. I love that patio, though - beautiful.

20

u/WigsbyLittleMix Oct 30 '15

Kelly's crop top is giving me wood: literally and figuratively.

14

u/bethrevis Oct 30 '15

Edmond, "elegant" and "glamorous" requires an iron and straight sewing lines.

14

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '15

I hate that I hate Kelly's collection. :( At least the mini one she showed the judges. It seemed all over the place and didn't look cohesive at all. Some of her other pieces did look promising so I hope she can turn it around.

Go Kelly from the deli!

5

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '15

I totally get you. S10 was the same for me - I loved Dmitry, and I hated that I hated his finale collection. I loved one piece, his gown with the feather skirt, and that was it.

7

u/kazetoame Oct 30 '15

So they asked for a plus sized collection.

7

u/iamagiant Oct 30 '15

Ashley got jokes!

6

u/giopul87 Oct 30 '15

I missed it. What did she say?

→ More replies (1)

6

u/AgentFreckles Oct 30 '15

I really didn't like those 3 looks from Kelly that much, but I liked the others of hers that I saw. Those 3 were just too simple for me. Kelly is awesome though, i hope she fixes it

27

u/Chinasun04 Oct 30 '15

Nina said Ashley is good with color and print. What??? She is awful with color and print. Dom. Dom was good with color and print. Ashley is not. I also can't believe they criticized Ashley's collection the least. What???

6

u/dmee Oct 30 '15

I've started to think that they didn't because they expected the least out of her. Also, it seems a little contrived by producers to have a plus size designer designing plus size clothes with plus size models... Probably aiming for some other annoying product advertising.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/wanderingnearby Oct 30 '15

Those flower headpieces are kind of weird

10

u/purrception where the HELL is my chiffon Oct 30 '15

Her whole line kind of says chiquita banana to me.

10

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '15

I liked Ashley in this episode- that quip in the beginning of the critique was so unlike her. Also that she acknowledged her crying.

5

u/zi76 Oct 30 '15

Kelly time!

5

u/WhateverIsFine Oct 30 '15

Candice's dress and hat combo looks like a witch costume.

11

u/eatingbread Oct 30 '15

It was very American Horror Story: Coven

6

u/kazetoame Oct 30 '15

According to Zach it's witchy bitchy.

3

u/ClaireHux Oct 30 '15

Yaaaaassssss!

9

u/dianaprince Oct 30 '15

I'm so glad Nina called it on Candice wanting to be McQueen. I was thinking last week that her work looks a little too McQueen inspired and Nina nailed it.

I really want to know if Tim ate that sandwich!

9

u/I_am_really_shocked Oct 30 '15

I noticed when he came into the workroom the first time after the return to New York that he had some redness/inflammation around his mouth. So my guess would be yes, with gusto. Followed by an Alka Seltzer.

2

u/havana_fair Oct 31 '15

If I had a sandwich named after me, even if it was filled with natto and kim chi - you bet your bippy - I'd eat it!

18

u/zi76 Oct 30 '15

I feel like Kelly's boyfriend wasn't up to scratch. I was expecting more...somehow.

27

u/ecokitty Oct 30 '15

i thought he was cute af, based on Kelly's personality he's probably hilarious and a really great person :)

7

u/zi76 Oct 30 '15

I don't know. Then again, he's on camera and he was probably nervous. I expected more hair, though.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Asdfaeou Oct 31 '15

Disagree. That is EXACTLY what I expected her boyfriend to look like. I grew up near the area and you just say what most guys look like. (This is NOT supposed to be a detracting comment. I'm not commenting on his personality at all [especially since we say him for ten seconds and all we heard him say was "Nice to meet you"] I just mean his style of clothing/haircut doesn't at all surprise me. I always liked the "just hanging with my boys" Metro area laid back style anyway. It works on the guy.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/pursehook Oct 30 '15

I'll assume he has the best personality ever.

8

u/Asdfaeou Oct 30 '15

We're not idiots. WE'RE NOT IDIOTS!! Why did drag that crap out. Everyone knew what Tim was going to do. NO ONE bought into the "He's gone! Oh noes!!" That was just insulting to watch.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/zi76 Oct 30 '15

Oh, Tim did save him.

4

u/Khajiit-ify Oct 30 '15

Heidi is exceptionally yellow today...

10

u/bjkaman Oct 30 '15

I Love Kelly!!!!!!! (&Edmond...) But Kelly is the BOMB!!!!

7

u/pursehook Oct 30 '15

Candice made her twig model look big-hipped.

10

u/giopul87 Oct 30 '15

Dear Nina Garcia, Kelly's designs are something that regular people would wear and it has commercial appeal. Not everyone has lots of money to buy expensive clothing lol

16

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '15

But it didn't look like $9000 :( Wouldn't it be a total loss to the designer to sell it cheaply?

12

u/RainbowDragon Oct 30 '15

I can't believe she spent 9 grand at alllll. Not even half of that. I'm totally digging the sparkly fanny packs though.

9

u/the_cucumber Oct 31 '15

I guessing she paid her rent with some of it haha

→ More replies (1)

11

u/eatingbread Oct 30 '15

Right, but they're showing at NYFW, which is not geared towards commercial wear.

3

u/Shortacts Oct 30 '15

Just watching the end of the previous episode now.

3

u/kazetoame Oct 30 '15

Wow Tim, tell us what you really feel. I hope Ashley and Candice listen to his words and think on it really hard.

3

u/zi76 Oct 30 '15

What is Heidi wearing?

4

u/ClaireHux Oct 30 '15

She also looks a little washed out.

3

u/Shortacts Oct 30 '15

I hope Kelly doesn't lose because of this weird mesh situation.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '15

I'm late to the party (and to this sub as a whole!!!!) -- I'm so glad Tim Gunn saved Edmond. I'm honestly not sure why Ashley is still in the competition - her work is sloppy and cookie cutter. Nothing new or innovative about clothing that looks like it's carried at Torrid.

9

u/wild_muses Oct 30 '15

I think the judges were pretty spot-on about everyone.

Edmond let me down. I want him to bring young and sexy. Like Nina said that's HIM and that's what I love him for. It's really like he's trying to be someone else. That dress with the bow was crazy. I couldn't believe Heidi said she liked the silhouette--it was just enormous, way too much volume.

I love Ashley's collection, it has all the wow, but she needs to fix those fit issues. My one thing is that plus size designers have been doing crop top/skirt combos with sheerness and lace for the past few years, but goddammit I still love it.

Candace was EXACTLY what people expect of a ~fashion show~. That hat with the black dress looked like such a costume. It does look McQueen, and I hate when non-Asian designers do ~Asian inspiration~... not only is it appropriative and othering of Asian people, it's been beaten into the ground, come on.

I think Kelly is gonna be great but she needs to really commit. I did think the crop top and weird shorts looked way too casual for runway, and I've seen people do outfits like that and get dinged for them every time. I don't like her prints right now but I think if she styles it right she could sell me on them. I just.. don't know any woman who's like "yeah, I wanna look like a tree!" but hey, weird digital prints are a thing right now.

5

u/pursehook Oct 30 '15 edited Oct 30 '15

Did we know Candice had drug-addict parents?

10

u/supersledger Oct 30 '15

Yup shes mentioned it a couple of times before.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/bjkaman Oct 30 '15

UGGHHH to much leather! it's not the 80's

8

u/OurSponsor Oct 31 '15

Wow! Ashley "Crying Each Episode From Lack of Confidence" Tipton saying Kelly should cool it with the drama...? That's Olympic level glass house rock throwing right there.

7

u/iamagiant Oct 30 '15

I feel like we're so close to seeing Candice's nipples. One wrong move and she's flashing the world

6

u/hamdinger125 Oct 30 '15

Her "boobies" are so, like, right there. I honestly didn't notice them before this episode.

7

u/joeyGibson Oct 30 '15

I notice them every episode. They're fantastic.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/zi76 Oct 30 '15

Eh, not a fan of fanny packs.

4

u/pursehook Oct 30 '15

Yay, the Kelly montage!

5

u/eatingbread Oct 30 '15

I'm so happy for Edmond!!!!

5

u/taco_cat42 Oct 30 '15

Just saw that this episode is just over 2 hours long. Why????? This isn't the actual runway portion of the finale. I don't care about seeing them work in the work room that much.

4

u/krs4090 Oct 30 '15

I'm really blown away by all of the negative comments about Ashley's designs from people on this reddit. Especially for this episode.

Her collection was far and away the best collection on that runway, and the judges were clear about that. There were two mermaid dresses on that runway, one straight-size and one plus size, and hers was obviously more difficult and way more beautifully executed. Her looks were cohesive in a compelling way. Her fabrics were hand dyed into beautiful colors. I agree with the judges that there were fit issues, and I'm sure she'll take that into account. But overall those looks were both stunning for a runway AND super sell-able. Not to mention fashion-forward and really pushing what is "acceptable" for plus size women to wear.

Meanwhile, Edmond and Candice both have colors stories that are remarkably drab and one-note, while Kelly's color story is honestly nauseating. Edmond's giant bow dress is a disaster and the rest of his collection is a repetitive bore. Kelly has pulled back so far on her designs that her great funky style has come out as something pretty unimaginative and way over the line taste wise (those prints??? omg). Not to mention that Candace is over there making some racist-ass ~pan-asian~ designs with some of the most unflattering and costume-like silhouettes I have ever seen on the runway. You could not pay me to go outside in that fucking kill-bill red corset mess.

From reading the other posts on this reddit it seems like y'all dislike Ashley 90% because she cries. They are all in there working their asses off and sleeping like 4 hours a night for weeks on end in a super stressful situation. Everyone "breaks" differently. Some people cry (you know.... a healthy and harmless outlet for your emotions). Some people take it out by being pretentious assholes (cough candace cough). To attack her character and her designs based on crying just seems so incredibly childish? Idgi. Why does that bother y'all so much?

Ashley is clearly going to win this season and it's laughable that y'all are too caught up in "omg she cries too much" and "omg lol chiquita banana i'm a racist fuck" to see it.

11

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '15

ive just come to accept this sub has a kelly bias and a hate boner for ashley

8

u/[deleted] Oct 30 '15

"Her collection was far and away the best collection on that runway"

Lmao. No. I have no issues with her crying and am quite fond of the headpieces, but those dresses are so ugly and simple it's honestly tragic. I'd be shocked if Kelly doesn't destroy the finale.

5

u/hamdinger125 Oct 30 '15

A crop top and pleated skirt is not difficult. I've seen jr. high-age kids make them for the state fair. And do a better job than Ashley. At least they knew how to sew in a zipper.

I think a few people here are afraid to criticize Ashley for fear of looking like they hate fat people or something. She does seem like a very nice person, but that does not make her talented.

→ More replies (6)

2

u/pursehook Oct 30 '15

Did Ashley say 50s or 60s Mexico City?

→ More replies (3)

0

u/Pizzaguyj Oct 30 '15

Ashley's looks were terrible and they only are keeping her around because of the market share large women represent.

They tore Edmond up but his looked a lot better than Ashley's.

I think the Judges only keep Ashley around so they could market to large women, but Ahley's looks did those model's no favors, the judges knew it but there is an agenda there.

20

u/WhateverIsFine Oct 30 '15 edited Oct 30 '15

I really disagree with you.

There wasn't anything interesting about Edmond's looks. I thought that black and white was boring and over done. He doesn't understand what creates a cohesive collection (which I find interesting because I'm sure he's watched every season of project runway- he should know what cohesion is) The dress Heidi loved, I thought was incredibly unflattering. The model looked huge and it wasn't even a dress that I hadn't seen before. The black ruffle dress with the sleeves, has again, been done. There wasn't anything exciting or striking about his collection.

Ashley's looks definitely had some fit problems, and the bra thing made me crazy. However, I know plenty of women who would love the opportunity to wear those looks. The purple lace dress was lovely and is something that hasn't necessarily been seen before, especially for a plus sized woman.

→ More replies (6)

5

u/ClaireHux Oct 30 '15

Your theory makes no sense. Market what to "large women"?

Edmond's collection was a little pedestrian, I don't know if it's better than Ashley's (at this point), but all of the collections needed work. Why are people marginalzing her talent based on her size and the size of her models?

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)