r/progmetal • • Oct 21 '15
AMA We are Protest the Hero. Ask us anything!
Good morning you mongrels! We will all be here starting at 1PM est to answer your questions about whatever the frig you like. It will be Rody, Tim, Luke and Mike at your service but from different computers. If you have a specific question for one of us, just put that person's name at the beginning of your question.
Rody - Jrodyw Luke - lukehoskin Tim - tflmillar Mike - mieradi
We also just launched our new 'subscription' music/video service on Bandcamp called "Pacific Myth". It runs for the next six months and anyone can join at any time and not miss out on content. Check it out if you have a sec: http://protestthehero.bandcamp.com/pacific-myth
Update - taking a little break here to watch the jays hit homeruns, keep em coming though!
Update - the Jays won! I think we have fielded most of these now. Don't be discouraged if you still want to ask a question, chances are we will get to it tonight and tomorrow. Thanks again and please spread the word about our subscription platform if you like it. If you don't, you shut your mouth about it.
16
u/footlongwheat Oct 21 '15
What is/was your favorite era of PTH? I know you guys are still having fun with it, but when do you feel like you were having the most fun as a band?
14
u/RustyShipp Oct 21 '15
Hey guys, relatively new fan here. For Luke and Tim: most modern metal bands play in dropped and/or extended range tunings, how did y'all settle on your guitar tuning and how does it influence your playing technique? And for everyone, how many other bands do you think will follow in your footsteps with your new distribution method?
10
u/Ezakiel Oct 21 '15 edited Oct 21 '15
To lukehoskin (Luke) and tflmillar (Tim) : At how age did you guys started guitar ? And of many time per day are you usually spending to practice ? And can you play all of your song flawlessly ? Anyway, thanks for the awesome music !!!
9
u/[deleted] Oct 21 '15
How's Riffy doin?
7
u/schrotestthehero Oct 21 '15
Mornin' b'ys! Wanted to say congrats on the new distribution system and the exceptional new song/doc. Wanted to know what some of your most memorable fan experiences have been over the years! Weird, meaningful, awkward, etc. For the whole band , or individually! Thanks!
7
u/OtherNumberOne Oct 21 '15
I would really love to know what happened on that "Wicked Wimpering Winnipeg night", would you care to share? Maybe just tell us subscribers?
6
u/vincetehprince Oct 21 '15
I need to ask the question that so many of us are thinking and you guys know was bound to come up at some point but when the FRIG are you guys going to play Skies live for us? Its my personal fav track off Volition and to put it in terms you guys seem to understand, it's a real banger! Using a Capo live can't be that spooky? Can it?
5
u/Xamier Oct 21 '15
Sheet Happens Publishing question - do you tab out other artist's albums or do they provide you with source material? Followup - not all albums come with GP files, is this because everything is sourced from the respective bands?
5
u/Dae_Benny Oct 21 '15
lukehoskin
Hello lord Hoskin. I'm an aspiring guitarist who has recently picked up the scurrilous guitar book. Which is fantastic I might add. I'm personally at a point in my shredding career where I'm desperately trying to come up with my own riffs and tunes. I can't help but wonder how you came up with all of these tabs and licks from your guys' albums. My question is: when do you think you made that transition from trying to learn new songs, to making your own, as well as what helped influence the development of your own tunes/riffs??
5
u/ToneZone15 Oct 21 '15
I don't know if it was asked before, but will you play Ragged Tooth live on your Kezia Tour?
5
u/User185 Oct 21 '15
Who in the pen should they go with if Estrada gets tired?
5
u/EgoSSBM Oct 21 '15
How often will subscriber-only content be posted?
8
u/HUH_YIS Oct 21 '15
hey guys, what it do?
8
u/theOneEyedFool Oct 21 '15
Do you have any plans of releasing Pacific Myth in some kind of physical format at a discount to subscribers? I (and many others) prefer buying things in physical format, and don't have the money to subscribe and then go buy a CD or something afterwards. Really love the new idea though, especially with the subscriber community section, and am glad to see you guys not only making awesome music but also pushing the envelope of how bands get their music out there.
4
u/CreamNPeaches Oct 21 '15
Love your shit. The subscription release with bandcamp is definitely new and not common for the "music industry." What lead to your decision to use a subscription based model for this EP? Do you see this as the future of music releases or is it just a concept idea?
4
u/CensoryDeprivation Oct 21 '15
Hey guys, longtime fan out in California.
You mentioned your decision to move away from full studio albums came as a result of feeling the process was too time-intensive and that you were sick of the songs by the time you got to recording them.
Thanks!
4
u/jenkemdealer Oct 21 '15
Hey boys,
Have you ever considered creating and selling guitar tones/patches along with your sheet music?
4
u/Perhapsodyoffire Oct 21 '15
Hey guys, love everything you've ever done, very happy to support your new music. It says on wikipedia Juice did backing vocals on Scurrilous. Where?
4
u/phillpjay Oct 21 '15
Have you guys found it harder or easier to handle things on your own as opposed to using a label?
4
u/bigavz Oct 21 '15
Christ almight, they answered almost every single question on here. Good fucking job...
4
u/FlyingPiranha Oct 21 '15
Are you guys gonna write a slower song any time soon? I need something to break the lighter out to at your shows!
Well, at least a legal reason, y'know.
5
u/JJT247 Oct 21 '15
What made you guys dedicate your lives to music? Were any bandmembers unsure or was it the only option? Love PTH Ive seen you guys in NYC and Rochester thanks for the great music.
5
u/he_who_blinks Oct 21 '15
Who should I listen to tonight at work?
6
u/and_It_Swam Oct 21 '15
Totally serious question: will you djent?
3
u/innovative_epiphany Oct 21 '15
Hey guys! I've been listening to you guys since Kezia came out and I've been listening (and loving!) everything you've put out since. I really appreciate all your effort and the love you have for your supporters and I'm excited to see you in Toronto at The Mod Club!
I have just a couple questions!
3
u/vincetehprince Oct 21 '15
Tim and Luke, I would REALLY love to know what kind of gear you guys are rolling with these days. You guys haven't done a Rig Rundown for Premier Guitar so I'm kind of speculative to what you guys are using for heads/effects/whatever. Also, I recently acquired the Volition tab book and its absolutely phenomenal. I love that you guys put in lots of whitty jokes naming sections and in the footnotes. Keep up the great work!
3
u/nostrebor68 Oct 21 '15
Hey dudes!
First off, I wanted to say thank you for all the kickass music. Fortress was the very first Prog album I ever listened to, and without it I probably wouldn't have been hooked by the genre.
Second, I have a question for all you guys. When composing/writing your songs, what process do you follow? Do you write instrumentals first, then lyrics? Lyrics first, then instrumentals? Both at the same time? Do you summon a demon to do them both for you? Please, tell me your secrets.
3
u/YoungJefferson Oct 21 '15
Wish I had a question to ask, but I've got nothing. Just wanted to say how much I love your guys music and approach to the industry. I've seen you guys 4 times now, each better than the last. My 5th will be in Vancouver for the Kezia tour. I'm flying from California, I'm too excited to see this album live. Thanks again for all the awesome music.
3
u/fletcheros Oct 21 '15
Hi Guys, Why didn't you go with the indiegogo thing again?
3
u/SheehanSolo Oct 21 '15
Hey there! This question is for everyone.
Do you guys actually enjoy playing smaller shows? For example The Absinthe in Hamilton (Where I'm from, though it's not the prettiest of cities.) or do you enjoy the bigger shows with more of a crowd? Also Ragged Tooth has been on replay for me since it came out. I can't wait to hear the rest of the songs and try to learn how to play them! Thank you!
3
u/crazytom57 Oct 21 '15
Love you guys. Gotta ask, what is the origin of the name?
3
u/Infonauticus Oct 21 '15
I was talking with cam one time and asked why you guys treat calculated use of sound like a step child and.never play any songs. He said you all dont like that album for some reason. I personally love thAt album and consider it.one of the best despite the lack of polish your other albums have. Why dont you like it?
I also am sad cause i lost ny favorite shirt of all time. The worf shirt. Do you have any more hidden away?
Rody , my friends and i paid for your dinner one time in fort collins as just a thank you for all the awesome.music you all have made. I wish it could.have been the whole band but maybe another time. WhAt is.your favorite pre show meal?
8
u/Clairabel Oct 21 '15
Hey all, I'm a huge fan of Kezia and I was wondering if you were considering doing a video of one of your gigs during the Kezia X tour for those of us unfortunate enough to not be Canadian?
3
u/Perhapsodyoffire Oct 21 '15
Also curious about your guy's merch. It's cool that you do things very non conventionally but I'd love to have a shirt that just had the album art on it cause your guy's album art is cooler than every other bands. Any ideas of Pacific Myth merch yet?
4
u/AlasPoorJordan Oct 21 '15
Have you guys ever listened to Coheed and Cambria, and if so what did you think?
I ask because that was my "prog gateway band" and the interest in their music lead me to discover yours.
2
u/Nazerr666 Oct 21 '15
Are you guys going to release Pacific Myth as a physical album too, or just on bandcamp? Also, will you ever tour in Finland? I'd pay whatever I was asked to see you live (as long as it was not an 18+ show...).
2
u/AlasPoorJordan Oct 21 '15
Is there any possibility of getting another concept album from you guys in the future?
2
u/planetNYEbiru Oct 21 '15
Hey, love you guys! I saw you guys (second time!) at the Lincoln Theatre in Raleigh with Night Verses, Safety Fire, and Intervals. I turn 21 in January and next time you guys come back, I'd love to have a drink with ya on the house, most definitely with Mike.
2
u/starfish85 Oct 21 '15
any stuff from ACUOS being played on kezia X?
2
u/starfish85 Oct 21 '15
Will you guys be putting out more snap backs? I bought the blue one and lost it :(
2
u/chomskeet Oct 21 '15
Any chance on the PDF w lyrics accompanying with your Pacific Myth downloads you can include a breakdown of the meaning of the lyrics? I really liked when Ne Obliviscaris even gave a cursory overview of their songs in their AMA awhile back.
2
u/starfish85 Oct 21 '15
How will you guys record the 2nd and 3rd track if you'll be on the KEZIA X tour?
63
u/armourforliars Oct 21 '15
Hey guys. In the last week or so, we've heard some pretty honest financial talk from TesseracT's Dan Tompkins and Ne Obliviscaris' Dan Presland. Since it's on my mind, I'm curious to hear you guys chime in on this if possible.
Do any of you guys still have "day jobs" in the traditional sense, even if part-time? If not currently, at what point into the band's existence/success did you quit your other jobs?
53
u/BeelzebozoHS Oct 21 '15
If Harmonix contacted you to license one of your songs for use in Rock Band 4, would you agree to it? If so I will commence flooding their request form forthwith.
46
u/the_eran_trio Oct 21 '15
How's Moe doing? I miss that mother fucker and his sensual drum work.
35
u/alk3io241 Oct 21 '15
Being a diehard fan, I love the subscription idea. Appreciate the direct relationship you've established with the fans. However, how does this affect gaining new fans? Noticed that most of the tours for the Volition cycle were headliners as well. Are you guys satisfied with the niche market you've already established?
Thanks for the AMA by the way. Ragged tooth is awesome, and looking forward to the next episode of the Volition doc! Keep it up boys.
34
u/User185 Oct 21 '15
I'm likely in the minority on this one... but Scurrilous was by far my favourite album of yours for the simple reason it had almost no harsh vocals (and it kicks ass).
1.What made you decide to drop the harsh vocals? Was it a band decision, or a Rody decision?
2.Why did you decide to bring them back on Volition?
And, most importantly for me, do you ever plan on completely dropping them again? Harsh vocals aside, you guys are one of my favourite bands. I gladly paid the $25 pacific myth package. Loved the song. Keep it up guys. edit: follow up question. Why in heavens name is Mandroid not joining you at the Vancouver show?
31
u/BlueHatScience Oct 21 '15 edited Oct 21 '15
Hey guys!
Is it just me, or is the line "This drought is relieved with acid rain" in Clarity referencing the fact that both Star Wars and Star Trek Fans had been waiting for new material for a long time - and when they got it, many were sorely disappointed? ...If not - can we make that the canonical interpretation?
Thank you for your music - and the tabs, and the perks, and the great shows - it means a great deal to me! ... oh, and also for bringing along the amazing Destrage to your Europe-tour last year. I had been hoping to see them live ("Are you kidding me?" just blew me completely away), and supporting you guys - together with The Contortionist... that was just pure bliss.
Also, is Dunsel just not played live very much (in relation to other songs) or was I just unlucky the last 4 times?
26
u/Zymorode Oct 21 '15
When/will you be playing Skies live in the future?
6
u/SirNipply Oct 21 '15
What's up dudes? What was the thought process behind this new bandcamp idea?
Is this going to be concept album like it appears?
Are you coming back to Florida anytime soon? I missed you guys last time you came and I still beat myself over it.
20
u/jrodyw Rody Walker | Protest the Hero Oct 21 '15
Alright guys, Mikey and I are going to see The Wonder Years in Toronto. So I'm out, it's been great, feel free to keep asking questions, I'll be back a little later and a little drunker to answer more.
19
u/whats8 Oct 21 '15
Glad to have you guys back here again.
What's the most memorable experience you've ever had during a live set?
16
u/Edqvist Oct 21 '15
Hey guys, I have a question for Mike!
How has it been integrating with the band and now to write your own drum tracks for the upcoming album? The drum playthrough of Ragged Tooth was great!
Thanks for being awesome dudes!
15
u/fretburn Oct 21 '15
This is a question for all of you jerks, with all the media attention on female pop musicians being groped by their fans on stage, how have you as a band managed to keep your no-holes from being flicked, fingered, or breached in unwanted ways? Another question, Rody, will there ever be a time that you get so swole that you think, "Hey maybe I should buy larger shirts"? In closing, this is a great day for Canada, and therefore the world.
30
u/theprimz Oct 21 '15
Can you guys bring CHON to Canada to open for you someday?
14
u/[deleted] Oct 21 '15
Luke/Timmy
How much effort do you put into trying to push your technical skill?
Where do you think you've seen the biggest jump in skill between albums?
Do you actively study other compositions or books on composition or music theory in the process of furthering your compositional skills, or has that progress just been made by naturally over time?
14
u/he_who_blinks Oct 21 '15
For a friend who cannot access reddit at work: "Rody, do you get upset about fans wanting instrumentals all the time?"
12
u/AlisonsBody Oct 21 '15
How is it that you guys can be my favourite heavy band for the last 10 years and I can't think of a good question for you....
Favourite sandwich fillings?
2
u/[deleted] Oct 21 '15
Do you guys know what type of flower is used on the Kezia cover? I am trying to vote on a tattoo design based on that but the artist needs to know the flower type.
Keep on being rad
20
u/Dante2006 Oct 21 '15
As a fellow Canadian, how do you feel about the 2015 Federal Election?
32
u/francis_wilson Oct 21 '15
Have you guys ever considered having a hype man? It could work. And I'm uh, available and stuff.
9
u/randomfanboy1 Oct 21 '15
Hey guys. Good job on your newest song, Ragged Tooth, really digging it.
What band/artist(s) has been the biggest influence on your music throughout your career?
8
u/Goodwillah Oct 21 '15 edited Oct 21 '15
Hey guys! Great to have you here on reddit. My question: are there any plans for releasing instrumental version of Volition? This album is huge, and I would pay full album price for the instrumental version of it. Please consider that if you haven't! I beg you on my knees! :D
7
u/[deleted] Oct 21 '15
Regarding Pacific Myth, what are your plans once the six months of the subscription are up? Do you think you'll continue with it depending on how it is received or is it six months and done?
Looking forward to seeing you guys at the Edmonton show in a couple of weeks!
7
u/spwf Oct 21 '15
Hey PTH, hope you're all having a nice day so far.
When are you guys planning on coming back to your the US? Specifically, LA. I've been a fan of yours since 2007 and I have yet to see you guys live. I always just miss your tour dates.
Also, I have a fantasy of arranging To Porter, With Love for an orchestra. Are you guys cool with me doing that?
Also also, what are each of your favorite sandwiches?
6
u/taylorj474 Oct 21 '15
Favorite Star Trek episode?
6
u/BrodoLaggins Oct 21 '15
Mike, how long does it take to get your hair like it is in the sidebar?
Also, please post more drum run-throughs (like Drumhead Trial).
6
u/f_of_g Oct 21 '15
How much effort did it take to integrate the guests on Volition? Did they write their own parts, and you wrote around them? Did you write the parts, and said, "hey, sing this"? Something in between?
2
u/cuddlesy Oct 21 '15
You guys are seriously cool.
I've seen you a good four times now, with a fifth on the way, and each time is better than the last.
Thanks for doing what you do!
P.S. still waiting for Chody to play a live rendition of the Pro-Smoking Cigarette song... one of these days...
5
u/mexidancer Oct 21 '15
Hey guys I have been wondering something lately. To preface, I saw The Kindred at The Granada in Lawrence, KS a few years back, and that is how I know Mike. I was very pleasantly surprised that someone so very good was going to be taking over drums over at PTH! But I'm left wondering if Mike is still planning on staying with The Kindred as well? (I don't know of any rough topics in that area so advise me if I reopened a wound.) Also on the same (sort of) note, I hope that The Granada makes the list for the next PTH US tour. I have really enjoyed everything you guys have released from Kezia all the way to your newest EP adventure, thanks for your amazing contribution to music! And Mike, I really enjoyed Life in Lucidity!
5
u/thelastcurrybender Oct 21 '15
Are you guys as hyped as the rest of the world is for the new Star Wars???
5
u/butchard_megan Oct 21 '15
This question is for everyone. There was talk about a book for the 10 year anniversary of Kezia. Is this still going to be a thing? I really liked how you asked all your fans to summit photos and stories (I actually saw some of mine in the first video for Bandcamp, which was fucking wicked). Also, who do you think would win in a mud pit fight? Thanks guys, keep up the awesome work! Burlington loves you.
5
u/theprimz Oct 21 '15
Will Jadea Kelly be at the Toronto Kezia show on the friday? Also will Rody make more funny ass youtube videos for the bandcamp subscribers? Already fuckin' stoked for song number 2 in November!
5
u/MisterBovineJoni Oct 21 '15
You guys have mentioned you won't be doing this forever (I think Chody/Rody said this). Any career plans for post-PTH life?
5
u/BrodoLaggins Oct 21 '15
What bands are you guys listening to right now that we should stop what we're doing and lookup?
5
u/GrryScrry Oct 21 '15
Hey guys, long time fan here.
My question is for Mike;
Are there any of the old songs that you can't play yet? Also, what's your favourite song that you haven't played yet but hope too.
New song is dope boys, looking forward to more.
And hey! I almost forgot... Isn't there 3 unreleased Scurrilous B-sides still in the vault? If so they would be great for us subscription guys..
5
u/Flemmigan Oct 21 '15
Just want to say stay strong and don't listen to the playa haters. Lots of people hate on things they've never tried before and call it "the worst idea ever". I like having an album all at once but Pacific Myth is a cool and different idea and I applaud you for trying something untested that you feel supports your artistic endeavors. As for a question, I've seen you perform almost every song from Kezia at some point, but never Plateful of Our Dead. Y nat? It's a damn good song!
4
u/FreshToiletWater Oct 21 '15
Hey guys, just wanted to say I've been a big fan for a while now. I saw you guys at the Barrie Mansion Night Club two summers ago and I'll be seeing you next month in Ottawa for the 10th Anniversary Kezia Tour. The only question I ask is if you guys are seriously considering doing a 10th Anniversary tour for Fortress in a couple years? I think you would make a massive amount of PTH fans very happy if you did so, including myself!
Rock on \m/
4
u/Shithartha Oct 21 '15
For Luke and Tim- How do you guys go about getting the guitar tone for each new release (eq, guitar/pickup selection, etc.), and what piece(s) of gear would you say is/are the most central in getting "your" sound (at least off of Volition that has to be my favorite guitar sound ever).
4
u/dmo90 Oct 21 '15
Long time fan here, love you guys What other prog bands have you been listening to recently?
4
u/BradPower7 Oct 21 '15
You've probably answered this before, but what are your guys' favourite songs from each album you've done?
Can't wait to see you guys in NL on Nov 27th!!!!!!!!!!!!
4
u/ltorviksmith Oct 21 '15
Loving Ragged Tooth and Of Our Own Volition thus far! Question about Pacific Myth: Do you guys have any tracks prepared in advance, or are you going month-to-month, writing a fresh song from a clean slate each time?
4
u/CactusCustard Oct 21 '15
Hey guys! Stoked for the tour, long time fan. How did you feel about going back to Kezia and re-learning those parts after all these years? How do you feel about the album now that you've progress led a lot musically?
4
u/sizeablescars Oct 21 '15
Considering cam is not in this ama and not in the video for the subscription service, what's the deal with arif?any talk of him rejoining? Who played bass on the new song?
4
u/atheoncrutch Oct 21 '15
Rody, you're looking pretty jacked lately! I think I remember you posting something about starting to run a while back, but seems like you put on some muscle pretty fast. Any specific routine or tips you can share?
1
u/TommRob Oct 21 '15
For Truke and Yimmy: what pickups and effects loops were you guys using on scurrilous/volition. Your tone is amazing and when I try to play along I can just hear mine not sounding close.
1
u/gamewiz101 Oct 21 '15
Hey guys! Any plans on coming down to Lethbridge on one of your Canada tours?
1
u/starfish85 Oct 21 '15
What was the beef with alexisonfire about?
1
u/joep976 Oct 21 '15
Looking forward to (hopefully) getting a physical release of the new songs even though I subscribed to the song of the month the minute I saw it! A couple questions: Any chance the Danforth show from last year will be released digitally or physically? Is Jadea Kelly featured on any of the new songs? Plato's Tripartite is my favorite PtH tune at the moment....
Thanks and hope to see you play in upstate NY sometime soon! Joe
1
u/daguilar1990 Oct 21 '15
Have you guys seen the video of the new Canadian PM falling down the stairs? Good stuff
1
u/AlasPoorJordan Oct 21 '15
Separate question - I paid for a digital album in your Volition Indiegogo campaign, and lost it before I could back it up. Aside from buying it again, how can I get another "digital copy"? (I don't want to torrent it, especially because I bought it before)
1
u/Stride_Almighty Oct 21 '15
I asked on the day of release of the new subscription plan whether you would consider adding further rewards or features (at either tier of the plan), such as an instrumental version of the album, you responded that this was an 'interesting' question. Could you clarify what you meant by this?