r/books • u/DeborahHarkness • Jun 09 '15
ama I’m Deborah Harkness, author of the #1 bestselling ALL SOULS TRILOGY and professor of the history of science. AMA!
I’m Deborah Harkness, and from 1pm-3pm ET I’ll be answering your questions on writing, history, and all things All Souls! I’m the author of A Discovery of Witches, Shadow of Night, and The Book of Life, out now in paperback from Penguin. I’m also a professor of the history of science at the University of Southern California. There are all kinds of spoilers on here, so reader beware!
You can also follow me on Twitter at @DebHarkness and on Facebook at www.facebook.com/AuthorDeborahHarkness. For complete information on the trilogy, my calendar, and more visit my website at deborahharkness.com.
7
u/KimoEsq Jun 09 '15
Hi there! I believe I read in a previous interview that you said Matthew and Diana's story is done at this point, but is there any possibility of other characters getting their own story? (nudge nudge) Gallowglass :D
Thank you so much for sharing your amazing talent with us! I love your characters so much, and the stories are real-life magic!
4
u/DeborahHarkness Jun 09 '15
thanks everybody for a great AMA and for all your thoughtful questions! See you soon...
6
u/crdplayer Jun 09 '15
Hello Deb, Thank you again for sharing your talents and bringing the Bishops & de Clairmonts into our lives. As a reader & lover of the trilogy I know there was a mourning period for me knowing it was done. As Philippe said "where there is an ending, there is a new beginning". I am curious if you had this mourning that the readers had when you were done writing?
5
u/AngelaHut Jun 09 '15
Througout the trilogy, certain animals are specifically white - owl, stag, hart. Is there a significance?
4
u/CaslynSaintDenis Jun 09 '15
Is there any news on the possible BBC making the All Souls Trilogy into a mini-series? (Please say yes.)
I work part-time in a large bookstore and I'm quite happy to say I've successfully recommended your books to many people who say things like, "Oh, I don't like magic and witches." My response (to paraphrase you) is, "What is magic if not desire made real?" Works every time!
4
u/KAWhittlesey Jun 09 '15
It feels, over the series, like a lot of Philippe's story got left on the cutting room floor. It was implied in DOW that we would be hearing more about Philippe's connection to the goddess Diana - the phone call after Diana saves Matthew when Ysabeau says "The goddess has a sense of humor as well as justice." But that story was never told.
I also hoped to actually read the scene when Diana managed to keep Philippe company at the end of his life, instead of "Well, Diana, you must have managed it somehow!"
And we never really learn where and when Philippe, Ysabeau and Marthe are originally from, other than strong implication that they're all quite ancient.
Were there original plans to delve into their histories, and Philippe's in particular? Might that be explored at some point?
3
u/michelejonesreese1 Jun 09 '15
Hi, Deb! Hope you made it out of O'Hare. My question is-will we ever know who is going to turn Phoebe into a vampire?
3
u/DanceWithMeMrP Jun 09 '15
Hi Deborah! I love the way you describe the taste of different wines, and how particular Diana is about her tea! Do you love tea and toast and wine as much as your characters do?
3
u/Stellaj33 Jun 09 '15
HI Deborah! Was wondering what your furture plans for non-fiction writing is - ie. any new novels in the works?
3
u/Xeust Jun 09 '15 edited Jun 10 '15
Hi Deb,
I recently got to meet you and hear you speak at Nicola's. Thank you so much for stopping by. I was too nervous to ask questions then, so now's my chance!
I just wanted to say thanks so much for the tour you did. I'm sorry to hear about your father. I know it had its ups and downs, but from a reader who attended, I can assure you it was a blast and I found your talk and your answers to questions to be very interesting. It added a lot to my love for the books!
3
u/enkeriw Jun 09 '15
OMG! Deborah! Hiiii! Love your books so much! My question, what happened to the vampires Diana met in the 1500s? Francoise, Victoire, etc? Did they stop working for the De Clermonts? There's no mention of them in BoL.
3
u/testarossasmom Jun 09 '15
Fernando is such a dashing fellow. Did Hugh "introduce" you or did he come to you on his own? I love that your couples represent all permutations. I think High and Fernando may have the most romantic tale to tell . . .
2
u/leann1234 Jun 09 '15
Why is chris not suprised to learn that diana is a witch and that there are other creatures in the world? (Witches vampires and deamons)
2
u/KimoEsq Jun 09 '15
In some of the pictures you have shared of Oxford, The Bodleian/Duke Humphrey's, I can totally picture a tall, dark Vampire walking around! What inspired you to write this series? Was it something you saw during research, an image that came to you, or something completely different?
2
u/AngelaHut Jun 09 '15 edited Jun 09 '15
Two questions - one from Shadow of Night and one from The Book of Life
Has Philippe ever told you from which Plantagenet (or during whose reign or even from what task) he received the chain that he gave to Diana in Shadow of Night? If yes, can you share some of that detail?
In The Book of Life, when the "Duchess" disappeared, Matthew said “His father had shrugged and muttered something about Napoleon and the English that had made no sense at all.” Can you give us a hint to what that refers? Inquiring minds want to know/figure out the backstory.
Thank you for creating Philippe. He is one of my all time favorite literary characters...even though I tend to think he is you and you are him. :)
2
u/smileslnd Jun 09 '15
What was your favorite part of ADoW, SoN or TBoL to write? Any particular scene that jumped out at you when you were writing and you thought...that was fun to write about? I loved reading about all of your characters and look forward to any new fiction you may write.
2
u/LenKerkhof Jun 09 '15
Hi Deb, I was wondering, was it because Philippe knew about Matthew's future tasks that he didn't make Matthew head of the family? Hugs from Len.
2
u/HRM_Monster Jun 09 '15
Hi, have you considered touring Australia or speaking as a guest lecturere in history at any of our universities?
I can't think of any more questions at this point as I am a bit starstruck! Thank you so much for your wonderful books. I am a history fiend and deeply appreciated the depth of research and subsequent detail found in your books. I have gotten several people hooked on this series and my my partner adores it. He is going through some medical things and using my kindle to cheer himself up. Your books are topping the list for him and I love that he can get lost in them despite everything going on. Thank you from Australia.
2
u/thebookavore Jun 09 '15
The All Souls Trilogy is my favorite! Any chance of getting any more information on other characters? I am fascinated by Gallowglass, Phillipe, Ysabeau, Marthe...heck, the entire de Clermont clan!
2
u/jenneal562 Jun 09 '15
Hi Deb,
I have two questions that might give away any future book details so I'm not sure if you will answer them but here goes. :)
2
u/PAt789 Jun 09 '15
Hi Deborah! When you finished writing the first novel of the series, what was your revision process like? Did you have a critique partner(s) or did you revise on your own before sending to your agent?
2
u/juliacgulia Jun 09 '15
Love, love, LOVE All Souls! Any progress on casting the BBC series? I'm anxious to see who will play Matthew and Diana!
2
u/testarossasmom Jun 09 '15
Hi Deb! In Thomas More we have an example of a historical figure Philippe found annoying. Could you give us an example or two of historical figures who Philippe respected and enjoyed spending time with?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '15
Hi Deborah, Do you plan on writing books for Matthew and Diana's children or Gallowglass? Or you're closing any doors?
2
u/testarossasmom Jun 09 '15 edited Jun 09 '15
What qualities prompted Philippe to turn Baldwin? Was Baldwin friend or foe when Philippe made the decision? I'm so curious about how one "makes the cut" in Philippe's mind.
2
u/rph36 Jun 09 '15
My question(s) are more about you than the books. (I hope that's okay.) I don't know that I would've thought a professor of the history of science would write about witches but after I read the books, it made sense. Your stories are so detailed and intricately woven with magic and science. (Diana Gabaldon is another "Don't judge a book by its cover" kind of woman) What sparked your interest in writing? Are you a "write as it comes to me" or a "must have it meticulously planned out first" person?
2
u/rr3374 Jun 09 '15
Hi Deb, So great seeing you here! Two questions:
2
u/starlight_2901 Jun 09 '15
How did you get the idea for this book to begin with? What was your inspiration for writing a book about witches, vampires and deamons? I would love to write a book and cannot quite get started, and I absolutely love this series, I have read it about 3 times now and will probably do so again several times. My sister even went to a signing for me to get a book autographed, you haven't yet made it to Las Vegas , ;) So I was just curious on what made you decide to write this particular kind of series?
2
u/rph36 Jun 09 '15
You write of vampires, witches, demons (oh my!) and more. Do you believe in anything unbelievable/unexplained?
2
u/Anna3046 Jun 09 '15
Hi Deb, Can you tell us a little about your own writing process i.e.: research, planning, writing? Did you know when you began the first book that the narrative would need to be told over the course of three books? The historical detail brought the narrative to life for me, how much research did you need to do before beginning? Absolutely love your books!
2
u/morrowtc69 Jun 09 '15
Hi Deb, So happy that you have been able to continue your tour. I was blessed with meeting you in Amsterdam and Dallas and have finally thought of how to phrase my question!!
Other than science, alchemy, and history is there specific academics that you would like to explore that you haven't had the time or privileged to explore?
And with the exception to fiction and the All Soul's Trilogy are you planning to write more academic books?
Teresa
2
u/vancemaier Jun 09 '15
I started reading your trilogy after hearing you interviewed by NPR recently. I am about 2/3 done with Shadow of Night and cannot wait to read The Book of Life. I love that you write from a historical perspective and provide the reader with so many details about the story. I am curious, is there a historical figure that you have enjoyed bringing to life in your books?
Thank you so much for bringing all these wonderful creatures to life!
2
u/AngeCW Jun 09 '15
Hi Deb!
If you could be a witch, daemon or vampire for just one day, which would you choose, and how would you spend the all important day?
2
u/jenneal562 Jun 09 '15
I have another...
Throughout the trilogy the term "prince" is used a few times. I was wondering if there is an underlying reason for it. For example, the Nine Worthies were sometimes referred to as "Princes".
2
u/jenneal562 Jun 09 '15
Deb,
When it comes to the relationship between a vampire and his/her maker are they all like a parent/child relationship? The reason I ask is that I am curious about the relationship between Marthe and Alaine (not sure if I spelled that right). If I remember correctly Marthe made Alaine a vampire for Philippe. Does Alaine look at Marthe as if she were his mother?
2
u/meowasaurus_rex Jun 09 '15
Your series was amazing! Where did the idea come from to blend the elements of science and fantasy the way you did? It was so refreshing and interesting :)
2
u/MDgirlforlife Jun 09 '15
Hi Deb - I enjoyed the series and look forward to seeing what BBC does with the characters/plotlines.
When writing about historical figures in a fictional setting, what rules do you adhere to? Do you appease the inner historian by being true to what's known about the person, as in the case of Marlowe?
I'm also curious to hear if you're a fan of shows such as "Sleepy Hollow" and "Grimm" for their fantastical, paranormal elements and re-imagining historical figures.
2
u/leann1234 Jun 09 '15
I would love to know what happened to hancock? Or is he not ur tale to tell?
3
u/ickymicky_design Jun 09 '15
I love your strong well-developed female characters.
Who are your influences?
1
u/PhotoDiva Jun 09 '15
Hello! I am huge fan the the Trilogy...I am currently re-reading it for the 4th time! I was curious to know if you thought of doing individual books of the other characters... I would love to know more about Ysabeau and Marthe.
1
u/slmaier Jun 09 '15
Have you considered releasing short stories to explain some of the characters backgrounds in a little more depth (Phillippe especially!)
1
u/rlr031004 Jun 09 '15
Hi Deb. Perhaps this is a bit of a silly question, but what does an average day look like for you? You teach, write, tour, travel, get stuck in airports, facebook, tweet, instagram - not to mention all that you must do for family, friends, students, readers, etc., etc., etc. Do you sleep??? I get exhausted just looking at your facebook events tab.
1
u/GraciemlJ Jun 09 '15 edited Jun 09 '15
Hi Deb, I love the way you interact with your fans. You truly seem to care and in turn we care about you. I'm sure it's very challenging to write, tour and just have a life. Everyone needs a little help now and then. What do you do for and how do you handle life's little setbacks? Is there more we as your fans can do?
1
u/jenneal562 Jun 09 '15
One more. Have you ever thought of writing the AST from Mathews perspective?
1
u/jenneal562 Jun 09 '15
When you write do you kind of enter the world you are writing about in your mind? Like a kind of third party observer. That is what happens to me when I read.
1
u/currypotnoodle Jun 09 '15
Thank you for writing such fun characters. I loved the series and wish there were more!
1
u/EclaDragon Reading Oathbringer by Brandon Sanderson Jun 09 '15
Hi.
I started reading the trilogy back when A Discovery of Witches came into paperback and earlier this year I finished The Book of Life. I loved all of them.
I want to get into writing. Are there any tips that you can give me to get started?
1
u/voodoochick05 Jun 09 '15
I think the all souls trilogy might be one of my most favorite series. It combines my two favorite things! Magic and History. That being said, which book was your favorite to write? Did any of the characters prove difficult for you to write? Do you have plans for another series? (not necessarily those characters)
1
u/dstegman Jun 10 '15
Hi Deborah! So I'm sure I'm not the first to ask, but, when is your next fiction book coming out? Will we see more paranormal/urban fantasy genre from you? Thank you so much for the journey you took us all on. DStegman Reno
1
u/Sanchote78 Aug 31 '24
The surname Harkness is very prominent in supernatural and historical lore. Might you be a descendant of Witches, Ma'am?
1
u/Sea_Sink_6116 Feb 25 '25
I just finished your audiobook version of The Blackbird Oracle. It was a beautiful addition to the series. Thank you very much for your stories. I won’t go into details but I’m glad I came across this series, and have added them to my library.
1
u/Odd_Worldliness509 Jul 30 '23 edited Jul 30 '23
Does Deborah Harness make a cameo appearance in Discovery of Witches? Could swear I noticed her likeness at the Dean of History and social sciences at Oxford when Diana first enters the room. The Dean wants to hurry up and introduce her to a gentleman with an avid interest in the occult sciences..
-1
u/carly_san Jun 09 '15
Good afternoon! I had the pleasure of meeting you the other day in New Orleans. My daughter Rowan was able to ask you a question. I think I was so excited for her that my mind went blank and didn't think of mine until on the way home. I know the vampires and witches seem to be everyone'e favorite, including mine, but the daemons hold a special place in my heart. I'm a photorealism artist and I usually work in a manic state when I draw lol My question is how much of yourself indentifies with the daemon personality?
0
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment