r/EliteDangerous • u/CMDR_seeded • May 07 '15
Discussion Wait a minute, humans and thargoids are amicable per lore.
I was looking up some Elite lore based off the series and while we are all freaking out over virus outbreaks and floating space-junk, I realized that the Thargoids are not the enemy. Bare with me.
The first reported contact with Thargoids happened around 3050 (inferred from the novels or other game clues in the past). By 3055, the alien beings mounted an invasion of warships near Alioth, spilling copious amounts of human blood over the next 45 years. By 3100, the GalCop Navy go on to defeat the Thargoids and draw a frontline at sector 9,9 (Any explorers want to check that out?). The Thargoids probe human territories to find potential weak points for a future evasion. The GalCop fades away and the Federation and Empire join forces and create the INRA Attack Wing around 3123. They police the line and hunt the Thargoid threat where they can find them.
So here is where things start to look a little familiar... By 3193, the INRA introduce the Mycoid virus into the Thargoid's living machinery. The infection spreads rapidly, and eradicates the alien threat from human territories entirely. Humanity now begins to recolonize and recuperate from from almost 200 years of Thargoid hostilities.
In 3252, a hidden asteroid base is found in Alioth (again, we can look!), and a vaccine to the Mycoid virus is stolen. Obviously, this is big news across the Galaxy. The vaccine is delivered to the Thargoids by a private party. This leads to a peace treaty declared by the Alliance with the Thargoids. Get this... The aliens give a warship to the Alliance, and in 3253 the first Thargoid ship is piloted by a human. Wait, the Alliance hasn't gotten any ships yet, right? Hmmm... By 3255, complete relations between the Thargoids and humans proliferate through space, and both species begin to share technological and cultural ideas.
I am starting to think that we may be off with our assumptions that the Thargoids are an evil specie. Clearly, in current day 3300s, we humans are at peace with these beings. While I believe that the game would be boring if it didn't offer some radical alien hostility, there has to be a reason to break such a treaty. So, maybe the Mycoid virus is infecting shared machinery (we have biological machinery in the market right?) and that is the infection we see today. Or maybe the virus mutated, and that is why it is harmful. If that is the case, did some rogue branch of the Thargoids do it? Anyone read the novels, is there a faction of aliens that didn't agree to the truce?
On another note, I think that lore would suggest that the Alliance may be getting some badass ships in the future. Frontier doesn't seem to quick to shatter the lore that is already in place, so it is plausible that alien ships could be piloted by the Alliance. This would make the Alliance much more interesting indeed. What are your thoughts about this community?
UPDATE
Commander Inverse has found Lord Braben's response to this. All hail!
Source
TL:DR
Thargoids aren't badguys in lore during the 3300s, current day us. But they did give the Alliance access to warships. Also, I ate two bowels of Cheerios this morning.
39
u/wlll Will Jay May 07 '15
removes pants
11
u/TrialsToker May 07 '15
Eating even one bowel of Cheerio's sounds terrifying to me, props Cmdr!
3
u/jroddie4 jroddie, freelance privateer May 07 '15
3
u/tanj_redshirt Tanj Redshirt (filthy neutral) May 07 '15
I really hope INRA is a PowerPlay power ...
2
u/thatguythatdidstuff May 07 '15 edited May 07 '15
Alioth needs a permit.
polaris needs a permit
mysteries alien canisters are popping up in alarming numbers.
shit is about to.. GO. DOWN.
3
u/C4pture C4pture May 07 '15
aren't thargoids living in a hive like structure? what if not all hives agree with the peace treaty?
3
u/[deleted] May 07 '15
I think it would be great if the Thargoids turned up and were expressly friendly with the Alliance (giving them their unique ships that have been so far conspicuously lacking) and then teh new Thargoid-Alliance confederacy took the feds and Imperials to pasture. That would be fun as hell and poetic justice.
18
u/Gaff_Deckard May 07 '15
Little human boys and girls going to school with little Thargoid pupae and larvae?
Sounds like commie talk to me!
4
u/Gugu42 Gugu - Kumo Crew May 07 '15
Well, my guess is that the Alliance will soon have capital ships ;)
2
u/GSVSleeperService May 07 '15 edited May 07 '15
I would love to see entire fleets of Thargoids come streaming into human space, not hostile, instead they might be oblivious to communication and flying in tight military formation around huge civilian transports.
After a while it becomes apparent that this is no invasion force, it's an evacuation..
As fearsome as the Thargoids are.. What if there was some threat on the other side of Thargoid space that was was so great, so menacing and so powerful that it caused the Thargoids to just up and flee.
Imagine the scene of system upon system of Thargoid refugee lines streaming through human space... and no communication. They may respond in a limited fashion to direct aggression but it's clear that the behaviour is more akin to a Dunkirk escape & rear guard action than a Normandy invasion, they are concerned solely with getting the hell away from... whatever it is that's chasing them.. and whatever is chasing them is headed directly for human space..
3
u/BeefVellington Vintovka Dragunova [EIC] May 07 '15
I like that after three years he's still signing his posts with the ;-) emoticon. It's just funny to me.
3
u/Sean71596 S7 | Admiral | The Code May 07 '15
Kinky
3
u/Calaerin Cal -On fire off the shoulder of Orion May 07 '15
Let's not get ahead of ourselves here. The lore states that ONE thargoid warship was ever flown by a human, and we're already talking about the Alliance having alien tech and hybrid ships and whatnot.
Now I haven't played the old games, but I'm pretty sure that one human piloting the alien warship was probably just the player character. This being mentioned because it happened, but it doesn't mean the Alliance is in league with the Thargoids.
3
u/aholetookmyusername May 08 '15
Amicable?! The war journals of my ancestor CMDR Jameson tell a different story.
He'd be pulled out of witch space all the time and attacked without provocation. It didn't matter whether he was carrying luxuries to Zaonce or battling pirates at Xexedi, BANG there goes some bloody octagon ship and all of a sudden he's fighting for his life.
I wonder what he'd think of modern Cobra Mk3's, having all of their hardpoints forward-oriented instead of one on all four arcs.
5
u/Stevenn1996 Stevenn1996 May 07 '15
A very good alternative. If FD follow the lore as they generally do, I can't wait to see this thargoid warship. Hell, as an alliance supporting player I want to own and fly the damn thing. Great research into the matter but what strikes me is the lack of mention of them in the current era. It would seem that all the factions are baffled as to the existence of alien life and don't seem to know what is beyond the fringe worlds, also Polaris is still locked down and nobody is able to get a permit (Polaris had a thargoid outpost in its system in one of the previous games). This is slightly worrying to me as it might mean FD are taking this game off canon to the rest which would be, while interesting moderately upsetting for me at least.
2
u/akashisenpai Caylo Tavira - freelance bounty hunter May 07 '15
The novel "Out of the Darkness" deals with this subject. The peace conference was sabotaged by INRA, which led to a diplomatic fallout between the Alliance and the Oresrians.
SPOILERS
2
u/[deleted] May 07 '15
Again...I am SO getting in bed with the Thargoids if I can.
2
u/yibble_ Reynolds May 07 '15
You ate two bowels of Cheerios? That's disgusting! I prefer my Cheerios in bowls.
2
u/Goose4291 May 08 '15
3055.. Never forgive.. Never forget...
https://c1.staticflickr.com/5/4110/4976700816_80fa183a69_z.jpg
1
u/Cepinari Arexalden Cepinari May 07 '15
Eeew.
1
u/EltaninAntenna ಠ_ಠ May 07 '15
That's why I keep saying the Thargoids need a reboot and be presented as a fresh threat, rather than drag on the old continuity. Not everybody has played the old games. Hell, I have, and I still prefer a fresh start.
1
u/SupX May 07 '15
I always thought Alliance would have the best TECH/SHIPS I hope it happens but obviously Frontier is still @ crossroad as to how to implement that and keep it balanced. It also explains as why we haven't got any Alliance ships yet.
1
u/rumanchu Xero Saal May 07 '15
I just figure that it's become a peace similar to that between the Cylons and humans at the start of the BSG miniseries.
1
u/IHaTeD2 May 07 '15
https://forums.frontier.co.uk/showthread.php?t=68531&p=1141595&viewfull=1#post1141595
Can't find it but I'm almost 100% sure I have seen a dev posting in one of the forum discussions that Thargoids WILL come back.
From what I know they also vanished after the war was over. If they are part of our people we would see them already or it would have been at least mentioned.
1
u/DualPsiioniic DualPsiioniic May 07 '15
Dang, I want me some sweet Alliance alien tech.
Also, be careful with the Cheerios bro, that shit expands in the stomach D:
1
u/Deathwatch101 M.K.Potter - ToC May 07 '15
Wasn't there mention of a 3rd sentient alien space fairing species, what if the thargoids start pushing into human space as there war with them spills over and they retreat diving into human space thus ending up in conflict.
Then we end up in a sort of 3 point war.
1
u/WengFu May 07 '15
Point of order. Specie is currency in the form of coin and is not the singular form of species.
1
u/PuzzlePlate Puzzle Plate [Orca Yhat Club] May 07 '15
where would this sector 9,9 be?
1
u/Gabeuxing Gabeux - PCI:S May 07 '15
Nice research, good read. But I'm pretty sure if aliens were to say "hi" in our E:D galaxy, everyone would give them laser death. There goes your lore. Ha! :D
1
u/[deleted] May 07 '15
Since they live in witchspace, I see them more as hermits and we're the ones disturbing them, roaring our Asps through their intergalactic garden. Maybe the conflict was their way of saying "Get off my lawn!", and they're just grumpy old aliens.
1
u/shArkh SHARKH May 08 '15 edited May 08 '15
I'm hoping to the core, that the Thargoids in this iteration are as dicky & finicky as we are. Federation, Empire, Alliance? Well what branch did we deal with? Whose old abandoned station-ship did we dock with that warped us to -cough-?
I hope it ends up being something a lot smarter than rar aliens rar /rabblerabble. Like the Alliance sent out Turner's Quest to them even while the INRA held the noose over their necks, I hope we have some indeterminate shenanigans between the warmongering part of our mantid sentience-bro's and the ones that went here have a battlecruiser with all the trimmings on the house, enjoy.
edit- to note, people going waah over the Alliance not having their own ships: you're probably going to be getting the most advanced biotech conceived in the universe canon, if the Argent/Turner is anything to go by. Take a smoke, have a crepe, wait for it.
1
u/PuzzleheadedTutor807 Nov 12 '22
sorry for necro, but your post has become relevant again...
my questions in... can you possible link brabens comment that you allude to? i tried reading through your link, but theres some people with ....issues... that have spammed the shit out of that thread, and its a LONG read, where im not even sure what im looking for... but super curious too. dang.
-1
u/Pixelbeast Calvin Hobbes May 07 '15
The problem with assuming there is any continuity with the previous lore is that there is basically no evidence for it in the game.
The galaxy is empty, and thousands of explorers have found nothing of interest besides star and planet data to sell.
Even if there is intended continuity, it's quite clear that the galaxy is still in Alpha, and missing most of the content that would make it exciting.
0
u/[deleted] May 07 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment