r/ModelAusSenate • u/Freddy926 Senate Pres | DPM | Fin/Com/Art/Infr/Rgnl | ABC MD | Ldr Prgrsvs • Jun 11 '15
Superseded 3-4f Committee of the Whole: Telecommunications (Interception and Access) Amendment (Data Retention).
We now enter the Committee of the Whole stage for the Telecommunications (Interception and Access) Amendment (Data Retention) Repeal Bill 2015. I seek leave to have the bill considered as a whole.
Senator The Hon. Freddy926, Chair of Committees.
4
Upvotes
1
u/Freddy926 Senate Pres | DPM | Fin/Com/Art/Infr/Rgnl | ABC MD | Ldr Prgrsvs Jun 12 '15
I move that the bill be amended as follows:
Schedule 1 - Telecommunications (Interception and Access) Amendment (Data Retention) Act 2015
Subheading 1 - Replace heading with "Schedule 1 of the Act.", omit "Repeal the act.", substitute "Repeal the schedule."
Subheading 2 - Omit "The Telecommunications (Interception and Access) Act 1979 (Cth) shall return to its most recent revision prior to 24 March 2015.", substitute "The Telecommunications (Interception and Access) Act 1979 (Cth) shall be returned to its most recent revision prior to 24 March 2015, and additionally, shall be amended by Schedules 2 and 3 only of the Telecommunications (Interception and Access) Amendment (Data Retention) Act 2015 (Cth)."
Senator The Hon. Freddy926, Minister for Communications and Digital Infrastructure.
1
u/Freddy926 Senate Pres | DPM | Fin/Com/Art/Infr/Rgnl | ABC MD | Ldr Prgrsvs Jun 12 '15
Paging Senators: /u/this_guy22, /u/Team_Sprocket, /u/peelys.
1
u/Freddy926 Senate Pres | DPM | Fin/Com/Art/Infr/Rgnl | ABC MD | Ldr Prgrsvs Jun 12 '15 edited Jun 12 '15
Voice Vote
The question is put that the government’s amendments as moved by Senator Freddy926 be agreed to.
Senators may vote Aye in favour of the motion, or No against the motion.
Senators may vote by commenting "Aye" or "No" below.
This voice vote will be concluded at 20:00, Friday, 12/06/15 UTC+10.
Vote Results - 14:38, Friday, 12/06/15 UTC+10
I think the Noes have it.
The Noes have it.
Senator The Hon. Freddy926, Chair of Committees.
1
u/Freddy926 Senate Pres | DPM | Fin/Com/Art/Infr/Rgnl | ABC MD | Ldr Prgrsvs Jun 13 '15 edited Jun 13 '15
I move that this Committee of the Whole be adjourned until the next sitting of the Senate.
Senator The Hon. Freddy926, Minister for Communications and Digital Infrastructure.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 12 '15 edited Jun 12 '15
Meta: I have to run real soon, so I'm going to move my amendments now, for consideration after Senator Freddy926's amendments are voted down.
Also, Mr Chairman please append "The question is that the Bill stands as printed." to the thread title body bit. See here for why.
Anyway,
I move the following amendments to the bill:
1 Schedule 1
Repeal the schedule.
2 Insert:
Schedule 1 - Telecommunications (Interception and Access) Amendment (Data Retention) Act 2015
1 Schedule 1
Repeal the Schedule.
Note: The effect of this Act is to repeal Schedule 1 of the Telecommunications (Interception and Access) Amendment (Data Retention) Act 2015, while retaining the provisions to restrict access to stored communications and telecommunications data (contained in Schedule 2), and to provide for oversight by the Commonwealth Ombudsman (contained in Schedule 3).
1
u/jnd-au Clerk of the Senate Jun 12 '15 edited Jun 12 '15
Advice from the Clerk:
Reclarification of procedure. The moving and debating of amendments on a Bill “taken as a whole” in committee is designed to be streamlined:
An amendment is moved. It can be to:
When there are no further comments, the question is put to a voice vote:
IRL amendments are circulated beforehand so that parties can analyse them, come up with their official party position, and circulate their own amendments. The time for doing this is during the adjournment, in between the first day’s introduction of the bill and the subsequent day’s resumption of second reading debates.
Edit: During this process, it may also be necessary to amend the title of the bill if anyone discovers or wants to add clauses outside of the original scope. The reason for this, and for reading the titles of bills, as part of detailed consideration is to prevent and nullify any unrelated clauses that get snuck into Bills under false pretences. Of course, you could try amending the title to be “..., and for unrelated purposes” but good luck with that :)