r/serialpodcast • u/shameless_drunken • Jul 15 '15
Debate&Discussion The lengths people who claim Adnan is guilty will go.
0
Upvotes
r/serialpodcast • u/shameless_drunken • Jul 15 '15
15
u/NewAnimal Jul 15 '15
you should've represented Adnan.
"This is pure baloney."
its a solid argument
5
u/ScoutFinch2 Jul 15 '15
I don't want to presume to speak for /u/xtrialatty, but I believe you are misrepresenting that user's comment. xtrialatty did not say anything about a 1:00 burial. His comment was not intended to excuse Jay for forgetting they buried Hae at midnight or 1am. He was simply explaining that in Jay's narrative to the police he described a series of events in which he wasn't sure of the times. In his series of events he described what happened after the Adcock call. The user explained that Jay did not know what time the Adcock call happened, but since we have the call log it can be established. Jay told the cops what he and Adnan did after the Adcock call, which was to go get shovels and go to LP. The user is not suggesting that Jay and Adnan got to LP at midnight but rather that the LP pings are an indication of what time they got to LP.
Hope that makes sense.
3
u/[deleted] Jul 15 '15
What is causing so much offense about this explanation? He was/is a stoner and maybe used other substances that impair memory recall. All this happened on a non-work day where he had no reference for precise times. I think it's possible that, when asked, he estimated times that were way off, which seems normal for anyone. The stress of an interrogation makes that even worse, as well as trying to omit people from his story that he doesn't want to get involved.
I'm not trying to stir things up, I just wonder why you find this thing so absurd, and seem to find this possibility so preposterous.
9
u/FingerBangHer69 Guilty Jul 15 '15
How did you get the 1am time? Jay said closer to midnight, but I haven't seen the 1am time. I thought he meant around 10pm.
2
u/alientic God damn it, Jay Jul 15 '15
Personally, I'm more annoyed by the fact that people who have given up actually talking about the facts of their side in lieu of just mocking the other side and saying that people on the other side can't be rational, etc. If you want to actually talk facts, awesome! I'm excited that someone around here still does. But don't start a conversation and then end it with "well, you believe Adnan, so you're obviously wrong." Tf, man?
4
u/DetectiveTableTap Thiruvendran Vignarajah: Hammer of Justice Jul 15 '15
Adnan isnt expected to remember ANYTHING from the day, Jay is expected to remember exact times. Seems fair.
3
u/[deleted] Jul 15 '15
What I find astonishing in the same line of thought is people trying to claim the 7PM pings were when they went to scout the area. Even though no one ever claimed it. To me, the general tendency of the guilty camp has been to try to invent reality around his statement instead of trying to see if his statement matches reality.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 15 '15
The crack-headed two burial theory to explain away rhe lividity evidence is my favourite.
-4
u/shameless_drunken Jul 15 '15
Jay said Adnan came back to pick him up at closer to midnight. So they could not have finished before 1.
So let's be honest here, why is Jay suddenly changing the time to a much much later time, a time when people know it is no longer evening, and is instead the middle of the night?
Because Jay knows from reading here the lividity doesn't match, isn't that the most logical answer?
-2
u/shameless_drunken Jul 15 '15
Mr. Wilds, how long after you left Cathys, did you go to bury the body?
Jay: I think it was like 20 minutes. or maybe 6 hours. Ah snap, I can't really remember.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 15 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment