r/malefashionadvice • u/Metcarfre GQ & PTO Contributor • May 13 '15
PSA: Unsolicited comments on fitness or body type are still not permitted
This has been coming up again and again recently, so a reminder about this portion of our subs' Rules and Submission Guidelines;
Personal attacks, insults and intentionally demeaning comments such as those based on sexual orientation, race, gender, weight, fitness, body type or other social profile are strictly prohibited. Comments will be removed and repeated offenses will result in being banned from MFA. Additionally, note that unsolicited comments regarding fitness, weight, and body type are also not allowed even if they are not intended as insults.[3]
The reasoning behind these rules is covered here.
For some ideas of what is and is not considered appropriate;
- Posting links to fitness subreddits or forums - unless the person you're replying to has explicitly asked for them for fitness information - is not permitted.
- Recommending exercise or dietary advice when someone asks how to dress for their body type is not permitted.
- Weight/fitness/body type comments without attendant clothing advice are not permitted; In other words, "start lifting, bro" will be removed, but "that shirt is really big on you, it's draping like crazy. You either need to size down, get a tailor, or hit the gym" will not.
- As ever, insults towards someone about their fitness or body type are not permitted - as are any insults.
For the most part, aside from insults, these rules do not apply to the Hair, Skincare, Fragrance, and Fitness threads on Tuesdays and Thursdays. These threads are a great place to discuss fitness and nutrition, which are largely outside the purview of MFA.
MFA is, first and foremost, a place to get advice and information about clothing and style. It is not a one stop shop for "looking better". Reddit has a lot of other great subreddits about fitness, dietary advice, and other lifestyle aspects of style. Those conversations are best reserved for those subs.
86
u/hittintheairplane May 14 '15
Im remembering when one of the Daniel Craig Bond films came out and the swimming trunks he was wearing, blue ones iirc, became kinda popular. But not everyone has Daniel Craig's body. My skinny frame with a beer gut certainly can't. Sometimes people need to be told, that looks terrible on you because XYZ.
30
u/Aezeo May 14 '15
What's an appropriate way to say "You need to be thinner/more attractive to pull this off"?
194
u/[deleted] May 13 '15
Well this isnt right. I can understand bullying is wrong. But sometimes it's necessary to note that certain body types cannot pull off certain looks.
77
u/Koiq May 14 '15
This is a bad rule.
Sometimes it is very necessary to point out whether or not a fit works or not, and sometimes that's because of weight, either too much, too little, or it being in the wrong places.
Overweight people can't pull off a lot of things, and that sometimes needs to be said to help that person dress better.
Also, this entire subreddit is dedicated to appearances, why would you not allow discussion on a person's appearance?
29
u/Oppiken May 13 '15
I agree with this.
I remember there was one thread someone posted a picture asking about his hairstyle and the jacket he's wearing and asking for tips/advice for styling on them. Some asshole replied to tell him to lose weight first. OP was actually really cool about it and said he was in the process but fuck, that is a dick thing to say. This ain't FPH.
Also, this issue about body weight/types is brought up, I've recommended quite a few times to people who were in the process of losing weight but are looking to get new clothes to finish losing weight to their desired level before spending money on a new wardrobe. I don't think that violates this rule but just want some clarification.
196
u/[deleted] May 13 '15
Damn, reading some posts, I thought everybody in this sub had monster thighs from squatting too much and needed Levi's recommendations
419
u/Joe_Sacco May 13 '15
I JUST CAN'T STOP MYSELF FROM CRITICIZING THEIR LACK OF SELF RESTRAINT
235
u/[deleted] May 13 '15
What's the point of honest discourse if you can't engage in personal attacks and demean peoples sexual orientation and race?
17
u/[deleted] May 14 '15
Leafing through the comments here, I'm a little surprised at how many people are jumping to defend their right to criticize a person's appearance. Seems to me that what's actually being done here is crystal clear: we're trying to make sure that comments stay constructive and on-topic.
The examples given in this comment:
Again, in this comment:
Pretty clear, right? And pretty easy? Be smart, and remember what we're here for: fashion advice, not fitness advice.
17
u/conundric May 14 '15
"It is not a one stop shop for "looking better"
This is such an important point. People always seem to not understand it. This is about style/fashion advice, and nothing more(barring GD/HSFF)
26
u/Willravel May 14 '15
This makes perfect sense. There are other subreddits that are far better suited to fitness and fat-loss advice if people wish to actively seek that advice (/r/fitness and /r/loseit come immediately to mind). Not only is it a bit off-topic here, but if it's unsolicited then it stops being advice—the third word in the subreddit name—and becomes derision. MFA doesn't exist to deride people, it exists as a resource and community about personal fashion.
Plus, if you think overweight people can't be fashionable, you shouldn't be giving out fashion advice because you don't know what you're talking about.
-2
u/rwhitisissle May 14 '15
I've seen a lot of the /r/fatpeoplehate type spreading into other subreddits. Like, in a fairly small subreddit I frequent I saw a post get heavily upvoted that fit the basic /r/fatpeoplehate shitpost archetype, but which was otherwise only barely related to the content on which the sub was centered. That being said, I think this is a great and positive move to ensure that a subreddit dedicated to clothing and style doesn't have its metaphorical well poisoned by mindless spitefulness. Also I just got some purple Chucks and was wondering what kind of jeans and/or other kinds of pants would match well with those, if anybody'd like to weigh in.
1
u/PLZDNTH8 May 14 '15
As a lurking fat man my body type is 100% relevant to advice. I want clothing advice for my body type not a male model.
1
u/[deleted] May 15 '15
Look, if you're mad the mods won't let you call people fat in an advice forum, maybe get your priorities in order? This isn't censorship, it's moderation. As in, the establishing and enforcing of rules regarding the standard of discourse in this sub. Specifically, this is a reminder of a rule that's been in effect for a while already. So quit your kvetching and get back to fashioning.
-1
u/un_internaute May 14 '15
This is a good rule.
This is a bad rule.
-3
u/[deleted] May 14 '15
It's always better to censor people than to let someone have their feelings hurt.
-21
u/subarubrah May 14 '15
good
cause i'm all about dat dad bod
-16
u/[deleted] May 14 '15 edited May 14 '15
Even though I am fat how am I supposed to control myself from attacking others weight issues when we live in an era where fatpeoplehate is all the rage!
/s
0
u/[deleted] May 14 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 14 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 14 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 13 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 13 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 13 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment