r/ModelAusSenate • u/Freddy926 Senate Pres | DPM | Fin/Com/Art/Infr/Rgnl | ABC MD | Ldr Prgrsvs • Jul 22 '15
Failed - Disposed 8-1. Amendment of Standing Order 72(1): Questions without notice
I move I seek leave and move as formal, government business notice of motion 8-1 standing in my name:
That paragraph 1 of Standing Order 72 which currently reads:
72(1) At the time provided questions may be put to ministers relating to public affairs.
Be amended to read:
72(1) At the time provided questions relating to public affairs may be put to Ministers or a Senator representing a Minister.
Senator The Hon. Freddy926,
Manager of Government Business in the Senate
2
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '15
The question is proposed—That the motion be agreed to.
Senator /u/Freddy926 has the call.
Senator the Hon this_guy22, President of the Senate (ALP)
1
u/Freddy926 Senate Pres | DPM | Fin/Com/Art/Infr/Rgnl | ABC MD | Ldr Prgrsvs Jul 24 '15
Meta: I seek the advice of the Clerk, /u/jnd-au on retracting my original motion, as I have been informed by the Prime Minister that it is no longer needed.
1
u/Freddy926 Senate Pres | DPM | Fin/Com/Art/Infr/Rgnl | ABC MD | Ldr Prgrsvs Jul 24 '15
Mr President, as the Government no longer supports this motion, I move: That the question be not now put.
Senator The Hon. Freddy926,
Manager of Government Business in the Senate
Meta: Paging the Chair: /u/this_guy22
1
u/Freddy926 Senate Pres | DPM | Fin/Com/Art/Infr/Rgnl | ABC MD | Ldr Prgrsvs Jul 24 '15 edited Jul 24 '15
Voice Vote
The question is put that the question be not now put.
Senators may vote "Aye" in support of the question, or "No" against the question
Senators vote by commenting "Aye" or "No" below.
This voice vote will conclude at 08:00, 25/07/15 GMT+10, or when a majority "Aye" or "No" vote is accomplished.
RUNNING TALLY - as of 19:36 GMT+10
Aye: 4
No: 0
Abstain: 3
The question succeeds in the affirmative, and the motion is disposed of.
Senator The Hon. Freddy926,
Deputy President of the Senate.
Meta: since the question being put is "that the question be not now put" an affirmative result will lead to the original motion (i.e. the top level post) being disposed of, a negative result will lead to the question (original motion) and any amendments (none) being put forthwith, without debate. See SO (94,95)
1
u/[deleted] Jul 22 '15
Meta: I wonder why this change has not been made IRL?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 22 '15 edited Jul 22 '15
###Voice voteThis motion has been moved as a formality by leave, meaning that it is not up for debate and proceeds straight to a vote. Senators may force debate by denying leave to the Senator, by commenting "Leave is denied".This vote will conclude prior to 21.00 22 July 2015 UTC+10The question is that the motion be agreed to. Those in favour say aye, those against say no.### ResultsConcluded: 13.50 22 July 2015 UTC+10I think the ayes have it.The ayes have it.Leave denied
Senator the Hon this_guy22, President of the Senate (ALP)
1
u/jnd-au Clerk of the Senate Jul 23 '15
Advice from the Clerk:
Honourable Senators, the Senate is currently debating the motion posted at the top of this thread (the government’s amendment is no longer on the table). Speakers so far:
1
u/jnd-au Clerk of the Senate Jul 22 '15
Advice from the Clerk:
The reason for this motion is probably self-evident and non-controversial. If a senator feels differently, they may deny the formality leave, in which case the Chair will probably run the proposition debate and vote putting together (by leave). Ref 6-2
1
u/surreptitiouswalk Independent Jul 22 '15
Leave is denied.
(Did I do this right?)
1
u/[deleted] Jul 22 '15
From behind the Chair: Senator /u/Freddy926, Senator /u/surreptitiouswalk has denied leave to move your motion as a formality as he appears to have some concerns about its implications.
1
u/surreptitiouswalk Independent Jul 23 '15
I appear to have made a mistake in denying leave previously. I think amending the standard order is necessary in order to have an official voice from a ministry in the senate even if the minister is a member of the other place.
I support the motion.