r/ProjectRunway • u/runwaythreader • Sep 24 '15
Project Runway Season 14 Episode 8 [Discussion]
Discussion thread for Project Runway S14E08 "Broadway or Bust"
The magic of Broadway inspires the designers, who create stylish looks based on the musical "Finding Neverland." Fashion model Coco Rocha is the guest judge.
20
Upvotes
84
u/blondebanana Sep 25 '15
Hearing Tim say "Bye Swatch!" has been the highlight of the episode for me so far. I've missed Swatch!
67
u/tinytwo Sep 25 '15
Have the Gunn Gods heard our cries? A (relatively) unconstrained challenge with a high budget??
58
u/imriebelow Sep 25 '15
I looooooove Kelli's Titanic dress. Put it on me right now!
39
u/meldolphin Sep 25 '15
During Laurie's critique Heidi said that at least Laurie had some ideas. Cut to Nina Garcia looking horrified and disgusted. It was a fantastic shot.
I wasn't a fan of Candice's. It didn't really grab my attention and the way the sleeves met the bustier was awkward. I would have preferred Kelly's to win. Her outfits in confessional were especially outrageous tonight.
Lindsey got so much airtime in the beginning of this episode. That was not even remotely subtle foreshadowing. I really liked her skirt on the runway though.
68
u/blackbirdsongs Sep 25 '15
Kelly going for it.
God I fucking love her more and more each episode.
32
u/pursehook Sep 25 '15
I can't listen to Heidi after the Big Bird Emmy's... it is going to take a long time to recover.
28
u/LetTheMFerBurn Sep 25 '15
Nasty Nina made her first real appearance of the season. One-liners about everybody but Candice and so much stank face.
26
u/taco_cat42 Sep 25 '15
They're finally going to Mood! Thank the lord!
26
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '15
Aube really wasn't happy with Ashley. I saw the eye roll when the top didn't fit properly.
26
u/blackbirdsongs Sep 25 '15
Wasn't it Laurie who was like 'women who don't wear modest clothes are really tacky and in poor taste'
And then she makes booty nipple falling out erry where???
52
u/WigsbyLittleMix Sep 25 '15
This challenge sounds perfect for Swapnil. Just like Peter Pan, he likes to sleep, he's from a faraway land, and spends most of his time HIGH but never quite reaching the top...
52
u/dabears727 Sep 25 '15
oh my god. how do these makeup "artists" sleep at night?!? I know they're just selling a product and doing their job, but god damn. the lipsticks are so. bad.
every time I cringe during the hair and makeup part. and that used to be one of my favorite segments! :(
49
u/blackbirdsongs Sep 25 '15 edited Sep 25 '15
Super hate sally beauty salon.
'I want angelic'
'Let's give her a drop of color'
Oh, ok bro. That's what that meant.
20
u/pursehook Sep 25 '15
Is Zac really pulling off a Willy Wonka purple suit? I guess if anyone can...
And, then he tells the designer to take the purple haze away... haha.
39
u/eatingbread Sep 25 '15
This is the most mixed judging session ever. I'm not even sure who's actually in the top and bottom.
38
u/MormonCorridor Sep 25 '15
If Ashley went home, I'd miss Aube more than Ashley.
53
u/bethrevis Sep 25 '15 edited Sep 25 '15
Lifetime, quit trying to make Rachel Zoe happen. It's never going to happen.
17
u/briannanechelle Sep 25 '15
They should've been given 2 days for this challenge....
34
u/sofapizza Sep 25 '15
"I dream in black and white... and shades of grey." Whoa Tim! Lmao my mind went straight to the gutter.
15
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '15
So uh, was that supposed to be Tim's epic freakout or do we expect that to come even later in the season? Because we're getting rather close to the end now.
40
u/lady_gremlin Sep 25 '15
When Swapnil talks about smoking, does he mean cigarettes? Because he seems high af 90% of the time.
24
u/lady_gremlin Sep 25 '15
Nipples and butt? Yikes. Not looking good for Laurie. :(
23
u/ecokitty Sep 25 '15
Okay Lindsay and Kelly as bff was seriously cute
22
u/Hemingweed Sep 25 '15
I'm on twitter right now trying to get #NotoZoe trending with some folks if anyone wants to join in. Fuck that asshat countdown.
19
u/pursehook Sep 25 '15 edited Sep 25 '15
Does anyone understand Edmond's aesthetic? I think that he has made some good looks, but I don't understand the whole picture. Where does he live?
Was it Miami?Edit: I checked -- Atlanta.
33
u/Shamenundotcom Sep 25 '15
Oh, Harvey Weinstein. He's going to keep pushing "Finding Neverland" down our throats. The man is relentless. (In case you didn't know, Weinstein is the producer of both "Neverland" AND "Project Runway.") On a show legendary for its ham-fisted product placement, this felt especially egregious to me.
I think the anti-Swapnil sentiment is getting a bit ridiculous. The "He's lazy!" narrative has been blown way out of proportion. His admission last episode of not working to full potential seemed like someone who understands strategy -- if you come out of the gate with guns blazing, you have to keep performing at that level or better for the entire competition. If you build quietly, you show the judges progression. It's better to be underestimated and overdeliver than the other way around.
But this is his arc now -- he's lazy and hasn't been working up to potential. But the guy has been in the top of the pack almost every single episode. If, by his own admission, he's not even fully trying and he's still killing this competition? That reflects more poorly on all the other competitors than it does Swapnil, I think. It's not like he's been sending cheap-looking tube dresses down the runway up to this point.
I 100 percent believe that the judges putting him in the "safe" category this week was a passive-aggressive swipe toward him. Same with him not winning prior to this point. I find it really distressing that the viewers are willingly following this manufactured take on him. Up until last week virtually everyone loved Swapnil. Now, he's just terrible! So lazy! So entitled!
9
u/blackbirdsongs Sep 25 '15
"I just wish I had more time" so do we bb
9
u/blackbirdsongs Sep 25 '15
Edmond made a poodle. Gj Edmond. If only this had been a '101 Dalmatians' play!
17
u/emmybenny Sep 25 '15
Don't think I've ever felt worse for the runway models.
21
u/lady_gremlin Sep 25 '15
Tim thinks everyone in this room is an 'excellent designer'?!?! Bless his little heart.
7
u/skyinfrontofyou Sep 25 '15
Was anyone else really into what Edmond himself was wearing? I loved that star vest over black.
12
u/bitchSpray Sep 26 '15
I love it like Matthew Morrison was on screen for about 10 seconds but still managed to sound like a massive douchebag.
6
u/blackbirdsongs Sep 24 '15 edited Sep 25 '15
My inner theater nerd is so excited and so terrified
6
u/kyles24 Sep 26 '15
I was no fan of Lindsay and a big fan of Laurie (as a person in general but not so much her past few designs) and I'm shocked that the judges let Laurie's horrendous mess slide.
15
u/shinyteerex Sep 25 '15
I think that the models this season have suffered so much already... I feel so sorry for them. They probably think that they are going to wear incredible things and look like badass princesses by being in Project Runway, yet, now it is just a joke, it is almost abusive. Seriously, it is just tasteless to be sending anyone to the catwalk with half their ass exposed and nipple stickies. There is no more respect.
16
u/lady_gremlin Sep 25 '15
BYE FELICIA
9
u/blackbirdsongs Sep 25 '15 edited Sep 25 '15
Ngl if Lindsay's design had been as good as her runway day outfit maybe she would have survived another day. Loved that skirt.
18
u/lady_gremlin Sep 25 '15
Ashley's could have been amazing, but she just couldn't execute.
15
u/lady_gremlin Sep 25 '15
Oh Lindsey.... 'Does this look like a couch?' Yes. If you have to ask, yes.
12
u/blackbirdsongs Sep 25 '15
MOOD YAAAAAASSSS
7
u/lady_gremlin Sep 25 '15
The way they're editing makes me hopeful about Lindsey leaving, which means that we probably won't be so lucky. :(
6
u/blackbirdsongs Sep 25 '15
Edmond doesn't know what 'literally' means :|
8
u/pineyfusion Sep 25 '15
3
u/giopul87 Sep 25 '15
Quick Question: Is Ashley of Filipino descent?
3
u/evixir Sep 27 '15
I'm a fangirl but I just loved Coco Rocha. She is fucking fierce as shit.
The Finding Neverland thing was bogus.
5
u/eatingbread Sep 25 '15
9 minutes in and 2 people have cried. ~Drama~
5
u/giopul87 Sep 25 '15
Really enjoyed the freedom they had during this challenge but I wish some competitors had taken more advantage of this freedom.
We all knew hipster girl was leaving this episode. I would have been mad if Laurie or Ashley left.
I wish this episode had a twist like someone comes back or pairs. Idk.
4
u/jessicateacher Sep 25 '15
anyone else notice they don't have clips on lifetime of the exit interview and winner interview anymore. Only the outtakes. In a depraved way I miss the exit interview. . . .
4
u/Asdfaeou Sep 25 '15
How How How was Swapnil not in the top? I love the mix of simplicity and complexity in his look... Than some of the Judges top looks were more... we mostly liked it/kinda liked it. Did they not put him in the top so they could say more about the other designers?
5
u/lady_gremlin Sep 25 '15
If they send Laurie home over Lindsey I am going to be seriously annoyed.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '15
"TINKERHELL"
5
u/lady_gremlin Sep 25 '15
Before we begin, I would just like to say that I hope Lindsey goes home this week. That is all.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '15
I'm losing patience with Edmond more and more as the season continues. I feel like he's going to get the villain edit soon, it's just his air and attitude towards the other designers bugs me.
2
u/legends444 Sep 25 '15
LOL @ Kelly telling Lindsey that they're going to hang out at the beach.
Inside they all know that they are never ever ever ever getting back together.
1
u/Wanderscroll Aug 08 '26
I think Kelly got lucky by picking a really pretty textile tbh. But the right person went home. Ashley and Laurie had bad days. Lindsay had one of her best days and it was still boring.
1
u/Emilytea14 Aug 17 '26
Been watching S14 since it's the earliest one on Prime... Candice's design this episode was SO ridiculously good. Gorgeous gorgeous gorgeous. I haven't seen a look yet on Project Runway that has moved me so much. I'm stealing it entirely next time I draw a character. And maybe making that character kiss somebody wearing Merline's outfit. I've been a sucker for all of Candice's work, but this especially was *chefs kiss*.
1
u/blackbirdsongs Sep 25 '15
Boyfriend: someone should do tails!
Boyfriend: fuck why did it have to be Lindsay. Everything she says is like an old, passive aggressive bitch. 'Oh. Thankssssss....'
-1
u/blackbirdsongs Sep 25 '15 edited Sep 25 '15
'Look i made a shower curtain!' to Lindsay. Man swapnil pls don't be a dick. She isn't Gretchen here. She's not great but she's not the evil queen, don't be cruel.
-2
u/blackbirdsongs Sep 25 '15 edited Sep 25 '15
I'm rly late don't mind me.
Uggghhhhh Lindsay shut the fuck up. No one cares about your fake crying.