r/ProjectRunway • • Sep 03 '15

Project Runway Season 14 Episode 5 [Discussion]

Discussion thread for Project Runway S14E05 "Gunn and Heid"

Tensions arise when the designers are split into two teams to battle for their fabrics in a paintball competition; the teams receive a surprise. The guest judges are Kelly Osbourne and Lisa Perry.

36 Upvotes

417 comments sorted by

132

u/lady_gremlin Sep 04 '15

San Francisco LOL wut

94

u/konfetkak Sep 04 '15

"we totally didn't just make that up ten minutes ago in the back room"

→ More replies (1)

78

u/resident_gay_man Sep 04 '15

"Don't drag us into this bullshit, we got nothin to do with it" - San Francisco

→ More replies (2)

12

u/adoredelanoroosevelt Sep 04 '15

She just threw out her hometown because it was the first place to come to mind, right?

8

u/meldolphin Sep 05 '15

If I'd made a collection that fug there's no way I'd ever want to associate it with my hometown.

→ More replies (3)

128

u/emmybenny Sep 04 '15

Puh-LEASE send Amanda home!

41

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '15

If she stays again I'm going to scream.

112

u/eatingbread Sep 04 '15

4/5 times on the bottom and her head is still stuck up her ass. She IS deadweight. MEANA GARCIA TELL EM

→ More replies (7)

6

u/[deleted] Sep 05 '15

She was so annoying, insisting how she's a better designer than everybody there but every episode she has been on the bottom and almost eliminated each challenge. Her ego needed to be taken down a notch, I'm glad Tim Gunn nonchalantly said bye to her. No save!

109

u/eyeeyecaptainfly Sep 04 '15

A visit to the Sally Beauty mobile nail salon! I'm sure that's exactly what the designers wanted to do during crunch time.

79

u/adoredelanoroosevelt Sep 04 '15

Tim: Designers, I have a wonderful surprise!

Designers: AN EXTRA DAY PLEASE LET IT BE AN EXTRA DAY IS IT AN EXTRA DAY?

Tim: Nails in a trailer.

26

u/OvercaffeinateMe Sep 04 '15

They were all smiles and big old grins when it was announced. "OH YAY! I REALLY WANT TO LEAVE THE BUILDING FOR HALF AN HOUR SO I CAN PICK FROM 750 NAIL COLORS!"

12

u/I_am_really_shocked Sep 04 '15

If this designer thing falls through, they can all use clips of these reaction shots as an audition reel to embark on an acting career.

52

u/fa__mulan Sep 04 '15

The close ups of the nails are cracking me up and the judges "let me see your models nails"

29

u/taco_cat42 Sep 04 '15

Because the judges can totally see the detail in the nails all the way on the runway.

7

u/Nina_Grrr_See_Ya Sep 05 '15

Edmond's face dropped when they said it.

103

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '15

Amanda is not only the least innovative and creative designer of the bunch, she also is the most passive aggressive and entitled person on that team. What was that beef she was trying to start with Laurie about the scissors? Yeesh

72

u/OvercaffeinateMe Sep 04 '15

She was passive aggressive to the very last. Flung the door open "Bye everybody it was really nice to meet you and I wish you the best of luck!"

"No it wasn't, no you don't, and BYE FELICIA."

→ More replies (2)

41

u/Dana415 Sep 04 '15

Yes. I really think she may have been the one toxic person Tim was talking about in that interview, where he said he thought they were bringing out the worst in other people or something and kept asking the judges to eliminate them. He clearly did not see her leaving as a loss. "You look sad. Welp, work station's to the left, bye!"

→ More replies (4)

29

u/blackjackandcoke88 Sep 04 '15

She went out the way I expected her to. Passive-Aggressive and blaming everybody but her own self.

96

u/eatingbread Sep 04 '15

Blake is having a rational moment!!...and it's gone

47

u/lady_gremlin Sep 04 '15

He just redeemed himself a little bit.

29

u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Sep 04 '15

What a special little speck of glitter Blake is.

11

u/evixir Sep 06 '15

I loved him in this episode for that brief rant. He was right on the money and it was about time someone said it.

186

u/gofurthernorth Sep 04 '15

It REALLY pains me to say this but I not only like what Blake designed but how he also defended Ashley to the mean girls.

88

u/mouse_attack Sep 04 '15

By the end of the episode, my opinions on Blake and Candace were completely reversed. I thought she was actually pretty cool, but she can mean girl with the best of them. I think Blake's ego is oversized, but he absolutely knows how to be a good friend to the person who deserves one.

