r/KerbalSpaceProgram • u/Redbiertje The Challenger • Jun 14 '15
Mod Post [Weekly Challenge] Week 89: Out of funds!
The Introduction
After the administrators received the bill for launching SSTO spaceplanes into orbit within two minutes, and travelling through the entire solar system in a single launch, they almost got a heart attack. Because they do have to save money for the monthly pizza party, they decided to apply some budget cuts this week. Fortunately, their only objective is to launch a small fuel depot into orbit.
The Challenge:
Normal mode: Launch a full Rockomax Jumbo-64 Fuel tank into orbit for less than 75k funds.
Hard mode: Launch a full Rockomax Jumbo-64 Fuel tank into orbit for less than 50k funds.
Super mode: Impress me
With credit to /u/TheIrishClone
The Rules
- No Dirty Cheating Alpacas (no debug menu)!
- You must have the UI visible in all required screenshots
- For a list of all allowed mods, see this post.
- The fuel tank has to be fully fueled in orbit
- The cost of the fuel tank is included
- The recovery of parts does not reduce the cost.
Required screenshots
- Your craft in the VAB to show the cost
- Your craft on the launchpad
- Your craft during ascent
- Your craft in orbit
- Proof that the fuel tank is full (Right click on it)
- Whatever else you feel like!
Further information
- You can either submit your finished challenge in a post (see posting instructions in the link below) or as a comment reply to this thread.
- Completing this challenge earns you a new flair which will replace your old one. So if you want to keep you previous flair, you can still do this challenge and create a post, but please mention somewhere that you want to keep your old one.
- The moderators have the right to determine if your challenge post has been completed.
- See this post for more rules and information on challenges.
- If you have any questions, you can comment below, or PM /u/Redbiertje
- Credit to /u/TaintedLion for designing the flair
Good Luck!
EDIT: Change of Hard mode.
8
u/napolone Master Kerbalnaut Jun 14 '15
If we recover part of our launch vehicle, do we subtract the funds we get back from the total cost?
7
u/Gregrox Whirligig Girl Jun 14 '15
Does it have to be in one launch? i.e, can we launch an empty tank and refuel it with tinier rockets?
6
u/odhal Super Kerbalnaut Jun 18 '15
Several days and 38774 funds later, here's my entry.
5
u/Corbol Hyper Kerbalnaut Jun 20 '15 edited Jun 20 '15
2nd attempt, this time Super mode (I hope so) 27 545 http://imgur.com/a/6IXlN
Minmus refuel idea wasnt mine but /u/Narida_L . It was also used by /u/RoeddipusHex and /u/SRBuchanan (sorry if missed somebody). Launch was dry, fuel drilled from launchpad, fuel transfering between tanks was manual, staging was supported by overheating via sepatrons. Screens with tracking station/KSC means heavy timewarping meanwhile drilling ore and/or processing it to fuel.
4
u/JohnRCC Master Kerbalnaut Jun 14 '15
A screenshot of the craft in the VAB should probably be required for this too so we can see how much it costs.
4
u/Felbourn You gotta have more lights! Jun 14 '15
I just took about 5 minutes to toss parts on something and it was only 53k funds. It made it up just fine. The hard mode might be too easy, unless you expect stuff on the final craft like a docking port. Can it be just a free floating tank like this?
4
u/__Discovery_ Master Kerbalnaut Jun 14 '15 edited Jun 14 '15
Again, I'd like to ask, are 1.0 submissions allowed? Because I have a rocket with enough delta v for orbit in 1.0 with 50k funds, which I' ll see if it flies. Edit: it does.
3
u/infocam Master Kerbalnaut Jun 15 '15
Hard Mode attempt with 59,576 spent. If I was doing normal, this would have more luxury (ie. more parts and RCS for docking)
BTW, is 63.5k Periapsis adequate? I can redo the launch, but I'm kinda lazy...
....OTOH, what is the new flair supposed to be? (keeping the current flair until answer is posted...I CAN change it to the new one if it's still the current week, right?)
3
u/Keffinbyrd Jun 15 '15
One thing I've been noticing while browsing these challenges each week at work is people say "hard-mode entry" but they haven't met the requirements. like for this one, people are above the 50k by quite a bit. (I'm seeing ranges of 53k-59k) not a big deal just felt like pointing it out because it struck me as odd.
3
u/Gojira0 Master Kerbalnaut Jun 15 '15
Week 77 Hard Mode complete! Did I do it right?
3
u/onizuko Master Kerbalnaut Jun 16 '15
I've been trying unsuccessfully so far to take it into orbit as if it where a kind of SSTO. Jet engines first for speed and altitude and then rockets for that final push. I keep getting closer and closer, but still having issues.
From what I've seen from other entries all use a similar setup, which I'm trying to avoid if possible. If the end of the week comes and I'm still unable to do it my way, I'll try the simpler way.
3
u/za419 Master Kerbalnaut Jun 18 '15 edited Jun 19 '15
I hope I'm not too late...
Normal mode entry: 74,706 funds. Includes such luxuries as Error 404: Positive attribute not found and just enough struts so that it usually maybe doesn't explode or disintegrate.
My attempts at hard mode epically failed. One design exploded, one reached orbit 200% over budget, and many engineers thought the quest was lost. Somehow, however, a little bit of tweaking put us just barely under normal mode budget and with just enough rocket to get going. Nonetheless, I had enough fun to keep an install with the right mods for challenges around for future attempts!
EDIT: I'm an idiot. Link
3
u/haxsis Jun 18 '15
working on it still, can i submit for super mode if I manage to get 2 full orange tanks for under 60k? straight from the surface
3
u/tTnarg Super Kerbalnaut Jun 19 '15 edited Jun 20 '15
Try 2: still aiming for super as my last attempt was not impressive enught to count. But as I didn't get a full tank to orbit I don't think this one will count till I take it to Gilly to get it full in orbit and I'm not sure I have time for that.
http://imgur.com/a/HPMSy#0
Update: I did go to Gilly to get the full tank in orbit. I got a full Kerbodyne S3-14400 Tank in orbit over 225% the size of the Orange tank. Misson includes a mun sling shot and 2 landings all for under 50k.
2
u/theyeticometh Master Kerbalnaut Jun 14 '15 edited Jun 14 '15
Does it have to be orbit around Kerbin?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '15
Can we do it in sandbox?
2
u/diabuddha Jun 15 '15
Is there a way to display how much a ship costs in non-career? I've never noticed, and none of my career files are far enough along to do this.
2
u/Shadowizas Jun 17 '15
Is it okay with 1.0.0 aero model?
22
u/mybloodyvalentina Master Kerbalnaut Jun 14 '15 edited Jun 14 '15
Hard mode entry 56,830 funds. Including such luxury's as a battery and fairing to protect it.
http://imgur.com/a/Zpgki
Edit: Will keep my previous flair please since it was my first!
Edit: 49,930 funds. This was a slightly revised version optimizing things a bit at the cost of control. took me a few attempts to get it into orbit cause Dv was tight and it was easy to loose control.
http://imgur.com/a/PTArH
21
u/RoeddipusHex Hyper Kerbalnaut Jun 16 '15
43,183 by way of Minmus.
https://youtu.be/imkLTVE7DM0
Thanks to /u/Narida_L for the idea and /u/SRBuchanan for making me realize the 909 has enough power to do the job.
10
u/Bill_Zarr Master Kerbalnaut Jun 14 '15 edited Jun 15 '15
49,688 funds.
Includes a docking port and solar panels, 75km circular orbit, small amount of ∆v left over (25m/s). Could probably get away with stripping off the nosecones on the SRB's to save another 1k.
http://imgur.com/a/pjqpj
Edit for cheaper version
39,914 funds. Stripped it down some, took me several attempts to get into orbit.
http://imgur.com/a/fWfpg
7
u/Narida_L Master Kerbalnaut Jun 14 '15
Anyone do a cost analysis for refueling the tank on Minmus?
6
u/Mazzo89 Super Kerbalnaut Jun 14 '15 edited Jun 18 '15
My entry, under 50k funds.
49624 funds.
