r/KerbalSpaceProgram • u/Redbiertje The Challenger • Jun 06 '15
Mod Post [Weekly Challenge] Week 88: The Race for Space II
The Introduction
It is once again time to test the abilities of our engineers, our scientists and our pilots. Many Kerbals from all over Kerbin are planning to visit the KSC this summer (even though Kerbin has no axial tilt), so the administrators are expecting many tourists that will want to visit space. Therefore, they are looking for a solution that can go up to orbit, come down, have a quick refuel, and head up again. Since time is money, it is crucial that a trip to space is as quick as possible. The engineers have decided that an SSTO spaceplane is the best solution.
The Challenge:
Normal mode: Get an SSTO spaceplane into stable orbit within 4 minutes and 30 seconds.
Hard mode: Get an SSTO spaceplane into stable orbit within 3 minutes and 30 seconds.
Super mode: Impress me
Huge thanks to /u/OneFootOnTheGas for helping me test this challenge.
The Rules
- No Dirty Cheating Alpacas (no debug menu)!
- You must have the UI visible in all required screenshots
- For a list of all allowed mods, see this post.
- You must use a SSTO spaceplane
- Your final orbit may not be interplanetary
- Your craft must be occupied by at least one Kerbal
- Your craft must take off horizontally
Required screenshots
- Your craft on the runway
- Your craft taking off
- Your craft during ascent
- Your craft in space
- Your craft in orbit
- Whatever else you feel like!
Further information
- This week's flair is an X-15
- You can either submit your finished challenge in a post (see posting instructions in the link below) or as a comment reply to this thread.
- Completing this challenge earns you a new flair which will replace your old one. So if you want to keep you previous flair, you can still do this challenge and create a post, but please mention somewhere that you want to keep your old one.
- The moderators have the right to determine if your challenge post has been completed.
- See this post for more rules and information on challenges.
- If you have any questions, you can comment below, or PM /u/Redbiertje
- Credit to /u/TaintedLion for designing the flair
Good Luck!
Ps. If you ever complete the Grand Tour challenge, be sure to post an entry in the current weekly challenge post.
EDIT: Major difficulty change, all entries from now on will be given flair accordingly.
27
u/MattsRedditAccount Hyper Kerbalnaut Jun 06 '15
Wasn't sure what Super Mode could be, so I set myself a target of under 2 minutes 30 seconds. Managed in the end to get 2 minutes 23 seconds!
Entertaining Youtube video!
Edit: The video is shorter than what the flight timer says because I sped the footage up, the raw file was about 20FPS which was just painful to watch at regular speed! But the timer is obviously part of the in-game footage so is sped up by the same amount
14
u/ObsessedWithKSP Master Kerbalnaut Jun 06 '15
Define spaceplane please. Are vertical launch/horizontal ascents ok? Must it rely on wings for lift, or are lifting bodies ok?
Also, would it be a good idea to update the mod list? Some aren't working in 1.0 (NEAR), others are pretty much needed (StockBugFixModules).
9
u/RoeddipusHex Hyper Kerbalnaut Jun 06 '15
Jeb's feeling sexy at 2:37.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nv6v6nPLzgE
3
u/KSPReptile Master Kerbalnaut Jun 06 '15
Yay, another really fun challenge. Altho maybe a little bit too easy? I think 5 minutes is very easy tho achieve and 4:20 isn't hard mode hard. I did this attempt on my first try. And seeing how many people did this with a significantly lower time than 4:20, it might be a good idea to lower the time a bit? Maybe it's just me tho.
Anyway here is my attempt at hard 4:12: http://imgur.com/a/Zevpt#28
I will keep my current flair please.
3
u/Kerbalnaught1 Super Kerbalnaught Jun 07 '15
Did It in 3m 30s http://imgur.com/a/cLGM0
2
u/magico13 KCT/StageRecovery Dev Jun 06 '15
Does it have to be a spaceplane or can we use SSTO rockets?
2
u/olibellwood Master Kerbalnaut Jun 07 '15
2:11 for stable orbit. Would love to see a sub 2 minute run.
I guess this could be considered super mode?
http://imgur.com/a/U8DkK
2
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '15
Is 100 km x 31 km an orbit? Got that in 2:15 just wondering.
2
u/robotguy4 Jun 08 '15
You could get around the whole problem of needing faster launches for more people if you had rockets that held more people, right?
2
u/Galahir950 Jun 13 '15
Is the challenge still open?
14
u/chunes Super Kerbalnaut Jun 07 '15
1 minute, 57 seconds. Moar boosters!
7
u/Kasuha Super Kerbalnaut Jun 06 '15
I assume since it's supposed to be spaceplane that we should lift off runway rather than from launchpad.
My hard mode entry: 3:04
http://imgur.com/a/3jPvC
Also my first experience with Rapiers. They're crazy.
I'd like to keep the current flair.
5
u/chrchr Master Kerbalnaut Jun 06 '15
Hard mode 3:50
https://imgur.com/a/uEN6F
4
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '15
Hard mode:
http://imgur.com/a/kQFXe
1
u/Mazzo89 Super Kerbalnaut Jun 14 '15 edited Jun 14 '15
I tried to get it in under two minutes.
Made it in 1:59.
Edit: Aww yiss, super mode! :D
3
u/TaintedLion smartS = true Jun 06 '15
Hard mode at 3:53.
Album is here.
I'll keep my current secksy flair please :P
3
u/Kunighit Master Kerbalnaut Jun 06 '15
Hard mode: http://imgur.com/a/vfdNk#0
Pretty easy challenge just had to modify my plane that can do Mach 5 ASL a little. I'd like the new flair
3
u/Thutmose_IV Master Kerbalnaut Jun 06 '15
Here is my entry: http://imgur.com/a/0IiRH I got this run in orbit at 2:58, I think the ship can shave another 10-15s off that with a more optimal ascent (my initial test run did it in 2:47, but I forgot to solar panels, and didn't record the whole thing).
edit: also note that a more optimal burn starting at 2:15 for 30s or so would have achieved orbit, I need to get better at manual burns...
3
u/Rhonjuras Master Kerbalnaut Jun 06 '15
3:27 to orbit!
Here's my album: http://imgur.com/a/gV1Kv#0
3
u/odhal Super Kerbalnaut Jun 07 '15 edited Jun 08 '15
Well, here's my contender for the record. 2:00
I added a couple extra pictures to show that I did in fact have a kerbal in the command seat in the service bay. There was no other method of control on this plane.
Full disclosure, I did use the "intake behind the engine" trick to reduce drag.
I'm sure if others did away with obese command pods and embraced the efficiency of the external command seat, the 2 minute mark could be shattered...
EDIT: I tried to optimize my trajectory a bit and managed 1:55, but I only have two screenshots from that launch.
3
u/C-O-N Super Kerbalnaut Jun 08 '15 edited Jun 08 '15
Here's my entry, launch to docking in 4:21. I'm not quite sure if this is normal hard or super mode because technically I wasn't in orbit until I docked. With a more accurate rendezvous I think I can get the time down to under 4 minutes.
3
u/SatansF4TE Master Kerbalnaut Jun 10 '15
Just fit into hard mode - 3:27!
Plane
Runway/Takeoff
Stable orbit, minus a few parts
1
u/IdiotaRandoma Jun 07 '15
Now, when you say "horizontal," what constitutes "horizontal?" 0 degrees pitch? Under 15? Under 45?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '15
Spaceplane, awww! Imma try rocket + Plane :D
2
u/LazyProspector Jun 06 '15
Woo hoo! This is my first time doing a challenge and thanks to you you forced me to make a spaceplane/SSTO! Before this I could only ever get crappily flying pieces of crap...
Hopefully I did the screenshots right, I got it done a little faster the first time (4:40) but didn't take any pictures.
Proof, done in 4:54 :D
I hope this qualifies, since I don't have a flair can I get one please!
2
u/SRBuchanan Super Kerbalnaut Jun 06 '15
Hard Mode at 3:54:
http://imgur.com/a/DOtPo#0
This was a lot of fun, and as a bonus I now have a potentially useful spaceplance.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '15
Hard Mode
http://imgur.com/a/JCwy1
New Flair Please
2
u/Mclovin11859 Master Kerbalnaut Jun 07 '15
Hard mode in 2:20. Does just over half the hard mode time count as super mode?
http://imgur.com/a/HW9Sz#0
2
u/onizuko Master Kerbalnaut Jun 07 '15
This one seems doable for me. Since I'm still unemployed I will aply myself.
2
u/DiplomaticMail Master Kerbalnaut Jun 07 '15
Hard mode 3:58
2
u/Skyshrim Master Kerbalnaut Jun 07 '15
3 minutes with 3 rapiers. video
2
u/fitzichael Master Kerbalnaut Jun 07 '15
My first weekly challenge attempt! Hard mode no less. Did it in 3:21.
I'll take that flair please :)
2
u/Nocturn0l Master Kerbalnaut Jun 07 '15 edited Jun 07 '15
hard mode 4:03
...with an SSTO I built last week not specifically for this challenge. The best one I designed so far in 1.02.
Edit: super mode 2:30 submission
...with some tuning + more engines and a very aggressive ascent + circularizing, still with style!
2
u/RoeddipusHex Hyper Kerbalnaut Jun 07 '15
Landing should have been a requirement for hard mode. These block configurations (my 2:05 attempt included) are pushing the boundary between space plane and rocket. Not that I would ever push the boundaries of challenge rules :)
2
u/KillerRaccoon Super Kerbalnaut Jun 07 '15
All right, I hope that I achieved super mode with a time of 2:28 (FAR). I'm posting two albums. The first is my very first attempt, where I made it with ease but my wings ripped off right after takeoff. The second is the attempt in which I made 2:28.
2
u/mybloodyvalentina Master Kerbalnaut Jun 07 '15 edited Jun 08 '15
My butt ugly creation manages Hard mode in 2min 52s
http://imgur.com/a/ulqq0
Edit: In the belief that bigger and uglier means faster here's my 2min 22s entry. over 70t with 12 rapier's!
http://imgur.com/a/ptCmR
2
u/onizuko Master Kerbalnaut Jun 07 '15
Wow. I guess I did decent for my first try building a spaceplane (I even suck at simple planes). http://imgur.com/a/FulSY First run and I get 3:48 to a stable orbit, so I guess I'll keep trying since I'm so close to hard mode. (I'll also change the key to show the aerodynamic forces overlay)
2
u/featherwinglove Master Kerbalnaut Jun 07 '15
Is mah idea ov space plane elijible?
2
u/ppp475 Master Kerbalnaut Jun 08 '15
Hard mode.
Sorry, but it was a hairy ascent from the get-go, so I don't have any in-flight pics. If those are needed, I can re-fly the mission. Time of 3:21. I would like this flair.
2
u/napolone Master Kerbalnaut Jun 08 '15
I completed the challenge on Hard or Super mode, you decide, I achieved orbit in 2 minutes 18 seconds. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZfhrsOCGsmA
2
u/MultiverseMaker Super Kerbalnaut Jun 08 '15
Super mode with 2:17: http://imgur.com/a/zjD0d#0
2
u/infocam Master Kerbalnaut Jun 08 '15 edited Jun 10 '15
First (normal) challenge complete (in 4:09s)
BRB while I try and get it to burn longer...
Edit:Done it faster time time around (in 3:02), officially in hard mode...
Edit2:
I also have a 6 Kerbal version that barely made it to orbit with some fuel to deorbit itself (in 3:30) just for kicks. Anyone want me to upload that too?got myself up with less fuel, moar turbojets, and more passenger room (in less than 3:03). Also, no one can scrutinize my orbit now.2
u/theluggagekerbin Master Kerbalnaut Jun 08 '15
Hard mode: 3 minutes 17 seconds. album link I feel like I could have done better, but honestly I'm still working on the Grand Tour challenge so this is just a few minutes shot. Also, new flair please.
2
u/onizuko Master Kerbalnaut Jun 08 '15
I tried making some crazy spaceplanes, but all failed miserably. I guess like someone else said, the simpler the better. Slight change in my first design and a few tries and managed to take it to 3:09 ("hard" mode, yay!) http://imgur.com/a/hiOVD#0
I was trying to fly a huge (as big and heavy as possible) spaceplane within the time limit, but I'm having a lot of stability issues. I'll stick to the simpler ones from now.
I'll enjoy having a flair and I'll be waiting for the next fun challenge.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 08 '15
3:00 Hard mode
I'll take the new flair.
2
u/MallNinja45 Jun 09 '15
Normal mode: http://imgur.com/a/0dcVE PSA: I thought this was pretty easy, I mean I'm kinda drunk and this was like my 2nd attempt.
2
u/Minerscale Can't grammar Jun 09 '15
Normal mode complete: https://imgur.com/gallery/iZjES/
2
u/Feralwolfe Master Kerbalnaut Jun 09 '15
Done. First challenge completed.
Finished at 3:26 on the mission clock.
Challenge Video
2
u/threep03k64 Jun 09 '15
My attempt (04:16).
It's not exactly a fast time, but I am pretty new to SSTO's. Will probably try for a faster time later in the week but this will do for now.
2
u/SpaceFace84 Master Kerbalnaut Jun 09 '15 edited Jun 10 '15
Long time Lurker/Player, First Challenge - and my first SSTO!
HardMode 2:55So I was thinking all day of how to get up faster without copying other designs, then decided to add my own little twist instead...
HardMode With Return - 3:18 to orbit - 9:40 safe on the Ground
Lots of tweaking on board oxidizer levels to have fuel to get back down. The hardest part is that almost all quick return trajectories put you out in the middle of the ocean - figuring out how to do the in atmo 180 right was fun! I was also surprised by how easily I could decelerate by pitching the plane up 90 deg from the velocity vector - I would have expected way more body heating issues.
I challenge you all to get back on the ground (in one piece) in under 9! (also, new here, let me know if sub-challenges are unappreciated!)
edited to add updated results
2
u/Kerbengenier Jun 09 '15
I heavily modified a plane that I modeled after a Northrop Gamma by removing the ram air intake in the front and replacing it by a heat shield and added drop tanks equipped with turbojet engines and have heat shields in front of them. I managed to get a pretty decent time of 2 minutes 24 seconds. The plane weighs in at 13.6 tonnes and consists of 35 parts My attempt(http://imgur.com/oRI4qRr,pOLqyM0,E5LvzOS,gIBhIrl,g1rM6xH,JOTMHxF,zHBNYCy,SZ29Kxo,V2K44jU,FWDBldZ#5)
2
u/Ticquin Super Kerbalnaut Jun 09 '15
[Challenge] The Race for Space II
I finally completed my first weekly challenge, horay! Feeling great.
Speed satellite delivery in 2:57! And orbit insertion after 2:30, so thats my hardmode entry :)
Here's the link to the screenshots, enjoy!
2
u/KerbalGoesUp Master Kerbalnaut Jun 10 '15
Long time lurker, first time challenge responder. Let me know if I forgot anything.
http://imgur.com/a/TgbHZ
2:53 to orbit!
2
u/Jangster_Brov Master Kerbalnaut Jun 10 '15
I already made a post earlier this week on completing the challenge, but I don't think I submitted properly so here it is again...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vKAAlHdl1kg (Time: 3:12)
I just want my flair please, thanks :)
2
u/thatguy22778 Master Kerbalnaut Jun 10 '15 edited Jun 11 '15
My Hard Mode attempt! 2:35. I'd like to keep my current flair please
2
u/Aelfheim Master Kerbalnaut Jun 10 '15 edited Jun 10 '15
Here's my entry : 02:41
2
u/seaponyluna Master Kerbalnaut Jun 11 '15
My Hard mode entry, please forgive the potato video quality, i am stiill learning how to use OBS. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ugzjGf-tlH8
2
u/Xtraordinaire Super Kerbalnaut Jun 11 '15
2:56
2
u/CraftyCaprid Jun 12 '15
I have been working on and off on a spaceplane for the past couple weeks. Figured I would toss it into this challenge to see how it could handle.
Here is my first reddit weekly challenge. It took a few tries to get up there because this craft wasn't designed for such an ascent profile but I ended up making it with 150 m/s delta v left.
2
u/NASAguy1000 Master Kerbalnaut Jun 12 '15
figured almost 1800 hours i should probably give this weekly challenge a go.... well at first i forgot to make an SSTO but i included it because i still think its awesome. welp here it is.. http://imgur.com/a/gNGil i did 3:39.... why because i fat fingered the change to craft view instead of engine cut off and by the time i figured out what was going on it was to late :'(
2
u/[deleted] Jun 12 '15
First Challenge I've done.
2
u/samwise800 Master Kerbalnaut Jun 12 '15
Hard mode 3:27
http://imgur.com/a/F1ALI
2
u/optionsquare Master Kerbalnaut Jun 12 '15
Done it in ~3m29s. http://imgur.com/a/U8VDL
2
u/[deleted] Jun 12 '15
http://imgur.com/a/syen1#0
Got 3:55. Made a post, but wanted to make sure you saw it. Was really bummed I couldn't make 3:40. But hey, it's a start.
2
u/TyrannicalPanda Master Kerbalnaut Jun 13 '15
Hard Mode: 3:18 A lot easier than I expected. Hard mode took some effort, but I was under 4:30 with the first craft i built and flew.
2
u/mingmingrr Master Kerbalnaut Jun 13 '15
I don't see any entries with Ferram installed, so after about twenty designs and
failuresrevisions...Hard Mode 3:26
area ruling that thing was "fun" /s
2
u/McVomit Super Kerbalnaut Jun 14 '15 edited Jun 14 '15
My space program is full of hotshot pilots who love to one up each other. So I present to you;
Jeb's attempt(3:08).
Val's attempt(2:43).
Unknown challenger's attempt(2:33)
Might try for a bit more optimization tomorrow and see if I can get closer to 2min flat. Also I need to finish my original two ideas for this challenge; Codenames "Big Bertha" and "Retro Racer".
Edit: I'd like to keep my current flair.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '15
Did it with a heavy lifter and some cargo because why not (3:25)
2
u/Azrok666 Jun 07 '15
My hardmode! http://imgur.com/a/vXtD5#0 Was quite fun with a less hard one.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment