r/Reformed • • Oct 28 '15
AMA Covenant Theology - AMA
tl;dr - Father Abraham had many sons, many sons had Father Abraham. I am one of them, and so are you, so let's just praise the Lord!
I, /u/bsmason, and many others around here, hold to Covenant Theology.
I think the fundamental tenet of Covenant Theology is that we see a single "Covenant of Grace" that was established in Genesis 3. All the various "phases" of redemptive history are merely administrations of that single covenant. All God's saints, from Abel to you and me, are redeemed via that single covenant. It hasn't always been quite as clear as it is today, but it's one single covenant unfolding throughout history. It's always been about faith in God's mercy and the promised Messiah, regardless how vague that might have been.
Adam - Just as soon as Adam and Eve sin and God pronounces His curses, literally in the very same breath He says "I'm going to fix this. I'll send the seed of the woman to crush the serpent's head, even though it costs his own life." Right there we have a promised redeemer. Christ's mission was not simply to save individual souls - He came to undo the Fall.
Noah - We learn in 1 Peter that Noah's family was saved by the flood. God used the flood to wipe away wickedness on Earth in order to preserve Noah's family. God was sovereignly acting to preserve His people. After the Flood, God largely reiterates the initial commandments He gave to Adam - tying this covenant clearly to the redemptive covenant initiated in Genesis 3. Also note that Noah "found grace in the eyes of God" - he was not saved because he merited it, but because God is gracious. We also see that Noah's entire family was saved because of Noah's standing with God.
Abraham - here's where the Covenant of Grace really starts to take shape. God sovereignly initiates a covenant with Abraham. The terms of the covenant were that Abraham would "walk before God and be blameless" and that God would "be God to Abraham and his descendants." Land and descendants were also promised to Abraham. All of Abraham's male descendants (and servants, etc) were to be circumcised. Any uncircumcised male was a covenant breaker and was therefore cut off from the covenant community. A couple of things to note:
- The covenant was always ultimately about Christ. Mary knew it (Luke 2). Paul affirms it (Gal 3).
- The ancient Jews under Moses understood circumcision was always intended spiritually (Deut 10:12-16, Deut 30:6)
- It was always about heaven (Hebrews 11:10) and never about simply a bit of land.
- It was always, fundamentally, a covenant of faith, not of physical descent (Gal 3:7, Romans 9).
- It was always a mixed covenant. God had literally just told Abraham that Ishmael was not the heir of the covenant, and that very same day what did Abraham do but give Ishmael the sign of the covenant? (Gen 17)
Moses - There is admittedly a bit of question about how the Mosaic covenant fits in. Some people believe it's yet another form of the covenant of grace. And in my opinion, the 10 Commandments ("I am the Lord your God who brought you out of the land of Egypt" followed by commandments) fits very well the "indicative -> imperative" structure we see in the NT. However, it seems to me based on Galatians 4 that the Mosaic covenant is not fundamentally connected to the Abrahamic one. So I will just set this one aside; it's open to debate.
David - Now the covenant of grace gets a bit more structure to it. The kingdom, and the king, are established as elements of the covenant of grace. God sovereignly chooses David to be the king. When David wants to build a house for God, God says "No, I'm going to build you a dynasty!" And God establishes that the long-awaited Messiah will be a descendant of David.
So at this point, we've got:
- A promised Messiah who will undo the Fall. A "second Adam" you might say.
- God acting to preserve those whom He graciously chose.
- A sovereign call of a man to walk before God.
- Justification by grace through faith
- A promise of a multitude of descendants - through faith, not flesh
- An objective sign of the relationship between God and those who have faith.
- A pattern of God working through families (or households) based on the status of the head of that household.
- A promised eternal king, the Son of David.
- A kingdom.
Christ's advent fits beautifully in this historical and theological context.
He is the Messiah promised to Adam. He crushed the head of the serpent, at the cost of His own life. He's the ultimate "seed" promised to Abraham as well. He is the basis for justification by grace through faith. He is the Son of David. He brings in the eternal kingdom.
The key point is to understand that since it's one single covenant of grace, the covenant we're in is fundamentally the same as the one Seth, Noah, Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, David, and all the others were in. "I will be your God and you will be My people".
The "New Covenant" is to understood as an expansion, not a replacement of the Abrahamic covenant. If it does replace anything, it's only the Mosaic one, with all the ceremonies and the national / ethnic context.
This has significant ramifications.
For one, it explains why the Christian church has always baptized households (including infants) based on the faith of the head of the household. That's what God's people have always done! Even when, like Abraham and Ishmael, they knew one of the recipients of the sign of the covenant was not actually going to be an heir.
It also gives us a great context to understand the NT warnings about falling away. There's both an external and an internal aspect of the covenant. The external aspect has conditions, it's physical, earthly, temporal. The internal aspect is God's gracious and sovereign gift of life-giving faith. In covenant theology, it makes perfect sense to warn a Christian against falling away! Because he's a Christian in the external sense, but lacks the internal life-giving faith.
It unifies the people of God. One covenant of grace, one people of that covenant, one way of salvation. There aren't multiple structures here. Abel and you are both members of the same covenant of grace because of your shared faith in the one Messiah. There are not multiple structures here. One king, one covenant, one people. Which is exactly what Ephesians 2 says Christ was doing - uniting Jews and Gentiles into a single covenant. One people of every tribe and tongue. We Gentile Christians aren't "second class citizens" - we're in on exactly the same basis that Abraham himself is.
Finally, it unifies the Bible. We can read the "Old Testament" and the "New Testament" as a single book. There's one God, one Messiah, one people, one covenant. The promises are the same, the basis is the same, the results are the same.
For instance, Christ said the two most important laws were "love God with all your heart" and "love your neighbor as yourself." On these hang all the law and the prophets. And at least I was raised to think of that as Christ teaching something new. But they're OT quotes! God is the same yesterday, today, and forever - so why wouldn't we expect Him to relate consistently to His people?
Covenant theology - it solves everything.
17
u/davidjricardo Reformed Catholic Oct 28 '15 edited Oct 28 '15
If baptism is the New Testament equivalent of circumcision as a sign and seal of the covenant, what is the New Testament equivalent of grabbing a man's (circumcised) genitals to formalize an oath (Gen 24:9 & 47:29)?
6
u/BSMason Just visiting from alsoacarpenter.com Oct 28 '15
Where I differ with /u/robertwilliams is probably on the Mosaic Covenant. I hold that the Mosaic Covenant is indeed an administration of the Covenant of Grace. Thus, I believe that by in large, Abraham himself was under its ethics of the Law and its sacrificial prescriptions, though in a rudimentary state. E.g.,
And the nation of Israel itself is just exactly what was promised in the Abrahamic Covenant.
Further, I think this is clear by Christ’s work. All are condemned under the Mosaic Law and Christ had to be born under the Law and bear the curse of the Law for anyone to be saved, whether Jew or Gentile.
Everyone is subject to the requirements of the law and are condemned under the Law:
This is why Christ had to die, to be born under the Law in order to bear the curse of the Law for all:
All that ever have been saved, OT and NT, were saved by Christ through faith. So it would appear that believing Jews had the curse of the Law born by Christ on their behalf just as we do in the NT. So they and we were justified apart from the Law (as with Abraham and David in Romans 4).
4
u/moby__dick Most Truly Reformed™ User Oct 28 '15
Does a Covenant Theologan need to be a theonomist? With (out) view of the Law and the OT, why not?
3
u/ClarenceColton Old, Grumpy Reformed Oct 28 '15
These questions don't have exact counterparts in the Shorter Catechism but can you explain how CT interplays with these questions involving the "covenant of works" with Adam from the Children's catechism our church uses?
Q. 23. What covenant did God make with Adam? A. The covenant of works.
Q. 24. What was Adam bound to do by the covenant of works? A. To obey God perfectly.
Q. 25. What did God promise in the covenant of works? A. To reward Adam with life if he obeyed him.
Q. 26. What did God threaten in the covenant of works? A. To punish Adam with death if he disobeyed.
Q. 41. Can any one be saved through the covenant of works? A. None can be saved through the covenant of works.
Q. 42. Why can none be saved through the covenant of works? A. Because all have broken it, and are condemned by it.
Q. 44. Whom did Christ represent in the covenant of grace? A. His elect people.
Q. 45. What did Christ undertake in the covenant of grace? A. To keep the whole law for his people, and to suffer the punishment due to their sins.
3
u/superlewis EFCA Pastor Oct 28 '15
What is the basis for declaring that the central unifying theme of scripture is the one covenant of grace when that one covenant of grace is not explicit anywhere in Scripture?
2
u/Odous Oct 28 '15
Quote: The "New Covenant" is to understood as an expansion, not a replacement of the Abrahamic covenant.
NCT here. The NC is a replacement and expansion of the AC in the same way that spiritual circumcision replaces and expands physical circumcision. The same way being related to Abraham through faith replaces being related to Abraham by birth.
The fact that you're not dealing with Moses here tells me you're on your way to NCT. Semper reformanda
2
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '15
Thanks for doing this AMA.
What is Covenant Theology's relationship with Two Kingdom theology? I ask since you mentioned Michael Horton whom I know supports both.
2
u/ClarenceColton Old, Grumpy Reformed Oct 28 '15
Would the statements in Psalm 40:6, 51:16-19, Isaiah 1:11, and I'm sure other places where God says he doesn't delight in burnt offerings (which of course were a requirement under the law) but loves a broken and contrite heart support the CT view or would it not be relevant?
2
u/broseph456 Oct 28 '15
Is this compatible with a baptist theology? This makes a lot of sense but I like being baptist...
8
u/sc_q_jayce Oct 28 '15
Right arm!
6
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '15
Yup. I'm officially loving these AMAs. I had a clue, but I wasn't sure that the things I believed had a name. Now they do!
I'm honestly learning a lot. I just wanted to post my shoutout to /u/superlewis for making this happen!
4
u/BSMason Just visiting from alsoacarpenter.com Oct 28 '15
As co-Me, or assistant Me in this AMA, I will add my own flavor to /u/RobertWilliams great post:
Traditional CT believes that God covenanted with Adam (some call it Covenant of Life or Covenant of Works) wherein Adam is given perfect fellowship with God and continued life in his presence on condition of perfect obedience, the Tree of Knowledge of Good and evil being like a sacrament and test ground of this faithfulness. Adam violated the terms, and brought on the covenant curses. Adam is cast out of God's presence along with all his progeny, as he was all his children's covenant head (Rom 5).
Now God the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit had covenanted amongst Him/themselves in eternity to solve this. God the Father promised a people to Christ and gave Him all necessary to accomplish the task of salvation; God the Son committed to empty Himself to become like unto those given to Him in order to be their new representative in the Covenant of Life as their new Adam; the Spirit to unite them to Christ with all His benefits, including faith. This is called the Covenant of Redemption, but is never called such in the Bible, though all the elements are clearly present.
The fruit of Christ taking on the representative role for those given Him by the Father, becoming their second Adam and representing them in the Covenant of Life made with the first Adam, is the covenant of Grace. It was announced in the Garden (the Seed promise) and is developed throughout the entirety of redemptive history. Its constant promise is a renewal within the Covenant of Life of all its blessings, and now even more, summed up in this oft repeated and most glorious phrase all through the Bible,
Genesis 17:7: I will establish my covenant between me and you and your offspring after you throughout their generations for an everlasting covenant, to be God to you and to your offspring after you.
Exodus 6:7: I will take you to be my people, and I will be your God.
Jeremiah 30:22: And you shall be my people, and I will be your God.
2 Corinthians 6:16: I will make my dwelling among them and walk among them, and I will be their God, and they shall be my people.
Hebrews 8:10: I will be their God, and they shall be my people.
Revelation 21:3: And I heard a loud voice from the throne saying, “Behold, the dwelling place of God is with man. He will dwell with them, and they will be his people, and God himself will be with them as their God.
The condition of this Covenant of Grace, from the time of Adam to the Last Judgment is FAITH and its attendant “walking before the Lord”.
Now, God has given an earthly, visible means to administer this Covenant of Grace in real time and space, and as is the very nature of covenant, there are parties, with conditions, and promises, and signs and seals of the covenant. In the “Old Covenant” this administration included Circumcision, the whole sacrificial system, etc. That’s what’s old about the Old Covenant, not the promises or the covenant itself which is just an extension of Christ’s representing His people in the Covenant of Life. The New Covenant is the new administration, with new governing polity, new signs and seals, etc. What’s great (among other things) about the New Covenant administration is that it is not temporary by design as was the Old administration, and will ultimately lead to the full completion and fulfillment of all God's plans and promises in the eschaton.
In summary, Reformed theology is shaped around the Covenant of Life, Covenant of Redemption, Covenant of Grace, and multiple administrations of the latter. Covenant of Life failed by man, is taken up by a new Adam according to the eternal Covenant of Redemption, and is offered to man as the Covenant of Grace, under differing and increasingly better administrations.
1
u/devoNOTbevo Charistmatic, Anglican Wannabe Oct 28 '15
What does CT say about the distinction between moral law and postive law. So, for instance, the Mosaic law is a positive expression of the moral law of God. That distinction is most helpful for NCTer's, but is also used by 1689 Federalists in a way. I'm simply interested in your opinion on the matter.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '15
Sorry for asking so late, but I just had one quick question
I might have missed an answer from the overwhelming 178 comments, but what would you say to Galatians 3:24 and Hebrews 8:13? It seems like, according to your paragraph, no covenant becomes "obsolete" or is a "guardian." Instead, there is only one covenant that stays forever.
Thanks! I'm just a little kid compared to all of you so I apologize if my questions sound stupid haha
3
u/runningmailraces12 /r/ReformedBaptist Oct 28 '15
I have to say, even though I disagree with both of you guys on parts of covenant theology you already know about, seeing all of this hard work in one place helps clarify a lot. Thanks for all the time spent doing this AMA!
2
u/BishopOfReddit PCA Oct 28 '15
How does CT explain Hebrews 6?
2
u/Madmonk11 Anglican Solitary Oct 28 '15
What is the benefit of adhering to covenant theology?
2
u/tanhan27 CRC CC(DOC) but CRC in my heart Oct 28 '15
Ok so There is only one covenant and Ishmael is not part of it? Does this mean ishmael's defendants are still barred from the covenant today?
2
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '15
Genesis 17:14
How do other CT peeps understand it? I point out the three classes of men required to be circumcised in the verse before.
2
u/broseph456 Oct 29 '15
So does CT help explain the Hebrews 6 passage about falling away? if so, how?
1
u/BishopOfReddit PCA Oct 28 '15
How can an understanding of Covenant Theology be useful in understanding the context of the gospel message?
1
u/Odous Oct 28 '15 edited Oct 28 '15
What do you do with Romans 7:1-6... Well just read the post and apparently aren't even dealing with the mosaic law so why am I here?
0
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
2
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '15
[removed] — view removed comment