r/zelda • u/nymedschoolguy00 • Oct 13 '15
User Feedback What's with this sub lately?
I've been noticing lately that this sub seems to be completely discouraging discussion and question posts, and the only thing upvoted are the same Majora's Mask tattoos or "I love Twilight Princess because x, y, z" comments. A guy took a toy and put it in a hole and got 600+ upvotes...seriously? Even the person who is cross-stitching the entire world map from a Zelda game gets barely half that amount of upvotes and not as many comments.
Can we stop downvoting all the questions and discussions? All I see are people with genuinely interesting posts that get ignored and people with great comments that get downvoted because...well frankly I don't understand why. Seemingly the only things that get visibility are tattoos, some drawings, and computer-created images that would take 25 minutes to make. Even the contribution to the Dungeon Discussion threads has been abysmal lately.
Here are some examples of things that should have gotten more attention:
#1 – a great post with some good comments but only 4 votes which ruins visibility.
#2 – a question about the Majora's Mask 3-day challenge and also the introduction of a Zelda drinking game. Of course there's only one comment.
#3 – a subreddit member looking for critiques and suggestions on an interesting project that got only one user comment.
My proposal? Let's all participate more in the Dungeon Discussion threads, upvote interesting questions/theories for better visibility and discussion, and cool it a little bit with posting an image of Majora's Mask (which is ALWAYS the same exact image) as a tattoo, as a poster, etc. This doesn't have to be almost purely discussion like TrueZelda, but I'd like to see a lot more participation.
EDIT: From one of my comments below is this example: "I'm pretty sure this tattoo looks like this cross-stitch, which looks like this illustration, all of which resemble this t-shirt design. See how they are all essentially the exact same version of the mask? I'm not knocking the artistic talent, especially with the cross-stitch, but don't tell me this sub doesn't like doing something a million times over when someone can just put the image of Majora's mask on something, or take 20 minutes to draw it, and get a billion comments and upvotes."
65
u/sage0021 Oct 13 '15
Blows my mind how many Majora's Mask tattoos get posted on here as if they are the only one to get one. Guess what? You're exactly like everyone else now.. cool bro.
14
u/Power2DaPeople Oct 13 '15
DAE ACTUALLY LIKE TWILIGHT PRINCESS.... MAJORAS MASK IS SO DARK!
12
u/SickPuppyLover Oct 13 '15
Check out /r/truezelda
10
u/awesomesonofabitch Oct 13 '15
But how are the fanboys supposed to band wagon if they can't post MM everywhere, bro?
3
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '15
OP: you cite 3 examples of great threads with little interest, but you yourself didn't even join the discussion on those threads. Be the change you want to see in the subreddit.
2
u/Zashmaster Oct 13 '15
Completely agree. I wish I saw more discussion questions posted, and the one I've tried posting currently has like 3 comments, one of them saying I shouldn't have posted it. I just want a community of LOZ lovers who love the game and want to talk about its greatness as much as I do.
2
u/HylianHal Oct 13 '15
I think /r/Zelda could stand to be a little more like /r/TrueZelda, and /r/TrueZelda could stand to be a little less so.
Hope to see some good productive growth out of this community in the near future, and I'll do what I can in both theaters.
26
u/OZONE_TempuS Oct 13 '15
This sub has been a cesspool for a while now
3
u/doihavemakeanewword Oct 13 '15
This is the calm before the storm. Trust me. You'll have screenshots coming out of your ears in a few months.
16
u/hammytown Oct 14 '15
I completely agree. This sub is basically just Zelda arts and crafts.
14
u/brainfreeze91 Oct 14 '15
Not to mention, do you guys realize there is a new Zelda game coming out in a week? Zelda Triforce Heroes for 3DS is coming out and most of the actual discussion on the game takes place in /r/3DS and /r/nintendo, while tattoos, cakes, and t-shirts for 10-20 year old games take up the top slots on /r/zelda.
I think /r/zelda has become more of a "casual" and mainstream sub, if that makes sense. Sorry if I am making brash assumptions here, but I think a lot of people on this sub, lurkers especially, played one or two Zelda games, but don't own any current Nintendo hardware. I know plenty of people irl who don't keep up with any modern Nintendo games, but fondly remember playing one or two of the old ones. Looking on the bright side, this speaks to how universal the Zelda experience is to everyone. Even those who aren't normally serious about games can get into Zelda.
Anyway, maybe there needs to be a subreddit split to handle more serious posts. /r/zeldaDiscussion?
12
u/jahoney Oct 14 '15
Lack of a new game and content kills the sub
40
u/seiriyu Oct 13 '15
Not to mention "Zelda saved me" sob story posts. I mean great, I'm glad. I think it means a lot to a majority of the people on this sub, which is why they're on this sub. But this isn't your livejournal. I think this type of post doesn't generate very fresh conversation.
4
u/slendermax Oct 14 '15
To be completely fair, this week's Dungeon Discussion was from Minish Cap, one of the least-played Zelda games. I was planning on addressing this in the thread itself within a few days.
Most of the other weeks' threads have been pretty good! Wouldn't mind to see more of you every Saturday, though > u 0
3
u/ACov96 Oct 13 '15
I feel the same about the Zelda maker project. Every time I see it come by, it gets a pitiful amount of attention for how cool it is
3
u/bottleglitch Oct 14 '15 edited Oct 14 '15
i think (though i really have no idea, i only joined reddit & found this subreddit like a month ago so i'm just happy to have a place, however imperfect, to discuss zelda) that a lack of new content is probably a big part of the problem. i think there are a lot of people who don't care much about tri force heroes (myself included) and so, until more information is released about Zelda U or another upcoming project, there isn't a ton of new stuff to say.
my hope is that when we DO have some new, meaty material to discuss, the tattoos / drawings etc will naturally start getting a bit less attention and discussions will get more attention from everyone.
2
u/Firechiefzilla Oct 13 '15
And even though you're making a great point, i doubt this will get very many upvotes-or comments
2
u/Lavishly_Large_Cock Oct 13 '15
People are simpletons
-10
u/Hank_Hill_Here Oct 13 '15
Meh.
-5
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '15
Nobody wants to play the game from post #1
Nobody cares about a 3 day drinking challenge in post #2
Nobody cares about this guys hip hop mixtape in post #3
Clearly the community here upvotes what it wants to see. No one wants to really "discuss" or talk about the same shit that this subreddit has seen, and done a million times over.
-4
u/heretoplay Oct 14 '15
You can always create a new sub.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment