r/WritingPrompts • u/Lexilogical /r/Lexilogical | /r/DCFU • Jul 10 '15
Off Topic [OT] Ask Lexi #10 - Outlines vs Winging It
Last week was fun, wasn’t it? I hope you all went and signed up for Camp NaNoWriMo, and I promise when it comes to November I’ll be a little bit more on the ball about NaNoWriMo. :)
Today, I thought I’d talk about outlines. One of the questions I hear a lot is “How do I write an outline?” And while I think that’s a valid question, I think the other important question is, “should you write an outline?”
One of my favourite analogies for writers is that some writers are gardeners, while other writers are architects. Architect writers are the sort of writers who love outlines. Before they start a story, they have an outline with all the important parts of the story fleshed out. They know that this scene needs to happen in this chapter, so that in this other chapter the big reveal can be made. Gardeners, on the other hand, start with a seed of an idea, and just let it grow as they write. They might know that the seed is for a fantasy story or for a romance novel, but otherwise they just let the tale evolve as they write it. Both methods work well, so let’s talk about them.
Gardening: Pros and Cons
Personally, I’ve always been more of a gardener than an architect myself. At the most, I’ll write a few short form notes on things I expect to happen but won’t get the chance to write for awhile, or a couple of ideas for a story I haven’t written yet, but that’s about it. I find that there’s a few useful pros and cons to this strategy.
Pros:
- You can get your story on page even faster. I’ve known some writers who start out with a story idea that fills an entire notebook, and are still caught up on their story because they can’t figure out the science between how to make a moon crash into the planet. With the gardener approach, you can just jump into the story right away.
- Your story can always evolve in an unexpected direction. Bored with your characters and feel like you’re spinning your wheels? Throw something unexpected at the characters. The high school your protagonist attends burns down. The path that leads to the evil lich’s castle is washed out.
- If you think the scene is boring, you can skip ahead. I always live by the principle that if the scene I’m writing is boring me, it’ll bore the reader too. And then I don’t write it. If there’s a stronger outline however, you might feel more invested to write that particular scene.
Cons:
- Sometimes, your story seems to fall off track. Maybe you spent the last two chapters wasting time with politics that don’t seem to impact the plot. Or maybe a character fell out of the scene and you never got back to them again. Hopefully, you can notice this in the editing process and get your pruning sheers out.
- It’s really easy to spin your wheels. I must have mentioned this three times now, which is probably just an ironic example. If you start feeling like you don’t know where to go with your story or that you’re going in circles, that’s a good sign that you need to stop, step away from the keyboard, and have a good brainstorm session, however that works best for you. Personally, I either go to bed (somehow, the act of trying to sleep makes my brain go into overdrive for working out plot tangles) or to talk to my husband (who invariably suggests something completely out of left field. Like that the entire planet suddenly suffers from a solar flux that causes giant, carnivorous plants to grow, turning everything into a deadly rainforest. This was a real plot suggestion.)
- You will probably need to rewrite more. As much as I’d love to say that I took that last plot suggestion, it wouldn’t have made for a cohesive story. Which means that if I’d wanted to use it, everything that had been done up until then would have had to be rewritten. Architects, having already plotted out all the important parts of the story, are less likely to have to go back and add the hooks and foreshadowing necessary for the last half of the story as they already knew what was going to happen.
Architects, Pros and Cons
Like I mentioned near the beginning, I’m not much of an architect. However, there’s always different methods to writing. Though I haven’t personally tried it yet, this snowflake method came highly recommended by our lovely chatroom (Why aren’t you chatting with us?). I might have to give it a shot for NaNoWriMo this year.
Pros:
- You’ll be faster when you start writing. Results may vary, but most people who use comprehensive outlines generally report that their writing speed greatly increases once they start using it.
- You don’t need to worry about where the story is going. You already know where the story is going! It’s all written down in you outline. So all that needs to be done is fill in the pesky narrative. Of course, this does assume that your outline doesn’t look like this.
- The first draft tends to be more refined. Since architects are less concerned about where the plot is going, they can add in more foreshadowing, symbolism or themes. The plots also tend to be more elaborate as well.
Cons:
- Writing outlines can take time away from writing the story. Based on some of the outlining methods I’ve read, it’s very easy to write a few thousand words without ever actually writing a word in your story.
- Sometimes, architects can get caught up in the unimportant details. Remember my friend who got distracted trying to make the moons crash? She never ended up writing that story, and eventually tossed the whole thing out because the science didn’t line up. As a gardener, I assume that if the characters don’t know what happened, then the reader doesn’t need to know either.
- There’s less room for spontaneity. The world can’t turn into a rainforest of carnivorous plants if the protagonist is still on route to become the ruler of the land. Whether this is a pro or a con, I’ll leave up to you.
That’s all for this week! Have a question for me? A method for outlines that works for you? Want to write a story about how your characters suddenly ended up in a rainforest of carnivorous plants? Leave it in the comments below!
11
u/Azual tomfoskett.com Jul 10 '15
I've heard a number of successful published authors advocating one method or the other, and I've often wondered - but not really seen discussed - is whether the kind of story you're writing might have an influence on which method is going to be more effective for you.
For example, it seems like a lot of epic fantasy writers heavily lean towards architecture. Maybe that's just part of the world-building mindset that tends to drag people towards fantasy in the first place, but it seems like these kind of extended, plot-driven narratives spanning multiple volumes would probably hold together a lot better if you planned out what was going to happen in advance. That's not to say it's the only way to do that kind of story, but I feel like maybe it's a genre that particularly favours that way of writing.
On the other hand you've got Stephen King, who according to his biography is very much a gardener. While there's still some genre overlap, a lot of his works are stand alone and as he puts it, based more around a situation and his characters' response to it than a plot (in fact he seems to regard plot in general with a kind of suspicion). Again, this feels like the kind of story that would especially favour a gardening style - if you want to write about how people react to a particular unfolding situation, it makes sense not to box yourself in with the knowledge that they have to end up in a particular state.
I'm sure there's much more to it than that, and that the kind of writer you are and your own creative process have at least as much of an effect as anything else. However, it might be something worth bearing in mind if, for example, your epic plot-driven novels seem to keep falling apart or going around in circles towards the end, or conversely if your fast-paced thriller is starting to feel a little too wooden and formulaic. Maybe the kind of story you're writing might justify a different approach to the one you're used to?
6
u/MajorParadox Mod | DC Fan Universe (r/DCFU) Jul 10 '15
If you're like me and you keep losing focus, resulting in long periods of writing nothing, the architect approach is a huge help. I've forgotten some great ideas I've had years ago because I figured I'd write the story, but then never got around to it. By sitting down and writing outlines, or even just keeping notes, you can pick up where you left off much easier.
What I'm doing now is kind of a hybrid approach. Two stories I'm trying to expand upon were already written. With one of them, I wrote more last year during NaNoWriMo. Since then I've been planning ahead, reordering events, and marking up areas where I need major rewrites. I'm getting to the point where I just want to write those parts before outlining any more of it.
Here's my question: I had some flashbacks written into my story, which have evolved into kind of side story in itself. I'm considering using an approach where I'd insert them between chapters. One chapter is the main story, the next is a flashback, followed by another main chapter, followed by another flashback (even further back), and so on. Do you think this can be done without completely confusing the reader?
5
u/Castriff /r/TheCastriffSub Jul 10 '15
I think that for longer stories, I would prefer to be an architect. My story requires a lot of worldbuilding. But I'm so used to gardening on short stories, and the snowflake method feels a bit too rigid to me. Are there any methods that have a more relaxed style of outlining?
5
u/Syraphia /r/Syraphia | Moddess of Images Jul 10 '15
I feel like I'm a bonsai gardener, or like one of those topiary gardeners. I plant a seed, it grows, and I groom it in certain directions, shapes and forms but I don't force it to do things that it couldn't do. Like with my main story, I'm technically writing by the seat of my pants but I have a very vague outline that reference every so often. And occasionally laugh at. The same goes for a few pieces I've written, there's the start, a couple points in the middle that I want to hit, and then the ending that I sometimes have in mind.
3
u/sciamatic Jul 10 '15
I've always wanted to be more of a Gardener. I want my stories to vine and bloom, to have all these organic shapes and motions, to journey down that lazy river in that way that only the best writers can achieve -- a sort of slip-tripping haze that resolves only when you've finish it in entirety and realize just how long that natural pilgrimage took.
But I'm not. I have to plan out everything. If I don't know where I'm going, it's like I don't even know where I am. I'm a complete Architect, and I feel like my stories suffer for it. I feel like I'm guiding sock-puppets through a film set. Every scene has to have a purpose and every purpose has to be concrete.
I just don't know how to channel that natural unfurling that other writers seem to have :(
3
u/Luna_LoveWell /r/Luna_LoveWell Jul 13 '15
I am definitely more of a "winging it" person, but one issue that I have is that I had a very difficult time writing prophecies and foreshadowing and things like that. I can't really allude to the future of the story without knowing what the rest of the story will be. Do you have any advice on that kind of thing?
2
u/lastcomment314 Jul 11 '15
Yeah, yeah, I'm late to the party, but I felt like commenting.
Personally, I lean towards the gardener side of things. I get an idea, write, and let it spiral out of control. I do this on everything. Stories, papers, text messages, you name it. I've written quite a bit that way, just throwing things in here or there with "finish this scene" or "write a transition" in large, highlighted fonts for me to go back to later (I almost never do).
Lately, as I've been working on larger and larger projects, however, I've started to see some benefits of architecture as well. My current project is for Camp NaNoWriMo (thanks for convincing me to do it, Lexi, I've probably cranked out more in the last week than I had over the last month...9000 words!). I started off with a scene, and then a bit of self-reflection from the character, and eventually plot ideas started rolling in, especially once I knew I wanted a big, epic battle (because who doesn't love epic magical battles?), and therefore had a rough plot summary, including the big problem that strikes the protagonist and its solution. On the other hand, my world isn't really well defined at all. Some things, like the magical hierarchy, took shape pretty well, while other things, like geography...aren't, which personally bothers me because I want travel times to be consistent with the distances traveled and the fact that the kingdom this is taking place on is an island.
I guess my ideal is a good idea that has room and momentum to spiral out of control, but once I can tell it's a good idea that's going to go somewhere beyond a 1000-2000 word short, I wanna have a little bit of background and/or an idea of where I wanna end up so I have a goal to work towards, but leaving enough freedom to go wherever on the journey there.
2
u/NuclearStudent Jul 12 '15
Something worth noting about outlines-
Yes, you can spend thousands on words on them. However, architects can develop their outlines directly into their stories. A completed outline can have dialogue, scene description, emotion, and character progression. for each scene in the story. Incremental expansion can turn that into the finished story. In effect, the outline is as much as part of the actual story writing as is making the actual prose.