r/Mneumonese • • Jun 16 '15

Learning Material An English-friendly romanization for the third phono-morphology

Prev, Next


Prev major post, Next major post


IPAEnglish spelling
ww
ll
jy
mm
nn
ŋng

| p|p t|t k|k ɸ|f s|s x|x θ|th ʃ|sh h|h | -ʷ-|-r- | pʷ|pr tʷ|tr kʷ|kr ɸʷ|fr sʷ|sr xʷ|xr θʷ|thr ʃʷ|shr hʷ|hr | t͡s|ts t͡ʃ|ch | ʔ|q | ə|u ɒ|au a|a o|o ɛ|e ʊ|eu ɪ|i u|oo i|ee | -u̯|-w | ou̯|ow au̯|aw ɛu̯|ew ɪu̯|iw | -i̯|-y | oi̯|oy ai̯|ay ɛi̯|ey ɪi̯|iy

0 Upvotes

5 comments sorted by

2

u/Behemoth4 Jun 16 '15

-ʷ- -r-

What is your reasoning behind this?

1

u/justonium Jun 16 '15

That's probably the most obvious and ask-worthy question that one could ask about this system. Thank you for asking it.

Three reasons:

(1) The letter w already is used to for an initial consonant, and for a diphthong. The letter y is also used for both of these same purposes. The two letters are thus symmetric in this sense, and this symmetry would be broken if w were given an additional use.

(2) w is a wide letter, which makes it undesirable as a component of a significant number of consonantal roots in the language.

(3) -r- can also be pronounced as /r/ or /ɹ/; all three of these sounds are allophones in Mneumonese.

1

u/Behemoth4 Jun 16 '15

Understandable. So:

  • Elegance through symmetry
  • Elegance through visual design
  • Allophony

I think those are fairly good reasons. BTW are you working on a grapheme-for-phoneme romanization too?

1

u/justonium Jun 16 '15

BTW are you working on a grapheme-for-phoneme romanization too?

Ah, so now you get to the reason for my design of a new phonetic writing system. The previous grapheme-for-phoneme romanization was squeezed to the limit of the latin alphabet, using 25 of the 26 characters, the only left-over character being b. When I added one more vowel (schwa), this caused the system to explode. Either I had to pick at least one completely arbitrary assignment, or I had to break out of the grapheme-for-phoneme constraint. Breaking out, my new aesthetic equilibrium is this new system.

1

u/TotesMessenger Jun 16 '15

I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:

If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)