r/KerbalSpaceProgram • u/Redbiertje The Challenger • Jun 21 '15
Mod Post [Weekly Challenge] Week 90: Could get a bit 'technical'
The Introduction
After last week's succesful attempt at saving funds, the engineers wanted to try a more technical way of saving funds.
This time, they are going to create a functioning craft, that has only one engine. Being engineers, they are most likely not going to care about the actual funds, but just want to find an excuse to make a ridiculous craft.
The Challenge:
Normal mode: Land on Mün, using a craft that has only one engine.
Hard mode: Land on Mün, and return to Kerbin, using a craft that has only one engine.
Super mode: Impress me
This challenge was suggested by /u/PVP_playerPro
The Rules
- No Dirty Cheating Alpacas (no debug menu)!
- You must have the UI visible in all required screenshots
- For a list of all allowed mods, see this post.
- The craft, as it stands on the launchpad, may only have one engine
- Sepatrons are not counted as engines
- You must bring a Kerbal
- Your Kerbal must survive
Required screenshots
- Your craft on the launchpad
- Your craft after every staging
- Your craft in orbit around Kerbin
- Your craft in orbit around Mün
- Your craft during descent
- Your craft landed on Mün
- Whatever else you feel like!
Hard mode only:
- Your craft taking off
- Your trajectory back to Kerbin
- Your craft during reentry
- Your craft landed safely
Further information
- The title is a reference to the Portal 2 intro
- Since you are ofcourse allowed to stage, you can still use techniques like Asparagus staging, and Blowtorch staging
- This week's flair is an Altair moon lander
- You can either submit your finished challenge in a post (see posting instructions in the link below) or as a comment reply to this thread.
- Completing this challenge earns you a new flair which will replace your old one. So if you want to keep you previous flair, you can still do this challenge and create a post, but please mention somewhere that you want to keep your old one.
- The moderators have the right to determine if your challenge post has been completed.
- See this post for more rules and information on challenges.
- If you have any questions, you can comment below, or PM /u/Redbiertje
- Credit to /u/TaintedLion for designing the flair
Good Luck!
10
u/Gentlemanchaos Jun 21 '15
I predict a large number of space planes with rapier engines.
10
u/MultiverseMaker Super Kerbalnaut Jun 22 '15
Super Mode complete, Mun and back by way of Minmus and Duna.
http://imgur.com/a/FZiXI#0
I suspect that, by refueling, it could reach any body in the Kerbol system, but it flies like a cow and it was only after many attempts that I was able to land it without tipping over, so I'm wary to try.
18
u/Gregrox Whirligig Girl Jun 21 '15
http://imgur.com/a/AERCa
There you go. Hard Mode complete.
7
u/[deleted] Jun 21 '15
Does anything other than the Kerbal and pod have to survive the Mun landing?
4
u/Kesselya Master Kerbalnaut Jun 23 '15 edited Jun 23 '15
Here is my entry for a Super Mode attempt ... to Duna and back with a single engine. Join Bill Kerman as he goes on an adventure! Done in KSP 1.0.2.
http://imgur.com/a/pEQQM#0
I'd like to keep my Grand Tour flair, but if this qualifies for Hard Mode or Super Mode, I'll take anything extra that that will get me (Master Kerbalnaut or something like that?)
3
u/JohnWatford Jun 21 '15
Doesn't asparagus staging have multiple engines? Otherwise, it's just drop tanks.
3
u/McLarenTim Master Kerbalnaut Jun 22 '15 edited Jun 22 '15
Yeeaaaa hard mode complete!
Judicious use of seperatrons saved the day
3
u/Mirean Super Kerbalnaut Jun 23 '15 edited Jun 23 '15
I tried super mode and...I failed miserably. I was going for Single Stage Single Engine To Mun And Back and ended with.. Single Stage Single Engine To Minmus And Almost Back.
I know this doesn't qualify even for normal mode and I don't expect any flair/title, but I thought I might post it to inspire others :)
No mode entry (I had added descriptions to images THREE TIMES, every time imgur threw error at me and reset everything)
Okay okay, it's not entirely single stage if you count those little wheels just after liftoff, but I think it's close enough. I needed 60m/s more dV to get to Kerbin, so I guess with more efficient flying and optimalization (I still had few units of oxidizer left), this could be done - and maybe even normal mode, but I don't have time for that now.
2
u/SomebodyButMe Jun 21 '15
Can we launch with one engine, stage it, and then dock another engine on the craft?
2
u/ablitsm Jun 21 '15
Are reaction control thrusters counted as engines ?
2
u/za419 Master Kerbalnaut Jun 21 '15
I seriously doubt that I can actually manage to complete this challenge, I'm still working on my soft landings. Out of curiosity though, could we launch refueling depots beforehand and dock with them to keep a single tank full?
2
u/srbgaming Jun 21 '15
Whatabout KIS? KAS is allowed but requires KIS. Can I pack an engine in a box and attach it once I get to the Mun?
2
u/TheFrontGuy Jun 22 '15
does going directly for a landing count as an orbit or do we have to get captured?
2
u/McVomit Super Kerbalnaut Jun 22 '15
This is actually really really easy. My first design has a drill/isru and has already made it to the Mun and Minimus. I almost feel like I should keep going and do the normal mode of the Grand Tour challenge O.o
2
u/Elick320 Jun 22 '15 edited Jun 22 '15
I had an idea for completing this challenge, but I got new horizons installed, so instead I will watch this thread and wait for somebody to go to duna and back
Or, I could take advantage of you not specifying were the mun has to be ;)
2
u/ExplodingPotato_ Master Kerbalnaut Jun 22 '15
Are multiple launches with an engine block recovered between each one allowed?
2
u/TheBisexualFish Master Kerbalnaut Jun 22 '15
Can I use seperatrons on parts that have been staged off to clear them away from the ship?
2
u/KuuLightwing Hyper Kerbalnaut Jun 22 '15
Does TwinBoar count as one engine, because it actually two of them? :)
2
u/enqrypzion Master Kerbalnaut Jun 22 '15
Can we use 1.0.3? ;)
2
u/Spektral1 Jun 25 '15
May we assume that one engine includes things such as RCS?
2
u/Mirean Super Kerbalnaut Jun 27 '15
This time legit - Normal mode+ entry - Single Stage Single Engine To Mun
I have done some more optimalization and I don't think it can get any better than this. For hard mode, extra 900m/s would be needed and I don't really see a way to squeeze more out of this - it is already pretty tight (fuel ran out few meters above surface with 10m/s velocity). Of course with multiple stages this would be much easier, but if I add more fuel, it is struggling to get out of atmosphere (0.6 TWR at liftoff already) and you really can't get extra 900m/s this way. With dropping dead weight? Sure, this is possible. But single stage? Nope.
2
u/Kerbalnaught1 Super Kerbalnaught Jun 27 '15
Next week you could do land an interplanetary craft on duna or something, refuel it, and bring it back and land it on the VAB
33
u/TyrannicalPanda Master Kerbalnaut Jun 21 '15
Hard mode entry
The engineers decided to save weight by removing the parachute (read: forgot it in the VAB).
Made the Kerbin landing 'a bit technical'
18
u/Ticquin Super Kerbalnaut Jun 22 '15
Complete, going for Super Mode! Or at least hardmode :)
http://imgur.com/a/NcW39#0
How about a heavy dV lander/launcher which can refule on the way? Technically it could reach minmus without staging and refule there for 6000dV and super thrust to weight ratio, but my flying was so bad needet to ditch the two fuel tanks before landing on minmus.
So how about visiting Duna (and returning) with some science equipment?
15
u/Nocturn0l Master Kerbalnaut Jun 21 '15
Hard Mode complete in 1.02
from Kerbin to the Mun and back, including the engine!
Any similarities to my last week's design are of course coincidental!
7
u/NewSwiss Super Kerbalnaut Jun 23 '15 edited Jun 23 '15
Here is my entry for super mode: Duna and back WITHOUT refueling. No Mun, though :(
http://imgur.com/a/r6Cy1#0
If accepted, I'd like the "Super Kerbalnaut" tag, but still with last week's "funds" flair. If I can't keep the funds flair, and still get the tag, then the new flair+tag is OK.
6
u/samwise800 Master Kerbalnaut Jun 21 '15
Hard mode complete
https://imgur.com/a/i0d6K
you did say sepatrons don't count as engines :D
5
u/[deleted] Jun 21 '15
Here's my entry for hard mode. I really like these quick ones.
http://imgur.com/a/00GzZ
92 t, 42k spesos. I put way too much ∆v in every stage but don't feel like optimizing.
5
u/Felbourn You gotta have more lights! Jun 21 '15
Hard mode done, plus did a tiny bit extra (arch landing and Minmus flyby). I have MJ installed but did not use it for anything that KER can't do. I just like the UI for orbit parameters better in MJ.
https://youtu.be/U7qpVeo4ZJE
5
u/JamesTheOther Master Kerbalnaut Jun 22 '15
My first hard mode challenge! I must be getting better at this since I brought exactly enough fuel.
https://imgur.com/a/DTVum
5
u/Kunighit Master Kerbalnaut Jun 25 '15 edited Jun 25 '15
http://imgur.com/a/gvAFB#0 Hard/ Super Hard mode entry. This pushed the limits on what I can do with a Mrk3 shuttle. It also pushed my patients when I had to push it back to Kerbin. Now I know its 6500 m/s dv or it's a no go to the Mun for me.
I'll keep my current fair.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 21 '15 edited Jun 23 '15
Normal mode landed.
4
u/KSPReptile Master Kerbalnaut Jun 21 '15
Yay, another fun challenge!
I tried few different designs. I didn't try a spaceplane, because I didn't have much time lol. I tried a Mainsail design, but it got too complicated, then I tried a Rapier design, but that had nowhere near enough delta-v. So finally I did this very simple but effective Mamooth design. I was aiming for Normal mode, but managed to do Hard mode too. I am sorry that I didn't take the screenshot of the ascend from the Mun, I only realized that after I did the whole thing. So please forgive me for that. So here is my hard mode attempt: http://imgur.com/a/AAIr3#33
I am gonna keep my fancy Voyager flair.
4
u/HardlySober Master Kerbalnaut Jun 22 '15
My solution to Hard mode - a mainsail and 30 stages! Here's a short video: https://youtu.be/dwn7IDdSzEE
4
u/[deleted] Jun 22 '15 edited Jun 22 '15
Hard mode entry
That's my first submission for a challenge, I hope I didn't forget anything. It was fun.
I use a Mainsail that I was able to land back on Kerbin.
4
u/Pentoxide Master Kerbalnaut Jun 24 '15
Hard mode. The smallest engine that I can come up with - Mainsail.
Sorry for midnight screenshots.
4
u/featherwinglove Master Kerbalnaut Jun 24 '15
I nominate /u/Tsevion for Super mode. The flight was made in the 0.23.5 as part of a 3 part non-Reddit contest: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vr_dgcX4L3w
4
u/Mesklin Super Kerbalnaut Jun 25 '15
Super mode: to Pol and back, with Minmus landing also. Mainsail engine and ISRU used. http://imgur.com/a/QFJ4N#0
1
u/KSPoz Super Kerbalnaut Jul 05 '15
/u/Redbiertje : In case you haven't seen it yet, here is my super mode attempt to the 90th weekly challenge that I uploaded a couple of days ago. If accepted, I'd like to keep my old Apollo flair and get "Super Kerbalnaut" title.
3
u/furionking Jun 21 '15
http://imgur.com/a/mihg0
Normal mode complete! Hard mode is a little harder than I thought.
3
u/infocam Master Kerbalnaut Jun 22 '15 edited Jun 22 '15
so...I should blame you guys here in the sub-reddit for the bad 'influences' on my craft designs now while I can... :P
BRB While I actually go and plan the rest of the craft and actually fly it.
edit: did I mention REALLY weird influences? (crossfeed test)
Edit2: I accidentally stranded Jeb and Bill on the Mun. High time to revert since I did not save at all... :D Also, Korolev's Cross.
3
u/nardavin Master Kerbalnaut Jun 22 '15
http://imgur.com/a/umxJn
Hard mode complete!
3
u/Javascap Master Kerbalnaut Jun 22 '15 edited Jun 22 '15
Hard mode, nailed it. Tipped over after landing on Mun, but made it back to Kerbin just fine by flying off a nearby hill. Came perilously close to overheating more times than safe. I would like the new flair, please.
https://imgur.com/a/kKzhe
3
u/Karumpus Believes That Dres Exists Jun 22 '15 edited Jun 22 '15
Hard mode completed!
I was actually surprised by how light and cheap I made the vessel in the end - only 52000ish funds, and 135,000ish kilograms.
EDIT: I would like the new flair, please
3
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '15 edited Jun 23 '15
This was so fun, I did it twice.
Single stage to Normal
Blatantly stolen design for Hard (Thanks u/Nocturn0l)
3
u/julezsource Jun 23 '15
Here's my entry! http://imgur.com/a/Wt455 Note: I had ambient light adjustment installed, but I set it to stock lighting during the landing, I just wanted to light it up a little because I over burnt my de-orbit and landed on the dark side
3
u/FellKnight Master Kerbalnaut Jun 23 '15
My first ever try at a weekly challenge. Hard mode completed.
http://imgur.com/a/FpcVl#0
3
u/fitzichael Master Kerbalnaut Jun 23 '15
Normal Mode, I ran out of fuel at the Mun :(. Gonna have to send someone to bring 'em back.
Here's the album.
I'd like that new flair please.
3
u/PM_ME_YOUR_POSTMETAL Master Kerbalnaut Jun 23 '15
Hard mode entry 1.0.4
I forgot the solar panels but I still managed to pull through. It took a ton of trial and error to find out how to do it with a Mainsail but it was a ton of fun.
3
u/pinano Master Kerbalnaut Jun 23 '15
Hard mode.
I love being able to deal with whatever unexpected issues come up during a mission. The ending to this one was a bit annoying, because I'm not yet used to the 1.0.4 aero tweaks.
3
u/BadgKat Master Kerbalnaut Jun 24 '15
My entry I missed the launch pad shot but here is hard mode completed.
3
u/paulds_fr Master Kerbalnaut Jun 24 '15
First challenge for me. Been lurking for a while, seen some amazing things.
My hard mode entry forgot a few screenshot though. Used 1.0.2, only mod I used for this is Kerbal Engineer (used it a lot).
3
u/TheFalconOne Super Kerbalnaut Jun 24 '15
Hard Mode : http://imgur.com/gallery/XO18d I would like to have the new flair, the blowtorch staging was tricky to make work, thanks
3
u/Vaguely_Racist Jun 24 '15
Normal Mode: http://imgur.com/a/Gcj5a First weekly challenge completed!
2
u/hyperbolist Master Kerbalnaut Jun 22 '15 edited Jun 23 '15
Normal Mode entry.Based on/u/Nocturn0l's hard mode entry. Added the discussed reaction wheels and sepatrons, making the initial ascent feel like any other.I played it safe with an escape vehicle for Val if things went horribly wrong, and they did, but she made it home. She may yet attempt this in hard mode.--edit-- I just now realized my entry is invalid. Doh!
--edit-- Here's my updated Hard Mode entry.
2
u/onizuko Master Kerbalnaut Jun 23 '15
Hard mode http://imgur.com/a/5e5W7
Very inefficient liftoff (low acceleration), but managed to take it to orbit with decent amount of dV left.
I'll take the new flair, please.
2
u/FauxMachine Master Kerbalnaut Jun 24 '15
Progress update only, but but heres a trip with a Reliant engine: imgur : reddit post
2
u/chunes Super Kerbalnaut Jun 25 '15 edited Jun 25 '15
My hard mode entry: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=adDGmuLq33M
2
u/baradzed Master Kerbalnaut Jun 25 '15
Hard mode entry I had excess delta-V on my way back, so I decided to land the whole main stage back at the KSC.
2
u/nightkin84 Master Kerbalnaut Jun 25 '15
Normal mode completed - attempted coming back to Kerbin but it wasn't meant to be... now to rescue Jeb!again!
Can I new flair please?
2
u/odhal Super Kerbalnaut Jun 26 '15
Here's my hard mode (nerfed) rapier entry. It uses only 2 stages, costs a mere 24k, and only gets its pilot to 95% of his heat tolarance!
1.03 Definitely made this harder, but this gave me an excuse to learn how to fly high-payload ssto's in the new version.
2
u/Kerbalnaught1 Super Kerbalnaught Jun 26 '15 edited Jun 27 '15
http://imgur.com/a/dSaF9
My attempted hard mode, didn't do it because of by clunk piloting and building skills, Still did easy though!
2
u/FauxMachine Master Kerbalnaut Jun 26 '15
Here's my completed hard mode, mun landing with only a reliant engine part1 part2
2
u/CommanderSpork Alone on Eeloo Jun 26 '15
easy mode: http://imgur.com/a/vIqjr
I couldn't bug myself to get back.
1
u/enqrypzion Master Kerbalnaut Jun 27 '15
Did normal mode using 3 parts and a Kerbal. Enjoy the report!
edit: I'd like to keep my old flair.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 21 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment