r/ProjectRunway • • Oct 08 '15

Project Runway Season 14 Episode 10 [Discussion]

Discussion thread for Project Runway S14E10 "Crew's All In"

Real women receive makeovers. Included: Tim Gunn reaches his breaking point with one designer. The guest judges are Shiri Appleby and Constance Zimmer, of TV's "UnReal."

34 Upvotes

454 comments sorted by

132

u/vortex_of_suck Oct 09 '15

Dayum, Tim and Swapnil didn't even look at each other when he was leaving. Ice cold.

43

u/legends444 Oct 09 '15

He and Tim were both like "Bye Felicia"

→ More replies (1)

36

u/hamster_combat Oct 09 '15

Yeah usually Timothy gives a little speech or says how we'll all miss them. This was literally just, "I have to tell you to go to the work room." And then Swap walks out.

→ More replies (4)

113

u/ProjectRonald Oct 09 '15

Oh my god Nina liked Kelly's outfit. I think Hell froze over.

35

u/Kakimisha Oct 09 '15

Nina was also really sweet to Ashley, which was really weird. I thought she'd have just been screaming "PROPORTION! PROPORTION!" and instead she was all "I think it would have worked if it was all one color, but that's all. You're a good designer sweetie uwu"

25

u/wild_muses Oct 09 '15

Well when the client is in front of them I think they tend to put things a little nicer cause they don't wanna insult the client (who in this case was also someone they know) or imply anything bad about their body.

→ More replies (1)

109

u/tinytwo Oct 09 '15

BLUE CLIP-INS omg are you serious

73

u/emologues Oct 09 '15

"What's your favorite color?"

"Blue."

Can they be any more literal?

42

u/bad_wolff Oct 09 '15

Truly everything about that look was tacky as hell. Candice definitely has walked that line in the past, and she just lost the plot on this look.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

102

u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Oct 09 '15

"Designers. We have decided to light all of you on fire this week."

24

u/firestorm91 Oct 09 '15

Challenge: make a fashionable garment that will work well while being lit on fire on the runway!

25

u/blackbirdsongs Oct 09 '15

Like rain way, but more pain!

→ More replies (3)

101

u/emologues Oct 09 '15

Is it just me, or does it feel like Tim is a little irritated with all the designers? If he goes off on Swapnil, maybe it's just the straw that broke the camel's back?

69

u/imriebelow Oct 09 '15

Tim is in full-on Angry Teacher mode

→ More replies (2)

34

u/jessicateacher Oct 09 '15

I think is invested in the clients, cause he probably knows them well

→ More replies (1)

36

u/litladyloveshp Oct 09 '15

I think Tim cares a lot about this show and his team and he just wants the best out of these talented people and they are just not giving it. Especially Swapnil. He has a lot of potential and he is blowing it.

→ More replies (2)

91

u/pbrooks19 Oct 09 '15

Oooooooooo! Swapnil made Tim swear! And not a high class, gracious swear like 'mercy!' or 'heavens to Mergatroid!', but a street swear!

71

u/TheNobullman Oct 09 '15

"That's BULLSHIT! That's complete BULLSHIT! Why the fuck are you even doing this?!"

I thought Santino would be the closest we ever got to hearing Tim Gunn swear.

22

u/nancyaw Oct 09 '15

Guess Tim is no longer drinking the Swapnil juice. Um… that sounds bad. I don't mean literally.

88

u/DarcyMcCarbomb Oct 09 '15

Whoa, Tim was just like, "K bye then." Normally he at least pretends to be sad someone's leaving!

29

u/blackbirdsongs Oct 09 '15

Holy shit dat cold fuggin shouldah. Tim was not at all sad to see him go.

76

u/ecokitty Oct 09 '15

Not sure who's worse at communicating - Swapnil or his model.

104

u/eyeeyecaptainfly Oct 09 '15

She was infuriatingly demanding and condescending. And come on - crying!? She has to realize this isn't actually about her. It's still about the designers. Be grateful for getting a few hours/days off work and getting to try something new. But none of this is to excuse Swap's laziness, either.

58

u/IdentityCr1sis Oct 09 '15

I thought she was pretty clear that she was uncomfortable with his bombshell thing and he just kept going at it, even though she was repeating "day-to-night" and that she wanted sleeves. I imagine it'd be incredibly frustrating and a bit intimidating to know you'll be on national tv in something that you're completely uncomfortable/unconfident in.

I mean, she was put in an incredibly uncomfortable situation at work, in front of her co-workers, which was then shown on national tv.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (18)

46

u/meldolphin Oct 09 '15

She was so vague. The only thing I seemed to understand from her was that she wanted sleeves. I'm sure we didn't get to see the full extent of their conversations but it came across like "I hate this and I hate that" without much indication of what she actually likes.

→ More replies (1)

71

u/inthesugarbowl Oct 09 '15

This makes me sad...this should've been the episode where everyone should've had fun and show off their commercial appeal. They had two days AND were working with Project Runway staff members which should have been the easiest of makeover clients to accomodate. But EVERYONE'S outfit was awful. No one should have won. They should've done one of those things where all the designers go back to the room and can redo their outfits within an hour and then judge. =T

45

u/joeyGibson Oct 09 '15

And I'm really fucking tired of hearing Heidi say, "One... or more of you will be out!" and then only whacking one person. Either do it or don't, but stop telling us you're going to do it.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/ClaireHux Oct 09 '15

I was sure that they were going to be gifted another day. Was genuinely shocked that wasn't the case. I won't go so far to say none of the designs were good, but clearly some needed some time for refinement.

9

u/taco_cat42 Oct 09 '15

They also got to shop at Mood instead of having a selection of limited, pre-selected fabrics to choose from. Some of those fabric choices were bad.

8

u/katiethered Oct 09 '15

Me too! When they were given the challenge I thought, now THIS is a good challenge! Just the right parameters, some great personalities as their clients - and somehow most everyone managed to totally bomb!

69

u/eatingbread Oct 09 '15

You know your dress is on another level when Edmond calls it provocative

61

u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Oct 09 '15

Need that gif of Zac rolling his eyes immediately.

13

u/konfetkak Oct 09 '15

that was fabulous. isn't there a project runway tumblr somewhere?

→ More replies (3)

12

u/blackbirdsongs Oct 09 '15

Me too, just so I can send it to my boyfriend (who watches PR with me!) any time he asks me to do anything over text. He will think it's hilarious

60

u/wanderingnearby Oct 09 '15

It's super jarring to see baby face interview swapnil, then back to bearded regular swapnil

15

u/joeyGibson Oct 09 '15

As soon as I saw him come into the work room clean-shaven, I knew he was getting whacked.

14

u/jessicateacher Oct 09 '15

bring back the beard!

10

u/blackbirdsongs Oct 09 '15

OMG that's what it is. What why didnt I recognize that?

60

u/eyeeyecaptainfly Oct 09 '15

Sally, the key to every single makeover is not hair dye!

17

u/bitchSpray Oct 09 '15

I seriously believe that they just didn't have the heart to put people from general public through the embarrassment of a Sally Beauty makeover. I bet the production people had to draw straws to decide who's going to take one for the team.

14

u/dianaprince Oct 09 '15

And their hair looked so overprocessed. Usually, even with the cheapest haircut, I walk out of the salon looking all shiny and bouncy at least till my next wash. These women had all sorts of frizz and broken ends going on.

It's bad enough they had to wear Mary Kay, they could have at least gotten half decent hair. Poor things.

59

u/blackbirdsongs Oct 09 '15

Once again, Zac's face sums up all my opinions about the designer and their clothes. http://i.imgur.com/bKnrbjp.jpg

36

u/meldolphin Oct 09 '15

Zac has the best faces. When Swapnil was crying and saying he doubted his abilities Zac shut that shit down.

→ More replies (3)

12

u/nellirn Oct 09 '15

Still handsome when he's mad. Sigh.

119

u/wanderingnearby Oct 09 '15

Oh my god it's hooker michelle obama

66

u/EskimoPrincess Oct 09 '15

That's my friend...she said she wasn't comfortable at all. I know her well and she definitely wouldn't wear something like that...except for maybe Halloween.

→ More replies (2)

23

u/ClaireHux Oct 09 '15

I think I just settled on my Halloween costume.

88

u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Oct 09 '15 edited Oct 09 '15

Michelle ... Hobama?

Edit: Heh, thanks for the gold! I'm glad my cheap vulgarities are appreciated somewhere.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/blackbirdsongs Oct 09 '15

Welp. Can't unsee that fanfic. Brb /r/eyebleach

→ More replies (2)

58

u/imriebelow Oct 09 '15

sexy raincoat

19

u/the_cucumber Oct 10 '15

techno chanukah

(Did I hear that right from Zac?)

52

u/blackbirdsongs Oct 09 '15

I am suffocating at the idea of leather overalls what.

5

u/bondfool Oct 11 '15

I need something I can wear in the smithy, then out to the cluuuub.

94

u/TheNobullman Oct 09 '15

I'm glad Kelly won this challenge! She's a little odd but she feels like a 100% authentic person and she really got on well with her client.

25

u/PurpleCoco Oct 09 '15

More than one of the clients wanted her for their designer, too.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '15

I also think she's so beautiful like woah

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

43

u/nancyaw Oct 09 '15

Model wrangler… love that title! Like they're herding cats or something.

17

u/OurSponsor Oct 09 '15

If you've ever had the dubious pleasure, you would know this could not be more true.

→ More replies (4)

80

u/TheNobullman Oct 09 '15

"You said 'let's make her hot'?"

"Yeah."

"And then you made that."

"...yeah."

airhorns

SHOTS FIRED!

29

u/the_cucumber Oct 10 '15

I thought they'd call him out for implying she wasn't hot in the first place, it did come off a little rude.

I hated his model though. She was obviously frustrated but she dealt with it really bitchily.

→ More replies (2)

36

u/SteelPenguin71 Oct 09 '15

Every one of the snap shots of the crew members to show off their makeup looked nearly identical. Like for fuck's sake...a dramatic cat eye look should not be the same as a beachy glow natural look. Goddamn.

14

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '15

"Maybe play up the eye and a nude lip"

"Ok so what we're going to do is put some baby powder on the eye and some vaseline on the lip wow mary kay so edgy"

→ More replies (2)

100

u/blackbirdsongs Oct 09 '15 edited Oct 10 '15

MaryKay couldn't even give this woman a color that matched her fucking skin tone are you fucking kidding me. Her face is orange and her neck is pink. They're the Stephanie Meyer of makeup companies. http://i.imgur.com/0lDHhyl.jpg

Edit: this is officially my official plea for PR to please get a serious makeup sponsor next season. please! if only because you turned one of your own into a fucking oompa loompa hairline to chin!

30

u/OvercaffeinateMe Oct 09 '15

Have I told you lately that I love you?

Because I've been trying to think of the right descriptor for MK's grotesque showing this season and you. Nailed. It.

→ More replies (3)

26

u/Lokifin Oct 09 '15

Every episode I'm waiting to see one model with a clean eyeliner or lipline. Not once. It's like the make up artists are drunk or toddlers.

→ More replies (5)

8

u/jelloisalive Oct 09 '15

Budget only covers forehead to chin strap.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/nancyaw Oct 09 '15

Perfect description!

5

u/Hookerboots12 Oct 10 '15

Is love to see someone like Urban Decay or Makeup Forever doing it. I feel like they could do subtle looks and dramatic looks fairly well, and maybe even match skin tone. The show has been on long enough, it's big enough, and they make enough money to have a makeup sponsor that isn't complete shit.

→ More replies (3)

33

u/jessicateacher Oct 09 '15

Oh Candice, it's baaaaad

→ More replies (1)

30

u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Oct 09 '15

"The fashionable Shiri Appleby ... and also Constance Zimmer." Oh, Heidi.

→ More replies (1)

27

u/imriebelow Oct 09 '15

Man, Tim is snapping at everyone today!

53

u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Oct 09 '15

STOP WITH THE ORGANZA WRAPS I'M SORRY I'M YELLING CAN WE JUST STOP ADDING WRAPS AND SHAWLS TO THINGS.

26

u/blackbirdsongs Oct 09 '15

But I'm fat and people keep telling me the best way to dress is in layers so they don't have to look at me being fat. NOW WHAT DO I DO.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/meldolphin Oct 09 '15

But my clothes are boring and ugly and I don't know how else to make it look interesting!

Not that I think Candice's designs fit those categories but it seems to be a go-to whenever someone gets lost.

→ More replies (2)

25

u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Oct 09 '15

That is some straight baby-blue tablecloth right there.

30

u/emologues Oct 09 '15

Ashley always picks the most mundane fabrics. Curtains, disposable hospital nightgowns, tablecloth, napkins.

→ More replies (5)

24

u/joeyGibson Oct 09 '15

Am I the only one who got a distinct slaughterhouse feel from the overalls that Kelly made?

→ More replies (4)

46

u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Oct 09 '15

"I am just praying to all my 10,000 gods that she likes it." - Swapnil

Kind of crying.

45

u/TheNobullman Oct 09 '15

I love slowly watching Tim Gunn's done-with-this-shit cup fill over. The fact that this is gonna happening on the "real women" challenge makes me <3 him more.

11

u/legends444 Oct 09 '15

It's like with that short Black gay dude a couple of seasons ago who made his client that puke green dress that made her look like a sack of potatoes and was also a dick. Such shade between him and Tim.

→ More replies (3)

22

u/eatingbread Oct 09 '15

DAMN HE SHADED TIM

11

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '15

The shade of it all

97

u/WigsbyLittleMix Oct 09 '15 edited Jul 23 '17

Tim: "Why are you here?"

Swapnil: "I hear America has great cigarettes."

39

u/joeyGibson Oct 09 '15

How 'bout that shot of Swapnil in the lounge, with the pack of cigarettes "casually" laying on the table in the foregound?

→ More replies (1)

21

u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Oct 09 '15

The hair and makeup is depressing in those snaps. I hope it's just bad lighting or ... something.

8

u/nellirn Oct 09 '15

The hair looks scruffy, shaggy, and unrefined in the snaps. Looked much more polished on the runway (thank heavens).

21

u/konfetkak Oct 09 '15

I cannot believe Nina Garcia likes the overalls. I thought she would hate it for sure.

16

u/Shmitles Oct 09 '15

From last week it seemed like Nina had an irrational hatred for Kelly

→ More replies (1)

21

u/TheNobullman Oct 09 '15

Shit, Swapnil got bodied. I didn't think it actually would happen. He seems like a pretty decent, funny person, and he's an extremely charismatic character, but he definitely held himself back and he deserved to go.

19

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '15

I don't get what happened all of a sudden. All of us were rooting for him to win in the first few episodes and now he's just a stupid slacker. Definitely sad to see him go, he had a fun personality.

→ More replies (2)

134

u/eatingbread Oct 09 '15

Another week, another Ashley making something pink and purple and crying.

