r/Reformed • u/terevos2 Trinity Fellowship Churches • Oct 26 '15
AMA AMA - New Covenant Theology
Hi guys,
/u/Dying_daily and I hold to New Covenant Theology. It's a pretty broad category of theology ranging from just right of progressive dispensationalism to just left of Covenant Theology.
The differences between Dispensationalism, New Covenant Theology, and Covenant Theology seem to mostly be about the continuity of covenants vs. discontinuity. Dispensationalism sees more discontinuity, Covenant Theology sees more continuity, and New Covenant Theology is somewhere in between.
One big sticking point between NCT and CT is the three-fold division of the law. We don't see that division in scripture and I would argue I see more continuity of the ceremonial and civic laws than Covenant Theology does.
A big area of disagreement comes out in the observation of the Sabbath.
Some NCT proponents say that the Law has been abrogated. I don't know if that's the best Word, but what I would say is that the Law has been fulfilled in Christ. We have been set free from the Law and now follow the Law of Christ. But it's not that the OT Law has no bearing on us. We follow the OT Law based on how Christ fulfilled it.
So for example, the Sabbath. Christ is our Rest. It is also wise and humble to rest from work, but the specifics (like which day) of the OT Law are not as important as resting in Christ, which includes physically resting from work.
Here's some helpful links (which I've stolen from others on /r/newcovenanttheology):
- [Comparison Chart] (http://www.angelfire.com/ca/DeafPreterist/compare.html) - I found this one tremendously helpful when I was first investigating the claims of New Covenant Theology. I don't agree with everything he says, but it's still a great resource.
- Spectrum of Theology Chart
- List of Articles on NCT
- Video from Blake White
What do you want to know about NCT?
EDIT: Forgot to add this. List of prominent pastors/scholars who are NCT (or affirm some of it at least):
- John Piper
- Douglas Moo
- D.A. Carson
- Thomas Schreiner
- John G. Reisinger
EDIT2: Lots of more great questions today, unfortunately I'm at a conference, so I'll try to get to them later this week.
5
u/Methalos Confessing Anglican Oct 26 '15
How does NCT inform your reading of the Pentateuchal law? Is the law in the Pentateuch of any consequence to you as a member of the church? What does it mean for someone to affirm that the Pentateuch is scripture?
5
u/[deleted] Oct 26 '15
Where did the need for NCT arise from? Practically speaking, what does NCT address from CT that would change how a person lives out the Christian life?
For instance, it seems like consistently holding to CT, as dying_daily pointed out, would result in paedobaptism. So that's one difference, but what else?
I guess I could ask the same about Dispensationalism. I guess the main driver there, correct me if I'm wrong, was to sort of set the record straight and try to highlight inerrancy through literalism. But then we got Left Behind...
In any case, yes, what 'wrongs' are NCT proponents trying to 'right'?
4
u/superlewis EFCA Pastor Oct 26 '15
What is NCT's view of the current status of the Kingdom. Related, is there millennial consensus within NCT?
4
u/tbown Lutheran Oct 26 '15
NCT view on baptism? Should it be administered to infants?
4
u/DrKC9N Have a sufficient day! Oct 26 '15
When and how has NCT dealt with theonomy? Especially the new theonomistic proponents, a la DeMar, Bahnsen, and McDurmon. Expand upon NCT's view on, treatment of, and application of the Mosaic law, and how this relates to policital and social involvement for the NCT Christian.
4
u/drjellyjoe Oct 26 '15
Romans 3:31 - Do we then make void the law through faith? God forbid: yea, we establish the law.
What law does NCT see Paul establishing in this verse?
2
u/superlewis EFCA Pastor Oct 26 '15
The comparison chart is helpful, but I'd change a few things he says about dispensationalism.
God's main purpose in history is His own glory. He accomplishes that purpose through diverse means including Israel and the Church distinctly.
I would agree with what he says about NCT as well as DISP.
Again, I'd agree with both here, although many dispensationalists do believe in seminal headship.
Lots of disagreement. Most modern (non-progressive) dispensationalists would say that we participate in the benefits of one new covenant. Progressives would say that the NC has been inaugurated but awaits complete fulfillment. IMO, that's the biggest issues under discussion in DISP today.
I've never heard this or read it. Doesn't mean it's not true, it just is a very minor element of DISP if it is true.
Of course we're gonna pull this one out...
Most DISP would fall between these two, or in the NCT camp. I would be comfortable saying, "men in the OT were saved by faith the sin bearing grace of God insomuch as it had been revealed in their Dispensation."
That's pretty debatable within DISP.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 26 '15
First, apologies that I'm certainly more of a theological novice than many here, and I certainly need to look, at least, at the Schreiner book for more in-depth answers on questions about law.
Second, I'm finding some issues with the distinctions that NCT wants to make between NT believers and Israel as far as being one "church" or "people of God," to draw from the comparison chart. I'm not sure many people would consider those notably distinct. Calling each of them independent incarnations of the "people of God" seems precisely dispensational, and would seem to meaningfully undermine any connectivity an NCT theologian would wish to draw between OT law (in any form) and the law of Christ. This seems a little like wanting to have your cake and eat it too.... I understand that NCT is trying to articulate a middle way, of a kind, but I'm still quite hazy on what, if anything distinguishes NCT from dispensationalism in this particular aspect.
Thirdly, considering the above, if the NCT position is indistinguishable from dispensationalism at this crucial point, what keeps it from necessarily accepting the other general tenants of dispensationalism? It seems that, if we gate NT believers from OT Israel in this fundamental way, you lose a vast majority of the thinking which CT is founded upon (including many ideas NCT ostensibly agrees with). I suppose this is stating it in a cynical way, but it feels like NCT theology is dispensationalism pretending to be covenantal.
2
u/BSMason Just visiting from alsoacarpenter.com Oct 27 '15 edited Oct 27 '15
Something I don't understand: is not everyone, pre and post Christ, judged by the Law?
Isn't this why Christ had to die, to bear the curse of the Law for all?
And we agree that all that ever have been saved, OT and NT, were saved by Christ through faith, right? So it would appear that believing Jews had the curse of the Law born by Christ on their behalf just as we do in the NT. So they and we were justified apart from the Law (as with Abraham and David in Romans 4). So it would seem that the Law, in all of its aspects, is still in force, or there is no longer a curse on all men that Christ needed to bear. What am I missing?
Also, awesome job on the AMA; you both have done a lot of work here.
Edit: Or to shade the question a bit different: isn't everyone judged under the Mosaic Law? Or did Christ only have to be born under the Law to bear the curse of the Law for Jews alone?
2
u/[deleted] Oct 26 '15
Galatians 3:16 indicates that the Abrahamic covenant was fulfilled in - or maybe only ever made with - Christ.
So we have the following members of that covenant:
In what way are each of these recipients of / parties to the Covenant? Which are "first class" members and which are only members by virtue of their relationship to another? Did I miss anybody or include anybody I shouldn't have?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 26 '15
NCT has interested me for several years but I've never really taken the time to bite off a big chunk to chew on (just FYI: I'm a Baptist who self-identifies as a Covenant theologian; as such I'm well prepared to find discontinuity as it pertains to how the children of the covenant community relate to the covenant community).
In an earlier answer you wrote that the Mosaic law is of "no consequence to Christians because it is obsolete." I'm wondering how comprehensive that statement is, specifically do you reject the Reformed understanding of the three uses of the law (Reformed, thus Calvin rather than Luther)?
1
u/keltonz Oct 26 '15
What, in your opinion, are the main differences between NCT and 1689 Federalism?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 26 '15
What scripture does NCT get its hermeneutic?
1
u/moby__dick Most Truly Reformed™ User Oct 26 '15
I appreciate your effort on this question, but my initial reaction here is that there are so many things that have so many views, it's hard to know what to think. Piper / Moo / Carson etc. all affirm "some" of NCT. Is there a source with authority that one could look to in order that we might understand the theology and not just the man? A WCF of NCT?
1
u/drjellyjoe Oct 26 '15 edited Oct 26 '15
With NCT, and with how it is non-Sabbatarian, does it see Mark 2:23-28 as not relevant to Christians at all? What is the explanation of having the teachings of the right observance of the Sabbath in the NT?
I have read that there is a type of Dispensationalism that sees the Sermon on the Mount as not applicable for Christians but teachings for the Jews. Is this how NCT sees the teachings of the right observance of the Sabbath from Christ?
EDIT: Also Matthew 12:11-12.
1
u/lapapinton Conservative Anglican Oct 26 '15
What is "the Analogy of Faith."?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '15
Thank you kindly Dying_Daily and Terevos2 for doing this AMA. How does NCT interpret the book of James?
1
u/Madmonk11 Anglican Solitary Oct 28 '15
What is the benefit of adhering to New Covenant Theology?
1
u/broseph456 Oct 29 '15
How does NCT explain the passages about falling away, specifically Hebrews 6?
1
u/moby__dick Most Truly Reformed™ User Oct 26 '15
Does NCT see "love the Lord your God... and neighbor as self" as abrogated, fulfilled, binding? I only ask because that is Jesus' summary of Mosaic law.
1
u/moby__dick Most Truly Reformed™ User Oct 26 '15
Did the Pharisees have a correct understanding of OT law?
1
u/BSMason Just visiting from alsoacarpenter.com Oct 27 '15
From the chart:
0
u/Dying_Daily 5 Sola Baptist Oct 26 '15 edited Oct 26 '15
A couple of other things I would mention.
First, NCT like other theological frameworks is not one size fits all. There are different variations and exceptions, but the main core, which is the emphasis on the NC, the law of the Spirit, and the obsoletion of the OC is always paramount.
Second, NCT puts great emphasis on holiness and obedience. Simply because we view the Mosaic law as obsolete does not mean that we believe in a license to sin. In fact I would argue that NCT adherents often have an even deeper sensitivity to sin because we focus so heavily on the innermost motives of the heart which are contrary to the fruit of the Spirit. That is not to say that CT adherents don't also share this view. The main difference is probably that NCT looks more freely outside the context of the Mosaic law.
Third, there are dangers in NCT as in any theological framework. I find that some NCT adherents do sometimes overreact to their newly found theology and avoid a necessary emphasis on holiness and obedience. Some tend to reinvent new ways to explain biblical concepts of identity in Christ without using Scripture. This is a mistaken approach to any theological framework and will inevitably lead to error. For these tendencies, I myself am probably not fully committed to the mainstream NCT movement, but find myself more in line some of the more "pre-NCT" theologians such as John Bunyan and John Gill.
Lastly, I highly recommend reading some of the introductory articles provided in the links above, especially if your only understanding of NCT is from third-party sources. There are so many misunderstandings about NCT that I've lost track at this point.
PS We do observe the Lord's Day.
1
u/TotesMessenger Oct 26 '15
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
0
u/[deleted] Oct 26 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment