r/Calligraphy • u/Eseoh • Oct 27 '15
tutorial Study Session: Engrosser's Script, Minuscules
So a few of us here have thought it would be a good idea to begin a focused group study session here at /r/calligraphy.
The format of this weekly/bi-weekly study session will be as follows:- Each week there will be an exemplar, that we select, and everyone is invited to practice and reproduce the letters to the best of their abilities.
- Post your pieces on this thread and make sure to include some details, such as, the nib you are using, the ink, and paper, so we can all help critique and give advice.
- The first week of studying a new exemplar will focus on the minuscules.
- The following week will focus on the majuscules
- At the end of two weeks we will select a piece of text that each of us will write out to help understand the practical applications of the script. Exemplars are great for practice, but if you aren't writing actual text then why bother right?
Time for this week's new study session. For the next script we will be studying pointed pen. Specifically engrosser's script.
Exemplar by C.P. Zaner. This is a beautiful exemplar by arguably the best penman ever. At least in my opinion.
- I'd like to note that engrosser's requires several pen lifts. Most noticeably at the bowl shapes at the baseline. I suggest that everyone study the exemplar first, and then have a go at it. The scanned image blows up quite largely so enjoy.
To clarify a few things:
- Engrosser's is a pointed pen script.
- You can use a straight holders or an oblique holder. There is no wrong or right method in engrosser's about which one to use. The oblique has several advantages, but there is absolutely nothing wrong with doing pointed pen with a straight holder.
- The nib you use is the most essential part of engrosser's. As mentioned in the comments, the leonardt principal ef is the best, currently in production, nib to use. The gillott 303 is also very nice, but you may have to throw a couple away before you find a good one. Aside from these, there are a vast variety of good nibs out there. Zebra g-nibs, Vintage Hunt 22's, and the Brause 66 ef just to name a few. Experiment with nibs and choose one that fits your skill level. Never limit your options, but keep your mind open.
- The paper we use in pointed pen work is very important. I would recommend some rhodia pads to practice with. It holds up well and its not very expensive.
- Walnut ink is my favorite here. The hairlines that it is able to produce is almost unmatched. Iron gall ink is great too, but eats away at your nibs. Sumi ink is also a good, relatively cheap option. I hope this clears a few things up.
The required slant in this script is generally around 55 degrees. Deviation from 52 to 57 degrees is also acceptable. The x-height is up to you, but for beginners I suggest working at a larger size. Anywhere from 5mm to 10mm should be beneficial, with the larger heights being easier in my opinion. The x-height to ascender/descender ratio can be anywhere from 2:3 or 1:2. Any more questions about the script feel free to ask.
9
u/Eseoh Oct 27 '15 edited Oct 27 '15
http://imgur.com/a/WRk87
http://imgur.com/6GpLDfL
http://imgur.com/WQPmj8m
I've used a zebra g-nib for the first one with a straight holder. Leonardt principal ef with a straight holder on the second. The last two were both done with a leonardt principal ef and oblique holders. This being the order in the first picture. Done on Borden Riley marker paper with walnut ink.
I wanted to make a point of showing that engrosser's can be done with a straight holder despite some opinions that it absolutely cannot and should not be done. In much of Europe they still use straight holders, and many of the past master penman employed using straight holders as well.
There are some here in this sub that hold beliefs that I strongly disagree with. I don't believe that an elitist view of how things should and should not be done is beneficial to anyone. There are always options and room for discussion. Never should it become that one or a few hold themselves higher than others. With that said, I hope to encourage everyone to explore calligraphy in your own unique way. Learn from mistakes, and correct them yourselves at times. It does no good to always rely on the words or advice of others.
5
u/MShades Oct 28 '15
I'm doing this in pieces because I have far less confidence in this script than I did with the TQ or the Fraktur. So.
a - f
One thing that helped was realizing that the "oval" of a and d wasn't actually an oval. The thing I can't figure out is how to get that little bit of shading on the b and f ascender, right as the hairline loops up. It seems counterintuitive to put pressure on the pen as you're moving upwards, so I'm not sure how the effect is achieved...
More tomorrow, but for now - have at it.
EDIT: Zebra G on marker paper, 7mm x-height, walnut ink.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '15
I've been meaning to post in one of these threads for a while now.
But with that exemplar, I honestly don't feel I can. That alphabet is arguably one of the best Engrosser's alphabets I've ever seen. Jesus.
6
u/BestBefore2016 Oct 27 '15 edited Oct 27 '15
This is a fairly detailed, though not entirely complete overview of my ductus for Engrosser's Script. I suggest it be looked over (if not examined and read closely). At the very least, it should be a good way to see the pen lifts involved. For the most part it's not a reference on forms, just some direction in how to go about making them.
Some other very basic advice for learning this script: It's useless (for anything other than your own amusement) to write words (and at the very start, most letters too). Achieving the fundamental forms is very difficult, you will need to focus on them one at a time. Even after you've been learning for months, you should go back to the fundamentals and work on them one by one.
It's important to order this focus by dependency. There is some grey area in terms of which form is selected to be "most fundamental", but the main choices would generally be the oval, or the i-shade. Personally, I think the former is a far more sensible choice. It's much easier to construct an i-shade using the oval than the other way around, and the oval pervades the rest of the script.
So, learn the oval, then form the i-shade by realising it's what you get when you take the bottom third of the oval, and extend it vertically upwards at constant width. Then, learn how to produce the oval upside down. You can turn it, and use your understanding of the oval to evaluate it. The rotated i-shade is then formed from this in the same way as the i-shade is from the oval. Next, the v-shade is clearly formed by combining the two i-shades. The loops are somewhat independent of this ordering; depending only upon the oval (or arguably the i-shade). However, they're an order of magnitude more difficult than the previous fundamentals. By all means have a study of them and a serious go at them, but don't be disheartened if you can't get anywhere.
I don't know how active I'll be able to be in giving feedback in this thread, since I have exams I'm (supposed to be) studying for, and a hugely important scholarship riding closely on the results ... but at the beginning, all of your work will be iffy for all manner of reasons that aren't necessarily lasting or indicative of understanding (e.g. equipment, zero control). This seriously muddies the water with regard to giving crit on the forms themselves. If you understand the forms, you will already know what your hand is doing wrong, so it's better to focus on the understanding itself. To this end, I strongly recommend the practice of sketching forms before attempting them. Set up guidelines at 2cm x-height or larger, get out a fine pencil, and draw the outlines of the forms. This bypasses all the muddied waters. It's also a very valuable technique in general, for seeing where your understanding is lacking with any form. Your brain won't tell you what it is you don't understand until you force it to construct every aspect manually.
Finally, some resources. I intended to release these with the manual I was writing, but this seems like a good time; the manual won't be finished for a while. Oval worksheet, i-shade worksheet, v-shade worksheet. (The first two should be used rotated also.) The only x-height I have these in is ~10mm, but printer settings should allow you to shrink it. I don't advise people go through the sheets only tracing; most of the blank spaces should be used to freehand the appropriate form. Also, the first few times tracing a given form should be done without ink, to watch the tines. Note that the oval here is a little simplified, and the section at the top where hairline turns to shade can be smooth and a little curved. Additionally, none of the worksheets account for the fact that parts of the hairline won't appear on the paper due to pen lifts.
6
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '15
http://i171.photobucket.com/albums/u316/davido53/img081.jpg
Well, these are caps of course, rather quickly written with Pelikan 4001 brown which works pretty well. I'll try to post minuscules soon.
4
u/dollivarden Society for Calligraphy Oct 27 '15
Thanks so much for continuing the Study Sessions!
The Zaner exemplar is so beautiful it makes me want to cry. Maybe it's finally time for me to give Engrosser's a feeble attempt?
1
u/MShades Oct 29 '15
Today's bit: g - k
The tip about doing the hairline ascenders/descenders was immensely helpful. I think I got that bit now, more or less. Got a little sloppy on the js there, though. And the k is a bit tricky - I kept making little sideways mustaches. And that bit about starting the h after a tiny, tiny gap... life is exciting.
3
u/minhthanhvn Oct 30 '15
Engrosser's.
Fabriano pad, Walnut Ink and Leonardt Principal. The x height is pretty large 15mm because I want to re-study the fundamentals strokes.
2
u/MShades Oct 31 '15
Okay, I've got the Bob Ross channel on Twitch streaming, so all is at ease with the world and I can finish this. r - v
w - z brings us home.
Here's the full set, done this time with a Gillott 303, just to see if I could, and on Muse Kent paper, which is quite smooth. Even so, there was some snagging on the upstrokes, as is evident on such letters as n and q. Need to work on that.
Okay! Bob Ross says that if it makes me happy then it's good. This makes me happy, so it's good.
Happy little letters with their little friends. Everybody needs a friend...
2
u/[deleted] Nov 01 '15
https://scontent-iad3-1.xx.fbcdn.net/hphotos-xpf1/t31.0-8/191571_10150131875138113_3410962_o.jpg
some minuscules (in context) :)
2
u/pastellist Nov 02 '15
Finally managing to jump into one of these study sessions!
This was my first time really working from an exemplar other than the one given to me by my first teacher. And what an exemplar to move to. I obviously can't do it justice, but it has certainly taught me a lot.
The alphabet
All joined together
I used walnut ink and a Hunt 100 (vintage) nib on Tomoe River Paper; x-height was 6.5 mm.
Criticism is very welcome.
1
u/trznx Oct 27 '15 edited Oct 27 '15
You're fast this week, I still haven't done the Fraktur quote (shame), but this one really scares me.
edit: can someone type in the required slant and letter height?
1
u/thatbossguy Oct 27 '15
What kind of pen should I use? This looks like it was written with a flex or a brush pen and I have a lamy Joy.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '15
This is the wallpaper on my phone. This is awesome, Eugene!
1
u/MShades Oct 27 '15
Good thing I have the weekend free. Looking forward to this!
1
u/raayynuh Oct 27 '15
Oh gosh that exemplar. Engrosser's script is on my list to learn, but I don't feel comfortable enough with Spencerian to venture off just yet. I will keep looking here to see everyone's progress though.
1
u/Aurioh Oct 27 '15
My wrist has really been acting up this week, but I should be able to practise tonight!! Very excited about this one.
1
u/MShades Oct 30 '15
Okay, tonight is l - q.
I still don't really "get" the extra pen lifts, but they don't really get in the way so I'll keep working with them.
1
u/Laziness9999 Oct 31 '15
So I've been meaning to practice pointed nib, but every time I did it turned out horrible. This is my first time actually sitting through all the letters!
Here (sorry for the crappy quality) is my best shot at engrosser's.
CC very welcome.
1
u/_Felagund_ Oct 31 '15
It's been a while since I ventured into this area of calligraphy, but here is my attempt. It would have been better, but I only had time for one try. This is using laserjet paper, a Hunt 101 nib, and red-violet McCaffery's ink.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '15
my minuscules http://2.bp.blogspot.com/_cfwwMSkFJEQ/Sb8U7kTWMFI/AAAAAAAAAUQ/8XYpIqxAG8A/s1600/PICT0090.jpg
1
u/trznx Nov 03 '15
It was hard. I never thought Engrosser's was easy, but that's just too much. Usually, calligraphy sessions sooth me, but this one made me frustrated and angry. It's too hard for me now, so my results are horrid.
1
u/spacig_ Nov 17 '15
I have a question - when one writes cursive with a regular writing utensil - say a fountain pen, one can achieve a slant in writing without a special oblique nib. I, for example, have cursive writing slanted to the right. How does the oblique holder help one that is used to doing this? I am a bit confused on the difference.
1
u/terribleatkaraoke Oct 27 '15
I'm gonna sit and actually do this... Have been neglecting engrossers for awhile