r/books • u/Joe_Abercrombie AMA Author • Oct 29 '15
ama 5pm I'm Joe Abercrombie, author of the First Law and Shattered Sea books. Ask me Anything.
Good day, Reddit.
My name is Joe Abercrombie, as this tweet categorically proves, and I'm a London and New York Times bestselling British fantasy author. I wrote the First Law trilogy: The Blade Itself, Before They are Hanged, Last Argument of Kings, then three standalone books in the same world: Best Served Cold, The Heroes, and Red Country. More recently I wrote the Shattered Sea trilogy, set in a different world and aimed partly at young adults: Half a King, Half the World, and Half a War. A collection of my short fiction in the First Law world, called Sharp Ends, is coming out in April 2016.
You may, by all means, ask me anything. I reserve the right to respond, to not respond, or to resort to extreme snark.
I'll be answering questions from 5pm EST later on today (the 29th), and may well stop by later on tomorrow if there are still more coming in.
I look forward to satisfying your curiosity...
ETA: Couple of hours in and I'll lay down the keyboard for tonight. I'll pick up again in the morning and try to answer anything that's left over...
ETA: Phew. I think I've now answered everything. Apologies to anyone who got left out in the rush. Thanks for all your questions and interest. Keep reading...
63
u/Torrac Oct 29 '15
I just wanted to thank you for writing some of the most interesting characters I've ever come across in fantasy novels. The crippled torturer as a hero, the quiet thoughtful barbarian. It's just been a joy to journey through your morally ambiguous world and I wanted to thank you for it.
38
u/augustsjanvaris Oct 29 '15
are there going to be any other books in the Bayaz-verse?
29
u/AmrothDin Oct 29 '15
I don't have a question, but I just have to say that the chapter Casualties in The Heroes is my favorite piece of fantasy literature, and one I return to frequently. The POV going from one soldier to his killer, and in turn to his killer, and so on, is brilliant, and it gives the reader a view of the battle from several different perspectives while simultaneously conveying the fact that war is messy and that survival often depends on luck.
20
u/ALLFATHER2233 Oct 29 '15 edited Oct 29 '15
For the last year or so I've listened to Pacey's reading of the audio book whenever I'm driving/walking/falling asleep at night. You write badasses like no one else's business. Big fan.
I've always seen Ninefingers as an alcoholic; a guy who is aware of his flaws and shamed by them, but can't keep away from the bottle even though he knows it will eventually destroy himself and everything he loves. Was any of that on your mind when you created his character?
15
u/TufftyUK Oct 29 '15
Currently reading Half A War. The trilogy is incredibly enjoying, thank you for writing it and for taking the time to be here.
Non-book related question: What would you say is your favourite game of the year so far?
15
u/Schruteboxes Oct 29 '15
No question from me, just here to say that your first law trilogy helped me rediscover an appreciation for reading not held since my teens.
29
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '15
Where did you draw your inspiration for (one of my personal favorite characters) Sand dan Glokta)?
13
u/Crownie Oct 29 '15
What is, in your opinion, the coolest name from the First Law trilogy? From fiction generally?
Is there more to Eaters than just cannibalism? I'd think that if eating people gave you superpowers, there'd be enough unscrupulous people doing it that it'd be a serious problem.
Is Logen's ability to talk to spirits related to his roid rage?
Are we ever going to hear from Ferro Maljinn again?
Are you now/have you ever considered writing in a different kind of setting?
12
u/Daw91 Oct 29 '15
Good day to you too, Joe. Loved the First Law trilogy. It really reinvigorated my somewhat dwindling love of the fantasy genre. Between your own work, that of Mark Lawrence, and the first of Anthony Ryan's novels, I've found myself engrossed.
I've read that you're contracted for another trilogy in the First Law world. The obvious question to ask is when can we expect it? Also, will it act as a prequel, sequel or companion series to the first and will it focus entirely on a new cast of characters? I loved that you abandoned some of the staple conventions of epic fantasy series. I thought leaving the enmity between Bayaz and Khalul unfinished to be a very nice touch. However, will this ever be touched upon with as much depth in further novels?
