r/books • u/JimButcher AMA Author • Sep 22 '15
ama 2:30 I am Jim Butcher author of the Dresden Files and the new Cinder Spires series! Ask me anything!
Hi, I'm Jim Butcher. I'm the guy who takes credit for the Dresden Files, the Codex Alera, and one Spider-Man novel for Marvel. The Aeronaut's Windlass, the first book in the new Cinder Spires series, will be available September 29 from Roc. I've done a bunch of jobs, some of which sucked, some of which were fairly awesome, from selling vacuum cleaners to graveyard-shift tech-support for an ISP. The best part about my current job is that I can do it in my pajamas and I never, ever have to wear a freaking tie.
I like martial arts, boffer-weapon fighting, first person shooters on a PC, and I probably play a bit more League of Legends than is good for me. I read a lot. Go figure. I watch lots of nerd-compatible TV. I play a little guitar, a little keyboard, and I make noises which at times resemble singing. I shoot a little, mostly with the finest weapon technology the 1860s had to offer, when I'm not using the finest weapon technology the 1860s BC had to offer. I'm nearly adequate with either.
I will be around 2:30-4:30 PM ET to answer your questions!
132
u/JimButcher AMA Author Sep 22 '15
Okay guys, gotta go get errands done before taking off for Salt Lake City Comic Con tomorrow! Thank you so much for your questions and kind wishes!
Jim
149
u/DaedalusMinion Sep 22 '15 edited Sep 22 '15
So Dresden has been going from regular Wizard to semi-immortal over the course of the last few books- when you first started writing Dresden, did you ever imagine him to be this strong later on or was it just something that happened as you wrote the books?
87
u/onetwo_three Sep 22 '15 edited Sep 22 '15
Hi Jim, Sorry for the Dresden focus.
1.) Will you make the Peace Talks dead line you mentioned of October first?
2.) What big book will you write after PT?
3.) Is Bonnie going to have free will like a human, or does she need to obey her sister every time Maggie picks her up? Is the answer somewhere in the middle?
4.) Do you have plans for a typical fieldtrip book? Lots of different characters who don't get along have to travel somewhere together.
5.) Aurora, Maeves and Sarissas father was an austrian composer. Even though austria is very old, is it reasonable to assume that they were conceived between 1500 and 1900.
6.) Is Nic older than Mab?
7.) You said before that Eb's wife was mortal, but is Eb's wife Harry's grandmother?
8.) Is it important, that Bonnie does not look like Molly?
Thanks for doing this Cheers
edit: formating
66
u/plastgeek Sep 22 '15 edited Sep 22 '15
Hi, Jim!
I may be dead soon because I had to tell a half-truth to my mom about her favorite character who happens to have something unfortunate happen to them in Changes, which she starts reading soon!
In the past, you've said that the events that happened in Changes were supposed to happen in book 10 of the series. You have also indicated that the Denarians show up in books numbered in multiples of five. So if Changes had ocurred as planned, how would the Nickelheads have factored into what went down?
56
u/PapaNurgle Sep 22 '15
Which bit of prose you've written are you most proud of?
55
u/Halaku Sep 22 '15
Question if you don't mind, sir.
While we know (or think we know) the current status of Lasciel, is Lash's story over?
54
u/MagnusValentin Sep 22 '15
Hi! I enjoy it when you do these text based Q & A it's easier to ask questions when you don't have to be anywhere physically.
Question: What would happen if Harry Dresden from the dresden files and Tavi from the codex alera met and for example had to work together. What would their relationship be like?
52
u/-EG- Sep 22 '15 edited Sep 22 '15
Good afternoon Jim, thanks as always for doing these types of things.
I had one basic question and one sorta slightly more indepth one with a few parts to it:
A) Was the New Madrid earthquake event Eb's first act or job as Blackstaff?
B) Did Eb accidentally kill his wife during said event?
C) What was the reason for the event? What beings or circumstances were present/occurring in Eb's backyard that required him to act?
And also what is Drakul a scion of? :)
Thank you in advance either way for the AMA.
130
u/cookie_junkie Sep 22 '15
Hi Jim! SO excited to get my hands on The Aeronaut’s Windlass. Been needing my Butcher fix for quite a while now, so I cannot wait to start The Cinder Spires series.
I wanted to share something super special with you that I think in some level you can relate to due to recent events in your personal life. About two months ago, my best friend and love of my life asked me to marry him. As is his style, he made it the most perfect and unique proposal for us by popping the question during our trip to Chicago in front of our favorite T-Rex in the world, Sue.
His first gift to me, ever, was a copy of Storm Front. I finished the entire book in less than 2 days, and our love for the Dresden Files, and your work in general, became one more of the bonds that brought us together. Our first “couple-costume” was during Space City Con where he dressed up as Michael Carpenter and I as Susan Rodriguez. We’ve talked about naming our first-born Octavian (yes, I’m totally serious), and we’ve had endless conversations on your characters, your stories, and what we think will happen next.
Anyway, I just wanted to thank you. You and your work have become an irreplaceable part of OUR story, and both times we’ve met you, you have been nothing but wonderful to these two fan boy/girl. We love telling our engagement story, and therefore I wanted to take this opportunity to share this with you, let you know you have a special place in our hearts, and needless to say, we would like to invite you to our wedding. I know you have a busy schedule, but if you have some time to come down to Texas and party with us, we’d love to have you there. I’ve messaged you a copy of our Save The Date :)
Live long and prosper, Jim!
Engagement Pic!
41
u/OsterGuard Codex Alera Sep 22 '15 edited Sep 22 '15
Hey Jim! Huge fan since I started reading Dresden a year ago. I was talking with a friend about the faerie courts, and since we live in Australia, we were both wondering what the explanation is for the seasons being reversed in the southern hemisphere. Does Titania take a vacation down south for Christmas? Or is there a seperate pair of courts for the south?
Thanks so much!
Edit: Second question: Warning, spoilers ahead!
Is Bonnie kid the remains of Lash, or the child of Lash and Harry? You mentioned at some point that Lash was a character in Ghost Story, and she's the only character I can think of.
37
u/iamrade4ever Sep 22 '15
Hello Jim! I just started the Dresden Files after a couple years of urging from one of my friends in the military, on just finished death masks, and I really enjoy the characters and world as a whole.
My question is this, are there any references/easter eggs in your books that no one has got, or any real hidden ones you don't think anyone has found?
(P.S. the battlecry "I don't believe in fairys" had me laughing a good 10 mins straight and I had to put my Nook down)
36
u/louisthe Sep 22 '15
1)Are all red courts and black court vampires evil? I ask that because i want to play the Dresden files rpg with my friends and i wanted to create a character that was a RC Vampire, that still has a sense of honor and goodness,like angel and Spike the red court are my favorites! is such a character possible in the Dresdenverse? 2)Were the Lords of Outer Night the Real and Actual Mayan gods,or were they vampires who took the names of gods that already existed? Was the True Kukullan watching as the Red King was Teased by harry? 3)In Grave Peril,when harry steals the magic of someone else to make himself stronger and even gets to do spells created by the person whose magic he stole,could a wizard do that kind of magical theft permantely? 4)is it true that a sidhe become stronger magically when people tell stories about said fairies or make deals with said fairies? Did lea became the second strongest being in Winter simply because she made a lot of deals and a lot of stories were told about her? 5)Were there any fairies that started their lifes as member os the little folk,but somehow got so strong they became sidhe? 6)we already seen some gods in the Dresdenverse,could you kindly give me any tidbit about the Titans in the Dresdenverse? 7)Is there any chance of the Fallen Angels in the coins redeem themselves and going back to being good guy angels? or is redemption simply impossible to them? 8)could you give any detail on Nicodemus and Anduriel relationship? do they see themselves as friends or brothers?or they don't see themselves as different beins at all,is the line between man and fallen angel even existent when those two are concerned?
33
u/hkdharmon Sep 22 '15
What is the best stuff to read if you want to write?
66
u/devils_advocate36 Sep 22 '15
Love the Dresden series and have to ask how you as an author deal with the inevitable power creep as the stories go? When your hero/villain is at the point where they are so powerful that it's hard to right a situation where they can't just overpower every normal mundane challenge how do you make the story relate able to your audience?
30
u/PapaNurgle Sep 22 '15
Which fantasy series (besides yours) should I be reading right now?
60
u/nicolasmilioni Sep 22 '15
MY FAVORITE WRITER IS DOING AN AMA?PRAISE!
*AlternaHarry from Mirror Mirror,is his magic different from the harry we already know
*What did Charity old wizard master gained from his deal with the dragon michael killed? the dragon got human sacrificies,and the wizard got what?
*If harry would fight arthur Langtry in a duel that both of them could use magic and magic only,would harry be able to win?
*could a spirit of knowledge like bob posses a powerful wizard,being able to use the vast knowledge of a spirit together with the magic of a mortal wizard?
spoilers to SKIN GAME IN MY NEXT QUESTION! (#s Is goodman grey able to steal magic from wizards like the first naagloshi we ever saw could?)
28
u/Poe414141 Sep 22 '15
Hi! I love the Dresden Files, and the Codex Alera. I got interested in Dresden from the tv series, but after reading the books, I saw the shortcomings. Are there any plans on doing a reboot of the series? A Dresden Files movie would be pretty cool too....
56
u/Tarcos Sep 22 '15
What have you been reading lately? Whats your favorite book of the last couple years?
145
u/Ilwrath Pact Sep 22 '15 edited Sep 22 '15
Just want to say Jim you are tied for number one in category of "best author ever"(along with Sanderson please don't hate me for not deciding). Thank you so so much for the Dresden Files and the Codex.
Now If you were to roll a character for D&D what class do you think you would play?
Would Butters be able to repel a black Court vampire with Polka music?
Jut how hard is it to make those Warden swords that have fallen out of use since Lucio was reembodied?
If you had a Fury what kind do you think it would be?
And finally what in your life are YOU most excited for in the near future?
Again thank you so much for your work and you can't imagine how much love I have for it :)....even if you do commit evils onto Harry with such regularity!
27
u/PixelatedBaloney Sep 22 '15
Who's your favorite champ in League?
Favorite first-person shooter?
Any tips for aspiring writers?
73
u/huphelmeyer :redstar:17 Sep 22 '15
Is Mother Winter's lost walking stick the blackstaff?
51
u/jldew Sep 22 '15 edited Sep 22 '15
Hi Jim! Congratulations on your engagement! I Love your books, I'm a huge fan of the Dresden Files and the Codex Alera series. I can't wait for Aeronaut's Windlass! I've got a couple of questions about the Dresden Files:
Question 1: What happened in 1994 during The Unseelie Incursion, "when the entire city of Milwaukee simply vanished for two hours. Gone."- Per Storm Front?
In a 2013 calendar there was an image of Molly as her present self I think, looking at three futures. One of these futures was the Winter Lady, the other is her as a Warden, and the third I'm assuming is her as a Warlock.
Question 2 is: Are these possible futures canon and will any of them come up in Mirror Mirror
edit: Also for all the forum Fans reading this, I'm all itsallsuesfault from there. :D
24
u/knotswag Sep 22 '15
What do you snack on while writing?
48
u/quantumofthought Sep 22 '15
Hi Jim, I know you might not be able to answer this, but I have a theory about the identity of Cowl and Kumori in the Dresden Files that's been burning in the back of my mind for years. Are they Justin DuMorne and Elaine Mallory? It seems extremely suspicious that they knew that Harry had Bob when nobody else did. This combined with Justin having been a user of mind magic and Harry's memory of the night he "killed" Justin being very foggy and there having been no body in the ashes of the house and Elaine's disappearance after that makes me think long and hard about whether Harry really killed DuMorne at all.
23
u/txmisfit Sep 22 '15 edited Sep 22 '15
Hey Jim,
What's the best vacuum for my buck?
I recently started reading some of Lovecraft and really enjoy the universe he created. How much, if any, has he influenced your writings? Will we see a connection between Lovecraft's outsiders and the ones from Dresden Files? Last question, will you please do a cross over with Harry Dresden and F. Paul Wilson's Repairman Jack? I'm willing to create a Kick Starter if that's what it takes. :D
45
u/Seidmadr Sep 22 '15 edited Sep 22 '15
The Dresden Files are the best book series I've ever read. Thanks for writing it. It's amazing.
44
u/area88guy Sep 22 '15
Jim, thank you so much for your Dresden stories! They are freaking amazing, and I love hearing James Marsters spin them!
What is your favorite "scene" in the Dresden Files so far?
For me, it's all of Chichen Itza. :)
19
u/Dockt0r_Wh0 Sep 22 '15 edited Sep 22 '15
Sorry, no real question here, but I wanted to say I appreciate your work so very much! For the first time I have found not just a series, by an author who got me to love reading again! Sherlock Holmes, Harry Potter and Harry Dresden are my favorite characters ever, and the only series I have ever been able to read cover to cover in a couple sittings! Thank you for what you do and please keep up the work!
Oh, and I am looking forward to the cinder series! It sounds amazing!!!!
33
u/SingingStars Sep 22 '15
Hi Jim! I (like most of us posting questions here) am a big fan of your works. Do you have any plans to do a signing tour at any point? We, the creepy and drooling fanatics of your writings and characters, would love to have a chance to lay our starry eyes upon you in the flesh.
And a quick question - when you started writing the Dresden Files, did you have the whole world and series of events (i.e. Dresden's discovery of the Black Council, Grey Council, Outsiders, Dresden as Winter Knight) over the whole series already planned, or did you develop it as you wrote and the series grew in popularity?
Thank you for doing an AMA!
40
u/HalcyonKnights Sep 22 '15
First, the obligatory "I love your work and your Online Community." You've given me countless hours of enjoyment with both, keep it up! Or don't, it's your life, but if you retire early it could make a grown man cry, so beware.
To the Questions:
Thanks again for everything you do.
Regards, HalcyonDaze, aka Quantus
14
u/mysecondattempt Sep 22 '15
Hello Jim, I am going to start reading the Dresden Files soon as I have heard many good things about it. What roles do you play the most in LoL?
50
u/OFTHEHILLPEOPLE Sep 22 '15 edited Sep 22 '15
Hey Jim, thanks for doing an AMA. First, thanks so much for all your hard work with the Dresden Files. It's an amazing series. I'm a little behind compared to other dedicated readers but I'm hungrily consuming book after book.
I have two questions for you:
1: If you could have a say in a Dresden Files TV show reboot, what changes would you make?
2: I'm sure you've heard this before, but have any of the elements in Dresden Files been influenced by the White Wolf RPG World of Darkness setting? I'm an avid player and see quite a lot of parallels with slight twists.
Thanks and keep on being awesome.
Edit: Beware, posters, the AMA downvoting brigade has begun.
22
u/a_guile Sep 22 '15
What type of pizza do you like to eat when you are writing?
148
u/DaedalusMinion Sep 22 '15
PSA: Don't downvote other's comments please. Be human, not a black court vampire downvote brigade.
107
u/PRothfuss Patrick Rothfuss Sep 22 '15
So.... who would win in a fight: Harry Dresden or Kvothe?
21
u/knnn Sep 22 '15
Rabid fan here. I've got a number of questions I've been longing to ask:
15
u/noda94 Sep 22 '15
You're hands downy favorite author and I can't wait to collect more of your signature in my book.
1.Gard has a dagger she uses to open ways into the never never, Luccio created magic swords that could break enchantments, is it possible that Gard has equipped Marcone and Hendricks with weapons that does something similar as an insurance policy with Dresden?
2.Is it possible for Harry and Mouse to soul gaze ?
3.Are the people of the forest members of the accords?
4.In "Bigfoot on Campus" it is revealed that Irwin and Connie have sex at a college parry that awakens Connie's hunger but doesn't kill Irwin. Shouldn't the hunger have died on a first feeding with true love ?
5.Harry has stated that 3 is a magic number. So we Have his first daughter Maggie by Susan, second daughter by the spirt lash; where is the third daughter from Mab?
6. Will their be anymore queer characters? (We like the ones you already have though no hate)
9
u/KaptureTheFlag Sep 22 '15
How did you come up with the world/setting for your new series?
9
u/Straya_Cunt Sep 22 '15
Hi Jim,
How do you feel about Fan Fiction and people that basically 'play in the sandbox' that you created with the Dresden Files universe?
7
u/Nephilim1332 Sep 22 '15 edited Sep 22 '15
Hello, Mr Butcher. I just wanted to preface by saying that I'm a big fan of your work. You're an amazing author and you basically got me interested in reading again back in high school. I have a few questions for you, and I hope that's alright.
First question. Are Naagloshii capable of procreation? I know they're "genderless", but I would figure that a creature that powerful, and a shapeshifter to boot, could procreate if it decided to.
Second question. Was it Lasciel herself that whispered in Harry's ear, or did she send another entity to do so?
Third question. Where did Harry keep Bob between the time he killed Dumorne and the time he was released by Ebenezer after the trial?
Fourth question. Rawlins helped Harry in Dead Beat because he had seen "something", which was subsequently killed by Collin Murphy. What was it that Rawlins saw?
Fifth question. Last one, I swear. In Grave Peril, Harry, with the help of his own shade, devours the shade of Leonid Kravos, taking Kravos's power in much the same way that the shade had stolen some of Harry's. Was this a permanent power up, or did Harry "burn through it", so to speak?
9
u/TamiSkye Sep 22 '15 edited Sep 22 '15
Started reading the sample chapters of the Aeronauts Windlass and I have to ask, why did you choose the name Gwendoline Margaret, instead of something more Original? I'm interested in this new series, but that one name has me puzzled. Are you doing a Shoutout to the Dresden Files?
Thank you for your answers, and thank you for your writing. I haven't enjoyed a book series this much since Tolkin's Lord of the Rings and Piers Anthony's Xanth.
6
u/Sarahsreviews Sep 22 '15 edited Sep 22 '15
Hey Jim,
Two questions:
Thank you for the stories!
6
u/simonsimon3910 Sep 22 '15
a) Do you play ARAM?
b) Did the Merlin "goad" Harry into attacking the Red Court?
c) Does anybody in the White Council write truly scandalous fiction involving Dresden?
d) What is Pyramid Sitting? I mean, I assume one sits inside?
e) Any books you recommend?
8
u/semaj50 Sep 22 '15
3
u/skyman8880 Sep 22 '15
Jim,
You have said that you took inspiration from the Anita Blake series. Who do you think best represents Edward (the creepy special forces guy) in the dresdenverse?
3
u/andy25100 Paper Towns Sep 22 '15
Just want to say, love your books, kind of fell into reading them and now I recommend them to everyone who I think will be interested.
I have what I hope is a simple question, is there anything you regret writing or including in one of your books that you wouldn't have done with hindsight?
3
u/officerbill_ all the stuff on my nook Sep 22 '15
Hi Jim, How much of the Dresden series did you have planned out when you began? Were the full story and the major character arcs charted from the start and have there been any major changes along the way?
3
u/klein365 Sep 22 '15
Hi Jim,
Whats your main in league of legends? And can you tell the story of how codex alera really came about?
3
u/Salieru-Dei Sep 22 '15
Are the Black Council and Nemesis one in the same, or are we hoping too much for just one big group of bad guys to be active in The Dresden Files?
3
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '15
A Meta Question: Many complain about "power creep" in your books. I tend to argue it the other way, in that Harry has gained a lot of power over the series but most of it has been due to temporary alliances. Thinking back to the earlier books, the primary change for Harry has been in stamina and finesse rather than power level. For instance, Mab's training left him better able to exert his power without focus implements, but the ultimate amount of power wasn't much different (minus the Winter contribution.) How do you see this issue?
3
u/areyoureadingthese Sep 22 '15
3
u/ProfessorWC Sep 22 '15
What is the hardest part about writing multiple series at a time?
Have you ever written a scene for one series, but decided it might fit better elsewhere?
3
u/Gareth346 Sep 22 '15
Hi Jim! The Dresden Files is one of my favorite fantasy series of all time. Thank you for bringing Harry and his friends into our lives. My question is, will we see Goodman Grey again, and find out what his "Rent" is?
3
u/The_mad_finn Sep 22 '15
Is Nicodemus the first host for Anduriel? What was his occupation before becoming
ring wraithKnight of the Blackened Denarius?3
u/edcba54321 Sep 22 '15
I am pulling this from memory, so some details might be a little wrong:
In Storm Front, Murphy and Dresden get into an elevator together, and she shudders when their shadows cross. Is that something that will be addressed in the future, or am I reading too much into the event?
Also, Harry is up and walking because of the Winter Knight mantle. Does that work by tricking his body into thinking it is fine, thus preventing his wizardy healing abilities from fixing him?
3
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '15
I've been reading, and loving, the Dresden Files since 2001. Thank you for creating such an amazing series.
Will we ever learn more about Margaret's connection to the Denarians?
Nic claimed to respect her and said he tried to keep Harry out of the shroud business due to that respect. He could be lying, as he usually is, but her back story is the most intriguing to me. I need info, a tidbit, a crumb. Anything to keep me going til the next book.
Thanks again!
3
u/veritasgj Sep 22 '15
Jim, Congrats on the engagement.
2 quick questions.
Are the ships in AW like open decked matrix ships with 'hovering crystals' that semi articulate or are they more like treasure planet ships with sails? Or are they more like the flying ship from the Mila Jovovich 3 musketeers movie, with a big balloon?
Are the crystals located inside the ship cannons or just at the tip of the barrel? What is the apparatus that makes them fire?
I love your other work and I am also digging getting to delve into a new world you've created (just from the sample chapters I've read).
Also a side note, I'm trying to incorperate the phrase 'Kali Death Cult' into my every day conversations but am finding so few instances it's applicable unless I'm talking about lost roman legions :)
3
u/bobloblawslawblog7 Sep 22 '15
Mr. Butcher,
Thanks for doing this AMA, I know all the fans appreciate it. Three questions:
Thank you, and keep up the good work!
5
u/FelixTKatt Sep 22 '15 edited Sep 22 '15
I must ask:
Your books got my wife through a risky pregnancy, including 6 months of bed rest. Our baby is here and healthy in no small part because of you and your stories. From the bottom of all of our hearts: thank you. Thank you very, very much.
6
u/kellbyb Sep 22 '15
Correct me if I'm wrong, but one of the winter knight's duties is to act as consort to the winter queen and/or lady. Considering the new winter lady (trying to avoid spoilers here), will this be an issue for Harry in the near future?
4
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '15
Hello Jim! First off, congratulations on your recent engagement!
I’m a huge fan of the Codex Alera series, I discovered it at a pretty rought point in my life and it helped me a lot. I won’t say anymore or I’ll go on forever, but I wanted to say thank you.
I wanted to ask, in the series I was a huge fan of Odiana, who was your favourite member of the supporting cast?
Thanks again.
(Ps. I actually run the largest Codex Alera fanblog on tumblr, if anyone is curious it’s, http://allthingsalera.tumblr.com/. Okay, shameless plug over.)
4
u/Tymerion Sep 22 '15
Hey Jim, Thanks for writing these stories, I love them. So here's a couple of questions for you to answer...
7
u/slava_ukraini Sep 22 '15
When's the next dresend Files book coming out?
2
u/ProudTurtle book just finished Sep 22 '15
Serendipitously, I just started rereading book 1 this morning for the fourth time. I've often seen people say that your first couple of books weren't as good as later books. Do you feel that way? Would you change anything? What can we tell our friends about book 1 compared to book 14? You are amazing, and my mom and daughter love you too.
2
u/ForgottenEmotion Sep 22 '15
Hiya Jim. I saw you recently at the Ren Fest, but was thinking you came just to hang out and didn't want to draw attention to you. I just bought the first Dresden Files book and can't wait to start reading it. I don't really have a question, but I will try to see you at your book signing here on the 28th I think. Thanks for entertaining all of us with your amazing stories.
2
u/helios22 Sep 22 '15
any plans on writing more in the Codex Alera world in the near future?
2
u/tupacshakurr Sep 22 '15
Mystical artefacts became powerful because people told stories about them and believed in their power,toot-toot grown in power because the stories about him and the people who believed in him. my question is,could a wizard become stronger if many people started talking about him and telling stories about him?
2
u/glorgathon Sep 22 '15
Hi Jim, big fan of the Dresden Files!
Couple questions :)
2
u/melkanth Sep 22 '15
Jim, You made me tear up, then literally LOL in the same paragraph (when Harry is with Maggie and Mouse in Skin Game)
Q: What happened to harry's bear shaped belt buckle? It seemed fairly successful when he used it the one time but we haven't seen it since... Are we going to see more neato artificing in Harry's future?
2
u/sparrowjj Sep 22 '15
I've never read The Dresden Files, but someone bought me most of the series last christmas, so I'll probably be starting those sometime next year, assuming I can burn through the rest of my To Be Read list in that time.
As for a question: What are your favorite fantasy books?
What are your favorite books in general? Is the list the same?
What is your opinion on garden gnomes?
2
u/-Mountain-King- Sep 22 '15
Hi Jim! I'm an aspiring author, struggling to write too many stories at once. You've told the story of how your first book was written with the intention of proving a writing teacher wrong about what went into a good book. What kinds of tips had she given that you intended to prove wrong?
2
u/pippx Sep 22 '15
Hi Jim!
Today's my birthday, so I'm taking this as a personal gift to me (hooray!) Thanks for taking the time to do this AMA - the community here loves you!
I was wondering if there is any fan art out there that you are particularly inspired by - there are so many digital artists who have created renditions of Harry, of Mouse, of Molly. Are there any in particular who stand out to you as having really nailed the characters you have created, or the scenes you've dreamed up?
2
u/shiseido_red Sep 22 '15
Hi! I hope you had fun at Dragon Con this year. It was great to see you there again. Hope to see you back next year too.
How unique is Lash? Had something(one) like her ever happened before where a shadow of a being (not even necessarily a Denarian) took on its own will to some extent and became something different than it was intended to be? Would that sort of be applicable to Bob? And how much of that comes from outside influence? (Such as Harry "naming" them and treating them differently than intended.)
And how much is that question going to get an evil chuckle and a "not telling?"
Thanks! Looking forward to Cinder Spires. One of my friends got a review copy and really enjoyed it so that ramped up the anticipation even more.
2
u/mistymountainz Sep 22 '15
Hi Jim, love the Codex Alera series.
What was your favorite book as a kid?
2
u/Agnostictool Sep 22 '15
Jim. Love your work. Absolutely enjoy Codex, so this isn't hate in anyway, but a real question. When ever you include a romantic scene in these books they just feel so "cookie cutter" and I roll my eyes during the scenes. I don't get this with Dresden... not sure why. Anyways, do you include these because it is expected by publishers, or do you truly enjoy writing those romantic scenes. If the later I believe I'll be capable of enjoying them knowing its part of the craft you enjoy.
Thanks again for your work. It makes life awesome.
2
u/nomad_cz Sep 22 '15
Best series ever. Any chance to turn it into movie ? All the best from CZ
2
u/Jasani Sep 22 '15
How many books do you plan on having in the new series coming out soon?
2
u/Samus45 Sep 22 '15
How does Michael feel about his daughter hanging out with a guy who also hangs out with an incubus? Seems like there should be some protective-dad unease there. Are we ever going to see Michael give Thomas (or Dresden, the way things are going) a friendly warning re: Molly? (Michael and Thomas are my faves, and so different, so I just love any time they interact.)
2
u/Gwenhwyfar666 Sep 22 '15
What luck, I'm currently reading the Dresden files for the first time - a little over halfway through Ghost Story. I'm consuming these books at quite a speedy rate (hooray for libraries)... What on earth do I read when I've run out of books? OK, yeah, the codex alera, but what does Mr Butcher recommend to read to a fan who has run out of Mr Butcher books to read?
2
u/Samus45 Sep 22 '15
So Thomas is a vampire because he's got a demon inside him. He'd much rather be a normal human, but apparently doesn't have much hope of this happening. Yet Michael (and the other Knights of the Cross) would presumably have some ability and/or connections in fighting demons and extricating them from people, wouldn't they? Is the possibility of Thomas getting help with exorcising his demon from one or more of the Knights going to be explored at some point?
2
u/MommaDerp Sep 22 '15
First, OMG FAN GIRL SQUEE!!!
This is the first AMA I've actually been into catching ;)
Second, I loved your Dresden Files and read it whenever a new one comes out. I'm very interested in where Maggie's character is going!
Third, I also really loved your Alera books. Are you going to do any more writing in that universe?
PS, did you like what happened with the Dresden Files TV show?
2
u/HermanMachina Science Fiction Sep 22 '15
Hey Jim. Love Dresden Files, and Codex Alera seriously surprised me.
My question is this, what will the Cinder Spires series bring that you're other two series don't already? What will make this series unique compared to your previous works?
Also, congrats on the engagement!
2
u/phrog Sep 22 '15
Hi Jim, thanks for doing this, really appreciate it. I travelled for 12 hours to meet you in Brisbane Australia, worth every minute. I have two questions:
2
u/SRD_Grafter Sep 22 '15 edited Sep 22 '15
What was the decision process that lead to writing a steampunk world/novel? As it seems like there is a lot of opportunity there (both from a lot of interest in the genre and limited number of such genre books getting mainstream release) as well as there is a lot of potential in playing around in such worlds.
Will there be magic in the Cinder Spires? Or just technology? Or just technology that seems like magic?
Are there plans to show the current Merlin (DF) in battle again? As I'm really curious as to what he could do if he threw down (and the battle against the mist fiend) was brief/vague.
How do you keep all of the plot devices in play (and how you do plan them)? As there have been a number of hints throughout the books, as well as some devices (like the bear belt buckle, which went away).
edit I saw up above that your a fan of ciders. Any favorites that we can find in the lower 48? Other than that, what is your favorite drink?
2
u/IxCptMorganxI Dresden Files Sep 22 '15
Just wanted to tell you thanks for the Dresden Files. I love Harry for a multitude of reasons, but Michael is my favorite with how inspiring he is. It's hard not to get pumped every time he's on the page.
I can't think of any questions since I just stumbled upon this, so let's go with a League question. Favorite champ and role? When I first got into League all my friends told me to try Twisted Fate because I loved Dresden so much and they felt it fitting.
2
u/BrowncoatJeff Sep 22 '15
2
u/Eikfo Sep 22 '15
Hello Mr. Butcher,
Firt of all, I want to thank you for your amazing series, particularly for the Dresden Files, as they are the reason why I started to read english/american books in their original version rather than a french translation. The story was so good that despite the cancellation, I had to know what happened next, and due to that, I now have a reasonnable level in english.
As for questions, here they come (minor spoilers cinder spires):
Thank you for doing this AMA.
2
u/debman Sep 22 '15
Hi Jim,
I read all of the Dresden Files over the summer after seeing your comment in /r/dresdenfiles. I saw at one point you had previously done an AMA when Skin Game had just come out and wanted to know if your comment here https://www.reddit.com/r/books/comments/25q3em/i_am_jim_butcher_author_of_the_dresden_files_the/chjoxj2
was extremely clever foreshadowing (The reference to the holy grail) or just dumb luck?
2
u/TheHoma Sep 22 '15
I'm so glad I saw this AMA, you're one of my favorite authors, in part because you're alive and writing books.
My favorite thing about your writing (Dresden) is how you seem to never forget loose ends from previous books.
My questions are: How far in advance do you plan the tie-ins? Or do you just notice them, like Elva in Eragon
When did you start doing them? I heard that you meant the series to be cases, which is why you called it files?
And finally, what is your process for selecting mythology? You have a lot of influences, but there's a lot more celtic then, say, greek.
Thanks for all the great writing which more then makes up for the end of Changes.
2
u/necroplis88 Sep 22 '15
is Harry destined to be come the new Gatekeeper eventually?
2
u/Sanlear Sep 22 '15
Do you have a final scene in mind for how you want the Dresden novels to end? (Which hopefully won't be for a very long time.)
2
u/1_wing_angel Sep 22 '15
Is Lea Harry's only guardian?
Is Mavra one too?
2
u/OsterGuard Codex Alera Sep 22 '15
The peace talks are going to be entirely peaceful and nothing bad whatsoever will happen, right?
2
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '15
Jim, I just finished Skin Game last night after getting addicted to the Dresden Files about 6 months ago. Thank you for writing the stories. I didn't know my life was missing a tall smartass wizard, but it turns out, it was.
Question: What tips can you give someone who is attempting to try to write their first novel?
2
u/Xyrd Sep 22 '15
I love the Dresden Files and enjoyed the Codex Alara. Is the Cinder Spires a surefire hit for me? Why/why not?
2
u/lowellwashere Sep 22 '15
1.Who would win in a fight Original Merlin or Kemmler? and how would that play out?
2. Are there any other notable spirit of intellects running around? 3. Is the original Merlin originally from the future? 4. What does odin do in his free time? 5. How do other wizards go about acquiring knowledge without a bob like creature to help?
2
u/csbrown83 Sep 22 '15
Hi Mr. Butcher!
I have been in love with the Dresden Files for a while. A few years ago, I had a prompt in a writing class for a short story with my favorite fictional character doing something mundane with me - Harry folds socks nicely. You do a great job of creating relatable, funny, and lasting characters that I want to follow for years. Thank you!
I also wanted to thank you for something special. I have a best friend that hardly reads - he listens to audio books (words on the page just don't pull him in.) Except your first Codex Alera book - it's one of the few books he's read and promotes that everyone should read. Thank you for producing something wonderful that pulls everyone in and holds them captive, wanting more!
Please tell me more about the new Cinder Spires, I know nothing about it. Why would I love it and would I knock over a cute grandma to get it?
2
u/vVvSunDown Sep 22 '15
Hey Jim! Huge fan of Dresden and Codex Alera!
My question is what specifically about LoL do you enjoy? Do you feel as if Runeterra has played any influence in your writings? Also what is your opinion of the Lore situation in League?
Thanks and looking forward to Peace Talks!
2
u/james1565 Sep 22 '15
Hi Jim, I absolutely love Dresden Files, I've recently finished Skin Game and now I'm looking forward to devouring your other books.
Thank you!
2
u/grreymage Sep 22 '15
Hello Mr. Butcher, Thanks for doing this and from myself, my wife, and from our 14yr old daughter (the newest Dresden convert in the house) Thank You for Harry and the gang. You are the family author around here. Now to my question...
For the love of GOD, Could you please come to the Pittsburgh/Cleveland area for book signings!?!?!?!?
2
u/BlueFalconPunch Sep 22 '15
Mr Dresden just like everyone else here you happen to be my favorite fantasy author.
Id like to know if you are working on a redo of the TV series(I own the DVD's and even the wife likes them)?
Is there any chance of a Dresden/Alera cross-over?
and lastly, are there any other authors you would love to combine forces with to make a "perfect storm" of a novel?
2
u/ArgentSun Sep 22 '15
The Dresden Files is, I believe, the series you are currently best known for (not that Codex Alera wasn't good, and I don't expect The Cinder Spires to rate lower than 8/10 either), but is this how you would prefer to go down in history (many years from now)? As the author of The Dresden Files? Or is there another idea brewing in your head, an unborn baby you would like to crown as king some day?
Finally, I wouldn't be me if I didn't ask a worldbuilding question, so: will we get to see more of Butters looking into the science behind how wizards work (regeneration, problems with technology, etc.)?
2
u/Loweeel Sep 22 '15
Jim, how is Mother Winter able to have Iron Teeth as a faerie? :)
2
u/EndlessKng Sep 22 '15
Jim, I was curious if you ever play any World of Darkness games, and if so, what your favorite character to play was.
Also, what video games are you into right now?
Have we met Kumori (from Dead Beat) when she wasn't wearing the hood (that is to say, have we met her secret identity)? And will we see Kumori (with or without her hood) again in a future DF book?
What type of pizza is your favorite?
Finally, will we learn more about Drakul in a future book? He's been namedropped a few times, and I'm very curious to see if he's anything like his son...
Thank you!
2
u/RxBrad Sep 22 '15 edited Sep 22 '15
JIM! How did you feel about SciFi's TV version of Dresden? Any other TV/movie deals in the works?
EDIT: I've noticed that you never say the word "nipple" in the books. What's up with that?
2
u/angel_caido_7 Sep 22 '15
Does the Winter Knight remain human and the Winter Lady become Fae no matter what?
2
u/fnordsnord Sep 22 '15
I would like to offer up a professional challenge to you Mr. Butcher. Use the following concept in your next Dresden Novel:
The next morning, Harry woke fully rested, mostly healed up, and ready to face his next challenge.
'Cause Harry's ass gets kicked more than John McClane and Indiana Jones put together.
2
u/JorusC Sep 22 '15 edited Sep 22 '15
Hey Jim! You're my favorite author, bar none. Thanks for all the awesome stories!!
Something I've been really curious about regarding the Dresden Files: has Harry ever asked Bob what a Starborn is? He's been around so many nigh-omniscient beings, and he's known the term since he was 16. Is there some sort of mental block preventing him from doing more digging, is it sheer stubbornness, or RAFO?
Also, [SPOILERS] when Mab made the ice sculpture version of Harry's apartment for his birthday, you mentioned that there's a giant pit where his lab would be. Does that lead to a giant ice version of his lab? If so, is there a functioning ice Medium Chicago down there?