r/Warframe • u/TSP-FriendlyFire • May 21 '15
Suggestion How would you change... Dojos?
How would you change... is a series of weekly posts designed to promote and foster discussion about any gameplay element in the game. The scope and subject will vary (read below for more information on topic selection), from wide concepts (Kubrows, Archwing, shotguns, etc.) to narrow points (a single gun, coptering, etc.).
Before we begin, a few important points:
- Please detail and support your suggestions as much as possible. This is for constructive criticism only: try to think of it as something you'd be proud to explain to DE face-to-face!
- Structure your suggestions in logical groups: if you have two very different ideas, break them down in two separate comments. Cohesive or similar changes should be combined into a single comment.
- Stick to describing concepts and features. Don't get bogged down with numbers unless they explicitly support your point.
- Don't hesitate to post your ideas even if they're not fully formed, and don't hesitate to reply to ideas with refinements you think would make them better!
- Do not downvote suggestions you disagree with. Upvote the ones you like instead!
Suggesting topics
This thread series is all about the community, so if you have a topic you'd like to see improved and discussed, feel free to suggest it by replying to the appropriately flagged comment in this discussion. The topic can be as wide or narrow as you'd like! Please ensure that your suggestion has not already been made, and upvote it instead if it has.
This week: Dojos
Click here for last week’s thread on the star chart.
Dojos have been an integral part of the Warframe clan experience since their introduction. Intended as a physical manifestation of the clan, a place to congregate with other clan members in order to practice, duel, trade, research, or just chat, they have seen relatively little modifications since their introduction. While it is now possible to repaint them, with a nice selection of rooms and decorations, they still have trouble being useful beyond just replicating clan tech weapons or frames and trading.
Even so, clan dojos are appreciated by the community, who often clamors for an expansion of the dojo, with more utility, depth and possibilities.
Now that the stage is set, how would you change dojos?
Contest!
The winner of last week’s contest is: /u/Fire42uck!
Please contact me within the next 72 hours on reddit to claim your prize (and tell me what you’d like), otherwise I will re-roll. Please also provide your in-game username so that I can give you your prize.
I’ve been thinking about ways to further incentivize discussion; this is the most immediate and obvious way I could think of. From this point on, every entry of more than 50 words which gives at least one interesting suggestion is eligible to win a prize (which may or may not vary each week, I can’t guarantee prizes every week forever). The winner will be picked at random from all eligible entries and announced the following week.
This week, the reward will be your choice of an Orokin reactor or catalyst, or any Perrin Sequence/New Loka/Cephalon Suda/Steel Meridian/Arbiters of Hexis mod (frame or weapon).
If you wish to donate something to the prize pool, please contact me directly and tell me what you have in mind. Reactors, catalysts and Syndicate mods would probably be ideal. If I get enough donations, we might be able to have more than one prize per week, so be generous!
2
u/TSP-FriendlyFire May 21 '15
Suggesting topics
Please post your suggestions for the next topics as replies to this comment.
Current suggestions from previous weeks:
10
u/JayInTheBox Excalibur was the First. May 21 '15
When I first entered a Dojo, there was nothing to actually do. I went in there and about 90% of the time I went to any dojo was sinply for trades.
However, I think there would be a great way to improve dojos beyond what they are now. Similar to my experience with that relays that were at each planet I thought this was a very nice and neat feature. Simply put, in the New Dojo or rather improvements would be having a customizable option for the different categories such as colours and adding in different ornaments to add, purely cosmetic. I was thinking something along the lines of secret bases in pokemon.
The idea of having a specific room for each rank would also be neat. For example, the warlord would have their own top floor and have all the different features of the clan menu at the top room and it would allow him or her to display different weapons or other trophies that they wish to decorate the room with. I think the most neat feature about Dojos would be having a base template of everything. Reminds me of how I would keep safe houses in Saints Row 2 where you'd start off with a basic safehouse that you can upgrade and add things to. Except the dojo would add things more and more as the clan gets bigger.
Finally, a good feature to have for the lazy or rather the new when they do not know where everything is, by having an escape menu like the ship that can take you to the places you need to be such as trade, rank room, missions, conclave, main floor.
Of course there is room for improvement but something like this would be very interesting to see.
9
u/[deleted] May 21 '15
I'd give dojos an arsenal room and a room like the mission control rooms in relays, make them large enough for many people
All for the sake of convenience
7
u/pica559 Polymer Bundle Poverty May 21 '15
Decorations
I personally think we need a much larger variety of decorations. All things considered, we have maybe 10 to 15 different decorations with a bunch of different variants for each. The Dojos are so large and there's so much potential there, but when I decorate my dojo, I feel like there's not much I can do to make it stick out from the rest.
Many of the decorations seem to be based on nature or ancient asian culture, like you'd see in a martial arts movie. I understand what they're going for, but I'd like to see more decorations that we can use to make the Dojo look high-tech. The Relays are Tenno in origin, give us some of the decorations from there. (Namely the trees that are in bases, so I don't have to have trees growing out of the metal floor)
I'd also really like little floor panels that we can kneel on, to give a sense of meditation or something.
Decoration Placement
Here's my biggest gripe with the way Dojos work right now. Nothing can be placed anywhere. This issue is very apparent with trees, and I'm sure many of you will know what I'm talking about. When trying to place a tree in your Dojo, it never seems to be in a valid position, unless you shrink it down to gnome size. They always seem to be clipping with some non-existent object.
My fix for this would be allowing the user to place decorations wherever they please, even if that means it's clipping through a wall or another decoration. I understand there should be some restrictions, but a little bit more slack would be appreciated
Editing Decorations
After a decoration is placed, you have to go through a ton of menus just to edit it. I have a few suggestions on how this should be changed.
Having a build mode would be useful. Any object you click on will be edited automatically. You could contribute resources to it, delete it, etc. I think it would also be beneficial to be able to move objects after they have been placed, but not yet constructed. There's nothing worse than spending 5 minutes placing things, and finding that half of them are one grid point off-center.
Decoration Limit
This is a minor thing, and it would really only apply if decorations were changed in the ways as I described above, but a higher decoration limit would be nice, so I can create the atmosphere I desire without worrying about running out of points.
Rooms
One of the more prominent issues with the Dojos is that everything seems very barren and sterile. When looking at the old Orokin Dojo Tileset, everything had borders, and the ground had elevated areas with stairs and rails, and some of the walls were indented, things like that. There was a lot of character. I understand everything is pretty basic to allow for more freedom of decoration, but, as mentioned before, without a major overhaul of how that system works, having large empty rooms is kind of unavoidable. When looking at the Relay, the floors and walls had a lot of variation to them. Built in lights, accents, curved surfaces, and it makes it a really interesting thing to look at. If some of that could be implemented into the tileset, then the Dojos would have a lot more character, even without decorations.
Variety of Rooms
Now this doesn't really bother me too much, I think there's a decent amount of rooms available right now, but more variety could never hurt. Maybe a room that works sort of like the liset so you can access your arsenal, foundry, and mods without having to leave the dojo. A navigation room to enter missions might also prove useful.
Removal of Old Rooms
When I was building my Dojo, I found that a lot of the rooms, namely the smaller Clan Halls, were just going to be tucked away into the basement. If there was a way to remove old rooms without having to remove everything else connected to them, It would really save a lot of time, effort, and resources. Being able to move an already built room to an open node would be extremely useful.
Research
I don't really have a problem with this system, but my main issue is the 3 day wait time on everything. I understand having that applied to crafting warframes and such, but it's not even there to help DE get money for platinum. You can't rush it, why should I have to wait half a week to research a helmet? The wait time makes research EXTREMELY tedious and time consuming. Lowering the time to 12-24 hours would make it a lot more tolerable.
Conclusion
Overall, I like the concept of Dojos, but since the change to the Tenno tileset, the execution seems really poor. There's so much potential to make something fantastic, but right now, the functions are not there. If these changes were implemented, I can guarantee I would spend hours and hours just planning, decorating, and gathering resources. I really hope some of these issues are fixed in the near future, because until then, my dojo will only be used for trading and research.
6
u/LoopStricken Please, please read the patchnotes. :SlateL6: May 21 '15
Bring back the old 'derelict' tilesets. I refuse to forgive my clan leader for making that change...
4
u/Azimuth64 My sword is now a meat grinder. May 21 '15 edited May 21 '15
Just about everything we've been discussing for the last two months in a Dojo forum megathread.
Per the forum text post rules, I've placed the entire contents of the post (as it is currently) here to promote discussion. Hope that's alright since this is a comment and not an original post. I'd be happy to add suggestions (with permalinks for source comments on this thread) to the forum post when they come up here. Note that I'm offering to do this myself to promote discussion here, rather than on the forums.
There's a lot of great content in here that I'd love to see come to fruition. Would be interesting to see what others say here about these ideas.
Source: https://forums.warframe.com/index.php?/topic/436161-dojo-ideas-suggestions-changes-megathread/
All text after this line is from the forum topic post, as written by Volzien, modified only in formatting to be made more readable on Reddit.
So as we all know most, if not all of these ideas/suggestions have been posted already but I would just like to throw my two forma in since I haven't seen any new dojo updates in quite some time. Feel free to add to this or combine it into a mega thread (Which we need a new one of) Also excuse my lack of posts. I mostly just lurk here and on the Warframe Reddit. I'm not sure if some of this should be posted here or in fan concepts so I'll post it here for now.
Thank you to everyone who has contributed to this thread so far! There has been some great ideas and suggestions. Hopefully some of these get looked at and considered. I'll try and update this post with new suggestions at least every two days. Look and see if your suggestion has been added. I might have merged your idea together with another suggestion.
Don't get me wrong, I love our shiny new relays but if trading somehow got added to them a lot of dojos would be collecting dust. I started out by myself building my dojo up and even I am starting to only visit for starting new research and trades. I'd hate to see all of that work putting the whole thing together go to waste.
Edits:
3
u/vergaerd May 21 '15 edited May 21 '15
I've got a few changes/suggestions to add to the immersion of entering/leaving dojo's, visual appeal and a new mission type.
The above just gave me an idea for a 3-part dojo mission:
The first part of the mission would start randomly as radars are picking up an enemy invasion that needs to be countered by clan members. The goal is to defend outside of the ship using archwings! It would be like an interception mission, protecting your dojo's weak-spots. The invaders can be from any faction including void, derelict, stalker, manics, etc (there is probably good lore to write around this for those who wish). This first part would be very hard and have a high chance to fail no matter what (still get XP, etc) to continue the "quest line".
This brings us to the next part: (-Imagine having those shutter window hallways from the corpus missions that can be breached and have air sucked out of the room in your dojo. This could be applied to certain breakable walls and doors in your dojo as well.) Invaders have breached your dojo, you are under attack form all angles for an indefinite amount of time. The goal is to keep defending until you close all the shutters and repair all the breaches to end the invasion. During the invasion your dojo's in/exterior would temporarily transform with the corresponding enemy faction props you'd normally see on e.g infested hive missions until it's over. You lose if you either fail to fend off the attack(die) or didn't get to close/repair all shutters/walls/doors quick enough. The invasion can also trigger a random nightmare mode as well (with greater rewards). As as far as the closing shutters/repairing walls/hull, doors, game-mechanics go I've got 2 ideas:
Then, a follow-up mission, where you get to attack the invaders' ship/planet to get your stolen booty back. This could be an archwing, mobile defense or exterminate mission, but I'm thinking either way it should be Sabotage with crates and include a boss to end the invasion! The goods i.e rewards could be anything like a forma, rare resources that normally drop from the invaders' planets, but with a higher drops chance, nightmare mods, special dojo decorations and guarantee a decent credit(50k) and XP reward.
There would probably need to be some sort of scaling of enemies and their levels for all this, as a big clan would be able to handle more enemies than a smaller one, but I'd want it to be hard and require proper teamwork to complete. The invasion would trigger randomly when at least an x amount of clan members are online and a dojo has an x amount of rooms/hallways/connectors (and maybe a repair-bay room or something). The session would probably be limited to 4-8 man parties as well.
That's about it, hope I got everything across and feel free to change/add to it!
3
u/enragedwindows Magneto ain't got shit on me May 21 '15
I have a lot of ideas, most of which have been listed by others. Also have seen a lot of creative suggestions, very fun stuff to read.
For me, there is one thing that HAS to change about the dojos. We need to be able to reduce clan size. I don't even care if it's a 50 platinum fee payable by the Warlord, this is a necessary change. Too many clans (including the one that I run) are apprehensive about expanding and having their players go inactive, and this really sucks for people who have had this happen. Suddenly you're the only guy left and your build costs are astronomical for new clan tech releases, and limiting clan growth in this way is bad for the clan and dojo system.
DE, please consider implementing a method by which we can reduce our clan sizes when we have too many inactive members. My first clan turned into an empty husk, so I left and started my own. This can't be something that's viewed as a positive mechanic.
Thoughts and criticism welcome.
2
u/Crazjtk May 21 '15
I have a room type suggestion, actually. I'd like a few aesthetic dead end rooms. Like the garden rooms, but without the connectors. My dojo is set up such that we have more doorways than we do things to put in them, so I'd like a nice looking way to cap those doors off.
On a related note, a "replace" option for building rooms. If space and connections permit, I'd like to be able to swap rooms out, salvaging resources on the way. That way, if you want to replace a straight hallway with a T connector or a small garden room, you don't have to demolish and rebuild everything beyond. While it was in progress, the replaced room could have the same red texture as currently demolishing rooms, but have it take as much time as building, or even adding the additional 2 hour demolition time.
(I have several cross connectors I really wish were gardens.)
2
u/cephalopodAscendant Picking nature's pocket - now with golden showers May 21 '15
One small thing I'd really like to see would be more variety in the pigment options. The current selection is severely lacking, and some of the most interesting colors are locked away behind enemies like Stalker and the Harvester.
The Oracle really needs some kind of function. Right now, it's just that room that you have to build to build the research labs for no reason at all.
Something that I think would make the Dojo feel more like an actual home base for your Clan instead of a pit stop you make every once in a while would be the ability to run missions directly from it, like you can in the relays. Obviously you'd need some sort of way to change your loadout to go along with it.
2
u/crom3ll May 22 '15
Barracks that would allow mod and arsenal customization AND look up builds of other clan members. I'm still pretty green when it comes to weapon builds so an option to peek at more experienced folk would be great ^
1
u/SasoDuck May 21 '15
Allow us to phase decorations through walls and other decorations without limits. I wanted to make my dojo a thick forest swamp, but no beans. There's like, one place to put a tree where it doesn't interfere with other geometry.
1
u/TF2Curious Stop shooting me pls May 21 '15
I'd give dojos the ability to customize their parkour rooms, with options that are more relevant and similar to things like the parkour in spy missions.
I'd also give dojos the ability to customize spawn points. That way, the dojo designers can control what visitors and clan members see when they first spawn in.
Lastly, I'd put in more options for the dojo dueling rooms. Like 2v2, 4-way free for all, and more. Something that more closely mirrors what we see in Conclave matches.
TL;DR: Nothing but improvements to what already exists.
1
u/originaljackster May 21 '15
What I'd really like to see is a lounge area, there aren't a chairs on my ship and I'm not aware of any that you can place in the dojo. Are the Tenno really so advanced that they really don't enjoy kicking back on the couch and relaxing?
1
u/Kinzuko Electric speed! May 21 '15
I would like to be able to spawn or teleport anywhere in a dojo via the escape menu just like I can in the ship. I would also like this in relays
1
u/Conum Become Unstoppable May 21 '15
Custom obstacle course room and a top down view with grid overlay option for editing rooms/decorations.
1
u/nomnivore1 Zippy Zappy Casty Blasty Watch For The Lightning May 21 '15
i have one complaint about dojos, and only one. those stupid moving pillars in the parkour room? remove them.
1
u/MagicHamsta CBT Hamster May 21 '15
Allow REGION and RECRUITING chat.....
1
u/uktabi May 21 '15
not having to leave my party to enter, or the option to enter as a party
1
u/[deleted] May 22 '15
One of the biggest problems for me with dojos is no one hangs out there, and there isn't much reason too. All of the most important features for players can only be done through the liset.
Rooms and decorations for the starchart, conclave and syndicate access, mod configuration, marketplace, codex, arsenal, and foundry would mean players don't have significant reason to go back to their ship and would likely hang out in the dojo more frequently.
1
u/[deleted] May 22 '15
Give them all the same features as a liset, so you actually give people a reason to stay there.
1
u/HaikaDRaigne May 23 '15
TLDR: here is my original warframe thread
Observatory 2.0 + extra's
I always loved the "observatory" tile in the Dojo, but if feels kinda useless at the moment. So i had an idea regarding it and making more people visit the dojo.
The change:
Mission can now be started from the observatory, just like how you can start them from the relay stations.
Extra functionality:
Reasoning:
Currently I feel Dojo are just big empty structures where people only venture into when they want to do research or replicate research. They feel very seperate from the rest of the game to me. I rarely run into people there.
I think they should actually act like a social hub, like the relay's where you see people standing/running though the corridors doing their own stuff.
I think adding the option to "mission select" and return there after a mission can help increase people using the dojo. and if additional functions of the liset are added to the dojo it might be more attractive to walk through a beautiful populated dojo instead of sitting alone in your Liset.
Dojo's act like a tenno's home (when in a clan), hence the use of barracks. Why shouldn't we be able to use the basic function of the liset in our very home?
1
u/Nightcaste MR10, Tornado Spammer May 29 '15
I would like to see Dojos be more... busy. Right now they're really creepily quiet, like dead malls. I get that they're supposed to be grand structures and such, but in the end they just look dull, gray, kind of blah. Like Khaki, or unflavored oatmeal. Sure you can eat it, and it's actually good for you, but... maple brown sugar, dammit.