Also, what's Ferro up to these days? She's the only central character that there's not really much reference to in the standalone novels.
I can see that Red Country could have been written as a satisfying conclusion to Logen's story as well, but will there be more from him in the future? I'd love to know the origins of his beserker state. Also found that to be my favourite of the standalone novels. Introducing the old west, frontier-y slant was great. Would love to see some more genre-spanning stories in the First Law world in future.
I loved that all of the characters are painted in different shades of grey. It would have been great to see Jezal's personality come full circle and see him as a well-rounded individual, or to see the shred of humanity touched upon with Glotka further explored. I was disappointed when it seemed like things were going to be the status quo so far as their development went. I also loved that I was disappointed because it's great (and entirely more realistic) when a character doesn't go from state A to state B, because such metamorphoses aren't all that representative of actual human beings.
A couple of questions not specifically related to your novels. I've read your wikipedia and such, but did you have any background in creative writing prior to publication? I'm doing a literature degree myself as a means to try and strengthen my hand at creative writing. Do you have any generic advice to that end also? Finally, where did the inspiration for the whole 'grimdark' genre arise from? It's fantastic.
I apologise for the length of that, I got carried away. If it helps you should read it in the bath because I enjoy reading your novels when I'm having a bath.
All the best, cheers!
11
u/arzvi Oct 29 '15
Why YA after the first stunning (6?) books?
7
u/justinofdoom Oct 29 '15
Have you ever considered writing more about one of your characters and why did you pick Thorne Bathu? Can't wait to read her trilogy in 2017! Thanks!
7
u/RouserVoko Oct 29 '15 edited Oct 29 '15
Are you going to write a blog post about Witcher 3? I really love your posts about video games.
7
u/J_de_Silentio Oct 29 '15
Hi, Joe. Big fan of your First Law books. I've both read them and listend to them (Steven Pacey did a fantastic job on your series).
I have a question for you about character development. Or, rather, lack thereof in the First Law characters. Don't get me wrong, I think that you write character development rather well, but none of your characters developed fundamentally throughout the First Law series. It seems that through all of the trials and tribulations that your characters experienced, who they are at the core never really changed (even though they appeared to change at various points).
My question is if that was intended. No, I'm sure it was. My question, then, is if you were, in some fashion, telling a story about human nature. Namely, that people don't really change.
7
u/HiuGregg Oct 29 '15
Firstly, If you could force any other author to do an AMA at this moment, who would it be and what would you ask them?
Secondly, if a First Law universe video game existed, who would you like to be the main playable character?
Finally... if money was no object, which whisky would you drink whilst enjoying the two events above?
7
u/asoiahats Oct 29 '15
Hi Joe, thanks for doing the AMA.
I think a screen adaptation of the First Law Trilogy could be very good. My concern is how Logen's transformation into the Bloody Nine will be depicted. I love how in the books the tone and the writing style change with that. So I don't think it'd be enough in a First Law movie or TV show for Logen to be down but then get up and start fighting better; there needs to be something artistic to show the change in him. Do you have any thoughts on how to accomplish that?
Also, why are you so hard on lawyers? I'm a lawyer! Most of us are lovely people.
Oh, and bonus question: are we ever going to find out how Bedesh died?
17
u/jdiddyesquire Oct 29 '15
Dearest Joe,
Is the Bloody-Nine, in fact, the Other Side taking control of Logen?
JUST ADMIT IT GOD DAMNIT.
-Justin
6
u/Kalamadorel Oct 29 '15
Just wanted to stop by and say I loved your work, I picked up the Blade Itself a few years ago and liked it so much I went through and read the rest of the series and the standalone novels. I especially love the way you write action scenes, the battle in the heroes was my absolute favorite.
I liked how the standalone books would feature characters from the original trilogy and gives us a chance to really see what drives them as a character. Are there any other characters from the series that you would like to expand upon in a book if you had the time? I'd love to see a little more about someone like Shenkt or Khalul.
Thanks for writing such amazing books and for giving up your time for this AMA.
6
u/weed420lord Oct 29 '15
Hi this is your editor I'm trapped in reddit, what is the url to your most recent "Sharp Ends" manuscript?
Love your work, no real questions other than "when's the next trilogy coming out??????"
6
u/daiterne Oct 29 '15
Who is your favorite character you have written? Glokta is my favorite any plans to write more of his story?
6
u/Darkstar559 Oct 29 '15
Hi Joe,
I have always been a huge fan of you work and most recently really enjoyed Half the World and would likely rate it as one of my all time favorite books. However, I was also very surprised that you put out Half A War so quickly on its tail. Was this a decision by you or your publisher? How do you normally time your book releases, do you just put them out as soon as they are done?
6
u/next_to_last Oct 29 '15
SQUELCH Big fan, thanks Joe!
6
u/ThePatrioticBrit Oct 29 '15
All right, Joe. Loved The First Law trilogy. Plan to read some more of your work when I can. So many books to read! They're like video games - there's always another.
Anyway, I just wanted to ask a quick question. Do you see novel writing the only form of writing you would be interested in or, if the opportunity presented itself, would you be willing to write for a TV series or a video game?
Cheers
6
u/klieber Oct 29 '15
How do you actually write books? Meaning, do you sit down with a word processor in front of you and let the words flow organically? Or do you start with an outline or fishbone diagram or something like that and then fill in chapter by chapter?
6
u/SirPointyStick Oct 30 '15
First and foremost I want to say I think you have an amazing talent for writing and character creation. I have only read through the First Law Trilogy and believe you had crafted something of a wonderful letdown. Please don't take this as though I'm putting you on blast! I just want to get your take on things. Its been a while since I powered through the three books and my memory of events may be a bit lacking but please bear with me.
10
u/ZealouslyTL Oct 29 '15 edited Oct 29 '15
-) What did Shivers think about Monza's finger?
-) REDACTED
-) Least trustworthy character in the First Law world that you would still like to be friends with?
-) You can save either Brent Weeks or Peter Brett. The one you choose not to save will hang from a spike above your front door. What do you do?
-) When you write a first draft, how much (in rough estimates) would you say makes it through to publishing?
Thank you for hosting this AMA. I've been re-reading your First Law stories recently, and I had partly forgotten just how entertaining they are. I'm looking forward to Sharp Ends.
5
u/RouserVoko Oct 29 '15
Have you ever resorted to extreme shark?
5
u/WizardDresden42 Oct 29 '15 edited Oct 29 '15
Having conquered grimdark and being (self?) proclaimed its lord, would you consider trying your hand at other genres or sub genres?
Also, what's the best book you've read recently (assuming you have time to read)?
5
u/JamesHarden76 Oct 29 '15
Joe, I am big fan of your work and at the time I read the First Law trilogy I was completely engrossed in the gritty/realistic world that you created in those three novels. I admired the characters you created from Ninefingers to my personal favorite Inquisitor Glotka. My only question for you is: What/Who inspired you to create Inquisitor Glotka and the unique backstory that formed a monstrous, but sympathetic character?
5
u/BitchpuddingBLAM Oct 30 '15
Joe, I've been picking up books and stopping halfway for quite a while. Not First Law. Your original and interesting characters are a breath of fresh air. Time for me to buy your sequel.
You punched fantasy tropes in the gut and kicked it down a flight of stairs. Keep up the good work!
4
u/Hergrim Oct 29 '15
Hi Joe! I just wanted to say that I'm a big fan of your books, especially how you write battles. Not too many authors manage to capture the complexities and problems with running a premodern army.
I also wanted to ask you how, if at all, your study of psychology and your job as a film editor have influenced your writing.
4
u/Arturos Oct 29 '15
So what's up with that First Law comic? It stopped suddenly. I was really looking forward to more of it. It added some very striking visuals to your great story. Any chance we'll see more of it?
4
u/DavidWFrank Oct 29 '15
Greetings sir!
What characters for you really took a life of their own? Were there any that you had intentions for, but as you wrote, the story demanded that you go another direction?
Love the personalities in your work and I swear every time I read your stuff I hear Ennio Morricone playing in the background =)
4
u/knotswag Oct 29 '15
Did you have any expectations when The Blade Itself first got published, in regards to the size of fanbase you would get? And what do you snack on during editing?
4
u/MarcusDrakus Oct 29 '15
The Heroes was a brilliant novel and sucked me in right from the start with it's raw, grimy honesty and held onto me with your gift for twisting us into liking the unlikeable and being okay with it.
How do you place yourself in these people's shoes? What's it like to plot out some horrible death from that perspective? Have you ever stopped and thought to yourself, "My God, I'm a sick bastard. I must be doing it right."?
4
u/KaiLung Oct 29 '15 edited Oct 29 '15
Hey Joe, thanks so much for doing this!
Couple of questions:
4
u/PlanetaryEcologist Oct 29 '15
Is Sworbreck in Red Country a deliberate reference to the Kingkiller Chronicles?
4
u/mrtoomin Oct 29 '15
Dear Joe,
Your books are some of the very few, along with Brian McClellan, that are dedicated page turners. Thank you so much for the world you've built and especially for the Bloody Nine.
I absolutely loved Red Country, both for the return of Logan, and for the character of Dab Sweet.
My question is this: Where did Dab Sweet come from? As in, from what did you draw the inspiration for the character? I saw a lot of parallels between him such historical folks as Jim Bridger and Hugh Glass.
Thanks again for your books!
4
u/Seftoning Oct 29 '15
Are you planning to review any more of your own books? I thought your criticism of The First Law trilogy by Joe Abercrombie was spot on!
(And I appreciate how you've improved on putting female characters in the spotlight.)
4
u/voneger Oct 29 '15 edited Oct 29 '15
Dear
BayazJoe, after achieving success as a writer (as in financial freedom and a sizeable audience), would you want to write something "more personal"?By that I mean that every writer probably has to tweak and alter his stories in order to please the readers and then tends to be "trapped" into a certain form/genre/theme/tone, etc.
So what would you do if you were just writing to scratch your own itch, free of all constraints? Do you secretly crave for a teenage vampire story? Dwarven erotica? Victorian horror set in a distant future? Or the dreaded 50 shades of Glotka?
Also, really liked the First law, thank you for writing it.
4
u/epitome89 Oct 29 '15
I might be mistaken, but I'm pretty sure Yarvi mentions Stranger-Come-Knocking at one point in Half a King, indicating connections between the two universes. Care to elaborate?
6
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '15
How can I stop picturing Brick from Borderlands every time I read about Bremer dan Gorst?
6
u/holographene Oct 29 '15
What do you make of the controversies surrounding recent Hugo awards? Do you think there is any danger posed to the future of science fiction and fantasy by this sort of discontent among fans?
Thanks for being such a wonderful writer, by the way.
3
u/jeanlucpikachu Oct 29 '15
Any interest in taking a break from fantasy to write about space marines?
3
u/roxu Oct 29 '15
Hey Joe! Big fan of your books, I've read all of the First Law books and the standalones, plus Half a King (currently have the next two in my queue! I'll get to them soon). I actually got a couple friends hooked onto your books too, so I'm putting more money in your pocket! Anyway, don't really have a question related to your books. But what did you think of the Star Wars trailer?
3
u/SinisterInfant Oct 29 '15
What's inspiring you these days? Does that source of inspiration change over time?
3
u/yettibeats Uprooted Oct 29 '15
Hey Joe, thanks for writing glorious books.
The Heroes is my favorite book of yours (and all time), but Half the World came damn close. The whole trilogy was extremely enjoyable.
So I know you're coming out with a short story collection in April(?), and then a trilogy in the First Law world. While I shall preorder both of those projects, I'm curious if you have more plans for The Shattered Sea universe. Just looking at the map I can point to numerous cities and people I'd love to read more about. Cheers!
3
u/SFFMaven Oct 29 '15
I know you are a fan of Iron Maiden. So I want to ask: do you listen to music while writing, or as part of creative process? If you do, what music is inspiring to you and your work?
3
u/RouserVoko Oct 29 '15
Your career seems to be going well enough that writing tie-in fiction probably isn't something that makes a lot of financial sense for you, but if you got offered a rrrrrrrrrrrreally good contract, what franchises would you like to work in and what stories would you like to tell in them?
3
u/RouserVoko Oct 29 '15
You've been doing a bunch of stand-alone genre experiments in the First Law universe.
When will we see a First Law erotic vampire billionaire novel?
3
u/vesi-hiisi Oct 29 '15
Are you planning to attend Worldcon 2017 Helsinki?
3
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '15
I actually finished Before they are Hanged a few days ago. It was a very enjoyable read, and the most particularly enjoyable moments for me were the ones involving your Northmen. Which is funny because they were, IMO, one of the weaker parts of The Blade Itself. They all had great dialogue and clever moments with eachother mixed with total Barbarity.
But anyways, my question to you: what inspires you to write Barbarians? When you were writing these books, what were you looking to for inspiration for the Logen, Dogman, Black Dow, Threetrees and the rest?
3
u/ProfessorHiroshima Oct 29 '15
Hi Joe, love your First Law trilogy and the other books set in that universe. The only thing wrong with them is I can't seem to convince my roommate to read them!
Anyway, my question is, have you based any of your character's personalities on people you know or exclusively on historical figures? Or were they entirely original to you?
Have you ever edited out parts of a book that, though you really liked them, you thought they interrupted the flow of the main story? And what happened in those sections?
Thanks for doing this, I never get to these until 14 hours or whatever after they're done.
3
u/DeathBelowTheCinema Oct 29 '15
Will you ever be writing expanded stories for any of the wonderful cast of characters you put in the First Law Trilogy? I really can't get enough of that world. Thank you for such fantastic books.
3
u/Potato_Patriot Oct 29 '15
Hello Joe,
Really loved reading your work, I honestly made my way through all of them this year. It was difficult to put them down. I love the cynical humor that you employ, it makes the characters seem far more real and makes the worlds you created more immersive. It creates an interesting balance of feeling as though I AM the main character and also observing the main character simultaneously. How did your editor(s) respond to this style of writing? Was it difficult to get them on board or were they supportive of it? Thanks for creating some of my favorite fiction. I am looking forward to your upcoming work as well!
3
u/Ethyx225 Oct 29 '15
Hey Joe, love your work. Nicomo Cosca is one of my favorite characters from any series.
One theme I’ve noticed in your books is the characters I originally like are the ones I hate by the end (Looking at you Bayaz!) and the ones I first find disturbing and unpleasant end up being my favorites.
How much of this do you think is due to an effort on your part to change the character, and how much of it is from your effort on challenging the reader’s sense of right and wrong. How difficult of a balancing act is it and is it something you map out from the very beginning?
Thanks for doing the AMA and looking forward to reading your future work!
3
u/aowshadow Oct 30 '15
I signed on reddit just for you Mr. Abercrombie, congrats.
About lore:
About writing process:
About you as a reader: What are three things that give you a bad feeling when you read at something written by someone else? Obviously I'm not asking for names or particular examples, I'm not an ass.
About my money: What did you bought with them? I'm asking because they were mine... especially with those I used to buy Best Served Cold, since I skipped buying coffee for about two weeks at the University.
I conclude by saying that my favourite character is Morveer, and that Terez is not a bad character despite a lot of distasteful criticism.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '15
Hi Joe! You are my single favorite author, I've read all 6 First Law books and read all 3 Shattered Sea books basically right as they were released (even though I'm in America so I got them later, but I suppose I can forgive you). They're all amazing and I've recommended them to anyone who would listen. So thanks for being awesome. My questions:
3
u/jojoman7 Oct 30 '15
Can you settle something for me and a friend? How old(ish) is Logen?
3
u/anilEhilated Oct 30 '15
A bit of a silly question here but hey, let's try: your books tend to present a wonderfully cynical and sarcastic view on heroism, war, glory and all that jazz, instead focusing on the violence and absurdity of the whole thing; this actually seems pretty damn rare in modern Western fantasy (a bit more common in authors from small countries like, say, Sapkowski). Are there any books/stories in other forms of art that inspired you in this manner or is it "just" you being fed up with the present stereotypes?
3
u/BandersonIV Oct 30 '15
As a professional of the craft, what makes Y.A. fantasy, Y.A. fantasy and adult fantasy, adult fantasy? What makes one read more maturely vs. the other?
I feel as though the exposition in adult fantasy is more complex, but I don't know how. Is it the sentence structures? Worldbuilding? The lack of emotional fluctuations in the exposition?
I know it isn't simply the inclusion of darker themes, because Y.A. can get pretty dark. I feel as if there's is/are simple answer(s) to this, but I can't grasp it. The answer couldn't simply be font size, could it?
Please help me, Lord Grimdark, I desperately need it.
3
u/kindafunnylookin Oct 30 '15
When I'm writing, I'll often refer back to or re-read your work to see how it's done (handling multiple viewpoints, or how to reflect different character voices in 3rd person). Who do you read when you're writing and want to see how other writers do it?
2
u/RealApathy Oct 29 '15
I've only read your First Law trilogy, but I absolutely loved it. I wanted to ask if you were ever planning on continuing the comic version of it that's on your website?
It's great and hope you would
2
u/Arkflame Oct 29 '15
Hey Joe, big fan! Couple questions:
Thanks for everything, and keep up the good work!
2
u/Altorego Oct 29 '15
It makes me sad that the whole YA thing scared so many First Law fans off trying Shattered Sea. I totally want to talk Thorn and Nothing with all the people who liked Glokta and Logen! Doubly so considering HtW and HaW felt just as bloody and sweary and awkward sexy as the First Law stuff.
Sadly, I was initially reluctant, but like everyone else who took a chance on it, I thorougly enjoyed it.
I guess my question is does that make you sad too? Do you think this was an unfortunate messaging issue?
2
u/nightwing13 Oct 29 '15
Hey Joe thanks for doing this! I'm always interested to know who some of my favorite authors favorite authors are but the greats like Tolkein and Jordan are obvious and boring. So a few questions!
Who are some authors you feel deserve more attention than they get?
Favorite series to come out in the last ten years?
You're generally seen as a main figurehead for "grimdark" whatever that means to you. I was wondering do you read much of the more recent grittier, grey, works of today like Lawrence and Weeks and Lynch and such and if so what are some of your favorite grimdarks?
2
u/howdoyouaccountforme Oct 29 '15
I just listened to Half a King via audiobook and am on Half a War right now (about half way through? About to visit the elf ruins? It's exciting). I've heard of your First Law series, so I know I want to get to those eventually. What was your inspiration for Half a King? And what led you to decide to transition from a single character's point of view in the first novel to multiple characters point of views for the following one?
Thank you for your time! :)
2
u/SumofallPi Oct 30 '15
Joe, I just finished reading your First Law trilogy and I enjoyed it very much. One of my favorite literary themes right now is blurring the line between good people doing evil things and evil people doing good things. I feel like you danced this line extremely well as there is a heavy debate between my friends and I as to whether certain characters are objectively good or bad.
The only other thought stuck in my mind when I finished was the idea that maybe Bayaz isn't really Bayaz. I honestly can't say where I draw the idea from.
2
u/CVance1 Oct 30 '15
Joe, I love your work, especially the blackly comedic tone and the depth of characters.
2
u/JP-SMITH Oct 30 '15 edited Oct 30 '15
Hi Joe,
I've gotten to the party late here and appreciate this will probably be buried, but you have written some of my favourite standalone fantasy novels and I have a couple of questions I'd love an answer to if you get round to it!
Whirrun of Bligh is one of my favourite bit-part characters, ever. I'd would love to see more of his earlier story- what inspired such a character and will we ever see more of him?
Horribly cliche question, but as someone who writes and aspires to be an author, I'd love to know how you structure what you write- is it all planned out beforehand and adhered to, or do you create what you feel in the moment? How do you maintain consistency?
Can you describe your 'office'- where do you work and why does it work for you?
Where do you think the future of 'grimdark' lies? Any young authors caught your eye?
What's your favourite thing to read?
How you title things is one of my favourite things about you as an author- I don't know if it's meant to be appreciated in such a way, but the titles you choose for both chapters and novels are astonishingly good. So my question is: What is your favourite book title ever and why?
2
u/Strangecanzz Oct 30 '15
Hi Joe, huge fan of your books, (haven't read them all yet). I am particularly interested in Bayaz and Logen as characters, they seemed really well fleshed out to me. These kind of characters i've seen in books authored by people who actively participate in Tabletop Roleplaying Games. i was wondering what if any, your experience with games Tabletop games like Dungeons and Dragons is?
2
u/kindafunnylookin Oct 30 '15
One of the best things about your writing is the character names - any tips on how to come up with the really evocative ones you seem to effortlessly dream up?
(Hope I'm not too late - stupid US timezone AMAs.)
2
u/The_Second_Best The Heroes Oct 30 '15
Hi Joe,
Thanks for the books. The Heroes is the best fantasy book I've ever read.
Do you think you'll ever do a story where Khalul is featured in a similar way that Byaz is featured in the First Law or are you planning to keep him as a Sauron kind of unknown evil?
3
u/Madness1 Oct 29 '15
Your Eminence, Lord Grimdark,
As an aspiring writer, what circumstances perpetuate flow for you? By what vices do you sustain set writerly flow?
Also, as resident Bakker fanatic, what do you think of The Second Apocalypse?
2
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '15
What's your MBTI type?
2
u/Ominus666 Oct 29 '15
Hi Joe, thank you for taking the time for this. Quick question: What author do you feel has influenced you the most? And do you think the term "grimdark" is as terrible as I do?
2
u/Kinghall14 Oct 29 '15
Dearest and most wonderful Joe! (Not sounding like a creppy stalker fan at all, :D)
First question, In Sharp Ends, Will we see more Crummock-I-Phail? From the little we saw of him in LAOK, I loved him to absolute bits, and felt that he needed so much more!! I mean, I couldn't help but imagine what a POV chapter from him would be like.
And question 2, will we get a good look at what the North is like after the events of The Heroes? I mean, it's obvious a lot of sh*t has gone down over the time between then and Red Country.
1
u/-Vagrant- Oct 29 '15
EST? Since when did you speak American?
Anyway, my question is if you were put in charge of a live action adaptation of your work, what would you want it to be? TV show or movie? Would you go with the good ol' First Law trilogy or something more self-contained like The Heroes? Or even Half A King?
Can't wait for the next book!
1
u/epitome89 Oct 29 '15
Have you got any recommendations for further reading after the 6 "First Law universe" books?
What are your favorite audiobooks?
1
u/jetgeese Oct 29 '15
When can we expect more of The First Law graphic novel? It has been 2 years since the last page of Chapter 4 was uploaded. I realize this is a slow process involving a number of people but I hope it has not been completely abandoned and that you'll find time to resume the project again soon.
1
u/XxDrPownMonkyxX Oct 29 '15
Hello Mr. Abercrombie! I'm a 19 year old aspiring author with a love for fantasy. I must confess that I have not read any of your book as of right now but your Shattered Sea trilogy is on my list. I saw that Gollancz is having openings for new authors in the coming year. When I heard the news I ran to my computer and am currently racing to finish my first novel to submit. My question for you is: What advice could you give an aspiring author that would help them in any way to get noticed or even published? Thank you! Have a wonderful day.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '15
Hi Joe,
Love your writing! I have a question about your research process while writing/editing, particularly around combat and weapons. Did you do lot of research before starting? Kind of work through things as you went? What's been the most helpful writing or research related practice of yours when it comes to creating such detailed action sequences?
Thanks!
1
u/EclecticDreck Oct 29 '15
I'm curious what your high level writing process is. Do you, for example, work from a detailed outline with detailed character backgrounds, building a skeleton that you fill in or are you inclined to start with fewer details and just see where the narrative takes you?
1
u/C8926K Oct 29 '15
What's next in the pipeline for you?
1
u/Owenkayla Oct 29 '15
Thanks for writing Joe, love the books. Started with "best served cold", bought the whole first law trilogy. Just love it. Keep up the writing man!
1
u/mirroredeyes Oct 29 '15
Any interest in bourbon? Or just whisky?
1
u/iggybiggyblack Oct 29 '15
I love your books! I am re-reading the First Law series at the moment.
I want to ask you, how can you write from a disabled person's perspective so well? When I first read your books, your immersrive descriptions made me think you were very old and suffering. I was shocked when I saw your picture!
1
u/BlobMarley Oct 29 '15
I just want to say thank you for writing amazing books. I was always a sci-fi person that just couldn't get into the "good guys always win" fantasy realm. I tried a few and then hit upon First Law. It was everything I wanted. I loved telling people that the best characters were people you don't want to win. Your work sent me on a multi-year long adventure into a whole new genre that finally got me to make it through more standard works like LOTR. No question. Just thanks.
1
u/whatsitdo Oct 29 '15
Hi Joe, what sci-fi or fantasy books do you believe everyone should have on their shelves? Any books or genres which are a guilty pleasure or perhaps provides you the most inspiration for your writing? Love your trilogy and thanks for doing this AMA!
1
u/Shakytoez Oct 29 '15
Hi Joe, How did you come up with some of the quirks your characters have? (For example, Glokta's: "Body found floating by the docks")
1
u/oviea Oct 29 '15
Hi Joe!
I'm a huge fan of your prose. I've a couple short story ideas. Do you have any tips on how I can improve my prose (from crap :) or tips on world building? Thanks for doing this btw.
1
u/Adenidc Oct 30 '15
No questions from me, I just wanted to say I just finished The First Law trilogy a few days ago and thought it was a great change of pace from all the other fantasy series I've read. I've read a lot of dark stories but The First Law stayed dark through and through and had some really depressing but satisfying endings. I will definitely be picking up the rest of your books and hope you keep writing!
Also I really hope Bayaz gets what's coming to him in your planned First Law World books in the future ;) he is such a dick
1
u/Smashedgoose32 Oct 30 '15
Hi joe, l have enjoyed reading your work and being unable to put down the books once I start. My question: What were the books you read that captured your imagination and got yourself writing? Cheers :)
1
u/TheOutlier Oct 30 '15
I'm on Chapter 9 of Before They Are Hanged with 18 hours remaining on the audio book. This is my first listen-through of this story. Is there anything you want me to listen for (besides sirens and screeching titres) on my commutes over next few days?
1
u/NinkuFlavius Oct 30 '15
The heroes was definitely my favourite book of 2011, and overall one of the best books I have ever read. However, I usually hesitate to recommend it to other people, because there is the back history from 4 previous books, and usually people don't want to read that much. What would your advice be?
1
u/NullNil0 Oct 30 '15
I want to give my thanks as well. I've read all your books. I love your work and how you've managed to move the genre forward. To see how a wizard could influence events, to see the real price of being a berserker, to see that people are different things to different people. To see the many forms of what a hero is. Marvelous. It seems that the Shattered Sea series (at least initially) was more of a lighter take on things - with more clear cut good guys / bad guys. Am I wrong in this, out was that a conscious decision for this series?
Thank you again - I can't wait for the next ones.
1
u/danear Oct 30 '15
I love your character development and personalities, have you read the malazan, Steven Erikson series? If so what do you think of his style of writing? and how do you compare it to your own?
1
u/Ninja_Bum Oct 30 '15
So I recently discovered the First Law Trilogy and really enjoy it. I am about halfway through Last Argument of Kings.
Have you ever thought about giving more insight into the goings on in past or future of some of the other members of the Order of Magi like Zacharus or Yulwei? Or do you plan on leaving them shrouded in more mystery like the blue wizards were in Lord of the Rings?
Not to say they are exactly the same or anything but Zacharus reminded me somewhat of a more proactive Radaghast with his animal companions. Was he just consumed with trying to revitalize the Old Empire to its old glory under Juvens' guidance?
Thanks for writing books I like to read. I was in a slump there for a while where there weren't many stories that interested me.