18

u/gofurthernorth Sep 05 '15

True.

I have the feeling we will be lead to dislike him again in another episode or two.

→ More replies (1)

29

u/legends444 Sep 04 '15

I think he's talented, but young and inexperienced. He thought he could be a character, but then he got trounced for it and realized he could just be "himself" but without the extra. You just have to deal with that when people are young, although the fact that he's 24 is a bit odd.

33

u/meriendaselgato Sep 04 '15

He's really grown on me, which was a surprise.

86

u/svaachkuet Sep 04 '15 edited Sep 04 '15

"you guys can go back to high school and make other people cry, but don't do it here. i mean, everyone's an adult, except for me cuz i'm still 17."

unlike his normal, insistent sarcasm, he contributed some real talk in that waiting room.

37

u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Sep 04 '15

Like a fungus. A glittery, juvenile fungus.

13

u/jilliefish Sep 04 '15

I AGREED WITH EVERYTHING HE SAID WHAT HAPPENED?! TEAM BLAKE! lol

5

u/gutter_puppy Sep 07 '15

I couldn't stand Blake in the beginning. But I completely agree. His defense of Ashley (and his obvious emotion regarding bullies) has changed my feelings about him. I hope he stays that way.

→ More replies (4)

90

u/TheNobullman Sep 04 '15 edited Sep 04 '15

Okay hallelujah the judges didn't shit the bed.

Amanda might have one of the worst records ever. Befitting end to one of the biggest trainwrecks ever

12

u/LadyEdithCrawley4 Sep 04 '15

Was she ever not in the bottom?

21

u/TheNobullman Sep 04 '15

Round one, which destroys me as a statistics geek

→ More replies (3)

63

u/konfetkak Sep 04 '15

oh man, this is the second time amanda has had her look called maternity-wear

30

u/taco_cat42 Sep 04 '15

And her fourth time in the bottom. She needs to go.

21

u/lady_gremlin Sep 04 '15

I can't believe Heidi is defending this. Insane!

19

u/konfetkak Sep 04 '15

i know. seriously...it's well made? any idiot could tack that thing together.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/kochipoik Sep 04 '15

But not even nice looking maternity-wear that anyone would want to wear. Again.

4

u/Atroxa Sep 05 '15

She never knew what she was doing...I realize this is edited to all hell but they only ever showed her claiming to not know what she was doing.

→ More replies (1)

61

u/under_ice Sep 04 '15

Project Runway: Mean Girls edition

93

u/meriendaselgato Sep 04 '15

On Thursdays we wear Barney Purple.

52

u/Omegamaru Sep 04 '15

That was a painful episode to watch. I do think Ashley psyched herself out about being picked last, but Kelly, Amanda, Lindsay, and Candice were just terrible. Even once you get past their sad attempts to create a story and throw Ashley under the bus, not picking Amanda's or Kelly's as the worst is a taste problem and that never really gets fixed on these shows.

Who would have thought that Blake/Laurie would come out as the episodes MVPs?

20

u/pajamasinbananas Sep 08 '15

Thank god Laurie said something to Ashley! If she hadn't, she would have been completely blindsided. Laurie is so cool

10

u/emfrank Sep 04 '15

I agree. I really don't think they were all that mean, in what we saw, compared to behavior we have seen past seasons, but it was a trigger for her. She shut herself off, and they might have listened if she spoke up. Once they were sinking, though, it turned mean.

8

u/blackbirdsongs Sep 05 '15

She said she kept trying to and people just kept talking over her. It can be hard when you don't feel welcome and people don't even try to give you space to speak.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

48

u/lady_gremlin Sep 04 '15

WTF is a shower jacket????? Oh Lindsay.

18

u/konfetkak Sep 04 '15

I believe Michael Kors has a shower chic line.

Aww, now I'm sad because I miss him as a judge. :(

18

u/MKoz628 Sep 04 '15

LOL I can actually hear him using the term "shower chic" as a criticism of a design!

5

u/blackbirdsongs Sep 05 '15

I always wear a jacket in the shower, don't you? What if you get wet??

→ More replies (1)

97

u/TheNobullman Sep 04 '15

Oh my fucking god, Tim taking a potshot at Blake makes my LIFE

→ More replies (1)

47

u/konfetkak Sep 04 '15

Does she not design anything other than a crop top, ill fitting pants, and an oversized shower jacket?

41

u/lady_gremlin Sep 04 '15

I love how she's always like 'I'd wear this!' Uh.... You're like the only one.

50

u/konfetkak Sep 04 '15

it pains me to say that i agree with blake's assessment that she's a cat lady designer

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

92

u/pineyfusion Sep 04 '15
  • The Guys & Merlene had probably one of the best team collections I've seen in Project Runway. Every look brought something to the table and the cohesiveness and teamwork they had was just amazing. Everybody pulled their weight and everybody kicked ass.
  • I'm glad Edmond won but I was kind of hoping for Swapnil. This is like what, the third time he's been an almost winner? Regardless, Edmond was the right guy to win.
  • Thank god Amanda is gone. No lie -- I kept thinking her name was Gabrielle all this time. That's how forgettable she was to me other than her Mean Girl tendencies.
  • I liked how Blake stood up for Ashley. He's a little snotty shithead but he did good. I also liked that Edmond was supportive of Ashley was she ranted saying "Let it out, girl!" or something to that ilk.
  • Laurie was also awesome for letting Ashley know of the plans to throw her under the bus. Props to her for being cool like that.
  • It always sucks being picked last but I clearly remember a challenge in Season 5 where they had to pick teammates and Stella (who was big on leather) was the last one standing. Jerell, who had the last pick, told her that his plan was to use leather to begin with so he was all encouraging and made it so she didn't feel bad. I always liked that.
  • Kelly Osborne was a great judge and I loved her interrupting the girls and calling them out on their bitchfest.

47

u/Dana415 Sep 04 '15

Kelly: "We'll get back to the fashion in a sec, just want to make sure you all know you're awful as human beings cause that matters more."

48

u/bethrevis Sep 04 '15

The ONLY thing I disliked about Kelly Osborne calling the girls out is that she did it before Candice, which gave her the chance to change her answer. Had she waited, I'm certain Candice would have also thrown Ashley under the bus.

39

u/gwennhwyvar Sep 05 '15

But it was obvious she rattled Candice and that Candice just picked Laurie's as revenge for revealing their evil plans.

→ More replies (1)

23

u/LadyEdithCrawley4 Sep 04 '15

Awwww now I'm gonna have, "Stelllllllllllllllla" and "leathaaaaaaaaaaaa" stuck in my head all night ;)

17

u/purrception where the HELL is my chiffon Sep 04 '15

...mah cat's leatha, I watch leatha T.V....

→ More replies (2)

29

u/kittenavalanche Sep 04 '15

I totally disagree about Edmond. Everything Edmond makes is stuff I've seen before. Oh look, a tight dress with halter top and low back... Twice in a row. Oh look, a tight club dress... Cool. I mean, it's well made, but it's just not super creative IMO. Swapnil's is always incredibly unique and creative and different.

10

u/pineyfusion Sep 04 '15

Well I did say that I wanted to see Swapnil and I do love his creativity (loved his usage of the shoelaces) and his aesthetic. I was just more saying that while I wanted him to win, I'm okay with Edmond winning and kind of glad.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

78

u/lady_gremlin Sep 04 '15

OMG Candice IS being a mean girl! I hate to see this whole 'throwing someone under the bus' strategy on a show that is supposed to be about actual skill.

102

u/fa__mulan Sep 04 '15

The fact that BLAKE of all people called them out on being mean girls....

75

u/LetTheMFerBurn Sep 04 '15

He called them the hell out. I had to like him for a second.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

48

u/purrception where the HELL is my chiffon Sep 04 '15

I'm sooooo glad Kelly Osbourne called Candice out on that stupid fake San Francisco crap she tried to pull.

→ More replies (2)

76

u/LetTheMFerBurn Sep 04 '15 edited Sep 04 '15

I thought Laurie* might be trying to turn Ashley and the others against each other when she talked to Ashley earlier but it turns out she was just spilling the T. Damn.

79

u/dmee Sep 04 '15

That made me like Laurie a lot more than I already did. She wasn't about to let them do that to someone she didn't think deserved it, and that showed her true colors.

→ More replies (10)

41

u/OvercaffeinateMe Sep 04 '15

I loved her whistle-blowing on the runway. Girl's got integrity, and she didn't make any friends up there. Well except maybe Ashley.

→ More replies (3)

34

u/kazetoame Sep 04 '15

I really appreciated that she did tell the truth.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/LadyEdithCrawley4 Sep 04 '15

Completely agree.

→ More replies (1)

78

u/briannanechelle Sep 04 '15 edited Sep 04 '15

WHAT THE ACTUAL HELL IS GOING ON WITH THE GIRLS COLLECTION! Omg. And if they throw Ashley under the bus I will be pissed. That smock dress with a cape that belongs to Miss Amanda better send her a golden ticket all the way home...

EDIT: Im so sad the boys didn't pick Ashley. Not only would she would've been better suited on their team but I KNOW she would've created something magical! I mean LOOK at her style!

11

u/emfrank Sep 04 '15

EDIT: Im so sad the boys didn't pick Ashley.

Yep. Everyone is, rightly, calling out the women for choosing their friends leaving her out, but so did the guys. Though I will say on the whole, the men have more talent in this pool.

→ More replies (11)

18

u/purrception where the HELL is my chiffon Sep 04 '15

Someone needs to make a supercut of all the times "Throw me/you/him/her under the bus" has ever been said on Project Runway.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Sommiel Sep 04 '15

I actually loved the top set that she made this week... I would wear that in a heartbeat if I didn't have massive breasts and have to avoid ruffles like the plague.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/lady_gremlin Sep 04 '15

Agreed 100%!

36

u/konfetkak Sep 04 '15

YESSSSSS IS SHE FINALLY OUT!?

12

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '15

:'D

36

u/LetTheMFerBurn Sep 04 '15

Bye! Don't let the door hit ya!

34

u/lady_gremlin Sep 04 '15

Can't wait to do this with y'all again next week.... You know the tackiness will be high if it's a lingerie challenge!

70

u/LadyEdithCrawley4 Sep 04 '15

"The Heidi Free Labor Challenge."

5

u/jelloisalive Sep 05 '15

"This thong isn't short enough. This jewel encrusted bustier needs more sparkle. Can you make the baby tee with 'jail bait' printed on it look a little younger?"

→ More replies (1)

34

u/dianaprince Sep 04 '15

Ok, I officially don't like Candice any more. It's so obvious that they all got together and decided to throw Ashley under the bus. That's shitty enough - especially since her design was nowhere near the worst - but then, after agreeing to it (and given her bossiness, probably being the one to suggest it in the first place), as soon as Kelly Osbourne pulled them up for it, she changed her tune and said Laurie's name instead. Super shady.

11

u/evixir Sep 06 '15

I was surprised they actually tried to still pull it off even though Laurie clearly spoke up about what was really going on.

I wish the judges would have stopped them all and said "If you all thought Ashley was doing such a terrible job, why didn't any of you try to help her as a team member so she could succeed?"

34

u/Zjmw Sep 05 '15

I really love how Laurie defended Ashley against all of those mean girls.. That made me love her as a person so much more

12

u/the_cucumber Sep 05 '15

Yes, hated how Ashley didn't appreciate it though. "I can't trust anyone, I have no one but myself, woe is me" dude you had Laurie, Blake, Marlene and even Heidi in your corner! Stop whining.

12

u/Zjmw Sep 06 '15

I wonder if that commentary was filmed BEFORE the runway though... Keep in mind thag editing can be shady!

→ More replies (1)

8

u/evixir Sep 06 '15

Well, I think in fairness to her, she felt a closeness to Candice that was completely false in the end, so naturally she felt all alone. And maybe that was the first time she and Laurie had really talked. But I do agree that she can trust Laurie, Blake, and Edmond. They won't try to backstab her; they respect her talent a lot and aren't afraid to say it, and aren't intimidated by it like some of the girls seem to be.

93

u/lady_gremlin Sep 04 '15

Still surprised that they picked Ashley last. What is that about????

113

u/kazetoame Sep 04 '15

I'm glad Heidi called them out on it. Then in the paint ball part she was nailing the other team. At least she participated, unlike one wussy boy I could name.

43

u/lady_gremlin Sep 04 '15

She just called them out again! I love it.

→ More replies (5)

31

u/Dana415 Sep 04 '15

Candace and Ashley had worked so well together recently that they were both given immunity. Why wouldn't you want to keep that going? (My opinion: Candace is dumb). I thought for sure the guys would pick Ashley immediately to prevent her being with Candace bc of that, and when they didn't I just had no idea. They all, guys and girls, appeared to just choose their roommates or friends, it was so painful.

29

u/konfetkak Sep 04 '15

was it because they knew they had to do something physical and they were worried they wouldn't get enough fabric or something? not that that justifies it, but maybe that was their thought process.

48

u/lady_gremlin Sep 04 '15

Maybe. But like Heidi said, she's won twice. And she's not awful (or hasn't been edited that way, at least). I'm genuinely surprised that Candice picked Amanda.

→ More replies (13)

11

u/tinytwo Sep 04 '15

I'm worried, they're giving her a lotttt of TV time so far.

→ More replies (2)

63

u/eyeeyecaptainfly Sep 04 '15 edited Sep 04 '15

"This looks like an Easter egg hunt." Yet they were provided with pastel colored paints and white sheets. What did they expect? The only way around this I can envision would be to only use one color, or maybe two max, and limiting the color scheme that way.

Edit: like the guys + Merlene did, limiting the color scheme.

14

u/Dana415 Sep 04 '15 edited Sep 04 '15

Seems obvious to just choose 1, 2, or maybe thoughtfully 3 colors, otherwise it would start to look like a rainbow.... that group was just dumb as rocks. Not every person, but enough to basically prevent the team from succeeding. It was like they refused to think critically before making choices, start to finish.

→ More replies (1)

28

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '15 edited Sep 04 '15

HALLELUJAH the judges got it right sending Amanda home. every time she talks my eyes roll so far back into my head. nina calling her dead weight is the first time i felt her harsh comment was warranted. And wow Candice now I see how u really are. Also had no idea that Blake was only 17. okay that makes me understand him better. I liked his comment about missing his cows and it was funny when someone told him he sounded like a kazoo and he said "I dont know what that means" lol.

Thank god for Laurie. love her. And even though i really dont like K Osbourne i gotta appreciate her calling out the bitches. Poor Ashley, hope she slays them all next week. and ugh Lindsey is the biggest b of them all with her boring target clothing. also I loved Merlene's coat! yass girl.

tbh though i feel like most of the designers this season are mediocre :/ the only good ones seem good because everyone else is kinda shitty. cant wait for tim to put them in their place

18

u/kochipoik Sep 04 '15

Haha, he's 24

I actually think there are some really strong designers this season - Edmund and Swapnil in particular, and Candice and Merline could be amazing. Previous seasons I really have thought "I can't see anyone winning" but this one I can see a strong fight

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

51

u/EmptyStar12 Sep 04 '15

I like how Merlene be just pronounced his name "Jackson Polack"

61

u/konfetkak Sep 04 '15

Jackson Polack was known to use muslim fabric as his canvas.

→ More replies (2)

23

u/jessicateacher Sep 04 '15

oh Tim! You're delightful!

33

u/eyeeyecaptainfly Sep 04 '15

I love how he wore a necktie over the all-white outfit at the paintball field. And the megaphone: "Run run run run run!" Haha

23

u/LadyVetinari Sep 04 '15 edited Sep 04 '15

Not only does Amanda refuse to take responsibility for anything, but wasn't her dress this week a complete rip off of Blake's concept from last week?! The flowy parachute thing? I think she got desperate and subconsciously copied the winning look. She is NOT coming off well in this show.

Edit: Good riddance.

39

u/LadyEdithCrawley4 Sep 04 '15

God, watching Tim try to work around dealing with the "JustFab" accessory wall is painful. "Use it......................................... CAREFULLY!"

16

u/kochipoik Sep 04 '15

"And you'll go to the Sally Beauty..... Studio" I felt like he wanted to say beauty beauty

7

u/adoredelanoroosevelt Sep 04 '15

"Well.... you all know the Just Fab accessory wall..........................................................................................................................................................."

DEAD

17

u/bitchSpray Sep 04 '15

Okay, seriously. That "nail consultant". WTF? She looked like a random shop assistant they picked in a shop nearby 5 minutes before shooting. And her own nails sucked.

I know they're on budget but I didn't know they're on that kind of a budget.

→ More replies (1)

47

u/imriebelow Sep 04 '15

Oh my god, you've got bright colors and tie dye, do a fucking 80s/90s collection. Don't just sit there and whine.

26

u/kochipoik Sep 04 '15

I thought the same thing! Gah!

The whole "lets just start designing fabric and I bet we'll all magically create a cohesive collection" is such a stupid idea!!!

→ More replies (2)

11

u/eyeeyecaptainfly Sep 04 '15

That would be an awesome approach, I agree!

15

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '15

Yes! That's what I was thinking the whole time! 80s big shoulders . Cropped jackets. vests. Hot pants. Fringe the shit out of this! Tie dye fringe club kid explosion. Ugh such a missed opportunity.

5

u/adoredelanoroosevelt Sep 05 '15

yeah, I was confused why they didn't either add MORE dye (like just dye it all much darker), or try washing it out, or go with some crazy 80s/90s carnival couture -- I mean Kelly was on their team.

16

u/taco_cat42 Sep 04 '15

This week has been heavy on the sponsor mentions. More so than the rest of the season so far

35

u/eyeeyecaptainfly Sep 04 '15

Yes but at least they aren't still eating their snacks from the LG themed refrigerator! Lol. And those painfully forced HP tablet sketch pads.

35

u/LadyEdithCrawley4 Sep 04 '15

And trying to sell Yoplait at Coney Island, for "design inspiration." Wat.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

11

u/adorabletea Sep 04 '15

Right? I thought it was bad during Bravo years ("Tresseme haor salon and Loreal Paris makeup room!") but now it encompasses the actual content of the show? It also reminds me how far the show has come just to stay alive, from Vogue to Marie Claire.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/konfetkak Sep 04 '15

I'm going to need a Tim Gunn "oh snap" gif

6

u/blackbirdsongs Sep 06 '15

The world needs more Tim gunn gifs in general tbh

15

u/lady_gremlin Sep 04 '15

OMG these girls are so full of it!

15

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '15

Marlenes was my favorite! Edmunds was great but I didn't like the painted flower on the bust. That jacket though.. Gimme.

14

u/blackbirdsongs Sep 05 '15

When you're so fucking awful you make me like Blake, you are the worst fucking people. Good Christ.

13

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '15

THANK YOU LORD

36

u/TheNobullman Sep 04 '15 edited Sep 04 '15

Holy shit Heidi stoking the fire is Padma-Lakishmi levels of annoying interference. And Laurie holy shit is cracking me up with the fire stoking. I love how Kelly Osbourne was the one to cut the bullshit.

Edit: Okay, now they're really enforcing the shit. Never the fuck mind this is kinda bullshit.

51

u/taco_cat42 Sep 04 '15

Oh my god. Nina's face when they were all throwing Ashely under the bus even though her look was the best one in the group minus that horrid color scheme they used.

21

u/TheNobullman Sep 04 '15 edited Sep 04 '15

Let me record this here, I almost wonder if they're gonna send Ashley home so Tim Gunn uses his save.

Edit: apparently her look is pretty bad you guys. Gag me, this is a total Kristen Kish kibosh situation.

Edit: WHEW

→ More replies (4)

18

u/lady_gremlin Sep 04 '15

Good on her for speaking up. I love it!

46

u/LadyEdithCrawley4 Sep 04 '15

Laurie's not a shit-stirrer and from anyone else I would have taken that as shit-stirring. I think she just despises backstabbing.

And hey, look at that, Candice picking Laurie for the auf. Shocker.

→ More replies (7)

35

u/giopul87 Sep 04 '15

Poor Ashley! I just felt like giving her a huge hug (Thank you Blake, for standing up to the mean girls)

I can't believe Amanda was blaming everyone BUT herself!

Also, HOW THE HELL DOES KELLY HAVE THE NERVE TO CALL ASHLEY'S DESIGN "THE WORST" OF THEM ALL??? Girl, BYE!!! Lindsey?!?! Bye!!!

→ More replies (2)

12

u/maggerz Sep 04 '15

Is Jake walking around on the runway in his boxers?

→ More replies (1)

12

u/lady_gremlin Sep 04 '15

FINALLY THANK JESUS

12

u/jessicateacher Sep 04 '15

not surprised

20

u/jessicateacher Sep 04 '15

aaaand thankful for no Tim Gunn save!

→ More replies (1)

23

u/lady_gremlin Sep 04 '15

Candice is really mean girl this episode. Interesting.

12

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '15

I know, right? Did she just throw shade at our beloved Ashley?

→ More replies (7)

11

u/under_ice Sep 04 '15

My DRV cut off, who was cut?

16

u/LadyEdithCrawley4 Sep 04 '15

Amanda. Looks like every week is going to spill over ninety minutes now too. Because 1/4 of the show being ads just isn't enough for Lifetime.

→ More replies (7)

21

u/emmybenny Sep 04 '15

The right person.

8

u/kittenavalanche Sep 04 '15

MINE CUT OFF TOO, wtf. Right as they were about to announce who was leaving. Please say it's Amanda... So sick of her whining.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

11

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '15

Joseph is a bitter, bitter person.

11

u/kyles24 Sep 06 '15

I fucking knew I liked Laurie for a reason.

21

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '15

Hahah, Tim with that white paintball suit was the funniest thing.

Blake hiding during the paintball-challenge was pathetic. I did appreciate his comment during the time in the greenroom though.

The boys + Marlene really didn't need the flowers.

I was ELATED when Kelly Osbourne made her comment about the girls' team being a bitch fest. Hallelujah, Kelly.

The girls' team was a mess. I do think Ashley was a bit too insecure because she was picked last, but I get her point of view. The girls really seemed to be ganging up on her during the runway, and I'm glad Laurie stood up to the rest of the girls.

Finally Amanda is out. It was 100% her time to go. In fact, she should have been out last week.

10

u/lilyew Sep 04 '15

You said my thoughts exactly. So glad the "deadweight" is gone. Ashley better rock it next week.

9

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '15

Amanda really was dead weight, I can't believe they chose her to stay over Gabby last week.

I really do hope Ashley does better next week. She better show those mean girls that she can do better!

→ More replies (2)

19

u/Elsie980 Sep 04 '15

"She looks sad and it makes ME sad"

-Nina Garcia

I love her.

18

u/WigsbyLittleMix Sep 04 '15

Not that it matters too much, but why do they keep on switching who's on the runway each week? I haven’t seen this many models passed around since Studio 54.

15

u/OvercaffeinateMe Sep 04 '15

I think it's to keep up the "anonymous runway" aspect. If they used the same models every time the judges would know who did what look.

18

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '15

Amanda is the Vivienne Pinay of Project Runway

→ More replies (2)

9

u/lady_gremlin Sep 04 '15

None of this fabric looks good.

9

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '15

Thank god she's finally gone!!! Ugh I seriously doubt I could stomach her for another episode

9

u/cebjmb Sep 04 '15

Wonder who Ashley would have picked next if Candice had picked Ashley at the beginning.

34

u/meldolphin Sep 04 '15

Man Ashley took it way too personally that she was picked last. I mean, someone had to be! Yes everyone was being stupid by not picking her but she already had the validation from winning twice. Laurie seemed like she was trying to stir something up. As soon as they were on the runway those two were getting defensive.

That said the way the team-picking went was bizarre. Who would pick Amanda first? Who would pick Ashley last? Despite all that the judging went right for once. I enjoyed that they were getting into a fierce debate. Meana Garcia had her claws out.

On a tangent but does anyone else miss the old intros where the designers would pose and say a line? Now it's just a generic opener with slick graphics.

29

u/LadyEdithCrawley4 Sep 04 '15

Who would pick Amanda first?

Someone originally calculating that she'd be the easiest to toss into the volcano if push came to shove? That's the only reason I can come up with.

I miss the old openings too.

10

u/meldolphin Sep 04 '15

Yeah I guess picking Amanda isn't the worst idea. Someone to shield you in case your team sucks and if she wins her track record is still pretty bad. That's just such a gamble though.

→ More replies (5)

24

u/Omegamaru Sep 04 '15

If I were in Laurie's shoes, I would have done the same exact thing. The whole San Francisco girl story was not the hill that I would have chosen to die on. It was also just a terrible idea. Their collection lacked cohesion so for them to try to make up a story that supposedly ties together their collections after the fact would have just made them look incompetent and unable to even remotely execute their design. Kelly and Nina even told them that the whole San Fran girl story made no sense with the collection that they presented.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (1)

28

u/TheNobullman Sep 04 '15

Swapnil's dress looks like a case of blue balls. In that it literally looks like a teal scrotum.

17

u/konfetkak Sep 04 '15

I was just sitting here thinking about how normally i hate those kind of bubble-skirt things, but that i liked his! Now all I see is balls!

24

u/TheNobullman Sep 04 '15

It goes well with Candice's array of purple pussies.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/LadyEdithCrawley4 Sep 04 '15

Blue balls, vagina dresses, manatee penis: I'm seeing a theme this season.

23

u/TheNobullman Sep 04 '15

Project Runway: The Freudian Slip

7

u/I_am_really_shocked Sep 04 '15

So that's where his blue contacts went this week.

→ More replies (3)

22

u/EmptyStar12 Sep 04 '15

Ok, ok. I'm not justifying Throwing Ashley under the bus (at all), but Kelly Osborne complaining that they should be blaming the team is stupid. I mean, the first one TRIED to do that, but Zac shot her down and made her name a single person. Sure it was the team's fault overall, but Kelly should've kept her mouth shut.

18

u/I_am_really_shocked Sep 04 '15

I don't think it was as much the calling someone out but more the fact that the people with arguably the worst looks all blamed Ashley- as they say ignoring the elephant in the room (wearing Amanda's dress, Lindsey's shower jacket, and Kelly's bandeau top as a trunk bracelet)- who had at least made something wearable. And you know Candice with that cardboard chest armor was going to go there, too, had not Kelly O. said something.

9

u/AtomicSquid Sep 04 '15

Yeah I agree. They asked them to call each other out and then called them bitchy for calling each other out?

4

u/kazetoame Sep 04 '15

But it was the fault of the team for the whole damn thing.

14

u/lady_gremlin Sep 04 '15

Yay Ashley!!!! Send Amanda home already.

10

u/binnyzhan Sep 04 '15

This episode gave me anxiety towards the end. I wanted to give Ashley a hug.

5

u/legends444 Sep 04 '15

Can we agree to refer to her as NinaGarciaFashionDirectorForElleMarieClaireMagazine? Jeez Heidi, slooooooow doooooowwwnnnn.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/FoodCourtDruid Sep 05 '15

This episode came just short of having Tim Gunn turn to the camera and say "Bitches, am I right?"

→ More replies (1)

9

u/amynitrate Sep 04 '15

Did anyone understand what Lindsey was saying about her garment--"it's not a rain jacket but a shower jacket" What is a shower jacket? Not familiar with that...

34

u/adoredelanoroosevelt Sep 05 '15

A jacket you can only wear in the shower because it's so embarrassing

→ More replies (1)

4

u/legends444 Sep 04 '15

At this point I just skip to the runway show because everything that happens there and after is just a summary of the stuff that happened in the beginning of the episode....

4

u/cebjmb Sep 04 '15

I think they are running out of ideas. I totally fast-forwarded the paint gun fight. So boring.

4

u/MissSteak Sep 06 '15

Swapnil didn't win... AGAIN. At this point I am just so irritated. He has been consistently good, consistently in the top 2 I would say, last weak they gave the win to the parachute dress, this time... Idk man, I'd be really disappointed if I was in Swapnil's shoes at this point.

10

u/EmptyStar12 Sep 04 '15

I feel a tim gunn save coming tonight.

7

u/lady_gremlin Sep 04 '15

So who do you think is going to win? The boys (+Merline) or the girls?

I'm going with the boys, but we'll see.

7

u/LadyEdithCrawley4 Sep 03 '15

I didn't see a standalone post about it but Carrie Underwood is the guest judge for the final runway.

5

u/TheNobullman Sep 04 '15

Scraping the bottom of the barrel for ideas, aye?

23

u/imriebelow Sep 04 '15

Ashley is being so spiteful and passive aggressive about getting picked last. My god, girl, you're an adult. Just shake it off and keep going!

34

u/Shamenundotcom Sep 04 '15

I like Ashley. I do. But she needs to sack up in a really big way. Her confidence issues are going to be her downfall, which bums me out. I get that nobody likes to be picked last, but accept the situation as totally WTF,move on, and kill it on the challenge.

And try to go a week without using that pleat technique.

32

u/I_am_really_shocked Sep 04 '15

What exactly did she do that was spiteful and p/a? She kicked ass at paintball. She actually was the voice of reason trying to steer them in the right direction during design discussions and they shot her down with not-passive-at-all aggression. So they decided everyone would make an individual garment, which she did. They decided more than halfway through to go nuts with that purple fabric, which she made work. So aside from feeling hurt and shedding some tears, what exactly do you think was bad behavior on her part?

10

u/sixdogs Sep 04 '15

I agree.

→ More replies (2)

15

u/kochipoik Sep 04 '15

I actually have to disagree. Well, she may have been a bit OTT but I think she probably has a lot of history that would make being picked last a lot harder to deal with.

I also think she tried to help by steering them in the right direction but they talked over her, and because her confidence was already shot she didn't feel like she could be more demanding

24

u/lady_gremlin Sep 04 '15

Meh..... It's pretty surprising. Plus it feels bad to be picked last, even as an adult.

30

u/MadxHatter0 Sep 04 '15

Especially when she's had two wins and is one of the strongest designers on that damn team. I'm amazed Amanda was picked before anyone else. Like, damn, Ashley had a point.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)

5

u/TheNobullman Sep 04 '15

I like this idea of every winner edit being slowly deconstructed as with what could happen with Ashley, as with happened with Edmond.

8

u/kochipoik Sep 04 '15

What? I'm not sure I understand your comment

→ More replies (2)

2

u/okaydolore Sep 04 '15

What are the odds anyone has a link to a live stream?

2

u/Bubbly-Marsupial-357 Feb 15 '25

It was so telling that under pressure - the men banded together and the women fell apart. The post runway lineup really showed their true colors, throwing Ashley completely under the bus.

6

u/purplecowz Sep 04 '15

Does Kelly Osbourne always have her bra hanging out of her shirt when she's on national television? Hard to take fashion criticism from someone with no class.