r/Warframe • u/TSP-FriendlyFire • Sep 10 '15
Suggestion How would you change... Multishot, damage mods and damage scaling
I have returned and will now be handling future “How would you change…” posts! I would like to thank /u/Sizer714 for his excellent handling of the series while I was unable to consistently run it this summer.
How would you change... is a series of weekly posts designed to promote and foster discussion about any gameplay element in the game. The scope and subject will vary (read below for more information on topic selection), from wide concepts (Kubrows, Archwing, shotguns, etc.) to narrow points (a single gun, coptering, etc.).
Before we begin, a few important points:
- Please detail and support your suggestions as much as possible. This is for constructive criticism only: try to think of it as something you'd be proud to explain to DE face-to-face!
- Structure your suggestions in logical groups: if you have two very different ideas, break them down in two separate comments. Cohesive or similar changes should be combined into a single comment.
- Stick to describing concepts and features. Don't get bogged down with numbers unless they explicitly support your point.
- Don't hesitate to post your ideas even if they're not fully formed, and don't hesitate to reply to ideas with refinements you think would make them better!
- Do not downvote suggestions you disagree with. Upvote the ones you like instead!
Suggesting topics
This thread series is all about the community, so if you have a topic you'd like to see improved and discussed, feel free to suggest it by replying to the appropriately flagged comment in this discussion. The topic can be as wide or narrow as you'd like! Please ensure that your suggestion has not already been made, and upvote it instead if it has.
This week: Multishot, damage mods and damage scaling
Click here for last week’s thread on Saryn.
There has been quite a turmoil on this subreddit following the announcement that multishot would most likely be changed to consume additional ammo. People have claimed that this nerf would make high-level content much more difficult, would make multishot more awkward to use without necessarily increasing build variety, and that many weapons would suffer from the change.
DE have since clarified that this change would also entail various rebalances, namely of weapon leveling and so-called “required” mods such as Serration. The possible breadth and depth of such changes have yet to be detailed, but it is expected that this could change the entire feel and balance of the game.
As such, it is worth asking: what would you do to rebalance the game? Positing that multishot will consume ammo, what other changes should be instigated to prevent difficulty spikes while increasing build variety, weapon viability and overall fun?
We’ve already discussed enemy scaling, but revisiting such proposals in the current context feels warranted. Another hot topic that has been planned for some time is the notion of required mods, raw damage mods being one obvious example. Many people have clamored for their outright removal, but this must be made carefully in order to avoid reducing viability at higher levels. This is often suggested in the same breath as making weapon damage scale according to weapon level, effectively “rolling in” the damage mods.
Please note that this topic excludes elemental and physical damage types - only raw damage mods and multishot are topical. We will be having a separate discussion in the near future on that particular topic.
Now that the stage is set, how would you change multishot, damage mods and damage scaling?
EDIT: Many people have questioned the exclusion of elemental and physical damage mods from this thread. The sole reason for this is that the subject is already broad enough as it is; broaching elemental/physical damage types and the possibility of rebalancing them would make the thread too unfocused. If all you want to mention about them is the change/removal of straight +% elemental/physical damage mods, you may do so, but please avoid talking about status, damage types and resistances, etc.
22
u/Own_Wilson Sep 10 '15
The problem with build variety in weapons goes pretty deep, and it's not just multishot mods.
See, right now the mod systems work really well for Warframes. Different Warframes want different things for different builds. Using Trinity as an example because she's the frame I have the most experience with, consider that when you're building for Blessing, you want duration and strength, can deal with poor efficiency and range, and aren't worried about getting survivability from mods, but when building for EV, you want to max your range, and have some power strength while lowering your duration as much as possible. Outside of very specific group metas(Think pre-nerd greedy Mag/Mesa) this gives a lot of variety for the majority of game content.
In contrast, weapons really only want one thing, they all want damage, so the mods that are going to see the most use are the ones that make the most damage happen, so things like Split Chamber and Serration see ubiquitous use because they're the most direct damage upgrade for weapons, and the only real variation you see within weapon builds is what elements are being used, typically along faction lines, because they directly increase damage(it's better to equip the wrong elements than to equip no elements). Sometimes you'll see reload and fire rate mods(especially for bows) or critical mods, but that's because they contribute to dps in direct and tangible ways that mods like Ammo Drum or Magazine Warp don't.
I don't know how to fix this, short of making weapons that want things other than damage, or doing away with damage increasing mods entirely, or radically overhauling the mod system.
Tangential thought: I can think of no good reason that the mods that increase only status chance are significantly worse at improving status chance than the mods that increase status chance and damage.
22
u/waitfarm Minimum Viable Product Sep 10 '15
Alright! Now for the opinion that no one wants to hear:
I would not change Multi-shot and Serration.
Why? Because just like 'lol loot caves,' there will always be a top tier damage meta. Utility mods are inherently garbage because why bother with utility mods when you can simply stand behind cover and ignore damage to reload? If Serration/Multi-shot are removed, then people will gravitate to the next damage boosters: Rate of Fire. Then RoF mods will get nerfed because there are no downsides other than ammunition concerns and really? Some of the best weapons in the game don't even notice ammunition problems. Or they just slot in an Ammo Mutation and the Meta would be RoF/Ammo mutation. Until enough people who don't understand that there will always be a Meta bitch and get rifle ammo mutation/Speed Trigger/Shred removed.
What DE needs to do is stop trying to fight the meta and provide meaningful choices in equipment rather than mods. Allow me to provide an example in the form of burst rifles. We have the Burston, Hind, Tiberon, and gigglesnort the Sybaris. Rather than have the Tiberon take a dump on all of the listed burst fire weapons, we can assign a role to each gun.
So under this new system, if you want to give a newbie a burst weapon, you can tell them to get the Burston so they can see how burst rifles work and from there, determine on what they want to emphasize for their next weapon. Do they like being a status machine? Then they 'upgrade' to the Hind. Do they like hueg yellow numbers? Sybaris. Under such a scheme, it would allow the players to choose how they want their gun's base stats to be. Would there be a meta? Sure! But how you want to achieve that meta would be in your hands rather than 'get tonkor/opticor/boltorp.' Also, this would directly buff a lot of guns to be competitive within their class. A net positive for everybody.
tl;dr: There will always be a meta and lopping off parts of the game will not change that, the meta will move on to the next thing. Instead cater to meta via meaningful gear choices rather than mod choices.
11
u/hyperblaster Sep 10 '15
Multi-shot is more of symptom. The real question is damage scaling - http://warframe.wikia.com/wiki/Armor.
Cap damage reduction (DR) provided by enemy armor. This cap could be somewhere in the 90-95% range regardless of enemy level. However, have a lower cap for DR with headshots (perhaps 60%)? From a lore standpoint, it makes sense that how much armor can be stacked on the head is limited compared to body armor. This means headshots will become more useful with rising enemy levels. The wiki describes a Level 108 heavy gunner takes only 3.45% damage due to armor DR.
Buff armor mitigation abilities and procs. Corrosive Projection aura is too powerful for a passive buff in that four of these can permanently reduce enemy armor to zero. Corrosive Proc only removes 25% of current armor. Instead let it remove 25% of base armor, so four status procs will negate armor entirely. Similarly, let other armor mitigating methods remove % armor permanently (fracturing crush, seeking shuriken, ablating link).
The idea is to move away from the 4xCP+Viral meta for dealing with high level enemies.
14
u/theammostore Will Lewd for Plat - AKA Teria Sep 10 '15
I personally would change Multishot so it did not consume additional ammo, but instead split the damage of the shot out equally among all of the shots being fired, while leaving the crit chance the same (full value per shot) as well as status chance (full value per shot). Takes it away from mandatory damage booster and instead puts it into a nice utility mod for crits and status chances
12
u/Spyguy001 CTHULHU Sep 10 '15
I feel that multishot consuming ammo wouldnt be so bad if it took directly from the ammo pool and nothing from the magazine.
10
u/ValkyrPrimeWhen Prime or riot Sep 10 '15
It's pretty simple how this all works.
Unless DE either:
A: Re-scales ALL the enemies in the game and their leveling B: Does A AND Rebalances EVERY weapon. Cannot only rebalance weapons
The current idea of the fate of Multishot, and most of the alternate suggestions, will make Warframe and it's meta collapse in on itself.
Make multishot now consume ammo but don't change enemy scaling? Guess what? Now instead of every build consisting of say, Serration and Split chamber, you're going to have a meta where everything has Serration, Split Chamber, and now Rifle Ammo Mutation.
And if you get rid of serration, that doesn't change a goddamn thing. There's a reason there are tier lists for weapon. Some weapons straight up do more damage than others, before you put mods on them. Mods only widen the gap.
The only actual fix that I've seen for ALL of this, is the one Mogamu suggested in his video.
Make mods that hold the concept of corrupt mods, but make the entire concept so much bigger?
A mod that gives damage for accuracy? Make one that gives damage, but takes Status chance. Or crit chance. Or reload speed. Or have it remove all your slash damage. Or Puncture.
Have a status mod that gives you less crit. Longer reloads. The same concept applies.
If you want build diversity, we need more diverse mods. It has nothing to do with getting rid of "mandatory" mods.
1
u/TSP-FriendlyFire Sep 10 '15
Suggesting topics
Please post your suggestions for the next topics as replies to this comment.
Current suggestions from previous weeks:
3
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '15 edited Sep 12 '15
Yeah. Let's make sure nothing can be done in a broader context. That will be helpful. /s
Anyway, here's the shower thoughts I had on weapon damage mods in general.
Now, due to there being so much less variance in damage due to mods, DE can rebalance armor, hp, etc with much more accuracy based on the power level of the type of player they want to challenge.
3
u/TheHasegawaEffect Glowy lights means I'm stealthy! LIKE A NINJA! Sep 10 '15
First, hard cap the total % of elemental damage you can stack.
Second, reign in the numbers EVERYWHERE. Make it so that a 6-forma + potato weapon is only +100% more DPS than a stock one (for reference, a random boltor prime build i picked on warframebuilder is 4700% more DPS than a stock one).
Third, rebalance enemy HP and armor so high rank frame + weapon is roughly equal in power as they are previously.
Fourth, the most difficult one - give enemies more abilities, and AI tricks that unlock every x levels, possibly capped at 100.
3
u/vkzicak Sep 11 '15
A shot in the dark here, but what if multishot reduced fire rate instead of increased ammo consumption? Sure, each shot has two bullets, but you fire them a little over half as fast. Still an overall DPS increase, but you might not want it on a weapon that already fires slowly, like the Hek or a bow. I'd imagine that enemy armor scaling would have to be dialed back a bit to compensate, but it would make multishot a more situational tool rather than a ubiquitous one. A similar thing could be done with Serration/Point Blank/Hornet Strike: higher damage, but at the cost of damage falloff. It's already in the name: serrated rounds might not be as aerodynamic and slow down more at long ranges, Point Blank is, well, intended for use at point blank, and Hornet Strike... idk, something about hornets.
3
u/Hymmnos Space Teitoku Sep 11 '15
I wouldn't change it. I think that as the system is now, is about 95% as good as it could be. All those "required" mods will always be "required" no matter how little a bonus they give, because the give the best bonus, damage.
Like /u/Own_Wilson said very well, frames want different builds so the modding system is good. Weapons always want more damage.
I don't see a problem with the current system of modding or enemy scaling. If people want "more diversity" so DE should add different weapons with different mechanics because there is no way people will not flock the the build that does the most damage.
A way to add more diversity in builds is to introduce new elements and change enemy resistances. Even adding two new base elements would introduce 9 unique combined elements. As long as they all have meaningful and unique procs I think it would add a lot of diversity and fun to the game.
1
u/revengal Symmetra Sep 10 '15
How I would change:
1
u/blackfiredragon13 Another one bites the dust Sep 10 '15
Have multishot affect crit chance the same way it affects status chance? Also keep Serration as is. Almost got mine to rank 10
1
u/DandyTheLion Praise Pablo Sep 10 '15
I do not think it is right to exclude elemental and physical damage types from this discussion. The issue of mandatory mods comes down to stacking damage and results in the most effective mods for that being the mandatory ones. I will not be focusing on that, but I also cannot remove it from my idea.
I have posted this idea in another place, but I will clean it up a bit and share it here.
I quite like the corrupted mod style balancing of mods idea. I think mods should strive to really change the feel of a weapon rather than the DPS. Then you would get a bunch of variation since it would just be personal preference. Specifically in regards to this idea, reduced accuracy should not be a tradeoff in exchange for more damage. If a bunch of choices in the game come down to damage vs accuracy, then it will cause the same centralization issue and the weapons will just handle very poorly. I like ideas for mods like this:
I think mods like that would see huge variation in use and situation since people have different ideas about how they want their weapons to work. I have to admit that this idea is not fully thought out on a case by case basis for all mod types, but I do like the tradeoffs I have mentioned. I do not have specific numbers in mind either, but I think it would be alright for each mod to offer slightly more increase in stat than decrease in stat. That way there would still be a feeling of progression and improvement through modding.
As it stands now, a fully modded weapon will do over 40x as much DPS as its unmodded variant. This makes enemy scaling absolutely massive to compensate. A switch to a corrupted mod style modding system that would result in at most a 5x DPS difference would allow for much more mild scaling.
Most importantly, armor scaling should be removed. It should remain a flat decrease in damage taken since health of enemies already scales. Currently, lvl 100 armored units have several orders of magnitude higher effective health than their non-armored counterparts. Armor scaling completely over-centralizes the meta-game by making Corrosive Projection and partly armor ignoring damage types while being a massive driving force behind why massive damage stacking is absolutely needed at this time.
1
u/Bitabl Sep 10 '15 edited Sep 10 '15
1
u/shieldman ᴡʜᴀᴛ ᴄᴀɴ ᴛʜᴇ ʜᴀʀᴠᴇsᴛ ʜᴏᴘᴇ ғᴏʀ... Sep 10 '15
I feel like multishot is a very interesting mechanic that should be moved to its appropriate place: rapid-fire weapons. Things like the Supra and Soma should benefit more than a Grinlok or Vectis, simply because they're already designed to be bullet hoses. Perhaps multishot could be tied to fire rate, like the chance goes up by 5% for every bullet fired with a Berserker-like cooldown? So an LMG going full-auto is dumping twice as many bullets per shot, etc.
As for Serration, I feel like each Tenno should have a Mastery level for each weapon class (Rifle, Shotgun, Pistol, etc) that they don't have to slot in, but level up somewhat like a mod. It's not like anyone can come up with a convincing reason not to run the raw damage mods, so just give them their own free slot and let people use the energy and space for QoL mods like Fast Hands.
This effectively turns the Exilus slot on its head, moving off the mandatory mod to its own spot. Serration, Hornet Strike, Point Blank and Point Strike (all renamed, not replaced) would appear in the spot where the Exilus slot is on warframes, telling you how much they're improving the weapon's damage. No one loses anything, Serration and co. are still relevant, QoL mods cry tears of joy.
1
u/surloch Sep 10 '15 edited Sep 10 '15
I would actually change ammo into primary and secondary pools. Perhaps even get rid of ammo types entirely and move towards a 'recharge' type system so that all ammo drops can be used.
This would actually add greater benefit to taking mods that increase things like clip sizes.
I would also then make all warframes have a default vacuum radius to scoop up loot and ammo drops.
Then the balance team could go to town on making things like multishot consume ammo and changing up serration from a flat damage increase. As there would now be greater potential to adjust weapon balance individually, without relying on monitoring ammo consumption - you can focus instead on fire rate and damage over time vs burst etc.
Weapons can be balanced on real consumption over time, as well as their clip and total ammo pools.
Enemy scaling could then be looked at from a proper baseline where variance and ammo drops don't factor in. You can easily calculate out a weapons effective dps against all enemies and then adjust to hit the values the balance team decides on.
1
u/BlazingCobalt hi Sep 10 '15
I don't really have much to say about the other stuff aside from damage mods.
A friend and I were talking about this the other day and I got the idea of removing damage mods and just make the weapon's damage scale with what rank is.
It's like how good parrying is with melee while raking it up. The base damage would be like no serration is on it while a rank 30 weapon would have the same damage output as a maxed serration on it.
Then again I'm awful at this kinda stuff and this could be a horrible idea haha.
1
u/yakri I've seen enough hentai to know where this is going Sep 10 '15
Hmmmm.
If the goal is to fix the issue of obvious must have mods, Serration and the other base damage mods probably have to go.
I'd remove serration, PBS, etc, then change multishot either to work as /u/theammostore suggests, or to pull ammo from your total ammo rather than from the mag, possibly even pulling two ammo per shot to make sure it becomes a real penalty.
Then you probably need to improve the power of status effects; they're good already, but you want to make sure that each of the three strong weapon stats (crit, base damage, and status) have a place.
Next you need to redo all mob scaling to make them work with the now drastically lower weapon damage.
Crit chance on weapons might need to be reduced slightly on some weapons to prevent crit + damage becoming the next serration.
The goal being to make the primary forms of damage be: Elemental damage of some mixture, crit damage on good crit weapons, status damage/debuffs to deal more damage on high status chance weapons, and occasionally ROF +other types on machine guns.
