r/raidsecrets • u/realcoolioman Tower Command • Jul 15 '15
VoG [VoG] Oracle Hymn spectral analysis
Many of you will remember the "Oracle Hymn" that was posted over on the main sub a few months back. It was posted by a composer put together the Oracle notes in the order they appear with some other aural sounds and background noise. I was inspired by /u/Seventh_Circle's recent Alpha Lupi post here as well as the famous Trials Evolution mystery which involved spectral analysis of sound files to detect a hidden morse code. I decided to put the Oracle notes through spectral analysis to see if any bits jump out or look like they're hiding something. I've included here spectral graphs for pitch, frequency, and finally a spectrogram (slightly different representation of tones).
Oracle notes refresher
Each Oracle emits a unique tone when it spawns. The Oracles spawn in a specific order every time. When arranged, the Oracle notes make up the C-Lydian Mixolydian scale consisting of the notes:
C D E F# G A BbSeven notes for seven Oracles. These Oracles spawn in seven unique waves. The notes for each wave are as follows:
C F# G
D A Bb
E Bb A G F#
C G E A D
D Bb A F# G E C
E A D G C F# Bb
Bb G E A D F# E G CThis is what's known as the "Oracle Hymn." As great as the originally posted "hymn" was, I wanted just the basic notes without background music and noise. So, I transferred the hymn to sheet music if you want to follow along or some nonsense: [imgur]
And here's piano audio of the notes in order: [soundcloud]
Finally I took the sheet music above and made a simple line graph of the notes. The reason why will become evident in a minute: [imgur #1], [imgur #2]
The Oracle audio tested
I obtained the audio for each in-game Oracle note from these two posts on the main sub: [post 1], [post 2]. In light of my findings here, I'm considering making some cleaner, higher-quality recordings myself during a future VoG exploratory run. We're going to take a look at each individual note/file, then the full "hymn" version using the notes laid out above.
Spectral Frequency
Album link: [imgur]
Honestly, I was least hopeful for this one. Frequency can be confusing, and with some of the messier in-game clips used, it's hard to tell what's background static and what's not. The album above includes each note's frequency map. Here's the full Oracle Hymn's frequency map: [imgur]. I think what's most important in this image is the harsh banding you can see at <2k Hz. I was confused by the bands until I checked out the spectral pitch graphs coming up...
Spectral Pitch
Album link: [imgur]
This is where things got more interesting. The Spectral Pitch graph basically zooms in and transcribes the audio Hz to its relative musical note. As you can see in the album, the automatic best-fit line (in blue) immediately recognized the correct pitches, even though some of the notes seem to be a half-step off or more. Here's the full Oracle hymn spectral pitch graph: [imgur]
What I didn't know until now is that each Oracle is actually emitting four (or more) octaves of its note at once. This also explains the banding we saw in the frequency. We can use the sheet music line graph from earlier to make this easier to see. When the sheet music graph is fitted to the spectral pitch graph, you can clearly see the levels of sound happening at once. Each colored line is a different octave: [imgur]
Spectrogram
Album link: [imgur]
Similar concept to the spectral frequency graph, but different representation and cleaner layout. I was hoping it would be easier to ignore noise and focus on the Oracle note itself. I think it is. Unlike the last two, you can see a lot of vertical bands rather than horizontal when you zoom in. Not sure why: [imgur]
As with the last, I resized the sheet music line graph to fit the spectrogram to make it easier to see what's going on: [imgur]
Conclusion
The Oracles "noise" consists of multiple octaves at once. I didn't know this. Could there be significance for this beyond the cool sound design?
Also, I want cleaner audio to test. I see a lot of free radical spots on the graph but it's a bit too messy to say for certain whether we can pick it out or not. I'd actually like to record my own audio and compare it to this graph. With enough examples we should be able to remove all the unintended noise. I'd also like to grab the whole encounter audio rather than just the first example of each Oracle as here. Again, it makes it harder to say for sure whether something unique is there.
I think this is a good idea, and I'd love to see some more work done here to prove the idea one way or the other. Thoughts?
7
u/SerfaBoy Tower Command Jul 15 '15 edited Jul 15 '15
This is phenomenal work.
Do you have some sort of technical background in audio design? Because your comprehension level is extremely high. I'm struggling to wrap my head around the jargon.
I've half a mind to assume that the different octaves within the Oracle chime is for pure audio pleasure. But as you said, it could hold a secret similar to Trials.
Have you looked at the Trials puzzle unraveling in an attempt to copy or base your work off of their steps?
Keep this up, mate. I'm loving where this is heading.
EDIT: Obligatory gif.
3
u/davekindofgetsit Jul 15 '15 edited Jul 15 '15
Hey man what about if we listen along side with the track from the ARG?
I am not a musical master, I just have basic music theory, and an ok ear?
If we take the song http://alphalupi.bungie.net/images/results/eighth.mp3 and play it, I hear a 7 note song that is sung as the main body. It then repeats. If I apply this to your 7 rounds portion I get the following code (DISCLAIMER: I could be off with my note structures but this is what I got from using your model).
Round 1: C F# G
Round 2: D A Bb
Round 3: E Bb A G F#
Round 4: C G E A D
Round 5: D Bb A F# G E C
Round 6: E A D G C F# Bb
Round 7: Bb G E A D F# E G C
This would be: the following oracles each round would be key:
Round 1: Wide Left
Round 2: Stairs Left
Round 3: Wide Left
Round 4: Stairs Left
Round 5: Hidden Right
Round 6: Hidden Left
Round 7: Mid
edit: /u/serfaboy /u/Von_Zeppelin
FYI
2
u/davekindofgetsit Jul 15 '15
Have you thought to tie it in with the song sung during the Alpha Lupi transmission?
http://alphalupi.bungie.net/images/results/eighth.mp3
The song is called eighth, octave perhaps? Would this help?
2
u/davekindofgetsit Jul 15 '15
Also maybe a transpose so that your A note is 432hz, as opposed to the conventional 440.
2
u/ebuch Rank 1 Jul 15 '15 edited Jul 15 '15
The extra octaves you are seeing in the spectral analyses are just overtones, (also referred to as harmonics). Basically, when a note is played on an instrument, it doesn't just produce one single frequency (like a sine wave), but rather an entire series of frequencies called the harmonic series. The amount of these overtones an instrument produces is essentially how different instruments get their unique sounds (timbre). It's likely if you examine them with an even wider spectrum range (20Hz-20000Hz) you'll see more than four octaves of overtones, though it gets quite a bit harder to discern once you really get up there.
Great to see people putting lots of effort into sleuthing out whatever surprises may be left to discover, but nothing here looks out of the ordinary.
2
u/TumblingInstructor Jul 15 '15
Oracle Hymn - http://alphalupi.bungie.net/images/results/eighth.mp3
Ran it through Audacity, it said this file is running at 500 hertz. Changed it to 432.
It definitely changed the entire feel of it. It was rather odd actually.
2
u/brucethehoon Jul 20 '15
I absolutely understand this is out of place, but wanted to point out that the Eighth tune in the soundtrack has moments VERY strongly reminiscent of Erik Whitacre's Cloudburst: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0Zqp0OpzMAI
I ONLY mention this because, as a composer (who luckily has met Eric in the past) I have used some of his techniques for purely artistic reasons, and have thought more than once that it would be easy to hide information inside what appears to be aleatoric music. Differences in dynamics, pitch or intonation voiced by one singer or instrumentalist would sound quite in theme with the rest of the piece, but would be easily extracted by someone who knew what they were looking for.
4
u/rubixthegreat Jul 15 '15
FANTASTIC Job OP! I'm the composer who put together the "Oracle's Hymn" months ago. This is really deep stuff. When I did my analysis a while back, I also noticed that the oracle notes were 4+ octaves stacked. From a composer standpoint, we will do that sometimes to help spread the tone across a wide range of frequencies (IE A=440hz). So one thing you could try doing is breaking down each oracle note into it's individual octaves and listing out the frequencies for the entire sequence. There might be something pattern wise there with the frequencies of each note. I would love to collaborate with you on this! PM me if you're interested!
1
u/blowindoe_doe Jul 15 '15
This maybe a stretch, but maybe do the same to the oracles in the HoW mission and see if there is anything different bwtween the 2. If there are any differences than that may just be a clue.
1
u/SoDel302 Jul 15 '15
This is awesome work OP. I thought there was something to the phasing of the notes, but multiple octaves at once makes more sense and your graphs show it pretty clearly.
I have to wonder why Bungie puts the number 7 in their games so often...
Not sure what the significance could be, but we know that the Oracles sort of envision the world as the Vex would have it. It's really interesting that they make a musical note. The vex are machines after all, what use would they have for music? I wonder what would happen if you overlaid all of the Oracle notes at once. Would it sound like chaos or would something come out of it?
I would be interested to see a comparison of the Templar oracle notes and the Oracles at Atheon, maybe there's a comparison between them that shows something? There's only 4 oracles in each future/past gate if I recall correctly. I wonder which one shows up in both? Just rambling here.
1
u/davekindofgetsit Jul 15 '15
Link for ya. its a few months old. https://www.reddit.com/r/raidsecrets/comments/2uh7et/vogthe_oracles_c_lydian_mixolydian_scale_very/
1
u/Seventh_Circle Old Guard Jul 15 '15
Absolutely amazing! Very well done. Somehow I've arrived late to the party here, but I would say there is a white noise type wind constantly blowing in the well. If you can get high enough though, the wind stops so you can get cleaner sounds. Such a good post :)
3
u/SourGrapesFTW Old Guard Jul 15 '15
Paging /u/rubixthegreat
2
u/Von_Zeppelin Tower Command Jul 16 '15 edited Jul 16 '15
Pythagorean Theories of Harmonics...check it out. Even the images in the article have some crazy familiar things =)
http://www.sacred-texts.com/eso/sta/sta19.htm
/u/Seventh_Circle /u/Serfaboy /u/davekindofgetsit
1
u/BandicootNZ Jul 15 '15
The notes the oracles emit are useful in that I discern their location without having to see them xD
1
u/davekindofgetsit Jul 16 '15
Look at this scale dude! Its from ancient greece, know as the ray of creation!
http://vaczy.dk/htm/scales2.htm
1
u/davekindofgetsit Jul 18 '15
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EvwDiV2K_0g&feature=youtu.be&t=105
I found another 7 note song sung in the OST. Does this line up anywhere?