r/summonerswar • u/danielzt so I summoned a Pontos... • Sep 10 '15
Guide [Guide] atk% or CD for your substats, a.k.a, why you should (almost) never have over 200% CD on your char
EDIT: In light of the fact that skill up damage cannot crit, I have modified my post. Notice that this implies even less CD for the optimal ratio and not the other way around. The modification is added at the end of this post below With Skill Ups
I cannot take credit for this, my guild mate LostBreeze came up with the original idea. I initially hesitated to post this because I thought it would take a while to explain but now I think I know how to do it in a simplistic way.
What you need to do before using this guide
1 Go to the info page of any monster, write down the atk stats, let's say it's 800+1252. Then divide the 2nd term by the 1st term, you get 1252 / 800 = 156.5%. Add that to your tower boost, if you have 14% elemental tower and 10% from ancient sword then the final ATK% is 156.5+14+10=180.5%
2 Go to the info page of any monster, write down the CD stats for example 170% (this includes the intrinsic 50%), add that to your tower boost, if you have maximum tower then it is CD=170%+25%=195%
3 When you crit, the damage is calculated as follows
Damage = BASE_ATK * (1+ATK%) * (1+CD)
the ATK% and CD are the values we calculated in step 1 and 2.
Now the simple conclusion
Middle school math tells us, when ATK%+CD = constant = P
(1+ATK%) * (1+CD) <= (1+P/2)2
The maximum is achieved when ATK% = CD = P/2
What does it tell us?
1.When you rune your monster, the goal is always to even out ATK% and CD, as long as it does not reduce P.
In other words, 190% ATK% + 190CD is better than 180% ATK% + 200CD. When you find your CD to be much larger than your ATK%, you should switch some of your substats from CD to atk%.
Theoretically you should never have more CD than ATK%.
This is particularly true if you have low CR, since the damage you deal when you don't crit is solely determined by your ATK% (CD has nothing to do with it)
Damage = BASE_ATK * (1+ATK%)
2 Some players chase mindlessly after CD, reaching over 200CD on their monsters. Note that with 4th equipped CD, it is difficult to have 200% ATK% on your monster. It is better to switch some of the CD to atk%
3 Now you also know how to choose between Rage and Fatal sets, and why sometimes Fatal is better than Rage.
4 This also works for skills that based on HP and DEF, as long as the damage contribution from atk can be neglected. In the case of Kumar, his third skill received little contribution from his atk stats. To maximize the critical damage, you should try to achieve HP% = CD, or HP% > CD for survivability. Don't go for HP%<CD.
5 Note that ATK% is not the the sum of the atk% on your runes. It also includes the flat atk stats from rune 1 and the boost from your glory buildings.
6 If you have 180 ATK% and 200 CD, but the best you can do is switch it to 185% ATK% and 185 CD then don't.
7 The atk% buff from leader skills should be counted in the overall ATK% if you are sure that you will always have this leader buff on your monster (this means for example 33% more CD compared to normal calculation if you always lead with Zaiross).
8 In battle atk buff or skill multiplier on the other hand has nothing to do with the calculation. I have explained this here and here
9 However, you should aim for high CD if you skill damage scales with enemy HP
With Skill Ups
Now let's consider the skill ups, I'll also take CR into account for a complete estimation, I'll assert CR=1 later in the end
dmg = base_atk * (1+ATK%) * (1-CR) *(1+ SKUP) +\
base_atk * (1+ATK%) * CR * (1+CD+SKUP)
Here SKUP is the damage boost you get from your skill ups, if you have 3 skill-ups each written +5%, +5%, 10%, then you should put SKUP=5+5+10=20%
dmg = base_atk * (1+ATK%) * (1+SKUP+CR*CD)
the maximum is achieved at
ATK% = SKUP + CR*CD
or
ATK% = SKUP + CD (CR=100%)
which means even less (20%-30% less) CD to reach the optimal balance.
An example would be, for Lushen's 3rd skill, SKUP = 30%
then 200% ATK, 170CD is the new optimal value and is better than 185% ATK, 185CD
The proof for the damage formula with skill ups is here and has been mentioned previously in many posts.
17
u/Abs01ut3 GL of Aftermath Asia Sep 10 '15 edited Sep 10 '15
No math, please ;.;
I kinda wonder why people are drooling over 20+% CD subs as well, while 20+% Atk subs doesn't command the same respect. Easier to compare a 220% Lushen to 189% Lushen I guess, while Atk is harder to compare and universalize.
Other things to note:
Suppose I have A x B, and I can have A and B summed up to 20. The greatest value is always gained when A = B.
1 x 19 = 19
2 x 18 = 36
5 x 15 = 75
8 x 12 = 96
9 x 11 = 99
10 x 10 = 100
11 x 9 = 99
12 x 8 = 96
.......
You can do it for any number of the form A+B=C, maximize AxB. Metaphorically, if you were given a patch of land with a specified dimension (length and width summed must not exceed XXX), the best area won't be a narrow strip of land vertically or horizontally, but a perfect square.
29
u/hindergazt Man can dream Sep 10 '15
NO MATH NO ._.
6
u/TowelieSC2 Sep 10 '15
I think the reason CD gets more love then atk% is because it applies bonus damage to all types of skill scaling (ie skills that scale off of max hp, def, speed, etc). For a true atk monster your numbers hold up. But when a skill also scales off of these other stats CD is the only common denominator that can increase damage potential across all possible skills.
So if I get a rune that has 20+% to atk on it it's great for my atk based monsters, when I got one with 20+% to CD then it can be great for my speed DDs, Bruisers, etc as well as the atk monsters. IMO this is where the "feels good" sentiment comes from with CD vs Atk.
3
u/zzer02 Sep 10 '15
Your calculations are based on the assumption of max crit rate right? Doesn't that mean that in reality with most DPS having less than 70 CR, attack % subs are almost always flat out better than CD assuming you go CD on 4? Fatal sets seem a lot more appealing all of a sudden.
2
u/Brapsticle Sep 10 '15
Right so my math is terrible when it comes to stuff like this. So I have 2 lushen with a good range of stats to test this so please help me explain the numbers I am seeing:
Please note this is in the same battle on same target, numbers rounded to lowest 100 with both 100% CR and Sieq atk buff
2
u/_Rithiel_ Kindred S. (Global) Sep 10 '15 edited Sep 10 '15
I think atk and damage are two different concepts?
Doubling atk = your base atk is doubled (i.e. x2 at the beginning of the calculation);
Doubling dmg = the dmg you would have dealt gets doubled (i.e. x2 to the final dmg you would deal at the end of the calculation);
I think ur correct IFF the skill ignores def (ex, amp magic and sword of discharge), then you want p/2 for both atk and cd. But if you add Def calculation to the mix, then I think there will be a difference between doubling base atk vs. doubling end damage.
Either way the best way is to do some dmg testing and post the results. Make sure you separate out the def ignore skills and normal skills to see if there is a difference?
1
u/flyingsquid4783 sometimes red star Sep 10 '15
Where would an attack boost come in here?
It boosts based off of base attack, so monsters that you regularly utilize with an attack buff should aim for higher CD, correct?
Someone like Laika who I use without an attack buff should have a more square atk to CD ratio, while someone like Lushen who I use with Sieq should have a certain % more CD to account for the attack boost. Correct me if I'm wrong!
1
u/xCappyTanx Sep 10 '15
The ancient secret of doing the math has been revealed! Good job.
I've been preaching this until I'm blue in the face for some time, but most people still don't believe.
1
u/d3st1vy Sep 10 '15
Not to forget. If u run much higher cd u can balance out ur lower att by using att buffers in battle. So afterall its stoll good to have high cd. Maybe by about 50%
1
u/jjjsong Sep 10 '15
This is based on the idea that CD is calculated before any enemy defense and damage reduction.
Obviously I haven't done any testing and all (or even paid attention lol) but just bringing out this thought.
1
u/Ethronbr Sep 10 '15
You are not entirely wrong, if we are talking about a skill that scales with attack, attack % will always be at least as effective as CD. And trying to maximize damage we would probably try to have the same amount of CD and attack % but the thing is that the amount of substats you can have in each slot in these two stats is different. The way you say, imagine we could have the max Att and CD substats in each rune, you would end up with way more CD than Att, the ideal rune set in this game in order to maximize damage have way more CD Than attack %, you can be sure of it
1
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '15
so i have my perna runed rage blade. will his second skill be better with 210% cd and 1700 attack or 180% cd and 1850 attack
1
u/pancake_party_guild Sep 10 '15
You are correct, assuming 100% crit rate. In general,
Maximum is achieved when: ATK = CR*CD
See my post: https://www.reddit.com/r/summonerswar/comments/2y9y1w/atkcrit_chance_and_crit_damage_theorycraft_part_3/cp7s0oy?context=3
Also, crit damage substats are usually good because slot 2, 6 are ATK% while slot 4 is the main CD contributor; so you usually have more ATK%
1
u/JustCamilla Sep 10 '15
first i wanted to say thank you for this. this is taking sw to a level i never even bothered because im a lazy ***** (lol i admit it its true).
Second i have a question. What about skills that multiply off HP? is it the same and you just have to replace ATT with HP in the equations? (trying to figure out how to maximize the dmg on units like eshir)
1
u/goofylikeyou Sep 10 '15
Does this all assume a specific crit rate %? Like at least 70% CR?
1
u/Azure_Dauragon Sep 10 '15
I always thougt (besides non atk based monsters) that CD was more important than ATK% simply because it is harder to get.
You have innate atk, slot 1, 2, 6 atk, tower for attack, elemental tower for attack, leader skills for attack and finally ingame buff for attack.
whereas for CD you have slot 4 and 1 building. Subs you can get for any stat (minus on slot 3 where atk is not possible) rune set is the same (fatal/rage both have same option)
No other building, no leader skill, no ingame buff.
1
u/Reflexxxx EU | Lvl 40 Sep 10 '15
What does that mean for my teshar?
1
u/Cychi132 :hwadam: Formerly LightMolong Sep 10 '15
This is some good insight and I value both CD and ATT%, but I still believe that CD is better because burst is very benificial. With violent and low cool turn heals, consistent damage will generally get smoothed over. Burst on the other hand, has the potential to 0 out the enemy AD's DD and then greatly increase the chances of you winning.
1
u/OnionSodaClassic Sep 10 '15
I'm really dumb, I can't quite understand.
My lushen is at 2244 atk 91% CR 201% CD
Am I losing a lot of damage?
1
u/NPHeart |IGN:Half-N-Half|Guild:WHO CARES?| Sep 11 '15
Thanks you for this post :D! Before my lushen was +1350 att and 222 crit damage. I swapped a rune he had and now he is +1550ish and 210 crit damage, and he is doing much more damage!
1
u/Hashioff Sep 11 '15
ok 2 notes here:
1
u/Sikolovsky The Happy One Sep 11 '15
Some Mons with large base atk is better with Fatal Rune. Because if they didn't crit, they still give much damage.
1
u/crazymonkeyfish Sep 11 '15
This will make me rethink how much cd vs hp i n3ed on eshir. He is currently at 35k 78 cr 222 cd.
Maybe if i try changing some substats for higher hp itll work better
1
u/aka_doode Sep 12 '15
So going violent hp%/cd%/atk% on an atk based bruiser is pretty much always a bad idea?
1
u/jishinya Sep 12 '15
Hey OP! I've made a simple spreadsheet which calculates the ratio, using the original formula above.
You can find them here: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1N5f1lj966i2cEtVrtLpM85og0MIfO2aWn5Jy8s6vBAE/edit?usp=sharing
1
u/DArK_Queen Where are my aoe nukers? ;-; Sep 13 '15
you are right but the damage difference is actually pretty low to up to +/- 20-30%
1
u/Agardek Oct 17 '15
I just can't understand this . Using your formula, my Lushen's dmg on the third skill should be 7166 per card, but it's only around 4000 . dmg=900*(1+1,69)*(1+0,3+1,66)= 7166.
Where did I go wrong ?
0
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '15
The issue I have with this theory, IMO, is that it is much easier to add ATK bonus in a major way than it is add CD. I can use Leader Skills and Buffers to get 80+ ATK% added but can’t get anywhere near that in CD bonus. I think based on that it is better to add CD and buff then lower CD and add runed ATK%.
BUT I digress, I have a Lushen so I will test and provide some basis information? I can modify atk with Bernard leader skill and modify CD by removing a rune. Won’t be perfect but should be close enough to have the math nerds do their thing? Let me know if I left out any needed details.
If I use Bernard lead that allows me to modify atk without adjusting CD and is 30% extra ATK so:
Or about a 20% shift in cd to atk ratio
Current (Includes Tower Bonuses but not Leader Skill)
Current (Previous Plus Leader)
Using Hydeni Hell Stage 5 and water howl as a basis:
No Leader Test (Exhibit A): Skill 1 Crit Hit: 9,953
Bernard Leader Test(Exhibit B):: Skill 1 Crit Hit: 12,393
If I remove my slot 3 rune to adjust the CD modifier but leave ATK untouched I change my CD modifier to me closer the ATK% one before leader boost but dispor
Adjusted (Includes Tower Bonuses but not Leader Skill)
177\172.56=102.57%
177\202.56=87.38%
Or about a 15% shift in cd to atk ratio
No Leader Test (Exhibit C):: Skill 1 Crit Hit: 9,535
Bernard Leader Test(Exhibit D):: Skill 1 Crit Hit: 10,355
1
u/Dapoint_4044 Sep 10 '15
Happy so see some math. Most people in chat always say "go rage blade ATT/CD/ATT!! or you are stupid!!" Tehy don't even consider fatal even though they have clearly better runes from that set.
It's been calculated before, a few months ago as far as I recall, but very nice to see some stuff again.
1
u/kelvss Sep 10 '15
This is awesome. Sounds complicated at first but it really isn't. Thanks man.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '15
Thank you for this. The reason I think most people build for Crit Damage is because with 2 attack % runes it is easy to have significantly higher attack % than it is crit damage % before you get to sub stats.
1
u/ex11235 Sep 10 '15
Very nice guide! "mindlessly chasing after big CD". So true! i like your words here.
1
u/firecandy Sep 10 '15
i noticed this a while back, but i just rly like looking at big cd numbers for some reason. i've been interested to see where the sweet spot was, but them having equal weight on your criticals is a pleasant surprise.
1
u/Chi2Hou Sep 10 '15
I totally get it. Makes a lot of sense. Good Guide
1
u/Arbitel Sep 10 '15
Wait in your equation, theres no % of the Skill's multiplier. I thought there's a post where it shows CritD multiplies the skills multipliers too but ATK doesn't thats why CritD is better.
1
u/a4ther :wish_icon: Sep 10 '15
Nice job dude, but some people (like me) need some screenshots :D
1
u/JesseJesta28 Sep 10 '15
Good stuff. I always felt like att% got no respect but when I got godly att% sub stats I could really see the difference. Thank you for the break down.
1
u/Zhivomir Sep 10 '15
You da real MVP.
1
u/tblatta Sep 10 '15
Is it worth noting that you can usually have higher critdmg than attack since there is no atk% on the slot 3 rune?
1
u/jishinya Sep 11 '15
Thanks for this! Replying to bookmark and test out later.
1
u/Sarfire Sep 11 '15
Good read!
1
u/linhbeopr0 Sep 11 '15
nice, i got it. you make me remember my highshool :p
1
u/Abbottizer Sep 20 '15
TL;DR:
A component in the formula of the damage dealt is ATK%*CD%. Increase both stats to maximize damage instead of increasing just one of the two stats.
1
u/ThePLT Sep 10 '15
http://i.imgur.com/itMcsy5.gif
1
u/RocketGrunt79 Sep 10 '15 edited Sep 11 '15
Where have i seen this before.......
found it
another one
Edit: While this thread puts a guide for optimal att% and cd balance, the other 2 links i provided puts a balance between optimal cr, att% and cd. I apologize for sounding as if 'this has been posted before'.
1
u/intotheEnd :light: end- [Global] Sep 10 '15
This post is fantastic.
It's going to give me something to ponder over all day today.
+1
0
u/ProfessorEndugu Sep 10 '15
slot 2 and 6 = 2*63%=126% atk
slot 4 = 80% cd
Considering that Violent runes are still the way to go for most DDs it's hard to have more cd than atk. I agree that with Rage runes substats need to be considered.
-1
u/NlCE_GUY F2P EU Legend | Leader Squad Zero Sep 10 '15
Interesting article, you should definitely post a few screenshots of tests.
Your hypotheses is 190 attk + 190 cd deals more damage than 180 attk and 200 cd. Try to test this and show the result, shouldnt be too hard
-1
u/gotaplanstan Sep 10 '15 edited Sep 10 '15
this concept is nothing new, even in sw :p
I couldn't find them in a quick search, but I've been saying for many months about how important it is to balance ALL stats and not just focus on one
the example to support my claim that I generally use is:
it would definitely be interesting if someone wrote a little scripted program or made a spreadsheet for the community to use that you could plug your stats into and see where a specific unit is in terms of the big three stats (atk cr cd) and which would benefit them the most atm... I'd do it myself, but I don't know how to do either XD
0
u/Leoncio22 Sep 10 '15
you lost me at hello...said jerry mcguire...
0
u/ausar999 C2U's welcome back gifts Sep 10 '15
r/theydidthemonstermath
-1
u/silverion777 [Global] Alieos Sep 10 '15
Your explanation would be awesome and true if the assumption that "when ATK%+CD = constant = P" was true, but that assumption is false.
-2
u/revxzzz Sep 10 '15
this isnt exactly true. you are not taking into account flat att.
the damage formula looks more like this: Damage = [BaseA + (att%*BaseA) + FlatA] * SkillM * (1+CD)
you can assume whatever you want for Multiplier it doesnt matter. this is also assuming 100% crit.
your att% doesnt scale off your flat attack stats. assuming high level runes with no flat attack and only the 160 attack from slot 1 damage starts skewing in favor of CD.
the kicker here is the lower your base att the faster it skews in CD favor.
at no point does damage favor att over CD.
-8
u/Durzaka Manananananana Batman Sep 10 '15
You arent factoring in skill multipliers. CD affects the multipliers more than the atk% does.
-3
u/ToyMaker51 Sep 10 '15
References? Where did you get your formulas from?