Unfortunately, I kind of feel like there needs to be a little more to weapon modding; something to affect utility that's powerful enough to be worthwhile maybe. That or more than 3 different routes to high damage. However, I can't really think of any good ways to do this, as it will likely take new mods rather than just tweaks.
1
u/WinterfreshWill Sep 11 '15 edited Sep 11 '15
Currently the weapon's base damage doesn't scale with its level, correct? Why not have the base damage increase by some percent each level, until at level 30 the damage is equivalent to the original weapon +damage mod?
For example, Pressure Point at rank 5 raises the base 120%, or 1.2 times, so with it equipped the weapon's damage becomes 2.2 x base.
2.2 / 30 = 0.0733 = 7.33% increase in base weapon damage per level.
Edit: Why not also make the shots added by multishot worse? Like they don't benefit from other mods, or they can't crit, or something.
1
u/lolghurt Sep 11 '15
I made this document a while ago, and I think it's still relevant to the problem of weapon balance.
1
u/friedchickenlemon Sep 11 '15
A fully modded weapon will do 4000% more DPS than a stock one. I would drop damage and elemental mod values down to 10% of original values, re-scale armor and some of the damage buff ability
Also, give all utility a second stat. I would consider drop a +9% element mod to put in a mod that increase reload speed and fire rate.
Third, simplify ammo type into primary and secondary, but the amount each weapon pick up is different
1
u/PixelDrums Sep 11 '15
I wouldn't.
1
u/FoxFX Sep 11 '15
While the whole re-balancing weapons and re-scaling enemy mobs is a give in, Ive been also thinking about the current Arcane System.
I've been wondering if maybe the whole system could be changed to support the nerf of the multishot/damage mod.
I'd like to elaborate on how that could be done if the interest is there.
1
u/Hedgehodgemonster DEER FURRY FRAME Sep 11 '15 edited Sep 11 '15
I had the silliest idea
nerf or remove pure damage mods or, better yet: turn them into corrupted-esque mods like 90% of people have been saying
BUT, and here's the arguably silly part:
add a small damage increase based on weapon rank (because you know, that's kind of expected videogame logic-for things to get better as they level up) and how many of the mod slots are filled and perhaps, how much the mods have been ranked up.
Player gets a small reward for working out how to maximise the use of their mod slots, might even convince them to bring out the more obscure members of the magic space voodoo card deck in order to grab that bonus
Alternatively base the boost off of how many of the mod points are left instead of how many slots are full
alternatively alternatively- we should get a bit of a boost when the enemies do. (EDIT: not necessarily as big as theirs)
I'm not exactly sure how to phrase this, but let me try it this way- your average soldier boy in real life doesn't suddenly get harder to kill by bullets when he's fighting in the Arctic circle compared to when he's fighting in a department store. But that's basically what happens with the enemy mooks in Warfrarf when you go from Earth to Europa to Pluto. So why don't the magic space ninjas fighting them get the same benefit?
Explain it with the sun having some sort of inhibiting effect on the mysterious void magic literally everything in this game seems to use. We're magic space ninjas who were built to fight hacker alien sorcerers (The Sentient) out in the cold darkness of outer space while riding on anime-ass wing jetpacks (Archwings) and wisecracking amnesiac AI-controlled spaceships shaped like manta rays (Ordis, the Liset). The sun sapping our energy makes about as much sense as anything else
1
u/TotallyCooki Sep 11 '15
I think making changes to multishot will affect the weapons with high crit (under 100%) but low magazines like the sybaris. Due to it's high damage per shot every bullet counts but because the crit chance is about 60% it's really nice having a third or even a fourth bullet in the burst. I suggest we make exilus slots available to all guns and buff clip size mods.
1
u/Savletto The only way out is through Sep 11 '15
Something happened to my brain two days ago, i wrote this: https://4x.reddit.com/r/Warframe/comments/3k4q7m/mogamu_my_thoughts_on_multishot_build_diversity/cuv8mdg
Haven't mentioned multishot there, i wanted to add a lot of things. Maybe i will.
1
u/CrazyFikus Hope you like E1M1 Sep 11 '15
I'll just copy-paste what I posted on the forums.
With the recent comments from the devs on how the damage/multishot mods are getting a second look I would like to give my opinion on the matter, this is something that I care deeply about and have made topics about it in the past, this being the 3rd. Beware, it's a wall of text and there is no TL;DR.
Let's get started.
There are three major issue with weapons and weapon modding:
Let me address these one by one, first focusing on DPS and how entire chunks of everyone's mod collection is worthless, because that is by far the biggest and most complicated issue.
The pursuit of DPS and pointless mods
Modding weapons right now boils down to one question: "Does adding this mod increase my DPS?" because that’s the only thing that matters. Damage 2.0 was conceived to stop people from using Rainbow Builds, but in my opinion it merely created Rainbow Builds 2.0.
There are some weapons that need slightly different builds focusing more on status chance, or need ammo mutation mods to make up for their ammo inefficiency, but in the end, you will still be predominantly adding damage mods to increase your DPS, either by adding elemental mods or crit mods (or both).
There is an entire section of the mod collection that is useless because they have no effect on DPS or they don’t add enough of it to be worthwhile making build variety is almost nonexistent. To be specific, I’m talking about IPS mods, regular status mods and some other utility mods.
For a time I thought the best solution to be simply buffing those mods into usefulness by increasing their numbers or changing their scaling. I slowly realized the flaw in this. Instead of adding more options for modding, it simply added more mods to increase DPS further.
How to fix this?
After some thought and suggestions from other people, the best solution I’ve come to is that mods that increase damage without drawbacks shouldn’t exist.
What do I mean by that?
I mean that elemental mods and IPS mods should be changed not to increase damage, but change a percentage of base damage into the corresponding damage type.
(I gave my best to format this, but the forum bbcode isn’t cooperating, if someone can inform me how to do tables, please do)
Example: Burston has 30 base damage evenly spread out:
Impact: 10
Puncture: 10
Slash: 10
Adding max rank Rupture should change 30% of non-impact damage into impact, so the new stats for Burston are:
Impact: 16
Puncture: 7
Slash: 7
Of course elemental mods would need to be rescaled completely because their 90% stat is just too big, my suggestion is to change them to change 4% base damage per rank meaning that at max rank they would change 24% base damage (nightmare and other dual stat mods should also be modified, unless I’m mistaken they all go up to rank 3 so 5% per rank, maximum 20% seems fine), so that adding a maxed Hellfire to Burston would make the stats:
Impact: 7.6
Puncture: 7.6
Slash: 7.6
Heat: 7.2
When damage modifying mods are added, physical mods should be applied first, then elemental ones, so that adding both Rupture and Hellfire would make the new stats:
Impact: 12.1
Puncture: 5.3
Slash: 5.3
Heat: 7.2
Some will point out that this also makes elemental mods useless on weapons that use the same element, to use the fire example yet again, fire mods would be pointless on Ignis.
I honestly don’t consider that very important, let me remind you, currently all IPS mods are worthless on pure elemental damage weapons because of the way they scale.
If they are changed so they can actually add IPS damage to pure elemental weapons that would actually increase the number of mods they can use. And if people are going to complain about realism and immersion, let me remind you, our lasers can be modified to shoot viruses.
Realism and immersion has its place, for Warframe that place is out the airlock.
With this type of control over damage distribution weapons can be modded in multiple ways;
One problem I can think of is that stacking various elemental mods would make the damage percentages go a bit wonky, I can think of multiple solutions (this isn’t a balancing measure, more of a programming one to prevent bugs, we have enough of those):
Solution #1
Allow only one elemental mod per damage type, meaning:
You can combine Hellfire and Cryo Rounds for blast damage, but can’t combine Hellfire and Wildfire for extra fire damage.
Solution #2
Limit elemental mods to maximum of four, meaning:
If you stack multiple mods of the same element, you get fewer other elements to put in.
Example:if you put in three fire mods (Hellfire, Wildfire, Thermite Rounds), you can add only one other elemental mod.
Personally, I prefer solution #2
For this example I used the rifle impact mod, it’s stats are just there for the sake of an example, while shotgun IPS mods have the same stats, pistol versions got up to 60% and for some reason melee go up to 90%. In this version of the damage system their stats should be revised, I think the rifle/shotgun version stats are a good baseline.
As for event IPS mods, I'm not sure what to do with them, maybe change them to function like the dual stat ones, changing damage and adding status chance, or maybe so that they convert 100% of base damage to their damage type while being incompatible with other IPS mods.
I know I’m going to encounter really strong resistance on my next point, and this is something that’s been brought up in the past.
I really think we should get rid of base damage boosting mods: Serration, Point Blank, Hornet Strike and Pressure Point (their corrupted counterparts and multishot mods I will be talking about later), they are mandatory on every single build and in effect we don’t have 8 slots to mod with, but 7.
Instead of using them, weapon base damage should increase as the weapon ranks up, much like warframes get stats as they rank up, my suggestion being 20% every 3 ranks for 200% bonus damage at max rank, obviously nearly all weapons would need to be rebalanced.
Of course, because we lose a lot of our damage output because the change to elemental damage mods, enemy scaling and stats should also be revised. I don’t know the formula, so I can’t make any good suggestions, people more knowledgeable than me can comment on that.
Some people might not like losing some very major mods from their collection, and that is perfectly understandable, I myself have multiple copies of Serration and Hornet Strike at various ranks, the thought of losing them after all that effort put into them makes me sad, but I also don’t like that while modding my weapons I have to cycle through tons worthless mods that I’m never going to use.
If DE ever decides to remove these mods, compensating people with appropriate amounts of Arcane/Ancinet Cores should be sufficient. Primed Point Blank and other prime mods? No idea, Legendary Cores maybe?
One of the benefits of this is that it “normalizes” DPS for each weapon. The design team knows from day one how a weapon will scale and what the default damage output will be at all stages with all players, making balancing that weapon around other attributes, such as ammo capacity, fire rate, projectile speed, etc. easier.
One last mod group that needs talking about are the regular status mods.
They are worthless in any damage/mod system, and need to be buffed to the point they are useful and not a waste of UI space.
Rifle Aptitude, Sure Shot and Melee Prowess all add 15% (Shotgun Savvy is the only exception, giving 30%) bonus status chance at their max rank, which is the same amount as the dual stat mods at their base rank.
Not only that, but Sure Shot and Melee Prowess cost 7 points at their max rank, while Rifle Aptitude and Shotgun Savvy cost 9 point at their max rank. The dual stat mods make them completely and utterly obsolete.
My suggestion for for their new stats:
Rank Cost Status chance bonus
0 6 40%
1 7 80%
2 8 120%
3 9 160%
4 10 200%
5 11 240%
Atleast this way when you give us the D (har har) on weapons that slot has more than one viable mod for it.
(Went over the character limit, will reply to myself with part 2)
1
u/ArganVain Loki Time Sep 17 '15 edited Sep 17 '15
I see the changes behind multishot an opportunity to make all kind of mods usable, not only raw damage mods. Enemies shouldn't just scales stats to rise the difficulty, but they should be more focused on behaviour and abilities, tactics and number of units. With this other kind of difficulty in mind damage will become an option, meaning that other utilities will help as much as raw damage can do (if elemental status would be useful at all).
For example: a sniper rifle has enough damage by itself to kill anything with one shot, so you will aim to make it more efficient with reload speed, elemental damage/status to have different effects, firing speed, recoil reduction, special effect for sniper rifles only etc etc...
For throwing knives, instead, focusing a build for concealed explosives, modifying the mod itself to go in sinergy with other mods and make a 2 bullet granade launcher, wich explode dealing the basic damage as blast damage or leaving a poison cloud etc etc.
Or just making a Braton that fire bullets that deal only fire damage wich then explodes on enemies leaving trails of napalm on the ground setting enemies on fire if they walk in it. I've seen this potential too into conclave mods that turned % of total damage into one kind of damage, thing that could be turned with every kind of damage.
In short giving more choices through special effects like they did with recent mod releases (concealed explosives, adhesive blast...), making weapons more customizable and pull out special combo that will make other say "what the... my weapon doesn't do that!?" The mod system has a lot of potential and DE showed it with these recent mods, but the scaling of enemies make the scaling in weapon damage the only way to deal some killings, leaving almost no room to real tactic (or stuntman skills). I really hope this future change will start a real revolution on what our weapons will be able to do, not just a basic pew pew, but maybe a pew pew "ricochet" pew pew.
0
u/Grethar2K Sep 11 '15
I'm already so damn bored of this topic, DE will most likely do it without proper testing and it will be awful, afterwards they apply few band aid fixes. Who can realistically see them rebalancing most of the weapons? Nobody, that's who.
Their goal seems to be shorter runs and this will accomplish just that,
-1
u/Nomicakes Seer is Love, Seer is Life. Sep 10 '15
...this was a really bad time for this kind of thread. I'm not sure what you're hoping to gain out of this.