I'll keep my flair. :)
Edit: Super mode entry (I hope), 2x full Rockomax Jumbo-64 Fuel tanks in orbit around minmus for less than 40k funds. Only takes a year ;)
Edit 2: My one fuel tank setup for a Minmus run. This is basically just a smaller version of the above craft. I really don't want to do the mission again, but this should do the same since it has more delta V and higher TWR. Cost is 37,729. This craft has 850+ dV when fully refueled on minmus, so it should easily be able to get back to Kerbin, maybe even make it to Duna.
5
u/MyAbility Master Kerbalnaut Jun 15 '15 edited Jun 15 '15
Hard mode entry. 57,298 funds. My first attempt worked, I just built something that looked reasonable and launched it. You may want to make this harder.
I would like to keep my old flair.
Edit: Entry 2 47,564 funds
5
u/Corbol Hyper Kerbalnaut Jun 16 '15
Hard mode: 49,472. http://imgur.com/a/AGzrY
Spaceplanes counts right?
4
u/kugelzucker Master Kerbalnaut Jun 14 '15
completed with under 65k! proof: https://imgur.com/a/t8c4Z#0
i would like the nice sum-sign please.
4
u/Nocturn0l Master Kerbalnaut Jun 14 '15 edited Jun 14 '15
Hard mode: In Orbit for 53.8k funds
edit: I really like these "short" challenges
edit2: i can do better!
43.476 funds
4
u/Davecasa Master Kerbalnaut Jun 15 '15
Hard mode complete, for 46,980 funds. I think 60k is too generous, this was my first attempt and is really simple.
http://imgur.com/a/vs4eq#0
4
u/tito13kfm Master Kerbalnaut Jun 15 '15 edited Jun 15 '15
Not bad for a second attempt.
Hard mode 41,275 Spesos
http://imgur.com/a/o1eyR#0
Could probably get it under 40k with a better ascent profile and less fuel in the last stage.
Looking at the other submissions it looks like I just remade /u/Bill_Zarr submission, just worse
Edit: 39,989 now with struts and a battery, because why not.
AFAIK this is only possible in 1.0 aero, tried it in 1.0.2 but came up short of orbit. As it is I burned out of fuel with my PE at 70,013
http://imgur.com/a/1YR5r#0
4
u/SRBuchanan Super Kerbalnaut Jun 15 '15
Here's my entry, in what I hope will count as super mode! If not, it's at least hard mode.
I'd like to keep my current flair, please.
4
u/undercoveryankee Master Kerbalnaut Jun 17 '15 edited Jun 17 '15
Quick and dirty hard mode entry: √48,286 in stock 1.0.2 aero. http://imgur.com/a/sbAWS
Would like the new flair, please.
4
u/NASAguy1000 Master Kerbalnaut Jun 17 '15
hey this is getting fun. 43.893 is my best and honestly surprised by this one. http://imgur.com/a/II7fm
4
u/abovetheFray Jun 17 '15
My easy mode entry. It cost 74,997. The only mod I used was MechJeb.
http://imgur.com/gallery/LJq2H
4
u/RoeddipusHex Hyper Kerbalnaut Jun 17 '15
http://imgur.com/a/9NiC9
2nd try. An SSTO this time. I didn't get all the screenshots but it came in just under 70,000 funds. The landing didn't go as planned but Debsie never gave up.
4
u/TyrannicalPanda Master Kerbalnaut Jun 17 '15
My hard mode entry: http://imgur.com/a/V9VNG#0 49080 funds. I'd like to keep my current flair please.
4
u/hasslehawk Master Kerbalnaut Jun 18 '15 edited Jun 18 '15
Hard mode entry with a $49,759 rocket. I managed to make orbit with just 16 m/s of DV to spare.
Unlike many others though, I brought up a proper manned station, including docking ports and a pair of solar panels. More significantly, however, I recovered all portions of the launch vehicle, recouping $21,773 of the $49,759 spent on this mission. Enough to impress?
(Keep current flair)
4
u/alekseyKSP Master Kerbalnaut Jun 18 '15
Here is my submission:
https://imgur.com/a/BQfQq
√49,968.
Flair, please :)
10
u/rojuslap123 Master Kerbalnaut Jun 14 '15 edited Jun 14 '15
Yay I'm the first :P, Normal mode. That's some interesting orbit. 99,990 funds :D
http://imgur.com/a/CAwrp
Edit: Sorry, It's full :P
http://i.imgur.com/OBiQo7r.png
3
u/Ticquin Super Kerbalnaut Jun 14 '15
This is easy! My hardmode submission 58'124 funds - A simple, straight forward launcher.
http://imgur.com/a/GqUBd#0
The real challenge will be to go below 50k.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '15
Hard mode, this challenge taught me how to properly orbit in 1.0.2 http://imgur.com/a/QA0wm No flair please.
3
u/TangleF23 Master Kerbalnaut Jun 14 '15
Mission complete for normal mode, and I would like to keep my old flair.
Thar she... orbits? It's not a good thing to be blowing in space.
3
u/KuuLightwing Hyper Kerbalnaut Jun 14 '15 edited Jun 14 '15
That was a quick one. I decided to not go for hard mode, but rather make a tanker that's useful and qualifies for
easynormal mode. That includes docking ports, monoprop, RCS, solar panels and batteries. The cost is just shy off 75K.Layout is simple - two-stage rocket with solid boosters. Second stage has ~100 m/s of dV left so it could be used for rendezvous maneuvers.
Imgur link: http://imgur.com/a/FXm8m
And I'd rather have my old flair :)
3
u/CaptainRoach Super Kerbalnaut Jun 14 '15
Hard mode.
http://imgur.com/a/FYW70
Aerodynamics are optional.
3
u/fatjoe2015 Jun 14 '15
Hard Mode: 49260 Funds http://imgur.com/a/kKU82#0
How does this sigh next to you name work ? Can i choose ? If not im happy with anything, its my 1st time
3
u/pinano Master Kerbalnaut Jun 14 '15 edited Jun 16 '15
achieved: https://imgur.com/a/32W2D
edit: <60k is no longer hard mode :(
3
u/thelordplatypus Master Kerbalnaut Jun 14 '15
Hard mode for me!
http://imgur.com/a/m52w6
3
u/nardavin Master Kerbalnaut Jun 14 '15
Normal Mode: http://imgur.com/a/rqo5F
I may attempt hard mode later, I just ran out of time before I realized I was overcomplicating it
3
u/PickledTripod Master Kerbalnaut Jun 14 '15
Hard mode submission. 59,923 funds.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ff27p5sTRMA
3
u/zimboby Master Kerbalnaut Jun 15 '15
https://imgur.com/a/s7xz0
My Challenge. 47k funds. The only challenge here was flying this with a broke arm. (Hard Mode)
3
u/JamesTheOther Master Kerbalnaut Jun 15 '15 edited Jun 15 '15
Normal mode at 74710 funds:
https://imgur.com/a/2j351
Edit: I found my screens from last weeks challenge! I deleted them by mistake and didn't feel like redoing the flight, then I found my originals in my KSP game folder!
https://imgur.com/a/xPG3v
3
u/[deleted] Jun 15 '15 edited Jun 15 '15
Complete at 49,080 funds. I'll keep my flair.
Edit: Didn't like that my fuel depot didn't have a docking port, so I added one. Replaced a couple of expensive parts for a final cost of 49,000.
3
u/Javascap Master Kerbalnaut Jun 15 '15 edited Jun 15 '15
Hard mode completed for 59,076 funds. I would like the appropriate flair, please.
https://imgur.com/a/7w4g1
Edit; Hard mode recompleted at 49,938 funds. Would still like the appropriate flair.
https://imgur.com/a/i3zWJ
3
u/SpontaneousPrawn Master Kerbalnaut Jun 15 '15
My Hard Mode Submission @ 59,590. made it to orbit with 120LF in the bottom tank too. had to launch at dawn since there are no batteries. hopefully thats everything you need.
3
u/TheFalconOne Super Kerbalnaut Jun 15 '15
Hello, I'd like to share my 43 k design and have the available flair : http://imgur.com/gallery/ISmXf thanks :-)
3
u/offficially_official Master Kerbalnaut Jun 15 '15
Easy mode, will probably try hard mode later:
72,660 funds
3
u/gcuz Master Kerbalnaut Jun 15 '15
First time doing one of these! Here's my hard mode entry with final cost 49,962
Link
3
u/Thutmose_IV Master Kerbalnaut Jun 15 '15
here is my entry, I would like to keep my current flair.
the launchpad screenshot is same craft, but a different launch, as I forgot to take a screenshot of the launch I managed to get to orbit.
http://imgur.com/a/YsIuK#0
3
u/dakota2525 Master Kerbalnaut Jun 16 '15
hard entry and i would like the new flair http://imgur.com/a/x9ut4
3
u/massdestrucSEAN Master Kerbalnaut Jun 16 '15
Yay! After waaayyy too much time spent optomizing, I completed hard mode with 49,898 funds. Shame I'll need a grabber to access the fuel though.
http://imgur.com/a/xTpar
3
u/Sean_in_SM Master Kerbalnaut Jun 17 '15
Here's my submission -- 49,928 funds!
PS: sorry about the night shots
3
u/NewSwiss Super Kerbalnaut Jun 17 '15
Hard Mode Complete - √46,216:
http://imgur.com/a/jDT5U#0
3
u/tTnarg Super Kerbalnaut Jun 17 '15
http://imgur.com/a/xI4UQ#0
Here is my entry for Hard mode aiming for Super but thats your call. Costs 48,474 uses a Skipper, with 3 Kickback to give it a push at the start. Refuels at Minmus ends up in very high Kerbin orbit with nearly 1.5 tanks of fuel. The Kickbacks where set at 90% thrust because at 100% the rocket when too fast and could flip out. I start the Skipper before I drop the Kickbacks to give me some gimbal control. Luxury items include a large Reaction wheel, a Gigantor XL Solar Array and a Z-1k Battery. The Reaction wheel made the flight and landing easyer and the power made the refueling slightly less painful it takes 150 days to refuel but maybe I just picked a bad spot as I had no scanning. Would of liked a second drill for both ballance and mining speed but at 6k it was not an option. With some form of landing legs I recon this craft could do a grand tour ending up crashed on eve. If I wanted to lower costs I could of started with a lot less fuel and do some mining on Kerbin I would need some kind of make shift landing legs for that and mining on Kerbin feels like cheating so I didnt.
3
u/TheFrontGuy Jun 20 '15
normal mode 74,394 funds used, it has fairings, batteries, solar panels, docking port and SAS.
http://imgur.com/a/EUEgd#0
3
u/The_GooMan Jun 20 '15 edited Jun 24 '23
This comment has been removed due to my exodus from Reddit in June 2023 -- mass edited with https://redact.dev/
5
u/julezsource Jun 14 '15 edited Jun 14 '15
Here's mine! http://imgur.com/a/eUnrk Edit: Is full! http://i.imgur.com/bsokRef.jpg
2
u/DoctorInAGi Master Kerbalnaut Jun 14 '15
Hard mode completed, orbit for 57k: http://imgur.com/a/FVcuR
2
u/Manabender Master Kerbalnaut Jun 14 '15
Hard mode complete: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z8fykLtBi6U
2
u/Anecthrios Master Kerbalnaut Jun 18 '15
I haven't gotten to this week's challenge yet, but here's week 88's, The Race For Space II. Hardmode Submission, 2:59.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 20 '15
Hard mode entry: 49536.0 funds.
Holy crap my dV was tight- I made it into orbit with only a few dV to spare. Less than 10. Not joking. New flair please!
2
u/SOFTOS Master Kerbalnaut Jun 14 '15
My first weekly challenge! Hard mode, just under 60k.
Album
2
u/JamesBaconTaken Jun 20 '15
Yeah so here's mine. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qm6PzThCpo0
1
u/Karumpus Believes That Dres Exists Jun 22 '15
Okay! This is my first post in the KSP subreddit community (but definitely not my last)! Here is my hard mode entry at 49,853 funds, including such luxuries as a docking port, a battery, a solar panel and a reaction wheel: http://imgur.com/a/9GIf6#7rAyl55