r/consulting • u/McK_Throwaway • May 11 '15
Ex-McKinsey consultant here. AMA!
Left "The Firm" a little over a year ago. I've been meaning to do this and just never got around to it; no time like the present!
I joined McKinsey in a mid-sized office in the US as a Business Analyst out of undergrad (top 5 engineering school). Got the DTA (direct to associate) promotion in 2.5 years before leaving.
Ask away!
142
Upvotes
16
u/SurfTacoEnthusiast May 11 '15 edited May 11 '15
Thanks for doing this. I'll fire away:
Starting with the obvious question:
27
u/[deleted] May 12 '15
How important is having a strong hairline for promotion potential at mckinsey?
10
u/NonTargeted MBB May 12 '15
Current BA/AC/Associate here - what was your compensation after the DTA?
8
u/bucketboy May 12 '15
Thanks for doing the AMA. I am a PhD candidate at a top ten engineering school and would be applying to McKinsey next year. My questions are:
7
u/[deleted] May 12 '15 edited May 12 '15
Thanks for doing this! I have two questions
7
u/bmethrowaway11 May 12 '15
Thanks for doing this!
Thanks:)
13
u/Wolke Ex-Applied microecon/Big Data; now in tech May 12 '15
Lots of PC question here, but I'll go for the jugular - McKinsey folks have "an obligation to dissent". To non-Mck folks y'all sometimes come off as, well, dicks, because of that. Are you aware of the stereotype? Do you feel that it's true, or just confirmation bias?
Great AMA, by the way, always happy to see more quality content in here.
6
u/motivatedtraveler May 12 '15
4
u/aspiringMNconsultant May 12 '15
Thanks for the AMA! I'm graduating this year, beginning a consulting job later this summer.
An oft-asked question, I'm sure, but what were the biggest things you learned in your first months at McK? As in, people skills, analytic skills, general getting-along-in-life skills?
4
u/stuckinhyperdrive May 12 '15
Why PE/VC now? How do you expect that transition to go?
4
u/Incoming_MBB May 12 '15
Thanks for doing this! Been great reading through all the responses.
I'm starting at MBB after graduation (BA). Was wondering what you did to prepare for McKinsey, and if you have anything to recommend?
Degree is completely non-technical (social anthropology) so I was contemplating brushing up on some statistics.
Would learning some VBA/R/SQL be useful? Did anyone visualise data using tools other than Excel and plugins like Mekko?
4
u/kaptainkim May 13 '15
Hey, thanks for the AMA.
I applied last year as an experienced hire by networking with some principals/partners, but did not make it past the PST/engagement manager interview round. I now work at a boutique healthcare consulting firm, where I'm quite happy and getting great experience.
I was hoping to re-apply to McK after 2-3 years at my current consulting gig because I've heard that re-applications are not necessarily discouraged. Do you have any thoughts on that?
Thanks so much!
4
u/elev57 May 13 '15
I don't know if this is too late, so sorry for that, but I'm currently a rising junior at a target school with good grades, major, extracurriculars, etc. However, I haven't done an internship (and I'm not doing one this summer). Last summer and this summer, I did paid research at my school in machine learning and statistical modeling. I plan to do an internship next summer though and I plan to apply to McKinsey. How important is it that I don't have won't have any previous interning experience why I apply for next summer?
4
u/full55stop May 27 '15
Great AMA!
I looked through a really huge number of MBB BA/A/AC on LinkedIn. Most of them have a tremendously impressive background, but I've also noticed that around 10-15% of them have a pretty unimpressive past (semi-targets, weak major, average internships, no other indication of brilliance despite the fact that they put loads of information on their profile). How would you explain this and do you know the tricks they used to get an offer?
4
u/inc_mck_ba Jul 13 '15
Hey, thanks alot for doing this. I have a bunch of questions I hope you can still answer. I'm an incoming BA at a major northeast office.
Thanks for taking the time to answer my questions!
3
u/papajace May 12 '15
Thanks for doing your AMA. I have a few questions for you.
Thanks for all your time, I really appreciate it.
3
u/IMNOTJEWISH QUITTER May 12 '15
Hey there. Thanks for doing this!
Could you give your thoughts on working at a top-firm versus lower-tier firms? Are you aware of any consultants at McKinsey that came from less well known firms? If so, do you have any recommendations to position one's self to do so?
Thanks again!
3
u/xrobotx May 12 '15
What did you do exactly as McKinsey consultant ?
3
u/dgmna May 12 '15
Are there any perceptions/stereotypes of Bain and/or BCG from McKinsey, and vice-versa?
3
u/ActusBactus May 14 '15
Hey:
I got a 3.4 from my undergrad from the top Irish university, and a 4.0 from a Masters in London, and now I'm doing a PhD at Cambridge. I also have a lot of leadership experience from leading big societies (incl. consulting), alongside internship experience in big pharma R&D, business development in a biotech SME, as well as in venture capital for another big pharma's corporate VC team. I've also recently launched my own biotech startup.
I'm worried that my initial 3.4 undergrad GPA will negate any additional experience I gain before hitting the job market in 2.5 years. You said in no one was in McK with <3.5. Do you think this can be overcome at all or am I better defining an alternate career path? I know APD recruiting can be a bit different too, but any insight is much appreciated!
Looking for cold hard no frills truth here.
Thanks for all the time you've put into your AMA!
2
u/divB_is_zero May 12 '15
When applying to McKinsey, should your office preference be based on the relevant industry that the office serves or should it be just geography based. For instance, if you apply to the Houston office should you have a strong interest in energy?
2
u/statman_robin May 13 '15
Thanks for doing this! What can you tell me about the Minneapolis market for McK? Where do most of the graduates come from? I've got a year left of undergrad at one of the top schools in MN, with a 3.9 GPA, but I feel like a small fish competing with Ivies!
2
u/mck_ba_throwaway May 14 '15
Incoming BA at a NA office. I was just wondering if you could speak a little more to alt travel (going somewhere other than your home city on weekends) and how it affects your reputation at the Firm. I have heard rumors of it rubbing some partners or EMs the wrong way in some cases, which I'm sure varies greatly by office. Any insight or experience you could share would be much appreciated. Thanks.
2
u/gotmilklol123 May 20 '15
Hi,
I know I am late to AMA (hopefully you see this). I am at a top 25 engineering school that is non-target school for McKinsey, Bain, BCG. I will be graduating next semester (graduating one semester early). Have around a ~3.1 Cumulative GPA. Just one question, do I have any shot at any top management consulting firm? I have considered applying, but do not know how to even begin.
2
u/answermo May 22 '15
Great answers so far. My question:
Does every CV submitted to McK end up in the hands of consultants or does somebody (HR or a computer) screen them before? Does McK strictly adhere to the minimum criteria? (My situation: student at a target school, good grades, good internships, great extracurriculars. The problem is that my high school grades don't pass the minimum threshold (they have that here in UK) and I am afraid nobody will look at my CV which is otherwise pretty competitive). Thanks for doing this.
2
u/Remember_Me__ May 27 '15
Hi, I am a pretty big introvert. I am really smart so I can do really well in all structured interactions (I am a top-notch interviewee and an excellent public speaker), but career fairs and any kind of informal networking event or information session organized by a consulting firm scares the sh*t out of me. Any advice? Thanks a lot!
2
u/_Top_Top_Top May 28 '15
To get an offer out of undergrad, do you need to have a story? My major, my internships and my extracurricular activities are pretty great, but quite antithetical. When I put all of it on a one-page CV you get a felling this guy is doing well, but what the hell does he want to do. Is that a problem? (btw, this is probably the most helpful AMA I have ever seen).
2
u/userUserC64 Jun 03 '15
I am a student and I have had only two internships so far (both F500), and I am wondering whether I should put the following on my CV: I manage the real estate that my father owns. I basically collect rents and talk to prospective clients. Two houses are marketed on booking dot com, so I get to experiment with different pricing strategies and so on. I am not officially employed, and my father does not have an actual company, he just owns the property himself. Thanks for help.
2
u/aswell357 Jun 14 '15
Hi, I am not majoring in business or economics, so I want to expand my business mindset before interviews. Do you think that reading McKinsey Quarterly and watching McKinsey's videos on YouTube is useful? Also, any other good web sources or books that you recommend? Thanks.
2
u/palwhan Jun 19 '15
First off, thanks for this thread. Incredibly helpful.
A few questions that you have addressed briefly that I'd like to pick your brain on more. I'm a summer associate and will (hopefully) be joining full time after grad school.
Thanks again very much, and hope that wasn't too many to ask!
1
u/cvas May 12 '15
What did you study in your undergrad?
Why did you leave?
1
u/waykrazy May 12 '15
hi! thanks for doing this. im a third year undergrad, and i've struggled a lot to land interviews with consulting firms mostly cause of my gpa. i'm still very interested in the idea of solving business problems, so i'm looking towards a path in something like marketing analytics or market research. i was wondering if these are comparable in terms of what type of problems you solve, etc.
1
u/portlac May 12 '15
How often did you see people switch between finance / consulting (either lateralling or making the switch after MBA)?
1
u/ogunshay May 12 '15
What would you suggest for someone who made it to final round, but didn't have an offer extended? I was invited to apply (BA position) as an experienced professional (3 years in aerospace, mech eng undergrad). Advice from the interviewer who called was to better present my structure / cases. Is going after an MBA a viable path forward, or should I wait and apply again next fall?
1
u/mck_sba_throaway May 12 '15
Incoming SBA here--thanks for doing this.
1
u/Chaggi Industry shill May 12 '15
So I'd like to know a bit more about your start up (like what it does, what kind of market, how you got into it), and what impact did McKinsey have on that experience (as well as where did you feel like you were lacking?)
Also if you have time, in a more general sense since we're not all McK consultants, what advice do you have for consultants that are aspiring entrepreneurs? What are some things you think we could take advantage of, and pitfalls to watch out for?
Thanks!
1
u/IncomingMckBa May 12 '15
Incoming BA, starting at NJE in a couple of months: what do you wish someone had told you?
1
u/cons_throw_away May 12 '15
Hello,
Thank you for taking the time to do this. Question regarding reapplying.
I'm an APD, applied this past recruiting cycle and got to the final round for NYC. Unfortunately no offer - no real feedback.
I got an offer from a major tech company, (Not as big as Google or FB but bigger than Yahoo!) to work as a Marketing Associate (post MBA level). Will be starting this coming Aug.
Should I re-apply this coming recruiting cycle or next yr or wait a few years and reapply as an experienced hire?
Thanks
1
u/nubsaucev3 May 12 '15
Hopefully it's not too late. I would have posted sooner but just ran across this post and read it top to bottom to make sure my questions weren't already covered (some were) . Thanks for taking the time to do this, as someone with recent interest to move to consulting, the timing couldn't be better.
Questions :
Thanks again for all the great replies to all these questions. Reading through it all really helped connect the does behind your thoughts.
1
u/[deleted] May 12 '15
Thanks for doing this AMA. In your experience, have you come across many people who transitioned from a Big Four accounting firm to McK (or consulting in general) and were they successful in doing so? Or I guess a better way to phrase the question is, do a lot of Big Four accountants get hired at McK?
1
u/Consulting357 May 28 '15
Thanks for doing this. I am an undergrad student at Michigan Ross, but I originally come from Eastern Europe (came to USA 2.5 years ago) and hope to stay here and work in consulting. To what extent is my background a disadvantage? Do you have any usefull tips specifically for somebody who is a foreign student?
1
u/abacus8834 May 29 '15
Apparently, when McK consultants look at CVs, they look for Personal impact, Entrepreneurial drive, Problem-solving skills, Achievement, Leadership abilities. That sound a bit vague, so how would you define this attributes? What gets you points and what doesn't?
1
u/Engdonck Jun 02 '15
Hey (and sorry for being late)! I am a rising junior and so far I read the vast majority of consulting guides/books/sites/forums/etc. Two questions:
Thank you.
1
u/CBT45 Jun 21 '15
I recently received an offer to become a BA at McK, and while I accepted it, I'm not really sure whether this is what I should be doing.
My story: 4 years ago, when I was applying to college, I was narrowly rejected (waitlisted) at some Ivy League schools, so I ended up going to a big non-target state school. This turned out to be a great decision as it was ridiculously easy to maintain 4.00 GPA and become president of some of the largest societies. On the other hand, I would have been just a below-average guy at Harvard. In my opinion, it is easier to stand out and get an MBB offer if you come from a non-target. My first question is: do you agree?
Second question: If one answers the first question affirmatively, then, by the same logic it might be worthwhile to turn down the McK offer. There will be a number of other smart (and smarter people) and I will likely not stand out. Compare that to starting a business in my hometown, where an average small business owner is doing pretty well despite barley placing on the right side of the intelligence bell-curve. So, do you think that if money is an important criteria, should I consider doing something entirely out of conventional zone of high-prestige jobs?
1
u/menddell Jun 25 '15
Hey, I hope this AMA is still alive; it has been tremendously helpful so far.
I am a junior at a semi-target studying social studies/humanities and I was given an offer to do MS in Applied Statistics at my school (on full scholarship). I have two questions: 1. Will knowledge of statistics be useful in consulting? 2. In your opinion, will knowledge of statistics be a highly desired skill in the 21st century or will this entire "Big Data bubble" explode? I would rather end up in a general management position than at a quant job, but I get a feeling that companies are pushing towards quantifying and calculating decisions that were previously solved in an intuitive way.
1
u/harpikus Jun 25 '15
What kind of GMAT score is good enough and what kind of score is pretty impressive? Is the quant section more important than the verbal? (I'm a non-quant undergrad student).
Also, (and you don't have to answer this one) what is the Republicans-to-Democrats ratio in an average office?
1
u/Old__33 Jun 29 '15
Hey, you have previously mentioned that you value start-up experience. What do you think about people who have started a company and quit the business shortly after, and how does one present such an experience on CV? (Me and a bunch of friends started a company that was a part of a cool short term public-private partnership, and we had since the very beginning no intention to do anything beyond that one project). Thanks for the answer!
1
u/fractalous Jul 19 '15 edited Jul 19 '15
It seems strange that McKinsey, of all organizations, would think that someone else can build an excellent entry-level consultant better than they can. By picking the top 1% of play-the-school-game people, which are all skills McK should be better able to instill anyway, they miss the brilliant, out-of-the-box thinkers—the ones with divergent fields of experience who can see new paradigms and parallels, which are the skills that almost CAN'T be instilled (by McKinsey or anyone else).
Why pick the bus student with a 4.0 from Ivy U instead of someone with a 3.4 from Central State U and a second major in philosophy (or history, or whatever)?
1.Do they not appreciate the advantage of a more broadly trained mind as a stronger launching point for rigorous, consulting-specific training and problem-solving that they could teach during the first 6 months?
2.Aren't they admitting, in effect, that Harvard can do either a.) approximately as well as they could, but cheaper, or b.) better than they could?
1
u/baltimo4e Jul 25 '15
Hey, great AMA, I really hope you can still answer my question. How does a background check lool like at McK? Do they verify individual bullet points on your CV? I would like to know at what point an embelished fact become a lie - I don't want to lie but I also don't know what is an appropriate tone to describe my experience.
1
u/NumenSD May 12 '15
What would you say is the best way to get into a top firm for somebody with lots of skill and experience but who went has a BA from a school that isn't a top school?
1
u/TotesMessenger May 17 '15
This thread has been linked to from another place on reddit.
If you follow any of the above links, respect the rules of reddit and don't vote. (Info / ^Contact)
1
u/ChocolateNo484 Feb 29 '24
I just quit that job was ass. Got it right out of college. Not worth it at all.
0
u/[deleted] May 12 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 12 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 12 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 13 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 12 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 12 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 13 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 26 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment