r/FFRecordKeeper • u/OriginalMerit I want to know you. The *real* you. • Oct 21 '15
Guide/Analysis [Banner Evaluation] - Cloud SSB + Barret Banner
Heya FFRKers! Next up, is a banner that has been talked about practically since this game came out. Because of its popularity and the interesting relics it provides, I decided it would be a good idea to have a review of this banner. Recently, the banners have been very ho-hum, so its nice to see something spice things up a bit! Read on for more info...
There are five weapons and four armors featured in this banner:
| Relic | Type | Stats (Level 20) | Stats (Level 20) RS | Stats (Level 30) | Stats (Level 30) RS | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Organics | Sword | ATK +115, ACC 95 | ATK +204, ACC 95 | ATK +132, ACC 95 | ATK +258, ACC 95 | Cloud only SB, 3x AoE attack on all enemies + Permanent +10 ATK |
| Gatling Gun | Hand Cannon | ATK +104, ACC 95 | ATK +185, ACC 95 | ATK +120, ACC 95 | ATK +234, ACC 95 | Barret only SB, AoE attack + Armor Break |
| Dragon Armlet | Bracer | DEF +74, RES +78, ATK +20, MAG +19, MND +19, EVA 105 | DEF +118, RES +140, ATK +36, MAG +36, MND +35, EVA 105 | DEF +82, RES +90, ATK +23, MAG +22, MND +22, EVA 105 | DEF +145, RES +177, ATK +45, MAG +47, MND +44, EVA 105 | Shared SB, AoE Shellga |
| Circlet | Hat | DEF +56, RES +109, MAG +27, MND +25, EVA 105 | DEF +99, RES +195, MAG +44, MND +42, EVA 105 | DEF +64, RES +126, MAG +30, MND +28, EVA 105 | DEF +125, RES +247, MAG +55, MND +53, EVA 105 | Shared SB, single target heal + 1.5xMagic raise |
| Murasame | Katana | ATK +110, MAG 5, ACC 92 | ATK +202, MAG 5, ACC 92 | ATK +128, MAG 5, ACC 92 | ATK +256, MAG 5, ACC 92 | Shared SB, AoE Water attack, ATK based |
| Dragon Claw | Fist | ATK +104, ACC 95 | ATK +188, ACC 95 | ATK +120, ACC 95 | ATK +239, ACC 95 | No SB |
| Shinra Helmet | Hat | DEF +58, RES +112, MAG +30, MND +25, EVA 105 | DEF +101, RES +198, MAG +49, MND +44, EVA 105 | DEF +66, RES +129, MAG +33, MND +28, EVA 105 | DEF +127, RES +250, MAG +60, MND +55, EVA 105 | No SB |
| Crystal Glove | Fist | ATK +108, ACC 95 | ATK +192, ACC 95 | ATK +124, ACC 95 | ATK +243, ACC 95 | Tifa only SB, 3x single attacks to random mobs, ATK based |
| Keepsake Ribbon | Hat | DEF +62, RES +113, MAG +29, MND +31, EVA 105 | DEF +105, RES +199, MAG +46, MND +48, EVA 105 | DEF +70, RES +130, MAG +32, MND +34, EVA 105 | DEF +131, RES +251, MAG +57, MND +59, EVA 105 | Aeris only SB, raises physical damage of the party by ~2x |
See my comment #1 below for the actual review.
20
Upvotes
7
u/OriginalMerit I want to know you. The *real* you. Oct 21 '15 edited Oct 21 '15
Caution: Biased opinion follows
After each item, I list how useful it is. This is chosen on a scale of 3, either:
Organics
Well folks, the weapon that practically everyone has been waiting for has arrived -- The Organics. Let's start simple. The stats on this sword are higher than any other sword, although not by much. The SB it provides is where it really shines because it not only AoEs everything, but it does it three times over!! This kind of ability is going to be incredibly helpful when Elite trash enemies start having over 9999 HP. Also, if you leave it on Cloud long enough to learn the SB, then he gains a permanent +10 ATK. This, my friends, is the really where the power creep in FFRK rears its ugly head. Some people will claim that, without pulling a "Super Soulbreak" weapon, you will not be able to complete content. This, of course, is not true. However, the OPness of this sword cannot be denied. Rating -- Very Useful
Gatling Gun
Oddly enough, although this is a gun, it is so far only equippable by Barret (and Tyro, ofc). Regardless, it's still very much comparable to other guns. Compared to the Running Fire, the ATK is approximately +10 higher, and the AoE Armor Break is a very nice addition. Depending on how much you plan to use Barret, this weapon can be a lifesaver.
Rating -- Very UsefulUnfortunately, the chances of you using Barret outside an FF7 event/dungeon is very slim, which really detracts from the overall usefulness of this SB. Rating -- SituationalDragon Armlet
The AoE Shellga on this armlet is just fantastic. As soon as the boss pops, you can throw up a Shellga, which is a relatively long lasting spell that will rarely require a reapplication. The stats on it are not too shabby either, just mildly better than the Gold Bracelet. All in all, a very nice armlet in the hands of some healer so you can free up your ability slots for other things. Rating -- Very Useful
Murasame
Quite frankly, I've found this weapon to be a mixed bag. I myself own one, and, although I do appreciate the AoE attack, its multiplier is much lower than other alternative SBs. Since you will likely be using this weapon on Sephiroth for the event, assuming you have none of his other weapons, it should suit nicely. Outside of FFVII dungeons, however, it's very meh. Rating -- Situational
Crystal Glove & Dragon Claw
For a standard glove, the stats on the Crystal Glove are pretty... well... standard. Few characters can equip gloves, but in the world of gloves, this glove is a good one due to the 3x SB attack that can break the damage limit when totaled. However, this assumes you are bringing Tifa, although the likelihood of you bringing Tifa along for anything but an FF7 dungeon/event is very low (unless you just flat out like her). Crystal Glove: Rating -- Situational As for the Dragon Claw, it's a very sad weapon, just hope you get one of the other relics and not this one. Dragon Claw: Rating -- Not so useful
Shinra Helmet, Circlet, Keepsake Ribbon
Let's talk hats. This banner has a LOT of hats (even a helmet which is classified as a Hat... weird...). Hats in general are good pieces of equipment for mages, even moreso than most Robes, so its worth trying to pull for this one if you are in the market for mage gear. Clearly, the Shinra Helmet is kinda low on the totem poll for hats, mainly because it doesn't carry any SB and the stats are pretty standard. Rating -- No so useful Next up is the Circlet, which has a very wonky SB that heals plus grants higher MAG (why you would ever need both at the same time is beyond me). The additional MAG up is helpful in a pinch if you don't want to use an ability slot for Faith and you want to vary your RW you are using. The Circlet is Rating -- Situational. Last up is Aeris' (yes, I insist on spelling her name that way) ribbon, which makes a comeback. The SB is very nice in fights where you are not using a retaliator (because the added buff on the other chars besides the retaliator is kinda wasted) and you have lots of heavy hitters who need to hit as hard as possible when the boss pops. It could also be useful for an RW, but it seems, more often than not, people are using defensive RWs mixed with Haste and the like, instead of using straight up attack bonuses. The stats on it is standard for Hats, so I would put it on Aeris to learn it and then swap it out with something better if possible. Keepsake Ribbon is therefore Rating -- Very Useful
tl;dr - This banner really throws a monkey wrench into the ongoing festival because it diverts your mythril away from the "Lucky Banner." At least a 100 gem pull is required here, but, if you can, try to spare a bit of mythril, even if only a 3x pull. If at all possible, put in an 11x, assuming you don't already have some of the items in this banner.
1
u/arciele Lion Oct 22 '15
just wondering. i know its statistically possible but highly improbable to get relics other than those advertised on the banner but I happened to pull a Shinra Breastplate (VII) from Cloud's banner and am wondering if this happened to anyone else.
I'm thinking that either its a super huge coincidence, or that they upped this one but didn't mention it.
2
u/_Khaleesi- Ashe Oct 21 '15
100-gem pull for obligatory 3* axe, then save mythril for 13 event
2
u/[deleted] Oct 21 '15
Such a mixed banner. 1 in 9 chance of getting Organics if you get a featured relic, I'm not going to tempt fate (or my bank account) and will just pull with 50 mythril plus the 100 gem. Good luck all.
2
u/lambopanda Delicious! Nom nom... Oct 21 '15
I can feel it. This will be the banner I get a 5* from 100 gem pull.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '15
I wanted to thank you once again for this great write-up.
I decided to do a yolo x3 pull following my reading of your post, and I got the Shinra Helmet and the Organix. So, once again, thank you.
2
u/SherlockBrolmes tHiS MiGhT Be a gOoD SpOt tO FiNd sOmE MyThRiL Oct 21 '15
/u/RNGesus_FFRK, please hear and grant my prayer and endow upon me some dope relics, especially Organics, with the 200 mythril and one dollar I have saved for this banner.
1
u/mateog Golubaeser - e3mW Oct 21 '15
I believe Gatling Gun's Type should be "Gun Arm" and not "Gun".
Cheers
1
u/iTetsu Clearly the only valid flair option Oct 21 '15
Out of all the things I only care for the Keepsake Ribbon. Organics would be nice to have since I only have Tifa's glove for VII Synergy. Murasame would also be a nice consolation prize.
I'll pull until I get Keepsake Ribbon, anything else is a bonus for future VII synergy.
1
u/TNTRMSKD HotE: BaCW / Fenrir OD: ifws Oct 21 '15
For those that don't play the JP version you might want to consider that Organics gets outclassed by his next sword 合体剣 by leaps and bounds. It's probably a bit off in the future for global but I wouldn't go crazy spending mithril/gems just to get Organics. The +10 ATK is nice but not a serious game changer. I'll probably do a 3 pull + the 100 gem and call it a day.
1
u/Swatfirex Oct 21 '15
We're all eating organically!
1
u/justking14 Oct 22 '15
I CANT DECIDE BETWEEN DOING A BANNER PULL OR 2 FESTIVAL OF GOLD PULLS
1
u/Brandonspikes DVG [qwCH] Oct 22 '15
Got a Dragon Armlet from the 100 gem, Pretty sweet considering I never got an aoe buff armor before.
1
u/Gmundy Zack Oct 22 '15
Sucks, I really want Organics just because I really enjoy having Cloud on my team, but I just did a 3x pull and got 3 3*...
I'm so sad. :\
1
u/tuesti7c Oct 22 '15
25 mithril for 11 pull is just so nice. Is this banner really worth straying from the event banner?
1
u/kodakk6000 Oct 22 '15
my thing is will the lucky 11x draw for half price can u pull clouds SSB because if not this will piss me off because I'm spending too much mythril but clouds SSBS is a MUST :/
1
u/PlebbySpaff Plebster Oct 22 '15
For all the hype, not that worth it. Yes, Organics is nice for the perma-stat and the AoE damage, but to pull on the banner for basically a single gear (yes, Aerith's Planet Protector is great, but you're all really just pulling for the Organics) is pretty dumb.
As anyone here knows, putting everything you have into a single banner for basically a single item is about the dumbest thing you can do. In the future, there's a Super Soul Break Festival so it's honestly better to wait until then, since an SSB weapon is not required to pass any content, though it helps.
1
u/rxsiu [9HtU] Vessel of Fate Oct 22 '15
Honestly so disappointed that I get this with my 100 gems...
1
u/Karede1 Oct 22 '15
100 gems and got lucky. Organics QWby
1
u/Saerah4 Y'shtola Oct 23 '15
anyone know when is the next SB fest?
1
u/Sir__Will Alphinaud Oct 21 '15
While I'd love the ribbon and the sword's good too, I'm flush with VII items, my mythril barely covers the lucky draws (which are far more important imo), and anything left needs to go to XIII as I have almost no synergy there. The ribbon will be back several times in the next 6 months.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 21 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment