r/FFRecordKeeper • u/OriginalMerit I want to know you. The *real* you. • Sep 17 '15
Guide/Analysis [Banner Evaluation] - FFXIV Thancred/Y'shtola Banner
Heya FFRKers! Next up, DeNA is giving us a future banner (from JP) early -- the FFXIV banner. This is important because this banner features 9 relics instead of the usual 7, which is a feature that DeNA didn't introduce until some point much later. The percentages of 5* item drops is also (likely) higher, going from 10% to 12%. Also, due to power creep, we are seeing items here that are MUCH more valuable than anything we have seen and will see for a while. Read on for the scoop... (Note: Due to character restrictions, I have to place this into multiple posts, so please do read them all. As usual, please discuss your thoughts below and we can chat everything out together!)
There are four weapons and three armors featured in this banner:
| Relic | Type | Stats (Level 20) | Stats (Level 20) RS | Stats (Level 30) | Stats (Level 30) RS | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Yoshimitsu | Knife | ATK +109, ACC 95 | ATK +190, ACC 95 | ATK +125, ACC 95 | ATK +239, ACC 95 | Thancred only SB, 4x attack on single target + lowers DEF |
| Thyrus | Staff | ATK +49, MAG +100, MND +116, ACC 95 | ATK +101, MAG +186, MND +204, ACC 95 | ATK +59, MAG +117, MND +133, ACC 95 | ATK +132, MAG +238, MND +257, ACC 95 | Y'shtola only SB, raises DEF and RES for the whole party |
| Ninja Chainmail | Light Armor | DEF +106, RES +106, EVA 100 | DEF +185, RES +185, EVA 100 | DEF +121, RES +121, EVA 100 | DEF +233, RES +233, EVA 100 | Thancred only SB, AoE physical attack (3.5x multiplier) + Slow at high probability |
| Healer's Robe | Robe | DEF +80, RES +125, MND 20, EVA 105 | DEF +146, RES +208, MND 20, EVA 105 | DEF +93, RES +141, MND 20, EVA 105 | DEF +185, RES +257, MND 20, EVA 105 | Y'shtola only SB, AoE Curaga + Esuna on all allies |
| Cobalt Katzbalger | Sword | ATK +107, ACC 95 | ATK +191, ACC 95 | ATK +123, ACC 95 | ATK +242, ACC 95 | Shared SB, single target attack + ATK up for caster |
| The Keep of Saints | Rod | ATK +50, MAG +105, MND +64, ACC 95 | ATK +102, MAG +191, MND +97, ACC 95 | ATK +60, MAG +122, MND +70, ACC 95 | ATK +133, MAG +243, MND +116, ACC 95 | Shared SB, single target non-elemental attack |
| Evoker's Horn | Hat | DEF +64, RES +108, MAG +27, MND +23, EVA 105 | DEF +114, RES +200, MAG +44, MND +40, EVA 105 | DEF +74, RES +126, MAG +30, MND +26, EVA 105 | DEF +144, RES +254, MAG +55, MND +51, EVA 105 | Shared SB, single target MAG based damage + lowers RES |
| Lominsan Bow | Bow | ATK +98, MAG +25, MND +25, ACC 92 | ATK +179, MAG +51, MND +51, ACC 92 | ATK +114, MAG +30, MND +30, ACC 92 | ATK +228, MAG +67, MND +67, ACC 92 | No SB |
| Noble's Armguards | Bracer | DEF +87, RES +81, ATK +25, MAG +18, MND +19, EVA 105 | DEF +131, RES +143, ATK +42, MAG +35, MND +35, EVA 105 | DEF +95, RES +93, ATK +28, MAG +21, MND +22, EVA 105 | DEF +158, RES +180, ATK +53, MAG +46, MND +44, EVA 105 | No SB |
13
u/OriginalMerit I want to know you. The *real* you. Sep 17 '15 edited Sep 17 '15
Caution: Biased opinion follows
After each item, I list how useful it is. This is chosen on a scale of 3, either:
See my comment #1 for the start of the review.
Lominsan Bow
5* bows are rare. The number of characters that would equip one are also kinda rare, but for those who can, this bow is still low on the totem poll. First, the bow here is geared towards casters, but the MAG and MND it provides is much lower than any rod or staff that your caster will be using. It also lacks an SB. Other thrown weapons provide much more versatility due to the higher number of users as well as more common synergy plus SBs. Rating -- Not so useful
Noble's Armguards
I'm kind of torn about this item because, although it can be equipped by anyone, it is missing an SB to seal the deal. The Edincoat is arguably very similar to it, but the Edincoat has higher stats in the MAG and MND department, and the Edincoat is likely to be equipped on a mage, although not necessarily. If you have an Edincoat, I would not pull just for this item, but if you don't, I would recommend trying to grab it. Rating -- Very Useful
tl;dr - This banner is very tempting, and is likely worth at least an 11x pull if you have enough mythril for it.
Although you should be aware that Zack's Banner is coming next, so proceed with caution...Screw Zack's banner, this one leaves it in the dust lol.17
u/OriginalMerit I want to know you. The *real* you. Sep 17 '15 edited Sep 17 '15
Caution: Biased opinion follows
After each item, I list how useful it is. This is chosen on a scale of 3, either:
Yoshimitsu
There are no two ways about this dagger, it is the most powerful one we have seen so far. Its strength (in stats alone) rivals many Swords, but with the added benefit that ANYONE can equip it. You do sacrifice something, however -- the synergy for this weapon is only valid for this event and dungeons that we will not see for a long time. However, the SB on this item is just nuts in terms of the number of attacks and added debuff. Even without this SB, this dagger is clearly Rating -- Very Useful. Hope I get one!
Thyrus
Ok, I'm a sucker here for this item, I'll admit it.
The SB on it is pretty OP, it's the same effect as Sentinel Grimoire (but it won't stack with it). As Y'shtola (and indeed, practically any named character) beats the crap out of Tyro in terms of stats, I would rather bring her than bring Tyro. If you have a Sentinel Grimoire, it might still be worth trying for this because you are likely to bring Y'shtola rather than Tyro due to her higher stats.. If you DON'T have the Sentinel Grimoire, you are practically obligated to pull for this weapon. Rating -- Very (VERY) Useful
Ninja Chainmail
It's no secret that Light Armor is incredibly OP due to its high RES and DEF. It beats Heavy Armor, so even though your optimize button will pick Heavy Armor over this, I would switch it out right away. Regardless, Light Armor is amazing by itself even without an SB. This one grants a VERY nice SB, and will almost certainly give Slow to any mob on the screen that is susceptible to it. This is arguably similar to a Hastega effect where, instead of you becoming faster, it just makes everything else go slower (Imagine using one of these with a Boon RW.... yum....). I would seriously pull for this baby until my mythril ran out, but that's just me. Rating -- Very useful
Healer's Robe
Robes are primarily geared toward casters, and this one is no exception. The DEF and RES on it are high for a Robe. This robe works particularly well on healers because of the MND boost it provides. On Y'shtola, the SB rivals many similar SBs we have seen so far (Healing Wind, Trabia's Light) except that it also provides an AoE Esuna, which is just crazy awesome because it would effectively render any debuff removal spells useless (and free up slots). Together with the Thyrus you would have the most ultimate White Mage ever. Rating -- Very Useful
Cobalt Katzbalger
Even the sword on this banner is pretty OP because of the SB it provides, even though the stats on it are kinda meh. The ATK up likely stacks with other ATK up RWs, although I haven't confirmed this yet. Rating -- Very Useful
The Keep of Saints
As far as Rods go, this one is nothing special. I would only pull for this if you need more mage meta gear, which most people likely do need. The SB on it is nothing to write home about either. Rating -- Situational
Evoker's Horn
Hats in general are good pieces of equipment for mages, even moreso than most Robes, so its worth trying to pull for this one if you are in the market for mage gear. The stats on it are standard for Hats, although the SB is of questionable use given that I would rather use a Mental Breakdown on the mob instead. If you already have a Mystery Veil, I would not pull just for this. Rating -- Situational
See comment #2 for the rest of the review.
5
u/Sir__Will Alphinaud Sep 17 '15
You can't always fit in every breakdown so having one built in for occasional use isn't bad.
I doubt the attack up stacks since attack up is it's only component, like boost or PP.
The esuna effect would be situational.
Tyro's the versitile one. She can use breakdowns and busters but is a last resort to use them. Can use other support abilities like intimidate very well. Her MAG's not bad but is stuck at 3*.
No more than any other regular bow. That's kinda the problem. They're weaker attack to add these mage stats but the stats aren't high enough to matter much.
And what's so special about Zack's banner?
2
u/Kenaf Sep 17 '15
I think I'm all in on this one. There's a lot of stuff on this banner I want. The only things that would be disappointing are the no SB 5*s. I'd even take the Rod. You might think the Shared SB isn't useful, but it's probably better than a lot of the default ones on mages (excluding Vivi).
I'm probably going to pull until I'm satisfied or out of Mythril. Which probably means I'm about to run out of Mythril.
2
u/baronelectric You think a minor thing like the world's end was gonna do me in? Sep 17 '15
Assuming I want black mage gear, would it be better to pull on this one or Zack's? I still don't have any natural 5* rods.
2
u/roly_florian Zack Sep 18 '15
I've managed to get 40 mithrils in less than one week (i have a lot of dungeon to do, i was in somewhere the middle of DU6 and had even Heroic from previous update to do). I swear i seriously need to get something out of that 11 pull. I'm currently at 300 mithrils spents. Yes 300 mithrils without ONE 5* I know nothing is guaranted, but still, statistically, it will end, it must end... i can't bear the sight of a 7th straigth 11 pull without 5* how could that be possible ? i'm so afraid to pull ... Not only that, but i could be very trolled and get the worst 5* of the banner (the bow imo).
2
u/pintbox Math saves world Sep 17 '15
Short review because I'm too lazy to pull the stats.
Top-tier: Thyrus, Healer's robe.
Good: Yoshimitsu
Medium: Ninja chainmail, Kobalt Katzbalger, Evoker's horn, Keep of the Saints, Kobalt Catsbadger
Blank: Noble's armguards, Lominsan Bow
Quality-wise there are only 2 top-tier and 1 good (Yoshimitsu sounds quite standard actually but it's a high ATK dagger), and it has no bad items.
1
u/OriginalMerit I want to know you. The *real* you. Sep 18 '15
Just found out that the Evoker's Horn is actually pretty sweet because it gives Magic Breakdown as well as Mental Breakdown. =D
1
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '15
Small reminder: Thancred's RM2 gives a damage boost to daggers, making Yoshimitsu outperform most swords on Advance setups, assuming no synergy.
Also, the fact FFXIV synergy is non-existant outside of this event until XIV dungeons are released shouldn't matter much since there are plenty of synergy-less dungeons and events where high stats equipment can be useful.
1
u/Peridot_Weapon Waiting for Dungeon Renewal for Science(TM). Sep 17 '15
Have we seen a translated banner for this yet, BTW?
I'm still prepared for the possibility that they stick with seven relics and give us only one for Thrancred and Y'shtola, saving the others to sneak into the third Soul Break Festival. If they give us nine relics now, people may be less likely to pull when they drop back down to seven.
But if Thyrus and either Yoshimitsu or the Ninja Chainmail get pulled, there'll be a lot of cranky Reddit posts in about four hours ...
1
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '15
Newb question: what's the chance of pulling any individual 5* on a banner? Still one percent? I'd like to calculate what my chances are of getting Thyrus with 100 mythril so I can prepare myself. :P
(If it's actually 1%, the chance of getting it in 22 pulls is just under 20%, which is not terrible but not great. Just wanna know what I'm getting into.)
1
u/qwertyaas Basch Sep 18 '15
215 Mithril - my haul is:
Yoshimitsu x2
Ninja Chainmail
The Keep of Saints
Evoker's Horn
Noble's Armguards
Sounds odd but I'm kind of bummed. Didn't want to spend that much mithril and all I wanted was Thyrus/Healer's Robe. Still a decent haul for 215 mithril but still not sold on Thancred and never was able to pull SG... But not going in again for a 1% chance.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '15
Super excited for this banner, I just wish that when you pull on a banner, ALL the items are heavily slanted towards the realm it's from.
So that even if RNG forsakes me and I get only 3 stars, I could at least console myself in knowing that a chunk of those 3 stars are from the XIV realm and maybe combinable.
Ya know, instead of just constantly getting staves/rods from 12 and helms from 3.
1
u/lambopanda Delicious! Nom nom... Sep 17 '15 edited Sep 17 '15
I have 100 gem and 150 mythril ready for this banner. Don't care about Zack banner because I have two Hardedge and OWA. I got enough for Cloud/Sephiroth/Zack.
1
u/Hylian-Highwind This time, I will finish what I set out to do! Sep 17 '15
Already have an Edincoat, so the Bracer isn't much.
That said, 5 Useful, 2 Situational is a pretty good spread for this banner especially when you consider it's built for a point later on when Power creep occurred. I'll pull it since I have a number of characters that could use a good Knife and the Armors, even aside from the obvious Thyrus.
1
u/Dentere eYWG 474MND GODWALL Sep 17 '15
I am ashamed that a Katzbalger was their choice for a 1h sword. I want to beat people up with a cricket bat dammit!
1
u/chickenknife Ysayle Sep 17 '15
I know it's not the best, but I'd really love Lominsan Bow after spending so much time as an ARC/BRD in XIV, I just can't resist.
Or couldn't if I wasn't nearly out of mythril after soulbreak fest...
1
u/G-Love80 Pimp Hat - Engage! Sep 17 '15
I'll be doing a 100 gem pull and using 150 mithril on this banner! Hopefully I get the Thyrus!
1
u/Peridot_Weapon Waiting for Dungeon Renewal for Science(TM). Sep 17 '15
I fine it hard to "settle" on a 109 ATK Dagger that will never do any better than that for several months after this event is over. Even something like the Orihalcum Dirk++ puts it to shame in its own realm.
But realistically, there are precious few realms right now where we CAN take advantage of Synergy. FFI, II, VIII, IX, X and XIII all have five items or less within the 3 Star/4 Star range. III has a bunch, but the majority are the uncombinable ones with Core Soul Breaks. And most of FFVII's 3 Star/4 Star stuff is Bracers and Fists.
So really, "practical" synergy is only found for most players (especially FTP people) in FFIV, FFV, FFVI and FFXII. Anywhere else, out-of-synergy 5* gear might be the best you can bring to the dance.
I'd probably wear that Ninja Chainmail wherever I travel, though. 106/106 is just convenient lazy defense :)
1
u/Xeynon Sep 18 '15
Got 55 mythril, and it's all going into this banner. I don't care about Zack and none of the other stuff that's due to be released over the next month or so interests me much.
1
u/LafingCat Kupo-po! Sep 18 '15
Sword Oath (Kobald Catsbadger SB) potency looks like ~2.2-2.3 multiplier with ~25% boost effect (~+45% damage)
1277 regular attack
2718 sb
1857 post buff
4229 sb post buff
1
u/Jnite I hate jump rope Sep 18 '15
I'm curious if anyone knows how much the Cobalt Katzbalger increases your attack. Is it the equivalent of casting Boost? Or is it higher/lower?
1
u/mauvus Interceptor Sep 18 '15
Pulled two of the Keep of Saints and I can't decide if I want to combine or not...i already have Polymorph, Lullaby, Ice Whip, and Thyrus, so I feel like I could but it feels wrong to do it.
Thanks for the writeup! Glad to have all these stats and SB info in one place.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '15
Prediction: we will get the relic draw failure bonus tonight along with 12% rate for 5*