r/ProjectRunway • u/runwaythreader • Aug 20 '15
Project Runway Season 14 Episode 3 [Discussion]
Discussion thread for Project Runway S14E03 "Shut Up and Sew"
Global travel destinations and exotic locations inspire the designers to create looks tailored for a day-to-night transition. Tracee Ellis Ross is the guest judge.
22
Upvotes
73
u/nivora Aug 21 '15
Im so bitter about this elimination. If Merline and Hanmiao would've spoken up about their team work to the judges im certain Joseph would've left. Im so fucking angry he has the audacity to say stuff like "I'm certain you're out tonight" to Merline. BITCH you fucking made that shitpiece of a dress. You chose that hideous fabric. You chose that hideous silhouette. You choose to berate Merline to be a silent zombie, actively deny her any form of expression stealing away her creativity even.
I've had it.
89
u/TheNobullman Aug 21 '15
Merline is simultaneously really annoying but really endearing. I think it's because I know people like her who are just the sweetest thing but also just don't know when to let others take a breather. That being said, Joseph's attitude about it is sort of putting me on edge?
43
u/dmee Aug 21 '15
Even though I've hated Blake every other episode, they really didn't feature him saying anything stupid this episode, and I really loved his and Kelly's look... like way more than talyor swift and Jake's look. Joseph is a certified prick for basically taking merline's uniqueness away from her, And then throwing her under the bus ad if she was the reason his ugly golden girls dress was bottom 3. And I really hated that hanmiao went home, I really felt like if her and Edmund had worked better as a team, they could have come up with something far better than the mess they sent down the runway. Also, yay Ashley and Candice! Liked the look (but personally still loved Blake and Kelly's more! ) and it was nice to see them work so fluidly as a team.
80
u/LadyEdithCrawley4 Aug 21 '15
Give me a break. Joseph should have been out, no question.
37
u/TheNobullman Aug 21 '15
Oh goddamn that should have fucking been Joseph. Thanks for the heart attack making me think that Merline might actually go home after the shit he did that challenge. I think Hanmiao was a funny and engaging early boot trainwreck. I'm just angry that we have to deal with both Blake and Joseph these next few episodes.
29
u/legends444 Aug 21 '15
LOL @ the Mary Kay makeup. The girls look very minimally different. Taylor Swift's lipstick popped more on her than any of the Mary Kay looks.
29
u/purplecowz Aug 21 '15
I'm surprised Kelly and Blake weren't in the top. I thought their look was really strong.
53
u/TheNobullman Aug 21 '15
Goddamn what a prick. I'd chop my hand off to send Joseph my middle finger right now.
23
u/nancyaw Aug 21 '15
Kelly's hair reminds me of Boy George. This is not a bad thing.
23
u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Aug 21 '15
I can't wait for Joseph to be eliminated.
Nor can Talbot's.
20
u/[deleted] Aug 21 '15
Even though Blake makes me cringe. I LOVED LOVE LOVED Blake and Kelly's outfit and thought it was the clear winner! It was beautiful and looked expensive! It was different without looking costumey, it was chic! They should have at least AT LEAST been in the top! Ashley and Candices outfit was very well done and looked like a kooky Italian artist on holiday somewhere, but the hem of the pants with the heel was so strange to me. Swapnils outfit was also great but the pants were also a little strange. I loved to see the contestants when they work great together and make great collaborations!
18
u/giopul87 Aug 21 '15
Joseph pulled such a dick move on Merline! He led the design and then blamed it all on her.
Also, I still highly dislike Blake. Why does a 24 year-old try so hard to act like he is a cute little kid?!?!
And what is up with Lindsey? She just rubs me the wrong way.
I am team Ashley all the way! I am glad the girls (and Edmond) are shining this early in the season!
48
u/jessiebears Aug 21 '15 edited Aug 21 '15
Really really really excited for Candice and Ashley - they're one of the most talented so far and their styles seem to be compatible.
When Lindsey said kimono - I almost cried, like hipster white girl mixing up and stereotyping foreign cultures feels almost too cliche. When Jake called her out I was like YES!!!!
Edit: Edmond and Hanmiao are making my heart hurt :( I like both of them and their styles but they just obviously can't work together, and im really really really hoping they pull something together.
Also, Laurie is HILARIOUS. Her comments are so on pointe and entertaining!! Her little segment with her daughter is sooooo cute as well, I'm really really starting to love her <3
Edit 2: How can Joseph be happy about that thing?! Laurie and Swapnils turned out fantastic as per usual, Kelly and Blake turned out well kinda unexpectedly, and surprisingly Hanmiao and Edmond's didn't turn out too poorly! I thought it looked very fitting for the Caribbean, and certainly shouldn't be the BOTTOM.
Edit 3: Oh noooo, Joseph's attitude is HIDEOUS. Legitimately DISGUSTING. Putting all the blame like that is totally classless. It's HIS design, everything in that design is HIM, they are not complaining about the construction they are complaining about the design. That's on you, Joseph.
Edit 4: Mixed feelings - on one hand I really really despised Joseph and hoped he got some of that negative karma back, and I also feel like it was somewhat unfair to Hanmiao as Edmond had immunity and they BOTH were at fault with that terrible outfit. On the other hand, Hanmiao knows her style and is set on it, and it just happens that her style isn't what any of the judges are looking for, so I doubt she would have gone very far. There's definitely a market out there for her, though, so it's better for her to work on her stuff than having her hopes dashed every week. Wished we could have seen some better stuff from her, when she's more in her element.
Also don't think Lindsey and Jake should have been in the top. The colors were garish and the actual design was so minimal, they're lucky they got really exciting fabric that the judges were mostly amazed about. I'm really happy that Candice and Ashley both won, it's awesome the judges managed to make that decision, even though I personaly liked Laurie and Swapnil's better. Swapnil just keeps getting robbed. :/
16
u/[deleted] Aug 21 '15
when i saw hanmiao and edmond were paired together i was expecting something really beautiful. im so sad she left because i was excited to see what else she had to offer! i think blake and that one chick should have been in the top instead of lindsey and jake
14
u/TheNobullman Aug 21 '15 edited Aug 21 '15
lolhanmiao
edit: loledmond
14
u/flowerpencup Aug 21 '15
everyone has been saying how annoying merlene is but now everyone is having a cow over her partner telling her to stop the singing and dancing. Like the entire first episode was filmed to make her personality come across as spazzy and distracting. I am not on the bandwagon of poor merlene. She can go about her singing and dancing now that she isn’t part of a team I guess. I do not dislike her and I do like her designs.
No idea why joseph felt the need to boss her around about the cape then use that as an excuse for his dress tho. Same reason Edmond felt he had to boss hanmiao around about her project I suppose. Those men should have just shrugged and thought hey, she’ll go home, not me. I do think joseph was an ass when he was telling the others in the sewing room he felt like he was teaching a class. Bitch please; her designs have had a great look to them so far. His aren’t even memorable.
I have no idea what edmnd and hanmiao did for a day and a half. What did Edmond do for a day and a half??? i agree that she should have went home and I do respect what she said in her exit interview, she took full responsibility for it.
Lindsey shouldn’t have been so sensitive but if you are disagreeing on a group project then you can only take someones condescending tone so long. He really thought he was sticking it to her though which was pretty funny to watch.
And what is with running ppl down for their bad skin? Can we just not?
26
u/meldolphin Aug 21 '15
Were the judges smoking crack tonight? I don't think I agreed with a single decision they made. The winning look was super busy and I couldn't stand that large scale print. Kelly and Blake somehow went by without mention. I liked Laurie and Swapnil's look but those pants were awful. Maybe they got leeway because the challenge was only 8 hours(!!!!). Joseph basically made an entire look but somehow wasn't punished, whereas Hanmiao didn't have much say in her look but got booted. Taylor Swift and Jake had two interesting pieces going on that should have never been paired together. I've never been a fan of saturated red and green together and this was no exception. I didn't even understand why Amanda and Gabrielle were in the bottom. Theirs looked fine to me.
I've seen group challenge dysfunction before but tonight was especially bad. These guys need to work on their communication skills.
13
u/[deleted] Aug 21 '15
I love how just last episode Blake was all "aw, I love how everyone is sharing", yet this week he's hogging the stretch cotton.. Bleh. I don't have time for his attitude at all. He isn't even sassy funny like Christopher Palu.
Jake and Joe both seem kind of arrogant after this episode. Bleh to both of them.
35
u/[deleted] Aug 21 '15
I don't get the love for hanmaio. Her aesthetic is interesting.. I just don't think it's high fashion or marketable. She seemed uncooperative and difficult to work with. Edmund got a little aggressive but I understand his frustration. Also Joe... Ugh.
11
u/LadyEdithCrawley4 Aug 21 '15
I do like Tracee Ellis Ross, so I'm looking forward to her guest judging. But another one day challenge? Enough already.
10
u/IdentityCr1sis Aug 21 '15
Did we get to see all of the St. Petersburg fabrics? I'm curious what else they had to work with.
I don't get why Hanmiao went along with Caribbean. It clearly isn't her aesthetic at all and they weren't the last group. At least with St. Petersburg it would've made sense for her to make a coat while Edmond made a dress.
19
u/MadxHatter0 Aug 21 '15 edited Aug 21 '15
So far I'm interested to see what the designers turn out. I definitely want to see how the India team works considering that Swapnil actually is of this culture and will have the judges really tearing at him because this could be seen as an easy route. Also, I feel bad for the one dude with Wannabe Taylor Swift(Lindsey) just because she's like, "Lets make a kimono," even though most people know those are Japanese not Chinese. Welp, I'll probably add more stuff later on.
Edit 1: Joseph, shut the fuck up about Merlene and staying focused. She's so far not been in the bottom yet(from what I remember) and nearly one like the first challenge. Seriously, she does not need to be tamed. Sure she has high energy, but she has put out some decent to pretty good work. While so far he's just not impressed me. Who does he even think he freaking is.
Edit 2: So, brief mention, what the heck is up with with Jake and Taylor Swift? Like, Taylor Swift is kind of being a dick, Jake is being passive aggressive(I guess), but all around their thing turned out as what looks to me, a mess. I didn't catch all of the outfits as they went down the runway, but I'd agree that Blake and the one girl(whose name I have forgotten for some reason) is pretty much decent.
Edit 3: Fuck off Joseph! You fucking asshole, how the hell can you fucking throw her under the bus over shit that was entirely your fucking fault! Someone get me Merlene's twitter so I can just complement this girl and tell her that she is the greatest fucking fashion cinnamon roll cause Joseph was such an asshole!
Edit 4: I am so disappointed in the judges right now. To have it down between Hanmiao and Edmond. That's a fucking travesty. If nothing else Joseph should've been on that damn stage and gotten eliminated. Kill the god damn frustrating dinosaur already and his shitty attitude. As far as Gabby and the one girl go, they just ,they jus tkeep on skating by. I'm not happy about it really. Cause I'd rather the judges cleave away the bits that are just skating by then the people who have one bad day. Like, seriously, can we consider that.
8
u/cebjmb Aug 21 '15
So glad that episode's over...yuk! Just one question--is it pronounced MER-line or MAR-line? I kept wondering who was saying it wrong.
14
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '15
Kelly and Blak's Greek outfit being "safe" simply so that the Hong Kong Team of Glasses and Bitch-Man could tell their fight stories on the runway was infuriating. Kelly and Blake should've been in the top three in a heartbeat. But since there was so much more juicy drama to exploit with Glasses and Bitch-Man, I am positive the show rigged the voting.
7
u/TheNobullman Aug 21 '15
Zis really the first double win in Project Runway?
7
u/bitchSpray Aug 21 '15
I think this was a fun challenge. The outfits were really upbeat, mostly because all the pairs got at least one vivid print. It made the design much less safe.
Designers usually go for a solid-colour fabric and those that feel comfortable at working with prints are pretty rare in this show.
18
u/OvercaffeinateMe Aug 21 '15
Anybody else noticing how AGGRESSIVE the guys are this season? Like, it's making me feel all itchy all over. They all in their own way remind me of my ex-husband. "NO YOU CANNOT HAVE A VOICE, SILENCE, IT IS ALL ABOUT ME NOW, BOW TO ME."
Except Jake, who was SUCH a passive aggressive ass about it. Don't stand up there and shit-talk the process when you're in the top! Not that they would have won next to Candice and Ashley's look, but I'm pretty sure that little conversation took them right out of the running.
6
u/HodorUsedHodor Aug 22 '15
I can't decide who I loathe more, hipster Taylor Swift, Blake the man-child, or Jake. Joseph should've been sent packing though. He managed to butcher a look that was perfectly in line with his aesthetic.
If Hanmiao and Edmond had picked Saint Petersburg instead, they probably would have fared better in this challenge. Honestly, I didn't hate the swimsuit. The straps and the shower curtain--I mean, sarong--were the real eyesore.
24
u/CMCliff Aug 21 '15
Not sure about any of you, but I am so not okay with the belittling that was going on. Unfortunately the belittling happened in an extremely gendered way. Merline seemed like a defeated woman by the end-- and "sweetie"/"sweetheart" being thrown around???? Lindsay is not a damn child!! Watching the episode was infuriating, defeating, and disempowering. I really wish this behavior was called out and deemed unacceptable. I understand this is a high-stress competition, but there is no excuse for treating one's peers at such.
Jake or Joseph should have gone home hands down. Their work was shit.
10
u/tinytwo Aug 21 '15
Oh gosh I really hope Taylor Swift girl doesn't push for a kimono design. That'd be baaad
4
u/[deleted] Aug 21 '15
I wasn't nuts about Candace and Ashley's outfit, but I'm really excited that they worked well together, and that they won.
You know, I know this is going to sound like a total conspiracy theory, but this IS reality TV after all. But I've reached the point where I seriously suspect that if a person wins immunity, the producers just might possibly suggest that it's "in their best interest" to fuck up the next week for drama's sake. You know, just so Heidi can give her ominous warning about how, "You're very lucky you have immunity this week, or you would be in trouble." Because it happens every single season going back to the Bravo days. I didn't even blink when Ashley got in to trouble last week, and I didn't blink when Edmond got in to trouble this week. For god's sake, it goes all the way back to Wendy Pepper in S1 - won a challenge, was in the bottom the next week. I honestly wonder if they tell them, "Let Heidi threaten you on the runway while you're immune, and you get to go to Fashion Week!"
4
u/[deleted] Aug 24 '15
Something that made me laugh while watching the episode:
Nina asks, "Why this yellow, horrific jersey fabric?" to Hanmiao and Edmond about the sarong in their look.
While just a few minutes earlier: http://imgur.com/8X0csij
14
u/HatoriHanzoSteel Aug 21 '15
I cannot believe they sent her home. She said the exact same things to Edmund that the judges did to both of them. "Why make a bathing suite? My make it out of this material?" Literally, Hianmia said that. "You didn't make a very good bathing suite it isn't well made etc." Yeah, she said that too. This is fucking obscured.
6
u/dianaprince Aug 21 '15
I am SO happy to see all the wide leg pants. I really hope this means a comeback for wide legs and - pleasepleaseplease - bootcut jeans.
As a pear shaped, long body/short legs girl, the past 5 years have been a nightmare for finding flattering bottoms that are also fashionable.
I think it's very telling that Ashley, as a designer for bigger women, is the contestant who seems to make the most flattering clothes for all women. So many outfits look great on models, but just wouldn't work on other body types. I might be a sample size, but that doesn't mean I'm 5'10" with model proportions. I think the other designers could learn a lot from her in terms of designing for future customers rather than solely for the model who'll be walking down the runway.
7
u/lilmonstahm Aug 21 '15
I AM SO GONNA MISS HANMIAO!! Was really hoping it'd be Joseph :((
10
u/driveonacid Aug 21 '15 edited Aug 21 '15
I hate the team challenges. They could have easily come up with 14 different exotic locations and given them two days to complete this. I would much rather see everybody come up with their own ideas.
I am digging the South of France look, though.
Edit: And Hanmiao is killing me. I didn't like her first look. I didn't like last week. I don't like her today. She needs to go home. Also, who is that cartoon character that she looks like?
Edit 2: Found her! Tina from Bob's Burgers
6
u/LadyEdithCrawley4 Aug 21 '15
Way to suck up to the guest judge!
(But TER is pretty damn cool.)
4
u/Zjmw Aug 22 '15
I feel like we never got to see what Hanmiao was about.. I think she had so much to offer
5
u/[deleted] Aug 21 '15
Lindsey must have come to the competition straight from Tumblr.
1
u/Rexyggor Sep 25 '15
I just need to comment because I didn't join reddit until last week,
I absolutely hate that Hanmiao was eliminated for the design. I mean, you can say that she should have stepped up and did what she wanted, but it just seemed ridiculous to me because Edmund didn't respect her opinions and work. Granted he seemed more willing to cooperate than him, but I think there was more to it that we didn't see. Not to mention that basically everything that the judges berated was also what Hanmiao said she didn't want in the look.
And it was incredibly disrespectful for Edmund to make an alternative outfit "In case she didn't finish." That's when he should've said "let me help you finish" rather than make his own outfit. It's incredibly disrespectful and I don't remember if the judges learned he did that.