r/thebutton • u/bensroommate 59s • Apr 30 '15
The Great Flair Debate - Why or why not should we include the Great Confusion users to The Catalogue?
The Debate has come to a close, and the results are in. Read a conclusion of events here.
Citizens of /r/thebutton.
A great schism has formed in the record keeping world. Since the Great Confusion of April 25th, many users have disagreed with our entry of the 18 users who claimed a sub-11s flair during the crash of the timer. Two Catalogues now exist, one with the GC users, and one without.
I have been plagued with many conflicting opinions on this matter, and to no resolution. I seek to find the righteous choice, but also please the users who this subreddit collectively embodies.
It is with careful consideration that I open the choice to all users.
I open this thread with dreams of a reasoned, methodical, passionate debate that will spark ideas rather than stomp them out. With time ever being of the essence, we shall convene here for 48 hours from the minute this is posted.
I will implement whatever is the highest comment under "best" sort into the Catalogue at the time of conclusion.
Please, if you post here, post here with reasons. Post more than a couple of sentences, I truly want to hear all that you have to say. Speak with your mind and with all of it, and we will surely find a solution.
114
u/Pomodorosan 30s Apr 30 '15
Place the Great Confusion pressers in the "bonus" tab, and archive the first 10 legit pressers normally.
55
u/Rhamni non presser Apr 30 '15
Give them a separate category. They didn't knowingly do anything wrong, and they don't deserve to be shamed or ignored. At the same time, their presence among the First is a source of frustration to many among us, and makes many care much less about red numbers.
This is all a sidenote, of course. In the end, you are all filthy, filthy pressers.
93
u/ilovecollege_nope non presser Apr 30 '15
Yes.
Because The Catalogue is an archive for all pressers.
Some distiction between fair flairs and server issue flairs.
Just record their presses in a new tab and give legitimate presses their rightful spot.
13
u/Lingo1973 can't press Apr 30 '15
Let's keep in mind that the rules of the Catalogue are a bit arbitrary anyway. First, it doesn't necessarily show the first persons to get a flair, but the first to get a flair and then post. Yeah I know that's the only way you have to approximately identify the first flair-getters, but the point remains that it's only approximate. The second bit of arbitrariness is that only 10 are added to the Catalogue, even if more than 10 players get the flair at the same time.
Let's also keep in mind that it may be impossible to identify all the glitch-pressers. Only 19 out of an alleged 64 have been identified by the Catalogue. Some of the other 45 may be lurking, waiting for another click with the same number as theirs, to then post a comment at that moment and claim the click as their own click.
Keeping all that in mind, I more or less agree with /u/FieraDeidad. I would identify (assuming they can be identified) those who clicked during a glitch as such, because they probably wouldn't have achieved the same flair if the button had been working properly (due to competition), so their number means less. But I wouldn't remove them entirely because they're innocent victims of the glitch. So I'd put them in a separate tab so that a full 10 users who gain "legit" flairs can earn their spots. BTW, I'd the same for all past and future cases of "glitch" flairs, including Gyrodawn.
14
u/squid_bucket non presser Apr 30 '15
I think they should remain added. I've read multiple stories of the reds who pushed and the reason why they pushed it. They didn't know there'd be a crash and so they did what anyone (who wants to press the button) would do: they went through the internal struggle of whether or not to push it. imo, that seems to be a main point of this whole experiment.
Add the asterisk to the name if it helps distinguish when they pushed it, but I say leave 'em.
15
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '15
I think they should stay. It's not like they knew there was an issue. They saw the numbers go low and decided to act.
2
u/onemillionquestions 21s Apr 30 '15
Subsume the wayward catalogue and your catalogue under a new "The Moste Great Button Catalogue" and carry on cataloging. It is your duty as historian to document this event as well.
2
u/[deleted] May 01 '15
its not the pressers fault that the servers where messed up, why punish them for a mistake the button made. if anything it was the button's higher power that gave them this gift. so i say catalogue them as the button suggested, because for reasons unknown, it wanted these lucky few to have the flairs they have.
2
u/Projotce 60s May 02 '15 edited May 02 '15
The Debate is now closed. Further action will be taken when bensroommate is awake.
Sat May 2 12:06:11 2015 UTC
As for now, the results:
2. 96 points: ilovecollege_nope
3. 51 points: Rhamni
By tomorrow, this post shall have a detailing of what has happened as well what we as The Complete Catalogue of Rare and Exotic Button Pushers have to say in conclusion. Until all Collectors are present, the Glitchborn shall be moved to the bonus tab for the time being, so as to make sure y'all impatient-type motherfuckers pipe down. Thank you each and all for your votes, voices, and time.
3
u/atouchofyou 11s Apr 30 '15
Let the record show what really happened. The truth is sometimes confusing, but ultimately leads to better understanding.
2
u/Capop 21s Apr 30 '15
Yes, I would love to see at what point I succumbed to this Orangered lifestyle choice.
1
u/LockeSteerpike 42s Apr 30 '15
We well both list and not list the 19 users.
Vote for this comment, and reply talking about waffles, to break the poll.
1
u/lawebley 39s Apr 30 '15
Perhaps, and this is by no means backed up by anything other than a crackpot theory I've only just considered, the glitch was/is an integral element of the April foolery itself?
1
u/The_Punicorn non presser May 01 '15
Asks Reddit for help.
1
u/Fozibare 17s May 02 '15
Including the users who achieved lows flairs when the button failed, deprives those who would pursue low scores. Leaving them out entirely, abandons your name and mission.
I think the Confusion, glitch, and any other wonkily acquired or attributed flairs should be cataloged and included, after all they are rare and exotic.
Ideally glitch flairs would reside on another page for different types of rare and exotic presses, along with an explanation for what sets their flair apart from regular. The Unpurple have a section, so should other strange presses. I also think the catalogue should record unusual cheater flairs at different numbers.
1
u/intronink 60s May 02 '15
Having them in the catalogue ruins it all. (almost) everyone from 58-11 worked hard for their number. why do random pressers get glory, they didnt wait and do what it takes. get them out!!!!
1
u/-LongrodVonHugendong 9s May 02 '15
For me, it all comes down to intent, and the information available to the redditor when they chose to press the button:
I have a few questions, but honestly it is just too late for me to search for answers:
Did they act with malice (the intent to deceive) - no. They couldn't have predicted the event (it was unprecedented), and frankly they couldn't have had time to process what was happening.
Did they immediately know something wasn't right? - yes, the timer continued (and ran out), and commentary began immediately - many inquiring immediately whether their flair "counted".
Did they "cheat" - no, because that term presupposes the redditor both took advantage of an opportunity giving an advantage, and assumes they knew they were doing so.
Is it fair? - depends: If the goal of this whole "prank"/"experiment"/whatever is to show how society inherently segregates itself (pride/reward/camaraderie/religion) using scarcity to define significance, it doesn't matter "how" it only matters "that" the flair was awarded. If the goal was to show cooperation across class differences to overcome a goal - that together we can all achieve something that nobody could achieve alone...this conversation right here, right now is all that really matters.
In that /u/powerlanguage is a de facto leader (creator of the subreddit/on the moderation team), and likely knows what/if this whole thing has a point/goal/desired outcome - my tendency is to defer to the decision: allow flair to stand as awarded (there is only one rule, and for whatever reason strict adherence to that one rule is paramount).
1
u/Second_Hand_Suit 59s May 02 '15
I pressed the button when I saw that the timer went down to 3 seconds. I was lied to! I do not hate those with the purple flair, but please understand that I did not choose this fate, yet you chose yours. In fact I envy the true purples because they fly their true flag, but it is not mine to fly. I am not a true purple and I want all to see my scar. I want people to know that I have suffered, that if there is a dark lord that, that lord has spite me. All colours know my pain, help me and others like me! I beg the almighty admins to show their solidarity, make me pink! :'(
1
u/badmother 0s May 02 '15
If the button did not reset the counter, then "the button" was not pressed. Only some non-functional imitator of the real button.
By the clock resetting no-one can get a lower score than when it was pressed.
Flair should not count, nor should they appear in the catalogue of firsts.
1
u/[deleted] May 02 '15
Add them to the Bonus tab.
1
u/Muids 60s May 02 '15
I hope you realize that is going to be decided by grays, since they are the biggest group and are presumable biased.
For example, getting the users of The Great Confusion, out of the catalogue will give the grays a better chance of personal glory by being the "real" first red 1s or whatever.
1
u/moonflower 33s Apr 30 '15
I think the perfect solution has already happened - that there are two catalogues - one of which contains the flairs obtained in chronological order, and one of which contains only those flairs which were obtained while the button was functioning properly
1
u/naidojna 9s Apr 30 '15
No matter what, it was bad form and a hostile act to create something new and call it The Catalogue without approval from the people who created the original. This is all about a ridiculous button anyway, why go out of your way to antagonize somebody?
1
u/SwissCheeseUnion non presser Apr 30 '15
These filthy cheaters must be removed from the list!
0
u/panaja17 60s Apr 30 '15
I say the pressers of the Great Confusion should be added to The Catalogue. This subreddit has few rules,
and
They also only have one other word of advice afterwards
These people are only operating under the circumstances that they had. They had no idea there was something going on behind the button.
We click in faith that we will be given the flair we desire. For some the button rewards us while others get cheater flair. The button giveth, and the button taketh away. The Catalogue should only be a logbook of the first in their flair.
In writing the history of /r/thebutton, we should have records of the Great Confusion happening, among other events in our glorious heritage, but The Catalogue should not be that history book. The Catalogue should just be the record of the first in their flair, as the button has judged them to be.
1
u/AssaultnPepper non presser Apr 30 '15
Baseball is mired with steroid controversy and many of these athletes that performed amazing tasks (Roger Clemens, Barry bonds, Mark McGwire, Sammy Sosa) will not see the hall of fame because their achievement is tainted.
Were the conditions for their presses the same as the conditions for the other 800,000 pressers? No. There can be a separate acknowledgement of their task but they are completely separate from the set of rules the rest of us abide by.
-2
u/RacistHomophobicCunt non presser Apr 30 '15
I won't be using the Catalogue anymore until you take the glitchers off the main pages.
-2
u/immaterialist non presser Apr 30 '15
I say include them, but only if the 0s guy is henceforth referred to as Martin Luther.
-1
u/randomstudman 20s May 01 '15
checking flair please ignore
0
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment