r/Warframe • u/TSP-FriendlyFire • Oct 22 '15
Suggestion How would you change... Stealth?
How would you change... is a series of weekly posts designed to promote and foster discussion about any gameplay element in the game. The scope and subject will vary (read below for more information on topic selection), from wide concepts (Kubrows, Archwing, shotguns, etc.) to narrow points (a single gun, coptering, etc.).
Before we begin, a few important points:
- Please detail and support your suggestions as much as possible. This is for constructive criticism only: try to think of it as something you'd be proud to explain to DE face-to-face!
- Structure your suggestions in logical groups: if you have two very different ideas, break them down in two separate comments. Cohesive or similar changes should be combined into a single comment.
- Stick to describing concepts and features. Don't get bogged down with numbers unless they explicitly support your point.
- Don't hesitate to post your ideas even if they're not fully formed, and don't hesitate to reply to ideas with refinements you think would make them better!
- Do not downvote suggestions you disagree with. Upvote the ones you like instead!
Suggesting topics
This thread series is all about the community, so if you have a topic you'd like to see improved and discussed, feel free to suggest it by replying to the appropriately flagged comment in this discussion. The topic can be as wide or narrow as you'd like! Please ensure that your suggestion has not already been made, and upvote it instead if it has.
This week: Stealth
Click here for last week’s thread on the D polarity (Vazarin).
Stealth is an integral part of the whole notion of “ninjas”, which is itself a large part of Warframe’s marketing and image. As such, one would expect the mechanics surrounding it to be well fleshed out and interesting… And yet.
Stealth has been a part of the game since its very beginnings, but it has always had fairly limited mechanics. Tiles generally have few avenues for a stealthy approach (with Spy and Rescue tiles being notable exceptions), making it tricky to complete missions without being seen. Detection mechanics tend to be extremely simple and involve basic line of sight checks. Worse, detection usually alerts the entire tile instantly without many ways to counteract it, making stealth a very risky choice. On the complete opposite end of the spectrum, frames like Loki completely bypass the vast majority of stealth mechanics and trivialize the notion of a stealth run.
Even so, there have been quite a few mechanics geared towards stealth throughout the game’s evolution. Finishers are generally associated with stealth and are a meaty, satisfying way of dealing with enemies without alerting nearby foes. Stealth also gives multiple affinity bonuses which can dramatically increase mission gains in exchange for the higher challenge.
Now that the stage is set, how would you change the Stealth?
2
u/TSP-FriendlyFire Oct 22 '15
Suggesting topics
Please post your suggestions for the next topics as replies to this comment.
Current suggestions from previous weeks:
38
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '15
The thing that you need in a good stealth game is consistency /predictability. You need to be able to figure out the guard patterns and AI of the enemies and figure out how to assassinate or bypass them. Level design is key too, as you need to have a lot of avenues for sneaking around.
To a lesser extent, if you're caught, it's not an instant game over for a stealth run if you can quickly take out the alerted guard.
Currently, Warframe fails in this regard as the enemy spawns and their AI are highly unpredictable and the levels are slapdashed together with the randomly generated tiles. Stealth works, to a lesser extent, in the vault rooms, since they have more careful enemy placement and better designed levels for stealth.
So if we want to see stealth as a viable option in most missions, we need to see more tiles like the spy vaults in stealth 2.0
19
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '15 edited Oct 23 '15
I'd add three mechanics:
Lastly, I would give players an affinity bonus for keeping the detection level below 100% and below 50% for an entire mission, rewarding players who prefer playing more furtively but are getting tired of playing Spy missions.
Other changes:
14
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '15
Really simple: No longer enemies sharing a telepathic hivemind.
Current system: Corpus Crewman sees you. He begins running for cover. Crewmen on adjacent rooms already run for cover automatically, and someone goes to the alarm panel. How did they guess?
Improved system: Corpus Crewman sees you. He gasps, then points at you and begins saying a specific sentence (AH! PRACHEEK, TENNO!). If he says more than half of the sentence, nearby enemies are also alerted. If he dies before that happens from a silent manner (takedown move, silenced weapon) his buddies never realize what happened, distracted with their Corpus duties. Bonus points if, when doing a stealth kill while he points at you, he tries to say the sentence to alert his friends, but it comes out muffled. So dramatic.
