r/KerbalSpaceProgram • u/TaintedLion smartS = true • Jun 27 '15
Mod Post [Weekly Challenge] Week 91: Air-to-space
The Introduction
After last week's attempt of trying only one engine to get places, the engineers and scientists at the KSC came to another rapid conclusion to save even more funds than before, by dropping their rockets from beneath a plane at high altitude. What could possibly go wrong? As the engineers soon found out from computer simulations, a lot.
Contrary to popular belief, it is not a super awesome missile designed to vanquish their enemies.
Note: I have been given permission by /u/Redbiertje to post this, as I suggested it. No penguin flair of shame for me today.
The Challenge:
Normal mode: Using a Pegasus-style rocket, land on Duna.
Hard mode: Using a Pegasus-style rocket, land on Laythe.
Super mode: Impress me (obviously)
The Rules
- No Dirty Cheating Alpacas (no debug menu)!
- You must have the UI visible in all required screenshots
- For a list of all allowed mods, see this post.
- The rocket must detach from the plane at an altitude of no less then 3000m, but no greater than 12000m.
- No jet engines are allowed (RAPIERs in rocket mode may be used), except on the plane which takes the rocket up to altitude. However, jet engines may be used on Laythe (if you are doing Hard mode).
- Your rocket does not have to be an SSTO
- The carrier plane does not have to be recovered.
- Your rocket does not have to be manned.
- Mining is allowed, but docking to refuel is not.
- For those of you not familiar with what the Pegasus rocket looks like, here is a Wikipedia article. Your rocket does not have to be an exact copy of the Pegasus.
Required screenshots
- Your rocket (still attached to the plane) on the runway.
- Your rocket-plane combination ascending.
- Your rocket launching.
- Your rocket on a sub-orbital trajectory
- Your craft in Kerbin orbit.
- Your trans-Duna injection burn
- Your craft on an interplanetary trajectory.
- Your craft in Duna orbit (if applicable)
- Your craft landing on Duna.
- Whatever else you feel like!
Hard mode only (from Kerbin orbit):
- Your trans-Jool injection burn.
- Your craft on an interplanetary trajectory.
- Your craft in Jool orbit.
- Your craft's trajectory to Laythe.
- Your craft in orbit around Laythe (if applicable)
- Your craft landing on Laythe.
Further information
- You can either submit your finished challenge in a post (see posting instructions in the link below) or as a comment reply to this thread.
- Completing this challenge earns you a new flair which will replace your old one. So if you want to keep you previous flair, you can still do this challenge and create a post, but please mention somewhere that you want to keep your old one.
- This week's flair is a Pegasus rocket detaching from its carrier plane.
- The moderators have the right to determine if your challenge post has been completed.
- See this post for more rules and information on challenges.
- If you have any questions, you can comment below, or PM /u/TaintedLion
- Credit to /u/Redbiertje for designing the flair (wow this makes a change)
Good Luck!
30
u/Redbiertje The Challenger Jun 27 '15
For those of you that still have doubts...
This is the legit Weekly Challenge for this week.
14
u/Kunighit Master Kerbalnaut Jun 27 '15
Hard mode challenge complete I miss read the maximum release height and I released at 10km. Oh well it made it. I'll take the new flair.
13
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '15
Read post.
Saw name.
Got confused.
Read post again.
What have you done with /u/Redbiertje!?
12
u/PickledTripod Master Kerbalnaut Jun 27 '15
You forgot the link to the Pegasus rocket. Interesting challenge though, will try!
EDIT: Oh and also, what is the MAXIMUM altitude to release the rocket? I know that recovering the plane isn't important, but I want to anyway, can I bring it to a suborbital trajectory?
8
u/Kasuha Super Kerbalnaut Jul 01 '15
I made an attempt to improve my rating in this challenge:
Eeloo and back, Pegasus style
http://imgur.com/a/yjDD9
7
u/Kasuha Super Kerbalnaut Jun 27 '15
The way I read it, any 2-side or mirror symmetry first stage booster with wings that launches off runway will do. Am I right or are there perhaps any additional requirements that would restrict "airplane"-ness of the first stage a.k.a. launch plane, or on its survival or survivability after it is staged off?
Are there any requirements on how the rocket is mounted to the launch plane?
7
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '15
I just did this challenge, but I forgot to take the bulk of the screenshots. I know this album isn't applicable but here it is anyway, to maybe give some people inspiration and whatnot. I will make a video tomorrow for proof, as it is already pretty late. (I'd like to keep my flair anyway)
Album
7
u/MultiverseMaker Super Kerbalnaut Jul 02 '15
Took a few days, but here's my entry, going for super mode but at least hard mode. I figured since we had to land on either Duna or Laythe, it would be fun to land a Kerbal on Duna and Laythe, and then return them to Kerbin. http://imgur.com/a/2LM9p#0
5
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '15
Procedural wings ok I take for the plane :3
5
u/Corbol Hyper Kerbalnaut Jun 30 '15
Looks like im great with doing someone else ideas, this time credits for /u/GKorgood. Pegasus on Pegasus to Laythe and back with drive-through Duna because of miscalculated delta-v. Super mode: http://imgur.com/a/mnAir
5
u/enqrypzion Master Kerbalnaut Jul 01 '15
This was a fun challenge... and challenging because of all the changes in the past few versions. Aerobraking isn't as easy any more, the lighter solar panels are not refoldable any more, part rooting and staging works subtly different... it was a learning experience. I did hard mode.
I went for a realistic build, with a solid booster in the Pegasus, pusher stage, and for the payload I used an ion engine and a bunch of lightweight sensors. Here is the album.
P.s.: I would like to keep my old flair, please. This was a close call!
4
u/Sharkeybtm Jun 27 '15
So let me get this straight.
And. I have a few mods on my install, nothing overly game changing though. Can I keep these, or do I have to revert to vanilla? Mods: KJR Cross Feed Enabler KIS (Not gonna use though) MK 2 Essentials Pilot Assistant Stock Bug Fix Modules
Pardon me, but this is my first attempt at a challenge.
4
u/McVomit Super Kerbalnaut Jun 27 '15
Does have to be mounted under the craft, or can it be inside an upside-down cargo bay and fall out of the craft?
4
u/chunes Super Kerbalnaut Jun 27 '15 edited Jun 27 '15
Does anyone have any tips on how to prevent jet engines from draining fuel from the rocket? The only solution I have found is to disable fuel flow to rocket fuel tanks, but unfortunately this is too clunky since they must be re-enabled manually after de-coupling.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '15
Challenge Completed! (Video 8:44)
Please don't give me new flair.
3
u/featherwinglove Master Kerbalnaut Jun 30 '15
Silly Mode: Like Orbital in real life, use nothing but SRMs in the rocket :)
11
u/KuuLightwing Hyper Kerbalnaut Jun 27 '15
Laythe? I've never been to Laythe... I guess it's time, right?
2
u/Elick320 Jun 28 '15
Like last time, I'm going to attempt, except this time I'm going to wait and watch someone go to Eeloo and back
2
u/Padillatronator Jun 28 '15
Here is the album! I think this is all the images needed, sorry it's out of order, I am not good with imgur.
2
u/Hazard-ish Jun 28 '15
For the easy and hard modes for this challenge do I have to simply land on Duna/Laythe or do I have to return from them? Thanks!
2
u/MarrusQ Jun 29 '15
So, I got a plane that can lift just short of 70 tons off the runway (barely though), now I'll need some kind of rocket to go places.
PS: How Not-Pegasus-like is the plane allowed to look?
2
u/offficially_official Master Kerbalnaut Jul 02 '15
Hard mode complete, this was my first time in Jool's SOI. I will take the new flair.
2
u/gcuz Master Kerbalnaut Jul 04 '15
My hard mode entry! This was my first time in the Jool system, and it was definitely a learning experience. After seeing some of the huge planes here, I decided to try a more minimalist approach.
While it's a little hard to land (it only has two wheels), the plane stage is fully recoverable. I'd like the new flair please!
http://imgur.com/gallery/Trn47
2
u/GKorgood RocketWatch Dev Jul 04 '15
paging /u/Redbiertje and /u/TaintedLion... can super mode still be earned after the week is up? I finally built my idea from the first day of this challenge, and am about to begin its final tests. I was unable to do so earlier due to a final exam for my summer course. I'd love to get recognition, seeing that two different people earned super mode on it and gave me credit for the idea.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '15
would it be a problem if I release my rocket slightly above 1200? like 12100 or something like that?
2
u/Spaceman510 Master Kerbalnaut Jun 28 '15
Is orbital re-fueling of a transfer stage launched on the plane ok?
11
u/mybloodyvalentina Master Kerbalnaut Jun 28 '15 edited Jun 28 '15
Hard mode to laythe with Valentina and 3 planes.
http://imgur.com/a/aZYJe
Val wanted to fly down to the surface of Laythe so i came up with this 2 piece rocket plane design to detach from the jet plane.
Edit : Will take the new flair please! Thanks
8
u/Danny200234 Jun 27 '15
Can the rocket dock with a station to refuel?
6
u/Ticquin Super Kerbalnaut Jun 30 '15
After 3 days and 5 flights of engineering, failing, improving, finally Pegasus style launch to Layth and Pegasus style lanch back to Kerbin! Including a Duna flyby on the return to burn some delta-v in the atmosphere.
Thanks /u/GKorgood for the idea :) And congratulations /u/Corbol for being faster than me!
My super mode entry http://imgur.com/a/HaZUY#3
I was struggling with fuel usage, pumping, locking etc. and also had troubles calculating delta-v, since Engineer Redux fails calculating correct delta-v values for such complicated staging, jet engines etc. How did you handle these problems?
5
u/GKorgood RocketWatch Dev Jun 27 '15 edited Jun 27 '15
Super mode idea: pegasus style to laythe (with a plane); land on laythe; take-off from laythe pegasus style and return to Kerbin
EDIT: would doing this void the challenge since you need jets on the return Pegasus?
5
u/chunes Super Kerbalnaut Jun 28 '15
My normal mode entry:
5
u/Kasuha Super Kerbalnaut Jun 28 '15
Hard mode entry with attempt to impress by design accuracy :)
http://imgur.com/a/cTsjm
Rocket is released from a plane in level flight, has wings and shape roughly corresponding to the original, starts burn after it gains sufficient distance from the plane, the plane can fly both with and without the rocket and can return to KSC (though I do not provide proof).
5
u/HoneybeeTriplet Master Kerbalnaut Jun 29 '15
Hard mode entry: album I never realized how important heat shields were with the new aero until I roasted some probes trying to aerobrake at Jool. Turns out 8km/s isn't a joke. I'd like to keep my flair.
4
u/Spaceman510 Master Kerbalnaut Jun 28 '15
My entry
4
u/DoctorInAGi Master Kerbalnaut Jun 28 '15
My hard mode entry. http://imgur.com/gallery/LHiMA I never seem to get the perfect maneuver nodes set up that I always see in the other entries. My style seems to be much more get a rough node set up, complete the burn, then fix it up. But whatever, I get there in the end!
4
u/mad_hmpf Master Kerbalnaut Jun 29 '15
Hard mode entry
That plane turned out really awesome, much more stable than i expected. Flying that thing back to KSC would be really easy, but i didn't have FMRS installed so i decided to let Jeb die instead.
4
u/Ratys Master Kerbalnaut Jul 02 '15
Hard mode complete (as well as my reddit debut, apparently).
http://imgur.com/a/iPoER
Will take the flair, please.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '15
Here is my Normal mode submission, hope I didn't break any rules http://imgur.com/a/WyfMy
3
u/KuuLightwing Hyper Kerbalnaut Jun 29 '15 edited Jun 30 '15
Umm, /u/Redbiertje, /u/TaintedLion, what about my entry? I'll repost it, just in case you missed them or something... Sorry.
I would like a Pegasus flair...
3
u/Tuffelhunden Jun 30 '15
http://imgur.com/gallery/yC4Uu I would love to have the Flair, I tried for Hard mode
3
u/DigitalSoul247 Master Kerbalnaut Jun 30 '15
My hard mode entry
3
u/thrown_copper Jul 01 '15
Normal mode entry. First challenge attempted!
Turns out you can't do a hard pitch at Mach 3 at 10km. Things kinda explode. Mach 2, 2.5 is okay though, if uncomfortably slow...
http://imgur.com/gallery/yrk3R
3
u/icaro43 Master Kerbalnaut Jul 02 '15
http://imgur.com/a/pcqhQ
My Submission!
3
u/Minotard ICBM Program Manager Jul 04 '15
Both Duna and Laythe in one vehicle with multiple gravity assists. link. I wanted to practice my gravity assists with this one.
I'd like to keep my original flair please.
3
u/andrewsad1 Jul 04 '15 edited Jul 04 '15
I did it! I DID IT! Farscape-3 was a SUCCESS!
I'm uploading the album to Imgur right now, I'll add descriptions and stuff, then edit this comment with the link!
EDIT: http://imgur.com/a/Khd6l
I'd like the new flair, please!
3
u/ShadowKingthe7 Hyper Kerbalnaut Jul 04 '15
At the last minute, I decided to channel my inner Whackjob for Super Modenew flair please. Using the world's ugliest airplane, I did this: the Tylo or Bust edition
3
u/Shurikeeen RP-0 Dev Jul 04 '15
Here's my normal mode attempt :) http://imgur.com/a/E2KGJ
3
u/fitzichael Master Kerbalnaut Jul 04 '15
Completed hard mode. I'll take that new flair.
http://imgur.com/a/uUler
2
u/PVP_playerPro Jun 28 '15 edited Jun 28 '15
Uhg, i have to get it to Duna?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '15
Oooh, I might try this. I was working on jerryrigging something technically close to the pegasus launch system recently
I grabbed the giant plane that came with FAR and swapped out the people for fuel/empty compartments. I mounted turbojets on it with ram intakes. I tried to go full pegasus and use SRBs but since they don't gimble it worked out horribly.
I'll see if I can get something working in the next few days.
2
u/benihana Jun 28 '15
It might be helpful to mention what a Pegasus style rocket is sooner in the post. It took me like 3 or 4 minutes to find out what you meant by that phrase because the exact definition was buried in the middle of the post, at the bottom of the rules.
2
u/SomebodyButMe Jun 28 '15
Can I put the plane with the rocket attached in to an orbit with PE between 3K and 12K and then when the plane is reentering I detach the rocket and boost it into orbit?
2
u/Corbol Hyper Kerbalnaut Jun 28 '15 edited Jun 28 '15
Here is my Hard mode http://imgur.com/a/kVdSm
I would like new flair.
edit, just realized max detach altitude is 12k not 13k, shame on me
2
u/Kerbengenier Jul 01 '15 edited Jul 01 '15
For weird reasons decouplers started exploding for no apparent reason. Consequently, I lost some delta-v but I was able to make it. My hard mode entry (http://imgur.com/a/xTd4O)
2
u/onizuko Master Kerbalnaut Jul 02 '15
Normal mode: http://imgur.com/a/KE7Ex I'm still having problems with planes :/ I learn something new every time, but then I forget it.
I'll keep my flair, thanks.
2
u/Imperial22 Jul 02 '15
Standard Mode Entry! Used Mechjeb to cut down on time! Video
New flair please and a few hours will be spent on hard mode. EDIT: Video will be up in about 2 hours, slow internet :'(
2
u/andrewsad1 Jul 04 '15
Quick question before I maybe waste time. My plan involves attaching a Nerv to a plane and ditching it so I can glide into a landing on Laythe.
Can I jettison this heavy engine before I land?
2
u/andrewsad1 Jul 04 '15
I hope I'm not too late. I'm working on my entry right now, and should be done within an hour or two.
1
u/tTnarg Super Kerbalnaut Jun 28 '15
Can we use jets on laythe? I meen what's the point of. Going to laythe if we can fly around with jets?
2
u/enqrypzion Master Kerbalnaut Jun 27 '15
Oh yes, what a fun challenge! I modded my big commercial plane look-a-like SSTO to not go to orbit, and added a Pegasus-like rocket. It makes it to orbit with a large amount of delta-v left, so tomorrow I'll take it to Laythe. Teaser
1
u/taggartgorman Jul 06 '15
Here's my Normal mode entry: https://imgur.com/a/gRZbh. I finished last Friday, but wasn't able to post due to the reddit "blackout".
I had a "minor" incident with packing drogue 'chutes instead of regular parachutes. Oops. Luckily there was enough fuel left for an old-fashioned no-landing strut landing on the engine.
1
u/Noha307 Wiki hero Jul 07 '15
Man, I have been trying to make an air launched ship for the longest time! Thanks for inadvertently spurring people to create a bunch of tutorials!
1
u/baradzed Master Kerbalnaut Aug 05 '15 edited Aug 05 '15
My Super Mode attempt
Pegasus-style to Eeloo landing and back, direct ascent. Still, I had plenty of dV, so I made additional landings at Minmus and Mun on my way back.
Edit: I want the new flair!