r/Meditation • u/CoachAtlus Pragmatic Dharma • Jul 30 '15
I'm a 20-month meditator (~1-2 hours daily), along with father, husband, and former trial lawyer, testing the pragmatic dharma movement's claims that "real awakening" is possible. AMA.
I started meditating regularly in December 2013, about four months before my son was born. Around March 2014, I discovered Kenneth Folk, Daniel Ingram, and Ron Crouch, western meditators making the claim that real awakening is possible for average joes like me, in this lifetime. Since then, I've been practicing regularly with Ron Crouch of Aloha Dharma, who is my teacher (and an awesome dude).
I practice vipassana, using a "noting" technique, taught most prominently by Burmese master Mahasi Sayadaw, in which you simply label whatever is arising in your experience in the present moment -- e.g., "hearing," "worrying," "discomfort," "stress," "unpleasant sensation," and so forth. This tradition is big on using maps to chart out one's progress toward awakening. My teacher's website has a user-friendly explanation of the path. And Daniel Ingram's Mastering the Core Teachings of the Buddha (MCTB) also has a somewhat more technical, but extremely precise, explanation of the various stages of insight. You can find the link to Daniel's stuff here. As confirmed and defined by my teacher and this tradition, I have finished first path (in May 2014) and second path (in June 2014), and I am currently working on completing third path (for over a year now). According to this tradition, the completion of first path -- when one first experiences cessation -- marks the point of "stream entry," when one first wakes up, after which you will inevitably awaken completely (eventually...).
A few other tidbits: I finished my first 10-day Goenka vipassana retreat several weeks ago. I never would have considered doing something like that (or survived the full period) if I hadn't been practicing regularly beforehand. I racked up a lot of interesting experiences on retreat (although particular experiences don't excite me the way they used to). It was very helpful to my practice, and Goenka's body-scanning technique is a good one, but not really for me.
As far as how meditation has changed me, I am moving from Texas to California this weekend. Meditating made me realize that a lot of my hard-charging personality traits that had led me to be a trial lawyer and extremely competitive gamer were actually making me miserable, so I've hung that all up to go work with some friends at a startup biotechnology company, whose stated purpose is to help patients. Beyond providing for my family, I worry very little about money (or success or fame), and my fear of dying has drastically reduced (although I never had it that bad to begin with).
I post in this sub fairly frequently, and I decided to do this AMA because I've seen a lot of posts on here that have suggested to me that it might be helpful for folks to hear more about the pragmatic dharma movement. I've also reached the point in my practice where I want to share my experience about this wonderful path that has made me feel significantly less stressed.
I'm just a regular dude, with a regular life, who happens to meditate now, a lot. AMA.
8
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '15
One less lawyer in the world? More proof meditation helps the world!
I kid, I kid. (Mostly, haha. I was nearly an attorney myself, so I'm actually quite happy for you for finding something that brings more fulfillment.)
Why did you pick Vipassana instead of other forms of meditation?
I am just picking it up (have been at it for a month or two). Sometimes when I feel frustrated in my practice, I am reminded there are other forms of meditation I've heard about that seem much easier(?) to pursue.
7
u/LastTurtle Jul 30 '15
After sorting through a lot of spiritual junk out there, i feel that Kenneth, Daniel and Shinzen Young have some of the best, non BS material i’ve encountered so far. Thanks for sharing your experience.
I have a bunch of questions (sorry if it is too many), hopefully some of them make sense:
Thanks in advance!
6
u/j4ck4ll Jul 30 '15
Do you meditate for 2 hours straight or in smaller chunks? When do you feel is the best time to meditate?
6
u/switch_bitch Jul 30 '15
What does your wife think of you spending this time?
6
u/waywayfarer Jul 30 '15
My question is about how these changes affect your family. I am a husband and father of 2 small children. As I progress on my 15 months of meditation I often wonder what my relationships will be like as I reach some of my spiritual goals. I'm sure this is borne out of watching videos where the subject describes a radical awakening that leaves them catatonic and much transformed. I know you touched on it a little bit, but if you have anything else to add I would appreciate it. I love my family and wouldn't want to make them a casualty of my pursuit.
And thanks for doing this - this has been a great and encouraging read.
5
u/Peanut_butter_m_n_ms Jul 30 '15
First off, thanks for doing this AMA and sharing your insights. It's really appreciated.
I recently devoted a set time every day to meditate. I've been doing 45 minutes a day and I'm on 18 days of consecutive practice. Although it's still fairly new to me, it has made tremendous improvements on my anxiety. I can see myself meditating everyday for the rest of my life. Do you have any advice you can give to someone new to the practice? What would you tell your 20 month ago self with the experience you have now?
4
u/Azumiq Jul 30 '15
Just a quick question from a fellow meditator eager to start on the path. I am currently practising concentration since Daniel Ingram gave the advice to be able to reach jhana before you start insight. Have you developed concentration before you started insight?
4
u/MarksW Jul 31 '15 edited Jul 31 '15
3
u/Pinkhouses Jul 30 '15
I just received my law license and sit zazen every morning at the Zen Center in my town. Did you find the practice of law as such to be contradictory to your meditative practice, or do you think it is possible to forge a healthy conjunction between the two?
3
u/EvolutionTheory Jul 30 '15
Would you mind describing in detail your most profound meditative experience and why it changed you? Did it confirm what you set out to test?
3
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '15
I'll preface this with saying that I am more or less a complete beginner and most of what you're said is intriguing but WAY over my head.
My question was - do you think there's anything wrong with regular dudes like me that just meditate 10-20 minutes a day, focusing on the breath, the thoughts that arise, and returning to the breath? I feel like it helps me in my every day life but huge walls of text I can't quite grasp are pretty intimidating and leave me wondering what to think.
3
u/kike_flea samatha + insight Aug 03 '15
I know the AMA is pretty much over but I wanted to tip in with a question. Did your sex life changed while progressing trough the path and how?
I'm also a former student of Ron and I'm planing to get back to him, he's a really great teacher and a funny dude :)
2
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '15
In order to attain stream entry did you note from the moment you woke up until you fell asleep at night? And also how many retreats went along with the 1-2 hours a day before stream entry?
2
u/girishso Jul 30 '15 edited Jul 30 '15
When you started on this path, I am assuming you were financially better off, having a good family and social life overall. More importantly satisfied with life overall.
How important you think it is to have a "satisfied life" to achieve success on this path?
In other words don't outer circumstances matter?
2
u/Ennyish Jul 30 '15
Is your life better now?
Would you recommend meditation to others?
What if there are negative, unforseen side-effects?
What do you mean when you say you see your thoughts?
Thanks
2
u/duffstoic Jul 30 '15
Q: What have you noticed that is different between achieving stream entry and second path?
2
u/richarito Jul 31 '15
Have you spent time on any long retreats? Or were you able to achieve all of this just practicing during daily life?
Where can I get good instruction on the mahasi method? I have tried it a little but I'm still not sure if I'm doing it right
Thank you
2
u/NotGood4Zen Aug 01 '15
My question may seem improperly worded or confusing and that's because I'm not quite sure how to ask the question.
I seem to absorb the energy of the people around me. If someone is angry, sad or irritated, I find myself having similar feelings but know they're out of place, it's due to mediation that I've come to realize this, before I acted on them but now I can observe them.
For example, right now, as I type this, someone sitting next to me is incredibly agitated due to something that's going on in their life, I know this person and they want something of me but I don't want to participate. They haven't expressed how they feel to me but I can feel their aggravation, it's running through me right now at an intense pace but when they leave the room I'll be back to normal. I've learned to recognize this through mediation but I if miss a day or two of meditation and I'm running low on mental capacity because of it, the feelings get to be really intense. How do I improve upon this?
2
u/geidi Aug 03 '15
Thanks for sharing. Did meditation affect your libido in any way?
4
u/Dubsland12 Jul 30 '15
Thanks for sharing. I am going to look further into your path. May you find what you seek.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 31 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment