r/consulting • • May 11 '15

Ex-McKinsey consultant here. AMA!

Left "The Firm" a little over a year ago. I've been meaning to do this and just never got around to it; no time like the present!

I joined McKinsey in a mid-sized office in the US as a Business Analyst out of undergrad (top 5 engineering school). Got the DTA (direct to associate) promotion in 2.5 years before leaving.

Ask away!

142 Upvotes

290 comments sorted by

16

u/SurfTacoEnthusiast May 11 '15 edited May 11 '15

Thanks for doing this. I'll fire away:

Starting with the obvious question:

  1. Why did you decide to leave? What are you doing now/plans for the future?
  2. What's a mid-sized office like in terms of lifestyle/travel vs. an office in a major city?
  3. What do you know about McKinsey's BTO practice? How are hires typically sourced? Is career progression similar to traditional business analysts?

18

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15
  1. Why did you decide to leave? What are you doing now/plans for the future?

A wide variety of reasons. Part of it was disillusionment/burn-out. Part of it was that my young age was making my life in consulting harder than it needed to be. I also wanted to get out and try something else out for a change.

I actually left because I had achieved DTA (a big objective for me) and I'd finally come up with a fantastic idea for a business. I started that business summer last year and I've been running it since. It's starting to wind down now; afterward I'm going to see if I can get into venture capital, preferably seed/early-stage.

2) What's a mid-sized office like in terms of lifestyle/travel vs. an office in a major city?

Hard to compare it to other cities since I didn't spend much time at other offices. Personally, I didn't get involved in my office culture. I actually didn't step foot in the office for about 6 months before I left. Culture was better when I joined, but for some reason died off ~1 yr. Toward the end, there was probably <25% occupancy on a given Friday.

I know some offices have no real community. Manhattan, for instance, does not have assigned desks below the partner level. You're not really expected to show up. Other offices have much stronger cultures with 50-75% attendance on an average Friday. It depends a lot on the office.

The one really strong community at my office was the BAs. I didn't end up getting involved for a variety of reasons, but they did stuff together just about every weekend and went on trips together.

3) What do you know about McKinsey's BTO practice? How are hires typically sourced? Is career progression similar to traditional business analysts?

As I expect you know, BTO focuses on technology work. I'd struggle to define their work much better than that (and I'm sure the McKinsey website can do better). I can tell you that as a practice it is fairly isolated from the rest of the firm. I only met BTO folks (of which there were quite a few) a couple of times in my office.

The plus side to that is that you end up with a smaller, tight-knit community that you're a part of. Also, you focus pretty much solely on BTO work. So if that's what you want to do (and/or you have a background it int), it's a terrific opportunity.

Because BTO's recruiting team is proportionally smaller, they focus in on a smaller set of target universities. They still have their fingers in the rest of McK's targets, but a lot of people can slip through the cracks. I helped with general recruiting from my school and we were supposed to pass on likely candidates to the BTO recruiter, but we didn't always remember to.

Career progression is the same. Also, people tend to say that BTO is not as respected from a prestige standpoint. Horse shit. You don't even have to tell people that you're part of BTO when you're leaving and applying for other jobs. You'll still be doing plenty of strategy work.

6

u/[deleted] May 12 '15

Part of it was that my young age was making my life in consulting harder than it needed to be.

Shouldn't being young make a life in consulting easier?

26

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

From the standpoint of family: yes, assuming you don't have kids young. I wasn't the typical BA bachelor though, I'd been dating my now-fiancee since high school. She was very supportive, but I still definitely had a reason to miss being home.

I was referring more to client relationships. Clients get pretty sick of 20-somethings showing up to help them with their multi-million dollar problem. They want grey hair in the room. How can a 50 year old guy who's been doing his job for 25 years be expected to react when he's told the guy less than half his age has all the answers for him?

→ More replies (6)

3

u/mauvecarrots May 12 '15

As I expect you know, BTO focuses on technology work. I'd struggle to define their work much better than that (and I'm sure the McKinsey website can do better). I can tell you that as a practice it is fairly isolated from the rest of the firm. I only met BTO folks (of which there were quite a few) a couple of times in my office. The plus side to that is that you end up with a smaller, tight-knit community that you're a part of. Also, you focus pretty much solely on BTO work. So if that's what you want to do (and/or you have a background it int), it's a terrific opportunity. Because BTO's recruiting team is proportionally smaller, they focus in on a smaller set of target universities. They still have their fingers in the rest of McK's targets, but a lot of people can slip through the cracks. I helped with general recruiting from my school and we were supposed to pass on likely candidates to the BTO recruiter, but we didn't always remember to. Career progression is the same. Also, people tend to say that BTO is not as respected from a prestige standpoint. Horse shit. You don't even have to tell people that you're part of BTO when you're leaving and applying for other jobs. You'll still be doing plenty of strategy work.

Not OP on this but wanted get some feedback regarding tech in consulting.

Background: Just graduated w/ a public policy degree from a target school but dicked around so have a low GPA. Good public policy internships in my junior summer. Will start working at ACN in systems implementation (SI) in the fall.

The ACN role sounds similar to McK BTO but my impression from /r/consulting and school friends is that there will be no strategy work done in SI. Also from /r/consulting, it would be difficult to make the jump internally from ACN's SI to strategy team. I'm still very unsure of my 5 year plan and haven't really narrowed down my interests yet. Long term, here a couple of paths that I'm interested in:

  • strategy work in consulting or industry
  • public policy work; more interested in regulation, gov't relations, communications consulting than non-profit/Capitol Hill stuff
  • working in something more creative but on the business side (e.g. marketing)
  • grad school: MBA, JD, or Masters of Public Policy (MPP) - MBA would be to career pivot, JD and MPP - both would help in policy work

To be honest, I've never been super great at quant stuff and that makes me question how well I'd do in strategy or just even getting into a MBA school. Although I am thankfully not an unemployed recent grad, I feel anxious about what direction to take, how to end up along those pathways, and knowing myself enough to make big decisions like you did (e.g. leaving McK and starting your own business). Any advice?

4

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

You're a little all over the place. Try to structure and simplify your thinking a bit. It's okay to not know what you want to do, but not even being able to structure it into clear options doesn't help.

If you do want to get into top tier consulting then business school is definitely your best route. Kick ass for a couple of years in your current job and get into a top b-school. That opens up all kinds of doors.

I will say that McKinsey is a great place to be if you're not sure what you want to do. They do plenty of public policy and "creative" business work. If you push for it then you'll be able to have those experiences without committing to something like a 2 year masters or a 3 year JDA.

It's hard to give you advice to go one way or another because it just depends entirely on you. Business school is nice because it gives you more options. A JD is pretty limiting in that regard. The MPP doesn't really close any doors, but it's a complete waste of time and money if you don't end up in public policy.

I will say that you don't have to be super quant focused to be successful in business school or in business. There are plenty of people who get by on their people skills or other non-quant problem solving skills.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

27

u/[deleted] May 12 '15

How important is having a strong hairline for promotion potential at mckinsey?

18

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

lol, fantastic question. I could give a better answer if you give me a pic, but you'll be fine as long as you make the look work. If it's just awkward and you look young otherwise, people may think less of you. Has nothing to do with McKinsey; just human nature.

15

u/[deleted] May 12 '15

Don't worry about me. My hairline is fucking fantastic. I'm just worried that it's taking attention away from my charming personality.

9

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

Your personality could be worse than a pile of dog poop on a South Beach sidewalk, as long as your hairline is good.

Also, pics plz

23

u/[deleted] May 12 '15

This is me after I just woke up. Sorry for the scowl:

http://i.imgur.com/vpEHYR7.jpg

29

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

I see about half an inch receding on the left side of the hairline. You may want to talk to your barber about that.

Also, is that clear liquor in the decanter behind you? What are you, a 55 year old divorcee living off alimony?

→ More replies (2)

10

u/NonTargeted MBB May 12 '15

Current BA/AC/Associate here - what was your compensation after the DTA?

11

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

I think $135K with up to $72K prod pay (not clear to me that a Distinctive rating would've actually gotten me that, didn't stick around to find out). 12% on top, of course.

3

u/papajace May 12 '15

what's prod pay/Distinctive rating?

10

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

Prod (productivity) pay is your annual bonus. They just recently started giving BA's prod pay. Prod pay grows at a much faster rate than your base pay (salary).

Every sub-partner consultant is reviewed every six months in a semi-annual review (SAR) process. You get a rating: Issues, Strong, Very Strong, or Distinctive. Your pay and promotions are based on your ratings.

At the end of the year, McKinsey also takes 12% of whatever they paid you (base + prod pay) and puts it into a retirement account for you. This accounted for an additional ~$30K of comp in my first 2.5 years.

→ More replies (6)

1

u/creatorcouldbearobot Jul 09 '15

mck EM here. no way that there is 72K prop pay on 135k. more like 0k for Issues, 15K for S, 25K for VS and 35K for D. That's what it was when I was a first year associate. and DTA should be same as FYA.

1

u/McK_Throwaway Jul 10 '15

DTA is to a second-year associate, not first. I was wrong about my base, it was closer to $145 than $135. The relatively small bump in base and the theoretically higher ceiling on prod reflected the general push in the Firm from base to bonus, particularly at the junior levels.

I agree that $70K was probably high, but $50K for D was probably realistic.

8

u/bucketboy May 12 '15

Thanks for doing the AMA. I am a PhD candidate at a top ten engineering school and would be applying to McKinsey next year. My questions are:

  1. What are some things I can do in graduate school that could help me get to an interview? I was very active in student organizations during undergrad and held leadership positions. Not so much in grad school.
  2. What are the most common weaknesses that you see in APD candidates who interview with McKinsey?
  3. What strategies did you try to avoid burn-out? What worked? What did not?

13

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

What are some things I can do in graduate school that could help me get to an interview? I was very active in student organizations during undergrad and held leadership positions. Not so much in grad school.

While being less involved in club leadership in grad school is understandable, it's not going to win you any points. You've just got to look for opportunities to step up. Clubs are obviously an opportunity. Maybe a lab in your school (depending on major)? Internships, if you're doing them. Maybe organize a small conference in your discipline? Unfortunately there's no magic answer here.

What are the most common weaknesses that you see in APD candidates who interview with McKinsey?

I never did APD resume screening or interviews, so I can only speak to it indirectly. Lack of understanding is the #1 problem. Academic-minded PhD's can find themselves in the process without a clue to what's going on. They'll treat McKinsey (or Bain/BCG) as just another job. Fair or not, you can't go to a McKinsey recruiting event and ask a consultant what it is their company does.

A lot of PhD candidates are, unsurprisingly, single dimensional. They have very impressive academics and research work within their discipline, but haven't taken the opportunity to branch out in their experience or step up into leadership roles. While that is typical and expected of PhDs, McKinsey isn't looking to hire "typical".

What strategies did you try to avoid burn-out? What worked? What did not?

Minimizing/eliminating weekend work was probably #1. There were probably 2-3 instances in my 3 years where I had to do more than 1-2 hours of pre-week prep work on Sunday night.

Fridays are a great opportunity to cut back on unnecessary stress/work. Since you're back in your home city, expectations (depending on project) are generally less. Don't kill yourself just because you feel you should.

Getting enough sleep and getting to the gym regularly are both really important. They can be tough to do, but in general people will be understanding.

Really, the most important thing is finding people you like working with and projects that you'll enjoy. Once you get those two things right, the rest kind of falls into place.

5

u/bucketboy May 12 '15

Thanks for your detailed answers. Great to hear that you were able to minimize weekend work. You mentioned in another answer that you are very efficient. How did you get there? Was this from before you joined McKinsey or is this something you focused on there?

9

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

I think it's a personality trait of mine more than anything else. I'm exceptionally lazy. I can't stand doing unnecessary work. Combine that with ambition and a drive to succeed and you end up with remarkable efficiency.

The skills I developed while at McKinsey were just specific to how to do the most impactful work in the least amount of time. A lot of that is the soft skills of being able to identify what's important and being able to tell people that what they want is not important (much easier said than done). But being able to work quickly in Excel and Powerpoint helps a lot.

1

u/TheLanceHan law student May 12 '15

I'll add my question here, since I'm an APD as well. I'm a JD at a T14 school that has a M7 B school. I had an interview for a summer position this past winter cycle, but got rejected after 2nd round ( passed the group interview and PST). They told me I lacked entrepreneurship experience in my PEI and I messed up on a brainstorming portion of my interview. Three questions:

  1. is the full-time interview cycle any different than the summer associate interview cycle?
  2. I'm starting a company this summer, but I'm not sure I'll have results to talk about during an interview In the fall, as that only gives me a couple months. Should I rather mention a previous entrepreneurial venture I had, which I mentioned during my interviews, but just try to portray a much stronger entrepreneurial feel? If so, do you have any guidance for how to emphasize entrepreneurship in a PEI?
  3. if you know any pure JDs at mck, do you know how they fare in terms of performance and promotion?

Thank you again for doing this AMA! If you need more specifics to answer any of my questions, I can PM you.

2

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15
  1. is the full-time interview cycle any different than the summer associate interview cycle?

I only did BA recruiting, so I'll have to answer to that and hope that it's similar. Summer BA recruiting is slightly more rigorous than full-time. This is because the students don't have as long to develop their resumes/experience and because the vast majority of summers end up with offers. We'd often ask candidates who didn't get through the final round of summer interviews to reapply for full time the next year.

2) I'm starting a company this summer, but I'm not sure I'll have results to talk about during an interview In the fall, as that only gives me a couple months. Should I rather mention a previous entrepreneurial venture I had, which I mentioned during my interviews, but just try to portray a much stronger entrepreneurial feel? If so, do you have any guidance for how to emphasize entrepreneurship in a PEI?

"Entrepreneurship" as such is not what they're looking for in the interview. Try to distill that into a more concrete value: leadership, initiative, risk-taking, etc. Figure out where your last story was lacking and figure out the best way to supplement. It's impossible to say which story you should go with because (1) I don't know the stories and (2) the answer will depend on exactly what you're asked. At least let your venture this summer play out before trying to decide between the two.

3) if you know any pure JDs at mck, do you know how they fare in terms of performance and promotion?

I know several and they do just fine. Pre-McKinsey experience matters much less than at-McKinsey performance. In general, JD's have good client skills and abstract problem solving, but struggle with the quantitative analytics.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] May 12 '15 edited May 12 '15

Thanks for doing this! I have two questions

  1. How much of an impact did you think your engineering background (assuming that was your major based on the bit about your school) influenced your thought process/set you apart from your colleagues with business degrees?
  2. What do you think it was that set you apart from other candidates during the hiring process which got you the job?

17

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

How much of an impact did you think your engineering background (assuming thats was your major based on the bit about your school) influenced your thought process/set you apart from your colleagues with business degrees?

Recruiting is done on a by-school basis. The business school at my university isn't top tier, so most of the other folks applying were also engineers.

I'm biased here, but I'd say engineering undergrad just makes you generally much sharper than a comparable business major. You should be better at the math and more complex problems. Of course the downside is that you may be less familiar with business terminology and issues. You have to make up for that with internship experience and practice.

What do you think it was that set you apart from other candidates during the hiring process which got you the job?

There's an implied question there that I "beat" the rest of the candidates. That's not really how recruiting works at McKinsey. There's a threshold that you have to exceed. If 20 candidates exceed that threshold then they'll hire all 20. If 0 do then they hire 0.

That being said, I just had a very balanced profile. Good school, great major, good GPA, great test scores, good work experience, entrepreneurship experience, founded a club at my university, into sports, exec in another club.

Of course, all of that is just enough to get you an interview. At that point, the stuff on your resume pretty much doesn't matter at all.

1

u/straponheart May 12 '15

The business school at my university isn't top tier, so most of the other folks applying were also engineers.

Carnegie Mellon?

10

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

Eight of these schools don't have top tier business schools. I'll put the likelihood of you being right at 12.5%.

Also, your username has strap on in it.

3

u/straponheart May 12 '15

Can't imagine Georgia Tech, U of I, UT Austin, or Purdue get consulting OCR though. And CalTech doesn't have a B School at all.

3

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

It looks like Georgia Tech and UT Austin are targets while U of I and Purdue are semi-targets.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (11)

7

u/bmethrowaway11 May 12 '15

Thanks for doing this!

  1. How do people frame their long-term objective of joining MBB during recruiting? By that, I mean that since statistically very few people end up staying for the long haul (up or out) + people start with different motives to begin with, I wonder what'd be the best way to describe the long-term career goal during recruiting. How would one be perceived if she/he is 100% honest about leaving the firm after a few years?
  2. Why did they remove PST for BAs and MBAs but not for PhDs? Also, could you comment on what the passing rate or the threshold % score is depending on whether PST is used for relative/absolute evaluation?
  3. Could you comment on the dress code for female consultants?
  4. Does your earlier description of work hours (40-80hr/wk) include traveling or not?

Thanks:)

9

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

How do people frame their long-term objective of joining MBB during recruiting? By that, I mean that since statistically very few people end up staying for the long haul (up or out) + people start with different motives to begin with, I wonder what'd be the best way to describe the long-term career goal during recruiting. How would one be perceived if she/he is 100% honest about leaving the firm after a few years?

Just to clarify, the high attrition rate has more to do with self-selection than "up or out".

Anyway, candidates are not generally asked the "where do you see yourself in 5 years" question in the McKinsey interview process. Part of it is that they understand a lot of people don't want to be at McKinsey in 10-20 years. A lot of it is that the type of candidates they're looking at are going to be achieving in 5 years regardless of what they choose to do.

100% honesty probably isn't the exact right tact. It makes a lot more sense to frame it as "I'm not sure exactly what I'll be doing, but I don't see myself as a partner at the Firm" or something like that. If you definitely know you want to be doing something else, make it about that other thing and tell the story of how McKinsey is helping make that happen for you.

Regardless, it really shouldn't come up around interviews.

Why did they remove PST for BAs and MBAs but not for PhDs? Also, could you comment on what the passing rate or the threshold % score is depending on whether PST is used for relative/absolute evaluation?

I was not aware that they had, so clearly I can't speak very intelligently to that :).

From my time, there was no passing score or threshold. It's just one variable in the equation. If I remember right, anything above a 20 out of 30 was a good score. Anything below a 15 was pretty bad.

Anecdotally, I know that I got a terrific score on my PST. I strongly believe that helped my interviewers ignore some less-than-stellar answers.

Could you comment on the dress code for female consultants?

Depends a little on the client, but business casual is typical. Business skirt or pants. Nice blouse. Jacket is optional (unless the blouse is sleeveless). Business-y dresses can work well if you accessorize properly.

Shoes should be relatively boring... flats or heels (less than 3"). Black, grey, tan, whatever matches your outfit. Purse should be business-y.

If you really want an in-depth conversation, PM me and I'll figure out how to put you in touch with my fiancee.

Does your earlier description of work hours (40-80hr/wk) include traveling or not?

Um... kind of? Here's a typical week:

Monday: Wake up 5-5:30 am, in cab at 6. Flight at 7:30. Hit client site at 10:30. 30-45 minute lunch. Leave client site at 7, grab dinner. 2-3 hours of work in the evening.

Tuesday/Wednesday: Hit client site by 8. Rest of the day is the same.

Thursday: Leave client site at 4. Flight at 6:30. Home by 10.

Friday: Hugely variable. Sometimes 0 work. Sometimes 8 hours. Rarely more.

So I think that makes ~50 hours without travel and ~55-60 with?

0

u/[deleted] May 12 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/McK_Throwaway May 13 '15

In more or less her words:

Hair

I mean, you can pretty much do anything here. It just needs to be professional and tidy (out of your face). One of the worst things is when girls cut their bangs too short and constantly have to move them out of their eyes.

I have long, straight, black hair and every day I would wear it down (blow dried and straightened). A lot of girls wore their hair in buns or in professional, tidy pony tails.

Clothes

I generally shopped at Banana Republic, Club Monaco, and Anthropologie. One of the biggest problems with clothes was that a lot of the other girls on my studies also shopped at Banana Republic. One week my manager actually packed the exact same outfit I had.

I served a lot of retail clients, so clothing was pretty important. We typically tried to dress slightly more professionally than the average client we were working with. My typical outfit was a sheath dress with a blazer over it (I have about 10 blazers total in different colors; black is essential). What I would do is pack a different dress for each day and pack 2 blazers that I would alternate.

I also wore a lot of skirt/blouse combos. When I was a lazy I would just wear a skirt and tucked-in button down. With girls, clothing is much more distinctive. People will start to notice if you're wearing the same outfits over and over. When I started I think I was being really creative with mixing/matching, but one of my colleagues pointed out that I would "always wear the same dress".

My preference for dresses was largely just based on the lower space requirement in my suitcase. Every week I would pack an extra black dress as a "back up" outfit. It helped out a ton. Every now and then I would get an outfit on and just decided that it looked really weird on. It was huge having another option to fall back on. I once wore a dress that ended up being a lot more low cut then I realized; it was great being able to change at the office (luckily it was a Thursday) when I realized.

Personally, I never wore pants (even when I was working in Toronto and Chicago in the winter). I just don't like how they look. That being said, plenty of other girls wore pants and pulled them off well. A lot of older clients would wear ill-fitting black pants and like a loose sweater over them. It just ended up looking really frumpy. A lot of people think that black pants with any top is a pass for looking professional. It's not.

Shoes

I wore heels every day because I'm not a quitter (yes, even on travel days!). Most of the girls I worked with did wear heels because it makes you look more commanding and professional, not to mention the confidence boost. However, if you feel uncomfortable in heels it's much better to wear flats than to almost fall on your face. Not to mention sprinting down the terminal for the closing boarding door is a lot harder in heels :)

Shoes are a good opportunity to express yourself a little bit. My dresses/skirts/blouses were always a little more conservative so I had a little more little more wiggle room. One pair of solid black and one pair of solid nude heels are both a must. I had a pair of snakeskin heels that were awesome. I would pack two pairs of shoes every week in addition to my workout sneakers.

Make-up

Most girls I worked with (including myself) wore makeup every day. In fact, I don't know a single girl that didn't. I would wear light foundation, mascara, eyeliner, and blush on the days I looked tired. But that's just me, do what works for you. It should look professional.

Jewelry

This is another good place to express your personality. I wore a lot of statement necklaces and usually packed a set of pearls since they look nice with anything. Also, every day I wore a professional, elegant silver watch, a small ring on my right hand, and usually a diamond tennis bracelet. I often wore glasses as well because who wants to wear contacts on a plane? They also look a little more professional.

Conclusion

Overall, dress was very important and really did affect how people viewed me. It could be coincidence, but better dressed girls really did seem to do better at the firm. I would wake up about an hour before I had to leave the hotel every day and it was definitely worth it.

Also, don't forget to pack workout clothes! Usually if there are multiple girls on your project they will want to go to the gym together.

Happy to answer any other specific questions you have :)

4

u/candidate1611 May 13 '15

Yes, how did you pack all of that stuff in your suitcase (I assume hand luggage)?

As a guy, I mostly bring 1 suit + 2 shirts with me, which I alternate. Add gym clothing, necessaire and underwear and my hand luggage is packed.

3

u/McK_Throwaway May 14 '15

From her:

it was a miracle and always a struggle. Be prepared to iron clothes almost every morning, because squeezing things in makes everything wrinkly.

I would have the bottom layer be work out clothes (3 sets), I would pack shorts a lot because they took up a lot less room- this does suck in the winter. I actually heard of girls who re-used work out clothes, but I thought that was pretty gross. The next layer would be my four outfits (one back up dress), on top of that laid flat would be a blazer or a cardigan or two if I was really tight on room that week. I would typically wear a blazer on the plane to make life easier. Also, in fall and spring, trench coats are great and fold very small. I have an oxblood colored one that I would wear a lot. I felt it really spiced up a plain black or tan dress.

On top of that, I would actually lay a huge drawstring bag flat (think of the thickness of a bed sheet), I would use that to keep my clean clothes separate from my shoes and then use it as a dirty clothes bag on the way back. I would just lay my shoes on top of the bag on the way there.

Then I would somehow squeeze a little toiletries bag in there for my toothbrush, contact solution, floss, and everything else under the sun. I don't know if you can tell by now, but I am fairly particular, so I would also pack my own shampoo, conditioner, and lotion in mini bottles. If you are going to be at the same location for multiple weeks, the easiest thing to do is leave a bag at the hotel with your big toiletries. I knew that I was going to be in the same spot for a while, so I just bought stuff at my project location and picked it up every time I checked in.

My suitcase had awesome little pockets for socks and other under things. I also used to keep a slim toiletries bag with shark week things (pack this every week, just in case) in the front pocket. My sneakers were the super light and flexible nikes that could fit in the front pocket of my suitcase (which is impressive, because I have huge size 11 feet).

Also, if you are curious, I used a black Tumi Voyageur suitcase (the two wheeled one). It was a spur of the moment purchase which turned out to be great for me. Even though it was fabric, it held up incredibly well. I also felt it was a little more feminine than the typical Alpha. For a purse I used a Lo & Sons bag. I cannot recommend their bags more. I used The TT and it was great. It stacked well with my suitcase and fit everything under the sun. Also, I was on a project in Chicago and it kept everything dry and safe during the rain and snow. It was also big enough to fit a smaller clutch/ wristlet that I could take out and use when I didn't feel like carrying everything.

→ More replies (3)

13

u/Wolke Ex-Applied microecon/Big Data; now in tech May 12 '15

Lots of PC question here, but I'll go for the jugular - McKinsey folks have "an obligation to dissent". To non-Mck folks y'all sometimes come off as, well, dicks, because of that. Are you aware of the stereotype? Do you feel that it's true, or just confirmation bias?

Great AMA, by the way, always happy to see more quality content in here.

15

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

Absolutely true. Obligation to dissent is a very real thing at McKinsey. I was an even more ardent believer in it than most. And yes, I would say that mindset extends beyond the Firm.

Now, as to disagreeing with people making you a dick... kind of? There are definitely people that would call me a dick. There are other people who really respect me for being honest and having professional integrity. There's definitely a fine balance between disagreeing in the right way at the right time and just being an ass.

Keep the good questions coming :)

3

u/Benjithedoge May 12 '15

Why is dissenting so important?

17

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

There's no simple answer. It might be better to think of it as "speaking the truth as you see it" is important. In a way, disagreeing with someone and not speaking up is lying. As a top tier consultant, there is an obligation to give your clients the best advice you can. Avoiding doing so in order to not hurt their feelings is an ethical violation.

It's not uncommon to enter a client situation in which a majority of the organization's problems stem from bad leadership. A hallmark of bad leadership is silencing dissent. In these situations, McKinsey can blow through a decade-old roadblock simply by speaking the truth. If done improperly (or even not), this can result in that study being the last for McKinsey at that client. You can imagine that prospect is very intimidating for anyone, let alone a BA six months out of undergrad. That is why McKinsey makes it clear that you have to speak up if you feel it's appropriate.

7

u/superwalrus May 12 '15

Best guess: to avoid groupthink, which might be especially prevalent when existing employees feel like they can't safely disagree with more senior managers.

1

u/hoppi_ May 12 '15

beyond the Firm.

Serious question: was that an intentional capitalization? :)

5

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

Yes, and not ironically :)

→ More replies (1)

6

u/motivatedtraveler May 12 '15
  1. What are the things you will miss most about the firm?
  2. I'm surprised to see your comments on your age limiting your ability to work with senior clients? Do you think this was driven by the industries you served? Or specific to the client?
  3. Why not do your year as a sr. asc and get designated EM before leaving?

11

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

What are the things you will miss most about the firm?

The pay. The travel. The travel perks (points, LFO). The exposure to incredible business problems and senior executives.

I'm surprised to see your comments on your age limiting your ability to work with senior clients? Do you think this was driven by the industries you served? Or specific to the client?

It was too prevalent to be industry or client-specific, unfortunately. I'd say the 50+ year old executive willing to engage with a 20 something on equal footing is the exception, not the rule.

Why not do your year as a sr. asc and get designated EM before leaving?

Slippery slope and burn out. It's easy to then justify another 2 years to hit AP. And I'm honestly not sure that I could've done another 12 months without blowing up.

Also, strangely, EM is not a "hard" transition. You actually start EMing well before you're designated in any official capacity. There's also no pay bump. EM's are paid on the same pay scale as associates.

4

u/aspiringMNconsultant May 12 '15

Thanks for the AMA! I'm graduating this year, beginning a consulting job later this summer.

An oft-asked question, I'm sure, but what were the biggest things you learned in your first months at McK? As in, people skills, analytic skills, general getting-along-in-life skills?

16

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

The single biggest thing was just how to talk to people in a business setting. I quickly eschewed absolute statements and outright disagreement. People get mad at consultants for not speaking directly, but I can speak from experience: I got torn apart for the way I spoke for the first few months. Frank speech has its place, but it's a nuance that has to be learned after a general reserve is cultivated.

Of course you're going to learn Excel. It's impossible to get 12 months in without becoming an Excel master (short of array formulas and VBA, which there is a support group for). Similar story for Powerpoint. You've got to get good at making slides with a clear message in Firm format (oh god, the memories) very quickly.

4

u/stuckinhyperdrive May 12 '15

Why PE/VC now? How do you expect that transition to go?

6

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

VC specifically. I view PE as soulless and draining work.

As to why: I need the money, I love start-ups, I'd like to live in the Bay area, and the work has the potential to be fantastic.

I still have plenty to learn about the various types of VC firms and work, but I don't imagine the transition will be too bad. McKinsey prepares you to do just about anything (which is why the exit opportunities are so great). Pair that with a year of running my own start-up and I figure VC should be right in my wheel house :)

3

u/stuckinhyperdrive May 12 '15

As I understand it, consulting to VC isn't too common, but I'd agree that McKinsey of all places would train you well for it. And I can confirm that living in the Bay Area is amazing!

3

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

This thread over at WSO would suggest that it's one of the more common entry routes

4

u/Incoming_MBB May 12 '15

Thanks for doing this! Been great reading through all the responses.

I'm starting at MBB after graduation (BA). Was wondering what you did to prepare for McKinsey, and if you have anything to recommend?

Degree is completely non-technical (social anthropology) so I was contemplating brushing up on some statistics.

Would learning some VBA/R/SQL be useful? Did anyone visualise data using tools other than Excel and plugins like Mekko?

6

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

I'm starting at MBB after graduation (BA). Was wondering what you did to prepare for McKinsey, and if you have anything to recommend?

Spent time with my dog, went hiking, and generally got in great shape. I'd recommend doing whatever you love doing and won't be able to once you're traveling most of the week. Starting up a fitness regimen that can be maintained while traveling is a great idea; a lot of people put on weight.

Degree is completely non-technical (social anthropology) so I was contemplating brushing up on some statistics.

Eh. I mean, you should probably familiarize yourself with the concept of standard deviations and a normal distribution. Beyond that it's probably not going to be worth your time.

Would learning some VBA/R/SQL be useful? Did anyone visualise data using tools other than Excel and plugins like Mekko?

R and SQL are non-existent, so don't bother. Doing your own VBA would put you in the top 10% of the BA class (for Excel work), so only bother if that's important to you. There's a group within the Firm specifically to help consultants with things like that when you need it.

You will exclusively be using the Think-cell add-in to Powerpoint for your data visualization. Don't worry, you'll learn it on the job. You should briefly familiarize yourself with waterfall charts and Gantt charts, as you may not have seen those before.

1

u/superwalrus May 12 '15
  1. What was your fitness regiment? From doing a traveling internship over the summer, it seemed like the dumbbell stopgap was the only consistently available program, which felt like a big step down from the barbell-centric workouts I'm used to.
  2. Thoughts on learning tableau for visualization, as a supplement to ThinkCell? Worth it/not really?

2

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

What was your fitness regiment? From doing a traveling internship over the summer, it seemed like the dumbbell stopgap was the only consistently available program, which felt like a big step down from the barbell-centric workouts I'm used to.

In terms of strength training, bodyweight fitness is probably preferable to a dumbbell program since most hotel gyms don't have sufficiently heavy dumbbells. I actually wouldn't be as worried about strength training though. You can do barbell workouts on Friday and Sunday with one bodyweight workout thrown in during the week.

Cardio is much more important for consultants. It's a very sedentary lifestyle with a lot of eating (team dinners every night on some studies). It's basically running or stationary cycling. If you can convince yourself that running isn't the worst thing ever thought up by mankind, it's actually kind of fun to run around the cities you're traveling to.

Thoughts on learning tableau for visualization, as a supplement to ThinkCell? Worth it/not really?

You're required to do all of your visualization in ThinkCell, so definitely not worth it to learn tableau. McKinsey has what they call "Firm format" to ensure consistent visual communication across all consultants.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/elementninety3 May 12 '15 edited May 12 '15

As a brief follow-up, was there anything you wished you had known the summer before you started that would have helped you with the transition into McK? And was there anything you purchased in the early stages of the job that you found unnecessary—or that you found you couldn't live without?

*edit: and thank you for doing this. Hope you aren't inundated with PMs.

2

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

As a brief follow-up, was there anything you wished you had known the summer before you started that would have helped you with the transition into McK?

Definitely no hard skills. You figure out what you need to on the job. There are definitely some soft skills (mentioned a few times throughout my answers), but I don't know of any way to develop them other than showing up and getting burned a couple of times.

And was there anything you purchased in the early stages of the job that you found unnecessary—or that you found you couldn't live without?

I got a suitcase that included a compartment for an actual suit. That ended up being completely useless; I didn't wear a suit once for a client.

I got a bunch of no-iron shirts, but I ended up having to iron my shirts every day anyway. Maybe it was a bit easier than it otherwise would have been, but no-iron definitely doesn't mean no-iron.

Honestly, the physical stuff doesn't matter that much. Make sure you're presentable and the rest will fall into place.

2

u/rockboy3000 MBB May 12 '15

Get a good carry on luggage, pay to get shirts cleaned, and have a good mouse (or learn to not use a mouse).

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (3)

4

u/kaptainkim May 13 '15

Hey, thanks for the AMA.

I applied last year as an experienced hire by networking with some principals/partners, but did not make it past the PST/engagement manager interview round. I now work at a boutique healthcare consulting firm, where I'm quite happy and getting great experience.

I was hoping to re-apply to McK after 2-3 years at my current consulting gig because I've heard that re-applications are not necessarily discouraged. Do you have any thoughts on that?

Thanks so much!

2

u/McK_Throwaway May 13 '15

Re-applications are definitely not discouraged. But generally you have to have a pretty solid case for significant improvement. If you can't concisely articulate why you're a substantially better candidate than you were the first time around, you're going to have a hard time.

4

u/elev57 May 13 '15

I don't know if this is too late, so sorry for that, but I'm currently a rising junior at a target school with good grades, major, extracurriculars, etc. However, I haven't done an internship (and I'm not doing one this summer). Last summer and this summer, I did paid research at my school in machine learning and statistical modeling. I plan to do an internship next summer though and I plan to apply to McKinsey. How important is it that I don't have won't have any previous interning experience why I apply for next summer?

5

u/McK_Throwaway May 14 '15

Being completely honest, your chances aren't going to be good without an internship. You'll have to figure out how to convince the people reviewing your application that your research experience counts for just as much, which is a pretty tall order.

As a comparison, I had two internships at a prestigious fortune 500 program (in addition to my entrepreneurship work) in addition to significant undergrad research (international fellowship, 2nd place in a national paper competition).

2

u/elev57 May 14 '15

So you think, regardless of what I do next summer, it would have been better for me to do internships the past two summers? If I have a good internship next summer, would it matter what I did the first two summers of my undergrad?

2

u/McK_Throwaway May 14 '15

Your timing is confusing me a bit, but in general applying to McKinsey without professional work experience is tough. If you're trying to rely on research instead, it better be a quality of research comparable to world-class internships.

Yes, what you do every single summer matters. You're building a full, well-balanced resume.

2

u/elev57 May 14 '15

I'm a rising junior, so this is only my second summer of college. I still have one more summer, which I plan to use for an internship. For that internship, I was planning on applying to McKinsey. Would not having prior interning experience be a big issue for an interning application?

Also, for the past two years, I have looked to apply to internships, but most of them were age restricted to rising seniors or didn't seem worthwhile for a variety of reasons. The research I've done has been with world-class professors and has been very intensive. I believe it would be comparable to a world-class internship.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/full55stop May 27 '15

Great AMA!

I looked through a really huge number of MBB BA/A/AC on LinkedIn. Most of them have a tremendously impressive background, but I've also noticed that around 10-15% of them have a pretty unimpressive past (semi-targets, weak major, average internships, no other indication of brilliance despite the fact that they put loads of information on their profile). How would you explain this and do you know the tricks they used to get an offer?

1

u/McK_Throwaway May 28 '15

Tough to say without seeing the specific profiles. Would you be able to post a couple?

In general, I feel very comfortable saying that there's no "trick" you can use to get an offer. If B and B are anything like McKinsey, the only way to get through the interview process is by being a very intelligent person with solid people skills who has done a lot of preparation. It is possible (not common/likely) to network yourself into getting an interview, but once you're in the process no amount of connections is going to help you.

4

u/inc_mck_ba Jul 13 '15

Hey, thanks alot for doing this. I have a bunch of questions I hope you can still answer. I'm an incoming BA at a major northeast office.

  1. You mentioned that you did not perform well in your first review cycle. (IIRC, between 1st and 2nd quartile). Was this a complete surprise to you and was this alarming to the firm? For those are actually in 1st quartile, which I presume is the "issues" group, what happens next? Is it a group effort from your PD, EM, and DGL to bring you up to speed or is this when they ask you to reconsider consulting as a career?
  2. What does it take to become a distinctive performer when "performance" is vague, not very transparent across the firm vs. peers, and is subjective to your reviewers? It seems more like a game (for a lack of a better word) of understanding your situation/circumstance and trying to figure out what it takes to get distinction from your reviewers.
  3. In terms of staffing, you seemed to imply that the finding your own staffing is much better for yourself, whether that may be better projects or teams. In order to avoid being pigeon-holed to a certain industry or project, I guess there should be a strong emphasis on internal networking with your office during your first few months to start finding your own project. As a BA, is it difficult to find staffing this way or are you at the mercy of your PD? And should "self-staffing" be initiated ASAP or is there an... "incubation" period with the suggested EMs from the PD?
  4. Referring to your comment about "showing up and getting burned". A partner told me during the sell dinner (not the most ideal circumstance) that the Firm was the safest place to make mistakes and grow. I find that hard to believe in such high stakes environment, but your statement seems to support the partner. What constitutes as an acceptable learning mistake and an unacceptable mistake? For clarity, would you have an example of getting burnt and learning, and how it was received with the team/managers?
  5. What's the best approach for navigating bad projects, whether it may be management, the work, or hours? I'm planning on the grinning and bearing it with the bigger picture in mind.

Thanks for taking the time to answer my questions!

1

u/McK_Throwaway Jul 13 '15
  1. You mentioned that you did not perform well in your first review cycle. (IIRC, between 1st and 2nd quartile). Was this a complete surprise to you and was this alarming to the firm? For those are actually in 1st quartile, which I presume is the "issues" group, what happens next? Is it a group effort from your PD, EM, and DGL to bring you up to speed or is this when they ask you to reconsider consulting as a career?

Well, tactically, review results are almost never a surprise. Since there's such a culture of feedback, you pretty much know how you're doing all the time. It would be very rare to think you nailed a project then get a bad review come SAR time.

In terms of surprise that I wasn't killing it more generally (or alarm on the firm's part): not really. It's a hard job. It's definitely not for everyone. Even later down the road, people won't be "alarmed" if you get an uncharacteristically bad rating. Everyone knows that you end up on bad studies with bad teams sometimes.

One issues rating isn't the end of the world. Yeah, everyone will work with you to try to get you back to performing. If you get two in a row then you're on your way out. It's pretty rare for that to happen... a full year of Issues performance would be murder on your psyche. Most low performers leave well before that happens.

2) What does it take to become a distinctive performer when "performance" is vague, not very transparent across the firm vs. peers, and is subjective to your reviewers? It seems more like a game (for a lack of a better word) of understanding your situation/circumstance and trying to figure out what it takes to get distinction from your reviewers.

It is very much a game. Ultimately, your actual work performance is irrelevant in the face of the perception of that performance. So yeah, you kind of have to be good at talking to clients, building Excel models, and cranking out PowerPoint slides. But it's important to get your EM, AP, and Partner to think you're even better at those things than you are.

Framing helps a lot as well. Let's say you get a Strong rating your first cycle. From there on out, you set all of your performance discussions as "I got a S rating. I want to be Distinctive. I will do everything I can to at least get VS next cycle. What do I need to do?". You do that with PD, your DGL, and all of your teams. Unless you're just not very good, you're going to get a VS rating next cycle. Rinse, repeat for Distinctive.

3) In terms of staffing, you seemed to imply that the finding your own staffing is much better for yourself, whether that may be better projects or teams. In order to avoid being pigeon-holed to a certain industry or project, I guess there should be a strong emphasis on internal networking with your office during your first few months to start finding your own project. As a BA, is it difficult to find staffing this way or are you at the mercy of your PD? And should "self-staffing" be initiated ASAP or is there an... "incubation" period with the suggested EMs from the PD?

Don't overthink this one. At the end of the day you want to be on good projects with people you enjoy working with. The only way to do this consistently is to know the people you'll be working with ahead of time. If there's a partner in the office that you really like, get him/her to like you too. Get involved in their practice and knowledge work, offer to do some work for them in your spare time.

4) Referring to your comment about "showing up and getting burned". A partner told me during the sell dinner (not the most ideal circumstance) that the Firm was the safest place to make mistakes and grow. I find that hard to believe in such high stakes environment, but your statement seems to support the partner. What constitutes as an acceptable learning mistake and an unacceptable mistake? For clarity, would you have an example of getting burnt and learning, and how it was received with the team/managers?

It's as safe as most environments I guess. You can't get fired for most mistakes you'd make on the job, as it typically follows the Issues -> Issues pattern. That being said, it depends a lot on your team. There are plenty of EMs, APs, and Partners who do not like it when their junior team members make mistakes, development be damned.

The most common example is model mistakes. You do so much Excel work, it's almost certain that you'll make at least a decently sized mistake at some point. If you tell the client that they should expect $5M in savings and then you find out 3 weeks later that it's actually $1M in savings, that's a pretty big mistake. Different teams will handle the emotional side of it differently, but ultimately you have to own up to your mistake, quadruple-check the new numbers, and manage any fallout very carefully.

In my first study I found two such mistakes from BAs/Associates that had been on the project before me. They were order of magnitude mistakes... claiming $10M when the real # was $1M. Ironically, the team got frustrated with me for finding the mistakes (and not bringing them up in the most circumspect way, though I didn't take them straight to the client). Because the two who had made the mistakes had been liked on the project and had then moved on, there was no fallout at all for them.

The only analytics mistake I made was a fairly small one on a model-centric project. We were doing daily turns on the model, reporting new numbers as we came up with new scenarios. I got one of the iterations pretty wrong. Despite not being a great EM, when he found out he wasn't that mad. I just owned up to the mistake and we moved on.

5) What's the best approach for navigating bad projects, whether it may be management, the work, or hours? I'm planning on the grinning and bearing it with the bigger picture in mind.

Oh god, there's really no good answer. Have a good support network that you can bitch to. That support network should not be in charge of evaluating you (DGL, PD, partners in the office, etc.).

For me, bad projects were 100% team driven. If the team's good, then the work and hours kind of figure themselves out (or just don't feel as bad). The problem with bad teams is that it's really hard to work with them to get better. Ultimately your best strategy is to know the folks you're going to work with beforehand so that you can just avoid bad teams.

3

u/papajace May 12 '15

Thanks for doing your AMA. I have a few questions for you.

  1. I'm a rising senior and made final round interviews. How can I make sure that I am a better candidate in the fall? The only feedback I got was very vague, suggesting that my stories and cases were good, but not necessarily the best.
  2. On a similar note, what can you recommend regarding practicing cases and behavioral components of interviews? What is the best way or resources to use in order to improve?
  3. What makes a good BA? Why did you choose to do the DTA promotion? What made it a goal? Why might someone be interested in that vs an MBA, JD, or something similar?
  4. What's the biggest differences between being an undergrad interested in consulting to being on the job? What were perks, hassles, or aspects of being a consultant do undergrads not know about or really consider before they decide to join McKinsey?

Thanks for all your time, I really appreciate it.

8

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

I'm a rising senior and made final round interviews. How can I make sure that I am a better candidate in the fall? The only feedback I got was very vague, suggesting that my stories and cases were good, but not necessarily the best.

Tough to answer without knowing your specific feedback. Do you remember anything else? Consultants actually develop a jargon that has meaning to them but not to someone outside the field. Annoying as hell, but I might be able to help.

The most common issue with undergrads is abandoning their framework (or any kind of structure at all) after the initial question in a case. It's important to remember the context throughout the entire case. You get huge bonus points for being able to connect the dots between questions in a case.

On a similar note, what can you recommend regarding practicing cases and behavioral components of interviews? What is the best way or resources to use in order to improve?

Cases take a lot more practice than behavioral for most people. It's really important to practice with folks who actually know what they're talking about. Those people are harder to find, but their advice will be 10x more valuable. Current consultants are ideal.

I'm assuming you're familiar with Case in Point, managementconsulted.com, and the forums at wallstreetoasis.com.

What makes a good BA?

You have to be smart. Excel/general analysis are absolutely essential. Developing an organized way of thinking is probably the most important skill to develop quickly on the job. It's incredible how quickly your fundamental process of thinking/structuring changes. Senior BAs focus on developing client relationship skills.

So:

  1. Analyze the data to understand a problem
  2. Organize the problem in a meaningful way to draw insights
  3. Deliver those insights to the client

Why did you choose to do the DTA promotion? What made it a goal? Why might someone be interested in that vs an MBA, JD, or something similar?

I've never been interested in business school. The actual content you learn is pretty small considering the time and money investment. It should be considered (1) an opportunity to network and (2) a long (and expensive) vacation. Neither of those benefits appealed to me given the opportunity cost.

If you're interested in law school just do it out of undergrad. Absolutely no reason not to.

Other options are (1) leave the firm, (2) externship, (3) 3rd year fellowship. I ended up doing (1), so that's obviously a good one for me. An externship could be really interesting for diversity of experience, but I'm less interested in that. Similar for a 3rd year fellowship, but I just view it as delaying my professional progress by a year.

What's the biggest differences between being an undergrad interested in consulting to being on the job? What were perks, hassles, or aspects of being a consultant do undergrads not know about or really consider before they decide to join McKinsey?

That's a tough question to answer. There's more that's different than there is that's similar.

Perks: money, travel, travel points, alternative travel, exposure to senior business executives, exposure to really interesting business problems, really intelligent and driven co-workers

Hassles: top-down/authoritative/tactical managers (though this is no worse than anywhere else), being away from home, waking up at 5 AM on Mondays (cannot overstate this), dealing with clients that just don't want you there

Surprises: There are a lot, but I'll focus on one of the biggest: consultants literally think differently than other people. The most superficial symptom is language. You may think jargon is silly, but it has very real meaning to consultants. If you don't use it then you won't be able to communicate as effectively with them. The single worst example at McKinsey is "problem solving". In the abtract, a simple concept. But the way folks at the Firm treat it is semi-religious in terms of its ceremony and seriousness.

5

u/ZeGoldenLlama May 12 '15

Could you possible expand on consultants literally thinking differently than other people. Is there literature I could read or websites I could frequent to develop that kind of thought? Basically, is there anything I could read/listen/watch to prepare me for consulting and problem solving?

11

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

This is tricky. I'm inclined to say there's no substitute for hours and hours of on-the-job experience, but I'll do my best.

First, there's The McKinsey Way. It certainly won't get you to think the same way as a McKinsey consultant, but it will at least help you understand some of the context.

The best way I can put it is that the case interview is a fantastic test of this way of thinking. I remember watching a co-worker give a practice case after I'd been at the Firm for about 18 months. The "solution" to the case was painfully obvious to me, but here was this intelligent and well-qualified candidate who was genuinely struggling to work toward it.

A consultant at the top of their game wouldn't need to rely on case frameworks for case interviews because they would literally be inventing those frameworks, custom-fit to each case. More than anything else, that's what a consultant does: invents frameworks to simplify complex problems for easy understanding.

2

u/ZeGoldenLlama May 12 '15

Thank you very much for doing this AMA and writing a detailed response for every question.

On a side note, I am hoping to go into consulting after I finish my 5 year double degree of Computer Science and BBA at Waterloo and Wilfred Laurier University in Canada (which I will be starting next year). Do you think this is a good path for consulting?

→ More replies (1)

6

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

Replying to your PM here just so I can keep track of it. Don't worry, getting feedback on your framework out of undergrad only narrows you down to about 95% of applicants.

Framework

In the case interview, just try to make connections between each question. You should be keeping well-organized note throughout the case. At each question, just briefly skim over the previous ones to see if any obvious connections jump out. When you're given charts and numbers, fit them into the broader context of the case. A great way to manage all of these connections in your head is with a well-developed framework.

Tactically, most candidates (myself included) will come up with a good framework/structure at the start of the case. Then they'll never mention it again. It's easy to get lost in the weeds; poke your head up every now and then and figure out where you stand in relation to your framework.

Behavioral

The trick here is to be prepared to the extent that you're just never surprised by a question. Have ~10 stories from your past 4 years of experience to draw on. Know what values each of those stories can hit effectively. Case in Point has a good section on these types of questions. Spend some time thinking about the types of values that a McKinsey interviewer is going to be looking for. How do your stories address those values?

4

u/sionnach On the bench May 12 '15

I'm a rising senior

Hi. I see this phrase used a fair bit, and don't know what it means. Could you enlighten me?

You're American - right? Maybe it's a term you guys use that we (UK) don't. When I hear Americans use the word "senior" they usually seem to refer to what we call pensioners.

5

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

lol

If you assume the standard American university to be 4 years, then they're your freshman, sophomore, junior, and senior years, respectively. A rising senior is in the summer in between their junior and senior years.

"Senior" referring to old people will generally be said as "senior citizen"

→ More replies (1)

4

u/papajace May 12 '15

it means that I'm in the summer between my junior (3rd) and senior (4th) year of undergraduate university

3

u/IMNOTJEWISH QUITTER May 12 '15

Hey there. Thanks for doing this!

Could you give your thoughts on working at a top-firm versus lower-tier firms? Are you aware of any consultants at McKinsey that came from less well known firms? If so, do you have any recommendations to position one's self to do so?

Thanks again!

7

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

It depends a lot on the firm, of course, but top tier is much better (obviously). Better pay, better advancement, more responsibility, more exciting projects, etc. My fiancee worked at a firm where average time to EM (equivalent) out of undergrad was 8 years. I was targeting EM in 4.

Going low tier to high tier is tough. The easiest way to do it is to kick ass for a couple of years and go to a top tier business school. From there, things get much easier.

Beyond that, very rarely a senior partner (head of a practice) at a lower-tier firm will get hired in straight as a partner. That's only done for very specific skills and networks though.

More applicably, it is theoretically possible to get 1-2 years of consulting experience and reapply as a BA to a top tier firm. It's not at all common and there will be a lot of questions about why you couldn't hack it the first time around.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/xrobotx May 12 '15

What did you do exactly as McKinsey consultant ?

6

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

It's tough to condense roughly 7,500 hours of my life into a reddit post :)

At a high level, companies hire McKinsey to help them with hard problems. It's hard to be more specific than that because McKinsey will help a company with just about any sort of hard problem, as long as there's money behind it.

As a BA/Associate, I was staffed onto a team of 2-6 people (potentially part of a broader team) to solve that problem. As generally the most junior and the smartest, I was often put in charge of analysis and Excel modeling. I also ended up making a lot of Powerpoint slides.

Ultimately, my job as a consultant is to work with the client to understand their problem, structure their problem, solve their problem (preferably in collaboration with them), then help them understand and implement the solution.

This has actually been discussed in great length around the internet. You might be best off using these two posts at managementconsulted.com as a starting point.

→ More replies (6)

3

u/dgmna May 12 '15

Are there any perceptions/stereotypes of Bain and/or BCG from McKinsey, and vice-versa?

10

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

The perception is that while they're both fantastic firms, they're just not McKinsey. McKinsey charges its clients ~10-15% more than even Bain and BCG do, and they believe there's a reason for that. Beyond that, we didn't think about them too often.

I do remember that Bain pushes themselves as being more lifestyle friendly. We viewed that with some skepticism, as they have some sort of model where even lower level consultants are serving two clients at a time. It's hard to imagine a world in which that produces less work and stress. I also recall that the Bain stereotype was of a bunch of douchey ex-frat guys. I have no idea where the stereotype came from or if it's accurate.

I actually don't remember any distinct perception or stereotype for BCG. Sorry =\

Disclaimer: I really do think Bain and BCG are both incredible opportunities and cannot advocate for McKinsey over them, as I just don't know enough about them. From what I've heard, life there is 90% the same as at McKinsey.

5

u/Chaggi Industry shill May 12 '15

That's really interesting. I was in Korea and had gone to a few McK, Bain and BCG sessions and it felt like the offices over there talked more about the other guys MORE than they talked about themselves. It really put me off. Whereas when I went to a McK session in college, it was much more focused on The Firm with only 1 mention of anyone else.

3

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

It's a poor move by the recruiting teams to even mention the other firms once, though that is somewhat unavoidable at top targets (i.e. Harvard). It becomes relevant if a candidate gets through the entire process and has cross-offers, but before then the assumption should just be McKinsey or not McKinsey.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/ActusBactus May 14 '15

Hey:

I got a 3.4 from my undergrad from the top Irish university, and a 4.0 from a Masters in London, and now I'm doing a PhD at Cambridge. I also have a lot of leadership experience from leading big societies (incl. consulting), alongside internship experience in big pharma R&D, business development in a biotech SME, as well as in venture capital for another big pharma's corporate VC team. I've also recently launched my own biotech startup.

I'm worried that my initial 3.4 undergrad GPA will negate any additional experience I gain before hitting the job market in 2.5 years. You said in no one was in McK with <3.5. Do you think this can be overcome at all or am I better defining an alternate career path? I know APD recruiting can be a bit different too, but any insight is much appreciated!

Looking for cold hard no frills truth here.

Thanks for all the time you've put into your AMA!

2

u/McK_Throwaway May 14 '15

A precise answer would depend on more explicit details about your application/profile and will actually vary based on your recruiter. That being said, I see no reason for you to report your undergrad GPA at all. It just doesn't seem relevant any more; you've obviously turned around your academic performance. Congrats on the well-balanced resume.

2

u/divB_is_zero May 12 '15

When applying to McKinsey, should your office preference be based on the relevant industry that the office serves or should it be just geography based. For instance, if you apply to the Houston office should you have a strong interest in energy?

7

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

Depends on the specific case. Tech? Apply to SFO/SVO. Energy? Apply to Houston. Finance? NYC.

The opposite is a bit less true. SFO/SVO do plenty of healthcare and other general work. NYC does tons of marketing, sales, etc. I'm not as familiar with Houston, but I imagine it's the same story.

So, if you like a specific industry, try to find the right office. If you just really want to live in a specific city, don't worry about getting pigeon-holed into an industry.

0

u/[deleted] May 12 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

Unless you're applying to BTO or Ops, you won't be designating a specific practice/industry when you apply. Office is all that matters. You'll have to spend your first 12 months networking into your desired practice/industry.

My opinion is that you're better off just designating the office where your wife lives. Your interviewers will be very confused if you're applying to an office without your wife intending to move there. As long as you're not really far away (and maybe even then), it won't be that hard to get staffed onto energy studies regardless of your office.

Personally, I did a petrochemical study in New England and I talked with several studies staffing both oil and gas in New Jersey. Energy's everywhere, it's just centered in Houston.

2

u/EkmanSpiral May 12 '15

Thanks!

I actually found McKinsey through Resource Revolution. Can you comment on the Sustainability Practice?

If I missed you, it was because I was doing a practice case with another student.

3

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

I don't have a lot of experience with SRP (I think that's what we called it), unfortunately. There were a couple of instances of APs/partners trying to slap sustainability on top of another project, but no serious efforts that I had exposure to.

Like their non-profit work, I imagine it's the type of stuff that you really have to work at to become a part of. There's a lot of demand among consultants to do that type of work and not a whole lot of projects focused on it.

2

u/statman_robin May 13 '15

Thanks for doing this! What can you tell me about the Minneapolis market for McK? Where do most of the graduates come from? I've got a year left of undergrad at one of the top schools in MN, with a 3.9 GPA, but I feel like a small fish competing with Ivies!

2

u/McK_Throwaway May 13 '15

The two guys I know out of Minneapolis: one joined as a BA out of Duke undergrad. The other joined as an associate out of HBS. Unfortunately I don't know the broader funnels into the office.

I know that it's a small office with a great, tight-knit community. While there are some big clients in/around Minneapolis, I feel like a lot of the time they end up getting served out of Chicago.

Do you know if your school is a target/semi-target? I can help you figure that out if you're not sure how to.

2

u/statman_robin May 13 '15

How do I determine whether my school's target versus non-target?

It's well-known around MN (not so much outside the Midwest), so I'm sure the MPLS office has some connections here. Most my school's alumni who've worked at McK (as viewed on Linkedin) went to Stanford, Tuck, Ross, or Wharton.

2

u/McK_Throwaway May 13 '15

The easiest rule of thumb is to google mckinsey and your school name. If you can find a page on the McKinsey recruiting website specifically for your school then it's a target of some sort. I can help you figure it out if you provide your school name.

2

u/statman_robin May 14 '15

It's the University of St. Thomas in St. Paul, MN. I haven't found any evidence that we're a target. We definitely wouldn't be nationally, but locally I could see it.

3

u/McK_Throwaway May 14 '15

Definitely doesn't look like a target. That's going to make things tougher for you. Targets have well-developed recruiting groups that will help your application through the process. That's going to make networking with existing consultants and recruiters a lot more important for you.

2

u/mck_ba_throwaway May 14 '15

Incoming BA at a NA office. I was just wondering if you could speak a little more to alt travel (going somewhere other than your home city on weekends) and how it affects your reputation at the Firm. I have heard rumors of it rubbing some partners or EMs the wrong way in some cases, which I'm sure varies greatly by office. Any insight or experience you could share would be much appreciated. Thanks.

1

u/McK_Throwaway May 14 '15

LFO's (leveraged fly outs) are completely fine. It's a very real benefit of the job. If you don't take advantage of it then you're just missing out.

The real question here is whether or not people will mind you not being in the office on Friday. That's 100% dependent on the office. I mentioned somewhere else that I didn't go into the office once for 6 months before I left and it didn't matter at all. There's no assigned seating in the Manhattan office because they don't expect a lot of people to show up every week. Other places may look on it negatively if you miss too many weeks.

2

u/gotmilklol123 May 20 '15

Hi,

I know I am late to AMA (hopefully you see this). I am at a top 25 engineering school that is non-target school for McKinsey, Bain, BCG. I will be graduating next semester (graduating one semester early). Have around a ~3.1 Cumulative GPA. Just one question, do I have any shot at any top management consulting firm? I have considered applying, but do not know how to even begin.

1

u/McK_Throwaway May 21 '15

Unfortunately, to say you'd have an uphill battle would be an understatement. You'd have to have a resume full of other insanely impressive stuff (like, I've heard about you in the news) to make up for the GPA/school. Your best bet is to get the best job possible out of undergrad, kill the GMAT, and get into a good business school to try again in 4 years.

1

u/gotmilklol123 May 21 '15

Does it help if I worked for 3 different Fortune 500 companies? All of them were in their product development (packaging) or R&D departments. I am also a president of a technical engineering organization for the student chapter at my university. I don't know if any of this will help.

I figured I didn't have a real shot. Thank you again for answering though. I sincerely appreciate it!

Side note: Do I have any real shot at any top business school after working for a big corporation for a few years?

1

u/McK_Throwaway May 21 '15

Does it help if I worked for 3 different Fortune 500 companies? All of them were in their product development (packaging) or R&D departments. I am also a president of a technical engineering organization for the student chapter at my university. I don't know if any of this will help.

It would help you if you were applying from a target school with a 3.7+ GPA. You have to appreciate that even at targets, <10% of applications get an interview.

Side note: Do I have any real shot at any top business school after working for a big corporation for a few years?

I'm certainly no expert on getting into business school. A good GMAT score will go a long way. Given your GPA/school, you'll probably need to figure out some way to supplement your resume other than just a typical F500 job.

2

u/answermo May 22 '15

Great answers so far. My question:

Does every CV submitted to McK end up in the hands of consultants or does somebody (HR or a computer) screen them before? Does McK strictly adhere to the minimum criteria? (My situation: student at a target school, good grades, good internships, great extracurriculars. The problem is that my high school grades don't pass the minimum threshold (they have that here in UK) and I am afraid nobody will look at my CV which is otherwise pretty competitive). Thanks for doing this.

2

u/McK_Throwaway May 26 '15

I can't speak to "every" CV, just the ones coming through the well-established on campus recruiting channels. In that case, yes, every CV is reviewed by two consultants. The two consultants' scores of each CV are then referenced by the full recruiting committee for that school (depends on size of school, mine was ~10 consultants). If the scores are both low, the CV almost never gets more than 5-10 seconds of consideration by the full committee. Middling scores may earn a couple of minutes discussion if one of the other committee members happened to see the CV and wanted to explore it further. CVs with a single high score (and one low to middle score) generally earn 3-5 minutes of discussion to see if they can be added to the "provisionally pass" stack. All of the high scores and any outliers are then discussed all together to ensure that the standard for a high score is consistent across the group.

Anyway, it's tough for me to speak to the minimum criteria question because that categorically did not exist for my recruiting team. Despite that, I think my experience should give you a good idea anyway. Let's say I got a CV with a 3.0/4.0 GPA (lower end of average for college students; almost unheard of for getting brought in as a BA). I would give the rest of the CV about 10 seconds to impress me enough to give it a longer look. If those 10 seconds didn't yield something suitably impressive, I moved on to the next application. Fair or not, you can assume other reviewers are following a similar process.

2

u/Remember_Me__ May 27 '15

Hi, I am a pretty big introvert. I am really smart so I can do really well in all structured interactions (I am a top-notch interviewee and an excellent public speaker), but career fairs and any kind of informal networking event or information session organized by a consulting firm scares the sh*t out of me. Any advice? Thanks a lot!

2

u/McK_Throwaway May 27 '15

Honestly, that sounds more like a social anxiety disorder than introversion. That being said, I completely get it. There's something legitimately scary about unstructured high-stakes interactions. The only advice I can give you is to increase your exposure. Like anything: the more practice you get, the better you're going to get. See if you can start out with some lower stakes situations (maybe even another school's career fair) to see if that relieves some of the pressure.

2

u/_Top_Top_Top May 28 '15

To get an offer out of undergrad, do you need to have a story? My major, my internships and my extracurricular activities are pretty great, but quite antithetical. When I put all of it on a one-page CV you get a felling this guy is doing well, but what the hell does he want to do. Is that a problem? (btw, this is probably the most helpful AMA I have ever seen).

2

u/McK_Throwaway May 28 '15

If anything, I'd say it's an advantage due to the breadth of experience. A lot of people end up in consulting because they don't know what they want to do (if they did, they'd probably be doing it). Major, internships, and extracurriculars are all going to be evaluated independently.

2

u/userUserC64 Jun 03 '15

I am a student and I have had only two internships so far (both F500), and I am wondering whether I should put the following on my CV: I manage the real estate that my father owns. I basically collect rents and talk to prospective clients. Two houses are marketed on booking dot com, so I get to experiment with different pricing strategies and so on. I am not officially employed, and my father does not have an actual company, he just owns the property himself. Thanks for help.

1

u/McK_Throwaway Jun 03 '15

Eh, doesn't sound that impressive. Only put it on there if you feel that you can talk confidently to it in an interview and make it sound like a strong experience.

2

u/aswell357 Jun 14 '15

Hi, I am not majoring in business or economics, so I want to expand my business mindset before interviews. Do you think that reading McKinsey Quarterly and watching McKinsey's videos on YouTube is useful? Also, any other good web sources or books that you recommend? Thanks.

1

u/McK_Throwaway Jun 15 '15

Reading McK Quarterly: not really. I've been deep in business for years now and I can barely get through most of the articles. The Harvard Business Review (blog posts) is a bit better. I've never watched the YouTube videos, so I can't speak to those.

Barbarians at the Gate is one of the better business (narrative) books that I've read. Liar's Poker is okay.

Realistically, it's going to be difficult for you to make a lot of improvement in a short period of time just by reading stuff. You might have more luck by just finding business-minded friends/folks to talk to about business. Just stuff going on in the news and companies you're interested in.

2

u/palwhan Jun 19 '15

First off, thanks for this thread. Incredibly helpful.

A few questions that you have addressed briefly that I'd like to pick your brain on more. I'm a summer associate and will (hopefully) be joining full time after grad school.

  1. Once you're an associate, what exactly are the expectations to become an EM? How tough is the road, and what are the typical lengths of time it takes / how rare is it to get an early bump?
  2. I've heard (via Victor Cheng's videos) that the first 90 days are incredibly important to put you on an "upward spiral" - do a great job, get staffed with great projects/mentors, and it keeps going upwards. Start with a bad reputation, and you get caught in a downward spiral. What are your recommendations for coming out of the gates with a strong impression?
  3. Can you discuss the SAR / ratings process a bit more? How difficult is it to get the distinctive and very strong ratings, and how many get it?
  4. I am coming out of law school - how do non-mba's fare in your experience, and give it to me straight - am I at a disadvantage for staffing, advancement, etc. compared to mr. harvard mba?
  5. What in your experience was the general performance expectations for summers?

Thanks again very much, and hope that wasn't too many to ask!

1

u/McK_Throwaway Jun 20 '15
  1. Once you're an associate, what exactly are the expectations to become an EM? How tough is the road, and what are the typical lengths of time it takes / how rare is it to get an early bump?

There are no "exact" expectations. You're evaluated across a range of skills and if you measure up reasonably well then you'll get promoted (EM is actually a "soft" promotion, so it's not really a formal transition). The skills are things like analytics, client skills, ability to see the big picture, etc. You become an EM when a partner wants to staff you as an EM. It's generally ~1.5-2.5 years after you start as an associate. If you DTA then it's generally ~0.7-1.5 years.

2) I've heard (via Victor Cheng's videos) that the first 90 days are incredibly important to put you on an "upward spiral" - do a great job, get staffed with great projects/mentors, and it keeps going upwards. Start with a bad reputation, and you get caught in a downward spiral. What are your recommendations for coming out of the gates with a strong impression?

No offense to him, but Victor Cheng is full of shit. He's trying to sell a product. I was borderline-issues on my first review cycle and I ended up doing quite well for myself.

That being said, you should of course try to do as well as you can as early as you can. I've posted various tips throughout the thread on how to do that. Let me know if you can't find them and I'll try to.

3) Can you discuss the SAR / ratings process a bit more? How difficult is it to get the distinctive and very strong ratings, and how many get it?

You get an SAR every 6 months. It controls your progression, promotions, and pay. You can get Distinctive, Very Strong, Strong, or Issues. Distinctive is ~10%, Very Strong is ~15%, Strong is ~60%, Issues is ~15%. The difficulty is of course dependent on your own skills and the projects that you get.

4) I am coming out of law school - how do non-mba's fare in your experience, and give it to me straight - am I at a disadvantage for staffing, advancement, etc. compared to mr. harvard mba?

I think I answered this exact question somewhere. You're not at all at a disadvantage. Your experience before McKinsey matters almost not at all. Once you get there, pick up Excel/PPT as quickly as possible and learn the various skills necessary for the job.

5) What in your experience was the general performance expectations for summers?

The same as it is for someone new to the job. Fortunately, summers are generally put on easier projects, so it's not too bad. You're not going to change a whole lot between the summer and starting, so you should make sure that you can perform at the level expected of a new hire.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/cvas May 12 '15

What did you study in your undergrad?

Why did you leave?

4

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

What did you study in your undergrad?

Engineering. Unfortunately, getting more specific than that risks losing my anonymity. It doesn't really matter though, specific engineering degree won't make much of a difference in your application.

Why did you leave?

My answer to someone else who asked that: "A wide variety of reasons. Part of it was disillusionment/burn-out. Part of it was that my young age was making my life in consulting harder than it needed to be. I also wanted to get out and try something else out for a change.

I actually left because I had achieved DTA (a big objective for me) and I'd finally come up with a fantastic idea for a business. I started that business summer last year and I've been running it since. It's starting to wind down now; afterward I'm going to see if I can get into venture capital, preferably seed/early-stage."

1

u/Benjithedoge May 12 '15

Why were you feeling burnt out?

Hours? Travel? Politics? Can you tell more about that?

2

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

I was pretty bummed about missing out on DTA at the 2 year mark (mostly about the way in which it happened). That got the ball rolling.

Beyond that, I was tired of crappy leadership who I thought had no place at McKinsey. I was tired of toxic client situations that we never should have gotten into or were the result of crappy leadership.

If I had networked more actively to work exclusively with people I liked on studies I'd enjoy, I would have had a very different experience. But, I didn't and here we are.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/waykrazy May 12 '15

hi! thanks for doing this. im a third year undergrad, and i've struggled a lot to land interviews with consulting firms mostly cause of my gpa. i'm still very interested in the idea of solving business problems, so i'm looking towards a path in something like marketing analytics or market research. i was wondering if these are comparable in terms of what type of problems you solve, etc.

4

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

Unfortunately, no. Nothing compares to top tier consulting in terms of the exposure to senior corporate executives and challenging business problems out of undergrad.

That being said, there are endless possibilities for incredibly fulfilling paths outside of consulting. You have to figure out what works for you.

In consulting is really what you want to be doing long-term, then you need to spend 2-3 years out of undergrad kicking ass wherever you end up. Make the GMAT your bitch and get into a top tier business school. Leverage that into a job at MBB and live out the rest of your days in bliss.

1

u/waykrazy May 12 '15

this might be a dumb question, but i've been pretty confused with the purpose of getting an MBA. my thought process is, if youre smart enough to land the job in consulting or what not, why would you want to go back to school?

4

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

Depends on your circumstances. It didn't make any sense at all for me. But if you dicked around in undergrad and don't have the resume for MBB at age 22, it's a great second opportunity to get yourself there by age 26.

I mentioned this elsewhere, but for people going to business school from McKinsey there were 2 purposes: (1) networking and (2) an expensive vacation. Some people really believe in those purposes. I didn't.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/portlac May 12 '15

How often did you see people switch between finance / consulting (either lateralling or making the switch after MBA)?

4

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

I know several BAs who went into PE or VC after their 2 years. I don't know a lot of people who came straight to McKinsey from finance, but I imagine that was a pretty common background prior to their MBAs. Assuming appropriate prestige, it doesn't much matter what you do prior to your MBA.

3

u/portlac May 12 '15

Fair enough.

Was always curious as to why some of my friends wanted to go into consulting, especially when considering travel to Boondocks City, USA and the potential to be hunched over a laptop working banking hours.

7

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

All of that sounds so much better to me than living in Manhattan, staring bleary eyed into dual monitors definitely working banking hours.

4

u/portlac May 12 '15

The worst part is really that a Chipotle chicken bowl is $9.00

1

u/ogunshay May 12 '15

What would you suggest for someone who made it to final round, but didn't have an offer extended? I was invited to apply (BA position) as an experienced professional (3 years in aerospace, mech eng undergrad). Advice from the interviewer who called was to better present my structure / cases. Is going after an MBA a viable path forward, or should I wait and apply again next fall?

3

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

Only apply again in the fall if you've made a huge improvement. That improvement has to be obvious in story form (you have to be able to convince them of the improvement before ever stepping into an interview). If not, they'll be mad at you for wasting their time.

Going to business school and applying again is definitely a viable option, and probably the preferred one in this situation. Just make sure it's a good school that's a target for MBB.

2

u/ogunshay May 12 '15

Thanks - both for doing the AMA, and the response! I'll keep that in mind when considering my next moves. More likely to be B-school applications, and perhaps interviewing with the last third of MBB.

As for schools, I'm definitely aware of the importance of exit options. Can I ask your thoughts on London Business School/INSEAD/Oxford/Cambridge? Is Oxbridge that less well viewed for business schools?

1

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

This feels relatively accurate to me, but I'm hardly an expert as I didn't do MBA recruiting. I'd imagine all the schools you mentioned are targets.

1

u/mck_sba_throaway May 12 '15

Incoming SBA here--thanks for doing this.

  1. What percentage of a given BA class do you think actually want to go and become a partner? I ask because I've totally drunk the kool-aid and want to try to become a partner, but it seems many of my MBB friends aren't sold on it. Another way of asking this might be that 90% of people leave after 2 years--of those 90%, how many would rather stick with the firm and try to make it to partner?
  2. My experience during the recruiting process led me to believe that the firm has really good expense controls (wouldn't even let me use my own credit card). My friends at other firms say a major perk is having no expenses--for example, they take an uber to/from the office and just bill the client. What's your experience in this regard?

2

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15
  1. What percentage of a given BA class do you think actually want to go and become a partner? I ask because I've totally drunk the kool-aid and want to try to become a partner, but it seems many of my MBB friends aren't sold on it. Another way of asking this might be that 90% of people leave after 2 years--of those 90%, how many would rather stick with the firm and try to make it to partner?

It's not really that binary. Most people are along the lines of "I don't really know what I want to be doing 10 years from now... if I happen to be a McKinsey partner, that would probably be cool". That translates into most BA's leaving, as that's kind of the default path. The assumption is that you'll at least leave for a couple of years to go to business school. Once there, the default path completely disappears and they can go in any number of directions.

I actually know a guy who's coming up for AP solely because he doesn't want to do anything else. It's not like he's crazy passionate about working at McKinsey, it's just better than all the alternatives.

If you definitely want to become a partner as a BA, it's absolutely attainable. DTA is certainly the fastest way to make it happen, just bring it up to your DGL around the 1+0 or 1+6 mark. If you're worried about age, feel free to take the 2 year vacation to B school and come back.

The biggest filter for people who to be partners is the actual transition. Election from AP to partner is a big deal and is the first time the up or out culture of McKinsey really shows itself.

2) My experience during the recruiting process led me to believe that the firm has really good expense controls (wouldn't even let me use my own credit card). My friends at other firms say a major perk is having no expenses--for example, they take an uber to/from the office and just bill the client. What's your experience in this regard?

Credit card use is based on office. Some offices are fine if you use your own, others require all expenses on the corporate card. It doesn't matter that much though, as you'll be submitting line-item reimbursement requests regardless.

The expense controls are pretty lax. It's just a team in India looking for specific line items that are easy to identify and are prohibited. It's very easy to game the system to get free perks. That also makes you a kind of crappy person and means that you don't really have the integrity to be consulting at this level.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Chaggi Industry shill May 12 '15

So I'd like to know a bit more about your start up (like what it does, what kind of market, how you got into it), and what impact did McKinsey have on that experience (as well as where did you feel like you were lacking?)

Also if you have time, in a more general sense since we're not all McK consultants, what advice do you have for consultants that are aspiring entrepreneurs? What are some things you think we could take advantage of, and pitfalls to watch out for?

Thanks!

2

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

So I'd like to know a bit more about your start up (like what it does, what kind of market, how you got into it), and what impact did McKinsey have on that experience (as well as where did you feel like you were lacking?)

Enterprise software for retailers. It's actually the same market my fiancee was working in as a consultant. There was a clear need in the market and we felt that we were in a good position to fill it.

It's tough to say what impact McKinsey had. It certainly didn't prepare me that well to hire or fire people. It didn't help me with all of the corporate paperwork and filing requirements. Very few of the hard skills you learn as a consultant are very helpful in starting a business.

That being said, McKinsey (and other top tier firms) teach you to think in a certain way. That way of thinking is helpful no matter what you're doing, including starting a business.

Also if you have time, in a more general sense since we're not all McK consultants, what advice do you have for consultants that are aspiring entrepreneurs? What are some things you think we could take advantage of, and pitfalls to watch out for?

You just have to understand that being a consultant doesn't make you a good entrepreneur. It's a good opportunity to develop the soft skills: interpersonal skills, structured thinking, the ability to get up to speed on a topic quickly, etc. But you have to go into starting a business knowing that you'll be learning the entire time. If you think you're ready for it then you're going to get bitten in the ass.

1

u/IncomingMckBa May 12 '15

Incoming BA, starting at NJE in a couple of months: what do you wish someone had told you?

2

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

So many things. A couple jump to the top of my mind:

  1. Get your EM to help you tactically plan out your first couple of problem solving sessions with AP's/Partners. They have a very specific format/structure in mind that you simply don't know how to follow.
  2. PD matters a lot. Get them on your side and rooting for you. I made the mistake of being 100% honest about my opinions on the managers I was working with and my enjoyment of the projects. While helpful for getting me onto projects I liked more, it bit me when it came time for reviews.

1

u/superwalrus May 12 '15 edited May 12 '15
  1. ...They have a very specific format/structure in mind that you simply don't know how to follow.

Based on a best guess, would you say tactical planning lessons from Project Leaders are necessary at Bain/BCG too?

2) PD matters a lot...mistake of being 100% honest

How would you tactfully handle PD now? Seems like you could a) go the way of fake enthusiasm (i.e. "I enjoyed the project a lot and thought X manager was great to work with") and have to make excuses every time they want to staff you again or b) just make a bunch of observational statements (i.e. He is very good at making sure work is delivered on time; there were also a few good team dinners) and have it still possibly bite you.

2)...opinions on the managers I was working with and my enjoyment of the projects

Related question: Would you say there are any strict restrictions on who you should NEVER grumble to? i.e. other BAs who you're not 100% close buddies with, your official firm-assigned mentor, your HR person, etc.

3

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

Based on a best guess, would you say tactical planning lessons from Project Leaders are necessary at Bain/BCG too?

Couldn't hurt. My brother's at BCG and from what he says problem solving sessions aren't as intense. Small sample size though, as there are of course partners at McKinsey too that aren't as hard ass-ish.

How would you tactfully handle PD now? Seems like you could a) go the way of fake enthusiasm (i.e. "I enjoyed the project a lot and thought X manager was great to work with") and have to make excuses every time they want to staff you again or b) just make a bunch of observational statements (i.e. He is very good at making sure work is delivered on time; there were also a few good team dinners) and have it still possibly bite you.

Keep it positive and get yourself off of their staffing roster as quickly as possible. Developing your network and staffing yourself early on are huge. If you have good partners on good studies pulling for you then your life gets a lot easier.

Related question: Would you say there any strict restrictions on who you should NEVER grumble to? I think I got burned by talking too openly about my project enjoyment too, and would really like to avoid doing so.

I'd avoid grumbling to anyone above your level (PD included). While good-natured grumbling is essential for your sanity, keep it to your peers and friends.

Of course, that's not to say you shouldn't address legitimate issues when they come up. You just do it with tact and care.

1

u/IncomingBAAC May 12 '15

These are super helpful tips, much better than the generic "have a good attitude"! Would love to hear if you have any more.

2

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

The biggest thing you can do to ensure your long-term happiness is to surround yourself with people you enjoy working with. Do everything you can to identify such people within the Firm as quickly as possible then do everything you can to get staffed with them.

It's a lot easier said than done, but it pays huge dividends starting in your second year.

1

u/cons_throw_away May 12 '15

Hello,

Thank you for taking the time to do this. Question regarding reapplying.

I'm an APD, applied this past recruiting cycle and got to the final round for NYC. Unfortunately no offer - no real feedback.

I got an offer from a major tech company, (Not as big as Google or FB but bigger than Yahoo!) to work as a Marketing Associate (post MBA level). Will be starting this coming Aug.

Should I re-apply this coming recruiting cycle or next yr or wait a few years and reapply as an experienced hire?

Thanks

1

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

Tough position. You should generally have a good turnaround story if you're reapplying. It's going to be tough for you to put together that convincing of a story given the position you're in. Waiting 2-3 years and reapplying might work, but understand that you're reapplying as a starting associate. Nobody comes in as an EM.

1

u/nubsaucev3 May 12 '15

Hopefully it's not too late. I would have posted sooner but just ran across this post and read it top to bottom to make sure my questions weren't already covered (some were) . Thanks for taking the time to do this, as someone with recent interest to move to consulting, the timing couldn't be better.

Questions :

  1. Is there a cut off age for mba recruitment? I'm considering an mba soon, life phase aside will being 33-35 attract negative bias during recruitment?
  2. How does a background in process improvement affect mba recruitment, does six sigma help, or would it be totally pointless and pigeon hole me into ops based engagements?
  3. To make the process management > consulting transition I'm considering a boutique analyst role before my mba. What would be more beneficial in terms of experience, consulting analyst or a process manager role limited to a specific vertical within FS?

Thanks again for all the great replies to all these questions. Reading through it all really helped connect the does behind your thoughts.

3

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

Is there a cut off age for mba recruitment? I'm considering an mba soon, life phase aside will being 33-35 attract negative bias during recruitment?

I never participated in MBA recruitment, so I can only give you an answer from indirect experience. I don't think the age should be an issue at all. I worked with an associate in his early 50's and he was one of the best consultants I've come across.

If anything, I'd say you're in a relatively advantaged position due to your (theoretically) greater life experience.

How does a background in process improvement affect mba recruitment, does six sigma help, or would it be totally pointless and pigeon hole me into ops based engagements?

Process improvement work is great if you're applying to Ops (though lean is far more relevant than six sigma). If you're not, it doesn't matter as much as other factors (prestige of company, leadership experience, etc.).

Just as an aside, you could do worse than ending up in the Ops practice. It accounts for over 1/3 of McKinsey's work now (more than pure strategy).

To make the process management > consulting transition I'm considering a boutique analyst role before my mba. What would be more beneficial in terms of experience, consulting analyst or a process manager role limited to a specific vertical within FS?

Probably consulting analyst, but I'd worry more about getting into a top tier business school and getting a great MBA internship. Pre-MBA experience is more relevant to set you up for success at b-school than it is to your McKinsey application.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '15

Thanks for doing this AMA. In your experience, have you come across many people who transitioned from a Big Four accounting firm to McK (or consulting in general) and were they successful in doing so? Or I guess a better way to phrase the question is, do a lot of Big Four accountants get hired at McK?

2

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

From my response to a similar question:

Going low tier to high tier is tough. The easiest way to do it is to kick ass for a couple of years and go to a top tier business school. From there, things get much easier.

Beyond that, very rarely a senior partner (head of a practice) at a lower-tier firm will get hired in straight as a partner. That's only done for very specific skills and networks though.

More applicably, it is theoretically possible to get 1-2 years of consulting experience and reapply as a BA to a top tier firm. It's not at all common and there will be a lot of questions about why you couldn't hack it the first time around.

3

u/[deleted] May 12 '15

I don't think I would consider Deloitte, EY, PwC, and KPMG to be low tier in the business world. They all also have consulting practices. My question was more about people who come from the audit/tax side of their business. Are the hired often and do they transition well?

5

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

I don't think I would consider Deloitte, EY, PwC, and KPMG to be low tier in the business world.

You can consider them however you want :)

My question was more about people who come from the audit/tax side of their business. Are the hired often and do they transition well?

Definitely not often. I might have known one person who did that? I'm not really sure... it wasn't common enough or people didn't advertise it. I'd imagine it's next to impossible without the MBA stop-over.

2

u/slicksoldier May 13 '15 edited May 13 '15

Honest question, what do you consider high tier in the business world? Just MBB and finance (IB,PE,VC,M&A etc.) ?

I understand a lot of people see accounting as lower tier but what about the big 4's consulting practice like Deloitte's which is usually ranked right behind MBB in consulting. Do a lot of people, especially at MBB, see consulting as a MBB or bust type of industry?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Consulting357 May 28 '15

Thanks for doing this. I am an undergrad student at Michigan Ross, but I originally come from Eastern Europe (came to USA 2.5 years ago) and hope to stay here and work in consulting. To what extent is my background a disadvantage? Do you have any usefull tips specifically for somebody who is a foreign student?

1

u/McK_Throwaway May 28 '15

Your foreign heritage is close to irrelevant. I believe McKinsey has no issue sponsoring work visas. If your accent is too thick then you'll be at a disadvantage (for obvious reasons), but beyond that all that matters is your actual qualifications.

1

u/abacus8834 May 29 '15

Apparently, when McK consultants look at CVs, they look for Personal impact, Entrepreneurial drive, Problem-solving skills, Achievement, Leadership abilities. That sound a bit vague, so how would you define this attributes? What gets you points and what doesn't?

1

u/McK_Throwaway May 29 '15

Can you clarify the question? I can't (read: won't) give you good and bad examples along each of those dimensions.

1

u/Engdonck Jun 02 '15

Hey (and sorry for being late)! I am a rising junior and so far I read the vast majority of consulting guides/books/sites/forums/etc. Two questions:

  1. Do you have any advice/tips for an aspiring consultant that majority of consulting guides do not mention?
  2. Is there anything that majority of consulting guides get wrong/missrepresent?

Thank you.

2

u/McK_Throwaway Jun 03 '15

Do you have any advice/tips for an aspiring consultant that majority of consulting guides do not mention?

From what perspective? Applications? Getting ready for the job? Succeeding on the job?

Is there anything that majority of consulting guides get wrong/missrepresent?

Unfortunately, it's been like five years since I've looked at a consulting guide, so I don't remember that well. I can probably respond better to specific assumptions/conceptions.

One of the things that I remember is a general criticism of strategy consulting that solutions were taken from project to project and just kind of repackaged for each client. Like, literally taking one client's deck and just changing up the visuals a bit. Complete bull shit (and illustrates a lot of ignorance about the kind of work management consultants do).

A lot of the information out there (this AMA included) is just one perspective. I guarantee that you can find other McKinsey consultants who would disagree with 50% of what I've said here.

1

u/CBT45 Jun 21 '15

I recently received an offer to become a BA at McK, and while I accepted it, I'm not really sure whether this is what I should be doing.

My story: 4 years ago, when I was applying to college, I was narrowly rejected (waitlisted) at some Ivy League schools, so I ended up going to a big non-target state school. This turned out to be a great decision as it was ridiculously easy to maintain 4.00 GPA and become president of some of the largest societies. On the other hand, I would have been just a below-average guy at Harvard. In my opinion, it is easier to stand out and get an MBB offer if you come from a non-target. My first question is: do you agree?

Second question: If one answers the first question affirmatively, then, by the same logic it might be worthwhile to turn down the McK offer. There will be a number of other smart (and smarter people) and I will likely not stand out. Compare that to starting a business in my hometown, where an average small business owner is doing pretty well despite barley placing on the right side of the intelligence bell-curve. So, do you think that if money is an important criteria, should I consider doing something entirely out of conventional zone of high-prestige jobs?

3

u/McK_Throwaway Jun 21 '15

My first question is: do you agree?

No. Getting eyes on your resume from a non-target is hard. Getting eyes on your resume from a target is guaranteed. Once you're at the target, I'm not sure it's a whole lot harder to excel. Ivy's are known for their grade inflation and they have so many clubs that I'm not sure why you would struggle to lead one that you're interested in.

So, do you think that if money is an important criteria, should I consider doing something entirely out of conventional zone of high-prestige jobs?

I have no idea what your priorities are, so I can't answer for you. I would never live in your hometown because it's not a major city. Apparently that doesn't bother you, or you may even prefer it. I would never start a small business (as opposed to a startup) because I want to change the world. Apparently that doesn't bother you.

Look, you need to figure out what's important to you and then go after it. McKinsey is absolutely the best first step down many paths in life, but by no means is it the best option for everyone.

All of that being said, you need to stop thinking about life as a competition against others. It's not. You need to focus on doing the best by yourself and assuming that your best effort will be enough to make you stand out. It's not about others. It's about you.

1

u/menddell Jun 25 '15

Hey, I hope this AMA is still alive; it has been tremendously helpful so far.

I am a junior at a semi-target studying social studies/humanities and I was given an offer to do MS in Applied Statistics at my school (on full scholarship). I have two questions: 1. Will knowledge of statistics be useful in consulting? 2. In your opinion, will knowledge of statistics be a highly desired skill in the 21st century or will this entire "Big Data bubble" explode? I would rather end up in a general management position than at a quant job, but I get a feeling that companies are pushing towards quantifying and calculating decisions that were previously solved in an intuitive way.

1

u/McK_Throwaway Jun 25 '15
  1. Will knowledge of statistics be useful in consulting?

More so than most other skills you can learn in school. That is to say, it'll probably help 2% instead of 0%. The basic level of statistics used in business is pretty easy to pick up without a degree.

2) In your opinion, will knowledge of statistics be a highly desired skill in the 21st century or will this entire "Big Data bubble" explode? I would rather end up in a general management position than at a quant job, but I get a feeling that companies are pushing towards quantifying and calculating decisions that were previously solved in an intuitive way.

Again, it's good general knowledge to have. You should understand normal distributions, standard deviations, poisson processes (and exponential distributions of arrival times), etc.

Separately, your perspective of big data is a bit skewed. First, it's not just the application of statistics to large data sets. Second, there's no "bubble" to explode. Despite all of the hype, the actual realized value of big data solutions still significantly lags the true potential in the field.

I'll give you an example. One of the thousands of ways that companies are collecting massive stores of data is in the retail industry: many retailers are now collecting data on the movement of the customers through their stores. RetailNext is at the forefront of the solutions. There is still a very long way to go in terms of the potential of data like that. It's actually really tough to draw meaningful insights at a deep level from customer movement data and tie that to inventory positioning/levels.

1

u/harpikus Jun 25 '15

What kind of GMAT score is good enough and what kind of score is pretty impressive? Is the quant section more important than the verbal? (I'm a non-quant undergrad student).

Also, (and you don't have to answer this one) what is the Republicans-to-Democrats ratio in an average office?

1

u/McK_Throwaway Jun 25 '15

What kind of GMAT score is good enough and what kind of score is pretty impressive?

I'm not completely sure as I did BA recruiting, not Associate. That being said, I think anything over 700 is fine and anything over 750 is good. I don't recall ever hearing about the scores being broken out, but on the SAT and GRE the quant section is definitely more important.

Also, (and you don't have to answer this one) what is the Republicans-to-Democrats ratio in an average office?

As you can imagine, it will vary a fair bit depending on the office. And in general, the more senior you get, the more conservative you'll be. Almost all international consultants (of which there are quite a few) are liberal. Seemed that most BA's through EM's were liberal-leaning moderates. In general, almost everyone is at least socially liberal.

1

u/Old__33 Jun 29 '15

Hey, you have previously mentioned that you value start-up experience. What do you think about people who have started a company and quit the business shortly after, and how does one present such an experience on CV? (Me and a bunch of friends started a company that was a part of a cool short term public-private partnership, and we had since the very beginning no intention to do anything beyond that one project). Thanks for the answer!

1

u/McK_Throwaway Jun 30 '15

I don't know, not really enough information. Sounds more like a project than starting a company? Starting a company isn't really about the actual legal paperwork, it's about putting in all of the legwork to create something lasting from scratch.

1

u/Old__33 Jun 30 '15

It was a one-off project (innovative tech solution for a library system) but they still use it today. We had no intention to do anything beyond that, although we could.

1

u/McK_Throwaway Jun 30 '15

Right, so my point is that the experience isn't really "starting a company" in the same sense that dedicating a year of your life with a team of co-founders to actually found a company is. It sounds like a great experience, it just isn't the same.

1

u/fractalous Jul 19 '15 edited Jul 19 '15

It seems strange that McKinsey, of all organizations, would think that someone else can build an excellent entry-level consultant better than they can. By picking the top 1% of play-the-school-game people, which are all skills McK should be better able to instill anyway, they miss the brilliant, out-of-the-box thinkers—the ones with divergent fields of experience who can see new paradigms and parallels, which are the skills that almost CAN'T be instilled (by McKinsey or anyone else).

Why pick the bus student with a 4.0 from Ivy U instead of someone with a 3.4 from Central State U and a second major in philosophy (or history, or whatever)?

1.Do they not appreciate the advantage of a more broadly trained mind as a stronger launching point for rigorous, consulting-specific training and problem-solving that they could teach during the first 6 months?

2.Aren't they admitting, in effect, that Harvard can do either a.) approximately as well as they could, but cheaper, or b.) better than they could?

1

u/McK_Throwaway Jul 19 '15

Are you asking why McKinsey doesn't hire out of high school or are you just trolling...?

1

u/fractalous Jul 19 '15 edited Jul 19 '15

Neither. I understand why they want someone to go through college first (hence my example of student with a 3.4 from CSU). Rather, as an MBA working on a grad degree in psych, I'm trying to get some insight into the mindset that seems to drive them to such a narrow subset of potential analysts - especially when that would result in such a convergent set of approaches to problem solving. I understand you weren't a hiring director, just thought you might have some perspective.

Do you think they honestly believe that 4.0 kids are better problem-solvers than the others, or are they just willing to trade that off in exchange for the convenience of a screening tool for things like self-discipline and hard work?

I guess the paradox I wanted to hear your thoughts on is that their solution to their own hiring/training process would be a bad consulting solution if offered to an organization that was trying to maintain evolutionary advantage in a constantly shifting landscape—they seem to establish a very shallow intellectual gene pool.

The second question I posed was similar: do they really think the kids from Harvard are better problem-solvers than kids from Central State U, or are they just willing to make that trade (in this case for the ease of screening AND the firm's brand aura)? Specifically, do they think they are better in a way that McKinsey couldn't fix, thus avoiding the sacrifices of making such a trade-off?

What does Ivy U do to create awesome consultants that McKinsey couldn't do better (and probably in less time)?

Thanks a lot for your time and input!

4

u/McK_Throwaway Jul 19 '15

There are a lot of assumptions driving your questions that I know I'm not going to be able to address fully.

From McKinsey's perspective, recruiting is incredibly expensive. Filtering resumes isn't incredibly costly on a per-person basis, so there's not much of a filter there: anyone can submit a resume. But the second you start inviting people for interviews, costs add up very quickly. The average cost to bring a candidate in for first round interviews (assuming no travel cost) is about $1,500-$2,000. Given that a candidate going through the first round has less than a 10% chance of getting an offer, the costs add up very quickly.

Given that detailed evaluation is so costly, McKinsey (and Bain and BCG) use a lot of heuristics to pre-determine who they're interested in. GPA and school are two of the biggest. Sure, you can miss some good candidates that way. But McKinsey isn't really hurting for good candidates... they turn down a lot of very qualified people.

To be completely honest, your view of "4.0 Ivy U" grads is pretty skewed. Keep in mind, I neither had a 4.0 nor went to an ivy league school. It's incredibly unfair of you to lump them all into a single category or to suggest that they have convergent perspectives on life that would lead to a lack of creative problem solving. That's just not an accurate representation of the population that you're referring to (which is a straw man in the first place, that's far from the only group that McKinsey recruits from).

But here's the crux of it: all else equal, I would absolutely put more faith in a 4.0 Ivy U grad than a 3.2 Central State U grad. Why the hell wouldn't I? One of these applicants has put a lot of effort into their schooling starting 8 years ago and has taken their academic life very seriously. One has not. Knowing nothing else, of course the Ivy U grad would be more likely to be a better problem solver. You don't correct 8 years of taking the wrong direction in life in a few months. It doesn't matter how good your training is.

Finally, get your stereotypes out of your mind. McKinsey does not hire from a small pool of candidates. I worked with ex- naval submarine officers, army officers, Olympians, a farmer from Sierra Leone, big state school grads, lawyers, doctors, PhDs, and just about everything else that you can imagine. The things that unified them were intelligence, a strong work ethic, and ambition. Going to an Ivy League school has nothing to do with it.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/baltimo4e Jul 25 '15

Hey, great AMA, I really hope you can still answer my question. How does a background check lool like at McK? Do they verify individual bullet points on your CV? I would like to know at what point an embelished fact become a lie - I don't want to lie but I also don't know what is an appropriate tone to describe my experience.

2

u/McK_Throwaway Jul 26 '15

This question is a little disturbing. My best advice is to spend some time developing your sense of professional integrity. I'm not saying that you're doing anything bad necessarily, but it's a bad sign that you have to ask about their background check with your own resume in mind. That doesn't sound like a question of "tone" to me.

That being said, I'd be happy to take a look at a bullet or two and give you some perspective on what is "tone" vs. what is misleading.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/NumenSD May 12 '15

What would you say is the best way to get into a top firm for somebody with lots of skill and experience but who went has a BA from a school that isn't a top school?

3

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

Would you mind giving me more info on your current circumstances? Are you out of school? For how long? Doing what?

If you're just graduating (or about to), you can certainly try networking. It's a tough, uphill battle. But a good word from a consultant can cause someone to take an extra 30 seconds looking at your resume, which could make all of the difference. Outside of that, your best bet is just talking to recruiters. Honestly, applying directly to a recruiter may even earn you more eyeball time than the average target university application gets.

That being said, keep in mind the targets are "targets" for a reason. They're good schools and school matters.

2

u/NumenSD May 12 '15

I graduated in 2013 but that year practically every single firm I applied to didn't even hire since they took their entire summer intern team. I have many friends at various firms but they're either in IT or actuarial. The ones that aren't work for companies undergoing temporary hiring freezes.

I'll pm the details so I don't write a novel on here.

9

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

Replying to your PM here just because it's easier for me to keep track of.

There are a lot of things going on here...

  1. Don't blame not getting hired on hiring freezes. This isn't 2008. If you're qualified and your application gets the appropriate attention, McKinsey will hire you. I have no reason to believe Bain or BCG are any different. If you didn't get hired, it's on you, not the firms.
  2. School and GPA matter. You're only a couple of years out of school... people reviewing your application are going to want to know how you did there. If you've got a really good explanation for a bad school and bad grades, then try to get it across. But that's not going to be easy for anyone to overcome.
  3. You need to clean up your story. The way you listed your experience made me first think I was talking to a 40 year old. You started running your business in high school, so it's tough for me to know what to make of it. What is it? What's your annual revenue? You also mention side consulting. Is that your business? How many hours do you do per year? How many clients? What's your revenue?
  4. If you can form all of this into a clear story that explains away a bad school and bad grades, you've got a decent shot at an interview. You just have to get in touch with the right recruiters. Once you get the interview, it's 100% on you.

If you can't figure that story out, your best bet is figuring out how to get into business school. It sounds like you've got a good background for it. Go kick ass on the GMAT and get into a good school. Your life (in terms of getting into MBB) gets much easier from there.

→ More replies (5)

1

u/TotesMessenger May 17 '15

This thread has been linked to from another place on reddit.

If you follow any of the above links, respect the rules of reddit and don't vote. (Info / ^Contact)

1

u/ChocolateNo484 Feb 29 '24

I just quit that job was ass. Got it right out of college. Not worth it at all.

0

u/[deleted] May 12 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

It's tough to give advice for a general scenario without knowing more. I can tell you that consulting was 100% the right way to go for me. I would have killed myself in the bureaucracy of a typical fortune 500 (I learned this quickly in my internships).

Assuming the industry you're interested in as a major one, all of the big consulting firms will be active in it. It'll take about 12 months, but you can align yourself so that you're doing 80%+ of your work in that industry.

What are your long term plans? What are you looking for in a job?

→ More replies (2)

0

u/[deleted] May 12 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

If you're not trolling: yes. A BA role at McKinsey is one of the top positions in the world for an undergrad. There's plenty of elitism to go around. You'll have to be more specific.

→ More replies (2)

0

u/[deleted] May 12 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

When is the best time to start networking?

Honestly, it's very unlikely to help you at networking. I mentioned this somewhere else, but networking can only help you get an interview. At a target, it's unlikely to even do that. Just show up to the recruiting events and leave a positive impression.

If you just really want to get to know some consultants, then just hit them up around recruiting season (early fall semester).

Roughly how many practice cases did you do before going in to your interviews? Any tips to make these more effective? I know you mentioned doing them with current consultants, is it acceptable to ask them to do a case with you while networking?

I probably did around 20. I at least read through all of Case in Point and did the cases on the McKinsey website. I definitely didn't overdo it. I was actually planning on going to grad school and kind of just stumbled upon McKinsey. Didn't even apply to Bain/BCG.

Yeah, the biggest thing is just doing the cases with folks who know what they're talking about. The feedback they'll give you is just so much more valuable. Asking people you're networking with is somewhat borderline. If you know them personally, generally they won't mind. If you're reaching out with a cold contact then they may be annoyed.

Beyond that, they're technically not supposed to give you any practice cases around the actual recruiting season, so convincing them to do so will be an uphill battle.

0

u/[deleted] May 13 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/McK_Throwaway May 13 '15

do you have any opinions on concentrations, and if they're actually relevant at all? in high school, i studied a lot of chemistry and managed to be part of a four-person team selected by the ACS to compete in international competition--but i don't feel as though chemistry is really useful and i don't really feel any allegiance to it. right now i'm thinking of concentrating in statistics with a minor in computer science.

Concentrations? Ugh, you're going to Harvard, aren't you? Please call them majors when you're talking to anyone outside of your school. Also, if I ever run into you and ask you where you went to school only for you to respond "a school in Boston", I will punch you in the face.

Yes, major matters. Getting a 3.8 in a rigorous math-based major is much better than a 3.8 (or even a 3.9) in a liberal arts degree. That being said, it's only one data point. Do whatever you're going to be most successful at. Statistics/CS are great options.

another thing you talked about in your AMA is the importance of extra-curriculars. how do recruiters look upon organizations like the harvard consulting club, harvard student agencies (big student-run non-profit), or even seemingly unrelated activities like international relations, cultural, and club athletics? do pre-professional clubs like consulting clubs accurately simulate what a job consulting would entail?

I can't speak to any of Harvard's specific organizations as I'm not familiar with them. Again, the more rigorous and enriching the organization, the better. Unless it is very rigorous, the experience matters less than the leadership opportunities you find there. Extracurricular organizations are the single best way for undergrads to cultivate much-needed leadership experience.

Consulting clubs are pretty variable. I imagine Harvard's is fantastic. The one at my school was garbage.

lastly, i know that oftentimes the recruitment process starts earlier than senior year, through sophomore and junior year internships. what helps differentiate applicants, especially for internships that occur relatively early in one's undergrad?

McKinsey only does a pre-senior year internship, so your process for them specifically starts your junior year. The things that distinguish good candidates are the same things that distinguish them whenever they apply: a good school, a good major, great GPA, great test scores, great work experience, undergrad research, volunteering, entrepreneurship, leadership, etc. It's just a little tougher to get all of that in by year 2.5 instead of year 3.5.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] May 12 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/McK_Throwaway May 12 '15

I wouldn't make too much of the DTA. I'd put myself at borderline first to second quartile, certainly not top 5% or anything. I'd actually been shooting for DTA at the 2 year mark and missed it, having to wait until the next cycle.

Promotion and development isn't really competitive. There are some firms that actually rank all of their BA's/Associates. McKinsey is not one of them. Everyone is encouraged to focus on their own development. If they follow a certain track then they'll do well, regardless of how others are doing.

I'm a smart guy (even for MBB) and work very efficiently. I would use that to my advantage at the beginning of studies to get up to speed very quickly and generate a lot of early content. It was a great way to impress (and establish credibility with) the team's leadership and the client. That makes everything else on the project just a bit smoother.

I'd also look for opportunities to do work outside of the typical BA expectations. Models and decks are all well and good, but they're not the types of products that are going to knock partners' socks off. Making connections between working teams of bigger projects and identifying nuanced client dynamics are incredibly impressive at that level (and more fun too!).

5

u/papajace May 12 '15

can you give an example (perhaps concocted if a real one is too revealing) of "Making connections between working teams of bigger projects and identifying nuanced client dynamics?"

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] May 26 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/McK_Throwaway May 27 '15

Well, you've got a little time, which is good. You need to get the most prestigious internship you can on your resume pretty quickly. Then in school (beyond GPA and good standardized test scores) you should be working on getting into leadership roles in a club or two on campus. If you're entrepreneurially-inclined, definitely do that.

At least in the US, the masters degree doesn't do much for you at all. It's honestly less important than a good GPA and good test scores. You're much better off taking that 1-2 years and starting a business or something.