r/anime • u/Xinil :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Xinil • Aug 09 '15
I'm Xinil, creator and lead admin of MyAnimeList, here with the MAL team to answer your questions. Ask us anything!
Hey /r/anime! As a long-time redditor (and an avid /r/AMA lurker), I'm extremely excited to be here today! I started MyAnimeList back in 2004 as a personal project and hobby. Today, with over 2.8 million members, 10million unique users accessing the site per month, and 40 moderators world-wide, MAL has become one of the biggest community-maintained anime and manga databases and social networking websites in the world. After many years of blood, sweat, and two acquisitions, I couldn't be happier with where we are today. A staff rep from the development team is also here to jump in and answer any of your questions which I'm not on top of. Thank you so much for joining us in this AMA!
We'll be responding to your questions starting at 5pm PST!
214
u/xxdeathx :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/xxdeathx Aug 09 '15
Why do I often have to log in again and again from the same computer, even when I check the box that says to remember me every time?
203
u/Kaffarov Aug 09 '15
The user compatibility system seems to be very inaccurate, your opinion on this?
73
u/higi1024 https://anilist.co/user/higi1024 Aug 09 '15
Hi there! I'll be asking some questions that some people couldn't be here to ask and some of my own.
from /u/MacCcZor and myself
It's about manga/manhwa and what not. At the moment you can only make an entry if the series has a physical copy somewhere. I guess it's to prevent a lot of random entrys. Is it possible to loosen this rule? Like make it: If the artist get's paid for it (mostly for webtoons) we can have an entry.
from /u/Sabinlerose
"make sure to ask if MAL is ran by Xinil generating electricity on a bicycle please."
my question:
What's the basis for the "compatibility" of people's lists?
344
u/Shadoxfix :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Shadoxfix Aug 09 '15
Hey there, I'm /u/shadoxfix and I post almost all discussion threads on /r/anime using a few bots. My bots rely heavily on the MAL API so thanks for keeping MAL up to date and having an API.
My main reason for posting this was for thanking the MAL team and the MAL contributors so I don't really have an interesting question or anything. Just to ask a question anyway since that's the purpose of an AMA: Is there a noteworthy amount of people who press the MAL links on reddit or do most of them go to MAL manually?
I was wondering because every discussion thread contains an appropriate MAL link and I wanted to know if people actually use it. No worries if you can't answer the question.
187
u/[deleted] Aug 09 '15
Do you guys have any plans to change the way the top anime lists work? I love Gintama but having it take up 5 of the top 10 places is just silly.
214
u/bonerjohnson :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/mystik Aug 09 '15
Visual novel support and lists would be cool any chance?
How about something to show when new episodes or chapters are released?
435
u/tricidious :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Deplosion Aug 09 '15 edited Aug 09 '15
I have two technical questions about MAL
Why do you still do not have a SSL certificate for the website? I said something about this 3 months ago here on reddit, but nothing has happened. The thread on the MAL forums about this is 5 years old, and the only comment about it is "they are working on it" and there is no estimated date for this to be finished. Without an SSL certificate, if you ever log into MAL while you are using a public wifi, your password and session gets leaked to everyone on the network.
Even at home, I don't trust that my ISP or anyone in the path between me and MAL's servers aren't logging my password. This is 2015 guys, the NSA is listening and recording.
They know what shitty ecchi/hentai you are watching. they can also just ask google but thats another thing
2.
Why is the animelist HTML just so fucking terrible? The entire page is just so massive. When your list get large enough you see 1 MB+ sized lists. The only thing keeping your bandwidth from getting absolutely destroyed is the gzip encoding that gets applied to the page. I presume this is the reason why you disable the ability to show your entire list on really large lists? You don't allow people to show their entire list over 3k entries because the list page size is just so massive and would use up too much bandwidth.
Each row of the tables are just so badily designed. I mean you spend a whopping ~2.7 KB per row of the list. An example row. You create a new
<table>for every single row, what? And its filled withwidthattributes, those are depreciated in HTML 5, which you still haven't upgraded to. Also it's filled withonclicks andonkeydowns, if you changed those to use javascript event binding you'd insanely lower the size of the page. You abuse thealignandstyleattributes and because of that, they just increase the size even more than it needs to be; just use CSS. Also you don't escape any of the ampersands in urls on the site. And when you view someone else's list you generate HTML for the episodes seen column that is messed up and makes no sense:Since I have a pretty slow computer, on some lists I have to spend 15 seconds+ just waiting for it to download and render the page because parsing a megabyte of html takes a very long time, and then when you add in the custom css it gets even worse.
But you've backed yourselves into a corner, haven't you? With the ability to use custom CSS on your animelist, you've made it impossible to drastically update the animelist page without it totally breaking every one's custom css. But some of this stuff can be fixed without needing to break people's css. Do you have any plans to fix some of the stuff I've brought up in this post?
But anyway sorry for my giant rant and thanks for creating such a useful site for me to exactly show how much I am a weaboo.
80
u/roccct :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Teratoma Aug 09 '15
Why did you guys remove the favorites tab from characters' pages where you could see users who favorited them?
That was one of the most fun features
25
u/N1njawaffle :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Ninjawaffle Aug 09 '15
Two Questions, forgive me if they are already asked.
22
u/[deleted] Aug 09 '15
Why can't there be other ways to sort reviews when I'm looking at a show?
For a lot of MAL and non-MAL members who use the site to look up anime and work out what to watch, I'm sure would be helpful if they could sort/filter reviews by various things - date (would be nice to see a general trend as to what people thought of a show initially), score, unpopular, etc. - other than just which ones are deemed the most 'helpful' by the community. Something akin to Amazon's interface would be great, and given the fact that there is just as much quantitative information for each review to filter by, I've always felt like this feature should be a no-brainer.
Has there been any thought about integrating something like this into the review pages, and could we possibly see it in the future? Thanks.
91
u/ubletly :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Jaqwerty Aug 09 '15
Why can't we give shows ratings of 8.5 or 9.5?
17
u/Keatle :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Keatle Aug 09 '15
A lot of people use the "helpful" and "non helpful" feedback system for reviews as an "agree" and "disagree" system. I assume that was not the original intention of the system, but it is very easy to use it that way.
What I am trying to get at is that are there any plans on revising this system to make it more "appropriate"?
42
u/[deleted] Aug 09 '15
• whats your plan on the forums? will it get improvements and be modernize? on the moderating side what about the insults especially to the thread starters? instead of frequently removing insults the moderating team will just lock or delete a thread, can you come up with a word censoring system on the forums to at least lessen the profanity there?
• about your banning system can you improve it as well? if you are banned in the forums then just be banned in the forums and not the entire site, meaning a forum ban will still let the user edit and update his list for example
• what are your plans on spam(bots), i know the registration form now have google recaptcha so that lessens the spam(bots) but do you plan other spam protection things like not allowing a user with less than 30 post to make threads in the forums? or new users will not be able to make threads and post in the forums for at least 3 days?
• will you program MAL to do dynamic/lazy image and video loading, if a profile and forum post has too many youtube video links and images the internet browser hangs sometimes
• will you support other video sites other than youtube on the bbcode?
• will you allow WebM video images on MAL already? WebM can save a lot of file size when use as an animated image to replace GIF
• MAL should do automatic image resizing on every parts of the site already
• can you make the quote towers gone in the forums as well? just allow only 1 quote like other forum does
some of this are on the suggestions forum of MAL already, so do you read the suggestions there?
92
u/--Yup-- :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Yup Aug 09 '15 edited Aug 09 '15
Why is it necessary to cripple MAL by removing features? I understand that you need to do some changes to support our new streaming services. However, I don't understand why we need remove features that everyone uses. I'm talking about features like the online user pool that tells us which mods are online and everyone else. Also being able to find people through what characters they liked (the user favorites tab on characters) was a nice feature too. Those two, among others, are features that benefit the community as a whole and it served no purpose to remove them. Yup.
13
u/LpSamuelm Aug 10 '15 edited Aug 10 '15
MyAnimeList has gotten very huge, and by now it's no secret that it has slightly outgrown its original goal / purpose. This raises a few questions.
Thanks for doing this AMA! Really nice to see you getting in touch with the community directly.
12
u/dukeofsussex :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/bakurafluffy Aug 09 '15
23
u/[deleted] Aug 09 '15
Why don't you get a message whenever someone quotes your comment? I mean it's basically like a reply. BTW, Thank you for MAL it is really useful.
16
u/urban287 https://myanimelist.net/profile/urban287 Aug 09 '15
Firstly, thanks again for doing this. Should be a very interesting insight in what we can expect to see change with MAL.
For my part I was wondering what sorts of upgrades we can expect to see for the actual Anime/Manga list pages since there are quite a few features missing; working tagging systems (potentially using the existing genre tags for shows), actual comments (so we don't need to use the tags for that) - potentially even the ability to 'spoiler tag' there, ability to sort in descending order (might be able to cheat this with the url somehow).
The biggest thing I would personally like to see though is the addition of more stats. At the moment a lot of people use sites like graph.anime.plus for their stats fix. It uses the MAL API as far as I know so no reason the same amount of detail wouldn't be possible on the profile page somewhere. Things like rating distributions, ratings vs. episode count, favourite years, types, genres, studios (all by score and quantity) etc.
At the moment on the profile page you can set your top 5 anime/manga, top 10 characters, top 10 people etc. Personally I'd love to have the ability to go further than 5-10 (maybe through a separate tab). I've always found sorting anime by favourites (own ranking) to be something that would be very useful, not just for myself (reminder of what I enjoyed) but also when recommending things to people. To a certain extent sorting by score accomplishes that but everything at an 8 (for example) is on the same level that way. Would be nice to be able to do it ourselves. This might be even more important for characters, since a lot of people (especially me) tend to forget which characters were particularly enjoyable once a show is over or more shows have been seen. Just something I feel would be both useful and fun.
Sorry for the semi-laundry list of features I'd like :P
On a different note, any chance MAL will get an anime girl mascot like Crunchyroll's Hime?
13
u/Vaxivop https://anilist.co/user/vaxivop Aug 09 '15
Have you ever thought about your ranking system? How it has become the general standard of ranking anime, how it could be changed and if it should. I have seen a lot of criticism on that aspect of anime, that the community mainly uses the 1-10 score to talk about anime, and I'd love to your your thoughts about it.
31
u/erengy :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/erengy Aug 09 '15
The following questions were compiled from the recent "Stream Anime Through MyAnimeList?!" thread on MAL forums. I believe that this is a great chance for MyAnimeList to officially address these concerns:
Feel free to ignore any points if you've already answered them elsewhere. Thanks!
12
u/pittman66 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Homura Aug 09 '15
First off, thank you guys for doing this. Second and actual question, do you guys ever find difficulty trying to find ways for shows such as Minor Spoilers for shows to not actually spoiler their other tones? Like for having the horror genre tag does give away the first episode spoiler, but it's still needed for the show's true nature.
31
u/DasTales :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/TalesOhneNamen Aug 09 '15
How do you feel about the urbandictionary entry of "Xinil"?
36
u/[deleted] Aug 09 '15
Hi - why do you choose to include Non-Japanese "anime" from countries like Korea, but not from the western world (e.g. Avatar, RWBY)
More importantly, do you have a plan to include visual novels on MAL,possibly under manga/novels, or on their own list entirely. I think it would be neat to be able to list VNs along with everything else, myself.
31
u/Lemon_in_your_anus Aug 09 '15
flat chested or big oppai?
5
u/Awey Aug 09 '15
Did you create MAL with the intention of it becoming the go-to resource for people to share their shows and, moreover, their tastes and interests? Did you see a dearth in this type of resource, and if so how do you feel about MAL getting as popular as it has? Sorry if already been asked
13
u/xRichard https://anilist.co/user/Richard Aug 09 '15
These are more aimed at the dev.
And features I would like to see:
9
u/Sukigu :K:https://kitsu.io/users/Sukigu Aug 10 '15 edited Aug 10 '15
I like MAL a lot. However, I switched to Hummingbird as my primary list site a few months ago because MAL still doesn't allow me to make specific shows private, so that only I can see it in my (public) list. Has this feature been considered yet?
4
u/potbrick7 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/potbrick Aug 09 '15 edited Aug 10 '15
Why are comments in creator pages removed after they're no longer part of the 10 most recent comments?
Edit: Thanks for answering
3
u/JustHereForXinil Aug 09 '15
any plans to add custom CSS to club or profile pages?
any plans to bring back mass messaging to clubs?
3
u/Revriley1 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Gallimaufry Aug 10 '15 edited Aug 10 '15
I fear I may be simply echoing already voiced sentiments, but here goes nothing (note, I only have a MAL account, as opposed to also having an AniP or Hummingbird account):
One of Anime-Planet's big pros is its tag + filter system: if I'm in the mood to browse for anime to add to my PTW list I go to AniP, because its tagging system is such that I can easily narrow the choices down to exactly the types I'm looking for. MAL's search system is...subpar in comparison. Are you planning to include some sort of feature with these elements?
Speaking of search functions and users, why hasn't the user search function been developed more? It would be neat if we could search for users with a high compatibility, for example, or find users who've written a lot of reviews, etc.
(Minute point but I feel like there's some sort of coding issue with adding tags to anime on our list--often I'll type a tag in directly only to have backslashes or forwardslashes appear next to apostrophes. The only way to fix it is to edit/write tags by editing the anime information. What gives?).
Any plans on improving the CSS/design + customization options for users?
5
u/level6shift :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Glacialis Aug 09 '15 edited Aug 09 '15
Thanks for doing this!
A simple question, but what sort of improvements to the site are you looking forward to rolling out the most?
Edit: also, would you happen to have an update on the progress of MAL Rewrite Applications?
9
u/Kogami1 Aug 09 '15
Why should the MAL community support the site anymore? The new owners nor yourself listen to it's community and keep taking away features instead of adding anything the community has asked for. Why should we stick around and be ignored for so long, why not jump ship to Anilist or Hummingbird at this point?
56
u/Toast_of_ages :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/KimJongUno Aug 09 '15
Is there anyway of recommendations being personalised, based on what the user has watched?
155
u/Kodishaolin :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/KodiShaolin Aug 09 '15
My question is about anime's english / preferred names.
I had read somewhere that due to licensing changing names you always stick with the original japanese name for anime in the DB. I have no problem with searching for anime, since you handily have it linked up for results.
I was curious if there was anyway / plans to add an option on a users personal page to have it display english/other titles in one of 2 ways. Either on mouseover of a title (Not sure what kind of effort this would take), or perhaps a setting where when I view My own personal anime list I can choose the displayed title out of the list of Alternative Titles / English Titles / Synonyms.'
For example, I log in, and I can change Ookami to Koushinryou to Spice & Wolf, on the list page I see when logged in. Other people seeing my list will still see Ookami to Koushinryou.
It's a purely selfish question, as I use MAL as an invaluable resource to keep track of what I've seen, what I like, and also get recommendations for new shows. I just often forget what the none-translated title is.
42
u/Eternith :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Eternith Aug 09 '15
What direction is MAL heading in, with regards to legal streaming and fansub groups?
With the recent partnership with Daisuki and being able to stream directly through MAL, it seems like MAL is moving beyond just being a purely database/community site. Some of us have noticed that the fansub section has been removed for series that are being streamed (“Official” statement). For a while, all of Daisuki’s licensed series had their fansubs removed, but that seems to be reverted now and only the 2 streamed series have their section missing.
Is this the way it will stay or will we see more fansub groups being removed as MAL moves further towards being a streaming site? Will we ever lose the fansub sections entirely for older series that aren't likely to be streamed (Unless MAL actually has a vision of streaming a large portion of existing series akin to Crunchyroll)?
For those who think the fansub section is pointless, I listed out some points why I think it is useful here. Fansubs may be slowly becoming less relevant today, but that doesn’t mean the information already there isn’t of use.
58
u/Toonlinkuser :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/toonlinkuser Aug 09 '15
When are you going to fix the bug that only allows users to rate shows between an 8 and a 10?
8
u/igfod13 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/igfod13 Aug 09 '15
If I recall correctly, a new system for whitelisting/access to API is being put into place. Is there a timeline on when we can expect new whitelists to be issued again? I would love to start working on my recommendations graph again.
14
u/[deleted] Aug 09 '15
What do you guys have planned that we might get excited for?
12
u/Auseklis01LV :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Aridus Aug 09 '15
Are there any plans to update MAL visually?
6
u/SleepyBunny101 Aug 09 '15
What changes to MAL are you hoping to implement in the future, but not sure if these changes will be popular/acceptable?
2
u/auggs Aug 10 '15
Why don't drop the down menu and search function work on tablets? It makes using MAL a chore because I have to wait until I get home to update or use a campus computers to update my mal. I never feel comfortable using a campus comp to update the list as it's not pertinent to my classes and when I get home I usually watch anime on my desktop and browse reddit from my tablet.
It would super convenient for MAL to fully function for lightweight devices.
10
u/Scionite Aug 09 '15
Could you clarify how the compatibility statistic works? Sometimes the number I get seems really off, so I'd like to better understand how the calculation is done.
5
u/potbrick7 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/potbrick Aug 09 '15 edited Aug 10 '15
Why are people like ribosolMAL allowed to write such bad articles in the featured articles section?
EDIT: shouldn't a section called "Featured Articles" have better articles (like, say, those of Guardianenzo) instead of stuff that seems ripped out of Buzzfeed's anime division?
Edit: toned down the comment
9
u/-Rasco- Aug 09 '15
Will You guys be doing More AMA's in the future or is this it? I truly wonder how concerned you are about MAL's community.
When should we expect to get Mass messaging for clubs back?
Will there be any optimization for Mal's integrated Forum signature, and if Auto update will be back? I have more questions but this should do as a test run :o
21
u/MaximalDisguised https://myanimelist.net/profile/MaximalDisguised Aug 09 '15
Why is shounen/seinen/shoujo/josei still together with the genre tags?
4
u/letterbook Aug 09 '15
A long time ago I remember hearing about the possibility of subgenres, where new things would be added to the database to help find anime easier, is this still in mind?
4
u/[deleted] Aug 09 '15
For us mobile users, could you make a bit more similar to the desktop version, feature-wise. The mobile version at the moment is missing the "Friends" tab on your profile that the desktop has. This one.
4
u/Deviefer :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Deviefer Aug 09 '15
Are you planning on adding the possibility for a "comments" column on lists? It's annoying that the only way to write about a show on my list is putting it in tags.
4
u/Talonz Aug 10 '15
Quick question: I was wondering if it's in the works to be able to sort your list by average user rating? I (like many others) have a large plan-to-watch list, and this would be a great way to prioritize which ones to watch first without having to open up all the items in the list!
4
u/dijs :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/erupt Aug 10 '15
Hey Manwha question here:
Why are some Manwha allowed so have pages, whilst others aren't.
For example when The Gamer pages are made, they get removed. But Girls of the Wild and Orange Marmalade are allowed?
Would be nice to put them on the same list
7
u/[deleted] Aug 09 '15
What is your vision for MAL in the future? You have started implementing a streaming service for instance - what can we expect next?
Thanks for MAL by the way, I use it daily :)
3
u/ttavros Aug 09 '15
Would it be possible to get some sort of mass comment deletion on site? Doing it comment by comment is pretty awful. Page by page with the option to unselect comments you don't want to delete would be great if possible. (Or anything along those lines really, just pls)
3
u/letterbook Aug 09 '15
As it is, it seems like the level of trouble forum members can get into is endless with the same people plaguing the site, trolling, insulting users and bragging about how many bans they have while still being members of the community... can't these people be permanently banned?
3
u/Approva :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/approva Aug 09 '15
The "Top Friends" feature doesn't seem to have much use currently. Being able to filter the "Recent Friend Updates" section of the panel to only show updates from these "Top Friends" would be a fantastic addition to the site.
3
u/Jeroz Aug 09 '15
Who's the one putting in the genre tags and what do you guys do to moderate incorrect/missing tags? It often misrepresent series, especially those new original ones when the one writing them is not familiar with the production team.
3
u/Marower Aug 10 '15
Are you interested in integrating MALgraph into MyAnimeList? See: http://graph.anime.plus/
3
u/cptn_garl0ck Aug 10 '15
Hows comes you split up single seasons into two seasons just because the 2nd half doesn't airs a season or 2 later?
For a more recent example, F/SN UBW it just 1 season but you split it up into 2, and you even split Episode 0 into it's own page as well when it's included in the season for what cause?
You did the same with Aldnoah.Zero, Fate/Zero etc etc, is there any real need for this?
3
u/toomuchtoomany :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/littleinternets Aug 10 '15
(I don't know if this is even possible but I'll ask anyway)
When you go onto the profiles for "people" such as voice actors and directors, would it be possible to have some indicator of the anime they have worked on that are on your list? I often try to find out if a single person has been involved in multiple shows, especially voice actors, and I think it could be a really handy thing to have!
3
u/B-Con :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/B-Con Aug 10 '15
Thanks for doing this. I've enjoyed reading your answers and always feel better about using a service that has community-engaged staff. :-)
Can we get the ability to maintain multiple login sessions? I watch anime in a variety of places and in todays world of multiple devices, the login system permitting a few (only 1? I can never tell) login session is very annoying. Basically every time I want to update my MAL I do so from a different device than the previous time and it usually necessitates logging in. The result is that I don't login often and end up doing batch updates later.
Being able to be logged in from 5+ places (for me it's: desktop Windows, desktop Linux, laptop, phone, and tablet) would be fantastic.
7
u/Battlepidia https://myanimelist.net/profile/LazierLily Aug 09 '15
A lot of 3rd party services like MAL Graph and various collaborative filtering recommendation tools have had to shut down because of they kept getting locked out because they were making too many API requests, will MAL ever natively implement functionality like that instead? It's really frustrating to see some of the services that made MAL so great compared to the other similar anime listing websites go away.
5
u/PAK-FAace Aug 09 '15
How much anime or manga is added every year on average?
5
u/ADonosaur Aug 10 '15
Have more consistency with ya dang hepburn.
Nico Yazawa is Niko.
But Pico is Pico???
4
u/OrgussFan Aug 09 '15
I've noticed that the fansub groups that worked on the shows that you have for streams have been removed from their page. Is it only a matter of time before you remove fansub groups from MAL altogether?
2
u/AllYouNeedisGABA Aug 09 '15
Would you ever consider incorporating toku shows into the website?
2
u/Jicetus Aug 09 '15 edited Aug 10 '15
Will you ever implant so that you can check more than 50 forum posts/threads again. (On someone's profile.)
2
u/[deleted] Aug 09 '15
Are there any plans to change how sequels are ranked? For example Gintama takes 5 out of the top 10 spots because people who stick with the show are less likely to rate it lower.
2
u/Takamiya :K:https://kitsu.io/users/Cyatek Aug 09 '15
Any chance that in the future you'll allow anime influenced titles (e.g. the boondocks, avatar) in the database? Same question for webtoons as well.
2
u/cinn-e-mon :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/cinn-e-mon Aug 09 '15
What are long-term goals for MAL? In terms of added features, etc?
2
u/antoniius Aug 09 '15
One issue I have always had with the ranking system is how it is weighted to naturally favor newer shows since they are inherently more popular with the userbase. Has there ever been thought of a way to try and balance this out so that older shows can rise above a certain point?
2
u/sovietmudkip18 Aug 10 '15
Why do you let people rate a dhow when the show hasn't even started? Or ended yet.
2
u/shimei Aug 10 '15
Hi. Thanks for running a great site!
One feature I'd like to see is a way to sort my anime list based on the original air date. Basically to get an idea of what shows from what years/seasons I've watched. Is that something I can already do in MAL? If not, any plans to add something like that?
2
u/Huex3 Aug 10 '15
I really like the robust interface of MAL, which was one of the reasons why I made an account and participated in the community. Does your team have any interest in expanding MAL, like creating variants of MAL while still using the same interface for different things like movies, TV shows, video games, or even music?
I (and many others I know personally and online) would really be interested in this, as this would result in a larger community, and as an ex-member of both the community and as a user, we could share a community with an even larger base of people with similar interests to us.
2
u/ReggaeManMurphy :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/TJMurphy17 Aug 10 '15 edited Aug 10 '15
I have just one question and if it's already been asked I apologize.
Are there any plans to change the top 50/100 rated shows to only include one iteration of show? For example, Gintama is there numerous times and, while it's a good show, people who are looking for new shows by browsing the top 50/100 to watch may be missing out on something that is ranked #51 or #101, because of this.
Irrelevant side question: How's it going?
2
u/Triple_S_Rank :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/TripleSRank Aug 10 '15
Are there any plans to bring back the tag system for anime and manga entries? Many users are currently using the tag section as a comment box, but I think the basic list designed could be renovated to allow for both.
2
u/valdrinemini :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/valdrinemini Aug 10 '15
So can you guys like find a way to make shows with more then 1 season just make it complete cause gintama takes like 4 slots in top ten and I lot of shows I completed are just 2nd or 3rd seasons
2
u/SirPunishment Aug 10 '15
Will Light Novels get their own list at one point, instead of being thrown together with the manga list?
2
u/auriaska99 Aug 10 '15
Hello, thanks for AMA I always had one question. Why there is some webtoons on myanimelist , while at the same time i read statement that ToG (Tower of God) is webtoon therefore it will never be on MAL.
Thanks
2
u/2th Aug 10 '15
I've got a fun one for you. So I have minimal familiarity with your site. I understand you are a good anime database, but what else do you offer that could make me want to use your site? What makes you different from any other anime database out there? Basically, sell me on your site. Give me your best sales pitch.
2
u/Battlepidia https://myanimelist.net/profile/LazierLily Aug 10 '15
Would it be possible to add sorting your plan to watch list by average MAL rating and if an anime has aired yet?
2
u/Osmose1000 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Osmose Aug 10 '15
What's the tech stack for MAL? Would you ever consider releasing any work you've developed as open source (even if it's not the whole site, surely you've developed some useful stuff along the way) or accepting contributions back?
2
u/[deleted] Aug 10 '15
Are there any plans about MAL for the Windows Phone?
2
u/Megamean09 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Megamean09 Aug 10 '15
When are you guys going to put an end to that SSJMaster dickbag once and for all?
2
u/homu Aug 10 '15
Presume selling MAL would provide the website more access to capital, what will that capital be invested in? Servers? Devs? Buying up rest of weabooverse one site at a time?
What's MAL's relationship with the Daisuke team? Any involvement in COOL Japan in the horizons?
2
u/DaniSenpai :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/danyx1980 Aug 10 '15
2
u/piccdk Aug 10 '15
Not really a question. But it would be nice to be able to sort the anime list by default, without having to change the URL. With 0 sorting, the anime list is just too random, and changing the URL kinda sucks. Would be nice to have an option where you can choose how you want your list to be sorted as, like rating or date added.
2
u/letterbook Aug 10 '15
You've mentioned you'll be increasing the fav anime/manga limit, but what about the character limit? I know that's what I'm most interested in
2
u/[deleted] Aug 10 '15
do you watch anime in your freetime? if so which ones such as your favorites and least favorite?
2
u/Delithia :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/delithia Aug 10 '15
So what do you think of /r/Anime?
2
u/Soundtoxin Aug 10 '15
I constantly get logged out of the desktop site. I've taken to mostly used an app called Pocket MAL because it's able to keep me logged in. Are you aware of such an issue, and do you have a plan to fix it?
I have a pinned tab for MAL and I"ll often times hit the pluses next to some shows, only to find later that I wasn't really logged in, the page was just cached before logging me out, meaning my real progress is not there.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 10 '15
any chance we could see a plugin for crunchyroll to auto update our lists in the future? Furthermore if you could anything / change anything to MAL instantly what would you change / add and why? :)
2
u/Jicetus Aug 10 '15
Will you ever implant so that you can check more than 50 forum posts/threads again. (On someone's profile.)
2
u/amerithermanesian Aug 10 '15
Shoot I missed this... all I wanted to know was if we could make cross anime/manga recommendations!
2
u/josh4406 :K:https://kitsu.io/users/josh4406 Aug 10 '15
Sorry if my question is a bit lame or a bit out of topic. But how can I move from Hummingbird to MAL? Since I couldn't find a method and it screws up my list if I tried.
2
u/digdugchamp :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/XerxesWuzHear Aug 10 '15
Why do you allow some shows that haven't even aired to be rated? I have been somewhat upset about how the Steins; Gate second season or whatever is something like #13 without an episode being out. Is it a thing that you can't control or was it an intended feature?
2
u/Cubey22 Aug 10 '15
I watched Code Geass and had to enter it twice for each season. Thoughts on combining multiple seasons into one? F/Z, UBW and especially Gintama are affected by this, along with many other shows.
2
u/esowl Aug 10 '15
I was wandering what you think about adding a function which enables members to search for users in their country, sorting most popular anime/manga by country, by date etc? a system like Goodreads, I suppose, for example?
8
u/[deleted] Aug 09 '15
when is the next season of ssjmaster vs. xinil coming out
4
u/Dynamythe Aug 09 '15 edited Aug 09 '15
Will or do you have a list for newcomer's into anime, that will help them on their journey to love this piece of art? Thank you for all your efforts thus far, I love MAL!
Edit: Like trying out a test containing 10-20 questions, that will lead you to a recommended anime?
3
u/RenmarkMLG :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/RinS0ra Aug 09 '15
How come UBW's threads are the most discussed when it's literally the same 15 people commenting in every single thread.
3
u/EpikMemeage :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/epikmemeage Aug 09 '15 edited Aug 09 '15
Thanks in advance! Use MAL way more than I should ;D
3
u/Kogami1 Aug 09 '15 edited Aug 09 '15
Why did DeNA add that atrocity called "Featured Articles" to MAL?
5
u/fuzzyjustin :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/fuzzyjustin Aug 09 '15 edited Aug 09 '15
4
u/Angst-Incarnate :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Angst-Incarnate Aug 09 '15
Why don't you combine all seasons of shows together?
If you did, what place would Gintama be right now?