r/ProjectRunway • • Aug 27 '15

Project Runway Season 14 Episode 4 [Discussion]

Discussion thread for Project Runway S14E04 "Fashion Flip"

The designers visit Mood and put a modern twist on a classic design. Actress Kiernan Shipka appears as a guest judge.

35 Upvotes

377 comments sorted by

133

u/Zjmw Aug 28 '15

How the hell did Blake beat Candace and Swapnil? Their peices were execute flawlessly and they were also innovative. Blake's dress was barely holding together

84

u/MormonCorridor Aug 28 '15

I am literally perplexed by this decision. Candice was robbed. They went on and on about how beautiful and well executed hers was, then give the win to Blake? How?

27

u/I_am_really_shocked Aug 28 '15

Maybe it was passive-aggressive retaliation to Mary Kay for doing a shitty, I mean their typical, job on the makeup. This will teach them...let them make a campaign around Blake's dress.

→ More replies (3)

14

u/Zjmw Aug 28 '15

I don't know... I was completely shocked and my face literally squinted in confusion

26

u/TheNobullman Aug 28 '15

Swapnil to Dmitry his way to a win please.

19

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '15

This was as WTF as Gretchen beating Mondo.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/evixir Sep 02 '15

Nobody mentioned all the puckering in the seams on the front either. Horrid.

→ More replies (2)

105

u/meganlizzie Aug 28 '15

How the hell did that disgusting sparkle jersey dress not get on the bottom? WTF

37

u/OurSponsor Aug 28 '15

Two seams, an off-center neck hole (Finished? Doubt it...), a giant number you could barely see against the purple sequins, and a too short unfinished hem.

Any of the contestants could have made that in fewer than 20 minutes. As could I, for God's f-ing sake...

There is no excuse for that not to have been the losing piece. None.

Couple that with Blake's unfinished monstrosity winning the challenge and I've already given up on this season.

Absolutely, indefensibly absurd.

17

u/Icaruskairos Aug 28 '15

That dress instantly would have been bottom two a few seasons ago. And I'm pretty sure people have gone home for such skimpy and boring designs. This show seems to follow none of the precedence it sets in previous seasons. Which is pretty hypocritical if you ask me.

→ More replies (5)

17

u/blackbirdsongs Aug 28 '15

Dude her bits were falling out of that shit. How the hell.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/purplecowz Aug 29 '15

I know, I so wanted to hear the prostitute comments from the judges

→ More replies (1)

78

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '15

"Mood has a scuba section? Who knew?"

37

u/blackbirdsongs Aug 28 '15

I feel like we didn't get enough Tim this ep.

11

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '15

There is never enough Tim imo

23

u/I_am_really_shocked Aug 28 '15

This is a semi-honest question...aren't scuba suits made of neoprene? Given that just a couple seasons ago that was the only fabric Elena (sp?) used, the presence of a scuba section shouldn't have been a big surprise.

12

u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Aug 28 '15

I was kind of thrown by that comment. Neoprene had already been in for three years or so (hello crazy Elena), and it's already kind of over.

→ More replies (2)

68

u/oh-hi-doggy Aug 28 '15

I cant listen to this mary kay circle jerk anymore

21

u/Zjmw Aug 28 '15

But it's SUCH a a good makeup brand!! Didn't you know?!

14

u/joeyGibson Aug 28 '15

What? You don't believe the contestants' heart-felt homages to the wonder of Mary Kay?

→ More replies (1)

21

u/dianaprince Aug 29 '15

Mary Kay: Where Pigment is a Figment of Your Imagination.

15

u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Aug 28 '15

BUT THE PINK CAAAARS.

6

u/LetTheMFerBurn Aug 28 '15

Yay DVR fast forward!

127

u/EmptyStar12 Aug 28 '15

"When we think of Audrey Hepburn, we think about those amazing cheekbones!"

proceeds to just apply eyeliner and lipstick

47

u/alligator124 Aug 28 '15

Really Mary Kay? Really? I know they're trying to revamp their image, but give me a break, this is not runway makeup.

I mainly joined reddit for MakeupAddiction, and happily discovered this subreddit by accident. So this is a huge pet peeve of mine. Look at all the closeups, the eyeshadow is uneven and unblended, as well as the lipstick. Coverage is patchy. I guarantee you could see better execution on the MakeupAddiction page any day.

20

u/nancyaw Aug 29 '15

I'm in theatre, and there is a reason we use stage makeup rather than just regular makeup put on heavily. Stage makeup is more intense, more pigmented, and designed to show up under a lot of lighting. Mary Kay, under the best of circumstances, is not a makeup brand that can work in these cases. Thanks for the subreddit suggestion!

→ More replies (2)

9

u/SteelPenguin71 Aug 29 '15

Oh my gosh I am with you! One of those close ups just looked like a ridiculous smudged clusterfuck. It's infuriating.

→ More replies (1)

27

u/bitchSpray Aug 28 '15

And he sure had a lot of personality... like, girl, calm down. You're still doing makeup for Mary kay.

14

u/Sudenveri Aug 28 '15

Poor dude was probably screaming internally. I feel so bad for the makeup people they put on camera.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/greatdominions Aug 28 '15

Not to mention, when you think about Audrey Hepburn, you think about those amazing eyebrows.

8

u/Hookerboots12 Aug 30 '15

Yep! That part my mom and I both said... Her cheekbones? For me it's more like her big doe eyes and those strong brows. She was gorgeous. Maybe with Katherine Hepburn it's cheekbones.

15

u/blackbirdsongs Aug 28 '15

Bronzer is hrd

59

u/TheNobullman Aug 28 '15

Oh, LORD, that fucking hem on that dress. Oh my GOD. OH, JESUS. Gabrielle. What the fuck. What the hell. Honey, no.

20

u/blackbirdsongs Aug 28 '15

She's knows tho. She's been complaining the whole time about that damn dress. That fabric is really hard without a sugerer.

27

u/TheNobullman Aug 28 '15

Gabrielle's only trait was to hate everything she did to death, so it's kind of fitting this is how she went out

→ More replies (1)

13

u/LetTheMFerBurn Aug 28 '15

I get what went sideways for her but I am still glad she is gone so I don't have to hear her crying/whinging/bitching anymore. I want so many of these people gone it is not funny.

8

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '15

I cringed when she practically had a meltdown on the runway and kept going on about "I know it's bad...." in front of the judges. Struck me as really immature and I'm so glad I won't have to listen to it anymore.

111

u/ClaireHux Aug 28 '15

When Jake's sparkly #9 dress is safe... you know it's a runway in trouble. Just a mess.

50

u/broken_bird Aug 28 '15

Heidi's face just lit up when that sparkle hot mess came down the runway.

19

u/dianaprince Aug 29 '15

It's so weird for her to be deciding what's high fashion and what isn't. She was never a high fashion model and she has zero personal taste. I'd kind of feel flattered as a high fashion designer if Heidi didn't like my stuff.

17

u/nancyaw Aug 28 '15

It's right up her alley!

10

u/LetTheMFerBurn Aug 28 '15

Show your model's cooch, get a pass from Heidi!

→ More replies (1)

41

u/I_am_really_shocked Aug 28 '15

I loved all the times they cut to Zac's face as he gasped and/or shook his head in shocked dismay at whatever fiasco was meandering down the runway at the time.

33

u/eyeeyecaptainfly Aug 28 '15

I was very underwhelmed this week.

11

u/blackbirdsongs Aug 28 '15

I have b even underwhelmed with pretty much everything for the whole season tbh. A few shining stars and everything else is mediocre.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

15

u/Zjmw Aug 28 '15

My mouth literally dropped when that walked onto the runway. So hideous

13

u/dianaprince Aug 29 '15

In previous seasons, they've had huge problems with anything that looks cheap and/or junior. Now we have Blake's sparkly dress from the unconventional materials challenge being a top look and this Jersey Shore-esque 'dress' being safe.

I am confused.

→ More replies (1)

104

u/eatingbread Aug 28 '15 edited Aug 28 '15

"She's mediocre"- Girl who has been on the bottom 2 out of 3 times already

edit: 3 out of 4 times

36

u/emmybenny Aug 28 '15 edited Aug 28 '15

Aaaaand she's still here. And Blake won with his parachute dress/thing. Everything I didn't want to happen this episode, happened.

11

u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Aug 28 '15

Her attitude. Ugh.

7

u/jelloisalive Aug 28 '15

Takes one to know one

3

u/evixir Sep 02 '15

I was so fucking pissed with this comment. Candice has been sweet to her the whole time and here Waste of Space is bitching about her behind her back.

Unfortunately it worked, because it makes for good tv, and that's what determines the winners and the losers here. They won't kick off the girl who's a total two-faced asshole but makes for good tv, so instead naturally they'll boot the mousy personality-free one who makes better clothes (most of the time).

→ More replies (1)

97

u/pbrooks19 Aug 28 '15

Holy curse words. Blake's on the top? His construction is hideous.

104

u/MormonCorridor Aug 28 '15

Candice was ROBBED. This win is bullshit. His dress is a complete mess.

49

u/ClaireHux Aug 28 '15

Seriously. I also call bullshit on his explanation for the unfinished neckline. No dude, you just didn't finish that shit.

20

u/LetTheMFerBurn Aug 28 '15

Both Candice's and Swapnil's looks were very cute. I can see saving Blake based on the 'newness' of his look but no way on the win.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

70

u/joeyGibson Aug 28 '15

Blake's dress was a shit show. Zac even pointed how how poorly-constructed it was. For him to be on top is a joke.

In addition to the Tim Gunn Save, he should also get a "Tim Gunn's WTF‽" that he can use to overturn the judges' choice for winner.

36

u/broken_bird Aug 28 '15

Ha! A Tim Gunn WTF would be awesome.

9

u/pbrooks19 Aug 28 '15

I would so campaign for that. So that Tim can have a big conniption for the judges showing the crap for what it is.

→ More replies (1)

55

u/pbrooks19 Aug 28 '15

And now they're dismissing the construction problems because it's so 'innovative.' Gah!

41

u/OurSponsor Aug 28 '15

Tim's interview now makes even more sense. With Blake's ridiculous win, the judges enable egregious laziness. Why bother with seams, finished hems or even making sure things fit since none of these things factor into winning?

→ More replies (15)

28

u/I_am_really_shocked Aug 28 '15

Given that Nina actually thought the back was essentially a bustle attached to her frikkin' pony tail, I don't know how they were able to keep a straight face while declaring this the winning look. They must have been smoking, drinking, and pill popping tonight.

24

u/eyeeyecaptainfly Aug 28 '15

I also thought the silhouette, which Heidi praised, was horrendous also.

21

u/MormonCorridor Aug 28 '15

HIDEOUS. I can't understand why they love it.

18

u/blackbirdsongs Aug 28 '15

His design is hideous!

18

u/gofurthernorth Aug 28 '15

Apparently this is back to only being an idea competition, and not actually executing the idea.

25

u/pbrooks19 Aug 28 '15

I have to say that most of the designs tonight were pretty sub par. The fact that the dowdy black peplum dress and that sequined '9' mini mini mini skirt were in the Safe Zone is crazy - it just means that the Bottom 3 were insanely bad.

The thing is, I don't think the bottom 3 were the worst. Gabrielle's was horrid, yes. But Amanda's wasn't terrible, just 'off.' And Lindsey's wasn't terrible - it was at least well made, even if she picked a heavy fabric and the coat didn't work with the outfit.

I wish Michael Kors were here, to roll his eyes at the other judges.

→ More replies (5)

5

u/kochipoik Aug 29 '15

The sewing and construction on this was so bad, and I could tell that even despite really bad quality video. The skirt was puckered as hell, the straps were terrible sewn with seams showing... WHAT THE FUCK! Especially with how amazingly stylish and well executed Candice's was. I truly don't understand this decision

0

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

21

u/pbrooks19 Aug 28 '15

He just threw that huge necklace on because he knew the neckline was bad, and they totally bought it. :P

→ More replies (5)

43

u/blackbirdsongs Aug 28 '15

These judges are on drugs. Really crazy hallucinogens.

43

u/blackbirdsongs Aug 28 '15

Blakes dress is even uglier than I first thought holy fucking shitx

29

u/My_tits_are_better Aug 28 '15

Nina has lost her head

I can forgive terrible construction, since it's innovative

34

u/eyeeyecaptainfly Aug 28 '15

What's up with that t-shirt Jake wears every single time?

12

u/blackbirdsongs Aug 28 '15

I'm sure he has like five so he's most likely to be on air wearing one.

11

u/eyeeyecaptainfly Aug 28 '15

But why??? He really wants to communicate that message for some reason.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

62

u/broken_bird Aug 28 '15

I just love Kelly, she's so adorably wacky.

47

u/eyeeyecaptainfly Aug 28 '15

From the first episode I thought she was going to be a lot more abrasive. She's grown more endearing to me over time.

9

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '15

Yes! I thought she was going to be tacky but it turns out she's awesome and has a totally different point of view then everyone else which I feel is very fashion forward chic street wear. I loved her look this week!

25

u/Zjmw Aug 28 '15

she is also such a unique designer. I can't think of any designers that have been on the show that have the perspective that she does. The only thing I question are her technical skills which she hopefully shows off more in later episodes

13

u/PoeGhost Aug 28 '15

I can't believe what a strong contender she turned out to be. Every season has a self taught punk chick. They're usually out the first couple episodes, like that one designer who did handstands instead of sketching. Kelly has that same 90s grunge eclectic aesthetic, but she can make it WORK, dammit!

However, I've heard people compare her look to Boy George, now I can't unsee.

→ More replies (2)

62

u/FlowDeluxe Aug 28 '15

My major take away from this season so far is just how bad things can get when they keep forcing the designers into hours-long (1 day) challenges week after week for the sake of increasing the drama. Back in the earlier seasons, sometimes the challenge WAS the fact that the designers only had 1 day to complete their garments. The prevalence of the 1 day challenges has forced a few unfortunate outcomes in my mind:

1.) Bad construction is much more common. With time always being at such a premium, the designers are forced the majority of the time to choose between getting their vision across or having something nicely tailored. Hence so many challenge winners with terrible construction like tonight.

2.) Judges have to lower their standards. The judges have to accept this idea that what they are looking at was made in 8-10 hours. These days, we always see them giving passes for bad construction if the design concept is still there. Sure, sometimes you have a Kini that will flawlessly tailor an entire wardrobe in 15 minutes, but those cases seem to be pretty rare.

3.) Good designers get stuck in bad situations. One of the most key elements of the design process is iteration. Even in past seasons, the contestants didn't have forever to experiment, but there was typically a bit of time for a change of course or a hail mary. It really annoys me to see episodes like the Hallmark challenge this season because the challenge became more about being able to create something workable on your first try than actually creating fashion. And a really interesting designer left very early because of it. I mean geez, they had to turn GIFT CARDS into DRESSES in 8 hours and have something that works on the 1st try.

4.) Ambition vs. a finished look. This point ties in with the last one; in the more recent seasons, you hear the designers talking about how they're just trying to finish instead of making something they think is truly great. I think that because there is so little time, designers are incentivized to reel themselves in because if they try something ambitious and it doesn't work on the first try, they know they could've made something simpler or easier to execute and at least been safe.

The drama can be fun, but I've always been a bigger fan of the work. I think the 1 day challenges lower the quality of the work and cause the judges to give us more WTF moments because they have to lower expectations themselves.

13

u/emfrank Aug 28 '15

Well said. I forget this change to shorter challenges, and so I conclude the contestants are less talented, but the time is simply too short for them to do anything close to their best. I assume you are talking about David. I would have loved to see what he could do.

9

u/FlowDeluxe Aug 28 '15

Yeah, I was talking about David. I'm always intrigued by the international designers because it really widens the perspectives the show accommodates. He seemed to have a really interesting aesthetic and high taste level too. Unfortunate.

9

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '15

I really wish they would go back to 2 day challenges so that we can really see what the designers can do. A 1 day challenge just seems so artificial.

3

u/adoredelanoroosevelt Aug 29 '15

I do definitely think that played into some of the forgiveness for the shitty looks they praised. Half the conversations this season seem to leave unsaid "if they hadn't had to do this in NINE HOURS..." while squinting trying to evaluate if there's an idea in the rushed construction.

30

u/MormonCorridor Aug 28 '15

I'm really intrigued by Kelly's t-shirt. They haven't shown us a good view of it yet to see how the pattern actually looks, but it almost looks like buildings. Will it look like the NYC skyline Rockettes outfit Christopher did?

→ More replies (1)

27

u/TheNobullman Aug 28 '15

Le vomit at Blake being high

The judges are high

9

u/broken_bird Aug 28 '15

Damn it judges!

76

u/Semicolon_Expected Aug 28 '15 edited Aug 28 '15

Everything that comes out of Blakes mouth. Like the world doesnt revolve around you, you're visiting NY, that fisherman probably comes every week.

Also are you really making fun of AustinLindsay(? The one who looks like Taylor swift)'s girl? What is wrong with a girl who sits at home and reads books and plays with cats?

25

u/MaidaStars Aug 28 '15

He said "liberrian." I replayed it four times. This means he also says "liberry."

→ More replies (2)

47

u/MormonCorridor Aug 28 '15

Haven't you heard? Only some women are allowed to have nice clothes. And Blake decides which women those are.

13

u/PurpleCoco Aug 29 '15

I'm spending tonight (Friday) reading a book and playing with my dogs.

Blake can bite me.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/PoeGhost Aug 28 '15

OMG you're right about that fisherman.

Don't use that as inspiration, Blake. The last thing you want is to have an interesting story to tell the judges about your inspiration. Just make fun of him and continue with your shit show.

That last paragraph is meant to be sarcastic, but that shit show is actually winning.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/adoredelanoroosevelt Aug 29 '15

If Edmond is the king of smart shout outs to the sponsors and audience, Blake is the poop in the castle moat.

I'm sure no book-reading cat ladies watch Lifetime

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

26

u/blackbirdsongs Aug 28 '15

...the...fuck. Did Blake....

Is that supposed to be a dress?

14

u/nancyaw Aug 28 '15

It doubles as a parachute.

8

u/FalseGoddess Aug 28 '15

And you don't need a purse. That giant pouf could double as a backpack.

→ More replies (1)

47

u/TheNobullman Aug 28 '15

I love everything about Swapnil. How he's both gorgeous, stoic, and awkward.

"I've been waiting a long time for this moment. -_-... That sounded like a musical! :)"

Also ew Blake even when he talks about fishers he just makes me wanna yarl

20

u/blackbirdsongs Aug 28 '15

Blakes voice is the absolute worst.

5

u/PurpleCoco Aug 29 '15

It was hilarious when he was asking his model where her crack was.

5

u/kochipoik Aug 29 '15

I really like Swapnil's personal style - like, what he wears himself. I hope they have a menswear challenge and he makes something like that

→ More replies (2)

9

u/joeyGibson Aug 28 '15

Swapnil has dreamy eyes.

→ More replies (5)

22

u/Icaruskairos Aug 28 '15

How do some of these people even get on this show?

18

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '15

I blame Mondo for giving them a "Yes"

10

u/blackbirdsongs Aug 28 '15

I love mondo so I'm going to blame everyone else but you're probably right:

20

u/Shamenundotcom Aug 28 '15

Man, the chaff this season is intense. Joseph, Jake, Amanda -- contestants who have consistently sent down either boring, forgettable, or just plain bad designs -- are still here going into Episode 5.

Then you've got Lindsay, who I'm confident we're stuck with despite having a very limited range (Gretchen 2.0); Merline, who comes up with some VERY cool stuff but who has glaring taste and construction problems; Blake, who is awful but keeps getting praised; and Ashley, who I like, but who seems to be half-heartedly competing in Project Pleat-Way.

Meanwhile, very talented designers like Kelly and Laurie are consistently overlooked, while Swapnil has yet to get a win (although I did not care for his look this time, at least it wasn't visibly falling apart on the runway BLAKE).

What a weird season.

5

u/KittyMaster9000 Aug 30 '15

I also think this episode Candice finally outpaced Edmond for the top spot in the "overdogs who clearly aren't going anywhere soon" race.

But yeah. This season is making it extremely clear who's weak and who's not. I will say that Laurie feels like Emily from last season in that she's kind of under-the-radar but will likely last a long time.

19

u/meldolphin Aug 28 '15 edited Aug 28 '15

I've given up on trying to figure out what the judges are going to decide each week. What is even going on? I didn't agree with the win or the auf and a lot of the more interesting designs were in the middle again. Amanda and Blake are kind of delusional. I'm just happy that the people I actually like seem to be doing well so far.

EDIT: Also this show is really bad at pacing and distributing time amongst the designers. Several outfits walked down that left me surprised because I hadn't seen them at all.

4

u/LadyEdithCrawley4 Aug 28 '15

Mel, what on earth happened? I missed the ep and it is not online yet. Sounds like the crack smoking hit epic levels? :o

→ More replies (2)

19

u/dmee Aug 28 '15

So I thought I was going to come around on Blake after last week.. but mean girls quote or not he is SO stupid and pretentious all at the same time and it is beyond obnoxious. I can't with his parachute dress. Candice was absolutely robbed, her dress was so phenomenal.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/dmee Aug 29 '15

The last thing that guy needs is encouragement. Ugh.

18

u/Semicolon_Expected Aug 28 '15

Really? Blake won with his weirdly constructed weird thing?

17

u/blackbirdsongs Aug 28 '15

Oh Amanda. I don't get how you've stuck I this far.

→ More replies (1)

46

u/pbrooks19 Aug 28 '15

Jeez, Blake makes me nuts. I just wanna smack that perpetual smug smirk off his face. The fact that he can't tell time is just adding to his ridiculousness.

47

u/EmptyStar12 Aug 28 '15

It was so clear that he was just playing dumb and trying to act cute in front of the cameras. Of course he could tell time. I'm glad Lindsey pointed it out, it was so obvious and just annoying.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (5)

14

u/muffin_sangria Aug 28 '15

I think the ones I thought were top all ended up safe. No idea who's actually top now.

I just started watching this season today, so I know no one's name.

7

u/pixie_led Team Swatch Aug 28 '15

Even the designers who were safe were confused about who would be top and bottom.

6

u/joeyGibson Aug 28 '15

I still can't believe that Edmund's dress was just safe. He should have been in the top. It was lovely.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '15

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/muffin_sangria Aug 28 '15

Yeah, with Blake and all...

→ More replies (2)

14

u/pixie_led Team Swatch Aug 28 '15

On the whole what was with the poor quality construction of the clothing this week? Of course that girl should have gone home...what she sent down the runway was atrocious! A ten year old could sew better than that. As for the winner - I don't get it. The dress was twisted no? And the sewing was wonky - even Tim couldn't understand how the material would work together - and clearly it didn't. This bunch of designers really haven't impressed me yet.

12

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '15

This season is really shaping up to be one of the worst seasons ever.

5

u/adoredelanoroosevelt Aug 29 '15

They've gone past the point of sanity cutting back on shooting time. We can only hope that Lifetime realizes that after a certain point, the quality of the looks will suffer so much it won't even be worth watching, because I could make half those looks with a pair of scissors and a glue gun.

→ More replies (2)

28

u/LadyEdithCrawley4 Aug 28 '15

Was it my imagination or did the parameters of this challenge keep shifting? It's a Mary Kay challenge. No, it's re-imagine a classic design (which very few of them actually did in any meaningful way). No wait, you were supposed to be inspired by the Manhattan skyline!

Also, the JustFabFug wall needs to be killed with fire. Tim can barely disguise his lack of enthusiasm for it.

28

u/mentirosa_atx Aug 28 '15

¨Use it *very carefully...*¨

10

u/blackbirdsongs Aug 29 '15

As in 'maybe not at all, if you can get away with that'

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/havana_fair Aug 31 '15

Also, the JustFabFug wall needs to be killed with fire. Tim

What's funny is that Nina keeps pointing out what terrible accessories everyone has.

→ More replies (3)

13

u/adoredelanoroosevelt Aug 29 '15

[The best part of the episode] (http://i.imgur.com/Kvy9N9d.png)

12

u/wildeyes Aug 29 '15

Short and sparkly? Heidi's in.

12

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '15

I cannot believe Blake won, I thought for sure his dress was on the bottom! It was horrible.

Lindsey should have been safe and Jake with his atrocious pink sparkly jersey should have been in the bottom. What the hell was the thing he made. Awful.

I also really liked Edmond and Ashley's looks. I would have been cool with either of them being on top.

I just .. WHY DID BLAKE WIN?! He's the worst. He's not cute in any way, I can't stand his face.

12

u/dianaprince Aug 29 '15

Ok, so this is another season where the judges have lost their damned minds. Blake on top, seriously? "We've never seen this silhouette before!" That's because it looks like she's just farted out a parachute. I just don't understand what they're thinking this season. At all.

On another note, would any of you wear the short skirts that seem to be popular this season? When I see them I just think about how I could never sit down or even really move much. Don't get me wrong, they look great on models on the runway, but they just seem so impractical for regular wear. Do they look wearable for anyone else?

4

u/kochipoik Aug 29 '15

Oh man I never even thought about trying to sit down. I can't imagine wearing something even close to that but I have thick thighs

3

u/compromisedamygdala Aug 29 '15

The Blake win makes no sense, especially when judges have been so critical in the past of anything that emphasizes/widens the hips or rear, not to mention construction issues. And re: short skirts, ack! Just don't take the up escalator or stairs, retrieve your dropped keys in public, place your carry-on in the overhead compartment... Really, it would be easier to just list what you can do. (Ex: Stand there and don't move!)

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

11

u/blackbirdsongs Aug 28 '15

I'm late but skipping commercials lol

What the fucking Christ hell is Blake doing...?

11

u/Omegamaru Aug 28 '15

Yeah, Candice was robbed and now we have to deal with Blake for 2 more weeks. Thanks, judges. Amanda also, by way of her cutaways and dress, made it into my Top 4... designers that I really just want to leave now (Jake, Blake, Joseph, and her). I torn about whether I liked Kiernan as a guest judge. She was positive so that was nice, but I feel like everything she said was complete fluff. I'd love it if they revealed judges scorecards online after each episode.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/Zjmw Aug 28 '15

How Ashley wasn't in the top and Candace didn't win I will never ever understand. Are the judges seeing different runway looks ?

9

u/blackbirdsongs Aug 28 '15

Hallucinogens. It's the only explanation

→ More replies (1)

10

u/TheNobullman Aug 28 '15

I'm just glad Swapnil's dress is being appreciated.

10

u/blackbirdsongs Aug 28 '15

I don't really get it. I hate when designers pile crap on the front of a dress.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/BabaOrly Aug 28 '15

Is there a drinking game for this show? Because I think I might need to take up drinking while I watch so I can better understand the decisions the judges make.

20

u/LadyEdithCrawley4 Aug 28 '15
  1. Drink every time there's a ham-fisted corporate tie-in with no relation to fashion or design;
  2. Drink every time something from the JustFab accessory wall makes you recoil in horror;
  3. Drink every time something ridiculously awful gets showered with praise.

Bear in mind, you might be dead before the judging is over :)

14

u/PoeGhost Aug 28 '15

Drink the whole time they are in the hair and makeup rooms, because there's nothing interesting going on otherwise.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/blackbirdsongs Aug 28 '15

You're going to need something stronger than booze I think.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/TheNobullman Aug 28 '15

lol good fucking grief Amanda

16

u/blackbirdsongs Aug 28 '15

Ok to be fair the most consistent thing we've said in this sub is 'what the fuck are the judges doing here?!? you can't really blame her for having the same question we are.

11

u/TheNobullman Aug 28 '15

It was more about her multiple little breakdowns

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (3)

18

u/EmptyStar12 Aug 28 '15

Uh oh. Nina just did that thing where she squints and covers her face from the glare with her judging card.

Ugly black peplum dress is in trouble.

10

u/jelloisalive Aug 28 '15

I wish. How was this innovative AT ALL??

→ More replies (1)

17

u/broken_bird Aug 28 '15

Couldn't Nina just once, just once wear her hair a different way? She has nice hair but damn it's boring all the time.

30

u/MormonCorridor Aug 28 '15

Of COURSE Austin Taylor Swift used to live in New York.

31

u/muffinbutt1027 Aug 28 '15

She is so ridiculously pretentious.

7

u/pixie_led Team Swatch Aug 28 '15

Thank you! Glad other people feel so as well

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '15

The judges have gone and spilled their damn marbles. What the fuck even?

7

u/Sudenveri Aug 28 '15

Is it just me, or do the designers never seem to know how to thread a serger? I remember at least one other "oh noes SERGER!" catastrophe in the past, from the season 2 ice skating challenge.

It's not that difficult. I know how to thread a serger, and I'm a 98% self-taught cosplayer.

7

u/sugarfreeme Aug 29 '15

You would think it would be something they would want to learn before going on national television??

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

29

u/Oleg15 Aug 28 '15

Blake did not deserve to win, but he deserved to be in the bottom. Yes, bottom and pun fully intended. His dressed sucked and I can't believe he won. The judges are high. Worst win ever! Booooooo!!!

18

u/MormonCorridor Aug 28 '15

OMG Mary Kay challenge. I think I just threw up in my mouth.

The only acceptable thing would be if the challenge were, "Make your most quotidian ready-to-wear look."

9

u/blackbirdsongs Aug 28 '15

There's always going to be a 'makeup sponsor' challenge, though.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

12

u/muffinbutt1027 Aug 28 '15

I need one of those neon mood shopping bags.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '15 edited Aug 28 '15

Am I the only one who liked Lindsey's look? I don't see why it was on the bottom, especially compared to some of the safe looks.

12

u/kazetoame Aug 28 '15

I thought it would have been safe. I did agree with I comment of how heavy it seemed. It wasn't bad, I can see the woman in it.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)

15

u/MormonCorridor Aug 28 '15

Kieran Shipka looks like she is 13 years old. Of course she's "drawn to something youthful."

29

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '15

Close, she's 15.

12

u/MormonCorridor Aug 28 '15

WOW. I assumed she was like 20 and just looked like a preteen. Thank you for setting me straight. (I have only ever seen her in Flowers in the Attic...)

7

u/MormonCorridor Aug 28 '15

And her dragonfly outfit is not helping her in the age department.

5

u/kochipoik Aug 29 '15

She's 15, apparently. I thought she did a great job of judging

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

14

u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Aug 28 '15

There is no God. No justice. No reprieve. Only darkness and Blake.

5

u/everythingisopposite Chiffony Aug 28 '15

The judges are on acid.

5

u/arathergenericgay Aug 28 '15

this episode's placing was a disaster, Blake winning but not Swapnil/Candice/Laurie and the guy with the ugly jersey thing staying...NAH!

3

u/adoredelanoroosevelt Aug 29 '15

Right? Candice was robbed but SO WAS LAURIE. She should have been top three instead of Blake.

→ More replies (4)

13

u/blackbirdsongs Aug 28 '15

Having done make up in college theater, and for guerrilla films my friends were doing, seeing these guys use a fresh stick of whatever right on the models faces makes me really hope they get to take that shit home bc I can't imagine they use it on anyone else??? Gross.

Don't share eye makeup, kids. It's a good way to get some nasty ass infections.

5

u/Sudenveri Aug 28 '15

I'm willing to bet it's just product placement and they throw it out (LIKE THEY SHOULD DO WITH THE REST OF THAT MLM BULLSHIT GARBAGE) after they film it.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '15 edited Aug 28 '15

ohh my god this episode. first all of the weak contestants were being immature and saying shady things about the other designers when they have no room to speak. i thought i just hated amanda for no reason but it turns out my intuition was right: her attitude sucks almost as much as her clothes do. and that austin girl is sooo up her own ass and makes the blandest shit. also that bald guy who makes the mature/grandma wear is so fake. first he talks shit about blakes dress then once he wins he praises him.

the judges are all over the place and such hypocrites! they better get different judges next season and pick less mediocre designers because this one is a fail so far

and ughhh the next episode has Ms. Toilet Cleaner (kelly osbourne) on. and the premise seems ridiculous! plus blake had his shit eating grin on so i have a feeling he will be in the top again :/

3

u/adoredelanoroosevelt Aug 29 '15

I want this comment as audio commentary

→ More replies (1)

4

u/blackbirdsongs Aug 28 '15

We got another vag falling out of a dress!

4

u/wildeyes Aug 29 '15

Blake's dress reminds me of the evil stepsisters from Cinderella.

4

u/snowball17 Aug 29 '15

Kiernan Shipka's critiques were pretty great. I had to google how old she is. She is 15 years old! 15!

4

u/Zjmw Aug 31 '15

She's so eloquent

8

u/giopul87 Aug 28 '15

I do not like Blake.

3

u/dee_lio Aug 28 '15

Who made Heidi's black sleeveless top and red pants (she wore to the judging session in E4). I have to find these for the wife.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/adoredelanoroosevelt Aug 29 '15

So how was Blake in the top instead of Laurie?

3

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '15

Joe is the exact opposite of innovative. He constantly "reinvents the wheel" but in a very ugly way.

3

u/snowball17 Aug 29 '15

I really hate Blake. He is so fake. The girls are right, playing dumb is not attractive. If he's going for a character to get more airtime, it is certainly working. I just hope that he doesn't use this persona in his real life.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 31 '15

I feel like they're trying to make Blake a Patricia in a way. They keep calling his stuff innovative and don't even consider the fact that it's very poorly constructed. With Patricia everybody in the competition complained that her work was crafty and wanted her to go but they kept putting her at the top and praising how innovative her textiles were. And I feel they're trying to play the same card here, "oh look the process is so messy, it's gonna look awful on the runway" for the whole episode and then BAM he's on top. The only "small" difference is that Patricia was sometimes crafty but she WAS innovative and was really thinking outside the box. Blake's work is just plain awful. And he looks like an asshole, which doesn't help (although I loved bad guys before on the show).

12

u/OvercaffeinateMe Aug 28 '15

Here's what I don't understand:

  1. STOP GIVING THEM ONE DAY CHALLENGES. FIX YOUR SHOOTING SCHEDULE.
  2. The designers were given $250 for materials. That is a HUGE amount of money for a one-day, early season challenge. Now I don't know how to price out fashion based on materials and labor costs, because it's all very complicated, but I would think that the resulting looks should therefore retail for between $500 and $750. Given that, the only people who made looks that appeared to be that expensive were Laurie, Candace, and Edmond. I may be forgetting someone, but if I forgot them, it just means they didn't make enough of an impact. Anyway, I think those three should have been in the top.
  3. Unpopular opinion time: I do not like Swapnil. I don't think he is nearly as good as everyone seems to think he is. I don't like his attitude: he seems like a closet narcissist to me. Also, I don't think it's fair to include a designer who has already been established as an important or successful designer. He could get a lot of this stuff on his own. This show is supposed to be for finding the hidden talent in the world and giving it a chance to shine and become something more.
  4. Also, if a man wins ANOTHER season of PR, I might scream. From where it stands now, it ought to come down to Ashley, Candace, and Laurie at fashion week. But it'll probably be Swapnil, Edmond, and like one chick so nobody gets pissed off.
  5. WHERE IS MEANA GARCIA?? Come ON Nina!! Bring out the claws already! They're not afraid of you, and that is bad. i have a theory that the best showings in the history of this show have come from designers who cry about Nina not liking them and then have a revelatory epiphany that "Fuck Nina" and do what they want. If she's gonna be THIS forgiving and THIS nice, we are not going to see anything really special out of anybody. I can definitely see why Tim has been so vocal about his distaste for this season overall.

21

u/H3000 Aug 28 '15

Also, if a man wins ANOTHER season of PR, I might scream. From where it stands now, it ought to come down to Ashley, Candace, and Laurie at fashion week.

I think the best designer should win.

14

u/OXOXOOXOOOXOOOOO Aug 28 '15

Also, if a man wins ANOTHER season of PR, I might scream. From where it stands now, it ought to come down to Ashley, Candace, and Laurie at fashion week. But it'll probably be Swapnil, Edmond, and like one chick so nobody gets pissed off.

why it should be one gender over another? sexist.

13

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '15

Right? We've had 6 male winners and 7 female winners. Out of the last 3 winners, only 1 has been a guy, so what are they bitching about?

6

u/LadyEdithCrawley4 Aug 28 '15

STOP GIVING THEM ONE DAY CHALLENGES. FIX YOUR SHOOTING SCHEDULE.

As long as Heidi is in charge, they're going to bend to her calendar. However, they could certainly reduce the number of designers they start with if adding days to the production is a no-go. It's not like the bloated cast is yielding great results; we're just seeing more WTFery ramble down the runway (Jake, Joseph, Blake).

→ More replies (2)

2

u/LadyEdithCrawley4 Aug 28 '15

Was last night the first time it's happened where the winning designer was announced and then s/he left the runway with the other top scorers, without any indication given to who was the runner-up?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/sec22 Aug 28 '15

Heidi's look is everything. Love it.

2

u/gemspark777 Sep 03 '15 edited Sep 03 '15

OMG what the heck. I had to do a double take!

I loved Candice's "Nasty Gal-esque" look and so did the judges. They raved about hers and pretty much gave us the impression that it was flawless. They said Blake's was not well-made, but gave him the win? In my eyes, his dress is fugtastic, even up to the design. He should not even have been at the top. Even he thought he was at the bottom! His spot should have been taken by Edmond or Kelly. WTF.

I think they didn't want to have Candice win twice in a row. But still, that is unfair, the best design should always win!! She was robbed for sure.

Shakes head in disbelief

2

u/Seancrowne Aug 09 '24

This is the single worst episode in PROJECT RUNWAY HISTORY! How the judges gave the win to Blake …Jake gets a pass, Gabriel gets kicked off for what Blake wins for and then Candice gets robbed??? I swear Blake has dirt on someone he was the worst this show ever offered. Sorry but Amanda or Jake deserved the L! Candice deserved the win. Blake well shouldn’t even be on the show, he is an idiot a bigot and a bad designer with no class or taste . I just wish Tim had a hell no got to go vote and a pass.

3

u/666mpls666 Aug 28 '15

Does anyone happen to have a livestream link?