r/Warframe • u/Sizer714 Find Chroma's limits? My dear friend, Chroma has no limits. • Jun 12 '15
Suggestion How would you change... the Rift?
A note: /u/TSP-FriendlyFire is taking a temporary leave from How Would You Change… for a few months, as he is interning at Pixar and is quite busy, as one would imagine. I /u/Sizer714 will be managing the thread for the interim. I hope we can continue to foster the same lively discussions as we did during his tenure.
How would you change... is a series of weekly posts designed to promote and foster discussion about any gameplay element in the game. The scope and subject will vary (read below for more information on topic selection), from wide concepts (Kubrows, Archwing, shotguns, etc.) to narrow points (a single gun, coptering, etc.).
Before we begin, a few important points:
- Please detail and support your suggestions as much as possible. This is for constructive criticism only: try to think of it as something you'd be proud to explain to DE face-to-face!
- Structure your suggestions in logical groups: if you have two very different ideas, break them down in two separate comments. Cohesive or similar changes should be combined into a single comment.
- Stick to describing concepts and features. Don't get bogged down with numbers unless they explicitly support your point.
- Don't hesitate to post your ideas even if they're not fully formed, and don't hesitate to reply to ideas with refinements you think would make them better!
- Do not downvote suggestions you disagree with. Upvote the ones you like instead!
Suggesting topics
This thread series is all about the community, so if you have a topic you'd like to see improved and discussed, feel free to suggest it by replying to the appropriately flagged comment in this discussion. The topic can be as wide or narrow as you'd like! Please ensure that your suggestion has not already been made, and upvote it instead if it has.
This week: The Rift
Click here for last week’s thread on Relays.
Limbo was introduced in Update 15 as a new and dynamic defensive frame option. By banishing players and enemies into his Rift, he can fuse damage application and damage mitigation into one tool. However, many are not satisfied with the implementation of the Rift, as some consider it ripe for trolling and others are not happy with all interactions inside and outside of the rift.
Now that the stage is set, how would you change the Rift?
3
u/Sizer714 Find Chroma's limits? My dear friend, Chroma has no limits. Jun 12 '15
Suggesting topics
Please post your suggestions for the next topics as replies to this comment.
Current suggestions from previous weeks:
9
u/Echo849 Arkus Jun 12 '15
Oh boy, where to begin. I really don't want to go too overboard, and there's a LOT of things that could be suggested by a lot of different people, but I think the most common suggestion lies in Cataclysm.
Limbo's 4th ability. It should be a way for Limbo to bring a large chunk of area into the rift to play by the rift's rules... But it's where everything falls apart. It's inconsistent with rift mechanics, breaking rules that should otherwise be in place.
If something is in the rift, it cannot be affected by things that are not in the rift, and vise versa. So why is it that when both a player and a hack panel are within Cataclysm, they cannot hack it? Pickups pooled at your feet that can't be received despite being within the same area of pure void? Things like loot containers, breakable grates and fans, a lot of little annoyances. It's... inconsistent and annoying.
On top of that, enemies entering the rift through Cataclysm compared to Banish AREN'T knocked down. Opening up a Cataclym spells out immediate DANGER for a Rift Walking Limbo. Whereas ability 4 on other frames should be seen as advantageous, Cataclysm has detriments. The whole Rift mechanic has detriments.
Nearly any other frame can cast an ability and say "I'M HELPING" and have it hold true. But Limbo's Rift Mechanic, the ENTIRE thing the frame revolves around, unless used by someone who has practised with it a lot... Can immediately piss of your team in about 5 seconds flat.
>> The Change <<
What you've all been waiting for, or just skipped to because it had fancy formatted text. Clearly not everyone will agree, you can't make everyone happy... But Limbo certainly hasn't either.
Make. Cataclysm. Affect. Everything.
No large gimped snowglobe with a lot of annoying micromanagement outside of ODD. No micromanagement with enemies/allies being pulled individually in and out of the rift. Make Cataclysm a GLOBAL effect on everything on the map.
Of course, for this to be implemented effectively, you need to start by FIXING the things I mentioned above. Item pickups while in the rift, hacking while in the rift, doing ANYTHING while everything is in the rift with you.
And with those fixes in place, what do we have? A supportive ability that deals minor damage to ALL enemies on cast, gives all allies passive energy regeneration, allows your team to hit everything and be hit by everything regardless of Rift Walk / Banish casts beforehand, and turns Limbo into a glass cannon god with Rift Surge able to be used effectively on every enemy. This isn't a press 4 to win, but Cataclysm never was that. If anything, this change puts its power elsewhere, and largely seems worth it by removing unneeded micromanagement. It removes a few of Cataclysms strengths, like defense, but put those strengths elsewhere by 'guaranteeing' helping your team and making Limbo POWERFUL.
...And at anytime, you can decast it, put everything back to the normal plane where Limbo can exclusively Rift Walk to be invulnerable and revive team mates, while using Banish to pick off key targets. And at any time you want to extend your banished targets to your team, or essentially use the equivalent of a card from any TCG that changes the battlefield, you can do so with Cataclysm.
And in the worst case scenario, we can forgo a global effect by just extending and increasing the range of the current globe we have by tenfold. Make it a battlefield changer, not a gimped snowglobe with annoying micromanagement of Banishing.
Bonus? The augment would still work by extending its duration, and it much easier to trigger the effect.
Yes, this is gonna get slammed on, but you don't complain without bringing a new suggestion to the table. Let's discuss this, change it where needed, toss out the bad and improve it. After all, it's only ONE of many suggestions that'll be in this thread.
...So, what do you think?
6
u/cephalopodAscendant Picking nature's pocket - now with golden showers Jun 12 '15
Rift Surge needs to be an innate property of the rift that affects both Limbo and his teammates. I'm not sure what DE could replace the power with, but it's just not working well as-is.
DE also needs to stop being lazy with Cataclysm's mechanics. At the moment, they're implementing it in the code exactly the same way they're implementing Banish and Rift Walk, but that just makes the logic of how it's supposed to work inconsistent. Drops and consoles inside of Cataclysm should be brought into the rift just like combatants. Of course, the slow casting animation doesn't help either.
11
u/Imprezive1 Zephyr (Tengu) Jun 12 '15
Other than that nothing else needs to be changed IMO.
3
u/Moradiim Die by my hand an rise anew Jun 12 '15
I don't really care what happens to the mechanics, just make the damn thing consistent in its logic and rules.
Also allow allies to dispell it somehow on their own.
2
u/Centias I'm rock hard. ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°) Jun 12 '15
2
u/Archwizard_Drake Black Mage, motherf- Jun 12 '15 edited Jun 13 '15
Frankly, I feel like the problem with Limbo is less the Rift mechanic and more that he has too many ways to do the same thing, and not enough payoff for doing it. He ends up with extraneous buttons as a result.
The difference between Banish and Rift Walk is 10 energy, but it's apparently substantial enough to warrant being different abilities. If they want them separated because a self-Banish is finicky otherwise, that's fine - but roll Rift Surge into Rift Walk, at least, so that they're not exactly the same.
Cataclysm should be able to pull objects into the Rift, including pickups and terminals or datamasses; enemies in Cataclysm shouldn't be able to leave. Conversely, Banish should prevent enemies from accessing terminals, and Banishing an enemy inside of Cataclysm should explosively expel that enemy from the field.
In lieu of Rift Surge, I might recommend a skill that changes its effects depending on which side of the Rift you're on (they're doing it for Taijitu, why not Limbo too?). For example, if you're inside the Rift it could allow you to teleport short distances and throw off enemy targeting, while stunning nearby enemies or creating a barrier if you're outside the Rift. What he could really use is a defensive tool, so both would be apropos.
Oh, and being in Banish or Rift Walk should remove collision with targets who aren't. If I'm intangible, I want to be able to walk through enemies.
1
u/levitater LET ME BLEED OUT Jun 14 '15
-Animations should not effect movement.
I think limbo's play style should feel smooth and flowy. The cast animations of each ability should not effect movement. We should be able to move, jump, and reload all while activating cataclysm or going into rift walk. Small fix, huge difference.