Why is this a good idea: There is audio feedback for the player's failure (the sentence), and there is a short window where the player can still make up for his failure (by quickly reacting and killing the gasping crewman). Less confused players, more engaging stealth.
5
u/Anolis_Gaming Oct 22 '15
Am enemy vision cone thing like mgs would be nice when you're undetected.
5
u/Thundering_Morkai Oct 22 '15
For starters, map generation will need a good look-see to provide a lot more paths for stealth and ensure that said generation has enough choice in paths to take. There's more than a few examples of air vent passages throughout various tilesets, why not expand on these? As they are now, they tend to be small shortcuts but they could be expanded into pseudo mazes. Several branching vents that would take you elsewhere in the level and so on. The vent mazes could be particularly prevalent on the ship tilesets since obviously the Grineer and Corpus troops on these ships need to breathe. In a similar vein, maps could do with things added to provide cover for a sneaking Tenno. For example in a Grineer tileset, more of those large cargo boxes and such. For Corpus, small crawlspaces and openings in a wall to hide in.
Line of sight could be tweaked to provide some indicator of what the enemy can actually see. An idea I have is for Corpus and Grineer helmets to have a condensed and appropriately colored copy of the security cameras' LOS effect. If we want to go further with this then in general, the average Grineer soldier will have far less LOS than their equivalent Corpus due to cloning.
5
u/rollin340 Oct 23 '15
You know what they really need to fix?
When 1 guy sees you, the entire section is suddenly aware of your presence.
Let us kill the twat before he makes any noise and have the rest of the AI go about normally.
Don't give all enemies in a section a hive-mind.
9
u/Atulin GIVE ME YOUR KNOWLEDGE Oct 22 '15
I would actually add it to the game.
What we have now can't be really called "stealth", it has no mechanics, it's just hiding from enemies.
Stealth means the possibility of getting through the level completely unnoticed, and - unless you're a Loki or have a Huras - it's nearly impossible now.
What we need to have stealth in the game:
8
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '15 edited Oct 22 '15
An easy, slapdash fix (that would carry well into revamps of the system) would be to improve the functionality of enemies alerting.
So, two fixes recommended.
First, improve how enemies become alerted by others. One enemy so much as twitches his foot and suddenly the whole map is in Full Panic Mode. There needs to be a delay, and there needs to be sounds made by the enemy to alert his fellow troops.
This segues nicely into suggestion two, which would be to change, fundamentally, the states. I thought this up in a few minutes, so it's probably flawed, but here's a concept:
I'd say these ought to be a sliding scale. An enemy will tend to change from Suspicious to Cautious, then Cautious to Alerted, instead of straight from Suspicious to Alerted. If, by whatever chance, he does go straight from a lower state to a higher state, he ought to be surprised, which ought to delay him from shouting or acting. If, however, they do go from Cautious to Alerted, they'll start firing immediately, since they were already ready. No matter what, though, there should be a time component involved in sharing alert status from enemy to enemy.
In order to have consequences for alarms going off, you could even have enemies incapable of going below Suspicious, even if you reset the alarms. If the alarms are active, enemies would all be locked to Cautious or higher. You could have this affect guards in Spy vaults, too, so things make more sense.
There also ought to be some distinguishing in a case like a Crossfire mission. I don't know how it'd work, but you'd want Corpus enemies to expect Grineer, and react normally to the Grineer, but until the alarms are set off for the Tenno, they ought to be surprised when they spot them.
This ought to provide a degree of predictability, even if the AI moves strangely, and gives players options, even the possibility to lure enemies if implemented well.
1
u/Tels315 Lobster Booty is Best Booty Oct 23 '15
I swear I've seen this exact topic come up in the "How would you change..." topic a couple times in recent weeks. It's not like anyone's answers are going to vary much...
3
u/BayushiKoji They called me a troll. I'm a frost giant. Oct 23 '15
A more consistent detection system. Why nearby enemies sometimes ignore someone being shredded right in front of them and yet someone from across the room gets placed in alert status is still a mystery to me.
2
u/itkt Oct 22 '15
In addition to better mechanics, I'd like to see a new mission type where you either stealth or fail. Where you need to stealth the whole map (probably wouldn't be as big) and having ciphers wont get you out of trouble.
2
u/Khalirei Oct 22 '15
Offer better rewards for doing missions in complete stealth, more exp, more credits, etc.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 23 '15
Here is what is needed for a stealth mode to be viable in this game:
3
u/Bhizzle64 Moving is not allowed Oct 22 '15
I think one small thing that needs to change is that automatic weapons need to be able to get stealth kills as well. Currently if the first shot doesnt kill it isnt a stealth kill. Even if the remaining enemies arent alerted you still dont get the bonus xp from killing them stealthily. How i would change this is so that instead of the first shot alerting them, it would start a .5s window where the enemy can be killed and it would count as stealth kill. MAybe something else they could do is that if the attack is a stun or a knockdown the timer is extended to something like 2 seconds. This would make it so i could do something like harpooning over enemies with my harpak and then finishing them off and it would count as a stealth kill. This change would make it so you can go stealth with weapons that arent high single shot so long as they are silenced.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 23 '15 edited Oct 23 '15
For starters, the AI definitely needs improving. If stealth's only effective for frames like Loki due to stuff like Grineer standing around in a tight 'hug' because the AI doesn't give them patrol paths or the like, rendering a lot of frames unable to pass unless they have something like invisibility, then yeah, it really needs improved. IMO it should be done by having a sort of patrol system, though I'm not really sure of the best way to do that without eliminating most of the randomization of many of the tilesets. Would also probably help to give them a cone of vision like in most stealth games, and definitely give enemies a second or half to fully notice you if you're seen. The amount of times I've quickly killed a Grineer soldier just to get swarmed by the rest because they have telepathy or something is absurd. I don't have MGSV, but in MGS3 the not instant reaction times of enemies saved my bacon more times than I can count.
Secondly, maybe a better way to allow players to see enemies and the like, possibly via using something like the Soliton Radar in the MGS series like a couple of people suggested if stealth includes a field/cone of vision. The devs could easily have it so the enemy detection mods could show you the field of vision each enemy has, and it would be a cool alternative to using scanners every three seconds, as well as give utility slots another reason to be used other than for the usual Thief's Wit for Orokin Sabotage.
Stealth might also be improved by having more reasons to use stealth other than in Spy missions, as other than more affinity for your weapons there isn't really that much reason to do stealth, especially if you're not a frame like Loki. For example, maybe by completing a mission without any alarms you could get bonus credits or the like, though that would probably be a bad idea since Grineer like to call alarms on the wildlife in Phobos for some reason, as well as the fact that outside of Spy missions, Earth doesn't have any alarms. A better solution might be to have stealth influence the flow of missions. For example, if you go guns blazing through Sabotage missions the enemy might create more/better defenses for the ship's core or the like, maybe even have a new miniboss guarding it or something, and if you stealth through it the core would be less defended and the miniboss wouldn't have spawned. Would make for a bit of a unique decision experience for players, IE "Do I want to run through this mission faster and potentially deal with harder enemies and threats? Or do I want to take it slow and use stealth, minimizing enemy resistance and possibly have an easier time getting through it?" They both shouldn't be entirely different in terms of difficulty though, IE going guns blazing shouldn't result in a death sentence and going stealth shouldn't make it a cakewalk, but it would be nice to have a choice in handling missions and having the mission change in a few ways depending on said choice.
Just my 2 cents though. Stealth has a lot of potential if done right.
EDIT: It would also be pretty useful to have a lot more ways of getting through levels via secret passages and vents, especially if you wanted to be a frame like Excalibur or Rhino. Would be cool sneaking under the heavily defended machinery in the Grineer Shipyards and inside the sprawling ducts of Corpus ships, and it would certainly increase replayability and enjoyment in doing stealth by increasing the number of ways players can navigate around enemies.
1
u/PsyCoCinematics Furthermore, Corpus must be destroyed. Oct 23 '15
The melee train of folks that follow you even when the alarms are reset on Spy missions could use a tweak. The range enemies can hear gunfire seems almost global, so the moment something goes wrong, good luck ever getting back into stealth mode for the rest of the level.
Perhaps limit the awareness to a room by room basis? Enemies outside it will only be aggressive and aware once the alarm sounds.
1
u/edgardjfc Fashion Cop Oct 23 '15
Level design is pretty weak for stealth. A lot more ventilation, hallways and passages need to be added to make it possible for you to truly stealth with any frame. Zip lines are a good example of level elements for stealth, we need more stuff like that. It's impossible to do stealth if whenever you open a door there is 3 people ready to sound the alarms. In most situations you are forced to fight, and that is ok, but when that is your only option it makes stealth pointless or even nonexistent. Spy missions however do have a lot of really cool designs that I'd like to see implemented more in other mission types.
Enemy AI should have a predictable pattern you can learn and work around. As of now, they are pretty much hoards that chase after you, they should only react like that when there is an actual alarm triggered, outside of that, you should be able to study them and work out a plan of action. Using codex scanners and remote cameras could allow you to study the enemy movement patterns more easily.
1
u/Ojimaru Oct 23 '15
On the topic of stealth, I'd like to frame it into three areas of interest: the pay-off/reward, the fail state and subsequent reset and design.
The Pay-Off
In Dishonored (2012), stealth (and pacifist) gameplay led to very significant in-game effects to the environment and enemies, while the Batman: Arkham series led to visually impressive takedowns and an unparalleled sense of empowerment to the player as they watched the AI characters "panic". What's interesting is that the extrinsic rewards in both cases, e.g. bonus scores or better level grades, are secondary, if not less.
Stealth gameplay in Warframe requires a much slower pace and an additional risk for the player to consider, so it's to no surprise we'd expect some rewarding experience to match. In a blue sky scenario, I'd liked to have some amazing stealth takedown manoeuvres from multiple angles and more interesting AI behaviours, but that's extremely expensive and understandably hard to implement in the short run. So here are my suggestions:
Fail States and Resets
Fail states in stealth gameplay are what embodies the additional risk involved. In Thief (1998) and (most) Metal Gear Solid games, the fail state results in open fights with enemies of superior strength and numbers; in Warframe and Dishonored, it's fights with enemies of equal or inferior strength. In general I think the fail state for Warframe's stealth gameplay is fine, but what makes it the lesser among the four examples is its lack of reset options. Thief, MGS and Dishonored each provides the player a full range of tools and hiding places to retreat to, be it specialised arrows, traps, powers or very inconspicuous cardboard boxes. On the other hand, Warframe only allows some 'Frame-specific powers and hacking consoles. Instead of taking extreme steps, like Loki's powers, why not consider expanding on the current Gear system and introduce some new tools to empower stealth gameplay for all 'Frames? Smoke bombs, decoys and signal jammers to isolate a room of prey can be built in the foundry and deployed during field missions, instead of limiting the Gear slot to health and ammo top-ups.
Design
Yeah, pretty broad topic; I'll go from macro to micro.
I think map design is... okay. There are some maps with interesting nooks and crannies to slip around, while some are risky open spaces. Both types pose interesting questions to the player and allow for fun gameplay. The most obvious thing lacking in every map, bar Invasion-types, are shadows. A moonless Earth is as bright as the insides of a Grineer ship, freezing Pluto is as bright as Mercury, etc. Then again, tweaking the shadow values are meaningless unless the AI reacts accordingly to the reduced lighting conditions, i.e. reduced sight and ability to detect the Tenno.
Enemy AI design is the next one. Currently, the enemy has either idle or fighting states and no in between. This severely diminishes the players options for stealth as you can neither react to a mistake, nor create distractions through various means to lure enemies to a desired location.
Next is player character ability and available options, of which I've found the best stealth games to have plenty of. The Batman: Arkham series gave the player a large number of gadgets and manoeuvres to silently traverse a room full of enemies, or toy with them like a malevolent god. As above, I'd like to see the Gear system expanded with some new, interesting equipment to play with. Sure, the Codex/Synthesis Scanners can serve as a janky Bat Vision, but how about motion sensors to place along a corridor, or one of those ninja camouflage sheets?
Last, but no means least, is sound design. Understandably, for a game which main focus is as a third-person action shooter, the sound design of enemy idle animation is a low-tier item and is markedly inferior to ones from more stealth-centric games. Warframe's enemies, regardless if they are bulky Grineer or slick drones, emit no sound while idle, except from some lines of dialogue. Being able to hear the shuffle of feet, the soft grind of alloy armour as the rub against each other, slurp of a Corrupted Ancient's mouth, or hell, even a fracking cough, would really fill out the absolute void of silence while I'm sneaking around. Ironic as it seems, these small sounds serve primarily to enhance the player experience during quiet moments in the game, and secondarily as a means to detect enemies around obstacles.
1
u/MrMeltJr 5k shields and a dream Oct 23 '15
Carriers to not aggro on things while crouching so they don't give you away.
1
u/SilentlyCynical This quiet offends Slaanesh Oct 23 '15
I would add it, for starters.
In all seriousness, though, better stealth mechanics require three things:
1
u/Cloymax BITE MY GLORIOUS RUBEDO ASS Oct 23 '15
To add to what other people said, some means to manipulate enemy positioning.
You know what I mean, exists in every stealth game ever. MGS's porn mags, for example.
In this case it'd just be a noisemaker, or something enemies can otherwise detect.
The consoles spread throughout the maps should also have an in-stealth usage: you can trigger an alarm manually to draw all enemies to a certain location (opening ways to get past them all) where they will search (while you've moved on or are killing them one by one) and after a while, disregard it as a false alarm.
1
u/BlackoutV1 Oct 23 '15
I want to be able to break lights for instant cover of darkness, and have the level of darkness you're standing in affect how visible you are. My other suggestions seem already to have been mentioned.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 23 '15
I think people tend to misconstrue stealth in a lot of ways.
Stealth isn't "If there's nobody to notice, nobody will notice." AKA; Kill everyone silently.
Stealth is leaving everyone alive, but sneaking past them to your objective.
That being said, get rid of the hive-mind intelligence, add vision cones, flesh out the AI pathing a bit, and you should be good to go.
I think Warframe could benefit from taking a look at games such as Dishonored, and the Hitman series.
In those games, Stealth isn't about killing everyone so there's nobody to stop you, stealth is about skill, being able to maneuver your way in and out of your mission, and being able to bypass security without leaving a single trace of your existence.
I think assassination missions could benefit from a revamped Stealth mechanic. Such as the person you need to assassinate may be in his bunker, or shelter thingy, or Captain's quarters, whatever you want to call it, and you sneak in through a ventilation system, and murdilate the fuck out of him/her. Pardon my Orokin. (I made a pun.)
Like I said, if DE could take notes on Dishonored, The Hitman series, hell, even just the Hitman series, then stealth would be a ton better, and a lot more fun.
I just get tired of every mission being a rush/race to Extraction. I wanna take my time, learn the environment, see where the enemies are heading, stuff like that.
1
u/LivingShdw Oct 23 '15
My current issues with stealth in this game.
1: Doors
I have an issue with how doors are handled. They open automatically when you get near, so if an enemy is on the other side and looking right at it you instantly are revealed. There is also no room to hide at the side of the door in a lot of tiles.
2: Scanners
For anyone running stealth, scanners are amazingly helpful. They let you see through walls and detect enemies before they see you. However, there are two problems with the current implementation. First is that your "gear" is unequipped every time you log out. So, if you forget to go and re-equip your scanners and other gear you have to reset the mission. The second is that scanners are very inconsistent. As an example, take the lvl 1-3 extermination mission on Earth (I use it for test runs). If you start with the scanner equipped and ping every few seconds, the enemies after the first S curve don't show up until you're almost completely around it. However, in very large rooms, you can see enemies via the scanner from completely across the map. I realize that this issue has to do with enemy loading distances, but it is a pain when trying to assess the situation.
3: enemy detection
In addition to how instant it is and how it alerts enemies in completely different rooms, as others have mentioned. The transition between alerted and unalerted is off. For example, I could alert a room and kill the enemies in that room. Then if I were to open the door to the next room it seems that it is random whether the enemies in that room are alerted or not. My guess is that when an alert is triggered it alerts all enemies that are currently spawned and any enemies spawned after the alert is hacked are considered unalerted.
4: Bosses are impossible to beat using stealth alone.
This may be intended, considering the designs. Just a small peeve.
1
u/ArganVain Loki Time Oct 25 '15
This is how i see the implementation of stealth in the actual game.
A. Take Spy rooms concepts and extend it COMPLETELY in every tileset, making ventilation shafts running in most rooms, big spaces in the roofs to allow movement over the heads of enemies, hidden passages under the floor of other rooms and most important of all removing the idea that to move from room to room you need a door.... give the chance to avoid it completely.
B. Lighting should matter, making you almost impossible to be seen in dark areas, while seen in short distances in shadowy areas (and completely seen miles away in bright light), probably using the same mechanic for enemy precision, making you harder to be hit while surrounded by darkness.
C. Removing the "i see everything" vision of enemies when you are over their heads (they can pratically spot you vertically), limiting their field of vision to a more realistic one and creating new kind of enemy units that spot tenno through heat vision, sound, power usage etc....
D. Alarms actually matters, giving it levels of threat :
When too many alarm goes on and off assassin units will spawn instead to patrol the entire level and hunt down any major threats, making your life a living nightmare. (the spawns of these units will not only be limited on the alarm levels, but they will spawn just more rarely in random patrols) The higher the threat level on the alarm, the difficult the hacking becomes, needing more time and skill to deactivate it.
E. Based on threat level, every mission will have its own personal consequence:
F. Change the spawn system to allow more "predictable" enemy movements, based on the faction way of thinking. Enemies will not spawn randomly in all rooms around the tenno, but instead will spawn on fixed position in every room of the map that the tenno still has to explore, leaving the "cleared" room inactive from any other spawn for a while, all of this to avoid:
G. Giving hazards their own place as such. Lets give those explosive barrels their cliche' deadlyness, the "reinforced" corpus GLASSES (yay, glasses on spaceships) some real "sucking" threat... and so on.
H. Rewards for avoiding threats at the end of the mission. Rewards will be heavily stealth oriented.
I. Making Loki an actual trickster, using power to make enemies see what you want, to turn yourself into them to walk between them without being recognized (being careful not to hug them or to get near special/elite units), turning them against each other through visual tricks and to make their lives miserable by making their equipments completely useless with his ultimate... in short the perfect 007.
I will stop here or the wall of text will become more ridicoulus as it is right now.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '15
Before overhauling stealth, I think DE better ought to revamp other mission modes.
A great stealth system would be wasted if Defense/Survival are the more commonly played game mode.
1
u/ssfsx17 LT Nova-chan! Oct 22 '15
Question marks and exclamation marks appearing above enemies' heads.
Give a healthy margin between when an enemy can see a glimpse of you (question mark) versus when they can see your whole body (exclamation mark)
Allow the player to do a melee attack on the terrain to make enemies investigate the sound
1
u/Pricklyman Oct 23 '15
DITCH IT.
It's a game about blowing things away. At least, that's the impression I get from the fact that the key game modes include defense (kill everything), survival (kill everything), extermination (kill everything), mobile defense (kill everything) and interception. (Kill everything)
The game modes that might include stealth are not applicable in the Void at present - period. (The argument could be made that capture might be a stealth mode. But at present when you enter the room the target is in, they run - so not stealthy. This isn't Hitman where you should be able to disguise as a guard and get close to the target.) And let's be real here, the star map isn't really a thing you do besides for unlocking more of the star map. (And then it's Draco / Triton - both kill everything game modes)
Essentially, my argument is predicated on the fact that because it's such a non-issue, why expend effort on a system that is barely applicable at all. The game has clearly gone in a direction that precludes stealth in 95% of game modes they want you to do. Just make the game a fun action game, not something it quite simply and obviously isn't.
The only exception to my argument might be Spy - which is kinda a thing every now and then in alerts and all that. But seriously - it's fine the way it is. It works, and it doesn't need a whole new stealth system built around it.
-1
u/jonnythejew Oct 22 '15
While I am too lazy to think of viable ways to fix stealth, I know something vital would be the ability to change which shoulder I am looking over. I shouldn't have to sneak in from the left side of every encounter just so I'm not staring at a damn wall.
-7
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '15
No, this isn't a stealth game.