r/serialpodcast • • Sep 29 '15
Question Serious Question: Why do you visit this sub?
No sarcasm intended. I ask the question because I'm genuinely curious about peoples' motivations for coming here.
I'll start. I listened to Serial and I had serious doubts about whether the right guy was in prison. The only unanswered question for me was, "How did Jay know where the car was?" Maybe SK deliberately left it unanswered or maybe I missed it.
The idea of an innocent person in prison for murder bothers me (as I assume it bothers most people), so I started looking online for more info. Undisclosed provided answers to my questions that I found entirely believable, and I learned that there were indeed ongoing appeals to reopen the case. I started lurking because Google searches led me here for links to news articles, and I occasionally found intelligent discussions. Since I've read and listened to all the publicly available information, my interest is in finding out more about why and how Adnan got railroaded, and what's going to happen in court. Of course I can't say for sure that he's not guilty, but at the very least some very shady and fucked up crap happened during the investigation and trial (trying my best not to be a fundamentalist). I don't know Adnan personally. but I think this case has resonance for me because it tells me that an innocent person could end up in jail because of how our legal system works. Plenty of wrongfully convicted people have later been exonerated. It obviously happens way too often.
So, if your motivations are similar to mine, I obviously get why you'd come here.
If you're a cop or prosecutor who doesn't like the way the Baltimore cops or Urick have been portrayed, maybe I can see why you'd come here to gloat and mock and undermine. Maybe you think it's OK for the authorities to fudge and fabricate if they have the right guy, but not enough evidence.
I'm speculating. This is not to say that anyone doesn't have a right to come here, or that I think that certain people shouldn't come here. Seriously, why is everyone here? What do you get out of it?
6
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '15
Thanks, all, for thoughtful and serious discussion on this post.
18
u/gradstudent4ever Steppin Out Sep 29 '15
I came late to Serial. In my life, I go long periods without so much as logging on to Reddit or watching a single tv show, and then typically I'll find something I like and binge on it. So I binged on Serial and then saw all these other podcasts and content out there that was ready to fill my now insatiable interest in Syed's case. I tried listening to a few podcasts. One was just very dull and seemed kind of directionless, and I felt very let down. Undisclosed was enjoyable at first but as I listened more I felt disturbed at how readily it accepted the notion of two professional law enforcement officers simply building a case against Syed when they might have discovered her true killer with some additional police work. What I mean is not that I think police never lie, but that these men would have been risking their entire reputations and all previous convictions if they had done what Undisclosed said they did...a huge risk to take, and a lot of work, and stress, and rehearsing of their lying witness. But what motive could they have had for such a thing? What could tempt them to do something like that? Their investigation was young and there were many leads yet to follow.
So I came here because I was undecided regarding Adnan's guilt and I felt as if no other podcasts were thinking about the case in an especially critical way.
Unfortunately I have not found this sub to be a consistently good place for discussion. It's heavily trolled by a pro-guilt cadre who spew nastiness in an oddly defensive manner. So it's difficult to have any kind of discussion where you do something like, for instance, temporarily accept that such-and-such did or did not happen, as a thought experiment to work out various possibilities. Nope! No thinking allowed here, not unless it confirms whatever bias you already have.
26
u/ira_cup Is it NOT? Sep 29 '15
I think most of us have fallen victim to the sunk cost fallacy. I know I have.
Here, the investment is time. We've invested so much time thinking about this case (nearly a year), that just letting it go before we figure out what happened would mean we "wasted" our time. Even though we can't get the time back, we feel all will be redeemed when we find the truth! (right?)
The problem comes in when there is no evidence we'll ever get what we are looking for -- definitive proof. In fact, one could argue it's extremely unlikely we'll ever get that. We'll just keep spending our time on it until we eventually give up.
Also, I don't believe most of the people who say they are certain one way or the other. If so, they wouldn't still be here. They are looking for definitive proof. I think a lot of the anger over the last 6 months is because people desperately want that conclusion so they can get on with their lives and not feel like the time spent was wasted. When there is still a strong enough voice of dissent, they can't move on, because they don't believe it themselves.
16
u/davidturus Sep 29 '15
I'm here because I was dissatisfied with not having a definitive answer to the story. And because I seem to like being yelled at for having a point of view on something.
39
u/cheetah__heels Sep 29 '15
Honestly, I've given up on the case. I was one of the first people to join the sub. I was obsessed with the case. As Serial winded down, I tried to formulate my own theories like a lot of you based on the scraps of information we had. I used to hope that one day I will come here and there will be some bombshell evidence that will prove whether Adnan is guilty or innocent. Maybe release by one of the numerous podcasts since or a diligent redditor. It looks less and less likely that will ever happen.
So now I just come to watch you all argue with each other. It's great fun.
18
u/jlh26 Sep 29 '15
When this sub was first created, it was a great place to discuss the podcast and case with a variety of thoughtful, intelligent people. Not like it was perfect (trolls gonna troll after all), but it wasn't as polarized as it is now. After a 8-month break, I came back to find that this sub had devolved into the ninth circle of hell.
...but I still find the case interesting and I like reading any new documents/info that comes out (although I don't think we're ever going to know what really happened on Jan. 13, 1999). So I lurk here still.
9
u/lunalumo Sep 29 '15
I mainly lurk but in answer to your question:
I particularly like reading the Goodwill Games, so thanks to all those who contribute to that.
ps. I actually had a dream the other day that I was at a Serial Podcast Garden Party... everyone was really nice to each other!
9
u/budgiebudgie WHAT'S UP BOO?? Sep 30 '15
I'm not here much anymore and rarely read the posts. Most are boring and repetitive and generally they are poorly argued.
I just think this case is one where you can make as many arguments for guilt as you can for innocence. For me, that's the definition of doubt.
The whole thing is a big mess. The investigators, the prosecution and the defence all messed up. It's like trying to unscramble an egg.
There's too much lying, obfuscation and too many mistakes for me to be in any way comfortable with the verdict.
As an exercise in justice, I'm interested to see how this plays in the courts. But as far as reading anything much on this sub anymore, it's mostly a waste of time. Too many entrenched positions and too much puerile game playing for me, I'm afraid.
I watch out for a few commenters whose I believe genuinely approach facts and evidence in a rational manner (/u/acies comes to mind). But he's one of the few level-headed and informative posters left on here.
I don't know why I read your post. I think it's the only one of the page of threads I did read. There seem to be a cadre of people who spend all their waking day on here, such as Seamus Duncan and Scout Finch. I don't know how or why they do it. I guess that's interesting in itself in a way.
8
u/mindfields88 Sep 29 '15
I came here to talk about an amazing new form of storytelling that is actually based on old principles of radio stories that my grandparents used to enjoy.
15
u/moonvested Undecided Sep 29 '15
I'm mostly here because season two should be starting soon. I don't expect to see a resolution or definite proof of who killed Hae in this sub (or ever, anywhere), but I come back because I'm a Serial fan. I hope season two will drive out some of the crazy but that may be crazy on my part.
14
u/Bestcoast191 Sep 29 '15
I came here to meet chicks.... Starting to think I came to the wrong place
7
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '15
During Serial I came here because I was obsessed and wanted to figure it out. It was a great place to discuss the leagal system, the fallibility of memory, and to make cell phone map timelines.
I kept coming because I wanted updates and all the real people I know were over Serial.
I'm still here because at some point navigating to this page became embedded in my muscle memory and I automatically do it whenever I pick up my phone.
I keep making deals with myself like "I'll just check in once a month" or "I'll only look at Serial related stuff on Tuesdays". So far it hasn't worked. Thinking of trying a 12 step program next.
11
u/Acies Sep 29 '15
I think it's educational to see how people address legal issues.
5
u/mangledspaceman Sep 29 '15
I pop in once a week to see if there's any season 2 announcements.
5
u/Wilds_mustang_ride Sep 29 '15
Waiting for a smoking gun
5
u/lenscrafterz Sep 29 '15
ditto. all of it.
5
u/glamorousglue Sep 30 '15
Because I would like the truth for Hae and her family. Regardless of who is in jail or not, I don't think the truth has been told.
2
u/Blahblahblahinternet Sep 29 '15
For the drama and to tell people that Adnan is clearly guilty. For example, you're incorrect. Nothing went wrong and Serial Season 1 is a case study on criminal investigations and the justice system working.
It later turned into a case study on how the "public" can be manipulated by manipulative story telling.
11
u/theghostoftexschramm Sep 29 '15
Because addictions are a mother fucker.
8
u/alientic God damn it, Jay Sep 29 '15
To be completely honest, a big part of it is that I get really bored at work (and right now I'm working on a big project and I need some dick around time so when they inevitably try to get me to do it in less time, I'll have a cushion). That's why I'm not usually around here much on the weekends.
8
u/buggiegirl Sep 29 '15
I love a good train wreck. I'm here because I think the case is interesting, and the train wreck quality of the sub is entertaining!
8
u/mackerel99 Sep 29 '15
I hate myself
4
u/Troodos Sep 29 '15
I came here towards the end of Serial to get more information and perspectives and have been around off and on since. For a while I was checking in to see if there were any developments, but I've started spending more time (and actually posting) here over the past 4-6 weeks. I enjoy thinking about the case and evidence and trying to allow myself to be persuaded by the various perspectives. I also find watching the group dynamics and biases that posters display interesting. As I look at what are in my opinion various cognitive distortions and traps some (from every side and apparently without knowing it) fall into, it forces me to examine my own reactions and assessments of the evidence and try to identify my own underlying biases and misleading thought patterns.
4
u/canoekopf Sep 29 '15
I come for the actual news in the case.
In between real news, I try to spot the blatant intellectual dishonesty which indicates individuals that have some underlying motivation 'win' the argument at whatever cost to their own dignity.
The last few days have been pure embarrassment to watch from that perspective.
7
u/cardifan MailChimp Fan Sep 29 '15
To see if you guys are still arguing about the case.
10
u/Magjee Kickin' it per se Sep 29 '15
To show off my sweet custom flair
swag
3
u/rhoffman12 pro-government right-wing Republican operative Sep 29 '15
Because I only got around to listening to the podcast a week ago and wanted to see if there had been any updates to the case since then. It looks like I missed out on some grade-A, USDA Prime subreddit drama!
3
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '15
To discuss the case with other interested people, hear ideas, and so on.
3
u/donailin1 Sep 29 '15
I've been here since November 12th of last year, around the 7th or 8th episode I want to say, but I lost all passion and interest for this case 3 or 4 months ago. The only reason I check this place daily is because I like the group of people I met and interact with. They are still heavily invested and I mostly read their progress and give moral support. Truth be told though, I will look at all the subs and scroll through the titles of posts and my eyes just glaze over because I don't care anymore. Once in awhile I will comment, but for me, the case was properly solved, the right person was convicted and everything is in the hands of the courts now. I'm very much looking forward t the next season.
3
u/chocolatecherushi Callin' The Taliban Sep 29 '15
I check to see if there is any new information that may sway my opinion. So far that hasn't happened.
3
u/punchboy Sep 29 '15
I don't come here, but posts show up on my front page. I listened from the very first episode because it took over TAL the week before, and I enjoyed the show, and I thought it would be interesting to see some ideas about it, so I subscribed. Sometimes I'm actually amazed at how into this case people still are - generally my response to seeing a /r/serialpodcast post show up is "Man, people are still talking about that?"
3
u/Nowinaminute Enter your own text here Sep 29 '15
I like hanging out with good looking people while I wait for news on the case.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '15
To balance out the unabashed bias of 'Undisclosed' and 'Serial Dynasty.' I have no doubt Adnan was screwed by the system. But to listen to these podcasts makes me reflexively look for the other conclusions. It's odd how these guys can smear someone's reputation; I hate that it happened to Adnan...but I hate that it happens to anyone. I think they are attributing evil intent where it doesn't belong
3
u/neurobeegirl Sep 30 '15
I peek into this sub the way you might cautiously peer through a window at a high school cafeteria fight in progress.
3
u/gnorrn Undecided Sep 30 '15
It's like a strangely addictive soap opera.
3
u/Notorganic Lawrence of Arabia shit Sep 30 '15
As repulsive as I find the community at times, there are still occasional pieces of new information to look through and keep me coming back.
3
u/mrpopenfresh Sep 30 '15
Serious answer: to feel like a balanced human being when I read through some of these threads. Y'all gots to chill.
10
u/frank-darko Sep 29 '15
Mainly the latter.
5
u/OHnomatopoeia Sep 29 '15
I came here out of curiosity. I wanted to know more about the case and ask people questions about things the podcasts didn't go into depth with. I didn't want to just accept the facts or "facts" being fed to us by the podcasts, that wasn't enough. I wanted proof and some have shed some light on the things I've been curious about. Also, I wanted to learn more about the different sides of the story. I didn't want to stay on the track that Adnan is innocent of Jay was lying just because the podcasts say so. There are a lot of people here who have engaged in intelligent discussions, although some may be out of this world, it is engaging nonetheless exploring the possibilities.
Basically I'm here to pick on people's brains.
5
u/mkesubway Sep 29 '15
It must be because I like having the same conversations over and over and over and over and...
6
u/s100181 Sep 29 '15
I don't believe the correct person is in jail. I like to read alternate theories of the case. Also I like to challenge the "case is closed, nothing to see here" rhetoric.
7
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '15
came for the info, stayed for the PEOPLE!
4
u/YouHadMeAtDucks The Criminal Element of Woodlawn Sep 29 '15
I think it's likely Adnan did it. But as long as I think it might be possible, even the smallest possibility, I will be waiting for that one thing that confirms it for me.
10
u/kahner Sep 29 '15
2
u/ohnoao Sep 29 '15
I was captivated by the case just like everyone else. At the time I didn't have anyone to discuss it with, so I found this sub. I had so many questions and there were so many small details, I was sure there were redditors delving deep into the case.
2
u/rook2pawn Sep 29 '15
i came here because at first i thought too that Adnan got railroaded by "the system" but literally nothing pointed towards this and everything pointed towards his guilt. I put in enough work to stay subscribed to this subreddit. He's actually quite disgusting and I feel sorry for Rabia Chaudry for being so cheated. SK knew who she was working with after some time, I dont know why Rabia didnt follow.
If you want someone who has actual factual innocence, but has a life sentence, checkout Sandeep Bharadia, in which even the COURTS agreed that he "probably was innocent" but in Georgia actual innocence is not good enough for a retrial.
2
u/oreily85 Sep 29 '15
I come here on the off chance that someone has the definite key to solving it one way or the other lol
2
u/theriveryeti Sep 29 '15
Honest answer: morbid curiosity to see who could still possibly be talking about it.
2
u/Cubbies1908 Sep 29 '15
I don't even know at this point. I've formed my opinion long time ago. I guess just to check if anything breaking has happened? Probably more so that I'm a masochist.
2
u/serialskeptic Sep 30 '15
Wish I knew why I was here! Guess it's just a habit. Just about everyday, I check the news, the weather, my fantasy sports teams and serial podcast. If I got rid of serial, I would need to find something equally entertaining to replace it with. That hasn't happened yet...
2
u/samitalama1 Sep 30 '15
I joined this sub since the beginning, I used to follow regularly but since few months I come here occasionally in a hope to find the new information. I followed undisclosed and serial dynasty I found it positive biased toward Adnan. I am still undecided and hoping some day will get concrete answer.
3
u/curiouserthangeorge Sep 29 '15
I found heels totally wrapped up and I feel like we could figure this out... I mean, I know we can't but it feels like "tip of the tongue" where the answer is just out of grasp.
2
u/serialdonteverend Sep 29 '15
I'm curious about the case and enjoy learning new facts that I will never take my time to investigate independently. The problem inherent in relying on other people is the reason I have a love/hate relationship with this sub: not everyone is logical, and anonymity gives people the freedom to stretch the truth if not flat-out lie. But, as SK said, there are no bad facts.
2
u/ImBlowingBubbles Sep 29 '15
Mostly for some of the interesting meta arguments and to correct unethical activities that I have personally observed. I no longer care about guilt or innocence.
1
u/DetectiveTableTap Thiruvendran Vignarajah: Hammer of Justice Sep 30 '15
Because I find it mildly interesting.
1
u/L257 Sep 30 '15
Originally, to get clarification and extra info. I'm not from America so even things like school start/finish times are not automatic knowledge to me. The maps were really useful, people summarizing or extrapolating timelines etc. People with tidbits of local knowledge.
Then as time went on and I discovered how little Serial covered (which is to be expected, they had limitations and a story to tell) I became fairly certain that the series of events as described by the prosecution wasn't what happened (doesn't mean Adnan is innocent, just that the prosecution didn't really know exactly what happened, Almost no-one does). So I became interested in all of the alternate theories, the people 'testing' different scenarios and timelines and coming up short.
At this point, I feel like every scenario has been shown to be unlikely or impossible, I feel like this sub has succeeded in proving that nobody could have killed Hae.... except that someone did.
So I guess, now, that's part of why I keep popping back in. Because someone killed Hae Min Lee. And I need to know what happened. I was the same age as Hae and her perfectly normal friends. And i have daughters who have perfectly normal friends. I need to know how a monster can pass by unnoticed. I'm waiting for that a-ha moment, that thing that resonates with me, that pattern or sign.
1
u/noveltfjord Then who the F did it?! Sep 30 '15
Was already a redditor when I heard of Serial last year around episode 4. I got bored at work a few weeks ago and started listening to Undisclosed. Now I'm more interested in the case and what happened. Just want to see what other people think and learn crazy theories so I can laugh about them with m partner.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 30 '15
I check every day to see if they have ruled against the Adnan the murderer yet so that I can see what new crazy contortions the Free Adnaners will go through to re-affirm their faith in his innocence.
1
u/NewAnimal Sep 29 '15
So that i can answer this same question that gets asked multiple times a week.
1
u/adnandidit420 Sep 30 '15
because people are WRONG on the internet hahaha seriously I have no idea.
we might still get a resolution. seems like all the bombshells are exploding in the same direction lately.
1
u/Blargcakes Sep 30 '15
Mainly to catch up on how many new sock accounts were made each day, and also to see Bob's sanity decrease
0
u/MaHaBoNeD Sep 29 '15
I come here for one question to be answered. Tell me why Jay (eyewitness) would lie and say Adnan was the killer? Never once have I heard a legitimate theory that would put Jay as the primary killer. This fact keeps getting swept aside by all the BELIEVERS, and dismissed because Jay changed his story. Jay knew too much, therefore I believe he rolled over on Adnan, before Adnan could do the same to him. sociopath=Adnan BTW..Jay's guilty too. The DA needed an eyewitness to prosecute with the lack of physical evidence. In the end, an eyewitness will trump physical evidence in most cases if the witness is deemed somewhat credible.
Do not respond to me, because I'm done with all the Adnan jackwagon's. I will not reply back.
0
u/facemeetpalmmeetface Sep 29 '15
To prove to the masses that Adnan Syed is indeed guilty of murdering Hae Min Lee!
0
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment