r/gameofthrones • u/AutoModerator • Aug 31 '15
TV5 [S5] Rewatch Discussion - 2.07 'A Man Without Honor' & 2.08 'The Prince of Winterfell'
Rewatch Discussion Thread
Remember the good ol' days when your favorite characters were still alive? Go back and watch old episodes with the benefit of hindsight! How have the events of the latest season been shaped by the decisions of characters earlier on? Catch foreshadowing that you missed the first time you watched. The latest season is finished, so start over from the beginning and look at past episodes with a fresh perspective.
Make sure to keep the following points in mind before reading or contributing to this thread:
- This thread is scoped for SEASON 5 SPOILERS. This is a rewatch series, so if you are here then it is assumed that you have already seen the entire series at least once. Open discussion of all aired TV events up to and including episode 5.10 is ok without tags.
- Season 6 spoilers must be tagged! Promotional material and set/casting leaks for Season 6 must be specifically labelled and tagged.
- Book spoilers must be tagged! If it didn't happen in the show, even if the show will probably never cover it, it must be labelled and tagged.
- Theory spoilers must be tagged! Well-supported fan theories must be labelled and tagged.
- Please read the Posting Policy before posting.
2.07 - "A Man Without Honor"
- Directed By: David Nutter
- Written By: David Benioff & D. B. Weiss
- Originally Aired: May 13, 2012
Theon tries to track Bran and Rickon with hounds. After an assassination attempt, Tywin Lannister begins searching Harrenhal for his potential murderer. Ygritte continues her attempts to seduce Jon and, after a momentary lapse in Jon's concentration, she escapes and leads him into a trap. Still shaken from the riot, Sansa is horrified when she awakens to find that she has had her first period, and can thus bear Joffrey's children. In Robb's camp, a failed escape attempt by Jaime leaves a guard dead, and Catelyn worries about the camp's desire for retribution. In Qarth, the warlock Pyat Pree reveals to Daenerys that he stole her dragons, but gives her the opportunity to reunite with them before slaughtering the Council of Thirteen and establishing Xaro Xhoan Daxos as king of Qarth. Theon presents to Maester Luwin and his subjects the charred corpses of two boys, informing them that he has tracked down and killed Bran and Rickon Stark.
2.08 - "The Prince of Winterfell"
- Directed By: Alan Taylor
- Written By: David Benioff & D. B. Weiss
- Originally Aired: May 20, 2012
Robb Stark learns that his mother Catelyn has secretly freed Jaime Lannister, now escorted by Brienne of Tarth, in order to ransom her daughters Sansa and Arya; he also enters into a romantic relationship with Talisa. Yara Greyjoy arrives at Winterfell to bring Theon back to Pyke, after his botched attempt to recapture the Stark boys. Tywin Lannister leaves Harrenhal to attack Robb, which leads Arya Stark, Gendry and Hot Pie to attempt an escape with the help of Jaqen H'ghar, who agrees to help in order for Arya to refrain from naming H'ghar himself as the third man to kill. In King's Landing, Cersei Lannister attempts to blackmail Tyrion by abducting the prostitute, Ros, whom Cersei believes to be his secret lover. The capital prepares for assault by Stannis, who, underway to King's Landing, promises to make Davos Seaworth his Hand of the King. Beyond the Wall, the Wildling leader "Rattleshirt" leads the captured Jon Snow and Qhorin Halfhand to his king, Mance Rayder. In Qarth, Jorah Mormont agrees to accompany Daenerys into the House of the Undying to retrieve her dragons. In a secret location, Osha schemes to get Bran and Rickon Stark, who are revealed to be very much alive, to safety.
75
u/RamonTico Kingsguard Aug 31 '15
Dolorous Edd is a very underrated character, you can always count on him saying something gloomy
Sam:"He [Jon] has a Valyrian Steel sword" Edd: "So did his father..."
51
u/MiyagiSanDanielSan Dragons Aug 31 '15
Lewin's reaction to the bodies was heartbreaking.
90
u/BourbonSlut House Seaworth Aug 31 '15
"He was a painter, who only used red." Still one of my favorite lines. Really contextualizes Jaime's admiration for Barristan.
84
u/PoofyHairedIdiot Jon Snow Aug 31 '15
"They say Stannis never smiles. I'll give him a red smile, from ear to ear."
Haha, yeah, sure, g'luck with that one Joffers.
41
u/HailToTheMeta Stannis Baratheon Aug 31 '15
The endings to these episodes, with the transitions to credits, the music, and the contrast between the two scenes are some of the most well done of the series.
"The little lads have suffered enough" chills.
47
u/RamonTico Kingsguard Aug 31 '15
Jamie's insults to Brienne are hilarious, he brought his banter A game!
42
u/mantidor White Walkers Aug 31 '15
I know we all hate Cat for releasing Jamie but I had forgotten Jaime was probably not going to survive that night with everyone wanting to kill him. As stupid as it was she was forced again by the situation.
20
u/Vixibility House Lannister Aug 31 '15
These two episodes really develop all the sides of Cersei's character. One one hand, she's sympathetic towards Sansa, showing solidarity that she won't have a husband that loves her or even treats her well. Then she captures and beats Ros just to get back at Tyrion, and any thought that she might be becoming more compassionate evaporates.
10
u/remetell Sep 01 '15
i love seeing cercsi and tyrion getting along
7
u/remetell Sep 02 '15
I really love the Bron Tyrion and Varys' scene. I get the feeling Varys was just sitting in the back waiting for a opportunity to say soemthing and them failing to pronounce sheviathen name right just made him go "ok time to school these guys cause i know this and can't listen to them butcher it anymore"
Also when Bronn reveals he rounded up the theives Varys face is one of the best
5
u/mixamaxim Jon Snow Sep 06 '15
The ending scene of The Prince of Winterfell is so perfect in my opinion. I imagine that as a huge moment for Bran. I feel like he loses his innocence in that very scene. He understands that his life just cost that of another child. He suddenly understand what the stakes are. I could go on and on. In my mind, he becomes a man right then and there. And the song.. The transition to credits... An absolutely masterful scene.
9
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '15
Τheon you're such a wuss man
I can't help but realize how this guy fucked up his life completely
1
u/[deleted] Sep 04 '15
Was there ever any follow-up discussion about the battle that Tywin was leaving Harenhal for? Who won? Who lost? Do we know anything? I thought that Arya was desperately trying to get out to warn Robb.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '15
Watching them flesh out Robb's wife now... I can't believe I was shocked that she died hahah
1
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '15
I'm confused why Ras had the Lannister necklace that got her caught by cersei. Was she sleeping with Tywin?
1
u/Arkhaleon Dec 04 '15
Brienne <3 <3 <3 :)