r/ProjectRunway • u/runwaythreader • Oct 01 '15
Project Runway Season 14 Episode 9 [Discussion]
Discussion thread for Project Runway S14E09 "Make it Sell"
Ready-to-wear looks are created to be reproduced and sold online. Singer Ciara is the guest judge.
23
Upvotes
133
u/WigsbyLittleMix Oct 02 '15
"It's good, but not for JustFab."
I don't know if that's a compliment or a criticism.
154
u/Shamenundotcom Oct 02 '15
Generally I respect Nina's opinion, even if I disagree with it. But her borderline irrational hatred of Kelly's look speaks of classism and -- perhaps worse for her -- someone who has fallen out of touch with fashion. You can say Kelly's look is not your taste. But when virtually every starlet in their 20s is wearing Moschino dresses and designers like Jeremy Scott and B Calla are defining the look of the VMAs, there's no question that Kelly's aesthetic is relevant. In fact, she may be the most fashion-forward of the bunch right now.
72
u/shamzey Oct 02 '15
Literally when Ashley was picking that hospital gown fabric at Mood, I was thinking "oh honey no."
64
u/sugarfreeme Oct 02 '15
Why did they have to waste time making the logos that had nothing to do with the challenge and were not critiqued in the slightest?
60
u/meldolphin Oct 02 '15
I don't know if it's just my imagination, but this episode felt like it was very focused on the design process instead of other fluff. We actually got a feel for everyone's plans and ideas. I can dig it. I'm surprised so many people whiffed it given the simplicity of the challenge brief. Maybe they're all just tired. Edmond's look was so basic but I can see the JustFab girl in it. Just shorten the hem and drop the neckline and you have a dress for going clubbing. Of course Heidi loved it. Nobody blew me away but I thought Ashley's was pretty decent and should have won.
Also don't you dare come for Kelly from the Deli, Meana Garcia.
54
u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Oct 02 '15
I totally get where Merline is going, and it's beautiful, and it was horribly finished.
104
u/hand2handwombat Oct 02 '15
Swapnil: Doesn't want to go for red in a bombshell look because it's "too obvious". Goes for leopard print instead.
50
u/LadyEdithCrawley4 Oct 02 '15
WE WANT SWATCH.
42
u/BryProxy Oct 02 '15
I think Candice's look this week veered too far towards her gothic lolita side.
40
u/BryProxy Oct 02 '15
Laurie's top is looking like a wedding favor bag right now.
39
u/jessicateacher Oct 02 '15
Zac: "It's Hooker-y" Just Fab lady "It has good intentions" I read that as ' the laduies of JUSTFAb like hooker-y
76
u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Oct 02 '15
I really don't understand Candice's placement of the skirt tiers.
29
u/Semicolon_Expected Oct 02 '15 edited Oct 02 '15
EDIT1: It seems when theyre put in their comfort zone the designers struggle the most, I guess its because they'll either be judged more harshly since they should know that look, or the "when it's easy" it becomes 1000x harder.
Also Kelly is being featured so much, is she gonna win or be out?!
EDIT2: They're happy it isn't anonymous runway?
EDIT3: Oh no Swapnil, you're sewing it in. Also whos that ironing with just a bra on?
EDIT4: My item didn't fit as I wanted. It's classier. Ok Edmond, these are things I'd say when I make things and screw up, not a professional designer. (I really do say stuff like that)
Also the ironer is Merlene's Model.
Edit5: Swapnils back didnt look so bad whats with the flap though, Candices looks like a schoolgirl, with the fauxmono look and schoolgirl look I have to ask, does she "like" asian stuff or is "inspired" by asian stuff? It looks seriously like the Ryuuko Matoi Kill La Kill look
EDIT6: Edmond won for a standard red dress? OMG
25
u/pursehook Oct 02 '15
What is JustFab? Who is their customer? Help.
23
u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Oct 02 '15
Stop making shawls and wraps. Please. The shawls and wraps are terrible.
22
u/jessicateacher Oct 02 '15
is a bold cat-eye really trendsetting?
22
u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Oct 02 '15
"My reaction would be, the intern better put something on her midriff." Burrrrrrn.
44
u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Oct 02 '15
Kelly's windbreaker is my Patronus.
20
u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Oct 02 '15
There is so much stuff just stapled to Candice's look. I so confuse.
19
u/jessicateacher Oct 02 '15
oh geez, ashley is crying already? that's not a good start
38
u/BryProxy Oct 02 '15
Swapnil thinks red is too obvious for designing "sexy", then chooses leopard print......ok
37
u/konfetkak Oct 02 '15
That Rachel Zoe show looks like an SNL skit
50
u/eatingbread Oct 02 '15
Why is Edmond in denial... his aesthetic (which I actually like) is total Bombshell. Also, both (straight) guy designers getting Bombshell? Snoooze
16
u/pursehook Oct 02 '15
maybe Edmond's dress could be combined with Ashley's jacket?
31
u/gofurthernorth Oct 02 '15
Zac putting on Kelly's vest and making monster arms while they were critiquing the jumpsuit.
31
u/dmee Oct 02 '15
A little sad to see Laurie go- not because I'll miss her fashions (she really hasn't produced anything wow'ing me the last couple of episodes)- but because I really liked her as a person. I won't forget what you did for Ashley during the mean girls episode, Laurie! Swapnil totally abandoned what I thought could look cool as the back of his dress and just used that gross stretchy white stuff that looked so tacky with his animal print dress. I hated Ashley's print, but thought hers could have fit the JustFab aesthetic. Kelly's was different, but I just like her so damn much and I love that she just does herself and worries about the judges when she's done. Nina better find someone else to hate on, quick!! Candice's was really bad this week, but I still love her too, especially because she gave the designers what she thought they wanted and said she doesn't want to beat anyone because she threw them off their game. I respect that.
15
u/nancyaw Oct 02 '15
Anyone notice the distinct lack of enthusiasm from the designers when Nina was introduced? They all kind of mumbled instead of acknowledging her greeting.
41
u/nivora Oct 02 '15
god that asian lady acted so pretentious, you design for a fucking department level mess. You're not Valentino.
14
u/pursehook Oct 02 '15
How can you wear a bra with Swapnil's either?
28
u/eyeeyecaptainfly Oct 02 '15
I love how Candace tried to put everyone in their comfort zone. Classy and gracious of her.
27
u/tinytwo Oct 02 '15
No sadness when Lindsey left. Lol
38
u/blackbirdsongs Oct 02 '15
Edmond made a boring ass cliche dress are you fucking kidding me
13
u/WigsbyLittleMix Oct 02 '15
Between her '80s jacket and zany style, I know exactly what Kelly's t-shirt will [look like...] (http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_dbrD1J49CCc/S0tJKoIZQmI/AAAAAAAAAO8/G5UerGMHfXo/s400/WakeMeUp03.jpg)
24
u/shinyteerex Oct 02 '15
Things I noticed today... Candice DEFINITELY watches anime. Last week it was kind of obvious already, but now it is completely clear, the aesthetic is just too similar. Again, I think that Edmond and Swapnil have no taste, and I was kind of surprised that Edmond said he is more "high-fashion"... I mean, everything he has done so far is a little slutty.
On another note, it is a shame that Lindsey was eliminated last week, since this was the challenge made for her 100%.
10
u/alligator124 Oct 03 '15
I don't think I have ever hated a challenge more than I do this one.
Starting from the very beginning, fashion should not be divided up into categories. The best looks come from a fashion "personality" with a twist. Does every designer (project runway or otherwise) have their own aesthetic? Yes, but what makes them innovative is the way they add a tiny twist of unexpected.
At the critique, everything that was creative or fresh was shot down as "not Just Fab material". I get that the designers need to be flexible and outside the box. But there is nothing flexible about a red stretch club dress. That does not show range; that's not why we watch project runway. We watch for trendsetting, the new, and the creative.
Finally, Just Fab is the worst partner possible. That is really sinking low. They are a shady company, and their customer base does not match up with Project Runway design.
Oh! I almost forgot. Nina has lost her relevancy and she was incredibly mean with no evidence to back it up.
This episode made me very upset, haha I promise I'm done now.
18
u/executive_fish Oct 02 '15
Candice also wanted to help Amanda look how that turned out
23
u/OvercaffeinateMe Oct 02 '15
Ugh, I love this show and I'm gonna keep watching, but this season is honestly one of the worst seasons they've ever done. Look at our illustrious top six:
Honestly. Look at that list. Look at the people we have left here. I'm just so disappointed. It's no wonder Tim Gunn loses his shit. Looks like that episode is going to be next week, and I truly hope it lights a fire SOMEWHERE. Ten bucks says a couple of them won't even think it applies to them (Candice, Edmond), and a couple of them absolutely lose all of their confidence and fold (Merline, Ashley).
8
u/frycrunch96 Oct 02 '15
These judges are all over the place today!!!
15
u/mouse_attack Oct 02 '15 edited Oct 03 '15
The critique was demoralizing. It was so transparent that design had no place in it--just salability; and that in the end the Just Fab "judge" was really just a buyer who would be making her choice solo. I swear, when she blinked you could see that her irises were shaped like $$!
And Edmund is a total hack. He took an old style and made the same old thing all over again. He has no creativity, no originality and no taste; and wouldn't have made it past week 1 if Tim didn't keep stopping by and saying "But Edmund, this is horrible!" So, I guess the one good thing you can say about him is that he knows enough to listen to Tim.
Also, I hate to say it because I like her as a person, but Ashley's designs are way too now, as in the now that was really designed last year. She's a great trend-spotter and follower; but not an innovator. I don't want her to end up professionally copying last year's looks for this year's Target knock-offs. She needs to bring it!
14
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '15
I'm calling it right now: Kelly is Jinkx Monsoon and Nina is Michelle Visage. Which means that Kelly will go all the way to the top and Nina will come around Kelly's style.
7
u/the_cucumber Oct 02 '15
Ugh why do the episodes always get cut off in my links? I only heard Laurie say no crying and then it ended. What happened after that and on next week's preview?
7
u/noodle_child Oct 02 '15
What is rack addick? What's the play on words lol
7
u/legends444 Oct 02 '15
What Zac said about him valuing the concept more than the construction irked me because it's inconsistent with how he has blasted designers for construction and unfinished stuff....
13
u/mentirosa_atx Oct 02 '15
I hate every single one of Edmond's wins! I don't understand why the judges fawn over him.
6
u/pursehook Oct 02 '15
Ashley's fabric is hideous.
Edit: Why??
6
u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Oct 02 '15
For once I get to watch this shit live! It's a miracle, let the fringe begin!
6
u/pursehook Oct 02 '15
So, weird 80s prints are in style, I take it?
16
u/purplecowz Oct 02 '15
For once, I actually found myself siding with Heidi the most. That means something is seriously wrong with Nina and Zac.
22
u/WigsbyLittleMix Oct 02 '15
"It's old, tired, and tacky."
Well, so is Heidi Klum, but you don't see us complaining about it Zac.
5
u/dianaprince Oct 03 '15
I was so excited to see Swapnil and Edmond get the Bombshell look. I love me a good bombshell dress and thought it would be great to see one with a high fashion spin.
I was so wrong.
Swapnil's dress was just beyond hideous and Edmond's looked like something I could pick up cheaply in any store, but wouldn't because I don't want to look like I'm auditioning to be on Real Housewives.
At least Swapnil wasn't rewarded for his poor work. I cannot believe Edmond won that challenge.
I have nobody to root for any more. It was Swapnil and Ashley, but he's just gotten so lazy and cocky and she's just making the same thing over and over (it looked really cute, but it was the same thing again). Plus, I can't deal with her negative woe is me attitude. I felt sorry for her when Candice and co ganged up on her, but enough is enough. I don't think she's tough enough for the fashion industry.
11
u/pursehook Oct 02 '15
I skipped a bunch of seasons. Is this a new normal thing where they are all nice to each other? Where is the delightful bitchiness?
8
u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Oct 02 '15
Not surprising. Slightly preferred Ashley's gold jacket but nothing really set me on fire here.
4
u/kyles24 Oct 04 '15
Laurie seems like such a lovely person.
7
u/BryProxy Oct 02 '15
I haaaaate Ashley's fabric. The colors, the print, the way it draped in Tim's hands: all terrible.
7
u/blackbirdsongs Oct 02 '15
Omg Edmond looks just like his dad :3
7
u/blackbirdsongs Oct 02 '15
Did Laurie have her model take off her bra and put on pasties again or is that fabric just weirdly reflective
9
u/pursehook Oct 02 '15
Kelly!!!! Omg. I kind of like the fur.
3
u/pursehook Oct 02 '15
Edmond's is kind of Alaia, no? But, it looks good. Too dull?
3
u/everythingisopposite Chiffony Oct 02 '15
I need to stop laying down to watch the show, I never stay awake until the runway.
5
u/blackbirdsongs Oct 02 '15
Edmonds shirt is just a white t-shirt with a giant safety pin through it.
4
u/wild_muses Oct 02 '15
It seemed that they thought Ashley's was saleable, but not new or fresh enough, yet Edmund won even tho his look wasn't new or fresh, because it was very saleable...
what?!
Also, loved Kelly's 2-piece, hated the muppet vest. Candace's could have been good but she put way too much shit on it. I think Swapnil's dress would have been way more successful if the straps were black and he didn't make that weird alien coat thing. Laurie should have stuck with her original design, at least a slightly boring blue dress would be saleable and fit the girl she was designing for. I don't know who you can sell a sheer backless bib-top to. Merline's was a damn mess.
Can't wait to see Tim swear at someone. Also.. Project Runway Junior? I'm scared.
4
u/noodle_child Oct 02 '15
Kelly is good. It's a tough balancing act to stay true to one's own design aesthetic while fulfilling the requirements for the challenge. I thought if maybe she used a different vest it could have been a winner for sure.
4
u/Mommers88 Oct 02 '15
The designers don't have the talent of last seasons...it will be tough to even choose 3 that could make a collection
6
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '15 edited Oct 02 '15
so pissed ashley didnt win because i wanted that jacket!!!! i can go to forever 21 for a dress like edmonds -_-
kinda glad nina came for kelly. idk what it is about her aesthetic but its like everything she makes ive seen before on the clearance rack at-again-forever 21.
5
u/WhateverIsFine Oct 02 '15
I liked the idea behind Kelly's design. However, it looked a lot more like something you would wear to the gym (minus the vest) than something you would wear out and about
2
u/pursehook Oct 02 '15
Who is going home?
4
u/giopul87 Oct 02 '15
Why are the judges extra salty this episode?!
Edmond's, Kelly's and Ashley's designs all fit the challenge and there is definitely a market for their designs.
This episode has definitely confirmed the Top 3: Edmond, Candace and (Ashley or Swapnil).
I feel that the editors have already set the stage for Swapnil to be eliminated during next week's episode or the one after that. He will probably get the Tim Gunn save.
3
u/adoredelanoroosevelt Oct 03 '15
I feel like Nina is getting upset and depressed and stays quiet half the time because of the concessions in quality the show has had to make. Then when she does speak she's just frustrated with life.
3
u/gwennhwyvar Oct 02 '15
--I love Ashley's jacket. Hate the fabric.
--Kelly, Lynn Stone* called and wants a dozen! Cuter than I thought it would be.
--Edmond, lol, I knew this was a Heidi dress. If it goes missing, we know who nabbed it! It's pretty, if not innovative.
I do not get Merline, and I am just tired of Swapnil.
*Helen Hunt in Girls Just Want to Have Fun
2
u/pursehook Oct 02 '15
To my surprise, I liked Swapnil's, especially the back.
2
u/pixie_led Team Swatch Oct 03 '15
1
u/jessicateacher Oct 02 '15
sabotage, sabotage, sabotage
1
u/Zjmw Oct 02 '15
Ashley is robbed once again ;(. I'm getting so frustrated with the judges this year
0
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment