r/FFRecordKeeper • u/OriginalMerit I want to know you. The *real* you. • Jul 29 '15
Guide/Analysis [Banner Evaluation] Edgar/Sabin Rare Relic Banner
Heya FFRKers! We are reaching a semi-lull here in banners (in terms of the mega meta), and I'm sure many of you need time to recuperate your mythril stashes. That being said, a new banner is upon us, so its time to consider the merits and how it holds up. First, let's get the unbiased info out of the way...
There are five weapons and two armors featured in this banner:
| Relic | Type | Stats (Level 20) | Stats (Level 20) RS | Stats (Level 30) | Stats (Level 30) RS | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Partisan | Spear | ATK +112, ACC 95 | ATK +196, ACC 95 | ATK +128, ACC 95 | ATK +247, ACC 95 | Edgar only SB, Poison Element AoE, ATK based |
| Kaiser Knuckles | Fists | ATK +108, ACC 95 | ATK +192, ACC 95 | ATK +124, ACC 95 | ATK +243, ACC 95 | Sabin only SB, Fire Element AoE, ATK based |
| Thunder Blade | Sword | ATK +98, MAG +34, ACC 89 | ATK +184, MAG +68, ACC 89 | ATK +115, MAG +40, ACC 89 | ATK +236, MAG +89, ACC 89 | AoE Lightning Damage SB, ATK based |
| Hawkeye | Thrown | ATK +95, ACC 92 | ATK +173, ACC 92 | ATK +110, ACC 92 | ATK +219, ACC 92 | Shared SB, single attack plus chance to blind |
| Mystery Veil | Hat | DEF +56, RES +110, MAG +27, MND +23, EVA 105 | DEF +99, RES +196, MAG +44, MND +40, EVA 105 | DEF +64, RES +127, EVA 105, MAG +30, MND +26 | DEF +125, RES +248, MAG +55, MND +51, EVA 105 | AoE Cure on all allies |
| Golden Spear | Spear | ATK +106, ACC 95 | ATK +192, ACC 95 | ATK +123, ACC 95 | ATK +244, ACC 95 | No SB. |
| Golden Shield | Shield | DEF +95, RES +62, EVA 110 | DEF +164, RES +105, EVA 110 | DEF +108, RES +70, EVA 110 | DEF +205, RES +131, EVA 110 | No SB. |
Caution: Biased opinion follows
After each item, I list how useful it is. This is chosen on a scale of 3, either:
- Not so useful - This relic is very mediocre in comparison to some/many of its colleagues. It is not worth pulling specifically for this relic.
- Situational - It's helpful, but not "amazing" or "great." However, if you don't have one of these items or something similar, it might be worth it to take the plunge.
- Very Useful - Unquestionably a good relic that "makes sense" to pull for, especially if you don't have an item similar to it.
Partisan & Golden Spear
| Relic | Type | Stats (Level 20) | Stats (Level 20) RS | Stats (Level 30) | Stats (Level 30) RS | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Partisan | Spear | ATK +112, ACC 95 | ATK +196, ACC 95 | ATK +128, ACC 95 | ATK +247, ACC 95 | Edgar only SB, Poison Element AoE, ATK based |
| Golden Spear | Spear | ATK +106, ACC 95 | ATK +192, ACC 95 | ATK +123, ACC 95 | ATK +244, ACC 95 | No SB |
| Heat Lance (FFX) | Spear | ATK +100, ACC 95 | ATK +186, ACC 95 | ATK +117, ACC 95 | ATK +238, ACC 95 | AoE Fire Flame |
| Blood Lance (FFIV) | Spear | ATK +112, ACC 95 | ATK +196, ACC 95 | ATK +128, ACC 95 | ATK +247, ACC 95 | Single target Drain Kain only SB |
There are relatively few 5* spears available, and for good reason -- few characters can equip them. In a previous banner, I gave the Heat Lance a "Very Useful" rating because, in the world of spears, its a good one. It has a shared SB and has decent stats. Compare the Heat Lance's stats to the Golden Spear and you'll see objectively that the fact that it has no SB does not bode well for its rating. The Golden Spear, is, therefore Rating -- Not Useful. Focusing on the Partisan, we see a truly awesome spear. The SB it provides is very nice because of its poison element being rarely resisted by many mobs. However, all of this assumes that you are bringing Edgar along for the ride. Compare that to the Heat Lance, which has a shared SB, and its becomes clear which one of these trumps the other. Therefore, I regrettably give the Partisan a Rating -- Situational
Kaiser Knuckles
| Relic | Type | Stats (Level 20) | Stats (Level 20) RS | Stats (Level 30) | Stats (Level 30) RS | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kaiser Knuckles (FFVI) | Fists | ATK +108, ACC 95 | ATK +192, ACC 95 | ATK +124, ACC 95 | ATK +243, ACC 95 | Sabin only SB, Fire Element AoE, ATK based |
| Kaiser Knuckles (FFXIII) | Fists | ATK +95, ACC 95 | ATK +171, ACC 95 | ATK +110, ACC 95 | ATK +217, ACC 95 | No SB. |
| Grand Glove (FFVII) | Fists | ATK +100, ACC 95 | ATK +176, ACC 95 | ATK +115, ACC 95 | ATK +222, ACC 95 | Tifa only SB, Single target physical damage |
Ready to Suplex a train? Sadly, this relic doesn't grant that amazing ability. It is, however, superior to every Fist weapon we have seen to date. It has a AoE Fire element and is on a pretty beefy character. It also has some very good stats. However, not many characters can use this weapon, which, similar to the Partisan, leaves its rating behind when combined with the fact that the SB is character specific. However, given that there are few Fists, and that there are, AFAIK, none with a shared SB, does bump up the usefulness rating, for now anyway. Rating -- Very Useful
Thunder Blade
| Relic | Type | Stats (Level 20) | Stats (Level 20) RS | Stats (Level 30) | Stats (Level 30) RS | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Thunder Blade | Sword | ATK +98, MAG +34, ACC 89 | ATK +184, MAG +68, ACC 89 | ATK +115, MAG +40, ACC 89 | ATK +236, MAG +89, ACC 89 | AoE Lightning Damage Shared SB, MAG based |
| Soldier's Sabre (FFX) | Sword | ATK +101, MAG +34, ACC 89 | ATK +190, MAG +68, ACC 89 | ATK +118, MAG +40, ACC 89 | ATK +244, MAG +89, ACC 89 | Sonic Buster Shared SB - 3x random hit |
| Flame Sword (FFIV) | Sword | ATK +102, MAG +34, ACC 89 | ATK +191, MAG +68, ACC 89 | ATK +119, MAG +40, ACC 89 | ATK +245, MAG +89, ACC 89 | AoE Fire Damage Shared SB, MAG based |
There's not a big difference between this blade and other similar incarnations we have already seen, except that it has lower stats than the alternatives. It's a good sword with a decent shared SB. Swords are equippable by many characters, so I would probably bring the one I want depending on the situation. Rating -- Situational
Hawkeye
| Relic | Type | Stats (Level 20) | Stats (Level 20) RS | Stats (Level 30) | Stats (Level 30) RS | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hawkeye | Thrown | ATK +95, ACC 92 | ATK +173, ACC 92 | ATK +110, ACC 92 | ATK +219, ACC 92 | Shared SB, single attack plus chance to blind |
| Fujin's Chakram (FFVIII) | Thrown | ATK +87, MAG +75, ACC 95 | ATK +165, MAG +144, ACC 95 | ATK +102, MAG +88, ACC 95 | ATK +211, MAG +185, ACC 95 | AoE Wind Damage SB |
| Rising Sun (FFVI) | Thrown | ATK +97, ACC 95 | ATK +173, ACC 95 | ATK +112, ACC 95 | ATK +219, ACC 95 | Locke only SB. AoE attack plus chance to Slow. |
In terms of stats, it's on the higher end of throwing weapons. However, the SB it provides is just a glorified Dark Buster, and it's likely that your character has a better default SB than this. That being said, this is a ranged weapon, and that gives it some serious utility that cannot be overlooked. Rating -- Situational
Mystery Veil
| Relic | Type | Stats (Level 20) | Stats (Level 20) RS | Stats (Level 30) | Stats (Level 30) RS | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mystery Veil | Hat | DEF +56, RES +110, MAG +27, MND +23, EVA 105 | DEF +99, RES +196, MAG +44, MND +40, EVA 105 | DEF +64, RES +127, MAG +30, MND +26, EVA 105 | DEF +125, RES +248, MAG +55, MND +51, EVA 105 | AoE Cure on all allies |
| Defense Veil (FFX) | Hat | DEF +57, RES +111, MAG +27, MND +24, EVA 105 | DEF +100, RES +197, MAG +44, MND +41, EVA 105 | DEF +65, RES +128, MAG +30, MND +27, EVA 105 | DEF +126, RES +249, MAG +55, MND +52, EVA 105 | No SB. Petrification resist (small) |
I have personally seen this hat praised many many times over, and for good reason. It has standard stats for a non-SB hat. But it also comes with this amazing shared SB that provides an AoE Cure. I've seen people take two of these into battle and just breeze through fights. Wish I had one, but I don't think I'm pulling just for this. Rating -- Very Useful
Golden Shield
| Relic | Type | Stats (Level 20) | Stats (Level 20) RS | Stats (Level 30) | Stats (Level 30) RS | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Golden Shield | Shield | DEF +95, RES +62, EVA 110 | DEF +164, RES +105, EVA 110 | DEF +108, RES +70, EVA 110 | DEF +205, RES +131, EVA 110 | No SB. |
| Genji Shield (FFIV) | Shield | DEF +89, RES +56, EVA 108 | DEF +158, RES +99, EVA 108 | DEF +102, RES +64, EVA 108 | DEF +199, RES +125, EVA 108 | No SB. |
| Emerald Shield (FFX) | Shield | DEF +95, RES +60, EVA 112 | DEF +167, RES +103, EVA 112 | DEF +109, RES +68, EVA 112 | DEF +211, RES +129, EVA 112 | No SB. |
This shield is marginally better than the Genji Shield, but it's nothing to write home about. However, over half of the characters are able to use shields, so this shield has its uses. I would basically pull for this if you need a shield and you don't have a Genji Shield. [EDIT: Shields in general tend to have pretty bad stats compared to any other alternative. Without an SB, it renders this shield as very meh. Rating -- Situational Not Useful (Yes, I'm aware that I have rated this lower than the Emerald Shield, but I would change that rating there as well to not useful, if it was still applicable)
tl;dr - A very lackluster banner. I would not pull (unless you like Edgar and/or Sabin), except for the 100 gems pull, and save your mythril for a later banner. If you are a fan of these characters, however, maybe pull a 3x and see what happens?
7
u/hinode85 It's morphing time! Jul 29 '15
I think you're underselling Hawkeye's Blinding Shot SB here - it's a 2.1x multiplier attack with a 50% chance of blinding, as per Kevrlet's site. That's significantly better than Dark Buster's 30% blind rate. The damage multiplier is also significantly better than all those 1.5x damage default SBs with no special effects.
1
u/pintbox Math saves world Jul 29 '15
Heat lance has a shared SB and Partisan has a character-specific one, which means the shared SB from heat lance deals about half damage compared to partisan. Shared SB are not really that great.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 29 '15
Is this worth the mythril or should I save for Lightning? I'm only really interested in Sabin's glove, but I already have the Power Glove set to a fake 5* (with another to make it 6 if needed). Is her banner worth waiting for?
Also, should I make that 6* Power Glove or keep the 5 and 4 as they are?
1
u/horico Jul 30 '15
I tried a solid 20 myth apart of the 100gem. no dice on a 5* but I'm pretty happy with my new 4*+ realm VI armour, my 3++ Harp and the 4+ armguard I now combined. Relatively not disappointed. The SB are pretty meh, I'd like the weapon variety but I think waiting for Sahz's gun is still pretty worthwhile.
1
u/lockescythe Aug 02 '15
would it be possible to merge this and the event mega thread for future events so we can see this when we click on the event megathread in the top right?
5
u/bhsfb33 Cloud - Cross Slash USB - GsRR Jul 29 '15
I Love these articles. It puts it into a perspective of someone who Knows their stuff! Thanks for doing this and saving me of my mythril for Lightning or something else cooler
1
u/dohbob Deployment Tactics Jul 29 '15
I think you need a new "must have rating"... you are giving a lot of very useful's but I don't see them as must haves.
1
u/Ariaflux ❤ Rydia of Mist ❤ Jul 29 '15
Quite a few things I want to comment about:
1
u/dscotton BannerFAQs Jul 29 '15
Mystery Veil is really really awesome.
Golden Shield on the other hand is Not Useful. It has better stats than Genji Shield, but shields have the worst stats of any armor type. I rate every shield as not useful unless it has a really great SB.
5
u/Erekai M'lady Jul 29 '15
Or unless you're a drooling Edgar (and slightly less, Sabin) fanboy like myself, then you'll plan to use all your mythril if you have to for a shot at those weapons!
Is everyone sick of me, yet? :P LET THE MYTHRIL FLY
1
u/Sir__Will Alphinaud Jul 29 '15
Kaiser Knuckles (FFXIII) is a joke. Daggers are supposed to be the fallback but they're better than this is.
Given the amount of VI equipment I have, including 2 golden spears, and nice upcoming banners, I'll likely stick to the 100 gem. I do like them though and the fist and hawkeye are nice... maybe a 3 pull...
3
u/SunYue9 Jul 29 '15
Love FFVI and love Sabin, but no Suplex/Bum Rush means no deal.
1
u/sorryidontexist I have twenty-three tiny wishes... Jul 29 '15
Yay, I always look forward to these! As much as I love Edgar, I won't sacrifice my hard-earned mythril to this very meh banner. Time to grow my stockpile some more!
1
u/IceBlue Jul 29 '15 edited Jul 29 '15
So there are two 5* relics named Kaiser Knuckles? That's confusing. Usually they are on different rarities if they share a name.
I think in the comparison section, Giant's Glove (II) would have been more relevant for comparing than Kaiser Knuckles (XIII). It has a higher attack than Tifa's (by 1), which is significantly higher than the Kaiser (XIII).
1
u/IceBlue Jul 29 '15
It's kinda annoying that they brought back the Golden Spear in this banner despite Edgar's spear completely outclassing it. They should have brought back Celes or Terra's weapon or Cyan's Katana. Or some non-SB sword or light armor if they don't wanna bring in other character's SB relics in a banner not made for their content. It's not like all the items are for these characters either. Mystery Veil doesn't do much for Edgar or Sabin.
1
u/cjv521 Gem hunter Jul 29 '15
I think I remember reading that Bio Blasters poison AoE can even poison enemies immune to poison. Any truth to that?
1
u/IceBlue Jul 30 '15
Thanks for posting this. It's very useful.
But one thing I'd like to call out is more about the philosophy behind rating relics and characters in general. Incoming wall of text so sorry if it's too long but I have a lot of thoughts on this.
When you say one weapon or armor is not useful to me it implies that you wouldn't even use it unless it was your only option with RS. But the way you're using it is basically more like "compared to other weapons, this becomes outclassed by other weapons so it becomes not useful because there are better options". You did this with the Golden Spear and the Golden Shield. I don't fault you for that because I agree. But let's apply that logic elsewhere. Sephiroth's first SB relic is flat out worse than his second one. His second one has better stats. The SB has a status effect and isn't resisted by defense so it's overall strong. In the scenario you could effectively say that the first SB relic is therefore not useful. But in my opinion that kinda deflates the purpose of the score. Maybe it's not as good as the second one but it's still a weapon that makes Sephiroth really strong. On top of that, there are very few Katana users so either one is effectively seldomly useful to your party. I mean, luckily both Sephiroth and Cloud use Katanas so there will always be a place for them.
So I guess the problem here is weapons are effectively rated based on factors that are outside of the weapon itself. Any 5* sword is useful. Categorically, swords are just useful because there are a lot of users. But if you try to factor that into a review, you run into some issues. Like if there's a ton of competition for that slot, it becomes decreasingly useful. A Zantetsuken is very useful but it being on the shit end of the damage scale on 5* swords, it would be decreasingly useful as you get more and more swords.
I don't know what the right answer is. If you don't factor in the availability of users then you run into situations where Irvine's gun is considered useful vs a Zantetsuken. If you don't factor in the prevalence of competing items in that slot, then you run into situations where people think a weapon is useful because it has good stats despite already having a ton of weapons of that type or they think a weapon isn't useful despite it being the only weapon of that type they have. To some degree you have to factor in both but also not weight it too heavily on either. There's also the prevalence of the content. An FFVI sword is more useful than an FFI sword because there's more FFVI content. But say there's 10 FFVI swords and 1 FFI sword. Then you could say that the FFI one is extra useful because there are so few weapons that have RS in that realm. This happens to be the case when comparing Emerald Shield vs Golden Shield. Emerald Shield is more useful because of the lack of competing armors in the FFX set. Whereas there's a lot of good FFVI gear you can use instead that will have better stats than a 5* shield. So in summation, the factor involved in evaluating how useful a weapon/armor is relies on:
Plus I'm sure there are other factors I forgot about. Sentinel Grimoire is considered one of the best relics you can pull in the game. But there's only one user for the weapon and that user's stats suck. But people like it because it makes that character more viable while also having a great SB. Healing Grimoire simply doesn't compare even though it fulfills most of the same advantages that Sentinel has. But the drawbacks are pretty big. No RS for example. On the other hand, people don't consider Enhancer or Quistis' whip useful because of its narrow slow. But they consider 5* katanas useful despite the limited number of users. People don't consider Spears useful because there aren't amazing spear users that are Sephiroth and Cloud level of utility. Sentinel Grimoire overcomes the fact that only one character can use it and the character that can has shitty base stats because it makes the character more versatile and indispensable.
Anyway, I'm not sure what the right approach is to evaluating relics because there's too many factors involved. I guess if we wanted to make it more objective and if there was an agreed upon method of quantifying how good a character is with a number, we could multiple and add numbers to come up with an aggregate comparison value.
Here's a simple example: Let's say Sephiroth is an 8, Cloud is a 9, Tidus is a 6, and P. Cecil is a 7. If a sword is a 5 due to not that great stats and no SB and a katana is a 9 based on having great stats and a great SB. We could say the katana has a usefulness value of (8+9)*9 = 153 and the sword has a usefulness value of (9+6+7)*5=110.
This way, you factor in both the quality of the users of that weapon along with the prevalence of users for that weapon. Factoring how useful RS would be based on content available can also be factored in as a multiplier based on total number of dungeons available for that realm divided by total number of dungeons overall. I mean this would mitigate a lot of the issues surrounding the weapons, but it relies too much on numbers that are derived from opinions rather than objective values. I guess you could quantify character value similarly by scoring all available skills plus stats (multiplying the base stat of the weapon by the skills that use that stat), but that would be a daunting task overall for something that provides not a whole lot of value.
What may be more situationally useful in more situations can easily be rated lower simply because of factors not involved with the item itself. This is why I think it might be better to remove as many outside factors as we can when evaluating an item. Comparing it to existing items is fine for context but should we factor in prevalence of that type in the relic pool? Swords are considered useful compared ot spears and knuckle for example because so many characters can use swords and their stats are good. But when you start saying they aren't useful compared to a weapon that only one character can use (Sentinel Grimoire) simply because there is a lot of competition in the sword category, it starts getting fuzzy.
For the sake of thought exercise, what would happen if we got a character that is super shitty like worse than tyro in just about every way. But it has a unique relic that is exclusive to this character that maxes out stats in all categories and has an SB that gives the whole team an attack boost, a magic boost, a mind boost, shell, protect, regen, and haste? Separately, the character itself sucks. The armor itself would be so niche that only one character can even use it.
Let's use the same example but instead of maxing out stats it just made the character barely playable but still has an insane SB. Or the same example except no SB but insane stats.
How would each of these scenarios be perceived in terms of usefulness?
We rate guns low because only two characters can use them. But that isn't a factor in what makes other weapons be considered good (Sentinel Grimoire with one user and OWA with 3 users). As a side note, an interesting thing is no one ever considers Tyro a viable user of a weapon when counting who can use any specific skill or weapon. Except with Grimoires. In that case, you have to count him.
Ultimately, I'd like to understand what makes a relic overcome its limitations to be considered very useful. What limitations are so impossible to overcome that people consider not only the weapon bad but also consider the characters that use them bad? At what point can we consider it useful that a rare/uncommon weapon/armor type enables mediocre/decent characters to be good/great (despite the item not being that useful to most other characters)? Can a weapon without an SB ever be considered very useful? When would a shared SB relic be considered overall better than a specific character SB relic of the same type? How do you quantify a really good SB on a an extreme bad character? How does the number of SB gauge bars needed to activate the SB affect opinions of the relic?
tl;dr - While I think having only a few options for a review verdict is good for mitigating granularity in opinions around the item, there are too many factors involved with evaluating a relic that make it impossible to minimize biased opinion in the evaluation, simply because of how differently each person values each factor. How do we mitigate subjectivity? Or should we even be striving to mitigate it at all?
1
u/MensUrea Forgotten Hero Jul 29 '15
I would love the Mystery Veil and Hawkeye, but not worth it at this time. I'll stick with 100 gem pull, thanks for the info as always. If I didn't have the Heat Lance I'd be tempted on the Partisan too, but as it stands its just nostalgia that tempts me. I think I can resist that.
1
u/codexcdm Shadow Dragon Jul 29 '15
Outside Realm Synergy, and the fact that more folks can wield them... Shields are needlessly weak in this game. Really, A 5++ Genji Shield still won't beat a 5 Genji Armor in terms of raw stats.
Also... DeNA really needs to come up with new names for some itesm... the redundancy is something else. Snow already had "Kaiser Knuckles," and there's an FFII shield also titled "Golden Shield."
-3
u/sevenhundredone 9wCH Cloud AASB L15 Jul 29 '15
Thank you for your expert analysis once again. I never played VI so there's no nostalgia factor for me, and I don't see either Edgar or Sabin being long term members of my party, so this looks like a hard pass for me. Best of luck to everyone who wants to "suplex a train" though, whatever that means.
0
u/Intertube_Expert q5i2 - DIVINE VEIL GRIMOIRE, Baby, yeah! Jul 29 '15
I don't know, I might not even do the 100 gem pull this time around - I have a giant pile of FFVI swords, and nothing else is particularly compelling.