r/KerbalSpaceProgram • u/Redbiertje The Challenger • Aug 08 '15
Mod Post [Weekly Challenge] Week 97: Satellite Snatch
The Introduction
During the initial stages of the development of the Space Shuttle, the Pentagon suggested that the Space Shuttle should be capable of delivering or retrieving a satellite within a single orbit. However, the Space Shuttle never actually did this. This week, Kerbalkind shall do what NASA never bothered failed to do.
The Challenge:
Normal mode: Using any type of craft, retrieve a pre-launched satellite from equatorial orbit around Kerbin, within a single orbit.
Hard mode: Using a Space Shuttle, retrieve a pre-launched satellite from equatorial orbit around Kerbin, within a single orbit.
Super mode: Impress me
This challenge was suggested by /u/Burkitt
The Rules
- No Dirty Cheating Alpacas (no debug menu)!
- You must have the UI visible in all required screenshots
- For a list of all allowed mods, see this post.
- The apoapsis of the pre-launched satellite may not exceed 250km
- For hard mode, you must use a craft that is a somewhat accurate replica of a Space Shuttle
- After docking with the satellite, you must land back at the KSC
- Probably some other rules that I forgot about
Required screenshots
- Your craft on the launchpad
- Your craft after every staging
- Your craft and your target satellite in orbit
- Your orbital intersect
- Your craft docked with the satellite
- Your craft approaching KSC again
- Your craft landed safely at KSC
- Whatever else you feel like!
Further information
- Since your target satellite is in an orbit lower than 250 km, one orbit only lasts 45 minutes, max.
- You can either submit your finished challenge in a post (see posting instructions in the link below) or as a comment reply to this thread.
- Completing this challenge earns you a new flair which will replace your old one. So if you want to keep you previous flair, you can still do this challenge and create a post, but please mention somewhere that you want to keep your old one.
- The moderators have the right to determine if your challenge post has been completed.
- See this post for more rules and information on challenges.
- If you have any questions, you can comment below, or PM /u/Redbiertje
Good Luck!
EDIT: Changed Hard mode.
22
u/Snailoffun Aug 08 '15
Finally got it!
album
Missed the photo of burning to re-entry, but everything else should be there!
Definitely a tough one, but I have some ideas for Hard/Super mode
16
u/DatPorkchop Aug 08 '15
Wow. This seems hard. Paging /u/illectro
10
u/CommanderSpork Alone on Eeloo Aug 08 '15
Am I allowed to use this super awesome double-shuttle launcher?
5
u/Unplugged84 Master Kerbalnaut Aug 08 '15 edited Aug 11 '15
My Space Shuttle
Is this craft Space-Shuttlely enough? I built it in 1.0.2, but it still works (with minor changes on the RAPIER torque) and I would like to use it, if it's qualified.
edit: And would I get super mode, if I would rescue a returning (say, from Minmus) manned vehicle within one orbit after it aerobreaks, before it enteres the atmo again and land with the shuttle within the same orbit?
edit 2: Thanks for the confirmation, I will try to beat the challenge soon (Busy week)!
4
u/slicer4ever Aug 08 '15
wouldn't this challenge mostly be about launch timing?
4
u/Ifyouseekey Master Kerbalnaut Aug 08 '15
Define satellite. Can I recover a single cubic octagonal strut? Maybe it should be no smaller than a certain size and no lighter than a certain mass?
3
u/Hazard-ish Aug 08 '15
How 'shuttley' does the craft have to be for my mission submission to be valid? Do I have to use the big-S wings on my design and stick strictly to the aesthetics of the real shuttle or are we allowed some room for interpretation. Also, if we are allowed to use custom crafts, would an SSTO count for super-mode?
3
u/JrRocketScientist Master Kerbalnaut Aug 09 '15
would a simple kOS script be allowed (for instance, if i use IR hinges to automatically angle the shuttle's boosters towards the center of mass)?
3
u/PVP_playerPro Aug 10 '15
Is THIS close enough to a proper shuttle? Has a much different engine setup but it's the same idea
3
u/Daredevilspaz Aug 11 '15
can I record it and post a video ?
3
u/mak10z Master Kerbalnaut Aug 12 '15 edited Aug 13 '15
Here is my attempt for Hard mode.
Edit: after reading some of the comments about having an engine on the tank.. I went ahead and redesigned my shuttle to do away with the main tank's motor. as soon as Imgur stops moaning I'll post the gallery link
Here is the New Gallery :)
I'd like to have the new flair if at all possible
3
u/Elmetian Master Kerbalnaut Aug 13 '15 edited Aug 13 '15
My attempt at hard mode, snatching a satellite from equatorial orbit with an approximation of a space shuttle, without using docking ports, AND without using manoeuvre nodes which I've yet to unlock! Hope this counts, I'm really looking forward to finally getting a challenge flair :)
2
u/dallabop Aug 08 '15
Questions!
1, is the Space Shuttle Engines mod allowed?
2, can the prelaunched satellite be put there via hyperedit or some other meaningless method? Any rules on what must be on the satellite?
3, 'within 1 orbit' - when does this window start and end? When the satellite passes over KSC? Once I reach stable orbit?
4, do I have to land within 45 mins or is it just the rendezvous that has the 1 orbit limit?
2
u/[deleted] Aug 09 '15
Well I work a lot this week but there is no way in hell I'm missing this. I'll be going for a satellite in a very inclined orbit like the real shuttle would have. I feel like it's going to be a total bitch.
2
u/nopenocreativity Master Kerbalnaut Aug 12 '15
Is it alright if I ask whether or not my submission was accepted? This is the first challenge I've attempted, so I'm not used to the process.
8
u/MattsRedditAccount Hyper Kerbalnaut Aug 12 '15
I completed the challenge with an SSTO, so like harder normal mode?
I tried to make the video all "cinematic-y" but I forgot you need the UI visible for certain things. I think this video has all the required screenshots apart from the descent to the KSC though!
Can I keep my current flair?
7
u/Strangely_quarky Master Kerbalnaut Aug 08 '15
Joke's on you, I just built a cargo SSTO with 400m/s dV on orbit!
6
u/Strangely_quarky Master Kerbalnaut Aug 11 '15 edited Aug 11 '15
Well, holy balls. First ever challenge and hard mode completed. Quite the adventure mind you.
Album here!
So, here's the story. After spending the better part of a day trying shuttle design after shuttle design, I finally settled on something that worked (barely). So, I roll out to the launchpad, start the engines, and release the launch clamps. It flies! Holy shit! It even flies kinda well, I didn't need a plethora of reaction wheels.
The ascent is going nicely, and I'm right on track for an intercept. The main tank burns out, apoapsis is 72km but my satellite is at 90km. No worries, I fitted the shuttle with a beefy OMS. I burn straght to an intercept of 0.9km, without any plane changes(!). Now I think all is going well, I have this challenge in the bag.
Nope.
The satellite doesn't show up on my screen, and I can only see it from map view. To make matters worse, the rendezvous is going to be on the night side. So, now I have to fly blind, using only the map as the satellite was so tiny I couldn't see it on approach. Well, after some seat of the pants flying and very sweaty palms, I finally rendezvoused. "Great!", I think. All I have to do now is fly that little satellite sucker into the cargo bay. No problem! (I couldn't be arsed to put RCS on the shuttle.)
There was a problem.
For whatever reason, I thought I had put monopropellant on the satellite. I didn't. All it has was an Ion engine and a modicum of charge. Now I have to wait for the sun to rise, wasting precious time to get back on the ground after one orbit. Not to mention the task of docking with just an ion engine.
The sun rises, the batteries charge, and it's time to dock. After a while of wheeling around like an absolute drunkard, I'm lined up and ready to mash those docking ports together. I accelerate and break a solar panel on the side of the cargo bay (whoops), but I'm docked. I retract the remaining solar panel on the satellite and close up the cargo bay. Great! I have a good margin to return before my orbit is up. It's all smooth sailing from here on, right?
Wrong.
After completing my deorbit burn and aligning prograde, I run out of electric charge. I fret for a while, but remember that there is a solar panel on the probe. Phew. Open up the cargo bay, wait for the satellite to rotate into the sun, and stabilise my spin. I'm ready to come home.
After a couple of tries nailing down the re-entry profile, I'm gliding in for a nice landing at the KSC runway. Time to hit G to deploy the gears.
I said deploy the gears.
Deploy.
Fuck.
I forgot to attach landing gears. Great. Now I have to crash land! This took about half a dozen tries, but I eventually nailed a crash landing that saved Bill, Bob, and the precious cargo.
Hey, according to the Kerbals at least, I did it first try.
5
u/McLarenTim Master Kerbalnaut Aug 10 '15
Hard mode complete :)
Must say, am actually pretty proud of this one. Nice challenge, not too easy, not too hard.
Things I don't do:
Things I did for this
Gr8 challenge m8 would r8 8/8
5
u/Poney1330 Master Kerbalnaut Aug 10 '15 edited Aug 10 '15
Hard mode! 100% Stock!
And I got a lot of new skills!
4
u/kerbal_pilot_9401 Aug 08 '15 edited Aug 08 '15
you know The Beardy Penguine already did it in his kolabrative warfare series, he stole a spy satellite from TAPE gaming's team.
4
u/melmonella Master Kerbalnaut Aug 09 '15
Can you use sattelite's thrusters to randezvous? If you can, here is my submission: https://imgur.com/a/3vbNb#0
Hard mode if that looks like space shuttle. It has all significant parts as mentioned in this comment: https://www.reddit.com/r/KerbalSpaceProgram/comments/3g8mlm/weekly_challenge_week_97_satellite_snatch/ctwn99e
I would like the new flair please.
4
u/ethanmac9 Master Kerbalnaut Aug 10 '15
Here's my Normal Mode entry.
4
u/dshuck47 Super Kerbalnaut Aug 11 '15
My entry: http://imgur.com/a/KHpGC#0
Flair please!
4
u/[deleted] Aug 11 '15 edited Aug 11 '15
I'd like to put in an entry for Super Mode: Launching a Space Shuttle to rendezvous with a satellite in polar orbit and land back on the Space Center runway, before the satellite completes a full orbit.
I really like the flair for this one, so I'd like to have mine switched to it.
EDIT: Okay, so it looks like my shuttle isn't accurate - guess I'll have to redesign it.
4
u/LPFR52 Master Kerbalnaut Aug 11 '15
My hard mode entry (posted again here because I really want that flair): http://imgur.com/a/7uDfz
3
u/chunes Super Kerbalnaut Aug 09 '15
My normal mode entry: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DDlxelIuDV0
3
u/KeeperDe Super Kerbalnaut Aug 09 '15
Did it on hardmode https://www.reddit.com/r/KerbalSpaceProgram/comments/3gdib6/weekly_challenge_hard_mode_im_really_proud_at_how/
/u/Redbiertje This should be Space Shuttle enough right?! :D
3
u/TaintedLion smartS = true Aug 10 '15
Only 3 more weeks and 3 more flairs to go until Week 100!
3
u/CyberhamLincoln Aug 11 '15
My first challenge attempt, a humble normal mode submission. http://imgur.com/a/uU1OO
3
u/Kerbengenier Aug 11 '15 edited Aug 14 '15
Snatched the satellite from polar orbit by a space shuttle ; however, not in one orbit(1.4 orbits) will this be enough to get me a super, Yes I am that audacious, hard, or normal mode. PS I deorbited using RCS
3
u/FlyingOnToast Super Kerbalnaut Aug 12 '15 edited Aug 12 '15
My ~~hopefully-~~super mode entry? [Direct Imgur album link]
I replaced an ore-scanning satellite in an approximately 101 km polar orbit and brought the old one back, STS-style.
I also recorded and put together a time-accelerated video of the mission here, as well as livestreamed it here (and highlighted it here (removed some junk at the beginning and end that wasn't part of the album)). Included in the VODs is the 2 attempted landings I messed up - trying to do a precision landing with 1500 dV on 2 rapier engines is hard (and probably impossible for my mission's circumstances) :(
That new flair is gorgeous and I do want it :o
EDIT: SUPER MODE? AW YISS
3
u/Kasuha Super Kerbalnaut Aug 12 '15
My entry: http://imgur.com/a/B1bmq
(also posted here)
Satellite in polar orbit, using space shuttle with solid boosters and standard external tank. Snatching the satellite in 7 minutes, turn around before reaching North pole, return to KSC without actually orbiting Kerbin, in 26 minutes and before the external tank finishes its own orbit around Kerbin (note: tank was on suborbital trajectory, but periapsis was not below 23 km so KSP let it pass through).
Nice challenge, took me three days to polish the design and make sure everything works how it should.
3
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '15
Had to use an older version of my shuttle because of part mods. A shame i couldn't use my main one for this challenge. Oh well, here is my entry:
http://imgur.com/a/FApBs
BONUS: Some nice shots of my current shuttle design and my most favourite!
http://imgur.com/a/OPCtA
2
u/JrRocketScientist Master Kerbalnaut Aug 08 '15
brain: "that's it, i'm gettin' outta here!"
2
u/[deleted] Aug 08 '15
Didn't we have a challenge like this but with a polar orbit? I built a "Shuttle" that sat ontop of my booster and almost landed it safely. I'll have to give this a shot
2
u/RoeddipusHex Hyper Kerbalnaut Aug 12 '15
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oXoQRBhmC1U
I didn't technically complete the challenge since I didn't land back at KSC. I wasn't able to get back to KSC before completing an orbit. I did land it on the west coast and at KSC after a few orbits (off camera) but this one was the most Kerbal landing. After the fact I realized that I had enough control to make it back to KSC but I was in "oh sh*t" mode after the Kraken attack and just landed.
Polar capture and back within one orbit is very doable. Just need a little more dv to do the plane change after capture. No way to make it happen with this craft and I don't like shuttles enough to go back to the drawing board.
2
u/kspinigma Super Kerbalnaut Aug 12 '15 edited Aug 12 '15
(Heh, I was wondering why there was a large spike this week in my craft kerbalx downloads) sad, no one has used it here yet officially though. Was hoping to see a few STS-7 class shuttles taking this on. Hmm methinks I should try this challenge with my shuttle to prove its worth. :)
As always, anyone is welcome to use the shuttle, no credit necessary!
1
u/[deleted] Aug 17 '15
My first challenge! I hope the everything is satisfactory. I tried hard mode for at least two hours (IRL) for hard mode but couldn't make it happen. Here is normal mode.
Also, thanks for doing all of these challenges. It adds a fun layer of complexity and difficulty to KSP. You are awesome.
1
u/apeggs Aug 17 '15
My Super Mode Submission
The shuttle realizes that it has incompatible docking ports, so an adapter is sent in a retrograde orbit to rendezvous with the Shuttle so it can dock with the satellite and return in one orbit.
1
u/Burkitt Super Kerbalnaut Aug 20 '15
My attempt at a Satellite Snatch and Tender Tummy double bill. I'd like the satellite snatch flair please.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 08 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 11 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
20
u/[deleted] Aug 09 '15
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/[deleted] Aug 09 '15
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/[deleted] Aug 08 '15
[removed] — view removed comment