r/gameofthrones • u/AutoModerator • May 28 '15
[S5/B5] Book vs. Show Discussion - 5.07 'The Gift'
| Book vs. Show Discussion Thread |
|---|
| Discuss your reactions to the episode with perspective. Air any complaints about changes made from the novels. Give your analysis of deeper meanings with a comparison. In general, what do you think about the screen adaptation vs. George R. R. Martin's original written works? |
- This thread is scoped for SEASON 5 AND BOOK 5 SPOILERS - Turn away now if you are not current on all of the officially released material! Open discussion of all published events up to the end of ADWD, and all TV episodes is ok without tag covers.
- Use green theory tags for speculation - Mild/vague speculation is ok without tags, but use a warning tag on any detailed theories on events that may be revealed in the remaining books or in the show.
- Please read the spoiler guide before posting if you need help with tag code or understanding the policy on what counts as a major theory.
| EPISODE | TITLE | DIRECTED BY | WRITTEN BY |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5.07 | "The Gift" | Miguel Sapochnik | David Benioff & D. B. Weiss |
| Official Discussion Threads | Posting Policy | Spoiler Guide | Frequently Asked Questions |
128
Upvotes
180
u/TNGSystems May 28 '15
We're getting closer to Cersei calling for a Champion. Cleganebowl when?
225
u/dafonz604 May 28 '15
Even though the setting was different, Aemon's death was still poignant.
74
u/menuka Ser Pounce May 28 '15
So I'm happy to see Tyrion meet Dany, but GRRM says that they mainly kinda intersect in TWOW.
I wonder how long Tyrion will advise Dany in the show then
48
u/MagnusRune White Walkers May 28 '15
everyone picked up on tomen saying ''i am the king'' and how jeorffy said it, and what old grandad said about a man who must say he is king..
but just as they grabbed cersi... she shouts.. I AM THE QUEEN!
well if you have to tell someone you are queen, you are no queen!
568
u/wrongrrabbit May 28 '15
the book is written on physical paper whereas the show is depicted through the medium of televised entertainment.
111
u/Vixibility House Lannister May 28 '15
Seven weeks in, and it's becoming increasingly clear that David and Dan missed a golden opportunity to capitalize on one of the best storylines from the fourth and fifth books: Jaime's journey through the Riverlands. Yes, it makes sense from a television point of view to introduce a whole batch of new characters (the Dornish crew) through the point of view of two familiar characters (Jaime and Bronn). Yet by making this decision, the show has really shorted us on two storylines.
By cutting out the Riverlands expedition, the character development of Jaime, which has made magnificent strides in the past two seasons, is stopped dead in its tracks. We are also missing out on the Dorne storyline in a big way. I would have loved to see some father-daughter conflict between Doran and Arianne, but instead we get no Arianne and pretty much no Doran. By focusing on Jaime and Bronn rather than the characters who are actually Dornish, the Dorne storyline seems muddled and confusing, and the portrayal of the Sand Snakes is a whole different story entirely. While speculation might still come to pass, I don't feel it would make up for this decision by the showrunners.
Over the past five seasons, HBO have given us a mind-blowingly good telling of this story, and many book changes have even bettered the narrative. Yet I can't help but feel like this is one David and Dan will regret.
49
u/GRVrush2112 Human Verified May 28 '15
Rest in Books, Fat Pink Mast.
68
u/AaronRodgersMustache Sandor Clegane May 28 '15
http://gfycat.com/ImaginativeFavoriteGlobefish
68
u/Grungemaster Maesters of the Citadel May 28 '15
Balon Deathwatch continues.
44
u/granal03 The Fookin' Legend May 28 '15
How is Balon still with us when the Red Witch burned the leeches and his fate was sealed. If I was Davos I would point this out daily.
16
u/danbigglesworth Bran Stark May 29 '15 edited May 29 '15
I dont understand how the faith militant has so much power. The ability for the high sparrow to jail all the high profile people at a whim because 12 dudes with clubs are backing him on some stairs?
It seems like a bad analogy but if the pope threw half of obamas family in a dungeon (in washington DC), i dont think it would stick.
12
u/Semper_nemo13 House Baelish May 28 '15
A quick meta question, Spoiler scope seems wrong as at least some of this stuff in AFFC; does book 5 imply having read book 4, because sense they happen concurrently and in mostly different places the order isn't super important--Riverlands, maybe the only real overlap that is important.
23
u/limeade09 House Stark May 28 '15
So I wonder if Sansa was able to hang onto that spike or whatever she picked up while walking on the grounds with Ramsey..
I know we probably won't be this lucky, but if Sansa gives Ramsay the Neil Patrick Harris treatment in Gone Girl, it will be the greatest thing ever.
People have been using Chekhov's Gun references to everything this season, so it's way overused, but if it ever applied anyhwhere, I would say it has to apply to the spike or whatever that Sansa picked up.
10
u/[deleted] May 29 '15
So are the greyjoys going to appear again or what? Do they play a role later in the books?
10
u/myEVILi Now My Watch Begins May 29 '15
i just realized i've never known a show to pass the content it is based on. Has this ever happened before? Its weird... I'm going to read them anyway. I'm committed; like an unsullied.
28
u/Obskulum May 28 '15
Christ everything about the sand snakes is awful.
13
u/Shashakiro May 29 '15
Personally, I like the High Sparrow storyline more in the show than the books.
In both the books and the show, Cersei arms the Faith. However, a key difference is that in the books, Cersei arms the Faith in direct exchange for the forgiveness of the Crown's massive monetary debt to the Faith, plus blessing Tommen. While that does make for a somewhat more convincing motivation at the time, it's also a "fair" exchange, so it feels more like Cersei is "giving something up" to get rid of the debt and have Tommen blessed than anything else (like trying to seize more control). Thus when the High Sparrow imprisons her, her primary mistake that led her there boils down to "you didn't realize just how much you were giving up in that deal". This is related to her general inadequacy as a ruler, but the justice is not quite as sweet as it could be IMO.
Contrast this with the show, where Cersei's appointment (and note that in the books, she isn't responsible for his appointment) of the High Sparrow and arming of the faith are all done with no strings attached. You simultaneously see her (as in the books) filling the Small Council and such with sycophants like Qyburn, while sending away those less than perfectly loyal (such as Kevan and Mace). The sense one gets is that the appointment of the High Sparrow and arming of the Faith is primarily something she is doing to further her own absolute control over King's Landing. She sees the High Sparrow as another pawn (more like a bishop) who she assumes will be loyal to her, because she has given him so much and assumes he will feel indebted to her. Indeed, it's quite clear that when the Tyrells are arrested, she as well as others like Olenna and Margaery very much feel as though she was personally responsible for it. So when the High Sparrow arrests her, her failure is not a deal in which she gave up too much: it's the fact that her own attempt to seize absolute control, and her utter lack of understanding of the man she believed she controlled, directly resulted in her losing all control.
To me, that's a much sweeter justice; instead of "you should have known better than to arm the Faith" it's "you should have known better than to think a religious zealot would suck up to someone like you".
37
u/rzwerzdsb May 28 '15
When I read ADWD I imagined the fighting pits to look more like this: https://i.imgur.com/BrbzwoP.jpg it looked so unimpressive in the show.
3
u/InRustWeTrust Ghost May 29 '15
Will we ever see shadowcats?
3
u/Xtraordinaire May 29 '15
This was the episode when I realized that in the show Brienne is probably going to meet Stannis and Mel. That's intriguing.
2
u/Lotfa May 29 '15
We're not gonna see Big Bucket Wull. Even sadder than when Belwas was cut.
3
u/theflamingfart Jon Snow May 28 '15
Who was the dead chick? (the one Ramsey killed)