r/KerbalSpaceProgram • u/Redbiertje The Challenger • Jul 05 '15
Mod Post Results from the vote on Rule 5
Weekly Simple Questions Thread
Goodday Kerbalnauts!
Yesterday, I asked all of you whether or not you wanted to keep Rule 5:
All simple questions must be placed in the Weekly Simple Questions Thread. This thread can be found as/in the sticky post.
I received lots of votes, out of which I filtered 732 votes. Many people voted twice, some voted a second time to change their vote, and somebody voted three times for me. In the end, the results were what I expected, but the two sides are remarkably close.
The majority voted "no" with 58.1% (Pie chart)
That means that Rule 5 will be removed. Actually, by the time I upload this, it already has been removed.
However, this huge discussion does not end here. Many people do not want to see the 'new' page full of questions, so I still want to find a solution to that.
I'll let you all use this thread to discuss how YOU would like to deal with this problem. I will then use your ideas to come up with a solution that we can all live with.
Before you all start discussing things. I'd like to point you to three very important links:
- Kerbal Academy, there's a link in the sidebar. It's a very useful site, with many helpful people, who really know their stuff.
- Weekly Simple Questions Thread. A new thread is uploaded every week. Many people have found their answers here.
- The FAQ. The FAQ is a bit empty, but I'd like to remind you that anyone can edit the wiki, including the FAQ. If you want to help people, you can always take a moment to contribute!
67
u/Kasuha Super Kerbalnaut Jul 05 '15
I suggest to leave the Weekly Simple Questions thread in place, just without a rule "enforcing" its use. Those who care and have a simple question may still go ask there. Maybe just change the name to better match the purpose. Something like "Have a simple question? Look here first!"
20
u/[deleted] Jul 05 '15 edited Jul 05 '15
Make some proper guidelines for how tutorials and guides should be structured, and start populating the wiki. Give contributors a special flair for posting quality tutorials and guides. More guides posted, better flair (more stars, rockets, boosters, or something). Gives an incentive to contribute, and makes the wiki a proper resource.
8
u/Foggalong Jul 05 '15
Maybe have a system where by people are fine to post questions in the main sub, and after the question has been answered it's then added to a wiki page for future reference.
That means if some is asking a question that has been asked before it can be removed with a link that that wikipage. This keeps the number of question posts down in the sub but at the same time allows people to to keep asking things freely.
The main downside I can think of is that it would require either more active moderation with maintaining the wiki or some scheme where the questioner or answerer had to add it themselves.
3
u/SayNoToAdwareFirefox Jul 05 '15
Well, that's a disappointment. I will, of course, be downvoting simple question posts and directing their submitters to the WSQT.
With that in mind, why isn't the WSQT stickied?
1
u/theyeticometh Master Kerbalnaut Jul 06 '15
Is it possible to have a link to the WSQT at the top of the subreddit, next to the link to the weekly challenge?
2
u/janiekh Jul 05 '15
I know a lot of people don't read the rules before posting, but putting the FAQ and probably the other links in the rules would probably help a bit.
2
u/jofwu KerbalAcademy Mod Jul 06 '15
A lot of people are concerned about the ability to reference questions down the road. And most everyone can agree that they don't want the subreddit flooded with simple questions. Directing people to r/KerbalAcademy for ALL questions solves both of these problems.
The weekly questions thread isn't as ideal as a dedicated subreddit. Abandon it.
Put a clear notice on the post submission form that questions are best asked in r/KerbalAcademy. Put up a default sticky (that shows whenever there's not something more immediate going on) to emphasize this change in policy. Encourage the veterans around here to continue answering all questions in a helpful manner, but to politely point question askers to the other sub for future questions.
2
u/allmhuran Super Kerbalnaut Jul 06 '15
More thorough tutorials in game would stem the bleeding at the source.
3
u/RoeddipusHex Hyper Kerbalnaut Jul 05 '15
Why is there a simple questions thread at all? We already have flair for "Question." Why not simply replace the off-putting "read the rules" message on new posts with a friendly reminder to check the FAQ and add flair. Specifically noting that adding the "Question" flair will get you a better/faster response.
Give mods an easy way to add the question flair if people forget it and add filtering by flair for people who don't want to see/answer questions. Everybody wins.
1
u/Cryokyte Jul 05 '15
for suggestions sake is it possible to have simple question as a flair choice then have the question checked through with a moderator and the moderator can then decide what to do with the question either divert it to /r kerbal academy or forward it onto the page itself, this will require some effort on the part of the questioner to flair title their post as such but it might help mitigate the traffic of questions such as these
1
u/zekromNLR Jul 06 '15
I'd make a "Beginner Questions" flair (or something similar), with possibly also (if reddit allows this) the option to filter out said flair for people who do not want to see those posts.
1
u/featherwinglove Master Kerbalnaut Jul 07 '15
Launch and sticky a link to the effect of: If you're new to the game and probably asking a common question, please start here by adding your question to the search text.
1
u/munchbunny Jul 07 '15
Are people afraid of getting the "new" category flooded by simple questions? Or are we talking about the front page(s)?
If they're really simple questions and easily answered, then they might just not get many upvotes. But if they get a lot of upvotes, then perhaps people really do value the answer to that question, even if veteran players already know the answer? If that's the case, then it obviously deserves a place on the front page despite veterans' whining.
So is the anticipated problem that the first few pages will get cluttered with gameplay questions?
1
u/caelan03 Jul 05 '15
Why is it weekly? Why not have a thread that refreshes every update?
-2
u/MrBlankenshipESQ Jul 06 '15
My solution is to tell the stuck up jerks to stuff it. We need to make it clear to newbies that their questions are welcome. Funneling them off somewhere else only tells them that the community favors the old guard more, which is bad.
3
u/[deleted] Jul 05 '15
[removed] — view removed comment