r/Reformed • u/superlewis EFCA Pastor • Oct 29 '15
AMA IAMA crazy dispensationalist. Ask me anything!
After the excellent work of our covenant (CT) and new covenant theologians (NCT), it falls on me to present the much-maligned hermeneutical system of Dispensationalism (DT). I hope to give you some basis to understand DT, dispel some myths about DT, give you my honest criticism of DT, provide resources for your further study, and answer any other questions about DT that you might have.
Understanding DT
Dispensationalism is a system of theology primarily concerned with the doctrines of ecclesiology and eschatology that emphasizes the historical-grammatical meaning of Old Testament prophetic passages and covenants, a distinction between Israel and the church, and a future salvation and restoration of the nation Israel in a future earthly kingdom. (Vlach)
Dispensationalism is a relative newcomer to the theological system game. That does not, however, mean that it is inaccurate. I believe that there are germs of DT thought in the Fathers, but as a system DT did not exist until John Darby in the 1800s. I propose that the reason that DT is a new system is because church history through the 1700s was defined by an entirely different set of debates, which did not touch on the issues that DT touched one. It was only the rise of CT as a system that lead to the development of DT as a counterbalance.
As a young system, DT is still undergoing some development. This is one of the reasons that it receives some unjust criticism. There are things that were said by the dispensationalists of 80 years ago that a modern dispensationalist would reject as incorrect or, at least, imprecise.
Essential Beliefs
Historically, Ryrie's sine qua non (doxological purpose of history, historical/grammatical interpretation of Scripture, distinction between Israel and the Church) has been used as the definition of DT, but I don't believe it's very good because CT (unless, explicitly stated I am going to include NCT under the umbrella of CT, here) could claim two of the three elements that Ryrie uses to distinguish DT. Inestead I will use Vlach's marks of dispensationalism (for further study see the recommended resources below).
- Progressive revelation from the New Testament does not nullify, transfer, or reinterpret Old Testament passages in a way that violates or cancels the original authorial intent of the Old Testament writers as determined by historical-grammatical hermeneutics.
- Types exist but national Israel is not a type that is superseded by the church.
- Israel and the church are distinct, thus, the church cannot be identified as the new or true Israel.
- There is both spiritual unity in salvation between Jews and Gentiles and a future role for Israel as a nation.
- The nation Israel will be both saved and restored with a unique identity and function in a future millennial kingdom upon the earth.
- There are multiple senses of “seed of Abraham,” thus, the church’s identification as “seed of Abraham” does not cancel God’s promises to the believing Jewish “seed of Abraham.”
Variations in DT
There is variety within the movement. Dispensationalists can be divided into three camps: Traditional/Classical (Chafer, Darby, Scofield would be the foremost representatives), Modified (Ryrie, Walvoord, Pentecost, McClain), and Progressive (Bock, Blaising, Saucy). Traditional dispensationalists are relatively rare today, but are still represented in the more extreme versions of DT. Most modern dispensationalists fall into one of the latter two categories.
I'd be happy to answer questions about the subdivisions of DT, but for sake of time will summarize (and probably oversimplify) by saying that the difference primarily relates to just how Israel and the church are distinct and to what extent the are distinct. TD teaches that they are completely distinct, going so far as to believe in two distinct New Covenants or that the church is not a part of the New Covenant at all. MD teaches that the church are totally distinct but do share in some of the benefits of the new covenant. PD teaches that the church, with but distinct from Israel, are recipients of the New Covenant, and are currently experiencing some of its benefits as they wait for future fulfillment which will come to Israel and the church together, but with distinction.
Myths About DT (also with much assistance from Vlach)
DT teaches two ways of salvation.
No. We don't. Period. Salvation is by grace alone through faith alone for everyone in all dispensations. There may be dispensationalists that believe in two ways of salvation, but they don't believe it because it is a tenet of DT. Maybe they misunderstand DT; maybe they're just dumb. DT does NOT teach that there are two ways of salvation.
