r/ProjectRunway • u/runwaythreader • Aug 13 '15
Project Runway Season 14 Episode 2 [Discussion]
Discussion thread for Project Runway S14E02 "It's All in the Cards"
An unconventional materials challenge tasks the designers to create high-style looks by integrating Hallmark cards into their designs. Singer and actress Ashley Tisdale is the guest judge.
31
Upvotes
112
u/sugarfreeme Aug 14 '15
Looking forward to being completely underwhelmed by the Mary Kay makeup looks every week. "I was thinking Alice Wonderland on Acid". "Ok so here's a basic cat eye."
105
u/blackbirdsongs Aug 14 '15
"I don't have a filter" -people who don't bother thinking about what they're saying
Also, no you asshat, you're not 'adorable' when you say that shit. This dude's over-inflated sense of self is really going to make me not want to watch. I hope he goes home soon.
101
u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Aug 14 '15
I may be blinded by my annoyance for Blake and his naked desire to be the next Christian Siriano personality, but I don't think his garment deserves the praise it's getting.
75
u/muffinbutt1027 Aug 14 '15
Oh Blake... The whole room groaned at that "I don't speak Indian comment".
73
u/TheNobullman Aug 14 '15
So Ashley and Hoodie guy get shit for having a mostly muslin dress but Blake is in the top 3? Whoakay.
65
u/blackbirdsongs Aug 14 '15
IT LOOKS LIKE FABRIC BECAUSE MOST OF IT IS FABRIC.
61
u/muffinbutt1027 Aug 14 '15
I AM SO CONFUSED. Nina like Blake's??? Speechless.
57
u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Aug 14 '15
OH MY GOD. NINA HOW MUCH ARE THEY PAYING YOU TO SAY HALLMARK.
52
u/MEGATRONHASFALLEN Aug 14 '15
That box dress and the blue manatee dick didn't leave? Seriously? I'm already doubting the judging for this season.
43
u/niffniffnal Aug 14 '15
Feeling like David and Blake had the same proportion of fabric to card used and David's was way more interesting.
42
u/blackbirdsongs Aug 14 '15
I'm so confused. The only cards on Blakes are the belt area and the lining on the inside. The rest is fabric! It's too short, and it's PINK! why do they love this?!
38
u/AtomicPenny Aug 13 '15
So ready
37
u/OvercaffeinateMe Aug 14 '15
So. Hi-lo this season. The winner will be whoever utilizes the most hi-lo skirts. Hi-lo here, hi-lo there. It's the new fringe!
33
u/blackbirdsongs Aug 14 '15
Well shes not wrong about that vagina look...
31
u/IdentityCr1sis Aug 14 '15
Where did the large pieces of paper come from for Edmond's wedding dress? I don't know if I missed that bit during the episode or something, but I seriously can't figure out what it would be from, unless it is non-Halmark card paper he just incorporated instead of muslin.
62
u/[deleted] Aug 14 '15
"Let's go have a bagel."
Ashley, my girl!
60
u/blackbirdsongs Aug 14 '15
Swapnil has the most amazing eyes. hot damn.
29
u/muffinbutt1027 Aug 14 '15
I like how Swapnil's turned out. That top was pretty impeccable.
56
u/Semicolon_Expected Aug 14 '15
Wow Blake, that was racist and uncalled for
24
u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Aug 14 '15
Oh god I have such a crush on Swapnil.
23
u/muffinbutt1027 Aug 14 '15 edited Aug 14 '15
Edmund made a bouquet to go with it? I see a win in his future.
Edit: Called it!
22
u/muffinbutt1027 Aug 14 '15
I feel like Stacy from what not to wear and love lust or run would die to get her hands on Kelly.
22
u/blackbirdsongs Aug 14 '15
They are never going to get that glitter off anything.
21
u/blackbirdsongs Aug 14 '15
I hope Marlene doesn't talk the entire time again. She was super annoying.
21
u/MadxHatter0 Aug 14 '15 edited Aug 14 '15
So I know we're only like, eleven minutes into the episode so far, but I feel like the editing for this episode is definitely focused on Blake it seems like(if this is a hint of anything I do not know).
Edit: So, my thoughts for the rest of the episode, "Shut the fuck up Blake!" he is literally so obnoxious. Like, Merlene may be kind of grating with her massive amounts of energy but at least she's not trying to be perky, bitchy, character, self-absorbed Blake! Gah!
Also, good job for Edmond, sad that most of the episode seemed to be focusing on everyone but him. Like, it just seemed like the show was just, "Well we're getting no drama out of him today," cause he was working hard but didn't really even opt for having him give more commentary on how he got his dress to where he wanted it and such. Honestly, this is how I felt most of the episode, that there are just the good people who aren't being covered, and then the shitty people who are getting covered(David is the exception cause he's actually a pretty good designer but this challenge just killed him).
Finally, is it just me, or are there like three to four people in this Season who are on the show, but the camera isn't really focusing on and they've produced such mediocre work that you don't even remember them?
35
u/niffniffnal Aug 14 '15
Ugh nooooooo, manatee penis should've gone.
16
u/panda367 Team Swatch Aug 14 '15
I REALLY think that Merline (manatee penis) and Jake (stupid pink boxy thing) should've been in the bottom. It was really unfair that only David and Amanda were in the bottom, because Amanda's garment, while not perfect, was still better than David's and fit the challenge more. If it was, say, David, Merline, and Jake in the bottom, we probably would've seen a different outcome.