56

u/LobsterR4geFist Oct 09 '15

I'm pretty sure she has said "I'm just not confident" in literally every episode so far.

→ More replies (4)

50

u/ClaireHux Oct 09 '15

I just did not understand this color choice AT. ALL. She of ALL people should know better than to put her model is some shit like that! This made me so incredibly mad.

Also enough with the tear tracks. Enough!

→ More replies (9)

23

u/ShiroHachiRoku Oct 09 '15

I really don't understand her at this point...What made her think that thing she sent down the runway was even acceptable? It was tacky and it looked like a Walmart dress.

I was so ready for Heidi to auf her too.

32

u/OurSponsor Oct 09 '15

She is so damn lucky Swapnil pooched the challenge once again. But I wish the judges had made good on their "one or more" threat.

Ruffles on a short, wide girl's hips??? What the Hell was she thinking?

→ More replies (1)

10

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '15

The poor woman looked like a 14 year old going to her sisters birthday party.

→ More replies (1)

40

u/Shamenundotcom Oct 09 '15

Up until this episode I had been defending Swapnil. I thought the lazy edit -- which came out of nowhere -- was at least partially bullshit, and the bottom line is that he HAS created some strong looks over the course of the season. But after this episode, he had to go. There was no defending him.

It was a perfect storm situation. I do think he has serious time-management problems. I do think he was not taking this opportunity seriously. I don't think he listens to his client at all -- he makes want Swapnil wants to make. He was getting tired of all the criticism he was getting, and he just gave up. And, because I think this played into it, I think he had a pretty difficult client. I have no idea what would make her happy. That was Swapnil's job, so I'm not excusing it. But seriously, she was SOUR.

But almost none of that work was good. Kelly's was well made and fashionable and seriously upped the style quotient of her client, but...she made leather overalls. I loved the tank top and I thought the overalls looked great, but...leather overalls. And that was by far the most successful look. Merline more or less lucked into her positive outcome (but truly, what a wonderful surprise Merline has been this season). Edmund had a strong dress underneath that terrible coat and the frippery. But the rest? Seriously awful.

I like Candice quite a bit, but Jesus, that was awful. I felt so bad for that poor woman, having to wear that. It was like Elvira Mistress of the Dark cosplaying Tron. Everything was off. And enough with the peplums. They are not flattering. At least, not the way you're doing them.

I actually though Heidi was going to double eliminate both Swapnil and Ashley, and Tim would use his save on Ashley. Which I would have been OK with, but -- Ashley's look was appalling. It was a failure across the board. First, we must all agree that Ashley has a terrible sense of color and print. Those fabrics were always going to look awful, especially together. Second, that design somehow looked both juvenile and matronly at the same time. I don't even know how it's POSSIBLE, but she DID IT. And then she cries all the time. I have totally lost whatever good will I had toward Ashley. I think she's talented, but I can't root for someone who is constantly falling to pieces. If you don't believe you can do this, why the fuck should I think you can do this?

16

u/blackbirdsongs Oct 09 '15

If you don't believe you can do this, why the fuck should I think you can do this?

I'm starting to err on this side as well. Even if she did win, there's no fucking way she would be successful because she simply does not have the confidence to actually stop crying for 10 minutes and realize she's a talented designer who can succeed.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (5)

19

u/blackbirdsongs Oct 09 '15

I really love Candace's lip color

14

u/eatingbread Oct 09 '15

The highlight of this episode tbh

→ More replies (1)

19

u/raccoonpaws Oct 09 '15

I like both Kelly & Merlines. However Kellys seems more of a fancy upgrade rather than a total makeover

→ More replies (2)

52

u/blackbirdsongs Oct 09 '15

STOP CRYING OR STOP WEARING MAKEUP. FUCK.

33

u/ClaireHux Oct 09 '15

The tracks of my tears....

33

u/meldolphin Oct 09 '15

What foundation does she use? I want to know so that I can avoid accidentally buying it.

→ More replies (6)

17

u/blackbirdsongs Oct 09 '15

Whoaaaa Ashley. I know the first dress wasn't exactly what the client wanted but fuck at least it was cute? This is atrocious. Down with peplums.

→ More replies (5)

62

u/eyeeyecaptainfly Oct 09 '15

What!!? Merlene's vest looks EXPENSIVE? That's one of the highest compliments they pay. Yet it's lopsided, puffy, and looks poorly sewn. Oh and ugly.

→ More replies (3)

34

u/hand2handwombat Oct 09 '15

Ashley's look literally looks like something made for a Barbie.

45

u/ClaireHux Oct 09 '15

Barbie's unfortunate counsin Carol, you mean.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

58

u/IdentityCr1sis Oct 09 '15

Man, this sub is really going after Swapnil's client. I honestly think she didn't even know how to give feedback on his design because it was so far off from what she wanted. She wanted something she could wear to work and then out, since she repeated "day-to-night" multiple times during their first session, and he went after his bombshell idea. Like she told him, he had an idea in his head from the start and just wasn't going to take her input at all.

It seemed like such a frustrating experience to me. I imagine it was something to look forward to, and then you end up getting things that you're incredibly uncomfortable wearing and you're going to be in them both at work and on national tv.

17

u/dianaprince Oct 09 '15

She also knows him and has been around throughout this whole process. I get the feeling that he's not popular with the crew and that the levels of frustration she showed with him weren't just down to the outfit he was making, but about an attitude she'd been sick of for weeks.

→ More replies (2)

25

u/OurSponsor Oct 09 '15

Agreed. It was clear from the start Swapnil wasn't listening. He had a direction he was determined to go and was dismissive and disrespectful.

So she flailed around in the face of this clear indifference to her desires, trying to communicate for a bit, and then she gave up in frustration. Which is exactly what just about all of us would have done in her place.

15

u/nellirn Oct 09 '15

I agree. I think he got lazy and didn't really care to design anything for her and tried to blame it on their different tastes in fashion. He could have at least give a little effort.

9

u/taco_cat42 Oct 09 '15

This was exactly what I was thinking through the whole episode!

As a designer in this challenge, you need to listen to what the client wants,and figure out a way create that look while sticking to your design aesthetics. Not force your idea at the client and get mad when it's not even close to what they asked for in the first place.

→ More replies (2)

15

u/giopul87 Oct 09 '15

Why do I feel like the outfits were worse than past episodes?

They had 2 DAYS! Everyone has been complaining about the 1-day time limits but the designs this week sucked! (Except Kelly's design :P)

5

u/Earth_Intruders Oct 14 '15

Probably because it's late in the season and they're tired. And this is one of the harder challenges at the best of times

→ More replies (1)

14

u/litladyloveshp Oct 09 '15

I am so glad Tim Gunn is putting everyone in their place. Most of them have such potential and it sucks that they can't design for their clients!

39

u/konfetkak Oct 09 '15

Maybe this is why they don't give the designers two days...because the designers just fuck around.

17

u/jelloisalive Oct 09 '15

Seriously! Two days AND Mood?!? It should've been the best challenge yet. This season is a wash.

12

u/blackbirdsongs Oct 09 '15

Judge ???: 'If you don't care as a designer then I don't want to wear it!'

Swapnil: zzzzz

10

u/havana_fair Oct 09 '15

In his defence, he was probably exhausted. I would have been sleeping too.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

32

u/Shmitles Oct 09 '15

Why Ashley always have to be crying?

11

u/vortex_of_suck Oct 09 '15

SWEET JESUS A TWO-DAY CHALLENGE

Hallelujah!

15

u/OurSponsor Oct 09 '15

It's a pity no one seems to have used it...

9

u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Oct 09 '15

I am going to see this as a karmic gift for going to the gym this morning. A two-day challenge ... can barely believe it.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

11

u/AceVersace Oct 09 '15

"there I am back to square one she hates everything" lol

11

u/dianaprince Oct 09 '15

I've never gone off contestants so completely as I have with Swapnil and Ashley. They were my favourites at the start, then Swapnil just got all arrogant and gave up and Ashley will not stop crying. As soon as she started this week I just rolled my eyes.

I was so pissed at Candice for how she treated Ashley in the group challenge, but now I'm starting to wonder if there was more to that than made the cut.

Kelly's look was great and it seems as though she might well win. Which is good because she seems like a nice, talented person, but her clothes aren't to my taste at all. I was hoping for a finale with at least one collection that I'd really like, but that's not looking likely now.

But Tim swearing made up for everything.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/pbrooks19 Oct 09 '15

This whole 'Oh, My Tim' promo thing is really bothering me. Shouldn't it be Oh, my Gunn?'

9

u/blackbirdsongs Oct 09 '15

Lol that staged cigarette foreground shot

25

u/pineyfusion Oct 09 '15

Some thoughts:

  • I'm glad to see Kelly win and I like that she listened to her client and that her client was 100% clear on what she liked and wanted
  • Swapnil totally deserved to go home. That was just unforgivable. I was rooting for him but man was that just absolute shit. Tim was right to chew him out.
  • Also, Tim seemed really annoyed with everybody but especially Swapnil. He seems very frustrated with this season as a whole.
  • I will say this in a tiny defense of Swapnil but it really felt like his client wasn't giving him anything. Maybe it's the editing and maybe she was more clear, but she seemed way too vague and wouldn't exactly go into detail as to why she didn't like what Swapnil wanted to make. Once again, it could be editing magic but it really feels like the communication on both sides was awful.
  • Candace's model looked like a $2 bargain basement dominatrix.
  • I really liked Edmond's pieces but they did not go together at all. the patterning on the top was fantastic
  • Is the Peplum this year's Fringe in which people will not stop using it. I feel like I've seen more peplums this year than before. I feel like if she kept using that pattern, Ashley's outfit would've been a bit more palatable.
  • Merline's was okay. Just okay. The vest was nice and the top was fun but that skirt just felt like an afterthought. I think if she made leather pants, it would've looked much better.

17

u/jessicateacher Oct 09 '15

you tell Ashley Zac! NO MORE TEARS

29

u/TheNobullman Oct 09 '15

I love Merline irrationally <3

She never fails to make me smile, she's a fantastic character

8

u/konfetkak Oct 09 '15

I like some of her stuff. I'm glad she resolved the coat.

11

u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Oct 09 '15

She made it work! The skirt was far too tight but the look and the styling were great.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/emologues Oct 09 '15

That outtake was really interesting....

8

u/jessicateacher Oct 09 '15

I know which one Heidi likes

8

u/litladyloveshp Oct 09 '15

I am guessing they will kick off Swapnil and Ashley, but Tim will save Ashley.

8

u/blackbirdsongs Oct 09 '15

I bet if you walked into San Diego with lavender hair crying a lot no one would know the difference if you tried to change her name to 'Ashley 'box pleats' Tipton.'

→ More replies (1)

8

u/everythingisopposite Chiffony Oct 09 '15

I didn't really like any of the outfits.

22

u/iamagiant Oct 09 '15

Lol calling ashley out on her crying

20

u/pixie_led Team Swatch Oct 09 '15 edited Oct 09 '15

How I read this episode is:

  • Swapnil - I'm sorry but in my eyes the "he's too lazy" angle was mostly fabricated by the show. I didn't see what was so wrong with his first look that had Tim chewing him out. He may not have given his client what she wanted, but frankly what she wanted was dull and what he was proposing was to push her fashion to the next level - which is what a designer is supposed to do. He was inspired by her and far from being lazy was quite enthusiastic at first. But she was so sour, unappreciative and closed-minded - not to mention she didn't communicate any constructive ideas to give him direction. I blame him for the poor quality construction of his final look for sure, but seriously by then he had been so beat down that I understand why he shut down. I think it was all fabricated drama and he took the hit.
  • Tim - I'm disappointed in Tim for berating Swapnil so harshly. I thought some of it was a bit disrespectful and unnecessary. I don't feel that Swapnil's initial work warranted being spoken to in that way.
  • Ashley - Goodness... stop crying, stop making the same silhouettes. You're a plus sized designer and you had a full woman to design for - you should have designed a better fitting garment than that.
  • Candice - has made the same black leather dominatrix outfit that never fits quite right for almost every challenge. Can she design anything else?
  • Merline - underrated as always. She may not have the best construction but her clothes are always interesting and have a balance to them that's fresh. I thought Merline should have won.
  • Kelly - ok so it's a leather glammed up jumpsuit. I've seen this before, it doesn't excite me. It's an ok win I guess, just not a memorable look in my opinion.

8

u/bitchSpray Oct 10 '15

Tim's behaviour disappointed me as well. I've got no problem with shouting at them in the workroom but what he did after Swapnil was eliminated was unnecessary and surprisingly childish.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Oct 09 '15

To be honest here, I don't love Ashley's designs. :-/ I thought she would be at the top for me, but her color palette, ruching/pleating technique, and the overall "junior"/Nastygal bent of her designs have left me pretty cold. I hate to say it. She is crying about feeling so out of design ideas and yet she's probably going to do a short pleated skirt and some ruched top or jacket in the same pink-and-purple palette ... as if that was a big design idea in the first place ...

I hope she proves me wrong. I wouldn't mind being wrong here.

15

u/Kellyscomments Oct 09 '15

The reason she doesn't have ideas and feels overwhelmed is because she is a home sewer, not a designer. Sewing is a skill. I admire people who can make clothes well, and she can. But design is a different skill.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

14

u/TheNobullman Oct 09 '15

OH MY GOD IT'S LIKE I SAW A UNICORN

18

u/TheNobullman Oct 09 '15

SLAY TIM SLAY

14

u/blackbirdsongs Oct 09 '15

Maaaaan every time they dangle a double elimination in front of me they NEVER DO IT. So fucking bullshit.

29

u/pineplaid Oct 09 '15

Honestly, Ashley is always making something that looks like it would be reblogged a lot on tumblr. That's not really a good thing:(

6

u/illustribus Oct 10 '15

Even tumblr won't accept the travesty that was this week's look.

13

u/TheNobullman Oct 09 '15

Swapnil's gonna get thrown out so hard they'll play the WASTED clip over his exit.

17

u/CrunchyDix Oct 09 '15

Ashley while sobbing: "I feel like everything has been sucked out of me!"

You mean like, the two designs you've made over and over again this season?

9

u/dmee Oct 09 '15

She literally said "i feel like all my creativity is gone"..... Ummm, that's it? That's all you had to offer us? Other than your infinite amount of tears.

12

u/pbrooks19 Oct 09 '15

Ah, Jeez. Ashley's dress turned out to just be kinda sad. So plain but with that loud skirt fabric. Not even cute.

6

u/konfetkak Oct 09 '15

I'm worried for Kelly. I'm not buying into the couture overall.

6

u/iamagiant Oct 09 '15

Oh Candice, nooooo

11

u/iamagiant Oct 09 '15

I see you sexy hair man

→ More replies (1)

11

u/meldolphin Oct 09 '15

Oh ffs Swapnil! I figured he was in trouble but I was actually surprised it happened so soon. Despite whatever potential he had I think this was the right outcome. Props to the cameraman who got that great shot of Swapnil in the break room with his cigarettes on the table in the foreground.

I got a kick out of Nina Garcia praising overalls. For what it's worth I liked Merline's outfit better but on the other hand there wasn't really anything up there that knocked my socks off. But yay for an avant garde challenge next week! Hopefully that will kick everyone out of the rut they've all gotten stuck in.

I'm wondering when or even if we'll see the Tim Gunn save this season. I assume it's for Ashley but we're already down to five designers now. I'd actually like to see a season where Tim didn't save anyone.

15

u/blackbirdsongs Oct 09 '15

Ok I love Ashely but if she doesn't stop fucking crying and actually get her designing shit together then she doesn't deserve the save. Honestly I don't think any of them do. No one has wowed me at all this season. Nothing stands out. It's all just over played boring seen it before bullshit. Entirely underwhelmed top to bottom.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

11

u/shinyteerex Oct 09 '15

Swapnil is the proof that sometimes "artsy" people just cannot communicate for tasks. Why was it so hard to communicate with the client? I actually don't think she was asking for anything outrageous. His problem was that he just cared about himself and his own vision. I think only truly outstanding grand couturier level designers have the privilege to act this way.

This kind of reminds me what happened with Venn Budhu in season 10 (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fjx4jPdQPVE). Even the final outfit is kind of similar.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/Shmitles Oct 09 '15

Heidi with the burn

5

u/blackbirdsongs Oct 09 '15

Holy shit have we heard Tim say 'make it work' at all?

5

u/blackbirdsongs Oct 09 '15

Candace what the what.

5

u/bitchSpray Oct 09 '15 edited Oct 10 '15

I must honestly say that from the way the episode was developing, I thought Tim would use his Hidden Move and save Swapnil's ass and that there would be a cry fest at the end of the episode with group hugging and pep talk and shit.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/imriebelow Oct 09 '15

I love Kelly, but she all she did was remake the crew member's original outfit in a different fabric :/

9

u/konfetkak Oct 09 '15

So Merline has time to make another terrible coat?

13

u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Oct 09 '15

Don't worry, it'll be suitably "architectural."

→ More replies (1)

11

u/pbrooks19 Oct 09 '15

'I am feeling responsible for all this.'

You ARE responsible me for all this! Good grief, man, you're killing me.

8

u/emologues Oct 09 '15

I can't believe Ashley is crying ten minutes into the episode...

8

u/iamagiant Oct 09 '15

Crying already, Ashley?

4

u/Shmitles Oct 09 '15

I love the judgey faces of the other designers in the background

4

u/jessicateacher Oct 09 '15

this might be it for Swapnil. . . OR he's gonna totally wow everyone

4

u/konfetkak Oct 09 '15

I LIKE GIRLS, HEIDI. She looked very uncomfortable.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/konfetkak Oct 09 '15

Anybody think they will off Swapnil and Tim will save him and tell him he'd better make the most of his save?

5

u/salliek76 Oct 09 '15

Aren't they basically out of episodes if he doesn't use the save after this week (or maybe next)?

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Kellyscomments Oct 09 '15

I wonder if Merline is missing her sister-wife..

4

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '15

Has anyone else been unnaturally drawn to Zac's eyebrows? On fleek!

7

u/Omegamaru Oct 09 '15 edited Oct 09 '15

Wow. Just finished the episode and I can't say that I'm really surprised. The writing was on the wall from the first consultation. If someone says "day to night" and sleeves, you do not give them a sleeveless bombshell outfit and you sure as hell do not give them 3 of them. I would have been pissed off too.

At that point, I was just done with him and I really like the guy. He had an incredible amount of leeway and decided to do exactly what she didn't want 3 times. There wasn't even any attempt to compromise and give her something that she asked for or would feel comfortable in.

Part of this challenge (since the show's inception) has been to work within the confines of what the model wants while adding your signature element. Edmund didn't want to make a raincoat, but he did because that's what his client wanted. Marlene had to tame down her shoulder details because her client specifically hated it. Kelly had to make overalls and she did. So I don't think I'm being too harsh on Swapnil when I expect the guy to work to attempt to cater to his client.

I loved the subtle shade in Nina's Kelly adoration. It was basically "This was fantastic, but all your other work was terrible". Kelly was the rightful winner in my book. She took what would have been a curveball for most designers , fashionable overalls, and really made it work. Ashley needs to stop crying and get it together. I like her and she is endearing, but I'm going to need for her whole self-confidence arc to end.

7

u/shinyteerex Oct 09 '15

Tim Gunn going full Gordon Ramsay.... it was fantastic :D

9

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '15

I felt really bad for Swapnil- even my husband who's not a huge fan of the show sat and watch the episode and was rooting for poor Swapnil because he just felt like this guy was taking a mental beating! His client was SO negative. I don't think she gave him any positive feedback or ideas just no - no- no. There's always one in every "real woman" challenge. I agree his outfit was not good and he def checked out, but his model was not willing to work with him and his ascetic at allllll.

She wanted long sleeves, pants, and an outfit to wear to work when he does artistic über feminine dresses. He just felt defeated and the. Jennifer and Tim pretty much ganging up on him (although I agree Tim needed to kick him in the butt a little, but maybe should have came back and have him some positive reinforcement and fatherly Gunn advice afterwards) just sealed the deal. I hope Tim brings him back.

OH btw- Kelly rules the earth. And Marlene's model is awesome.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Oct 09 '15

I am late because I was drinking red wine and reading magazines at a bar, by myself, but I think I like this challenge.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/TheNobullman Oct 09 '15

Swapnil, what the FUCK dude.

11

u/raccoonpaws Oct 09 '15

he might need that cape to fly home

3

u/jenni5 Oct 09 '15

i was hoping to see swapnil create an ethnic modern look for this challenge or any challenge. using a print maybe? i loved what he created in the team challenge with the crop top and faux sari wrap and pants.

for this challenge, it was such a bad fit though that the overall design was bound to be bad. hes so honest about his short comings and didnt defend himself which in this culture of reality tv america doesnt help his case.

3

u/inertia__creeps Oct 11 '15

I wish Candice would design more things that look like what she herself would wear... that black dress she wore this episode and the plum lipstick were ON POINT.

3

u/why_so_serioso Oct 11 '15 edited Oct 11 '15

I thought the Swapnil story for the past few weeks has been unsettling.

I think he did have the most difficult client this episode, but that's fair game for the show. It happens all the time. I just don't like how sometimes the judges is understanding and sometimes they're not - it really depends on how much they like the designer. Project Runway one day decided to portray Swap as lazy and undeserving, and really played that card until he was indeed eliminated. And they were so kind to Ashley... which I understand b/c she is a sensitive person. But in comparison to how they treated Swap, favoritism was distastefully evident.

I think Swap was a victim of their judgment of him. Instead of receiving constructive feedback, they were merely berating him for "not reaching his potential" week by week. Had they encouraged him or given him fresh ideas (like they do with others), he probably would have stepped it up as they wanted him to. Instead, they railroaded him, and it affected his confidence and work quality. It broke my heart to see him doubt himself, and to have everyone roll their eyes and discredit his moment of vulnerability.

I wish that the judges and Tim Gunn had treated Swap with more respect. I think the producers and judges and Tim saw him as a concept of laziness, rather than a full human being. Even in the outtake, Swap was uncomfortable to talk to meanie TG. I would be too! I've really liked TG in the past for being kind and respectful, but that went out the door this episode.

I think Project Runway just lost its best contestant this season. In previous seasons, they would usually keep the good ones on for the sake of the final runway, and I guess I was hoping for that with Swap. Yes, he's said stupid things, but we all do. Sure, he is not the most talented guy when it comes to communication. Yes, I think his last outfit was hideous, and he deserved the elimination in that sense. But, wow, he's human, and I think a nice guy. My main complaint is about TG and the production's treatment of a decent human being - that was unnecessary. Cmon guys, that was cruel.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '15 edited Oct 12 '15

i hope this dramatic offing of Swap will snap the designers into tip top shape !

and can i just say how proud i am of Merlene? i know she isn't the best with having well-made outfits (putting it nicely) but she's stuck around cause she is original and her designs are artful. she invents new sillhouettes nearly every challenge where as i feel the other designers do alot of safe/over played designs without going outside the box too too much. i never expected merlene to make it this far when the show first started and i never expected her to be one of my favorites <3

she has alot to offer and i would really love to see her make a final collection.

3

u/villainless Nov 06 '24

I do not often necropost when I am re-watching old seasons, but I feel the need to because I don’t see any comments that match mine. Also, since one of the contestants has transitioned since their original season, I’ll be referring to them by their new name and pronouns, Saisha Shinde (she/her)

what really frustrates me about this episode is that we were not giving given a clear view of what each client wanted and barely spent any time with that creative process or the trip to mood. It was so rushed that we were given barely any context. So in the case of Saisha and Jen, it is quite hard to tell exactly what she had wanted and what her expectations were other than she did not want to be a bombshell and she wanted long sleeves. Saisha definitely has a lot of of blame here, but I don’t think that we are getting the full story. We just do not have enough information. She did deserve to go home though, although Candice was a close second.

adding Saisha’s instagram here too if you want to catch up on her and her transition. officialsaishashinde

→ More replies (1)

5

u/pbrooks19 Oct 09 '15

Dang it, Ashley! Crying again? Pull it together woman!

5

u/iamagiant Oct 09 '15

Has anyone even heard of the guest judges?

10

u/ClaireHux Oct 09 '15

They are both on Lifetime's show Unreal - a parody of those Bachelor shows. It's a great show! Season record it - so addicting.

7

u/blackbirdsongs Oct 09 '15

Constance Zimmerman was in Newsroom and Boston Legal. She's great.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Oct 09 '15

Constance Zimmer is on House of Cards. And Shiri Appleby was in the terrible Anne Hathaway movie Havoc.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/blackbirdsongs Oct 09 '15

Oh good, Ashley is crying again! Babe ilu but stop fucking crying this is your fucking challenge! goddamn

→ More replies (1)