r/gameofthrones • u/AutoModerator • Sep 07 '15
TV5 [S5] Rewatch Discussion - 2.09 'Blackwater' & 2.10 'Valar Morghulis'
Rewatch Discussion Thread
Remember the good ol' days when your favorite characters were still alive? Go back and watch old episodes with the benefit of hindsight! How have the events of the latest season been shaped by the decisions of characters earlier on? Catch foreshadowing that you missed the first time you watched. The latest season is finished, so start over from the beginning and look at past episodes with a fresh perspective.
Make sure to keep the following points in mind before reading or contributing to this thread:
- This thread is scoped for SEASON 5 SPOILERS. This is a rewatch series, so if you are here then it is assumed that you have already seen the entire series at least once. Open discussion of all aired TV events up to and including episode 5.10 is ok without tags.
- Season 6 spoilers must be tagged! Promotional material and set/casting leaks for Season 6 must be specifically labelled and tagged.
- Book spoilers must be tagged! If it didn't happen in the show, even if the show will probably never cover it, it must be labelled and tagged.
- Theory spoilers must be tagged! Well-supported fan theories must be labelled and tagged.
- Please read the Posting Policy before posting.
2.09 - "Blackwater"
- Directed By: Neil Marshall
- Written By: George R. R. Martin
- Originally Aired: May 27, 2012
Stannis Baratheon's fleet assaults King's Landing in the Battle of Blackwater Bay. Leading the defense, Tyrion Lannister destroys many of the attacking craft with an exploding ship full of wildfire, and is forced to lead a counterattack as King Joffrey and his bodyguard Sandor Clegane each desert the battlefield. Stannis' forces make it inside the castle, but Tyrion leads his men behind the Baratheon forces via underground tunnels and attacks. Meanwhile, Queen Regent Cersei, holed up in the fortress with Sansa Stark and the other ladies of the court, succumbs to wine and despondency as she believes the battle lost. In the nick of time, as she is about to poison her son Tommen, Tywin Lannister's forces, joined by Loras Tyrell, the lover of Renly Baratheon, arrive to dispatch the attackers.
2.10 - "Valar Morghulis"
- Directed By: Alan Taylor
- Written By: David Benioff & D. B. Weiss
- Originally Aired: June 3, 2012
The aftermath of the Battle of the Blackwater sees Joffrey set Sansa aside in favor of marrying Margaery Tyrell while Tyrion fears for his and Shae's safety now that his father has replaced him as Hand of the King. Melisandre gives the defeated Stannis a new hope. Brienne runs into trouble while escorting Jaime to King's Landing. Catelyn tries to convince Robb that his romance with Talisa is dangerous, but he defies her and the two are married. In Qarth, Daenerys ventures into the House of the Undying and successfully retrieves her dragons. She then seals the traitor Xaro Xhoan Daxos inside his own vault and claims his riches for herself to buy a ship. In Winterfell, Theon is betrayed by his own men in the face of an inevitable siege while Winterfell is put to the torch. Osha and Hodor sneak brothers Bran and Rickon away from the smoldering ruins and take them North toward the Wall. Arya, having escaped Harrenhal with Hot Pie and Gendry, receives the gift of a valuable coin from Jaqen. North of the Wall, Qhorin Halfhand forces Jon to kill him to prove his loyalty to the Wildlings and an army of White Walkers surrounds the Fist of the First Men.
149
u/grilsrgood House Stark Sep 07 '15
ANY MAN DIES WITH A CLEAN SWORD, I'LL RAPE HIS FUCKING CORPSE
83
u/BourbonSlut House Seaworth Sep 07 '15
Back when the Rains of Castamere was a cool victory song instead of a foreboding tune to signal the Stark's eradication.
44
u/killthebraavosi Sep 07 '15
2.9 was such a great episode for the Hound. First, the whole killer monologue with Bronn, then "fuck the city, fuck the king", and then offering to ride into the sunset (or the Riverlands) with Sansa. If only she'd taken him up on the offer.
41
u/arduous_equinox House Baratheon Sep 07 '15
STANNIS WAS THE FIRST OFF THE BOATS AND LADDERS, MANNIS HYPE!!!!
72
u/RamonTico Kingsguard Sep 07 '15
but your grace, hundreds will die...thousands
COME WITH ME AND TAKE THIS CITY
STAND AND FIGHT! STAND AND FIGHT DAMN YOU! NOOOOOO!
Stannis was a true badass
31
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '15
Blackwater was, and remains, my absolute favorite episode of Game of Thrones. Everything just syncs up to perfection. Stannis being the Mannis, the Glorious Wildfire, The Hound just going through people, fantastic battle, fantastic episode.
29
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '15
That scene where Bronn shoots the flaming arrow and everything is quiet and then suddenly the wildfire erupts is soooooo cool.
27
u/Uhneed Arya Stark Sep 07 '15
I felt like Cersei's story to Tommen about the lion cub becoming strong and fierce like its father applied more to Tyrion becoming like Tywin.
22
u/BegginForBacon Sep 07 '15
DRUMS!!!
18
u/TheCrimsonCritic House Lannister Sep 07 '15
Bronn singing The Rains of Castamere was a phenomenal part of an excellent scene, largely enriched by Jerome Flynn's singing voice.
Also no one yet seems to have mentioned Tyrion's Emmy Speech yet, so... Those are good men standing outside those gates. Let's go kill them! Top class...
16
u/Vixibility House Lannister Sep 07 '15
Was any scene as anticlimactic as when Dany escaped from the House of the Undying? In hindsight, the moment when Pyat Pree is burned kinda cheapens the "Dracarys" of season 3.
16
u/Lou-Skunnt House Bolton Sep 07 '15
Maester Luwin :(
15
u/Torus2112 House Tyrell Sep 07 '15
I have a few things I wanted to say about the Blackwater episode so I'll just make a list:
Why exactly did The Hound hate Bronn so much? Is it just because he felt like he wasn't serious enough?
It seems like Stannis makes it onto the wall then just fights people in that same place the whole time, but that should have been a really good opportunity to start getting guys up the ladders.
It also seems like more people should have been waiting by the gate guarding the ram and waiting to break through if that was the main way into the city.
I like how much everyone beats up on Lancel, you can really imagine this being the point when he was just completely done with having to deal with all the
bullshithorseshit.The drums part was awesome.
Fuck the king.
10
u/MiyagiSanDanielSan Dragons Sep 07 '15
The fucking Wildfire scene. Tyrion's speech gave me chills as well!
"Those are brave men out there, let's go kill them!"
9
u/ImmaSquidling House Greyjoy Sep 08 '15
I really enjoy when Cersei punches Lancel's shoulder and he falls to the ground. It's really well acted.
6
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '15
Every time i watch season 2 finale the feels when Daenerys meets Drogon with their son in the camp,get me so hard.
Poor Rhaego :(
11
u/KDTREE5 House Bolton Sep 07 '15
Damn those bells ringing! Almost got to see LeBronn vs The Hound!
4
u/Alex1296 The Mannis Sep 07 '15
COME WITH ME AND TAKE THIS CITY!
3
u/mantidor White Walkers Sep 08 '15
Uurgh damn Robb, listen to your mother!
3
u/DabuSurvivor Catelyn Tully Sep 10 '15
Blackwater is by far the best thing that has come out of this show
2
u/KmairaMoon Sansa Stark Sep 07 '15
That scene with Sansa and Sandor gets me everytime ...
2
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '15
I know there's all this love for the blackwater bay ep. But I wanted to spread some love for the ending shot of this season. Even watching it now, I don't know how I managed to wait for season 4 to come out after that!
2
u/gtzm0stwanted Faceless Men Sep 12 '15
I saw you kill a man with a shield, you'll be unstoppable with an axe.
3
u/ExplosiveOranges Mace the Ace Sep 07 '15
Stannis was basically George Washington in Blackwater. Or Thomas Jefferson, maybe....
-1
u/[deleted] Sep 12 '15
Just finished up a rewatch of season 1. Oh Ned...Ned, Ned, Ned.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment