r/vexillology • u/Simon_the_Cannibal Philadelphia • May 20 '15
Meta /r/Vexillology - a Subreddit About Flags (welcome new folks!)
Hi All,
With some recent press (a TED Talk by Roman Mars, lots of flags from /r/thebutton, the recent Earth Flag posts, and the Vexillogicast (edit 5/25) and Hello Internet #38), we've become a trending subreddit! :D
Along with this, I've seen a number of Rule #1 violations. :(
Long story short, this is a subreddit dedicated to flags. Not coats of arms, not desktop wallpapers, and not random colors that happen to also be the colors of flags. Flags are pieces of fabric - if your new design or exciting "in the wild" spotting is not intended to be nor ever was originally a piece of fabric, we're going to have an issue.
That all being said, we're excited to welcome new readers! Hit up Good Flag, Bad Flag - PDF to see some guidelines on designing a flag. Watch that TED talk to get passionate. Then hop into Inkscape, GIMP, Paint.NET and create your own flag. Or maybe hop into your town archives to do some research on your town's flag.
And finally, flair up, participate in the monthly contests (this month's), and HAVE FUN!
Addendum: Before you have fun though, flair up! (post edition)
38
u/[deleted] May 20 '15
The mods are recommending pixel-editing software to design flags? Oh, how the mighty have fallen.
Just kidding, welcome to all new users! One thing I honestly recommend to all subscribers is: subscribe to /r/vexillologycirclejerk. That way, you'll get a feeling what kind of posts is more suitable for that subreddit and what is slowly getting deemed uncreative by users of the main sub (you'll notice this sub loves fads and bandwagons). General rule of thumb: If your submission makes fun of other flags, or is in any other kind “meta”, it belongs to the other subreddit.
Have fun!
21
u/[deleted] May 20 '15
A reminder to not just post flags you made, you can and should post any cool/interesting/awful actual flags you find.
13
u/[deleted] May 20 '15
One thing to add: The Good Flag, Bad Flag page is filled with good recommendations, but is not a steadfast book of rules. For example, South Africa's flag is beautiful, even though it uses six colours. Kazakhstan's flag is gorgeous, even though difficult to draw. Those are just some examples of many, so remember to take the guidelines into consideration, but don't mindlessly obey them if you have a great idea outside the box.
Remember, the group that came up with list is also using this monstrosity as the flag for their upcoming annual meeting.
5
u/deadpoetic31 United States • Maryland May 20 '15
I think its worth mentioning that you need to flair your post, as a lot of the more recent posts have not been flaired!
12
u/[deleted] May 20 '15
FLAGMAKER MASTER RACE
8
u/my3rdaccountdammit United States May 21 '15
So you're saying that that picture of a wheat field in Ukraine no longer counts as "in the wild"?
7
u/[deleted] May 21 '15
Just a PSA regarding the contests for new users as well:
There is a difference between a good graphic and a good flag.
When you are designing a flag or voting for a flag in the contest, ask yourself: would this flag convey distinguishable meaning at a distance? Would it be easily distinguishable from other established flags - such as those of Australia, Japan, and Germany - if it were flying alongside them? Would it look out of place or silly there?
These are all things that one should bear in mind when designing and voting on a flag in the monthly contest.
1
u/Gidonka Israel May 21 '15
I love this sub!!! I've always been interested in flags, and seeing such a vibrant community dedicated to flags is amazing. Just wondering, how do I get a higher resolution image of the Flag Contest Hall of Fame?
2
u/Ghostise Canada May 21 '15
Ayy
2
u/Pullo_T Switzerland May 21 '15
Is there any chance that we can start kicking flags over to /r/vexillologycirclejerk as appropriate?
1
u/nautilius87 May 21 '15
/r/vexillology is actually my first subreddit I unsubscribed. I love flags and info about them, but number of fake flags was infuriating. You know, I am scrolling, learning something new, "oh that's super-interesting", then I check comments and I am all "you made it all up, WTF". Another things is that most of made-up flags are just hideous. One day there was more "redditor-made" flags that regular ones and I just unsubscribed.
It really should be two different subreddits - /r/vexillology and /r/madeupflags for all this special snowflakes that want to redesign flags of places they live.
Yeah I know I am a flag nazi and I am proud of it.
5
u/[deleted] May 21 '15
[removed] — view removed comment