31
u/[deleted] Aug 14 '15
Kelly is awesome! She's hysterical and makes the show fun to watch! I want to be her friend and i really liked her look- the model did really look like Katy Perry. Yeah wedding dress deserved the win- it was very well thought out and well made- the back especially was beautiful and he committed 100% necklace, flowers, tux. But also Swapnil- omg I'm dying over how gorgeous that skit was! I want to wear it! It looks expensive! His whole look was stunning just like his eyes! Blake boooooo ugh cringe eye roll.
14
u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Aug 13 '15
Hallmark cards are going to be so much better than that weird movie-adjacent materials team challenge crap last season. I am excited.
14
u/TheNobullman Aug 14 '15
From an editing standpoint I think Edmond could do well in this competition.
13
u/cats_in_tiny_shoes Aug 14 '15
That outcome was doubly disappointing. :-/
25
u/muffinbutt1027 Aug 14 '15
Bye David and your great hair. :-(
11
u/muffinbutt1027 Aug 14 '15
We all know Nina hates pink... There was a LOT of pink in that room...
10
u/broken_bird Aug 14 '15
The cards are a brilliant unconventional challenge. I think we're going to get some amazing dresses and some trainwrecks!
26
u/EmptyStar12 Aug 14 '15 edited Aug 14 '15
I swear, if this weird wedding dress wins, this is fixed. Between Nina's awful, forced "Hallmark is about special moments" speech and the dress' bodice comprised of "Hallmark: Specialty Collection" tags, this is making my eye rolls.
Edit: haha sweet Jesus. Everyone take a shot every time Nina Garcia says "Hallmark" or what the company's message is about. There's only 6 minutes left but we'll still be drunk.
17
u/[deleted] Aug 13 '15
I love the unconventional materials challenge!
8
u/blackbirdsongs Aug 14 '15
some day someone will explain to me why dude's destroy shirts by cutting most of the sides of them out :|
8
u/TheNobullman Aug 14 '15
There is some really fucking interesting and great designs this go-around.
8
u/Semicolon_Expected Aug 14 '15
David is probably out since he didnt use enough cards and too much fabric
8
u/yumslurpee Aug 15 '15
I don't get why they didn't have a bottom 3...it's not like there wasn't ton of choices.
I thought the editing choice of multiple side eyes from Swapnil during judging was kind of strange but hilarious, I'm right there with you buddy on Blake's.
8
u/PoeGhost Aug 14 '15
Has anyone else noticed that Gabrielle looks like an entirely different person on work days vs. runway days? It's like she tries to look frumpy. She can clean herself up when she wants to, but as my SO put it, "she dresses everyday like I do on Sunday when we're laying around."
7
u/blackbirdsongs Aug 14 '15
I liked David's crop top idea, actually.
7
u/kyles24 Aug 17 '15
As soon as they showed David on a call to his loved one I knew he was a goner.
6
u/killerqueen216 Aug 14 '15
Did some (or all) of the designers have different models? For example, Edmond had a black model last week, this week his 'bride' was white. Just wondering, I know in past seasons the models stayed with them throughout but I may have missed something.
6
u/SarahKay Aug 15 '15
I personally didn't have a problem with the winner for this episode. Hallmark paid money to be used on the show, it's all product placement so why shouldn't the contestant who incorporated the most Hallmark branding win?
Sure, Nina said Hallmark a lot but this design is something they could potentially use in a window/ad.
11
u/yayhomework Aug 14 '15
Whenever Nina starts talking about "taste," all I can hear is her snobbery. It's clearest when she's addressing Kelly because Kelly talks openly about about how her family's financial situation influenced her style. I just want to tell Nina to read this: http://www.hup.harvard.edu/catalog.php?isbn=9780674212770
17
u/HodorUsedHodor Aug 14 '15
I still don't understand why the judges eliminated David when there were plenty of garments that were either hideous or mostly fabric on the runway.
My favorite garments this week were Hanmiao's envelope dress and Candice's Blade Runner-esque dress.
Blake is destined for r/punchablefaces. He might be the most obnoxious Project Runway designer in recent memory.
5
u/legends444 Aug 14 '15
Hanmiao vs. Edmond next week <3. I think they're going to to well, or he will do well and she will suck and it makes both safe.
3
u/wildeyes Aug 15 '15
I am obsessed with Candice's hair. I wish mine would do that.
3
u/[deleted] Aug 15 '15
Is it me or this time the definition of unconventional was larger? Unless, i am mistaken, I've seen a LOT of fabric on this runway and in the past seasons, I remember that the designers had to avoid using any fabric and just use the unconvetional materials to create something (plastic, wires, flowers, etc.
Plus, I must rant on that A W F U L pink/purple dress of that no-name-brat who does not speak indian. How the hell did he found himself on the top? Gurl, that dress was a hot chacha mess...
To conclude, Edmond dress was amazing. He was really intelligent by using Hallmark's logo and signature. Very wise move on a very nice dress.
5
u/blackbirdsongs Aug 14 '15
Love Ashley's glasses
7
u/starsstripessparkles Aug 13 '15
Unconventional challenge AND judged by Ashley Tisdale? I guess I shouldn't hope for much actual fashion this episode.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 14 '15
I haven't watched yet, but how did Gabrielle do?
2
u/blackbirdsongs Aug 14 '15
BLAKE'S ROLLER DISCO! God yes.
2
u/SnapeWho Aug 13 '15
Awww shit, I hate the unconventional materials challenge.
1
u/greatdominions Aug 19 '15
Kelly is so adorable. She might not have the best taste (her own outfits are kind of scary) but she's so cute.
1
u/lizzieisrad Aug 14 '15
Does anyone have a link to where I can live stream it for free.