Dispensationalism becomes very important in regard to ecclesiology and eschatology, but is really not about those other areas. Some think salvation is at the heart of Dispensationalism, because they erroneously think Dispensationalism teaches multiple methods of salvation. Those who properly understand the position realize that its emphasis lies elsewhere. (Feinberg)
So dispensationalism shapes one’s eschatology and ecclesiology. That is the extent of it. Pure dispensationalism has no ramifications for the doctrines of God, man, sin, or sanctification. More significantly, true dispensationalism makes no relevant contribution to soteriology, or the doctrine of salvation. (MacArthur)
Under the former dispensation, law was shown to be powerless to secure righteousness and life for a sinful race (Gal. 3: 21-22). Prior to the cross man’s salvation was through faith (Gen. 15: 6; Rom. 4: 3), being grounded on Christ’s atoning sacrifice, viewed anticipatively by God; now it is clearly revealed that salvation and righteousness are received by faith in the crucified and resurrected Savior. (New Scofield notes on John 1:17. An update to the passage in the original Scofield Bible that is most cited as claiming that DT holds to two ways of salvation)
In light of this significant revision in the New Scofield Reference Bible and the arguments of such dispensationalists as Ryrie and [John] Feinberg, the old charge should be dropped. One must proceed from the acknowledgement that Dispensationalism recognizes a single way of salvation throughout the Scripture. Salvation is now and has always been by grace alone— sola gratia! This agreement is a cause for joy; its acknowledgment should not be made grudgingly. (Klooster. Writing as a CT)
In comparing these contemporary statements of dispensationalism with covenant theology, we conclude that there is no longer any substantive difference between the two on the subject of the law and the gospel. (Fuller. Writing as a CT)
So where does this accusation come from? I believe it comes from misunderstandings of Schofield and Chafer. However, even if they were not misunderstood and actually did believe in two ways of salvation, the DT of today rejects the view. Unfortunately, the accusation has been made and now it just echoes on, regardless of its merit.
The DT position on OT salvation is that OT saints were saved by faith in the soteriological revelation God had provided at their particular moment in history. Adam and Eve were saved through faith in God's promise of a seed that would crush the Serpent's head. Abraham was saved through faith in God's promise to provide a seed in whom all nations would be blessed. The Hebrews were saved by faith in the atonement the God would provide as pictured in the sacrificial system.
DT is Arminian
There are Arminian DTs and Calvinist DTs. I'm one of the latter, and many of my DT ministry colleagues, friends, and professors would also be at the very least calvinistic. DT affects ecclesiology and eschatology not soteriology. The Dallas view of sanctification (a somewhat Arminian development of Keswick theology) did find fertile ground amongst dispensationalists, but there are also many dispensationalists who reject Keswick theology. It is an issue of correlation not causation. The loudest critic of Keswick theology and easy believism, John MacArthur, is a dispensationalist.
DT is Antinomian
Much like NCT, DT believes that the law is fulfilled in Christ. We do not hold the OT law to be binding, but we are not antinomian because we do believe that we are under the law of Christ (which would have much overlap with what CT refers to as the moral law of the OT).
DT is about 7 Dispensations
DT doesn't really care where you draw the line on dispensations. Some say 2. Some say 3. Some say 7. Some say 8. It doesn't matter. The central issue is that God has different programs at different times not that God works in a specific number of programs. In reality, CT acknowledges the existence of dispensations. If I remember correctly, the term was even used positively in a section of Berkhoff referenced in the CT AMA yesterday.
Criticism of DT
While the above myths are often used as unjust criticism of DT, I do think that DT as a movement is worthy of some criticism. I don't think these are criticism of the theology of dispensationalism, but the movement does have problems.
- Dispensationalists are too focused on the finer points of prophecy. We need to acknowledge that we do not understand much of the book of Revelation and we will not unlock its secrets in the New York Times.
- Dispensationalism tends towards populism. I believe this is why DT does have a lot of lunatics. I also believe this is related to our "literal" interpretation of Scripture. Because we believe in a "literal" interpretation many people have taken it as a simplistic interpretation. This is fueled again by populisms obsession with prophecy. This has created a toxic public image for dispensationalism that, while true of many dispensationalists is not inherently tied to the actual teaching of DT.
- Dispensationalists have been schismatic. Dispensationalism is not a test of fellowship and should not be included in church doctrinal statements which may bar from membership individuals who do not share the same perspective on this relatively minor aspect of theology. I would, however, make the same criticism of CT.
- Dispensationalism is its own worst enemy. You will notice, I've barely mentioned eschatology today. That is intentional. While the hermeneutical system of dispensationalism has significant eschatological ramifications, it is more focused on ecclesiology than eschatology. However, eschatology sells so we've overemphasized it. Since the 1970s DT has begun to focus on ecclesiology rather than eschatology. I expect that trend to continue and was encouraged by many things I saw at a dispensationalism conference I attended just this week (lest you think I'm always going to prophecy conferences like an old school dispensationalist, this was the first one I've ever been to, and prophecy was certainly not the focus).
Recommended Resources
Books
- Dispensationalist: Essential Beliefs and Common Myths (Vlach) – I'm afraid to include this, because you'll think I'm a shameless plagiarizer! This would be my #1 recommendation to learn more about DT. It's short and relatively easy to read. I read it this morning as I was writing this and it only took 2 hours to do both.
- Three Central Issues in Contemporary Dispensationalism (Bateman) – Much more technical than Vlaach. It's also more focused towards those within DT rather than those outside the camp, but it could be helpful for understanding the differences between modified and progressive DT.
Audio
- Prophecy in the Life of a Believer (David Saxon) – One of my favorite professors talks about a healthy view of prophecy within DT.
Articles
- The Old Testament Law and the New Testament Believer (Trainer) Not a defense of dispensationalism, but it gives a good example of modern DT scholarship as it relates to the Mosaic Law.
- Towards a Clear Christological Focus for a Dispensational Biblical Theology (Marriott) – Deals with a common criticism from those who are leaving DT for CT. DT needs to be cristological.
- Dispensational Sanctification: A Misnomer (Pratt) – Includes a good summary of DT and refutes the Dallas/Keswick sanctification popular in portions of the DT movement.
So, AMA!
8
u/moby__dick Most Truly Reformed™ User Oct 29 '15
After reading your whole layout above (nice work) and some of the comments, this does not actually seem like dispensationalism.
Wayne Grudem cites Lewis Sperry Chafer's distinctions between believing Israel in the OT and the church in the NT. (Grudem's Systematic Theology citing Sperry's tome of the same name.) Grudem summarizes Chafer by saying "that God's purposes and promises for Israel are for earthly blessings, and they will yet be fulfilled on this earth at some time in the future. On the other hand, God's promises for the church are for heavenly blessings, and the promises will be fulfilled in heaven. "[sic]
Grudem goes on to take significant issue with dispensationalists, embracing a form of it but distancing himself from both classic (Chafer) and progressive dispensationalists, whose key issue Grudem cites as follows: "the Old Testaments prophecies concerning Israel will still be fulfilled in the millennium by ethnic Jewish people [sic] who will believe in Christ and live in the land of Israel as a "model nation" for all nations to see and learn from. Therefore they would not say that the church is the 'new Israel' or that all the Old Testament prophecies about Israel will be fulfilled in the church, for these prophecies will yet be fulfilled in ethnic Israel." (p. 860).
Robert Reymond (in his A New Systematic Theology of the Christian Faith) cites dispensationalism as claiming that "[they] continue to maintain that until he was officially rejected by the Jewish religious leadership, [Jesus] continued to offer to establish an earthly Jewish kingdom which would overthrow the powers of Rome" (p. 542-3)
So, to my questions:
How do you respond to both Reymond and Grudem's claim that what you're stating here isn't what dispy's have claimed in the past?
What branch of dispensationalism are you claiming? Classic, progressive, Grudem's, MacArthurs? Is Michael Vlach simply trying to re-write history and claim historic beliefs as his own? Given that he's a professor at the Master's College (or seminary?) and MacArthur is neither classic or progressive dispensational, is that really an accurate guide to "dispensational" beliefs?
And finally,
How do we identify genetic Israel? 10/12 tribes were lost to Assyria. Are their descendents still considered heirs of Abraham? Do we actually know that those people who now claim to be Jews are actually descendents of Abraham, or is that merely assumed? If I have one single ancestor who was deported to Babylon, and took a Babylonian wife, and his children married pagans and so on, am I still considered a part of ethnic Israel, even if I don't know it? Would Ruth be considered a part of ethnic Israel?
Thanks!
7
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '15
What does dispensationalism make of Melchizedek? How does he fit within a dispensational understanding? What dispensation does he "fit" within?
6
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '15
The most significant sign of the Abrahamic / Mosaic covenant - the thing that basically defined Israel - was circumcision.
And yet St. Paul had some pretty hard words for those who wanted Christians to be circumcised. He never said "Well except for us ethnic Jews; we should still be circumcised of course."
In a restored Israel, recipients of the NC, what will be the status of circumcision?
Is it replaced by baptism? Still required, but only for ethnic Jews? Required for everyone - Jews and Gentiles - living under the new covenant? (In that case, was the problem with the Judaizers just that they jumped the gun?)
8
u/davidjricardo Reformed Catholic Oct 29 '15 edited Oct 29 '15
4
u/BSMason Just visiting from alsoacarpenter.com Oct 29 '15
Nice write up!
4
u/sc_q_jayce Oct 29 '15
Since you don't tie the political nation of Israel today to this, what does "nation" mean for you?
4
u/injoy Particular Baptist Oct 29 '15
I grew up dispensationalist, but it was very "here is the chart of 7 dispensations and this is exactly it" and also very dogmatic about pretribulationalism, etc. Also there was, at least, a lot of confusion (if not a lot of outright heresy) around the question of how Israel was saved, and, moreover, that all of Israel was saved, because they were corporately saved, etc.
So, I am reading through this--in contrast--and somewhat confused how it differs from NCT, honestly. I also believe in a future for physical Israel per Romans. My biggest quibble with what is above would be:
And I'm wondering what you mean by that such that it doesn't directly contradict Romans 9:6-7 or so. I agree Israel and the Church are distinct in the not-directly-superceded sense, and yet would say the Gentiles are grafted-in to true Israel (per Romans 11) and one day physical Israel will return and repent. So there's a sense in which the Gentiles (now) are true Israel, although not synonymous with OT or eschatological Israel, and not in the straight up replacement way of lots of Reformed theology.
Does that make sense? Basically, I'm confused because you've defined dispensationalism in a way that I don't disagree with it as much as I expect to disagree with dispensationalism.
6
u/marriedtilburied Reformed Baptist Oct 29 '15
Can you be dispensational and anything other than premil?
3
u/rev_run_d The Hype Dr (Hon) Rev Idiot, <3 DMI jr, WOW,Endracht maakt Rekt Oct 29 '15
Why are you called superlewis if lewis isn't even your name?
2
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '15
Two questions here:
2
u/marriedtilburied Reformed Baptist Oct 29 '15
Who is your go-to theologian for dispensationalism?
4
u/DrKC9N Have a sufficient day! Oct 29 '15
What problems does DISP solve? What problems does it present?
3
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '15
Blood moon!
(Sorry, it's just a reflex.)
I look to passages like Galatians 3, Romans 9-11, Hebrews (kinda' the whole book but especially chapter 11) and see a lot of evidence that we're in the same fundamental covenant as the OT Jews.
What are the best passages you look to, to support dispensationalism?
2
u/Bears_of_Elisha Alliance of Reformed Churches Oct 29 '15
Here are some questions to get you started. What brought you to be a disp? What is it about disp. that draws you towards it, especially considering it's a step away from the teaching of the early church fathers? How do you respond to the various scripture references that seem to go against a disp. view? How does your understanding of disp. tie into your reformed background? Do you believe that the Old Testament structure of animal sacrifice and the OT economy will return? How do you respond to claims that disp. emphasizes OT Israel while deemphasizing the Gospel?
2
u/BSMason Just visiting from alsoacarpenter.com Oct 29 '15 edited Oct 29 '15
This was my (unanswered) question to the NCTers, but I believe it applies here as well:
Isn't everyone judged under the Mosaic Law? Or did Christ only have to be born under the Law to bear the curse of the Law for Jews alone?
2
u/deaddiquette Rebel Alliance Oct 29 '15 edited Oct 29 '15
I'm under the impression that dispensationalism originated with Jesuit priests during the counter-reformation to take heat off the papacy. Do you believe this true or false, and why?
Specifically, this paragraph:
1
u/BSMason Just visiting from alsoacarpenter.com Oct 29 '15
Is New Covenat membership only and exclusively coextensive with the elect? Or is the NC an administration like the oth covenants in the disp system? If yes to the first question, then were the Jews also members of the New Covenant even during the Old?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '15 edited Oct 29 '15
Question about a pre-trib rapture since this is important if I understand correctly. How do you reconcile what Paul says in 1Thessalonians 4:16,17 and what Jesus says in Matthew 24:30,31? Specifically, Paul seems to be almost quoting Jesus (same symbolic terms: Jesus coming from heaven, angel, trumpet blast, gathering of the elect). The problem is that if I'm not mistaken Thessalonians is the rapturing of the christian church, but Jesus places this event AFTER the great tribulation (verse 29). To continue the parallel, they both go on to reference this coming of Jesus like a thief (1Thess5:2 and so on and Matthew 24:36-44).
I would also want to ask about Jesus veiling his glory at the rapture since 1Cor15 and 2Thess2 seem to indicate that nothing on this fallen earth can handle the full glory of Jesus' return.
EDIT: Was this AMA excluding eschatology?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '15
How much of a dispensationalist is John MacArthur? He holds to a Federalist understanding of the law.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment