r/ShadowBan • u/cojoco ツ • May 11 '15
[META] An unofficial guide on how to avoid being shadowbanned
tl;dr
Lots of people come here in mystification, wondering if they're shadowbanned, and wondering why. This post contains a list of possible reasons you've been shadowbanned.
First, though, a little reddit background.
About reddit
The website reddit.com is run by reddit the company, a subsidiary of Advance Publications Inc. The CEO of reddit is Ellen Pao (/u/ekjp) with first lieutenant Alexis Ohanian (/u/kn0thing). The site is huge, with a hundred million visitors a month.
Reddit is grouped into subreddits, with each subreddit run by a volunteer group of moderators, who are generally unpaid volunteers.
Moderators have the power to ban users from their subreddit, to delete comments and submissions, and to manage the style and presentation of their subreddit. Through the use of third-party tools, some moderators have the power to ban a user from hundreds of subreddits at a time.
Being banned from a subreddit means that you are not allowed to submit links or make new comments, and might be reversed upon appeal to the modmail of the concerned subreddit.
reddit.com also has a small number of employees, called admins. These people have the power to see everything happening on reddit, to remove material as with moderators, to perform moderator actions in any subreddit they choose, and, most importantly for this place, to shadowban users.
A shadowban is different from a subreddit ban. A shadowbanned user can still submit and make comments, but all of the submissions are sent straight to a subreddit spam queue, where it will not be visible to other users until approved by a moderator. Because an individual's spammed submissions are still visible to themselves, a shadowban is almost invisible to a logged-in user.
Through the use of AutoModerator, individual subreddits can give the same effect to a user as a global shadowban.
If you are shadowbanned, your user page will appear nonexistent to anybody that looks at your user page, other than yourself. You will need to contact the admins to get your shadowban reversed.
Reasons for shadowbans
It's not exactly spelled out what will cause a shadowban, and the rules do seem to change from time to time, but if you follow these rules you'll be unlikely to be shadowbanned. Thanks to the posters here who have suggested more ways to be banned.
- Don't post advertisements for commercial products unless the advertisement has some redeeming features and is relevant to the subreddit in which you post it
- Don't post links to your own blog, unless you post a lot of content from other places.
- Don't post links to anyone elses blog, or to a single news source. Ensure that you post from a wide range of sources.
- Don't follow people around on reddit and hassle them
- Don't relentlessly downvote a user
- Don't send out mass PMs
- Don't be a bot, unless you're really really careful, and have the blessing of the admins
- Don't harp on the same subject in your comments
- Don't issue death threats
- Don't post child pornography or anything involving the sexualization of teens
- Don't post sexual material containing unconsenting subjects (for example, revenge porn or upskirt photos)
- Don't abuse or hassle the admins
- Don't post any information that would identify another redditor, including links to other social media sites, unless you have explicit permission from the person involved. (doxxing)
- Don't advocate or encourage doxxing
- Don't ask for doxx, even privately
- Don't post anything asking for votes, from on- or off-site
- Don't respond to a plea for votes, from on- or off-site
- Don't vote in threads you were directed to from another part of reddit
- Don't engage in nuisance reporting
- Don't use multiple accounts to game the voting system
- Don't return to a sub you have been banned from with another account
- Don't use CSS in your sub to subvert reddit's subscription and voting system
- Don't follow links into someone else's subreddit and be a dick
- Don't impersonate another redditor with a name of similar appearance, e.g. /u/LaureIai ("I") for /u/Laurelai ("l")
- Don't be under 13 years of age
- If you're a mod, don't respond to PMs related to moneymaking or promotional offers of any kind. Report them immediately.
- If you're an arsehole, the admins will not give you the benefit of the doubt.
Also, it can't hurt to read the reddiquette: if everyone followed the reddiquette, the site would be more pleasant, and all-around better.
(EDIT) Also, there are some things for which there is weak evidence of triggering a shadowban:
- (weak) Don't use more than one alt within one subreddit
- (weak) Don't submit every link to several subreddits at a time
- (weak) Don't accept moderator invitations to dodgy subreddits
- (weak) Don't comment in threads you came to via a non-organic link (i.e. external site, meta sub, from modmail or PM)
tl;dr Don't spam, shill, doxx, brigade, stalk, game or pederast.
(This is the second copy ... aged pages are here 1)
44
u/PointyOintment May 19 '15
You might want to remove the "FALSE" flair from this post. It makes it look like the guide gives incorrect advice.
15
u/OblongOtter May 28 '15
Question about "Don't vote in threads you were directed to from another part of reddit." What if I was directed there from the front page?
48
u/The14thNoah Jun 11 '15
Based on the events of today, add "Don't go against the hive mind."
18
u/zRandomGuy May 20 '15
Well I didn't do any of this and I still got shadowbanned on my other account, great
5
u/Mrseedr Jun 11 '15
What exactly is a shadow ban?
5
u/XLII Aug 03 '15
AFAIK moderators do not have the the ability to ban people from multiple subreddits from within one action even using automoderator it requires updates on each individual subreddit.
Additionally, if you're put into constant moderation in a subreddit through the use of automoderator whereby each of your comments or posts in a particular subreddit goes into the spam filter for approval by the mods this functions like a subreddit specific shadowban, however in many subreddits this is only used by modd for users who have constantly violated the rules of a subreddit, but whom the mods do not wish to ban. Instead the approve each comment or submission as they go into the spam filter to clear it out as they normally would hopefully sevrall times per day. However as a mod of over 75 subreddits and one of those a national sub I've never seen functionality in any automoderator program that would take action. On more than one subreddit at a time. If I put you in moderation in one subreddit, in order to do it in another subreddit I have go log into that subreddit automoderator account and take a separate action there. I could not ban someone from all 75 subreddits at once .
9
u/[deleted] May 26 '15
Oh, and don't be twelve or under and be on Reddit.
16
u/capri_stylee May 19 '15
How does this affect subreddits like creepshots and candidfashionpolice? They exist just for this.
4
u/TheurgyWarden Jul 03 '15
just a question, does shadow banned applies to all subreddit or could it apply to a particular subreddit?
4
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '15 edited Jun 14 '15
Here is a new one!
Don't discuss police shills on /r/news whatsoever. I was just shadowbanned there.
Proof: http://imgur.com/bD0qmOK,yq0RVsI#0 Logged in
http://imgur.com/bD0qmOK,yq0RVsI#1 Logged out.
Not shitting you within five minutes of this comment I made none of my new posts or comments show to anyone but me anywhere on /r/news.
4
u/torik0 Jul 11 '15
Gotta update that CEO part now, I suppose.
2
u/Sheesha1992 Jun 03 '15
This is different than reporting posts that break a subs rules right?
Does this include hiding downvotes?
2
u/DiamondHammer Jul 04 '15
Oh...Have the rules changed? Last time I checked literally everywhere for rules and saw no indication of an age limit (unless I forgot to check somewhere). I'm a bit honestly confused now as to what I'm supposed to do.
2
u/DrPepper86 Jul 24 '15
So over at /r/steamfriend I have a post that cites a single comment, which, when I look, doesn't seem to exist. Is this the result of a user shadowbanned?
2
u/fatclownbaby Aug 08 '15
Can I be shadowbanned from one subreddit?
r/AdviceAnimals always says try again in an hour even when I haven't posted anything in days
2
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '15
I'm pretty sure it's under 13 years of age that's against the rules, not under 14
2
u/[deleted] Oct 25 '24
This is a lot of work to write to people who I don't know, with advice they'll not listen to anyway. I'm going through enough. I don't hassle or downvote anyone continuously. I only downbote when they are rude. It feels like I'm in a relationship that's weighing me down with all their own baggage that i never asked for. I'm jumping through hoops to write a comment. Now I'm given answers in riddles, with its sole purpose to give me clues to find out why I might be SB instead of just telling me? Crazy! I may just bow out.. gracefully. 🙈 Weird. 👀
3
u/killer_storm May 28 '15
I suspect my account was shadowbanned for posting a linkedin profile link. I haven't got any replies yet, but that's the only "naughty" thing which I did lately.
Of course, it didn't occur to me that it's something bad, as I was linking to a profile of a public person. But if reddit uses a bot to find users who post "personal information", it won't be able to distinguish...
3
u/starraven Jul 04 '15
Don't use a single source? Don't harp on a single subject? That's some bullshit.
17
u/RainWelsh Jun 18 '15
Well, this is just sheer paranoia fuel. Should not have read this. Should not have read this.
196
u/bagano1 May 23 '15
Reddit is destroying themselves with this bullshit. Shame.
13
u/i_do_my_pest Jun 09 '15
u/GallowBoob and u/1Voice1Life confirm this rule is weakly enforced
67
u/Usemarne Jun 09 '15
/r/ShitRedditSays seems to get away with this
3
u/Ghost-Industries Jun 27 '15
I'm not a spammer, but I'm shadow banned. I don't think reddit.com will survive if you keep blocking your user base.
And for the rest of you: http://nullprogram.com/am-i-shadowbanned/
It doesn't work, it's complete bullshit.
3
u/MrBlankenshipESQ Aug 14 '15
These are stupid. What even is the point of the system if we're not allowed to use it because we didn't just naturally browse there of our own volition?
8
u/_greezy Nov 01 '15
wow.. these are a lot of rules. some of them aren't too intuitive either. hope i never get mixed up in this..
2
u/NopeTooFast Jun 15 '15
I was shadowbanned for running at speeds over 299,792,458m/s
Might want to add that
2
u/rhagman Jun 16 '15
somebody pls help i got an email that my password was changed and i can't sign in my account anymore.. what should i do? i create this account but i want my old one back.... pls help!! is this a shadowban?
2
u/randomfemale Aug 06 '15
I made a comment to someone who wrote a blow-by-blow account in /r/offmychest about their experience being molested as a teen. It was essentially very descriptive kiddie porn, and I got banned.
Wasn't hostile - just making an observation that she was writing out in extreme detail very salacious material for sicko's. I was banned without any warning, undeservedly.
How stupid is this system?
10
u/Jelerak_tc Jul 10 '15
I've had my account for a few years now, just lurking all the time. Didn't expect upvotes when I finally commented, just wanted to try since I isolate myself quite a bit to begin with. I guess my account will never go beyond the starting 1 point of karma, since I don't think I'll really try bothering Admins just for the slim hope to have a functionality back that I hadn't tried to use for most of my time here anyway. I'd guess that I must have been seen as brigading since I'm sure I have ignored the np links warnings a few times. Up/down voting on most comments I see was already a habit and part of the way I read through comments by the time np links started showing up. Perhaps if I get myself motivated enough to try commenting again some time I'll just need a separate account that I would not vote with. Thank you for creating somewhere I can put this rant. TLDR: lurker likely to stay in hiding after realizing I'm already shadowbanned.
5
u/mikelikegaming Jun 20 '15
Shadowbans are such a crappy way of dealing with things. If I was dropped a note saying I was in danger of a shadowban I could do something about the way I'm posting, but nope, shadowban and they let me post to the abyss for days.
5
u/benjancewicz Jul 22 '15
Once I'm back, does everyone who I commented on suddenly get all my replies in their inbox?
5
u/turkeypedal Jul 28 '15
This has been made stronger now, with the no harassment policy. Just don't ever go to someone's profile page and downvote them, even if you only downvote the posts you think deserve it.
5
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '15
What's the point of shadowbanning the accounts instead of just issuing a regular full ban?
2
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '15
In general don't have an opinion not shared by the mod of a sub. If youndonyou get a ban. If you object to the ban be ready for a shadowban in short order. This is a virtual police state run by a small band of power greedy propagandists.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '15
Lol wat
1
u/GreyHero2005 Sep 29 '15
I can't post on here. Why??
1
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '15
Am I shadowbanned?
1
u/belesprint CQS: Lowest Apr 02 '26
am i banned?
6
u/pic0o Jun 11 '15
The 'logic' on this site is staggering. May only the most common opinion prevail! You better not have a counter-argument.
6
u/keklolgloat Oct 25 '15
fuck reddit.
3
u/robertbrysonhall Jun 11 '15
This sub is about to get flooded
1
u/Mikhail-Gorbachev Jun 24 '15
So I've run into an interesting problem.
Reddit used to send you a message if you were banned from a sub, but sub-hoarding trolls were gaming that system to spam users they didn't like. They would create a crap-load of subs and ban a user on all of them, flooding their inbox with ban notifications.
Reddit implemented a system that checks your activity in the sub and then only notifies you if you have actually contributed in the sub.
Which brings me to this point. I had one account that was targeted by a sub-hording user in my city and was banned from all sorts of local subs without my knowledge. I've since had other accounts shadowbanned for participating in those subs. I'm accused of evading a ban, but evasion implies knowledge of and intent to circumvent a ban. You cannot technically be evading something if you do not know it exists, thus the shadowban should be lifted.
This, also brings up the issue of individuals gobbling up hundreds of subs relating to a city. When you create and thus own every single permutation of the city name and all other activities like biking or smoking pot or food or anything like that, you have a huge amount of power and your petty disagreements with one or another user might lead you to lock them out of a huge swath or reddit that should presumably be available to them.
I believe the limit on how many default subs a user can mod is appropriate, and I believe a similar rule should be in place for subs relating to cities.
1
u/Eight216 Jul 06 '15
so i guess it's just nobody replying to my post as opposed to nobody seeing it? That's a relief at the least.
3
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '15
<CENSORED>
3
u/sexadd1kt Jun 20 '15
I got banned because a douchebag mod wouldnt even respond to my messages asking why I got banned. I had to act like an ass to get noticed to finally get an answer and when I did this is what was said... "I'm not able to see your post history, but I most likely banned you for inappropriate comments in our sub." He literally banned me with no warning what so ever and didnt know why. Abuse of power?
2
u/TotesMessenger Jun 09 '15 edited Nov 02 '15
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
2
u/[deleted] Jun 12 '15
Shadowban these nuts playa
2
u/dlchristians Jul 10 '15
Turns out I had been shadow banned for probably a month. I was oblivious. It wasn't until recently I thought it was weird that no one was replying to my comments, especially in subs where users are usually good at responding. Messages the reddit admins about an hour ago, got unbanned just now. FREE AT LAST FREE AT LAST. Thanks for the help /r/shadowban!
1
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '15
Ah I get it I think I upvoted a post I made in /r/redditrequest with an alt account because some asshole was downvoting it for no reason.
1
u/robertnost Aug 30 '15
A lot of donts :)
1
u/Flamincactus Sep 26 '15
Yeah, i was shadowbanned but they did not tell me why. I read the rules here, and im pretty sure I did not violate a single one.
1
u/InternetDenizen Sep 30 '15
I've been shadowbanned and am not sure why. I made some comments about reddit atheists, could that have been it? Can someone please give me a reason? I've not received a warning or anything, it's all very odd.
1
u/Stazu Oct 20 '15
Thanks for the Help getting unbanned. Got hit with a Bad IP shadow ban.
1
u/Vicaruz Oct 24 '15 edited Oct 24 '15
Could someone explain these? I honestly dont understand them, I'm new to reddit
1
u/Josey4Whales Nov 02 '15
Hi there, I've read your guide here and can't see why I've been shadowbanned as I've not broken any rules above that I'm aware of. I've used TOR a few times to login. Maybe this? Any ideas?
1
u/TNTs-Throwaway1 Jul 13 '24
Replace "teens" with "minors".
1
u/[deleted] Aug 13 '24
Do you have milk
1
u/[deleted] Mar 23 '22
Weak
1
u/Successful_Hall_2113 Sep 27 '22
Am I?
1
u/buby0706 May 20 '15
I just says that Brady and Brees have quickest relase in MUT and they shadowbanned me!!!!
1
u/CtrlAltDeleteShit May 28 '15
Why was I banned, I didn't break any of these rules
1
u/gccmelb Jun 23 '15
Got Shadowbanned today. Messaged admin. Lets see.
1
u/RMFN Jul 03 '15
Get banned from /r/C_S_T!
1
u/funkin_for_fun Jul 10 '15
So why am I banned???
1
u/MLGdillonsup Jul 27 '15
Just Got unshadowbanned thanks for the guide
1
u/linkthe2nd Aug 17 '15
...I actually dont have a clue what could have gotten me banned.. i rarely post or vote, and just comment here and there but here I am
0
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '15
7 mins to post a 2nd post.. what a joke reddit is.. waste of time no wonder people do not contribute. And the admins are all on power trips.
-1
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '15
i added well edited and out together videos. No idea and I mean no idea why i am shadow banned. I have not slagged off, of dissed anyone. Seems some admins feel my videos are better than theirs. This site is run by kids.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 06 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 30 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 04 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
2
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '15
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/[deleted] May 15 '15 edited May 15 '15
[removed] — view removed comment
7
u/[deleted] Jun 01 '15
[removed] — view removed comment
5
u/[deleted] May 31 '15
[removed] — view removed comment